Showing 1–18 of 18 results for author: Schnitzer, M E

Valid post-selection inference for penalized G-estimation with longitudinal observational data

Authors: Ajmery Jaman, Ashkan Ertefaie, Michèle Bally, Renée Lévesque, Robert W. Platt, Mireille E. Schnitzer

Abstract: Understanding treatment effect heterogeneity is important for decision making in medical and clinical practices, or handling various engineering and marketing challenges. When dealing with high-dimensional covariates or when the effect modifiers are not predefined and need to be discovered, data-adaptive selection approaches become essential. However, with data-driven model selection, the quantifi… ▽ More Understanding treatment effect heterogeneity is important for decision making in medical and clinical practices, or handling various engineering and marketing challenges. When dealing with high-dimensional covariates or when the effect modifiers are not predefined and need to be discovered, data-adaptive selection approaches become essential. However, with data-driven model selection, the quantification of statistical uncertainty is complicated by post-selection inference due to difficulties in approximating the sampling distribution of the target estimator. Data-driven model selection tends to favor models with strong effect modifiers with an associated cost of inflated type I errors. Although several frameworks and methods for valid statistical inference have been proposed for ordinary least squares regression following data-driven model selection, fewer options exist for valid inference for effect modifier discovery in causal modeling contexts. In this article, we extend two different methods to develop valid inference for penalized G-estimation that investigates effect modification of proximal treatment effects within the structural nested mean model framework. We show the asymptotic validity of the proposed methods. Using extensive simulation studies, we evaluate and compare the finite sample performance of the proposed methods and the naive inference based on a sandwich variance estimator. Our work is motivated by the study of hemodiafiltration for treating patients with end-stage renal disease at the Centre Hospitalier de l'Université de Montréal. We apply these methods to draw inference about the effect heterogeneity of dialysis facility on the repeated session-specific hemodiafiltration outcomes. △ Less

Submitted 15 January, 2025; originally announced January 2025.

What if we had built a prediction model with a survival super learner instead of a Cox model 10 years ago?

Authors: Arthur Chatton, Émilie Pilote, Kevin Assob Feugo, Héloïse Cardinal, Robert W. Platt, Mireille E Schnitzer

Abstract: Objective: This study sought to compare the drop in predictive performance over time according to the modeling approach (regression versus machine learning) used to build a kidney transplant failure prediction model with a time-to-event outcome. Study Design and Setting: The Kidney Transplant Failure Score (KTFS) was used as a benchmark. We reused the data from which it was developed (DIVAT coho… ▽ More Objective: This study sought to compare the drop in predictive performance over time according to the modeling approach (regression versus machine learning) used to build a kidney transplant failure prediction model with a time-to-event outcome. Study Design and Setting: The Kidney Transplant Failure Score (KTFS) was used as a benchmark. We reused the data from which it was developed (DIVAT cohort, n=2,169) to build another prediction algorithm using a survival super learner combining (semi-)parametric and non-parametric methods. Performance in DIVAT was estimated for the two prediction models using internal validation. Then, the drop in predictive performance was evaluated in the same geographical population approximately ten years later (EKiTE cohort, n=2,329). Results: In DIVAT, the super learner achieved better discrimination than the KTFS, with a tAUROC of 0.83 (0.79-0.87) compared to 0.76 (0.70-0.82). While the discrimination remained stable for the KTFS, it was not the case for the super learner, with a drop to 0.80 (0.76-0.83). Regarding calibration, the survival SL overestimated graft survival at development, while the KTFS underestimated graft survival ten years later. Brier score values were similar regardless of the approach and the timing. Conclusion: The more flexible SL provided superior discrimination on the population used to fit it compared to a Cox model and similar discrimination when applied to a future dataset of the same population. Both methods are subject to calibration drift over time. However, weak calibration on the population used to develop the prediction model was correct only for the Cox model, and recalibration should be considered in the future to correct the calibration drift. △ Less

Submitted 13 December, 2024; originally announced December 2024.

Comments: 10 pages, 2 Tables, 3 Figures, Submitted

Regression trees for nonparametric diagnostics of sequential positivity violations in longitudinal causal inference

Authors: Arthur Chatton, Michael Schomaker, Miguel-Angel Luque-Fernandez, Robert W. Platt, Mireille E. Schnitzer

Abstract: Sequential positivity is often a necessary assumption for drawing causal inferences, such as through marginal structural modeling. Unfortunately, verification of this assumption can be challenging because it usually relies on multiple parametric propensity score models, unlikely all correctly specified. Therefore, we propose a new algorithm, called "sequential Positivity Regression Tree" (sPoRT),… ▽ More Sequential positivity is often a necessary assumption for drawing causal inferences, such as through marginal structural modeling. Unfortunately, verification of this assumption can be challenging because it usually relies on multiple parametric propensity score models, unlikely all correctly specified. Therefore, we propose a new algorithm, called "sequential Positivity Regression Tree" (sPoRT), to check this assumption with greater ease under either static or dynamic treatment strategies. This algorithm also identifies the subgroups found to be violating this assumption, allowing for insights about the nature of the violations and potential solutions. We first present different versions of sPoRT based on either stratifying or pooling over time. Finally, we illustrate its use in a real-life application of HIV-positive children in Southern Africa with and without pooling over time. An R notebook showing how to use sPoRT is available at github.com/ArthurChatton/sPoRT-notebook. △ Less

Submitted 13 December, 2024; originally announced December 2024.

Comments: 10 pages, 4 Tables, 2 Figures. Submitted

trajmsm: An R package for Trajectory Analysis and Causal Modeling

Authors: Awa Diop, Caroline Sirois, Jason R. Guertin, Mireille E. Schnitzer, James M. Brophy, Denis Talbot

Abstract: The R package trajmsm provides functions designed to simplify the estimation of the parameters of a model combining latent class growth analysis (LCGA), a trajectory analysis technique, and marginal structural models (MSMs) called LCGA-MSM. LCGA summarizes similar patterns of change over time into a few distinct categories called trajectory groups, which are then included as "treatments" in the MS… ▽ More The R package trajmsm provides functions designed to simplify the estimation of the parameters of a model combining latent class growth analysis (LCGA), a trajectory analysis technique, and marginal structural models (MSMs) called LCGA-MSM. LCGA summarizes similar patterns of change over time into a few distinct categories called trajectory groups, which are then included as "treatments" in the MSM. MSMs are a class of causal models that correctly handle treatment-confounder feedback. The parameters of LCGA-MSMs can be consistently estimated using different estimators, such as inverse probability weighting (IPW), g-computation, and pooled longitudinal targeted maximum likelihood estimation (pooled LTMLE). These three estimators of the parameters of LCGA-MSMs are currently implemented in our package. In the context of a time-dependent outcome, we previously proposed a combination of LCGA and history-restricted MSMs (LCGA-HRMSMs). Our package provides additional functions to estimate the parameters of such models. Version 0.1.3 of the package is currently available on CRAN. △ Less

Submitted 29 October, 2024; v1 submitted 25 October, 2024; originally announced October 2024.

Comments: 19 pages, 13 tables, 3 figures

Adaptive sparsening and smoothing of the treatment model for longitudinal causal inference using outcome-adaptive LASSO and marginal fused LASSO

Authors: Mireille E Schnitzer, Denis Talbot, Yan Liu, David Berger, Guanbo Wang, Jennifer O'Loughlin, Marie-Pierre Sylvestre, Ashkan Ertefaie

Abstract: Causal variable selection in time-varying treatment settings is challenging due to evolving confounding effects. Existing methods mainly focus on time-fixed exposures and are not directly applicable to time-varying scenarios. We propose a novel two-step procedure for variable selection when modeling the treatment probability at each time point. We first introduce a novel approach to longitudinal c… ▽ More Causal variable selection in time-varying treatment settings is challenging due to evolving confounding effects. Existing methods mainly focus on time-fixed exposures and are not directly applicable to time-varying scenarios. We propose a novel two-step procedure for variable selection when modeling the treatment probability at each time point. We first introduce a novel approach to longitudinal confounder selection using a Longitudinal Outcome Adaptive LASSO (LOAL) that will data-adaptively select covariates with theoretical justification of variance reduction of the estimator of the causal effect. We then propose an Adaptive Fused LASSO that can collapse treatment model parameters over time points with the goal of simplifying the models in order to improve the efficiency of the estimator while minimizing model misspecification bias compared with naive pooled logistic regression models. Our simulation studies highlight the need for and usefulness of the proposed approach in practice. We implemented our method on data from the Nicotine Dependence in Teens study to estimate the effect of the timing of alcohol initiation during adolescence on depressive symptoms in early adulthood. △ Less

Submitted 10 October, 2024; originally announced October 2024.

Penalized G-estimation for effect modifier selection in a structural nested mean model for repeated outcomes

Authors: Ajmery Jaman, Guanbo Wang, Ashkan Ertefaie, Michèle Bally, Renée Lévesque, Robert W. Platt, Mireille E. Schnitzer

Abstract: Effect modification occurs when the impact of the treatment on an outcome varies based on the levels of other covariates known as effect modifiers. Modeling these effect differences is important for etiological goals and for purposes of optimizing treatment. Structural nested mean models (SNMMs) are useful causal models for estimating the potentially heterogeneous effect of a time-varying exposure… ▽ More Effect modification occurs when the impact of the treatment on an outcome varies based on the levels of other covariates known as effect modifiers. Modeling these effect differences is important for etiological goals and for purposes of optimizing treatment. Structural nested mean models (SNMMs) are useful causal models for estimating the potentially heterogeneous effect of a time-varying exposure on the mean of an outcome in the presence of time-varying confounding. A data-adaptive selection approach is necessary if the effect modifiers are unknown a priori and need to be identified. Although variable selection techniques are available for estimating the conditional average treatment effects using marginal structural models or for developing optimal dynamic treatment regimens, all of these methods consider a single end-of-follow-up outcome. In the context of an SNMM for repeated outcomes, we propose a doubly robust penalized G-estimator for the causal effect of a time-varying exposure with a simultaneous selection of effect modifiers and prove the oracle property of our estimator. We conduct a simulation study for the evaluation of its performance in finite samples and verification of its double-robustness property. Our work is motivated by the study of hemodiafiltration for treating patients with end-stage renal disease at the Centre Hospitalier de l'Université de Montréal. We apply the proposed method to investigate the effect heterogeneity of dialysis facility on the repeated session-specific hemodiafiltration outcomes. △ Less

Submitted 19 January, 2025; v1 submitted 31 January, 2024; originally announced February 2024.

Personalised dynamic super learning: an application in predicting hemodiafiltration convection volumes

Authors: Arthur Chatton, Michèle Bally, Renée Lévesque, Ivana Malenica, Robert W. Platt, Mireille E. Schnitzer

Abstract: Obtaining continuously updated predictions is a major challenge for personalised medicine. Leveraging combinations of parametric regressions and machine learning approaches, the personalised online super learner (POSL) can achieve such dynamic and personalised predictions. We adapt POSL to predict a repeated continuous outcome dynamically and propose a new way to validate such personalised or dyna… ▽ More Obtaining continuously updated predictions is a major challenge for personalised medicine. Leveraging combinations of parametric regressions and machine learning approaches, the personalised online super learner (POSL) can achieve such dynamic and personalised predictions. We adapt POSL to predict a repeated continuous outcome dynamically and propose a new way to validate such personalised or dynamic prediction models. We illustrate its performance by predicting the convection volume of patients undergoing hemodiafiltration. POSL outperformed its candidate learners with respect to median absolute error, calibration-in-the-large, discrimination, and net benefit. We finally discuss the choices and challenges underlying the use of POSL. △ Less

Submitted 14 November, 2024; v1 submitted 12 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Comments: 16 pages, 6 Figures, 2 Tables. Supplementary materials are available at https://arthurchatton.netlify.app/publication/ Accepted in Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series C

A Double Machine Learning Approach for the Evaluation of COVID-19 Vaccine Effectiveness under the Test-Negative Design: Analysis of Québec Administrative Data

Authors: Cong Jiang, Denis Talbot, Sara Carazo, Mireille E Schnitzer

Abstract: The test-negative design (TND), which is routinely used for monitoring seasonal flu vaccine effectiveness (VE), has recently become integral to COVID-19 vaccine surveillance, notably in Québec, Canada. Some studies have addressed the identifiability and estimation of causal parameters under the TND, but efficiency bounds for nonparametric estimators of the target parameter under the unconfoundedne… ▽ More The test-negative design (TND), which is routinely used for monitoring seasonal flu vaccine effectiveness (VE), has recently become integral to COVID-19 vaccine surveillance, notably in Québec, Canada. Some studies have addressed the identifiability and estimation of causal parameters under the TND, but efficiency bounds for nonparametric estimators of the target parameter under the unconfoundedness assumption have not yet been investigated. Motivated by the goal of improving adjustment for measured confounders when estimating COVID-19 VE among community-dwelling people aged $\geq 60$ years in Québec, we propose a one-step doubly robust and locally efficient estimator called TNDDR (TND doubly robust), which utilizes cross-fitting (sample splitting) and can incorporate machine learning techniques to estimate the nuisance functions and thus improve control for measured confounders. We derive the efficient influence function (EIF) for the marginal expectation of the outcome under a vaccination intervention, explore the von Mises expansion, and establish the conditions for $\sqrt{n}-$consistency, asymptotic normality and double robustness of TNDDR. The proposed estimator is supported by both theoretical and empirical justifications. △ Less

Submitted 11 December, 2024; v1 submitted 6 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Structured Learning in Time-dependent Cox Models

Authors: Guanbo Wang, Yi Lian, Archer Y. Yang, Robert W. Platt, Rui Wang, Sylvie Perreault, Marc Dorais, Mireille E. Schnitzer

Abstract: Cox models with time-dependent coefficients and covariates are widely used in survival analysis. In high-dimensional settings, sparse regularization techniques are employed for variable selection, but existing methods for time-dependent Cox models lack flexibility in enforcing specific sparsity patterns (i.e., covariate structures). We propose a flexible framework for variable selection in time-de… ▽ More Cox models with time-dependent coefficients and covariates are widely used in survival analysis. In high-dimensional settings, sparse regularization techniques are employed for variable selection, but existing methods for time-dependent Cox models lack flexibility in enforcing specific sparsity patterns (i.e., covariate structures). We propose a flexible framework for variable selection in time-dependent Cox models, accommodating complex selection rules. Our method can adapt to arbitrary grouping structures, including interaction selection, temporal, spatial, tree, and directed acyclic graph structures. It achieves accurate estimation with low false alarm rates. We develop the sox package, implementing a network flow algorithm for efficiently solving models with complex covariate structures. sox offers a user-friendly interface for specifying grouping structures and delivers fast computation. Through examples, including a case study on identifying predictors of time to all-cause death in atrial fibrillation patients, we demonstrate the practical application of our method with specific selection rules. △ Less

Submitted 6 January, 2024; v1 submitted 21 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: 33 pages (with 15 pages of appendix),15 tables, 4 figures

The Delta-Method and Influence Function in Medical Statistics: a Reproducible Tutorial

Authors: Rodrigo Zepeda-Tello, Michael Schomaker, Camille Maringe, Matthew J. Smith, Aurelien Belot, Bernard Rachet, Mireille E. Schnitzer, Miguel Angel Luque-Fernandez

Abstract: Approximate statistical inference via determination of the asymptotic distribution of a statistic is routinely used for inference in applied medical statistics (e.g. to estimate the standard error of the marginal or conditional risk ratio). One method for variance estimation is the classical Delta-method but there is a knowledge gap as this method is not routinely included in training for applied… ▽ More Approximate statistical inference via determination of the asymptotic distribution of a statistic is routinely used for inference in applied medical statistics (e.g. to estimate the standard error of the marginal or conditional risk ratio). One method for variance estimation is the classical Delta-method but there is a knowledge gap as this method is not routinely included in training for applied medical statistics and its uses are not widely understood. Given that a smooth function of an asymptotically normal estimator is also asymptotically normally distributed, the Delta-method allows approximating the large-sample variance of a function of an estimator with known large-sample properties. In a more general setting, it is a technique for approximating the variance of a functional (i.e., an estimand) that takes a function as an input and applies another function to it (e.g. the expectation function). Specifically, we may approximate the variance of the function using the functional Delta-method based on the influence function (IF). The IF explores how a functional $φ(θ)$ changes in response to small perturbations in the sample distribution of the estimator and allows computing the empirical standard error of the distribution of the functional. The ongoing development of new methods and techniques may pose a challenge for applied statisticians who are interested in mastering the application of these methods. In this tutorial, we review the use of the classical and functional Delta-method and their links to the IF from a practical perspective. We illustrate the methods using a cancer epidemiology example and we provide reproducible and commented code in R and Python using symbolic programming. The code can be accessed at https://github.com/migariane/DeltaMethodInfluenceFunction △ Less

Submitted 30 June, 2022; originally announced June 2022.

Integrating complex selection rules into the latent overlapping group Lasso for constructing coherent prediction models

Authors: Guanbo Wang, Sylvie Perreault, Robert W. Platt, Rui Wang, Marc Dorais, Mireille E. Schnitzer

Abstract: The construction of coherent prediction models holds great importance in medical research as such models enable health researchers to gain deeper insights into disease epidemiology and clinicians to identify patients at higher risk of adverse outcomes. One commonly employed approach to developing prediction models is variable selection through penalized regression techniques. Integrating natural v… ▽ More The construction of coherent prediction models holds great importance in medical research as such models enable health researchers to gain deeper insights into disease epidemiology and clinicians to identify patients at higher risk of adverse outcomes. One commonly employed approach to developing prediction models is variable selection through penalized regression techniques. Integrating natural variable structures into this process not only enhances model interpretability but can also %increase the likelihood of recovering the true underlying model and boost prediction accuracy. However, a challenge lies in determining how to effectively integrate potentially complex selection dependencies into the penalized regression. In this work, we demonstrate how to represent selection dependencies mathematically, provide algorithms for deriving the complete set of potential models, and offer a structured approach for integrating complex rules into variable selection through the latent overlapping group Lasso. To illustrate our methodology, we applied these techniques to construct a coherent prediction model for major bleeding in hypertensive patients recently hospitalized for atrial fibrillation and subsequently prescribed oral anticoagulants. In this application, we account for a proxy of anticoagulant adherence and its interaction with dosage and the type of oral anticoagulants in addition to drug-drug interactions. △ Less

Submitted 15 January, 2024; v1 submitted 10 June, 2022; originally announced June 2022.

Comments: 58 pages, 1 figure

A general framework for formulating structured variable selection

Authors: Guanbo Wang, Mireille E. Schnitzer, Tom Chen, Rui Wang, Robert W. Platt

Abstract: In variable selection, a selection rule that prescribes the permissible sets of selected variables (called a "selection dictionary") is desirable due to the inherent structural constraints among the candidate variables. Such selection rules can be complex in real-world data analyses, and failing to incorporate such restrictions could not only compromise the interpretability of the model but also l… ▽ More In variable selection, a selection rule that prescribes the permissible sets of selected variables (called a "selection dictionary") is desirable due to the inherent structural constraints among the candidate variables. Such selection rules can be complex in real-world data analyses, and failing to incorporate such restrictions could not only compromise the interpretability of the model but also lead to decreased prediction accuracy. However, no general framework has been proposed to formalize selection rules and their applications, which poses a significant challenge for practitioners seeking to integrate these rules into their analyses. In this work, we establish a framework for structured variable selection that can incorporate universal structural constraints. We develop a mathematical language for constructing arbitrary selection rules, where the selection dictionary is formally defined. We demonstrate that all selection rules can be expressed as combinations of operations on constructs, facilitating the identification of the corresponding selection dictionary. Once this selection dictionary is derived, practitioners can apply their own user-defined criteria to select the optimal model. Additionally, our framework enhances existing penalized regression methods for variable selection by providing guidance on how to appropriately group variables to achieve the desired selection rule. Furthermore, our innovative framework opens the door to establishing new l0 norm-based penalized regression techniques that can be tailored to respect arbitrary selection rules, thereby expanding the possibilities for more robust and tailored model development. △ Less

Submitted 15 January, 2024; v1 submitted 3 October, 2021; originally announced October 2021.

Comments: 14 pages

Journal ref: Transactions on Machine Learning Research (2024/01)

Data Integration through outcome adaptive LASSO and a collaborative propensity score approach

Authors: Asma Bahamyirou, Mireille E. Schnitzer

Abstract: Administrative data, or non-probability sample data, are increasingly being used to obtain official statistics due to their many benefits over survey methods. In particular, they are less costly, provide a larger sample size, and are not reliant on the response rate. However, it is difficult to obtain an unbiased estimate of the population mean from such data due to the absence of design weights.… ▽ More Administrative data, or non-probability sample data, are increasingly being used to obtain official statistics due to their many benefits over survey methods. In particular, they are less costly, provide a larger sample size, and are not reliant on the response rate. However, it is difficult to obtain an unbiased estimate of the population mean from such data due to the absence of design weights. Several estimation approaches have been proposed recently using an auxiliary probability sample which provides representative covariate information of the target population. However, when this covariate information is high-dimensional, variable selection is not a straight-forward task even for a subject matter expert. In the context of efficient and doubly robust estimation approaches for estimating a population mean, we develop two data adaptive methods for variable selection using the outcome adaptive LASSO and a collaborative propensity score, respectively. Simulation studies are performed in order to verify the performance of the proposed methods versus competing methods. Finally, we presented an anayisis of the impact of Covid-19 on Canadians. △ Less

Submitted 28 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Doubly Robust Adaptive LASSO for Effect Modifier Discovery

Authors: Asma Bahamyirou, Mireille E. Schnitzer, Edward H. Kennedy, Lucie Blais, Yi Yang

Abstract: Effect modification occurs when the effect of the treatment on an outcome differs according to the level of a third variable (the effect modifier, EM). A natural way to assess effect modification is by subgroup analysis or include the interaction terms between the treatment and the covariates in an outcome regression. The latter, however, does not target a parameter of a marginal structural model… ▽ More Effect modification occurs when the effect of the treatment on an outcome differs according to the level of a third variable (the effect modifier, EM). A natural way to assess effect modification is by subgroup analysis or include the interaction terms between the treatment and the covariates in an outcome regression. The latter, however, does not target a parameter of a marginal structural model (MSM) unless a correctly specified outcome model is specified. Our aim is to develop a data-adaptive method to select effect modifying variables in an MSM with a single time point exposure. A two-stage procedure is proposed. First, we estimate the conditional outcome expectation and propensity score and plug these into a doubly robust loss function. Second, we use the adaptive LASSO to select the EMs and estimate MSM coefficients. Post-selection inference is then used to obtain coverage on the selected EMs. Simulations studies are performed in order to verify the performance of the proposed methods. △ Less

Submitted 21 December, 2021; v1 submitted 25 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Identifiability and estimation under the test-negative design with population controls with the goal of identifying risk and preventive factors for SARS-CoV-2 infection

Authors: Mireille E. Schnitzer, Daphna Harel, Vikki Ho, Anita Koushik, Joanna Merckx

Abstract: Due to the rapidly evolving COVID-19 pandemic caused by the SARS-CoV-2 virus, quick public health investigations of the relationships between behaviours and infection risk are essential. Recently the test-negative design was proposed to recruit and survey participants who are symptomatic and being tested for SARS-CoV-2 infection with the goal of evaluating associations between the survey responses… ▽ More Due to the rapidly evolving COVID-19 pandemic caused by the SARS-CoV-2 virus, quick public health investigations of the relationships between behaviours and infection risk are essential. Recently the test-negative design was proposed to recruit and survey participants who are symptomatic and being tested for SARS-CoV-2 infection with the goal of evaluating associations between the survey responses (including behaviours and environment) and testing positive on the test. It was also proposed to recruit additional controls who are part of the general population as a baseline comparison group in order to evaluate risk factors specific to SARS-CoV-2 infection. In this study, we consider an alternative design where we recruit among all individuals, symptomatic and asymptomatic, being tested for the virus in addition to population controls. We define a regression parameter related to a prospective risk factor analysis and investigate its identifiability under the two study designs. We review the difference between the prospective risk factor parameter and the parameter targeted in the typical test-negative design where only symptomatic and tested people are recruited. Using missing data directed acyclic graphs we provide conditions and required data collection under which identifiability of the prospective risk factor parameter is possible and compare the benefits and limitations of the alternative study designs and target parameters. We propose a novel inverse probability weighting estimator and demonstrate the performance of this estimator through simulation study. △ Less

Submitted 5 February, 2021; v1 submitted 4 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Educational Note: Paradoxical Collider Effect in the Analysis of Non-Communicable Disease Epidemiological Data: a reproducible illustration and web application

Authors: Miguel Angel Luque-Fernandez, Michael Schomaker, Daniel Redondo-Sanchez, Maria Jose Sanchez Perez, Anand Vaidya, Mireille E. Schnitzer

Abstract: Classical epidemiology has focused on the control of confounding but it is only recently that epidemiologists have started to focus on the bias produced by colliders. A collider for a certain pair of variables (e.g., an outcome Y and an exposure A) is a third variable (C) that is caused by both. In a directed acyclic graph (DAG), a collider is the variable in the middle of an inverted fork (i.e.,… ▽ More Classical epidemiology has focused on the control of confounding but it is only recently that epidemiologists have started to focus on the bias produced by colliders. A collider for a certain pair of variables (e.g., an outcome Y and an exposure A) is a third variable (C) that is caused by both. In a directed acyclic graph (DAG), a collider is the variable in the middle of an inverted fork (i.e., the variable C in A -> C <- Y). Controlling for, or conditioning an analysis on a collider (i.e., through stratification or regression) can introduce a spurious association between its causes. This potentially explains many paradoxical findings in the medical literature, where established risk factors for a particular outcome appear protective. We use an example from non-communicable disease epidemiology to contextualize and explain the effect of conditioning on a collider. We generate a dataset with 1,000 observations and run Monte-Carlo simulations to estimate the effect of 24-hour dietary sodium intake on systolic blood pressure, controlling for age, which acts as a confounder, and 24-hour urinary protein excretion, which acts as a collider. We illustrate how adding a collider to a regression model introduces bias. Thus, to prevent paradoxical associations, epidemiologists estimating causal effects should be wary of conditioning on colliders. We provide R-code in easy-to-read boxes throughout the manuscript and a GitHub repository (https://github.com/migariane/ColliderApp) for the reader to reproduce our example. We also provide an educational web application allowing real-time interaction to visualize the paradoxical effect of conditioning on a collider http://watzilei.com/shiny/collider/. △ Less

Submitted 10 November, 2019; v1 submitted 19 September, 2018; originally announced September 2018.

A causal inference approach to network meta-analysis

Authors: Mireille E. Schnitzer, Russell J. Steele, Michèle Bally, Ian Shrier

Abstract: While standard meta-analysis pools the results from randomized trials that compare two treatments, network meta-analysis aggregates the results of randomized trials comparing a wider variety of treatment options. However, it is unclear whether the aggregation of effect estimates across heterogeneous populations will be consistent for a meaningful parameter when not all treatments are evaluated on… ▽ More While standard meta-analysis pools the results from randomized trials that compare two treatments, network meta-analysis aggregates the results of randomized trials comparing a wider variety of treatment options. However, it is unclear whether the aggregation of effect estimates across heterogeneous populations will be consistent for a meaningful parameter when not all treatments are evaluated on each population. Drawing from counterfactual theory and the causal inference framework, we define the population of interest in a network meta-analysis and define the target parameter under a series of nonparametric structural assumptions. This allows us to determine the requirements for identifiability of this parameter, enabling a description of the conditions under which network meta-analysis is appropriate and when it might mislead decision making. We then adapt several modeling strategies from the causal inference literature to obtain consistent estimation of the intervention-specific mean outcome and model-independent contrasts between treatments. Finally, we perform a reanalysis of a systematic review to compare the efficacy of antibiotics on suspected or confirmed methicillin-resistant \emph{Staphylococcus aureus} in hospitalized patients. △ Less

Submitted 11 August, 2016; v1 submitted 4 June, 2015; originally announced June 2015.

Effect of breastfeeding on gastrointestinal infection in infants: A targeted maximum likelihood approach for clustered longitudinal data

Authors: Mireille E. Schnitzer, Mark J. van der Laan, Erica E. M. Moodie, Robert W. Platt

Abstract: The PROmotion of Breastfeeding Intervention Trial (PROBIT) cluster-randomized a program encouraging breastfeeding to new mothers in hospital centers. The original studies indicated that this intervention successfully increased duration of breastfeeding and lowered rates of gastrointestinal tract infections in newborns. Additional scientific and popular interest lies in determining the causal effec… ▽ More The PROmotion of Breastfeeding Intervention Trial (PROBIT) cluster-randomized a program encouraging breastfeeding to new mothers in hospital centers. The original studies indicated that this intervention successfully increased duration of breastfeeding and lowered rates of gastrointestinal tract infections in newborns. Additional scientific and popular interest lies in determining the causal effect of longer breastfeeding on gastrointestinal infection. In this study, we estimate the expected infection count under various lengths of breastfeeding in order to estimate the effect of breastfeeding duration on infection. Due to the presence of baseline and time-dependent confounding, specialized "causal" estimation methods are required. We demonstrate the double-robust method of Targeted Maximum Likelihood Estimation (TMLE) in the context of this application and review some related methods and the adjustments required to account for clustering. We compare TMLE (implemented both parametrically and using a data-adaptive algorithm) to other causal methods for this example. In addition, we conduct a simulation study to determine (1) the effectiveness of controlling for clustering indicators when cluster-specific confounders are unmeasured and (2) the importance of using data-adaptive TMLE. △ Less

Submitted 31 July, 2014; originally announced July 2014.

Comments: Published in at http://dx.doi.org/10.1214/14-AOAS727 the Annals of Applied Statistics (http://www.imstat.org/aoas/) by the Institute of Mathematical Statistics (http://www.imstat.org)

Report number: IMS-AOAS-AOAS727

Journal ref: Annals of Applied Statistics 2014, Vol. 8, No. 2, 703-725