-
"Predicting" after peeking into the future: Correcting a fundamental flaw in the SAOM -- TERGM comparison of Leifeld and Cranmer (2019)
Authors:
Per Block,
James Hollway,
Christoph Stadtfeld,
Johan Koskinen,
Tom Snijders
Abstract:
We review the empirical comparison of SAOMs and TERGMs by Leifeld and Cranmer (2019) in Network Science. We note that their model specification uses nodal covariates calculated from observed degrees instead of using structural effects, thus turning endogeneity into circularity. In consequence, their out-of-sample predictions using TERGMs are based on out-of-sample information and thereby predict t…
▽ More
We review the empirical comparison of SAOMs and TERGMs by Leifeld and Cranmer (2019) in Network Science. We note that their model specification uses nodal covariates calculated from observed degrees instead of using structural effects, thus turning endogeneity into circularity. In consequence, their out-of-sample predictions using TERGMs are based on out-of-sample information and thereby predict the future using observations from the future. We conclude that their analysis rest on erroneous model specifications that render the article's conclusions meaningless. Consequently, researchers should disregard recommendations from the criticized paper when making informed modelling choices.
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Social interaction networks and depressive symptoms
Authors:
Timon Elmer,
Christoph Stadtfeld
Abstract:
Face-to-face social interactions are an important aspect of peoples' social lives. A lack of interactions can explain how individuals develop depressive symptoms, but depressive symptoms can also explain how individuals engage in social interactions. Understanding in detail how depression affects individuals' social interaction networks is important to break this vicious cycle of social isolation…
▽ More
Face-to-face social interactions are an important aspect of peoples' social lives. A lack of interactions can explain how individuals develop depressive symptoms, but depressive symptoms can also explain how individuals engage in social interactions. Understanding in detail how depression affects individuals' social interaction networks is important to break this vicious cycle of social isolation and depression. This article tackles two central methodological challenges in understanding the micro-level mechanisms between depressive symptoms and social interactions. The first contribution is the application of novel data collection strategies that employ RFID sensors to record behavioral data on interpersonal interaction, which we combine with self-reported depressive symptoms and sociometric data on friendship relations. The second contribution is the analysis of these data with statistical social network methodology that allows testing hypotheses on the duration of interactions between pairs of individuals. With this unique approach, we test four social network hypotheses in an empirical setting of two first-year undergraduate student cohorts (N(pairs) = 2,454, N(individuals) = 123) spending a weekend together in a remote camp house. We conclude that depressive symptoms are associated with (1) spending less time in social interaction, (2) spending time with similarly depressed others, (3) spending time in pair-wise interactions rather than group interactions, and with (4) spending more time with reciprocal friends (but not with unilaterally perceived friends). Our findings offer new insights into social consequences of depressive symptoms and call for the development of social network-oriented intervention strategies to prevent depressed individuals from being socially isolated.
△ Less
Submitted 19 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
The co-evolution of emotional well-being with weak and strong friendship ties
Authors:
Timon Elmer,
Zsofia Boda,
Christoph Stadtfeld
Abstract:
Social ties are strongly related to well-being. But what characterizes this relationship? This study investigates social mechanisms explaining how social ties affect well-being through social integration and social influence, and how well-being affects social ties through social selection. We hypothesize that highly integrated individuals - those with more extensive and dense friendship networks -…
▽ More
Social ties are strongly related to well-being. But what characterizes this relationship? This study investigates social mechanisms explaining how social ties affect well-being through social integration and social influence, and how well-being affects social ties through social selection. We hypothesize that highly integrated individuals - those with more extensive and dense friendship networks - report higher emotional well-being than others. Moreover, emotional well-being should be influenced by the well-being of close friends. Finally, well-being should affect friendship selection when individuals prefer others with higher levels of well-being, and others whose well-being is similar to theirs. We test our hypotheses using longitudinal social network and well-being data of 117 individuals living in a graduate housing community. The application of a novel extension of Stochastic Actor-Oriented Models for ordered networks (ordered SAOMs) allows us to detail and test our hypotheses for weak- and strong-tied friendship networks simultaneously. Results do not support our social integration and social influence hypotheses but provide evidence for selection: individuals with higher emotional well-being tend to have more strong-tied friends, and there are homophily processes regarding emotional well-being in strong-tied networks. Our study highlights the two-directional relationship between social ties and well-being, and demonstrates the importance of considering different tie strengths for various social processes.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Statistical Power in Longitudinal Network Studies
Authors:
Christoph Stadtfeld,
Tom A. B. Snijders,
Christian Steglich,
Marijtje A. J. van Duijn
Abstract:
Longitudinal social network studies can easily suffer from insufficient statistical power. Studies that simultaneously investigate change of network ties and change of nodal attributes (selection and influence studies) are particularly at risk because the number of nodal observations is typically much lower than the number of observed tie variables. This paper presents a simulation-based procedure…
▽ More
Longitudinal social network studies can easily suffer from insufficient statistical power. Studies that simultaneously investigate change of network ties and change of nodal attributes (selection and influence studies) are particularly at risk because the number of nodal observations is typically much lower than the number of observed tie variables. This paper presents a simulation-based procedure to evaluate statistical power of longitudinal social network studies in which stochastic actor-oriented models (SAOMs) are to be applied. Two detailed case studies illustrate how statistical power is strongly affected by network size, number of data collection waves, effect sizes, missing data, and participant turnover. These issues should thus be explored in the design phase of longitudinal social network studies.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2018; v1 submitted 18 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.