Title:High detection significance of the dark substructure in gravitational lens SDSSJ0946+1006 is revealed by image pixel supersampling

Abstract:Recent studies have shown that the dark substructure reported in the gravitational lens SDSSJ0946+1006 has a high central density which is in apparent tension with the $\Lambda$CDM paradigm. However, the detection significance of the substructure has been found in Ballard et al. (2024) to be sensitive to the assumed prior on the smoothness of the source galaxy: a sufficiently noisy source allows for noise-level residuals even without including a subhalo in the model. Here we show that the detection significance of the substructure is higher than previously reported ($\Delta\ln Z \approx 143$, equivalent to a $\sim17\sigma$ detection) by approximating the integration of light over each pixel via ray tracing and averaging over many subpixels--a technique known as supersampling--and this result is insensitive to the assumed prior on the source galaxy smoothness. Assuming a dark matter subhalo, supersampling also tightens the subhalo constraints: we find that the subhalo's projected mass enclosed within 1 kpc lies within the range $(2.2-3.4)\times10^9M_\odot$ at the 95\% confidence level in our highest evidence model, while the log-slope of the subhalo's projected density profile at 1 kpc is steeper than $-1.75$ at the 95\% confidence level, further establishing it as an outlier compared to expectations from CDM. Supersampling also allows us to identify a systematic within the data that has biased the slope of the primary lensing galaxy's density profile in prior studies, which we speculate might be due to the presence of dust or an imperfect foreground subtraction. Our analysis places the existence of the substructure in SDSSJ0946+1006 on firmer ground, and should motivate deeper follow-up observations to better constrain the properties of this substructure and clarify the severity of its apparent tension with $\Lambda$CDM.