A Partially Pooled NSUM Model: Detailed estimation of CSEM trafficking prevalence in Philippine municipalities
Authors:
Albert Nyarko-Agyei,
Scott Moser,
Rowland G Seymour,
Ben Brewster,
Sabrina Li,
Esther Weir,
Todd Landman,
Emily Wyman,
Christine Belle Torres,
Imogen Fell,
Doreen Boyd
Abstract:
Effective policy and intervention strategies to combat human trafficking for child sexual exploitation material (CSEM) production require accurate prevalence estimates. Traditional Network Scale Up Method (NSUM) models often necessitate standalone surveys for each geographic region, escalating costs and complexity. This study introduces a partially pooled NSUM model, using a hierarchical Bayesian…
▽ More
Effective policy and intervention strategies to combat human trafficking for child sexual exploitation material (CSEM) production require accurate prevalence estimates. Traditional Network Scale Up Method (NSUM) models often necessitate standalone surveys for each geographic region, escalating costs and complexity. This study introduces a partially pooled NSUM model, using a hierarchical Bayesian framework that efficiently aggregates and utilizes data across multiple regions without increasing sample sizes. We developed this model for a novel national survey dataset from the Philippines and we demonstrate its ability to produce detailed municipal-level prevalence estimates of trafficking for CSEM production. Our results not only underscore the model's precision in estimating hidden populations but also highlight its potential for broader application in other areas of social science and public health research, offering significant implications for resource allocation and intervention planning.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2025; v1 submitted 18 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
Comparative Judgement Modeling to Map Forced Marriage at Local Levels
Authors:
R. G. Seymour,
A. Nyarko-Agyei,
H. R. McCabe,
K. Severn,
T. Kypraios,
D. Sirl,
A. Taylor
Abstract:
Forcing someone into marriage against their will is a violation of their human rights. In 2021, the county of Nottinghamshire, UK, launched a strategy to tackle forced marriage and violence against women and girls. However, accessing information about where victims are located in the county could compromise their safety, so it is not possible to develop interventions for different areas of the cou…
▽ More
Forcing someone into marriage against their will is a violation of their human rights. In 2021, the county of Nottinghamshire, UK, launched a strategy to tackle forced marriage and violence against women and girls. However, accessing information about where victims are located in the county could compromise their safety, so it is not possible to develop interventions for different areas of the county. Comparative judgement studies offer a way to map the risk of human rights abuses without collecting data that could compromise victim safety. Current methods require studies to have a large number of participants, so we develop a comparative judgement model that provides a more flexible spatial modelling structure and a mechanism to schedule comparisons more effectively. The methods reduce the data collection burden on participants and make a comparative judgement study feasible with a small number of participants. Underpinning these methods is a latent variable representation that improves on the scalability of previous comparative judgement models. We use these methods to map the risk of forced marriage across Nottinghamshire thereby supporting the county's strategy for tackling violence against women and girls.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 2025; v1 submitted 2 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
