-
Fiducial Inference and Decision Theory
Authors:
G. Taraldsen,
B. H. Lindquist
Abstract:
The majority of the statisticians concluded many decades ago that fiducial inference was nonsensical to them. Hannig et al. (2016) and others have, however, contributed to a renewed interest and focus. Fiducial inference is similar to Bayesian analysis, but without requiring a prior. The prior information is replaced by assuming a particular data generating equation. Berger (1985) explains that Ba…
▽ More
The majority of the statisticians concluded many decades ago that fiducial inference was nonsensical to them. Hannig et al. (2016) and others have, however, contributed to a renewed interest and focus. Fiducial inference is similar to Bayesian analysis, but without requiring a prior. The prior information is replaced by assuming a particular data generating equation. Berger (1985) explains that Bayesian analysis and statistical decision theory are in harmony. Taraldsen and Lindqvist (2013) show that fiducial theory and statistical decision theory also play well together. The purpose of this text is to explain and exemplify this together with recent mathematical results.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Conditional Monte Carlo revisited
Authors:
Bo Henry Lindqvist,
Rasmus Erlemann,
Gunnar Taraldsen
Abstract:
Conditional Monte Carlo refers to sampling from the conditional distribution of a random vector X given the value T(X) = t for a function T(X). Classical conditional Monte Carlo methods were designed for estimating conditional expectations of functions of X by sampling from unconditional distributions obtained by certain weighting schemes. The basic ingredients were the use of importance sampling…
▽ More
Conditional Monte Carlo refers to sampling from the conditional distribution of a random vector X given the value T(X) = t for a function T(X). Classical conditional Monte Carlo methods were designed for estimating conditional expectations of functions of X by sampling from unconditional distributions obtained by certain weighting schemes. The basic ingredients were the use of importance sampling and change of variables. In the present paper we reformulate the problem by introducing an artificial parametric model, representing the conditional distribution of X given T(X)=t within this new model. The key is to provide the parameter of the artificial model by a distribution. The approach is illustrated by several examples, which are particularly chosen to illustrate conditional sampling in cases where such sampling is not straightforward. A simulation study and an application to goodness-of-fit testing of real data are also given.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Discussion of "Nonparametric generalized fiducial inference for survival functions under censoring"
Authors:
G. Taraldsen,
B. H. Lindqvist
Abstract:
The following discussion is inspired by the paper Nonparametric generalized fiducial inference for survival functions under censoring by Cui and Hannig. The discussion consists of comments on the results, but also indicates it's importance more generally in the context of fiducial inference. A two page introduction to fiducial inference is given to provide a context.
The following discussion is inspired by the paper Nonparametric generalized fiducial inference for survival functions under censoring by Cui and Hannig. The discussion consists of comments on the results, but also indicates it's importance more generally in the context of fiducial inference. A two page introduction to fiducial inference is given to provide a context.
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
On the proper treatment of improper distributions
Authors:
Bo H. Lindqvist,
Gunnar Taraldsen
Abstract:
The axiomatic foundation of probability theory presented by Kolmogorov has been the basis of modern theory for probability and statistics. In certain applications it is, however, necessary or convenient to allow improper (unbounded) distributions, which is often done without a theoretical foundation. The paper reviews a recent theory which includes improper distributions, and which is related to R…
▽ More
The axiomatic foundation of probability theory presented by Kolmogorov has been the basis of modern theory for probability and statistics. In certain applications it is, however, necessary or convenient to allow improper (unbounded) distributions, which is often done without a theoretical foundation. The paper reviews a recent theory which includes improper distributions, and which is related to Renyi's theory of conditional probability spaces. It is in particular demonstrated how the theory leads to simple explanations of apparent paradoxes known from the Bayesian literature. Several examples from statistical practice with improper distributions are discussed in light of the given theoretical results, which also include a recent theory of convergence of proper distributions to improper ones.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Fiducial on a string
Authors:
Gunnar Taraldsen,
Bo Henry Lindqvist
Abstract:
The fiducial argument of Fisher (1973) has been described as his biggest blunder, but the recent review of Hannig et al. (2016) demonstrates the current and increasing interest in this brilliant idea. This short note analyses an example introduced by Seidenfeld (1992) where the fiducial distribution is restricted to a string.
Keywords and phrases: Bayesian and fiducial inference, Restrictions on…
▽ More
The fiducial argument of Fisher (1973) has been described as his biggest blunder, but the recent review of Hannig et al. (2016) demonstrates the current and increasing interest in this brilliant idea. This short note analyses an example introduced by Seidenfeld (1992) where the fiducial distribution is restricted to a string.
Keywords and phrases: Bayesian and fiducial inference, Restrictions on parameters, Uncertainty quantification, Epistemic probability, Statistics on a manifold.
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.