-
A general approach to detect gene (G)-environment (E) additive interaction leveraging G-E independence in case-control studies
Authors:
Eric J. Tchetgen Tchetgen,
Xu Shi,
Tamar Sofer,
Benedict H. W. Wong
Abstract:
It is increasingly of interest in statistical genetics to test for the presence of a mechanistic interaction between genetic (G) and environmental (E) risk factors by testing for the presence of an additive GxE interaction. In case-control studies involving a rare disease, a statistical test of no additive interaction typically entails a test of no relative excess risk due to interaction (RERI). I…
▽ More
It is increasingly of interest in statistical genetics to test for the presence of a mechanistic interaction between genetic (G) and environmental (E) risk factors by testing for the presence of an additive GxE interaction. In case-control studies involving a rare disease, a statistical test of no additive interaction typically entails a test of no relative excess risk due to interaction (RERI). It is also well known that a test of multiplicative interaction exploiting G-E independence can be dramatically more powerful than standard logistic regression for case-control data. Likewise, it has recently been shown that a likelihood ratio test of a null RERI incorporating the G-E independence assumption (RERI-LRT) outperforms the standard RERI approach. In this paper, the authors describe a general, yet relatively straightforward approach to test for GxE additive interaction exploiting G-E independence. The approach which relies on regression models for G and E is particularly attractive because, unlike the RERI-LRT, it allows the regression model for the binary outcome to remain unrestricted. Therefore, the new methodology is completely robust to possible mis-specification in the outcome regression. This is particularly important for settings not easily handled by RERI-LRT, such as when E is a count or a continuous exposure with multiple components, or when there are several auxiliary covariates in the regression model. While the proposed approach avoids fitting an outcome regression, it nonetheless still allows for straightforward covariate adjustment. The methods are illustrated through an extensive simulation study and an ovarian cancer empirical application.
△ Less
Submitted 17 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
Testing for replicability in a follow-up study when the primary study hypotheses are two-sided
Authors:
Ruth Heller,
Marina Bogomolov,
Yoav Benjamini,
Tamar Sofer
Abstract:
When testing for replication of results from a primary study with two-sided hypotheses in a follow-up study, we are usually interested in discovering the features with discoveries in the same direction in the two studies. The direction of testing in the follow-up study for each feature can therefore be decided by the primary study. We prove that in this case the methods suggested in Heller, Bogomo…
▽ More
When testing for replication of results from a primary study with two-sided hypotheses in a follow-up study, we are usually interested in discovering the features with discoveries in the same direction in the two studies. The direction of testing in the follow-up study for each feature can therefore be decided by the primary study. We prove that in this case the methods suggested in Heller, Bogomolov, and Benjamini (2014) for control over false replicability claims are valid. Specifically, we prove that if we input into the procedures in Heller, Bogomolov, and Benjamini (2014) the one-sided p-values in the directions favoured by the primary study, then we achieve directional control over the desired error measure (family-wise error rate or false discovery rate).
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Control Function Assisted IPW Estimation with a Secondary Outcome in Case-Control Studies
Authors:
Tamar Sofer,
Marilyn C. Cornelis,
Peter Kraft,
Eric J. Tchetgen Tchetgen
Abstract:
Case-control studies are designed towards studying associations between risk factors and a single, primary outcome. Information about additional, secondary outcomes is also collected, but association studies targeting such secondary outcomes should account for the case-control sampling scheme, or otherwise results may be biased. Often, one uses inverse probability weighted (IPW) estimators to esti…
▽ More
Case-control studies are designed towards studying associations between risk factors and a single, primary outcome. Information about additional, secondary outcomes is also collected, but association studies targeting such secondary outcomes should account for the case-control sampling scheme, or otherwise results may be biased. Often, one uses inverse probability weighted (IPW) estimators to estimate population effects in such studies. However, these estimators are inefficient relative to estimators that make additional assumptions about the data generating mechanism. We propose a class of estimators for the effect of risk factors on a secondary outcome in case-control studies, when the mean is modeled using either the identity or the log link. The proposed estimator combines IPW with a mean zero control function that depends explicitly on a model for the primary disease outcome. The efficient estimator in our class of estimators reduces to standard IPW when the model for the primary disease outcome is unrestricted, and is more efficient than standard IPW when the model is either parametric or semiparametric.
△ Less
Submitted 16 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
