-
Mobile Distributed MIMO (MD-MIMO) for NextG: Mobility Meets Cooperation in Distributed Arrays
Authors:
Karim A. Said,
Yibin Liang,
Usama Saeed,
Ramin Safavinejad,
Kumar Sai Bondada,
Evan Allen,
Nima Mohammadi,
Benjamin Pimentel,
Brian Kelley,
Jeff Reed,
Nishith Tripathi,
Michael Buehrer,
Yang,
Yi,
Daniel Jakubisin,
Lingjia Liu
Abstract:
Distributed multiple-input multiple-output (D\mbox{-}MIMO) is a promising technology to realize the promise of massive MIMO gains by fiber-connecting the distributed antenna arrays, thereby overcoming the form factor limitations of co-located MIMO. In this paper, we introduce the concept of mobile D-MIMO (MD-MIMO) network, a further extension of the D-MIMO technology where distributed antenna arra…
▽ More
Distributed multiple-input multiple-output (D\mbox{-}MIMO) is a promising technology to realize the promise of massive MIMO gains by fiber-connecting the distributed antenna arrays, thereby overcoming the form factor limitations of co-located MIMO. In this paper, we introduce the concept of mobile D-MIMO (MD-MIMO) network, a further extension of the D-MIMO technology where distributed antenna arrays are connected to the base station with a wireless link allowing all radio network nodes to be mobile. This approach significantly improves deployment flexibility and reduces operating costs, enabling the network to adapt to the highly dynamic nature of next-generation (NextG) networks. We discuss use cases, system design, network architecture, and the key enabling technologies for MD-MIMO. Furthermore, we investigate a case study of MD-MIMO for vehicular networks, presenting detailed performance evaluations for both downlink and uplink. The results show that an MD-MIMO network can provide substantial improvements in network throughput and reliability.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
Indoor Positioning for Public Safety: Role of UAVs, LEOs, and Propagation-Aware Techniques
Authors:
Gaurav Duggal,
Harish K. Dureppagari,
Harpreet S. Dhillon,
Jeffrey H. Reed,
R. Michael Buehrer
Abstract:
Effective indoor positioning is critical for public safety, enabling first responders to locate at-risk individuals accurately during emergency scenarios. However, traditional Global Navigation Satellite Systems (GNSS) often perform poorly indoors due to poor coverage and non-line-of-sight (NLOS) conditions. Moreover, relying on fixed cellular infrastructure, such as terrestrial networks (TNs), ma…
▽ More
Effective indoor positioning is critical for public safety, enabling first responders to locate at-risk individuals accurately during emergency scenarios. However, traditional Global Navigation Satellite Systems (GNSS) often perform poorly indoors due to poor coverage and non-line-of-sight (NLOS) conditions. Moreover, relying on fixed cellular infrastructure, such as terrestrial networks (TNs), may not be feasible, as indoor signal coverage from a sufficient number of base stations or WiFi access points cannot be guaranteed for accurate positioning. In this paper, we propose a rapidly deployable indoor positioning system (IPS) leveraging mobile anchors, including uncrewed aerial vehicles (UAVs) and Low-Earth-Orbit (LEO) satellites, and discuss the role of GNSS and LEOs in localizing the mobile anchors. Additionally, we discuss the role of sidelink-based positioning, which is introduced in 3rd Generation Partnership Project (3GPP) Release 18, in enabling public safety systems. By examining outdoor-to-indoor (O2I) signal propagation, particularly diffraction-based approaches, we highlight how propagation-aware positioning methods can outperform conventional strategies that disregard propagation mechanism information. The study highlights how emerging 5G Advanced and Non-Terrestrial Networks (NTN) features offer new avenues to improve positioning in challenging indoor environments, ultimately paving the way for cost-effective and resilient IPS solutions tailored to public safety applications.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Impact of Frequency on Diffraction-Aided Wireless Positioning
Authors:
Gaurav Duggal,
Anand M. Kumar,
R. Michael Buehrer,
Harpreet S. Dhillon,
Nishith Tripathi,
Jeffrey H. Reed
Abstract:
This paper tackles the challenge of accurate positioning in Non-Line-of-Sight (NLoS) environments, with a focus on indoor public safety scenarios where NLoS bias severely impacts localization performance. We explore Diffraction MultiPath Components (MPC) as a critical mechanism for Outdoor-to-Indoor (O2I) signal propagation and its role in positioning. The proposed system comprises outdoor Uncrewe…
▽ More
This paper tackles the challenge of accurate positioning in Non-Line-of-Sight (NLoS) environments, with a focus on indoor public safety scenarios where NLoS bias severely impacts localization performance. We explore Diffraction MultiPath Components (MPC) as a critical mechanism for Outdoor-to-Indoor (O2I) signal propagation and its role in positioning. The proposed system comprises outdoor Uncrewed Aerial Vehicle (UAV) transmitters and indoor receivers that require localization. To facilitate diffraction-based positioning, we develop a method to isolate diffraction MPCs at indoor receivers and validate its effectiveness using a ray-tracing-generated dataset, which we have made publicly available. Our evaluation across the FR1, FR2, and FR3 frequency bands within the 5G/6G spectrum confirms the viability of diffraction-based positioning techniques for next-generation wireless networks.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Dual-Use Commercial and Military Communications on a Single Platform using RAN Domain Specific Language
Authors:
Alan Gatherer,
Chaitali Sengupta,
Sudipta Sen,
Jeffery H. Reed
Abstract:
Despite the success of the O-RAN Alliance in developing a set of interoperable interfaces, development of unique Radio Access Network (RAN) deployments remains challenging. This is especially true for military communications, where deployments are highly specialized with limited volume. The construction and maintenance of the RAN, which is a real time embedded system, is an ill-defined NP problem…
▽ More
Despite the success of the O-RAN Alliance in developing a set of interoperable interfaces, development of unique Radio Access Network (RAN) deployments remains challenging. This is especially true for military communications, where deployments are highly specialized with limited volume. The construction and maintenance of the RAN, which is a real time embedded system, is an ill-defined NP problem requiring teams of specialized system engineers, with specialized knowledge of the hardware platform. In this paper, we introduce a RAN Domain Specific Language (RDSL(TM)) to formally describe use cases, constraints, and multi-vendor hardware/software abstraction to allow automation of RAN construction. In this DSL, system requirements are declarative, and performance constraints are guaranteed by construction using an automated system solver. Using our RAN system solver platform, Gabriel(TM) we show how a system engineer can confidently modify RAN functionality without knowledge of the underlying hardware. We show benefits for specific system requirements when compared to the manually optimized, default configuration of the Intel FlexRAN(TM), and conclude that DSL/automation driven construction of the RAN can lead to significant power and latency benefits when the deployment constraints are tuned for a specific case. We give examples of how constraints and requirements can be formatted in a "Kubernetes style" YAML format which allows the use of other tools, such as Ansible, to integrate the generation of these requirements into higher level automation flows such as Service Management and Orchestration (SMO).
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
Experimental Validation of a 3GPP Compliant 5G-Based Positioning System
Authors:
Sarik Dhungel,
Gaurav Duggal,
Dara Ron,
Nishith Tripathi,
R. Michael Buehrer,
Jeffrey H. Reed,
Vijay K Shah
Abstract:
The advent of 5G positioning techniques by 3GPP has unlocked possibilities for applications in public safety, vehicular systems, and location-based services. However, these applications demand accurate and reliable positioning performance, which has led to the proposal of newer positioning techniques. To further advance the research on these techniques, in this paper, we develop a 3GPP-compliant 5…
▽ More
The advent of 5G positioning techniques by 3GPP has unlocked possibilities for applications in public safety, vehicular systems, and location-based services. However, these applications demand accurate and reliable positioning performance, which has led to the proposal of newer positioning techniques. To further advance the research on these techniques, in this paper, we develop a 3GPP-compliant 5G positioning testbed, incorporating gNodeBs (gNBs) and User Equipment (UE). The testbed uses New Radio (NR) Positioning Reference Signals (PRS) transmitted by the gNB to generate Time of Arrival (TOA) estimates at the UE. We mathematically model the inter-gNB and UE-gNB time offsets affecting the TOA estimates and examine their impact on positioning performance. Additionally, we propose a calibration method for estimating these time offsets. Furthermore, we investigate the environmental impact on the TOA estimates. Our findings are based on our mathematical model and supported by experimental results.
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Directed Testing of ORAN using a Partially Specified Declarative Digital Twin
Authors:
Alan Gatherer,
Chaitali Sengupta,
Sudipta Sen,
Jeffery H. Reed
Abstract:
Real Time performance testing can be divided into two distinct parts: system test and algorithm test. System test checks that the right functions operate on the right data within power, latency, and other constraints under all conditions. Major RAN OEMs, put as much effort into system test and debug as they do into algorithm test, to ensure a competitive product. An algorithm tester will provide l…
▽ More
Real Time performance testing can be divided into two distinct parts: system test and algorithm test. System test checks that the right functions operate on the right data within power, latency, and other constraints under all conditions. Major RAN OEMs, put as much effort into system test and debug as they do into algorithm test, to ensure a competitive product. An algorithm tester will provide little insight into real time and hardware-software (HW-SW) capacity as it is unaware of the system implementation. In this paper we present an innovative Digital Twin technology, which we call Declarative Digital Twin (DDT). A DDT can describe the system requirements of the RAN such that critical corner cases can be found via automation, that would normally be missed by conventional testing. This is possible even when the RAN requirements are only partially specified. We present a Domain Specific Language (DSL) for declarative description of the RAN and show results from an automated solver that demonstrate how potential HW-SW implementation related corner cases can be identified from the DDT of an ORAN DU.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Diffraction Aided Wireless Positioning
Authors:
Gaurav Duggal,
R. Michael Buehrer,
Harpreet S. Dhillon,
Jeffrey H. Reed
Abstract:
Wireless positioning in Non-Line-of-Sight (NLoS) scenarios presents significant challenges due to multipath effects that lead to biased measurements and reduced positioning accuracy. This paper revisits electromagnetic field theory related to diffraction and in the context of wireless positioning and proposes a novel positioning technique that greatly improves accuracy in NLoS environments dominat…
▽ More
Wireless positioning in Non-Line-of-Sight (NLoS) scenarios presents significant challenges due to multipath effects that lead to biased measurements and reduced positioning accuracy. This paper revisits electromagnetic field theory related to diffraction and in the context of wireless positioning and proposes a novel positioning technique that greatly improves accuracy in NLoS environments dominated by diffraction. The method is applied to a critical public safety use case: precisely locating at-risk individuals within buildings, with a particular focus on improving 3D positioning and z-axis accuracy. By leveraging the Geometrical Theory of Diffraction (GTD), the approach introduces an innovative NLoS path length model and a new NLOS positioning technique. Using Fisher information analysis, we establish the conditions required for 3D positioning and derive lower bounds on positioning performance for both 3D and z-axis estimates for the proposed NLOS positioning technique. Additionally, we propose an algorithmic implementation of the proposed NLoS positioning method using non-linear least squares estimation, which we term D-NLS. The positioning performance of our proposed NLOs positioning technique is validated using an extensive ray-tracing simulation. The numerical results highlight the superiority of our approach in outdoor-to-indoor environments, which directly estimates NLoS path lengths and delivers significant performance enhancements over existing methods for both 3D and z-axis positioning scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 2025; v1 submitted 4 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
3D Positioning using a New Diffraction Path Model
Authors:
Gaurav Duggal,
R. Michael Buehrer,
Harpreet S. Dhillon,
Jeffrey H. Reed
Abstract:
Enhancing 3D and Z-axis positioning accuracy is crucial for effective rescue in indoor emergencies, ensuring safety for emergency responders and at-risk individuals. Additionally, reducing the dependence of a positioning system on fixed infrastructure is crucial, given its vulnerability to power failures and damage during emergencies. Further challenges from a signal propagation perspective includ…
▽ More
Enhancing 3D and Z-axis positioning accuracy is crucial for effective rescue in indoor emergencies, ensuring safety for emergency responders and at-risk individuals. Additionally, reducing the dependence of a positioning system on fixed infrastructure is crucial, given its vulnerability to power failures and damage during emergencies. Further challenges from a signal propagation perspective include poor indoor signal coverage, multipath effects and the problem of Non-Line-OfSight (NLOS) measurement bias. In this study, we utilize the mobility provided by a rapidly deployable Uncrewed Aerial Vehicle (UAV) based wireless network to address these challenges. We recognize diffraction from window edges as a crucial signal propagation mechanism and employ the Geometrical Theory of Diffraction (GTD) to introduce a novel NLOS path length model. Using this path length model, we propose two different techniques to improve the indoor positioning performance for emergency scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
ASCENT: A Context-Aware Spectrum Coexistence Design and Implementation Toolset for Policymakers in Satellite Bands
Authors:
Ta-seen Reaz Niloy,
Saurav Kumar,
Aniruddha Hore,
Zoheb Hassan,
Carl Dietrich,
Eric W. Burger,
Jeffrey H. Reed,
Vijay K. Shah
Abstract:
This paper introduces ASCENT (context Aware Spectrum Coexistence Design and Implementation) toolset, an advanced context-aware terrestrial satellite spectrum sharing toolset designed for researchers, policymakers, and regulators. It serves two essential purposes (a) evaluating the potential for harmful interference to primary users in satellite bands and (b) facilitating the analysis, design, and…
▽ More
This paper introduces ASCENT (context Aware Spectrum Coexistence Design and Implementation) toolset, an advanced context-aware terrestrial satellite spectrum sharing toolset designed for researchers, policymakers, and regulators. It serves two essential purposes (a) evaluating the potential for harmful interference to primary users in satellite bands and (b) facilitating the analysis, design, and implementation of diverse regulatory policies on spectrum usage and sharing. Notably, ASCENT implements a closed-loop feedback system that allows dynamic adaptation of policies according to a wide range of contextual factors (e.g., weather, buildings, summer/winter foliage, etc.) and feedback on the impact of these policies through realistic simulation. Specifically, ASCENT comprises the following components (i) interference evaluation tool for evaluating interference at the incumbents in a spectrum-sharing environment while taking the underlying contexts, (ii) dynamic spectrum access (DSA) framework for providing context-aware instructions to adapt networking parameters and control secondary terrestrial network's access to the shared spectrum band according to context aware prioritization, (iii) Context broker to acquire essential and relevant contexts from external context information providers; and (iv) DSA Database to store dynamic and static contexts and the regulator's policy information. The closed-loop feedback system of ASCENT is implemented by integrating these components in a modular software architecture. A case study of sharing the lower 12 GHz Ku band (12.2-12.7 GHz) with the 5G terrestrial cellular network is considered, and the usability of ASCENT is demonstrated by dynamically changing exclusion zone's radius in different weather conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2024; v1 submitted 7 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Keep It Simple: CNN Model Complexity Studies for Interference Classification Tasks
Authors:
Taiwo Oyedare,
Vijay K. Shah,
Daniel J. Jakubisin,
Jeffrey H. Reed
Abstract:
The growing number of devices using the wireless spectrum makes it important to find ways to minimize interference and optimize the use of the spectrum. Deep learning models, such as convolutional neural networks (CNNs), have been widely utilized to identify, classify, or mitigate interference due to their ability to learn from the data directly. However, there have been limited research on the co…
▽ More
The growing number of devices using the wireless spectrum makes it important to find ways to minimize interference and optimize the use of the spectrum. Deep learning models, such as convolutional neural networks (CNNs), have been widely utilized to identify, classify, or mitigate interference due to their ability to learn from the data directly. However, there have been limited research on the complexity of such deep learning models. The major focus of deep learning-based wireless classification literature has been on improving classification accuracy, often at the expense of model complexity. This may not be practical for many wireless devices, such as, internet of things (IoT) devices, which usually have very limited computational resources and cannot handle very complex models. Thus, it becomes important to account for model complexity when designing deep learning-based models for interference classification. To address this, we conduct an analysis of CNN based wireless classification that explores the trade-off amongst dataset size, CNN model complexity, and classification accuracy under various levels of classification difficulty: namely, interference classification, heterogeneous transmitter classification, and homogeneous transmitter classification. Our study, based on three wireless datasets, shows that a simpler CNN model with fewer parameters can perform just as well as a more complex model, providing important insights into the use of CNNs in computationally constrained applications.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Line-of-Sight Probability for Outdoor-to-Indoor UAV-Assisted Emergency Networks
Authors:
Gaurav Duggal,
R. Michael Buehrer,
Nishith Tripathi,
Jeffrey H. Reed
Abstract:
For emergency response scenarios like firefighting in urban environments, there is a need to both localize emergency responders inside the building and also support a high bandwidth communication link between the responders and a command-and-control center. The emergency networks for such scenarios can be established with the quick deployment of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs). Further, the 3D mob…
▽ More
For emergency response scenarios like firefighting in urban environments, there is a need to both localize emergency responders inside the building and also support a high bandwidth communication link between the responders and a command-and-control center. The emergency networks for such scenarios can be established with the quick deployment of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs). Further, the 3D mobility of UAVs can be leveraged to improve the quality of the wireless link by maneuvering them into advantageous locations. This has motivated recent propagation measurement campaigns to study low-altitude air-to-ground channels in both 5G-sub6 GHz and 5G-mmWave bands. In this paper, we develop a model for the link in a UAV-assisted emergency location and/or communication system. Specifically, given the importance of Line-of-Sight (LoS) links in localization as well as mmWave communication, we derive a closed-form expression for the LoS probability. This probability is parameterized by the UAV base station location, the size of the building, and the size of the window that offers the best propagation path. An expression for coverage probability is also derived.
The LoS probability and coverage probabilities derived in this paper can be used to analyze the outdoor UAV-to-indoor propagation environment to determine optimal UAV positioning and the number of UAVs needed to achieve the desired performance of the emergency network.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
AI Testing Framework for Next-G O-RAN Networks: Requirements, Design, and Research Opportunities
Authors:
Bo Tang,
Vijay K. Shah,
Vuk Marojevic,
Jeffrey H. Reed
Abstract:
Openness and intelligence are two enabling features to be introduced in next generation wireless networks, e.g. Beyond 5G and 6G, to support service heterogeneity, open hardware, optimal resource utilization, and on-demand service deployment. The open radio access network (O-RAN) is a promising RAN architecture to achieve both openness and intelligence through virtualized network elements and well…
▽ More
Openness and intelligence are two enabling features to be introduced in next generation wireless networks, e.g. Beyond 5G and 6G, to support service heterogeneity, open hardware, optimal resource utilization, and on-demand service deployment. The open radio access network (O-RAN) is a promising RAN architecture to achieve both openness and intelligence through virtualized network elements and well-defined interfaces. While deploying artificial intelligence (AI) models is becoming easier in O-RAN, one significant challenge that has been long neglected is the comprehensive testing of their performance in realistic environments. This article presents a general automated, distributed and AI-enabled testing framework to test AI models deployed in O-RAN in terms of their decision-making performance, vulnerability and security. This framework adopts a master-actor architecture to manage a number of end devices for distributed testing. More importantly, it leverages AI to automatically and intelligently explore the decision space of AI models in O-RAN. Both software simulation testing and software-defined radio hardware testing are supported, enabling rapid proof of concept research and experimental research on wireless research platforms.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Probability-Reduction of Geolocation using Reconfigurable Intelligent Surface Reflections
Authors:
Anders M. Buvarp,
Daniel J. Jakubisin,
William C. Headley,
Jeffrey H. Reed
Abstract:
With the recent introduction of electromagnetic meta-surfaces and reconfigurable intelligent surfaces, a paradigm shift is currently taking place in the world of wireless communications and related industries. These new technologies have enabled the inclusion of the wireless channel as part of the optimization process. This is of great interest as we transition from 5G mobile communications toward…
▽ More
With the recent introduction of electromagnetic meta-surfaces and reconfigurable intelligent surfaces, a paradigm shift is currently taking place in the world of wireless communications and related industries. These new technologies have enabled the inclusion of the wireless channel as part of the optimization process. This is of great interest as we transition from 5G mobile communications towards 6G. In this paper, we explore the possibility of using a reconfigurable intelligent surface in order to disrupt the ability of an unintended receiver to geolocate the source of transmitted signals in a 5G communication system. We investigate how the performance of the MUSIC algorithm at the unintended receiver is degraded by correlated reflected signals introduced by a reconfigurable intelligent surface in the wireless channel. We analyze the impact of the direction of arrival, delay, correlation, and strength of the reconfigurable intelligent surface signal with respect to the line-of-sight path from the transmitter to the unintended receiver. An effective method is introduced for defeating direction-finding efforts using dual sets of surface reflections. This novel method is called Geolocation-Probability Reduction using Dual Reconfigurable Intelligent Surfaces (GPRIS). We also show that the efficiency of this method is highly dependent on the geometry, that is, the placement of the reconfigurable intelligent surface relative to the unintended receiver and the transmitter.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2023; v1 submitted 18 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Combined Plant and Controller Optimization of an Underwater Energy Harvesting Kite System
Authors:
Kartik Naik,
Sumedh Beknalkar,
James Reed,
Andre Mazzoleni,
Hosam Fathy,
Chris Vermillion
Abstract:
This paper presents the formulation and results for a control-aware optimization of the combined geometric and structural design of an energy-harvesting underwater kite. Because kite-based energy-harvesting systems, both airborne and underwater, possess strong coupling between closed-loop flight control, geometric design, and structural design, consideration of all three facets of the design withi…
▽ More
This paper presents the formulation and results for a control-aware optimization of the combined geometric and structural design of an energy-harvesting underwater kite. Because kite-based energy-harvesting systems, both airborne and underwater, possess strong coupling between closed-loop flight control, geometric design, and structural design, consideration of all three facets of the design within a single co-design framework is highly desirable. However, while prior literature has addressed one or two attributes of the design at a time, the present work constitutes the first comprehensive effort aimed at addressing all three. In particular, focusing on the goals of power maximization and mass minimization, we present a co-design formulation that fuses a geometric optimization tool, structural optimization tool, and closed-loop flight efficiency map. The resulting integrated co-design tool is used to address two mathematical optimization formulations that exhibit subtle differences: a Pareto optimal formulation and a dual-objective formulation that focuses on a weighted power-to-mass ratio as the techno-economic metric of merit. Based on the resulting geometric and structural designs, using a medium-fidelity closed-loop simulation tool, the proposed formulation is shown to achieve more than three times the power-to-mass ratio of a previously published, un-optimized benchmark design.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Predictive Closed-Loop Service Automation in O-RAN based Network Slicing
Authors:
Joseph Thaliath,
Solmaz Niknam,
Sukhdeep Singh,
Rahul Banerji,
Navrati Saxena,
Harpreet S. Dhillon,
Jeffrey H. Reed,
Ali Kashif Bashir,
Avinash Bhat,
Abhishek Roy
Abstract:
Network slicing provides introduces customized and agile network deployment for managing different service types for various verticals under the same infrastructure. To cater to the dynamic service requirements of these verticals and meet the required quality-of-service (QoS) mentioned in the service-level agreement (SLA), network slices need to be isolated through dedicated elements and resources…
▽ More
Network slicing provides introduces customized and agile network deployment for managing different service types for various verticals under the same infrastructure. To cater to the dynamic service requirements of these verticals and meet the required quality-of-service (QoS) mentioned in the service-level agreement (SLA), network slices need to be isolated through dedicated elements and resources. Additionally, allocated resources to these slices need to be continuously monitored and intelligently managed. This enables immediate detection and correction of any SLA violation to support automated service assurance in a closed-loop fashion. By reducing human intervention, intelligent and closed-loop resource management reduces the cost of offering flexible services. Resource management in a network shared among verticals (potentially administered by different providers), would be further facilitated through open and standardized interfaces. Open radio access network (O-RAN) is perhaps the most promising RAN architecture that inherits all the aforementioned features, namely intelligence, open and standard interfaces, and closed control loop. Inspired by this, in this article we provide a closed-loop and intelligent resource provisioning scheme for O-RAN slicing to prevent SLA violations. In order to maintain realism, a real-world dataset of a large operator is used to train a learning solution for optimizing resource utilization in the proposed closed-loop service automation process. Moreover, the deployment architecture and the corresponding flow that are cognizant of the O-RAN requirements are also discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Interference Suppression Using Deep Learning: Current Approaches and Open Challenges
Authors:
Taiwo Oyedare,
Vijay K Shah,
Daniel J Jakubisin,
Jeff H Reed
Abstract:
In light of the finite nature of the wireless spectrum and the increasing demand for spectrum use arising from recent technological breakthroughs in wireless communication, the problem of interference continues to persist. Despite recent advancements in resolving interference issues, interference still presents a difficult challenge to effective usage of the spectrum. This is partly due to the ris…
▽ More
In light of the finite nature of the wireless spectrum and the increasing demand for spectrum use arising from recent technological breakthroughs in wireless communication, the problem of interference continues to persist. Despite recent advancements in resolving interference issues, interference still presents a difficult challenge to effective usage of the spectrum. This is partly due to the rise in the use of license-free and managed shared bands for Wi-Fi, long term evolution (LTE) unlicensed (LTE-U), LTE licensed assisted access (LAA), 5G NR, and other opportunistic spectrum access solutions. As a result of this, the need for efficient spectrum usage schemes that are robust against interference has never been more important. In the past, most solutions to interference have addressed the problem by using avoidance techniques as well as non-AI mitigation approaches (for example, adaptive filters). The key downside to non-AI techniques is the need for domain expertise in the extraction or exploitation of signal features such as cyclostationarity, bandwidth and modulation of the interfering signals. More recently, researchers have successfully explored AI/ML enabled physical (PHY) layer techniques, especially deep learning which reduces or compensates for the interfering signal instead of simply avoiding it. The underlying idea of ML based approaches is to learn the interference or the interference characteristics from the data, thereby sidelining the need for domain expertise in suppressing the interference. In this paper, we review a wide range of techniques that have used deep learning to suppress interference. We provide comparison and guidelines for many different types of deep learning techniques in interference suppression. In addition, we highlight challenges and potential future research directions for the successful adoption of deep learning in interference suppression.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Decentralized Spectrum Access System: Vision, Challenges, and a Blockchain Solution
Authors:
Yang Xiao,
Shanghao Shi,
Wenjing Lou,
Chonggang Wang,
Xu Li,
Ning Zhang,
Y. Thomas Hou,
Jeffrey H. Reed
Abstract:
Spectrum access system (SAS) is widely considered the de facto solution to coordinating dynamic spectrum sharing (DSS) and protecting incumbent users. The current SAS paradigm prescribed by the FCC for the CBRS band and standardized by the WInnForum follows a centralized service model in that a spectrum user subscribes to a SAS server for spectrum allocation service. This model, however, neither t…
▽ More
Spectrum access system (SAS) is widely considered the de facto solution to coordinating dynamic spectrum sharing (DSS) and protecting incumbent users. The current SAS paradigm prescribed by the FCC for the CBRS band and standardized by the WInnForum follows a centralized service model in that a spectrum user subscribes to a SAS server for spectrum allocation service. This model, however, neither tolerates SAS server failures (crash or Byzantine) nor resists dishonest SAS administrators, leading to serious concerns on SAS system reliability and trustworthiness. This is especially concerning for the evolving DSS landscape where an increasing number of SAS service providers and heterogeneous user requirements are coming up. To address these challenges, we propose a novel blockchain-based decentralized SAS architecture called BD-SAS that provides SAS services securely and efficiently, without relying on the trust of each individual SAS server for the overall system trustworthiness. In BD-SAS, a global blockchain (G-Chain) is used for spectrum regulatory compliance while smart contract-enabled local blockchains (L-Chains) are instantiated in individual spectrum zones for automating spectrum access assignment per user request. We hope our vision of a decentralized SAS, the BD-SAS architecture, and discussion on future challenges can open up a new direction towards reliable spectrum management in a decentralized manner.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Receding Horizon Iterative Learning Control for Continuously Operated Systems
Authors:
Maxwell Wu,
Mitchell Cobb,
James Reed,
Kirti Mishra,
Chris Vermillion,
Kira Barton
Abstract:
This paper presents an iterative learning control (ILC) scheme for continuously operated repetitive systems for which no initial condition reset exists. To accomplish this, we develop a lifted system representation that accounts for the effect of the initial conditions on dynamics and projects the dynamics over multiple future iterations. Additionally, we develop an economic cost function and upda…
▽ More
This paper presents an iterative learning control (ILC) scheme for continuously operated repetitive systems for which no initial condition reset exists. To accomplish this, we develop a lifted system representation that accounts for the effect of the initial conditions on dynamics and projects the dynamics over multiple future iterations. Additionally, we develop an economic cost function and update law that considers the performance over multiple iterations in the future, thus allowing for the prediction horizon to be larger than just the next iteration. Convergence of the iteration varying initial condition and applied input are proven and demonstrated using a simulated servo-positioning system test case.
△ Less
Submitted 15 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
AoI-minimizing Scheduling in UAV-relayed IoT Networks
Authors:
Biplav Choudhury,
Vijay K. Shah,
Aidin Ferdowsi,
Jeffrey H. Reed,
Y. Thomas Hou
Abstract:
Due to flexibility, autonomy and low operational cost, unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs), as fixed aerial base stations, are increasingly being used as \textit{relays} to collect time-sensitive information (i.e., status updates) from IoT devices and deliver it to the nearby terrestrial base station (TBS), where the information gets processed. In order to ensure timely delivery of information to the…
▽ More
Due to flexibility, autonomy and low operational cost, unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs), as fixed aerial base stations, are increasingly being used as \textit{relays} to collect time-sensitive information (i.e., status updates) from IoT devices and deliver it to the nearby terrestrial base station (TBS), where the information gets processed. In order to ensure timely delivery of information to the TBS (from all IoT devices), optimal scheduling of time-sensitive information over two hop UAV-relayed IoT networks (i.e., IoT device to the UAV [hop 1], and UAV to the TBS [hop 2]) becomes a critical challenge. To address this, we propose scheduling policies for Age of Information (AoI) minimization in such two-hop UAV-relayed IoT networks. To this end, we present a low-complexity MAF-MAD scheduler, that employs Maximum AoI First (MAF) policy for sampling of IoT devices at UAV (hop 1) and Maximum AoI Difference (MAD) policy for updating sampled packets from UAV to the TBS (hop 2). We show that MAF-MAD is the optimal scheduler under ideal conditions, i.e., error-free channels and generate-at-will traffic generation at IoT devices. On the contrary, for realistic conditions, we propose a Deep-Q-Networks (DQN) based scheduler. Our simulation results show that DQN-based scheduler outperforms MAF-MAD scheduler and three other baseline schedulers, i.e., Maximal AoI First (MAF), Round Robin (RR) and Random, employed at both hops under general conditions when the network is small (with 10's of IoT devices). However, it does not scale well with network size whereas MAF-MAD outperforms all other schedulers under all considered scenarios for larger networks.
△ Less
Submitted 24 September, 2021; v1 submitted 11 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
RAN Slicing in Multi-MVNO Environment under Dynamic Channel Conditions
Authors:
Darshan A. Ravi,
Vijay K. Shah,
Chengzhang Li,
Tom Hou,
Jeffrey H. Reed
Abstract:
With the increasing diversity in the requirement of wireless services with guaranteed quality of service(QoS), radio access network(RAN) slicing becomes an important aspect in implementation of next generation wireless systems(5G). RAN slicing involves division of network resources into many logical segments where each segment has specific QoS and can serve users of mobile virtual network operator…
▽ More
With the increasing diversity in the requirement of wireless services with guaranteed quality of service(QoS), radio access network(RAN) slicing becomes an important aspect in implementation of next generation wireless systems(5G). RAN slicing involves division of network resources into many logical segments where each segment has specific QoS and can serve users of mobile virtual network operator(MVNO) with these requirements. This allows the Network Operator(NO) to provide service to multiple MVNOs each with different service requirements. Efficient allocation of the available resources to slices becomes vital in determining number of users and therefore, number of MVNOs that a NO can support. In this work, we study the problem of Modulation and Coding Scheme(MCS) aware RAN slicing(MaRS) in the context of a wireless system having MVNOs which have users with minimum data rate requirement. Channel Quality Indicator(CQI) report sent from each user in the network determines the MCS selected, which in turn determines the achievable data rate. But the channel conditions might not remain the same for the entire duration of user being served. For this reason, we consider the channel conditions to be dynamic where the choice of MCS level varies at each time instant. We model the MaRS problem as a Non-Linear Programming problem and show that it is NP-Hard. Next, we propose a solution based on greedy algorithm paradigm. We then develop an upper performance bound for this problem and finally evaluate the performance of proposed solution by comparing against the upper bound under various channel and network configurations.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Deep Learning for Fast and Reliable Initial Access in AI-Driven 6G mmWave Networks
Authors:
Tarun S. Cousik,
Vijay K. Shah,
Tugba Erpek,
Yalin E. Sagduyu,
Jeffrey H. Reed
Abstract:
We present DeepIA, a deep neural network (DNN) framework for enabling fast and reliable initial access for AI-driven beyond 5G and 6G millimeter (mmWave) networks. DeepIA reduces the beam sweep time compared to a conventional exhaustive search-based IA process by utilizing only a subset of the available beams. DeepIA maps received signal strengths (RSSs) obtained from a subset of beams to the beam…
▽ More
We present DeepIA, a deep neural network (DNN) framework for enabling fast and reliable initial access for AI-driven beyond 5G and 6G millimeter (mmWave) networks. DeepIA reduces the beam sweep time compared to a conventional exhaustive search-based IA process by utilizing only a subset of the available beams. DeepIA maps received signal strengths (RSSs) obtained from a subset of beams to the beam that is best oriented to the receiver. In both line of sight (LoS) and non-line of sight (NLoS) conditions, DeepIA reduces the IA time and outperforms the conventional IA's beam prediction accuracy. We show that the beam prediction accuracy of DeepIA saturates with the number of beams used for IA and depends on the particular selection of the beams. In LoS conditions, the selection of the beams is consequential and improves the accuracy by up to 70%. In NLoS situations, it improves accuracy by up to 35%. We find that, averaging multiple RSS snapshots further reduces the number of beams needed and achieves more than 95% accuracy in both LoS and NLoS conditions. Finally, we evaluate the beam prediction time of DeepIA through embedded hardware implementation and show the improvement over the conventional beam sweeping.
△ Less
Submitted 5 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Underlay Radar-Massive MIMO Spectrum Sharing: Modeling Fundamentals and Performance Analysis
Authors:
Raghunandan M. Rao,
Harpreet S. Dhillon,
Vuk Marojevic,
Jeffrey H. Reed
Abstract:
In this work, we study underlay radar-massive MIMO cellular coexistence in LoS/near-LoS channels, where both systems have 3D beamforming capabilities. Using mathematical tools from stochastic geometry, we derive an upper bound on the average interference power at the radar due to the 3D massive MIMO cellular downlink under the worst-case `cell-edge beamforming' conditions. To overcome the technica…
▽ More
In this work, we study underlay radar-massive MIMO cellular coexistence in LoS/near-LoS channels, where both systems have 3D beamforming capabilities. Using mathematical tools from stochastic geometry, we derive an upper bound on the average interference power at the radar due to the 3D massive MIMO cellular downlink under the worst-case `cell-edge beamforming' conditions. To overcome the technical challenges imposed by asymmetric and arbitrarily large cells, we devise a novel construction in which each Poisson Voronoi (PV) cell is bounded by its circumcircle to bound the effect of the random cell shapes on average interference. Since this model is intractable for further analysis due to the correlation between adjacent PV cells' shapes and sizes, we propose a tractable nominal interference model, where we model each PV cell as a circular disk with an area equal to the average area of the typical cell. We quantify the gap in the average interference power between these two models and show that the upper bound is tight for realistic deployment parameters. We also compare them with a more practical but intractable MU-MIMO scheduling model to show that our worst-case interference models show the same trends and do not deviate significantly from realistic scheduler models. Under the nominal interference model, we characterize the interference distribution using the dominant interferer approximation by deriving the equi-interference contour expression when the typical receiver uses 3D beamforming. Finally, we use tractable expressions for the interference distribution to characterize radar's spatial probability of false alarm/detection in a quasi-static target tracking scenario. Our results reveal useful trends in the average interference as a function of the deployment parameters (BS density, exclusion zone radius, antenna height, transmit power of each BS, etc.).
△ Less
Submitted 16 May, 2021; v1 submitted 3 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Survey of Spectrum Regulation for Intelligent Transportation Systems
Authors:
Junsung Choi,
Vuk Marojevic,
Carl B. Dietrich,
Jeffrey H. Reed,
Seungyoung Ahn
Abstract:
As 5G communication technology develops, vehicular communications that require high reliability, low latency, and massive connectivity are drawing increasing interest from those in academia and industry. Due to these developing technologies, vehicular communication is not limited to vehicle components in the forms of Vehicle-to-Vehicle (V2V) or Vehicle-to-Infrastructure (V2I) networks, but has als…
▽ More
As 5G communication technology develops, vehicular communications that require high reliability, low latency, and massive connectivity are drawing increasing interest from those in academia and industry. Due to these developing technologies, vehicular communication is not limited to vehicle components in the forms of Vehicle-to-Vehicle (V2V) or Vehicle-to-Infrastructure (V2I) networks, but has also been extended to connect with others, such as pedestrians and cellular users. Dedicated Short-Range Communications (DSRC) is the conventional vehicular communication standard for Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITS). More recently, the 3rd Generation Partnership Project introduced Cellular-Vehicle-to-Everything (C-V2X), a competitor to DSRC. Meanwhile, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC)issued a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM) to consider deploying Unlicensed National Information Infrastructure (U-NII)devices in the ITS band with two interference mitigation approaches: Detect-and-Vacate (DAV)and Re-channelization (Re-CH). With multiple standard options and interference mitigation approaches, numerous regulatory taxonomies can be identified and notification of relevant technical challenges issued. However, these challenges are much broader than the current and future regulatory taxonomies pursued by the different countries involved. Because their plans differ, the technical and regulatory challenges vary. This paper presents a literature survey about the technical challenges, the current and future ITS band usage plans, and the major research testbeds for the U.S., Europe, China, Korea, and Japan. This survey shows that the most likely deployment taxonomies are (1) DSRC, C-V2X, and Wi-Fi with Re-CH; (2) DSRC and C-V2X with interoperation, and (3) C-V2X only. The most difficult technical challenge is the interoperability between the Wi-Fi-like DSRC and 4G LTE-like C-V2X.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2020; v1 submitted 26 June, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Fast Initial Access with Deep Learning for Beam Prediction in 5G mmWave Networks
Authors:
Tarun S. Cousik,
Vijay K. Shah,
Jeffrey H. Reed,
Tugba Erpek,
Yalin E. Sagduyu
Abstract:
This paper presents DeepIA, a deep learning solution for faster and more accurate initial access (IA) in 5G millimeter wave (mmWave) networks when compared to conventional IA. By utilizing a subset of beams in the IA process, DeepIA removes the need for an exhaustive beam search thereby reducing the beam sweep time in IA. A deep neural network (DNN) is trained to learn the complex mapping from the…
▽ More
This paper presents DeepIA, a deep learning solution for faster and more accurate initial access (IA) in 5G millimeter wave (mmWave) networks when compared to conventional IA. By utilizing a subset of beams in the IA process, DeepIA removes the need for an exhaustive beam search thereby reducing the beam sweep time in IA. A deep neural network (DNN) is trained to learn the complex mapping from the received signal strengths (RSSs) collected with a reduced number of beams to the optimal spatial beam of the receiver (among a larger set of beams). In test time, DeepIA measures RSSs only from a small number of beams and runs the DNN to predict the best beam for IA. We show that DeepIA reduces the IA time by sweeping fewer beams and significantly outperforms the conventional IA's beam prediction accuracy in both line of sight (LoS) and non-line of sight (NLoS) mmWave channel conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Semi-Blind Post-Equalizer SINR Estimation and Dual CSI Feedback for Radar-Cellular Coexistence
Authors:
Raghunandan M. Rao,
Vuk Marojevic,
Jeffrey H. Reed
Abstract:
Current cellular systems use pilot-aided statistical-channel state information (S-CSI) estimation and limited feedback schemes to aid in link adaptation and scheduling decisions. However, in the presence of pulsed radar signals, pilot-aided S-CSI is inaccurate since interference statistics on pilot and non-pilot resources can be different. Moreover, the channel will be bimodal as a result of the p…
▽ More
Current cellular systems use pilot-aided statistical-channel state information (S-CSI) estimation and limited feedback schemes to aid in link adaptation and scheduling decisions. However, in the presence of pulsed radar signals, pilot-aided S-CSI is inaccurate since interference statistics on pilot and non-pilot resources can be different. Moreover, the channel will be bimodal as a result of the periodic interference. In this paper, we propose a max-min heuristic to estimate the post-equalizer SINR in the case of non-pilot pulsed radar interference, and characterize its distribution as a function of noise variance and interference power. We observe that the proposed heuristic incurs low computational complexity, and is robust beyond a certain SINR threshold for different modulation schemes, especially for QPSK. This enables us to develop a comprehensive semi-blind framework to estimate the wideband SINR metric that is commonly used for S-CSI quantization in 3GPP Long-Term Evolution (LTE) and New Radio (NR) networks. Finally, we propose dual CSI feedback for practical radar-cellular spectrum sharing, to enable accurate CSI acquisition in the bimodal channel. We demonstrate significant improvements in throughput, block error rate and retransmission-induced latency for LTE-Advanced Pro when compared to conventional pilot-aided S-CSI estimation and limited feedback schemes.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Intelligent O-RAN for Beyond 5G and 6G Wireless Networks
Authors:
Solmaz Niknam,
Abhishek Roy,
Harpreet S. Dhillon,
Sukhdeep Singh,
Rahul Banerji,
Jeffery H. Reed,
Navrati Saxena,
Seungil Yoon
Abstract:
Building on the principles of openness and intelligence, there has been a concerted global effort from the operators towards enhancing the radio access network (RAN) architecture. The objective is to build an operator-defined RAN architecture (and associated interfaces) on open hardware that provides intelligent radio control for beyond fifth generation (5G) as well as future sixth generation (6G)…
▽ More
Building on the principles of openness and intelligence, there has been a concerted global effort from the operators towards enhancing the radio access network (RAN) architecture. The objective is to build an operator-defined RAN architecture (and associated interfaces) on open hardware that provides intelligent radio control for beyond fifth generation (5G) as well as future sixth generation (6G) wireless networks. Specifically, the open-radio access network (O-RAN) alliance has been formed by merging xRAN forum and C-RAN alliance to formally define the requirements that would help achieve this objective. Owing to the importance of O-RAN in the current wireless landscape, this article provides an introduction to the concepts, principles, and requirements of the Open RAN as specified by the O-RAN alliance. In order to illustrate the role of intelligence in O-RAN, we propose an intelligent radio resource management scheme to handle traffic congestion and demonstrate its efficacy on a real-world dataset obtained from a large operator. A high-level architecture of this deployment scenario that is compliant with the O-RAN requirements is also discussed. The article concludes with key technical challenges and open problems for future research and development.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Probability of Pilot Interference in Pulsed Radar-Cellular Coexistence: Fundamental Insights on Demodulation and Limited CSI Feedback
Authors:
Raghunandan M. Rao,
Vuk Marojevic,
Jeffrey H. Reed
Abstract:
This paper considers an underlay pulsed radar-cellular spectrum sharing scenario, where the cellular system uses pilot-aided demodulation, statistical channel state information (S-CSI) estimation and limited feedback schemes. Under a realistic system model, upper and lower bounds are derived on the probability that at least a specified number of pilot signals are interfered by a radar pulse train…
▽ More
This paper considers an underlay pulsed radar-cellular spectrum sharing scenario, where the cellular system uses pilot-aided demodulation, statistical channel state information (S-CSI) estimation and limited feedback schemes. Under a realistic system model, upper and lower bounds are derived on the probability that at least a specified number of pilot signals are interfered by a radar pulse train in a finite CSI estimation window. Exact probabilities are also derived for important special cases which reveal operational regimes where the lower bound is achieved. Using these results, this paper (a) provides insights on pilot interference-minimizing schemes for accurate coherent symbol demodulation, and (b) demonstrates that pilot-aided methods fail to accurately estimate S-CSI of the pulsed radar interference channel for a wide range of radar repetition intervals.
△ Less
Submitted 30 April, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
CogRF: A New Frontier for Machine Learning and Artificial Intelligence for 6G RF Systems
Authors:
Tarun Cousik,
Rubayet Shafin,
Zhou Zhou,
Kaleb Kleine,
Jeffrey Reed,
Lingjia Liu
Abstract:
The concept of CogRF, a novel tunable radio frequency (RF) frontend that uses artificial intelligence (AI) to meet mission requirements for beyond 5G and 6G systems, is introduced. CogRF utilizes AI as the core to control and operate RF system components with the objective of optimizing the overall system performance. An overview of the vital elements that make up CogRF as well as the overall hier…
▽ More
The concept of CogRF, a novel tunable radio frequency (RF) frontend that uses artificial intelligence (AI) to meet mission requirements for beyond 5G and 6G systems, is introduced. CogRF utilizes AI as the core to control and operate RF system components with the objective of optimizing the overall system performance. An overview of the vital elements that make up CogRF as well as the overall hierarchy of the envisioned CogRF system is provided, and potential RF components and control parameters are discussed. AI-powered flexible RF front ends, provide new opportunities to identify to enhance security, speed up optimization of device configurations, further refine radio design, improve existing spectrum sharing operations, and develop device health analytics. Top research challenges for CogRF systems have also been described and potential research directions are provided.
△ Less
Submitted 15 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Federated Learning for Wireless Communications: Motivation, Opportunities and Challenges
Authors:
Solmaz Niknam,
Harpreet S. Dhillon,
Jeffery H. Reed
Abstract:
There is a growing interest in the wireless communications community to complement the traditional model-based design approaches with data-driven machine learning (ML)-based solutions. While conventional ML approaches rely on the assumption of having the data and processing heads in a central entity, this is not always feasible in wireless communications applications because of the inaccessibility…
▽ More
There is a growing interest in the wireless communications community to complement the traditional model-based design approaches with data-driven machine learning (ML)-based solutions. While conventional ML approaches rely on the assumption of having the data and processing heads in a central entity, this is not always feasible in wireless communications applications because of the inaccessibility of private data and large communication overhead required to transmit raw data to central ML processors. As a result, decentralized ML approaches that keep the data where it is generated are much more appealing. Owing to its privacy-preserving nature, federated learning is particularly relevant for many wireless applications, especially in the context of fifth generation (5G) networks. In this article, we provide an accessible introduction to the general idea of federated learning, discuss several possible applications in 5G networks, and describe key technical challenges and open problems for future research on federated learning in the context of wireless communications.
△ Less
Submitted 2 May, 2020; v1 submitted 30 July, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Analysis of Worst-Case Interference in Underlay Radar-Massive MIMO Spectrum Sharing Scenarios
Authors:
Raghunandan M. Rao,
Harpeet S. Dhillon,
Vuk Marojevic,
Jeffrey H. Reed
Abstract:
In this paper, we consider an underlay radar-massive MIMO spectrum sharing scenario in which massive MIMO base stations (BSs) are allowed to operate outside a circular exclusion zone centered at the radar. Modeling the locations of the massive MIMO BSs as a homogeneous Poisson point process (PPP), we derive an analytical expression for a tight upper bound on the average interference at the radar d…
▽ More
In this paper, we consider an underlay radar-massive MIMO spectrum sharing scenario in which massive MIMO base stations (BSs) are allowed to operate outside a circular exclusion zone centered at the radar. Modeling the locations of the massive MIMO BSs as a homogeneous Poisson point process (PPP), we derive an analytical expression for a tight upper bound on the average interference at the radar due to cellular transmissions. The technical novelty is in bounding the worst-case elevation angle for each massive MIMO BS for which we devise a novel construction based on the circumradius distribution of a typical Poisson-Voronoi (PV) cell. While these worst-case elevation angles are correlated for neighboring BSs due to the structure of the PV tessellation, it does not explicitly appear in our analysis because of our focus on the average interference. We also provide an estimate of the nominal average interference by approximating each cell as a circle with area equal to the average area of the typical cell. Using these results, we demonstrate that the gap between the two results remains approximately constant with respect to the exclusion zone radius. Our analysis reveals useful trends in average interference power, as a function of key deployment parameters such as radar/BS antenna heights, number of antenna elements per radar/BS, BS density, and exclusion zone radius.
△ Less
Submitted 22 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Artificial Intelligence-Enabled Cellular Networks: A Critical Path to Beyond-5G and 6G
Authors:
Rubayet Shafin,
Lingjia Liu,
Vikram Chandrasekhar,
Hao Chen,
Jeffrey Reed,
Jianzhong,
Zhang
Abstract:
Mobile Network Operators (MNOs) are in process of overlaying their conventional macro cellular networks with shorter range cells such as outdoor pico cells. The resultant increase in network complexity creates substantial overhead in terms of operating expenses, time, and labor for their planning and management. Artificial intelligence (AI) offers the potential for MNOs to operate their networks i…
▽ More
Mobile Network Operators (MNOs) are in process of overlaying their conventional macro cellular networks with shorter range cells such as outdoor pico cells. The resultant increase in network complexity creates substantial overhead in terms of operating expenses, time, and labor for their planning and management. Artificial intelligence (AI) offers the potential for MNOs to operate their networks in a more organic and cost-efficient manner. We argue that deploying AI in 5G and Beyond will require surmounting significant technical barriers in terms of robustness, performance, and complexity. We outline future research directions, identify top 5 challenges, and present a possible roadmap to realize the vision of AI-enabled cellular networks for Beyond-5G and 6G.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Self-Tuning Sectorization: Deep Reinforcement Learning Meets Broadcast Beam Optimization
Authors:
Rubayet Shafin,
Hao Chen,
Young Han Nam,
Sooyoung Hur,
Jeongho Park,
Jianzhong,
Zhang,
Jeffrey Reed,
Lingjia Liu
Abstract:
Beamforming in multiple input multiple output (MIMO) systems is one of the key technologies for modern wireless communication. Creating appropriate sector-specific broadcast beams are essential for enhancing the coverage of cellular network and for improving the broadcast operation for control signals. However, in order to maximize the coverage, patterns for broadcast beams need to be adapted base…
▽ More
Beamforming in multiple input multiple output (MIMO) systems is one of the key technologies for modern wireless communication. Creating appropriate sector-specific broadcast beams are essential for enhancing the coverage of cellular network and for improving the broadcast operation for control signals. However, in order to maximize the coverage, patterns for broadcast beams need to be adapted based on the users' distribution and movement over time. In this work, we present self-tuning sectorization: a deep reinforcement learning framework to optimize MIMO broadcast beams autonomously and dynamically based on user' distribution in the network. Taking directly UE measurement results as input, deep reinforcement learning agent can track and predict the UE distribution pattern and come up with the best broadcast beams for each cell. Extensive simulation results show that the introduced framework can achieve the optimal coverage, and converge to the oracle solution for both single sector and multiple sectors environment, and for both periodic and Markov mobility patterns.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Prototypes of Using Directional Antenna for Railroad Crossing Safety Applications
Authors:
Xiaofu Ma,
Sayantan Guha,
Junsung Choi,
Christopher R. Anderson,
Randall Nealy,
Jared Withers,
Jeffrey H. Reed,
Carl Dietrich
Abstract:
In this demonstration proposal, we present a prototype of a rapidly deployable and cost-effective railroad crossing early warning system integrated with the railway system. Specifically, the proposed demonstration deal with the safety applications based on dedicated short range communications (DSRC) protocol and devices using our different antennas. We will demonstrate the feasibility and advantag…
▽ More
In this demonstration proposal, we present a prototype of a rapidly deployable and cost-effective railroad crossing early warning system integrated with the railway system. Specifically, the proposed demonstration deal with the safety applications based on dedicated short range communications (DSRC) protocol and devices using our different antennas. We will demonstrate the feasibility and advantages of our proposed system, including the antenna design, system deployment, the over-the-air transmission, and the software applications that we developed for the end users.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2018;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Demonstration Paper: Wirelessly Sensing Medication Administration: Cyber-Physical Event Detection and Notification Utilizing Multi-Element Chipless RFID
Authors:
Xiaofu Ma,
Thaddeus Czauski,
Taeyoung Yang,
Jeffrey H Reed
Abstract:
Medication administration is one pathway by which Adverse Drug Events (ADE) can occur. While Electronic Medical Administration Record (eMAR) systems help reduce the number of ADEs, current eMAR implementations suffer from workarounds that defeat safety and verification mechanisms meant to limit the number of potential ADEs that occur during medication administration. In this paper, we introduce Mu…
▽ More
Medication administration is one pathway by which Adverse Drug Events (ADE) can occur. While Electronic Medical Administration Record (eMAR) systems help reduce the number of ADEs, current eMAR implementations suffer from workarounds that defeat safety and verification mechanisms meant to limit the number of potential ADEs that occur during medication administration. In this paper, we introduce Multi-Element ChipLess (MECL) RFID tags which enable real-time event notifications through event signatures. Event signatures correspond to the physical configuration of different RFID elements in a chipless RFID tag. Augmenting physical objects, such as a pill container, with MECL-RFID can allow caregivers to detect the moment a particular pill container is opened or closed. We present the fundamentals behind real-time event detection using MECL-RFID and propose a cyber-physical intervention system that can be used to reduce ADEs through realtime event monitoring and notifications sent to clinicians administering medication. We also present a prototype MECL-RFID to demonstrate potential future improvements to eMAR systems that minimize ADEs.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Analysis of directional antenna for railroad crossing safety applications
Authors:
Xiaofu Ma,
Sayantan Guha,
Junsung Choi,
Christopher R Anderson,
Randall Nealy,
Jared Withers,
Jeffrey H Reed,
Carl Dietrich
Abstract:
A rapidly deployable and cost-effective railroad crossing early warning system integrated with the railway system is attractive due to its protection of the unmanned grade crossings, which requires a warning system with long-distance communication link. In this paper, we investigate the problem of suitable antenna selection for such a railway warning system First, the antenna criteria for railroad…
▽ More
A rapidly deployable and cost-effective railroad crossing early warning system integrated with the railway system is attractive due to its protection of the unmanned grade crossings, which requires a warning system with long-distance communication link. In this paper, we investigate the problem of suitable antenna selection for such a railway warning system First, the antenna criteria for railroad crossing safety applications are described based on practical system considerations, the safe distances on the road and on the railway. Then, the optimal antenna pattern is derived theoretically to get the smallest size which fits for the practical installation. We also conducted a feasibility study of an array antenna through measurements on a near field scanner.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Hypergraph matching for MU-MIMO user grouping in wireless LANs
Authors:
Xiaofu Ma,
Qinghai Gao,
Vuk Marojevic,
Jeffrey H. Reed
Abstract:
This paper investigates the user grouping problem of downlink wireless local area networks (WLANs) with multi-user MIMO (MU-MIMO). Particularly, we focus on the problem of whether single user transmit beamforming (SU-TxBF) or MU-MIMO should be utilized, and how many users and which users should be in a multi-user (MU) group. We formulate the problem for maximizing the system throughput subject to…
▽ More
This paper investigates the user grouping problem of downlink wireless local area networks (WLANs) with multi-user MIMO (MU-MIMO). Particularly, we focus on the problem of whether single user transmit beamforming (SU-TxBF) or MU-MIMO should be utilized, and how many users and which users should be in a multi-user (MU) group. We formulate the problem for maximizing the system throughput subject to the multi-user air time fairness (MU-ATF) criterion. We show that hypergraphs provide a suitable mathematical model and effective tool for finding the optimal or close to optimal solution. We show that the optimal grouping problem can be solved efficiently for the case where only SU-TxBF and 2-user MU groups are allowed in the system. For the general case, where any number of users can be assigned to groups of different sizes, we develop an efficient graph matching algorithm (GMA) based on graph theory principles. We evaluate the proposed algorithm in terms of system throughput using an 802.11ac emulator, which is created using collected channel measurements from an indoor environment and simulated channel samples for outdoor scenarios. We show that our GMA achieves at least 93% of the optimal system throughput in all considered test cases.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Dynamic Sounding for Multi-User MIMO in Wireless LANs
Authors:
Xiaofu Ma,
Qinghai Gao,
Ji Wang,
Vuk Marojevic,
Jeffrey H. Reed
Abstract:
Consumer electronic (CE) devices increasingly rely on wireless local area networks (WLANs). Next generation WLANs will continue to exploit multiple antenna systems to satisfy the growing need for WLAN system capacity. Multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) antenna systems improve the spectral efficiency and single user throughput. Multi-user MIMO (MU-MIMO) systems exploit the spatial separation of…
▽ More
Consumer electronic (CE) devices increasingly rely on wireless local area networks (WLANs). Next generation WLANs will continue to exploit multiple antenna systems to satisfy the growing need for WLAN system capacity. Multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) antenna systems improve the spectral efficiency and single user throughput. Multi-user MIMO (MU-MIMO) systems exploit the spatial separation of users for increasing the sum-throughput. In an MU-MIMO system, efficient channel sounding is essential for achieving optimal performance. The system analysis in this paper provides insights into the rate at which to perform channel sounding. This paper shows that optimal sounding intervals exist for single user transmit beamforming (SU-TxBF) and MU-MIMO, and proposes a low-complexity dynamic sounding approach for practical MU-MIMO WLAN deployments. The proposed approach adjusts the sounding interval adaptively based on the real-time learning outcomes in the given radio environment. Using real over-the-air channel measurements, significant throughput improvements (up to 31.8%) are demonstrated by adopting the proposed dynamic sounding approach, which is compliant with IEEE 802.11ac.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Artificial Intelligence-Defined 5G Radio Access Networks
Authors:
Miao Yao,
Munawwar Sohul,
Vuk Marojevic,
Jeffrey H. Reed
Abstract:
Massive multiple-input multiple-output antenna systems, millimeter wave communications, and ultra-dense networks have been widely perceived as the three key enablers that facilitate the development and deployment of 5G systems. This article discusses the intelligent agent in 5G base station which combines sensing, learning, understanding and optimizing to facilitate these enablers. We present a fl…
▽ More
Massive multiple-input multiple-output antenna systems, millimeter wave communications, and ultra-dense networks have been widely perceived as the three key enablers that facilitate the development and deployment of 5G systems. This article discusses the intelligent agent in 5G base station which combines sensing, learning, understanding and optimizing to facilitate these enablers. We present a flexible, rapidly deployable, and cross-layer artificial intelligence (AI)-based framework to enable the imminent and future demands on 5G and beyond infrastructure. We present example AI-enabled 5G use cases that accommodate important 5G-specific capabilities and discuss the value of AI for enabling beyond 5G network evolution.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2018; v1 submitted 21 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Regulatory Options and Technical Challenges for the 5.9 GHz Spectrum: Survey and Analysis
Authors:
Junsung Choi,
Vuk Marojevic,
Mina Labib,
Siddharth Kabra,
Jayanthi Rao,
Sushanta Das,
Jeffery H. Reed,
Carl B. Dietrich
Abstract:
In 1999, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) allocated 75 MHz in the 5.9 GHz ITS Band (5850-5925 MHz) for use by Dedicated Short Range Communications (DSRC) to facilitate information transfer between equipped vehicles and roadside systems. This allocation for DSRC in the ITS band has been a co-primary allocation while the band is shared with the Fixed Satellite Service (FSS), fixed microwa…
▽ More
In 1999, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) allocated 75 MHz in the 5.9 GHz ITS Band (5850-5925 MHz) for use by Dedicated Short Range Communications (DSRC) to facilitate information transfer between equipped vehicles and roadside systems. This allocation for DSRC in the ITS band has been a co-primary allocation while the band is shared with the Fixed Satellite Service (FSS), fixed microwave service, amateur radio services and other Federal users authorized by the National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA). In recent time, Cellular V2X (C-V2X), introduced in 3GPP Release 14 LTE standard, has received significant attention due to its perceived ability to deliver superior performance with respect to vehicular safety applications. There is a strong momentum in the industry for C-V2X to be considered as a viable alternative to DSRC and accordingly, to operate in the ITS spectrum. In another recent notice, the FCC is soliciting input for a proposed rulemaking to open up more bandwidth for unlicensed Wi-Fi devices, mainly based on the 802.11ac standard. The FCC plans to work with the Department of Transportation (DoT), and the automotive and communications industries to evaluate potential sharing techniques in the ITS band between DSRC and Wi-Fi devices. This paper analyzes the expected scenarios that might emerge from FCC and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) regulation options and identifies the technical challenge associated with each scenario. We also provide a literature survey and find that many of resulting technical challenges remain open research problems that need to be addressed. We conclude that the most challenging issue is related to the interoperability between DSRC and C-V2X in the 5.9 GHz band and the detection and avoidance of harmful adjacent and co-channel interference.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Measuring Hardware Impairments with Software-Defined Radios
Authors:
Vuk Marojevic,
Aditya V. Padaki,
Raghunandan M. Rao,
Jeffrey H. Reed
Abstract:
This Innovative Practice Full Paper introduces a novel tool for educating electrical engineering students about hardware impairments in wireless communications. A radio frequency (RF) front end is an essential part of a wireless transmitter or receiver. It features analog processing components and data converters which are driven by today's digital communication systems. Advancements in computing…
▽ More
This Innovative Practice Full Paper introduces a novel tool for educating electrical engineering students about hardware impairments in wireless communications. A radio frequency (RF) front end is an essential part of a wireless transmitter or receiver. It features analog processing components and data converters which are driven by today's digital communication systems. Advancements in computing and software-defined radio (SDR) technology have enabled shaping waveforms in software and using experimental and easily accessible plug-and-play RF front ends for education, research and development. We use this same technology to teach nonlinear effects of RF front ends and their implications. It uses widely available RF instruments and components and SDR technology--well-established affordable hardware and free open source software--to teach students how to characterize the nonlinearity of RF receivers while providing hands-on experience with SDR tools. We present the hardware, software and procedures of our laboratory session that enable easy reproducibility in other classrooms. We discuss different forms of evaluating the suitability of the new class modules and conclude that it provides a valuable learning experience that bolsters the theory that is typically provided in lectures only.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Semidefinite Relaxation-Based PAPR-Aware Precoding for Massive MIMO-OFDM Systems
Authors:
Miao Yao,
Matt Carrick,
Munawwar M. Sohul,
Vuk Marojevic,
Cameron D. Patterson,
Jeffrey H. Reed
Abstract:
Massive MIMO requires a large number of antennas and the same amount of power amplifiers (PAs), one per antenna. As opposed to 4G base stations, which could afford highly linear PAs, next-generation base stations will need to use inexpensive PAs, which have a limited region of linear amplification. One of the research challenges is effectively handling signals which have high peak-to-average power…
▽ More
Massive MIMO requires a large number of antennas and the same amount of power amplifiers (PAs), one per antenna. As opposed to 4G base stations, which could afford highly linear PAs, next-generation base stations will need to use inexpensive PAs, which have a limited region of linear amplification. One of the research challenges is effectively handling signals which have high peak-to-average power ratios (PAPRs), such as orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM). This paper introduces a PAPR-aware precoding scheme that exploits the excessive spatial degrees-of-freedom of large scale multiple-input multipleoutput (MIMO) antenna systems. This typically requires finding a solution to a nonconvex optimization problem. Instead of relaxing the problem to minimize the peak power, we introduce a practical semidefinite relaxation (SDR) framework that enables accurately and efficiently approximating the theoretical PAPR-aware precoding performance for OFDM-based massive MIMO systems. The framework allows incorporating channel uncertainties and intercell coordination. Numerical results show that several orders of magnitude improvements can be achieved w.r.t. state of the art techniques, such as instantaneous power consumption reduction and multiuser interference cancellation. The proposed PAPRaware precoding can be effectively handled along with the multicell signal processing by the centralized baseband processing platforms of next-generation radio access networks. Performance can be traded for the computing efficiency for other platforms
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Deep Predictive Coding Neural Network for RF Anomaly Detection in Wireless Networks
Authors:
Nistha Tandiya,
Ahmad Jauhar,
Vuk Marojevic,
Jeffrey H. Reed
Abstract:
Intrusion detection has become one of the most critical tasks in a wireless network to prevent service outages that can take long to fix. The sheer variety of anomalous events necessitates adopting cognitive anomaly detection methods instead of the traditional signature-based detection techniques. This paper proposes an anomaly detection methodology for wireless systems that is based on monitoring…
▽ More
Intrusion detection has become one of the most critical tasks in a wireless network to prevent service outages that can take long to fix. The sheer variety of anomalous events necessitates adopting cognitive anomaly detection methods instead of the traditional signature-based detection techniques. This paper proposes an anomaly detection methodology for wireless systems that is based on monitoring and analyzing radio frequency (RF) spectrum activities. Our detection technique leverages an existing solution for the video prediction problem, and uses it on image sequences generated from monitoring the wireless spectrum. The deep predictive coding network is trained with images corresponding to the normal behavior of the system, and whenever there is an anomaly, its detection is triggered by the deviation between the actual and predicted behavior. For our analysis, we use the images generated from the time-frequency spectrograms and spectral correlation functions of the received RF signal. We test our technique on a dataset which contains anomalies such as jamming, chirping of transmitters, spectrum hijacking, and node failure, and evaluate its performance using standard classifier metrics: detection ratio, and false alarm rate. Simulation results demonstrate that the proposed methodology effectively detects many unforeseen anomalous events in real time. We discuss the applications, which encompass industrial IoT, autonomous vehicle control and mission-critical communications services.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
A Digital Predistortion Scheme Exploiting Degrees-of-Freedom for Massive MIMO Systems
Authors:
Miao Yao,
Munawwar Sohul,
Randall Nealy,
Vuk Marojevic,
Jeffrey Reed
Abstract:
The primary source of nonlinear distortion in wireless transmitters is the power amplifier (PA). Conventional digital predistortion (DPD) schemes use high-order polynomials to accurately approximate and compensate for the nonlinearity of the PA. This is not practical for scaling to tens or hundreds of PAs in massive multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) systems. There is more than one candidate pr…
▽ More
The primary source of nonlinear distortion in wireless transmitters is the power amplifier (PA). Conventional digital predistortion (DPD) schemes use high-order polynomials to accurately approximate and compensate for the nonlinearity of the PA. This is not practical for scaling to tens or hundreds of PAs in massive multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) systems. There is more than one candidate precoding matrix in a massive MIMO system because of the excess degrees-of-freedom (DoFs), and each precoding matrix requires a different DPD polynomial order to compensate for the PA nonlinearity. This paper proposes a low-order DPD method achieved by exploiting massive DoFs of next-generation front ends. We propose a novel indirect learning structure which adapts the channel and PA distortion iteratively by cascading adaptive zero forcing precoding and DPD. Our solution uses a 3rd order polynomial to achieve the same performance as the conventional DPD using an 11th order polynomial for a 100x10 massive MIMO configuration. Experimental results show a 70% reduction in computational complexity, enabling ultra-low latency communications.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Sustainable Green Networking: Exploiting Degrees of Freedom towards Energy-Efficient 5G Systems
Authors:
Miao Yao,
Munawwar Sohul,
Xiaofu Ma,
Vuk Marojevic,
Jeffrey H. Reed
Abstract:
The carbon footprint concern in the development and deployment of 5G new radio systems has drawn the attention to several stakeholders. In this article, we analyze the critical power consuming component of all candidate 5G system architectures-the power amplifier (PA)-and propose PA-centric resource management solutions for green 5G communications. We discuss the impact of ongoing trends in cellul…
▽ More
The carbon footprint concern in the development and deployment of 5G new radio systems has drawn the attention to several stakeholders. In this article, we analyze the critical power consuming component of all candidate 5G system architectures-the power amplifier (PA)-and propose PA-centric resource management solutions for green 5G communications. We discuss the impact of ongoing trends in cellular communications on sustainable green networking and analyze two communications architectures that allow exploiting the extra degrees-of-freedom (DoF) from multi-antenna and massive antenna deployments: small cells/distributed antenna network and massive MIMO. For small cell systems with a moderate number of antennas, we propose a peak to average power ratio-aware resource allocation scheme for joint orthogonal frequency and space division multiple access. For massive MIMO systems, we develop a highly parallel recurrent neural network for energy-efficient precoding. Simulation results for representative 5G deployment scenarios demonstrate an energy efficiency improvement of one order of magnitude or higher with respect to current state-of-the-art solutions.
△ Less
Submitted 1 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
LTE Spectrum Sharing Research Testbed: Integrated Hardware, Software, Network and Data
Authors:
Vuk Marojevic,
Randall Nealy,
Jeffrey H. Reed
Abstract:
This paper presents Virginia Tech's wireless testbed supporting research on long-term evolution (LTE) signaling and radio frequency (RF) spectrum coexistence. LTE is continuously refined and new features released. As the communications contexts for LTE expand, new research problems arise and include operation in harsh RF signaling environments and coexistence with other radios. Our testbed provide…
▽ More
This paper presents Virginia Tech's wireless testbed supporting research on long-term evolution (LTE) signaling and radio frequency (RF) spectrum coexistence. LTE is continuously refined and new features released. As the communications contexts for LTE expand, new research problems arise and include operation in harsh RF signaling environments and coexistence with other radios. Our testbed provides an integrated research tool for investigating these and other research problems; it allows analyzing the severity of the problem, designing and rapidly prototyping solutions, and assessing them with standard-compliant equipment and test procedures. The modular testbed integrates general-purpose software-defined radio hardware, LTE-specific test equipment, RF components, free open-source and commercial LTE software, a configurable RF network and recorded radar waveform samples. It supports RF channel emulated and over-the-air radiated modes. The testbed can be remotely accessed and configured. An RF switching network allows for designing many different experiments that can involve a variety of real and virtual radios with support for multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) antenna operation. We present the testbed, the research it has enabled and some valuable lessons that we learned and that may help designing, developing, and operating future wireless testbeds.
△ Less
Submitted 6 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Coexistence between Communication and Radar Systems - A Survey
Authors:
Mina Labib,
Vuk Marojevic,
Anthony F. Martone,
Jeffrey H. Reed,
Amir I. Zaghloul
Abstract:
Data traffic demand in cellular networks has been tremendously growing and has led to creating congested RF environment. Accordingly, innovative approaches for spectrum sharing have been proposed and implemented to accommodate several systems within the same frequency band. Spectrum sharing between radar and communication systems is one of the important research and development areas. In this pape…
▽ More
Data traffic demand in cellular networks has been tremendously growing and has led to creating congested RF environment. Accordingly, innovative approaches for spectrum sharing have been proposed and implemented to accommodate several systems within the same frequency band. Spectrum sharing between radar and communication systems is one of the important research and development areas. In this paper, we present the fundamental spectrum sharing concepts and technologies, then we provide an updated and comprehensive survey of spectrum sharing techniques that have been developed to enable some of the wireless communication systems to coexist in the same band as radar systems.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.