Title:A Possible Solution to the $B\to ππ$ Puzzle Using the Principle of Maximum Conformality

Abstract:The measured $B_d \to \pi^0\pi^0$ branching fraction deviates significantly from conventional QCD predictions, a puzzle which has persisted for more than 10 years. This may be a hint of new physics beyond the Standard Model; however, as we shall show in this paper, the pQCD prediction is highly sensitive to the choice of the renormalization scales which enter the decay amplitude. It is conventional to choose a typical momentum transfer as the renormalization scale and take an arbitrary range to estimate the theory uncertainty. However, the prediction using this procedure depends on the renormalization scheme, leaves a non-convergent renormalon series, and gives an arbitrary estimate of the systematic error. In contrast, if one fixes the renormalization scale using the Principle of Maximum Conformality (PMC), all non-conformal $\{\beta_i\}$-terms in the perturbative expansion series are resummed into the running coupling, one then obtains a unique, scale-fixed, scheme-independent prediction at any finite order. The PMC is a generalization of the BLM procedure, and it reduces in the Abelian limit to the standard Gell Mann-Low procedure used for precision tests of QED. We show that the renormalization scale uncertainties for $B\to \pi\pi$ can be greatly reduced by applying PMC scale-setting. Combining the errors in quadrature, we obtain ${\cal B}(B_{d}\to \pi^0\pi^0)|_{\rm PMC} = (0.95^{+0.65}_{-0.51}) \times10^{-6}$ by using the "massive" analytic pQCD model for the running coupling. All of the $B \to \pi \pi $ branching fractions predicted by the PMC are consistent with the Particle Data Group average values.