Title:Reuse Distance-based Copy-backs of Clean Cache Lines to Lower-level Caches

Abstract:Cache plays a critical role in reducing the performance gap between CPU and main memory. A modern multi-core CPU generally employs a multi-level hierarchy of caches, through which the most recently and frequently used data are maintained in each core's local private caches while all cores share the last-level cache (LLC). For inclusive caches, clean cache lines replaced in higher-level caches are not necessarily copied back to lower levels, as the inclusiveness implies their existences in lower levels. For exclusive and non-inclusive caches that are widely utilized by Intel, AMD, and ARM today, either indiscriminately copying back all or none of replaced clean cache lines to lower levels raises no violation to exclusiveness and non-inclusiveness definitions.
We have conducted a quantitative study and found that, copying back all or none of clean cache lines to lower-level cache of exclusive caches entails suboptimal performance. The reason is that only a part of cache lines would be reused and others turn to be dead in a long run. This observation motivates us to selectively copy back some clean cache lines to LLC in an architecture of exclusive or non-inclusive caches. We revisit the concept of reuse distance of cache lines. In a nutshell, a clean cache line with a shorter reuse distance is copied back to lower-level cache as it is likely to be re-referenced in the near future, while cache lines with much longer reuse distances would be discarded or sent to memory if they are dirty. We have implemented and evaluated our proposal with non-volatile (STT-MRAM) LLC. Experimental results with gem5 and SPEC CPU 2017 benchmarks show that on average our proposal yields up to 12.8% higher throughput of IPC (instructions per cycle) than the least-recently-used (LRU) replacement policy with copying back all clean cache lines for STT-MRAM LLC.