Title:Is downward conduction possible in turbulent convection driven by internal heating?

Abstract:Consider an internally heated fluid between parallel plates with fixed thermal fluxes. Can the upward convective heat transport due to turbulence be so effective that the top plate is on average hotter than the bottom one, causing a downward conductive heat flux? For a large class of heat sources that vary in the direction of gravity, we prove that the average temperature difference between the bottom and top plates satisfies $\langle \delta T \rangle_h \geq \sigma R^{-1/3} - \mu$, where $R$ is a `flux' Rayleigh number and the constants $\sigma,\mu >0$ depend on the geometric properties of the internal heating. This lower bound implies that $\langle \delta T \rangle_h \geq 0$ for all Rayleigh numbers smaller than a critical value $R_o$, revealing regimes in which mean downward conduction is impossible. The critical Rayleigh number $R_o$ depends on the heating distribution and can be made arbitrarily large by concentrating the heating near the bottom plate. However, there is no heat distribution for which our lower bound rules out downward conduction at all Rayleigh numbers. This points to a fundamental difference between internally heated convection and its limiting case of Rayleigh-Bénard convection with fixed flux boundary conditions, for which $\langle \delta T \rangle_h$ is known to remain positive.