Showing 1–22 of 22 results for author: Smith, M S

Tractable Unified Skew-t Distribution and Copula for Heterogeneous Asymmetries

Authors: Lin Deng, Michael Stanley Smith, Worapree Maneesoonthorn

Abstract: Multivariate distributions that allow for asymmetry and heavy tails are important building blocks in many econometric and statistical models. The Unified Skew-t (UST) is a promising choice because it is both scalable and allows for a high level of flexibility in the asymmetry in the distribution. However, it suffers from parameter identification and computational hurdles that have to date inhibite… ▽ More Multivariate distributions that allow for asymmetry and heavy tails are important building blocks in many econometric and statistical models. The Unified Skew-t (UST) is a promising choice because it is both scalable and allows for a high level of flexibility in the asymmetry in the distribution. However, it suffers from parameter identification and computational hurdles that have to date inhibited its use for modeling data. In this paper we propose a new tractable variant of the unified skew-t (TrUST) distribution that addresses both challenges. Moreover, the copula of this distribution is shown to also be tractable, while allowing for greater heterogeneity in asymmetric dependence over variable pairs than the popular skew-t copula. We show how Bayesian posterior inference for both the distribution and its copula can be computed using an extended likelihood derived from a generative representation of the distribution. The efficacy of this Bayesian method, and the enhanced flexibility of both the TrUST distribution and its implicit copula, is first demonstrated using simulated data. Applications of the TrUST distribution to highly skewed regional Australian electricity prices, and the TrUST copula to intraday U.S. equity returns, demonstrate how our proposed distribution and its copula can provide substantial increases in accuracy over the popular skew-t and its copula in practice. △ Less

Submitted 16 May, 2025; originally announced May 2025.

Vector Copula Variational Inference and Dependent Block Posterior Approximations

Authors: Yu Fu, Michael Stanley Smith, Anastasios Panagiotelis

Abstract: Variational inference (VI) is a popular method to estimate statistical and econometric models. The key to VI is the selection of a tractable density to approximate the Bayesian posterior. For large and complex models a common choice is to assume independence between multivariate blocks in a partition of the parameter space. While this simplifies the problem it can reduce accuracy. This paper propo… ▽ More Variational inference (VI) is a popular method to estimate statistical and econometric models. The key to VI is the selection of a tractable density to approximate the Bayesian posterior. For large and complex models a common choice is to assume independence between multivariate blocks in a partition of the parameter space. While this simplifies the problem it can reduce accuracy. This paper proposes using vector copulas to capture dependence between the blocks parsimoniously. Tailored multivariate marginals are constructed using learnable cyclically monotone transformations. We call the resulting joint distribution a ``dependent block posterior'' approximation. Vector copula models are suggested that make tractable and flexible variational approximations. They allow for differing marginals, numbers of blocks, block sizes and forms of between block dependence. They also allow for solution of the variational optimization using fast and efficient stochastic gradient methods. The efficacy and versatility of the approach is demonstrated using four different statistical models and 16 datasets which have posteriors that are challenging to approximate. In all cases, our method produces more accurate posterior approximations than benchmark VI methods that either assume block independence or factor-based dependence, at limited additional computational cost. △ Less

Submitted 2 March, 2025; originally announced March 2025.

Regression Copulas for Multivariate Responses

Authors: Nadja Klein, Michael Stanley Smith, David Nott, Ryan Chisholm

Abstract: We propose a novel distributional regression model for a multivariate response vector based on a copula process over the covariate space. It uses the implicit copula of a Gaussian multivariate regression, which we call a ``regression copula''. To allow for large covariate vectors their coefficients are regularized using a novel multivariate extension of the horseshoe prior. Bayesian inference and… ▽ More We propose a novel distributional regression model for a multivariate response vector based on a copula process over the covariate space. It uses the implicit copula of a Gaussian multivariate regression, which we call a ``regression copula''. To allow for large covariate vectors their coefficients are regularized using a novel multivariate extension of the horseshoe prior. Bayesian inference and distributional predictions are evaluated using efficient variational inference methods, allowing application to large datasets. An advantage of the approach is that the marginal distributions of the response vector can be estimated separately and accurately, resulting in predictive distributions that are marginally-calibrated. Two substantive applications of the methodology highlight its efficacy in multivariate modeling. The first is the econometric modeling and prediction of half-hourly regional Australian electricity prices. Here, our approach produces more accurate distributional forecasts than leading benchmark methods. The second is the evaluation of multivariate posteriors in likelihood-free inference (LFI) of a model for tree species abundance data, extending a previous univariate regression copula LFI method. In both applications, we demonstrate that our new approach exhibits a desirable marginal calibration property. △ Less

Submitted 5 March, 2024; v1 submitted 22 January, 2024; originally announced January 2024.

Cutting Feedback in Misspecified Copula Models

Authors: Michael Stanley Smith, Weichang Yu, David J. Nott, David Frazier

Abstract: In copula models the marginal distributions and copula function are specified separately. We treat these as two modules in a modular Bayesian inference framework, and propose conducting modified Bayesian inference by "cutting feedback". Cutting feedback limits the influence of potentially misspecified modules in posterior inference. We consider two types of cuts. The first limits the influence of… ▽ More In copula models the marginal distributions and copula function are specified separately. We treat these as two modules in a modular Bayesian inference framework, and propose conducting modified Bayesian inference by "cutting feedback". Cutting feedback limits the influence of potentially misspecified modules in posterior inference. We consider two types of cuts. The first limits the influence of a misspecified copula on inference for the marginals, which is a Bayesian analogue of the popular Inference for Margins (IFM) estimator. The second limits the influence of misspecified marginals on inference for the copula parameters by using a pseudo likelihood of the ranks to define the cut model. We establish that if only one of the modules is misspecified, then the appropriate cut posterior gives accurate uncertainty quantification asymptotically for the parameters in the other module. Computation of the cut posteriors is difficult, and new variational inference methods to do so are proposed. The efficacy of the new methodology is demonstrated using both simulated data and a substantive multivariate time series application from macroeconomic forecasting. In the latter, cutting feedback from misspecified marginals to a 1096 dimension copula improves posterior inference and predictive accuracy greatly, compared to conventional Bayesian inference. △ Less

Submitted 27 June, 2024; v1 submitted 5 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Large Skew-t Copula Models and Asymmetric Dependence in Intraday Equity Returns

Authors: Lin Deng, Michael Stanley Smith, Worapree Maneesoonthorn

Abstract: Skew-t copula models are attractive for the modeling of financial data because they allow for asymmetric and extreme tail dependence. We show that the copula implicit in the skew-t distribution of Azzalini and Capitanio (2003) allows for a higher level of pairwise asymmetric dependence than two popular alternative skew-t copulas. Estimation of this copula in high dimensions is challenging, and we… ▽ More Skew-t copula models are attractive for the modeling of financial data because they allow for asymmetric and extreme tail dependence. We show that the copula implicit in the skew-t distribution of Azzalini and Capitanio (2003) allows for a higher level of pairwise asymmetric dependence than two popular alternative skew-t copulas. Estimation of this copula in high dimensions is challenging, and we propose a fast and accurate Bayesian variational inference (VI) approach to do so. The method uses a generative representation of the skew-t distribution to define an augmented posterior that can be approximated accurately. A stochastic gradient ascent algorithm is used to solve the variational optimization. The methodology is used to estimate skew-t factor copula models with up to 15 factors for intraday returns from 2017 to 2021 on 93 U.S. equities. The copula captures substantial heterogeneity in asymmetric dependence over equity pairs, in addition to the variability in pairwise correlations. In a moving window study we show that the asymmetric dependencies also vary over time, and that intraday predictive densities from the skew-t copula are more accurate than those from benchmark copula models. Portfolio selection strategies based on the estimated pairwise asymmetric dependencies improve performance relative to the index. △ Less

Submitted 2 July, 2024; v1 submitted 10 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

Natural Gradient Hybrid Variational Inference with Application to Deep Mixed Models

Authors: Weiben Zhang, Michael Stanley Smith, Worapree Maneesoonthorn, Ruben Loaiza-Maya

Abstract: Stochastic models with global parameters and latent variables are common, and for which variational inference (VI) is popular. However, existing methods are often either slow or inaccurate in high dimensions. We suggest a fast and accurate VI method for this case that employs a well-defined natural gradient variational optimization that targets the joint posterior of the global parameters and late… ▽ More Stochastic models with global parameters and latent variables are common, and for which variational inference (VI) is popular. However, existing methods are often either slow or inaccurate in high dimensions. We suggest a fast and accurate VI method for this case that employs a well-defined natural gradient variational optimization that targets the joint posterior of the global parameters and latent variables. It is a hybrid method, where at each step the global parameters are updated using the natural gradient and the latent variables are generated from their conditional posterior. A fast to compute expression for the Tikhonov damped Fisher information matrix is used, along with the re-parameterization trick, to provide a stable natural gradient. We apply the approach to deep mixed models, which are an emerging class of Bayesian neural networks with random output layer coefficients to allow for heterogeneity. A range of simulations show that using the natural gradient is substantially more efficient than using the ordinary gradient, and that the approach is faster and more accurate than two cutting-edge natural gradient VI methods. In a financial application we show that accounting for industry level heterogeneity using the deep mixed model improves the accuracy of asset pricing models. MATLAB code to implement the method can be found at: https://github.com/WeibenZhang07/NG-HVI. △ Less

Submitted 24 July, 2024; v1 submitted 27 February, 2023; originally announced February 2023.

Implicit copula variational inference

Authors: Michael Stanley Smith, Rubén Loaiza-Maya

Abstract: Key to effective generic, or "black-box", variational inference is the selection of an approximation to the target density that balances accuracy and speed. Copula models are promising options, but calibration of the approximation can be slow for some choices. Smith et al. (2020) suggest using tractable and scalable "implicit copula" models that are formed by element-wise transformation of the tar… ▽ More Key to effective generic, or "black-box", variational inference is the selection of an approximation to the target density that balances accuracy and speed. Copula models are promising options, but calibration of the approximation can be slow for some choices. Smith et al. (2020) suggest using tractable and scalable "implicit copula" models that are formed by element-wise transformation of the target parameters. We propose an adjustment to these transformations that make the approximation invariant to the scale and location of the target density. We also show how a sub-class of elliptical copulas have a generative representation that allows easy application of the re-parameterization trick and efficient first order optimization. We demonstrate the estimation methodology using two statistical models as examples. The first is a mixed effects logistic regression, and the second is a regularized correlation matrix. For the latter, standard Markov chain Monte Carlo estimation methods can be slow or difficult to implement, yet our proposed variational approach provides an effective and scalable estimator. We illustrate by estimating a regularized Gaussian copula model for income inequality in U.S. states between 1917 and 2018. An Online Appendix and MATLAB code to implement the method are available as Supplementary Materials. △ Less

Submitted 29 June, 2022; v1 submitted 17 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Comments: Abstract has been updated. The abstract of v2 is not up-to-date

Implicit Copulas: An Overview

Authors: Michael Stanley Smith

Abstract: Implicit copulas are the most common copula choice for modeling dependence in high dimensions. This broad class of copulas is introduced and surveyed, including elliptical copulas, skew $t$ copulas, factor copulas, time series copulas and regression copulas. The common auxiliary representation of implicit copulas is outlined, and how this makes them both scalable and tractable for statistical mode… ▽ More Implicit copulas are the most common copula choice for modeling dependence in high dimensions. This broad class of copulas is introduced and surveyed, including elliptical copulas, skew $t$ copulas, factor copulas, time series copulas and regression copulas. The common auxiliary representation of implicit copulas is outlined, and how this makes them both scalable and tractable for statistical modeling. Issues such as parameter identification, extended likelihoods for discrete or mixed data, parsimony in high dimensions, and simulation from the copula model are considered. Bayesian approaches to estimate the copula parameters, and predict from an implicit copula model, are outlined. Particular attention is given to implicit copula processes constructed from time series and regression models, which is at the forefront of current research. Two econometric applications -- one from macroeconomic time series and the other from financial asset pricing -- illustrate the advantages of implicit copula models. △ Less

Submitted 10 September, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

Variational inference for cutting feedback in misspecified models

Authors: Xuejun Yu, David J. Nott, Michael Stanley Smith

Abstract: Bayesian analyses combine information represented by different terms in a joint Bayesian model. When one or more of the terms is misspecified, it can be helpful to restrict the use of information from suspect model components to modify posterior inference. This is called "cutting feedback", and both the specification and computation of the posterior for such "cut models" is challenging. In this pa… ▽ More Bayesian analyses combine information represented by different terms in a joint Bayesian model. When one or more of the terms is misspecified, it can be helpful to restrict the use of information from suspect model components to modify posterior inference. This is called "cutting feedback", and both the specification and computation of the posterior for such "cut models" is challenging. In this paper, we define cut posterior distributions as solutions to constrained optimization problems, and propose optimization-based variational methods for their computation. These methods are faster than existing Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) approaches for computing cut posterior distributions by an order of magnitude. It is also shown that variational methods allow for the evaluation of computationally intensive conflict checks that can be used to decide whether or not feedback should be cut. Our methods are illustrated in a number of simulated and real examples, including an application where recent methodological advances that combine variational inference and MCMC within the variational optimization are used. △ Less

Submitted 24 June, 2022; v1 submitted 25 August, 2021; originally announced August 2021.

Deep Distributional Time Series Models and the Probabilistic Forecasting of Intraday Electricity Prices

Authors: Nadja Klein, Michael Stanley Smith, David J. Nott

Abstract: Recurrent neural networks (RNNs) with rich feature vectors of past values can provide accurate point forecasts for series that exhibit complex serial dependence. We propose two approaches to constructing deep time series probabilistic models based on a variant of RNN called an echo state network (ESN). The first is where the output layer of the ESN has stochastic disturbances and a shrinkage prior… ▽ More Recurrent neural networks (RNNs) with rich feature vectors of past values can provide accurate point forecasts for series that exhibit complex serial dependence. We propose two approaches to constructing deep time series probabilistic models based on a variant of RNN called an echo state network (ESN). The first is where the output layer of the ESN has stochastic disturbances and a shrinkage prior for additional regularization. The second approach employs the implicit copula of an ESN with Gaussian disturbances, which is a deep copula process on the feature space. Combining this copula with a non-parametrically estimated marginal distribution produces a deep distributional time series model. The resulting probabilistic forecasts are deep functions of the feature vector and also marginally calibrated. In both approaches, Bayesian Markov chain Monte Carlo methods are used to estimate the models and compute forecasts. The proposed models are suitable for the complex task of forecasting intraday electricity prices. Using data from the Australian National Electricity Market, we show that our deep time series models provide accurate short term probabilistic price forecasts, with the copula model dominating. Moreover, the models provide a flexible framework for incorporating probabilistic forecasts of electricity demand as additional features, which increases upper tail forecast accuracy from the copula model significantly. △ Less

Submitted 27 May, 2021; v1 submitted 5 October, 2020; originally announced October 2020.

Journal ref: Journal of Applied Econometrics (2023), 38( 4), 493-511

Fast and Accurate Variational Inference for Models with Many Latent Variables

Authors: Rubén Loaiza-Maya, Michael Stanley Smith, David J. Nott, Peter J. Danaher

Abstract: Models with a large number of latent variables are often used to fully utilize the information in big or complex data. However, they can be difficult to estimate using standard approaches, and variational inference methods are a popular alternative. Key to the success of these is the selection of an approximation to the target density that is accurate, tractable and fast to calibrate using optimiz… ▽ More Models with a large number of latent variables are often used to fully utilize the information in big or complex data. However, they can be difficult to estimate using standard approaches, and variational inference methods are a popular alternative. Key to the success of these is the selection of an approximation to the target density that is accurate, tractable and fast to calibrate using optimization methods. Most existing choices can be inaccurate or slow to calibrate when there are many latent variables. Here, we propose a family of tractable variational approximations that are more accurate and faster to calibrate for this case. It combines a parsimonious parametric approximation for the parameter posterior, with the exact conditional posterior of the latent variables. We derive a simplified expression for the re-parameterization gradient of the variational lower bound, which is the main ingredient of efficient optimization algorithms used to implement variational estimation. To do so only requires the ability to generate exactly or approximately from the conditional posterior of the latent variables, rather than to compute its density. We illustrate using two complex contemporary econometric examples. The first is a nonlinear multivariate state space model for U.S. macroeconomic variables. The second is a random coefficients tobit model applied to two million sales by 20,000 individuals in a large consumer panel from a marketing study. In both cases, we show that our approximating family is considerably more accurate than mean field or structured Gaussian approximations, and faster than Markov chain Monte Carlo. Last, we show how to implement data sub-sampling in variational inference for our approximation, which can lead to a further reduction in computation time. MATLAB code implementing the method for our examples is included in supplementary material. △ Less

Submitted 18 April, 2021; v1 submitted 15 May, 2020; originally announced May 2020.

Comments: Macroeconomic example was replaced by the bigger and more challenging time varying parameter vector autoregression model with stochastic volatility. Microeconomic example was extended to 20,000 individuals and variational subsampling is also implemented for this example. Small microeconomics example now uses 1000 individuals

MSC Class: 62P20 ACM Class: G.3

Marginally-calibrated deep distributional regression

Authors: Nadja Klein, David J. Nott, Michael Stanley Smith

Abstract: Deep neural network (DNN) regression models are widely used in applications requiring state-of-the-art predictive accuracy. However, until recently there has been little work on accurate uncertainty quantification for predictions from such models. We add to this literature by outlining an approach to constructing predictive distributions that are `marginally calibrated'. This is where the long run… ▽ More Deep neural network (DNN) regression models are widely used in applications requiring state-of-the-art predictive accuracy. However, until recently there has been little work on accurate uncertainty quantification for predictions from such models. We add to this literature by outlining an approach to constructing predictive distributions that are `marginally calibrated'. This is where the long run average of the predictive distributions of the response variable matches the observed empirical margin. Our approach considers a DNN regression with a conditionally Gaussian prior for the final layer weights, from which an implicit copula process on the feature space is extracted. This copula process is combined with a non-parametrically estimated marginal distribution for the response. The end result is a scalable distributional DNN regression method with marginally calibrated predictions, and our work complements existing methods for probability calibration. The approach is first illustrated using two applications of dense layer feed-forward neural networks. However, our main motivating applications are in likelihood-free inference, where distributional deep regression is used to estimate marginal posterior distributions. In two complex ecological time series examples we employ the implicit copulas of convolutional networks, and show that marginal calibration results in improved uncertainty quantification. Our approach also avoids the need for manual specification of summary statistics, a requirement that is burdensome for users and typical of competing likelihood-free inference methods. △ Less

Submitted 3 September, 2020; v1 submitted 26 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Journal ref: Journal of Computational and Graphical Statistics (2020)

Bayesian Variable Selection for Non-Gaussian Responses: A Marginally Calibrated Copula Approach

Authors: Nadja Klein, Michael Stanley Smith

Abstract: We propose a new highly flexible and tractable Bayesian approach to undertake variable selection in non-Gaussian regression models. It uses a copula decomposition for the joint distribution of observations on the dependent variable. This allows the marginal distribution of the dependent variable to be calibrated accurately using a nonparametric or other estimator. The family of copulas employed ar… ▽ More We propose a new highly flexible and tractable Bayesian approach to undertake variable selection in non-Gaussian regression models. It uses a copula decomposition for the joint distribution of observations on the dependent variable. This allows the marginal distribution of the dependent variable to be calibrated accurately using a nonparametric or other estimator. The family of copulas employed are `implicit copulas' that are constructed from existing hierarchical Bayesian models widely used for variable selection, and we establish some of their properties. Even though the copulas are high-dimensional, they can be estimated efficiently and quickly using Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC). A simulation study shows that when the responses are non-Gaussian the approach selects variables more accurately than contemporary benchmarks. A real data example in the Web Appendix illustrates that accounting for even mild deviations from normality can lead to a substantial increase in accuracy. To illustrate the full potential of our approach we extend it to spatial variable selection for fMRI. Using real data, we show our method allows for voxel-specific marginal calibration of the magnetic resonance signal at over 6,000 voxels, leading to an increase in the quality of the activation maps. △ Less

Submitted 3 September, 2020; v1 submitted 10 July, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

Journal ref: Biometrics (2020)

Bayesian Inference for Regression Copulas

Authors: Michael Stanley Smith, Nadja Klein

Abstract: We propose a new semi-parametric distributional regression smoother that is based on a copula decomposition of the joint distribution of the vector of response values. The copula is high-dimensional and constructed by inversion of a pseudo regression, where the conditional mean and variance are semi-parametric functions of covariates modeled using regularized basis functions. By integrating out th… ▽ More We propose a new semi-parametric distributional regression smoother that is based on a copula decomposition of the joint distribution of the vector of response values. The copula is high-dimensional and constructed by inversion of a pseudo regression, where the conditional mean and variance are semi-parametric functions of covariates modeled using regularized basis functions. By integrating out the basis coefficients, an implicit copula process on the covariate space is obtained, which we call a `regression copula'. We combine this with a non-parametric margin to define a copula model, where the entire distribution - including the mean and variance - of the response is a smooth semi-parametric function of the covariates. The copula is estimated using both Hamiltonian Monte Carlo and variational Bayes; the latter of which is scalable to high dimensions. Using real data examples and a simulation study we illustrate the efficacy of these estimators and the copula model. In a substantive example, we estimate the distribution of half-hourly electricity spot prices as a function of demand and two time covariates using radial bases and horseshoe regularization. The copula model produces distributional estimates that are locally adaptive with respect to the covariates, and predictions that are more accurate than those from benchmark models. △ Less

Submitted 24 January, 2020; v1 submitted 10 July, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

Comments: Journal of Business & Economic Statistics (2020)

High-dimensional copula variational approximation through transformation

Authors: Michael Stanley Smith, Ruben Loaiza-Maya, David J. Nott

Abstract: Variational methods are attractive for computing Bayesian inference for highly parametrized models and large datasets where exact inference is impractical. They approximate a target distribution - either the posterior or an augmented posterior - using a simpler distribution that is selected to balance accuracy with computational feasibility. Here we approximate an element-wise parametric transform… ▽ More Variational methods are attractive for computing Bayesian inference for highly parametrized models and large datasets where exact inference is impractical. They approximate a target distribution - either the posterior or an augmented posterior - using a simpler distribution that is selected to balance accuracy with computational feasibility. Here we approximate an element-wise parametric transformation of the target distribution as multivariate Gaussian or skew-normal. Approximations of this kind are implicit copula models for the original parameters, with a Gaussian or skew-normal copula function and flexible parametric margins. A key observation is that their adoption can improve the accuracy of variational inference in high dimensions at limited or no additional computational cost. We consider the Yeo-Johnson and G&H transformations, along with sparse factor structures for the scale matrix of the Gaussian or skew-normal. We also show how to implement efficient reparametrization gradient methods for these copula-based approximations. The efficacy of the approach is illustrated by computing posterior inference for three different models using six real datasets. In each case, we show that our proposed copula model distributions are more accurate variational approximations than Gaussian or skew-normal distributions, but at only a minor or no increase in computational cost. △ Less

Submitted 20 November, 2019; v1 submitted 16 April, 2019; originally announced April 2019.

Implicit Copulas from Bayesian Regularized Regression Smoothers

Authors: Nadja Klein, Michael Stanley Smith

Abstract: We show how to extract the implicit copula of a response vector from a Bayesian regularized regression smoother with Gaussian disturbances. The copula can be used to compare smoothers that employ different shrinkage priors and function bases. We illustrate with three popular choices of shrinkage priors --- a pairwise prior, the horseshoe prior and a g prior augmented with a point mass as employed… ▽ More We show how to extract the implicit copula of a response vector from a Bayesian regularized regression smoother with Gaussian disturbances. The copula can be used to compare smoothers that employ different shrinkage priors and function bases. We illustrate with three popular choices of shrinkage priors --- a pairwise prior, the horseshoe prior and a g prior augmented with a point mass as employed for Bayesian variable selection --- and both univariate and multivariate function bases. The implicit copulas are high-dimensional, have flexible dependence structures that are far from that of a Gaussian copula, and are unavailable in closed form. However, we show how they can be evaluated by first constructing a Gaussian copula conditional on the regularization parameters, and then integrating over these. Combined with non-parametric margins the regularized smoothers can be used to model the distribution of non-Gaussian univariate responses conditional on the covariates. Efficient Markov chain Monte Carlo schemes for evaluating the copula are given for this case. Using both simulated and real data, we show how such copula smoothing models can improve the quality of resulting function estimates and predictive distributions. △ Less

Submitted 14 May, 2018; v1 submitted 27 April, 2018; originally announced April 2018.

Journal ref: Bayesian Anal. 14 (2019), no. 4, 1143--1171

Econometric Modeling of Regional Electricity Spot Prices in the Australian Market

Authors: Michael Stanley Smith, Thomas S. Shively

Abstract: Wholesale electricity markets are increasingly integrated via high voltage interconnectors, and inter-regional trade in electricity is growing. To model this, we consider a spatial equilibrium model of price formation, where constraints on inter-regional flows result in three distinct equilibria in prices. We use this to motivate an econometric model for the distribution of observed electricity sp… ▽ More Wholesale electricity markets are increasingly integrated via high voltage interconnectors, and inter-regional trade in electricity is growing. To model this, we consider a spatial equilibrium model of price formation, where constraints on inter-regional flows result in three distinct equilibria in prices. We use this to motivate an econometric model for the distribution of observed electricity spot prices that captures many of their unique empirical characteristics. The econometric model features supply and inter-regional trade cost functions, which are estimated using Bayesian monotonic regression smoothing methodology. A copula multivariate time series model is employed to capture additional dependence -- both cross-sectional and serial-- in regional prices. The marginal distributions are nonparametric, with means given by the regression means. The model has the advantage of preserving the heavy right-hand tail in the predictive densities of price. We fit the model to half-hourly spot price data in the five interconnected regions of the Australian national electricity market. The fitted model is then used to measure how both supply and price shocks in one region are transmitted to the distribution of prices in all regions in subsequent periods. Finally, to validate our econometric model, we show that prices forecast using the proposed model compare favorably with those from some benchmark alternatives. △ Less

Submitted 22 April, 2018; originally announced April 2018.

Comments: Key Words: Bayesian Monotonic Function Estimation, Intraday Electricity Prices, Copula Time Series Model. JEL: C11, C14, C32, C53

Variational Bayes Estimation of Discrete-Margined Copula Models with Application to Time Series

Authors: Ruben Loaiza-Maya, Michael Stanley Smith

Abstract: We propose a new variational Bayes estimator for high-dimensional copulas with discrete, or a combination of discrete and continuous, margins. The method is based on a variational approximation to a tractable augmented posterior, and is faster than previous likelihood-based approaches. We use it to estimate drawable vine copulas for univariate and multivariate Markov ordinal and mixed time series.… ▽ More We propose a new variational Bayes estimator for high-dimensional copulas with discrete, or a combination of discrete and continuous, margins. The method is based on a variational approximation to a tractable augmented posterior, and is faster than previous likelihood-based approaches. We use it to estimate drawable vine copulas for univariate and multivariate Markov ordinal and mixed time series. These have dimension $rT$, where $T$ is the number of observations and $r$ is the number of series, and are difficult to estimate using previous methods. The vine pair-copulas are carefully selected to allow for heteroskedasticity, which is a feature of most ordinal time series data. When combined with flexible margins, the resulting time series models also allow for other common features of ordinal data, such as zero inflation, multiple modes and under- or over-dispersion. Using six example series, we illustrate both the flexibility of the time series copula models, and the efficacy of the variational Bayes estimator for copulas of up to 792 dimensions and 60 parameters. This far exceeds the size and complexity of copula models for discrete data that can be estimated using previous methods. △ Less

Submitted 20 July, 2018; v1 submitted 25 December, 2017; originally announced December 2017.

Time Series Copulas for Heteroskedastic Data

Authors: Rubén Loaiza-Maya, Michael S. Smith, Worapree Maneesoonthorn

Abstract: We propose parametric copulas that capture serial dependence in stationary heteroskedastic time series. We develop our copula for first order Markov series, and extend it to higher orders and multivariate series. We derive the copula of a volatility proxy, based on which we propose new measures of volatility dependence, including co-movement and spillover in multivariate series. In general, these… ▽ More We propose parametric copulas that capture serial dependence in stationary heteroskedastic time series. We develop our copula for first order Markov series, and extend it to higher orders and multivariate series. We derive the copula of a volatility proxy, based on which we propose new measures of volatility dependence, including co-movement and spillover in multivariate series. In general, these depend upon the marginal distributions of the series. Using exchange rate returns, we show that the resulting copula models can capture their marginal distributions more accurately than univariate and multivariate GARCH models, and produce more accurate value at risk forecasts. △ Less

Submitted 24 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Gaussian variational approximation with a factor covariance structure

Authors: Victor M. -H. Ong, David J. Nott, Michael S. Smith

Abstract: Variational approximation methods have proven to be useful for scaling Bayesian computations to large data sets and highly parametrized models. Applying variational methods involves solving an optimization problem, and recent research in this area has focused on stochastic gradient ascent methods as a general approach to implementation. Here variational approximation is considered for a posterior… ▽ More Variational approximation methods have proven to be useful for scaling Bayesian computations to large data sets and highly parametrized models. Applying variational methods involves solving an optimization problem, and recent research in this area has focused on stochastic gradient ascent methods as a general approach to implementation. Here variational approximation is considered for a posterior distribution in high dimensions using a Gaussian approximating family. Gaussian variational approximation with an unrestricted covariance matrix can be computationally burdensome in many problems because the number of elements in the covariance matrix increases quadratically with the dimension of the model parameter. To circumvent this problem, low-dimensional factor covariance structures are considered. General stochastic gradient approaches to efficiently perform the optimization are described, with gradient estimates obtained using the so-called "reparametrization trick". The end result is a flexible and efficient approach to high-dimensional Gaussian variational approximation, which we illustrate using eight real datasets. △ Less

Submitted 11 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Inversion Copulas from Nonlinear State Space Models

Authors: Michael Stanley Smith, Worapree Maneesoonthorn

Abstract: We propose to construct copulas from the inversion of nonlinear state space models. These allow for new time series models that have the same serial dependence structure of a state space model, but with an arbitrary marginal distribution, and flexible density forecasts. We examine the time series properties of the copulas, outline serial dependence measures, and estimate the models using likelihoo… ▽ More We propose to construct copulas from the inversion of nonlinear state space models. These allow for new time series models that have the same serial dependence structure of a state space model, but with an arbitrary marginal distribution, and flexible density forecasts. We examine the time series properties of the copulas, outline serial dependence measures, and estimate the models using likelihood-based methods. Copulas constructed from three example state space models are considered: a stochastic volatility model with an unobserved component, a Markov switching autoregression, and a Gaussian linear unobserved component model. We show that all three inversion copulas with flexible margins improve the fit and density forecasts of quarterly U.S. broad inflation and electricity inflation. △ Less

Submitted 21 October, 2017; v1 submitted 15 June, 2016; originally announced June 2016.

Bayesian Approaches to Copula Modelling

Authors: Michael Stanley Smith

Abstract: Copula models have become one of the most widely used tools in the applied modelling of multivariate data. Similarly, Bayesian methods are increasingly used to obtain efficient likelihood-based inference. However, to date, there has been only limited use of Bayesian approaches in the formulation and estimation of copula models. This article aims to address this shortcoming in two ways. First, to i… ▽ More Copula models have become one of the most widely used tools in the applied modelling of multivariate data. Similarly, Bayesian methods are increasingly used to obtain efficient likelihood-based inference. However, to date, there has been only limited use of Bayesian approaches in the formulation and estimation of copula models. This article aims to address this shortcoming in two ways. First, to introduce copula models and aspects of copula theory that are especially relevant for a Bayesian analysis. Second, to outline Bayesian approaches to formulating and estimating copula models, and their advantages over alternative methods. Copulas covered include Archimedean, copulas constructed by inversion, and vine copulas; along with their interpretation as transformations. A number of parameterisations of a correlation matrix of a Gaussian copula are considered, along with hierarchical priors that allow for Bayesian selection and model averaging for each parameterisation. Markov chain Monte Carlo sampling schemes for fitting Gaussian and D-vine copulas, with and without selection, are given in detail. The relationship between the prior for the parameters of a D-vine, and the prior for a correlation matrix of a Gaussian copula, is discussed. Last, it is shown how to compute Bayesian inference when the data are discrete-valued using data augmentation. This approach generalises popular Bayesian methods for the estimation of models for multivariate binary and other ordinal data to more general copula models. Bayesian data augmentation has substantial advantages over other methods of estimation for this class of models. △ Less

Submitted 18 December, 2011; originally announced December 2011.