Title:Bridging Critical Gaps in Convergent Learning: How Representational Alignment Evolves Across Layers, Training, and Distribution Shifts

Abstract:Understanding convergent learning -- the extent to which artificial and biological neural networks develop similar representations -- is crucial for neuroscience and AI, as it reveals shared learning principles and guides brain-like model design. While several studies have noted convergence in early and late layers of vision networks, key gaps remain. First, much existing work relies on a limited set of metrics, overlooking transformation invariances required for proper alignment. We compare three metrics that ignore specific irrelevant transformations: linear regression (ignoring affine transformations), Procrustes (ignoring rotations and reflections), and permutation/soft-matching (ignoring unit order). Notably, orthogonal transformations align representations nearly as effectively as more flexible linear ones, and although permutation scores are lower, they significantly exceed chance, indicating a robust representational basis. A second critical gap lies in understanding when alignment emerges during training. Contrary to expectations that convergence builds gradually with task-specific learning, our findings reveal that nearly all convergence occurs within the first epoch -- long before networks achieve optimal performance. This suggests that shared input statistics, architectural biases, or early training dynamics drive convergence rather than the final task solution. Finally, prior studies have not systematically examined how changes in input statistics affect alignment. Our work shows that out-of-distribution (OOD) inputs consistently amplify differences in later layers, while early layers remain aligned for both in-distribution and OOD inputs, suggesting that this alignment is driven by generalizable features stable across distribution shifts. These findings fill critical gaps in our understanding of representational convergence, with implications for neuroscience and AI.