Title:On the Physical Origin of the 1/4 Exact Exchange in Density Functional Theory

Abstract:The physical origin of the exact exchange mixing in density functional theory (DFT)'s hybrid functionals is an open problem in electronic structure theory. Here we show that the widely used 1/4 fraction of exact exchange is compatible with a correct quantum mechanical treatment of the exchange energy of an electron pair in the interacting electron gas. The 1/4 exact exchange is shown to mimic a correlation effect due to the coupling between doubly-excited electronic configurations. This interaction consists of a spin-flip exchange process between electron pair states with antiparallel spin, which is not included in semilocal DFT. A corollary of our result is that a 3/4 fraction is the correct amount of density-based exchange, even for an ideally accurate exchange density functional; using a larger fraction would fail to take into account the spin-dependent nature of exchange as well as quantum superposition effects. The relation between our results and empirical trends observed in hybrid DFT calculations is discussed, along with other implications, including a possible explanation for why the local density approximation overbinds matter in spite of its variational nature.