Title:Non-existence of a limiting standing wave of extreme form on deep water

Abstract:Inspired by Stokes' work predicting that the traveling water wave of greatest height should feature wave crests with sharp 120 degree corners, Penney and Price conjectured in 1952 that there is a critical amplitude at which standing water waves become singular by developing sharp 90 degree crest angles each time the fluid comes to rest during its evolution. Numerous attempts to verify this conjecture have been inconclusive due to the difficulty of maintaining accuracy in nearly singular free surface calculations. By increasing the spatial resolution near the crest tip by a factor of more than 200 over previous numerical studies, we are able to show that this conjecture is incorrect. What was thought to be a single one-parameter family of standing waves turns out to contain several disjoint branches separated by imperfect bifurcations, and waves on each branch become oscillatory near the crest tip rather than sharp as the bifurcation parameter increases. Thus, we observe a rich structure of dynamic behavior at small length scales in a regime previously believed to be self-similar.