-
Reranking Laws for Language Generation: A Communication-Theoretic Perspective
Authors:
António Farinhas,
Haau-Sing Li,
André F. T. Martins
Abstract:
To ensure large language models (LLMs) are used safely, one must reduce their propensity to hallucinate or to generate unacceptable answers. A simple and often used strategy is to first let the LLM generate multiple hypotheses and then employ a reranker to choose the best one. In this paper, we draw a parallel between this strategy and the use of redundancy to decrease the error rate in noisy comm…
▽ More
To ensure large language models (LLMs) are used safely, one must reduce their propensity to hallucinate or to generate unacceptable answers. A simple and often used strategy is to first let the LLM generate multiple hypotheses and then employ a reranker to choose the best one. In this paper, we draw a parallel between this strategy and the use of redundancy to decrease the error rate in noisy communication channels. We conceptualize the generator as a sender transmitting multiple descriptions of a message through parallel noisy channels. The receiver decodes the message by ranking the (potentially corrupted) descriptions and selecting the one found to be most reliable. We provide conditions under which this protocol is asymptotically error-free (i.e., yields an acceptable answer almost surely) even in scenarios where the reranker is imperfect (governed by Mallows or Zipf-Mandelbrot models) and the channel distributions are statistically dependent. We use our framework to obtain reranking laws which we validate empirically on two real-world tasks using LLMs: text-to-code generation with DeepSeek-Coder 7B and machine translation of medical data with TowerInstruct 13B.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2025; v1 submitted 11 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Non-Exchangeable Conformal Risk Control
Authors:
António Farinhas,
Chrysoula Zerva,
Dennis Ulmer,
André F. T. Martins
Abstract:
Split conformal prediction has recently sparked great interest due to its ability to provide formally guaranteed uncertainty sets or intervals for predictions made by black-box neural models, ensuring a predefined probability of containing the actual ground truth. While the original formulation assumes data exchangeability, some extensions handle non-exchangeable data, which is often the case in m…
▽ More
Split conformal prediction has recently sparked great interest due to its ability to provide formally guaranteed uncertainty sets or intervals for predictions made by black-box neural models, ensuring a predefined probability of containing the actual ground truth. While the original formulation assumes data exchangeability, some extensions handle non-exchangeable data, which is often the case in many real-world scenarios. In parallel, some progress has been made in conformal methods that provide statistical guarantees for a broader range of objectives, such as bounding the best $F_1$-score or minimizing the false negative rate in expectation. In this paper, we leverage and extend these two lines of work by proposing non-exchangeable conformal risk control, which allows controlling the expected value of any monotone loss function when the data is not exchangeable. Our framework is flexible, makes very few assumptions, and allows weighting the data based on its relevance for a given test example; a careful choice of weights may result on tighter bounds, making our framework useful in the presence of change points, time series, or other forms of distribution drift. Experiments with both synthetic and real world data show the usefulness of our method.
△ Less
Submitted 26 January, 2024; v1 submitted 2 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Discrete Latent Structure in Neural Networks
Authors:
Vlad Niculae,
Caio F. Corro,
Nikita Nangia,
Tsvetomila Mihaylova,
André F. T. Martins
Abstract:
Many types of data from fields including natural language processing, computer vision, and bioinformatics, are well represented by discrete, compositional structures such as trees, sequences, or matchings. Latent structure models are a powerful tool for learning to extract such representations, offering a way to incorporate structural bias, discover insight about the data, and interpret decisions.…
▽ More
Many types of data from fields including natural language processing, computer vision, and bioinformatics, are well represented by discrete, compositional structures such as trees, sequences, or matchings. Latent structure models are a powerful tool for learning to extract such representations, offering a way to incorporate structural bias, discover insight about the data, and interpret decisions. However, effective training is challenging, as neural networks are typically designed for continuous computation.
This text explores three broad strategies for learning with discrete latent structure: continuous relaxation, surrogate gradients, and probabilistic estimation. Our presentation relies on consistent notations for a wide range of models. As such, we reveal many new connections between latent structure learning strategies, showing how most consist of the same small set of fundamental building blocks, but use them differently, leading to substantially different applicability and properties.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2024; v1 submitted 18 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Differentiable Causal Discovery Under Latent Interventions
Authors:
Gonçalo R. A. Faria,
André F. T. Martins,
Mário A. T. Figueiredo
Abstract:
Recent work has shown promising results in causal discovery by leveraging interventional data with gradient-based methods, even when the intervened variables are unknown. However, previous work assumes that the correspondence between samples and interventions is known, which is often unrealistic. We envision a scenario with an extensive dataset sampled from multiple intervention distributions and…
▽ More
Recent work has shown promising results in causal discovery by leveraging interventional data with gradient-based methods, even when the intervened variables are unknown. However, previous work assumes that the correspondence between samples and interventions is known, which is often unrealistic. We envision a scenario with an extensive dataset sampled from multiple intervention distributions and one observation distribution, but where we do not know which distribution originated each sample and how the intervention affected the system, \textit{i.e.}, interventions are entirely latent. We propose a method based on neural networks and variational inference that addresses this scenario by framing it as learning a shared causal graph among an infinite mixture (under a Dirichlet process prior) of intervention structural causal models. Experiments with synthetic and real data show that our approach and its semi-supervised variant are able to discover causal relations in this challenging scenario.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Sparse Continuous Distributions and Fenchel-Young Losses
Authors:
André F. T. Martins,
Marcos Treviso,
António Farinhas,
Pedro M. Q. Aguiar,
Mário A. T. Figueiredo,
Mathieu Blondel,
Vlad Niculae
Abstract:
Exponential families are widely used in machine learning, including many distributions in continuous and discrete domains (e.g., Gaussian, Dirichlet, Poisson, and categorical distributions via the softmax transformation). Distributions in each of these families have fixed support. In contrast, for finite domains, recent work on sparse alternatives to softmax (e.g., sparsemax, $α$-entmax, and fused…
▽ More
Exponential families are widely used in machine learning, including many distributions in continuous and discrete domains (e.g., Gaussian, Dirichlet, Poisson, and categorical distributions via the softmax transformation). Distributions in each of these families have fixed support. In contrast, for finite domains, recent work on sparse alternatives to softmax (e.g., sparsemax, $α$-entmax, and fusedmax), has led to distributions with varying support.
This paper develops sparse alternatives to continuous distributions, based on several technical contributions: First, we define $Ω$-regularized prediction maps and Fenchel-Young losses for arbitrary domains (possibly countably infinite or continuous). For linearly parametrized families, we show that minimization of Fenchel-Young losses is equivalent to moment matching of the statistics, generalizing a fundamental property of exponential families. When $Ω$ is a Tsallis negentropy with parameter $α$, we obtain ``deformed exponential families,'' which include $α$-entmax and sparsemax ($α=2$) as particular cases. For quadratic energy functions, the resulting densities are $β$-Gaussians, an instance of elliptical distributions that contain as particular cases the Gaussian, biweight, triweight, and Epanechnikov densities, and for which we derive closed-form expressions for the variance, Tsallis entropy, and Fenchel-Young loss. When $Ω$ is a total variation or Sobolev regularizer, we obtain a continuous version of the fusedmax. Finally, we introduce continuous-domain attention mechanisms, deriving efficient gradient backpropagation algorithms for $α\in \{1, 4/3, 3/2, 2\}$. Using these algorithms, we demonstrate our sparse continuous distributions for attention-based audio classification and visual question answering, showing that they allow attending to time intervals and compact regions.
△ Less
Submitted 4 August, 2022; v1 submitted 4 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Efficient Marginalization of Discrete and Structured Latent Variables via Sparsity
Authors:
Gonçalo M. Correia,
Vlad Niculae,
Wilker Aziz,
André F. T. Martins
Abstract:
Training neural network models with discrete (categorical or structured) latent variables can be computationally challenging, due to the need for marginalization over large or combinatorial sets. To circumvent this issue, one typically resorts to sampling-based approximations of the true marginal, requiring noisy gradient estimators (e.g., score function estimator) or continuous relaxations with l…
▽ More
Training neural network models with discrete (categorical or structured) latent variables can be computationally challenging, due to the need for marginalization over large or combinatorial sets. To circumvent this issue, one typically resorts to sampling-based approximations of the true marginal, requiring noisy gradient estimators (e.g., score function estimator) or continuous relaxations with lower-variance reparameterized gradients (e.g., Gumbel-Softmax). In this paper, we propose a new training strategy which replaces these estimators by an exact yet efficient marginalization. To achieve this, we parameterize discrete distributions over latent assignments using differentiable sparse mappings: sparsemax and its structured counterparts. In effect, the support of these distributions is greatly reduced, which enables efficient marginalization. We report successful results in three tasks covering a range of latent variable modeling applications: a semisupervised deep generative model, a latent communication game, and a generative model with a bit-vector latent representation. In all cases, we obtain good performance while still achieving the practicality of sampling-based approximations.
△ Less
Submitted 28 December, 2020; v1 submitted 3 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Sparse and Continuous Attention Mechanisms
Authors:
André F. T. Martins,
António Farinhas,
Marcos Treviso,
Vlad Niculae,
Pedro M. Q. Aguiar,
Mário A. T. Figueiredo
Abstract:
Exponential families are widely used in machine learning; they include many distributions in continuous and discrete domains (e.g., Gaussian, Dirichlet, Poisson, and categorical distributions via the softmax transformation). Distributions in each of these families have fixed support. In contrast, for finite domains, there has been recent work on sparse alternatives to softmax (e.g. sparsemax and a…
▽ More
Exponential families are widely used in machine learning; they include many distributions in continuous and discrete domains (e.g., Gaussian, Dirichlet, Poisson, and categorical distributions via the softmax transformation). Distributions in each of these families have fixed support. In contrast, for finite domains, there has been recent work on sparse alternatives to softmax (e.g. sparsemax and alpha-entmax), which have varying support, being able to assign zero probability to irrelevant categories. This paper expands that work in two directions: first, we extend alpha-entmax to continuous domains, revealing a link with Tsallis statistics and deformed exponential families. Second, we introduce continuous-domain attention mechanisms, deriving efficient gradient backpropagation algorithms for alpha in {1,2}. Experiments on attention-based text classification, machine translation, and visual question answering illustrate the use of continuous attention in 1D and 2D, showing that it allows attending to time intervals and compact regions.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2020; v1 submitted 12 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
LP-SparseMAP: Differentiable Relaxed Optimization for Sparse Structured Prediction
Authors:
Vlad Niculae,
André F. T. Martins
Abstract:
Structured prediction requires manipulating a large number of combinatorial structures, e.g., dependency trees or alignments, either as latent or output variables. Recently, the SparseMAP method has been proposed as a differentiable, sparse alternative to maximum a posteriori (MAP) and marginal inference. SparseMAP returns a combination of a small number of structures, a desirable property in some…
▽ More
Structured prediction requires manipulating a large number of combinatorial structures, e.g., dependency trees or alignments, either as latent or output variables. Recently, the SparseMAP method has been proposed as a differentiable, sparse alternative to maximum a posteriori (MAP) and marginal inference. SparseMAP returns a combination of a small number of structures, a desirable property in some downstream applications. However, SparseMAP requires a tractable MAP inference oracle. This excludes, e.g., loopy graphical models or factor graphs with logic constraints, which generally require approximate inference. In this paper, we introduce LP-SparseMAP, an extension of SparseMAP that addresses this limitation via a local polytope relaxation. LP-SparseMAP uses the flexible and powerful domain specific language of factor graphs for defining and backpropagating through arbitrary hidden structure, supporting coarse decompositions, hard logic constraints, and higher-order correlations. We derive the forward and backward algorithms needed for using LP-SparseMAP as a hidden or output layer. Experiments in three structured prediction tasks show benefits compared to SparseMAP and Structured SVM.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2020; v1 submitted 13 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Adaptively Sparse Transformers
Authors:
Gonçalo M. Correia,
Vlad Niculae,
André F. T. Martins
Abstract:
Attention mechanisms have become ubiquitous in NLP. Recent architectures, notably the Transformer, learn powerful context-aware word representations through layered, multi-headed attention. The multiple heads learn diverse types of word relationships. However, with standard softmax attention, all attention heads are dense, assigning a non-zero weight to all context words. In this work, we introduc…
▽ More
Attention mechanisms have become ubiquitous in NLP. Recent architectures, notably the Transformer, learn powerful context-aware word representations through layered, multi-headed attention. The multiple heads learn diverse types of word relationships. However, with standard softmax attention, all attention heads are dense, assigning a non-zero weight to all context words. In this work, we introduce the adaptively sparse Transformer, wherein attention heads have flexible, context-dependent sparsity patterns. This sparsity is accomplished by replacing softmax with $α$-entmax: a differentiable generalization of softmax that allows low-scoring words to receive precisely zero weight. Moreover, we derive a method to automatically learn the $α$ parameter -- which controls the shape and sparsity of $α$-entmax -- allowing attention heads to choose between focused or spread-out behavior. Our adaptively sparse Transformer improves interpretability and head diversity when compared to softmax Transformers on machine translation datasets. Findings of the quantitative and qualitative analysis of our approach include that heads in different layers learn different sparsity preferences and tend to be more diverse in their attention distributions than softmax Transformers. Furthermore, at no cost in accuracy, sparsity in attention heads helps to uncover different head specializations.
△ Less
Submitted 6 September, 2019; v1 submitted 30 August, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Notes on Latent Structure Models and SPIGOT
Authors:
André F. T. Martins,
Vlad Niculae
Abstract:
These notes aim to shed light on the recently proposed structured projected intermediate gradient optimization technique (SPIGOT, Peng et al., 2018). SPIGOT is a variant of the straight-through estimator (Bengio et al., 2013) which bypasses gradients of the argmax function by back-propagating a surrogate "gradient." We provide a new interpretation to the proposed gradient and put this technique in…
▽ More
These notes aim to shed light on the recently proposed structured projected intermediate gradient optimization technique (SPIGOT, Peng et al., 2018). SPIGOT is a variant of the straight-through estimator (Bengio et al., 2013) which bypasses gradients of the argmax function by back-propagating a surrogate "gradient." We provide a new interpretation to the proposed gradient and put this technique into perspective, linking it to other methods for training neural networks with discrete latent variables. As a by-product, we suggest alternate variants of SPIGOT which will be further explored in future work.
△ Less
Submitted 24 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Learning with Fenchel-Young Losses
Authors:
Mathieu Blondel,
André F. T. Martins,
Vlad Niculae
Abstract:
Over the past decades, numerous loss functions have been been proposed for a variety of supervised learning tasks, including regression, classification, ranking, and more generally structured prediction. Understanding the core principles and theoretical properties underpinning these losses is key to choose the right loss for the right problem, as well as to create new losses which combine their st…
▽ More
Over the past decades, numerous loss functions have been been proposed for a variety of supervised learning tasks, including regression, classification, ranking, and more generally structured prediction. Understanding the core principles and theoretical properties underpinning these losses is key to choose the right loss for the right problem, as well as to create new losses which combine their strengths. In this paper, we introduce Fenchel-Young losses, a generic way to construct a convex loss function for a regularized prediction function. We provide an in-depth study of their properties in a very broad setting, covering all the aforementioned supervised learning tasks, and revealing new connections between sparsity, generalized entropies, and separation margins. We show that Fenchel-Young losses unify many well-known loss functions and allow to create useful new ones easily. Finally, we derive efficient predictive and training algorithms, making Fenchel-Young losses appealing both in theory and practice.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2020; v1 submitted 8 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Towards Dynamic Computation Graphs via Sparse Latent Structure
Authors:
Vlad Niculae,
André F. T. Martins,
Claire Cardie
Abstract:
Deep NLP models benefit from underlying structures in the data---e.g., parse trees---typically extracted using off-the-shelf parsers. Recent attempts to jointly learn the latent structure encounter a tradeoff: either make factorization assumptions that limit expressiveness, or sacrifice end-to-end differentiability. Using the recently proposed SparseMAP inference, which retrieves a sparse distribu…
▽ More
Deep NLP models benefit from underlying structures in the data---e.g., parse trees---typically extracted using off-the-shelf parsers. Recent attempts to jointly learn the latent structure encounter a tradeoff: either make factorization assumptions that limit expressiveness, or sacrifice end-to-end differentiability. Using the recently proposed SparseMAP inference, which retrieves a sparse distribution over latent structures, we propose a novel approach for end-to-end learning of latent structure predictors jointly with a downstream predictor. To the best of our knowledge, our method is the first to enable unrestricted dynamic computation graph construction from the global latent structure, while maintaining differentiability.
△ Less
Submitted 3 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Learning Classifiers with Fenchel-Young Losses: Generalized Entropies, Margins, and Algorithms
Authors:
Mathieu Blondel,
André F. T. Martins,
Vlad Niculae
Abstract:
This paper studies Fenchel-Young losses, a generic way to construct convex loss functions from a regularization function. We analyze their properties in depth, showing that they unify many well-known loss functions and allow to create useful new ones easily. Fenchel-Young losses constructed from a generalized entropy, including the Shannon and Tsallis entropies, induce predictive probability distr…
▽ More
This paper studies Fenchel-Young losses, a generic way to construct convex loss functions from a regularization function. We analyze their properties in depth, showing that they unify many well-known loss functions and allow to create useful new ones easily. Fenchel-Young losses constructed from a generalized entropy, including the Shannon and Tsallis entropies, induce predictive probability distributions. We formulate conditions for a generalized entropy to yield losses with a separation margin, and probability distributions with sparse support. Finally, we derive efficient algorithms, making Fenchel-Young losses appealing both in theory and practice.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2019; v1 submitted 24 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
SparseMAP: Differentiable Sparse Structured Inference
Authors:
Vlad Niculae,
André F. T. Martins,
Mathieu Blondel,
Claire Cardie
Abstract:
Structured prediction requires searching over a combinatorial number of structures. To tackle it, we introduce SparseMAP: a new method for sparse structured inference, and its natural loss function. SparseMAP automatically selects only a few global structures: it is situated between MAP inference, which picks a single structure, and marginal inference, which assigns probability mass to all structu…
▽ More
Structured prediction requires searching over a combinatorial number of structures. To tackle it, we introduce SparseMAP: a new method for sparse structured inference, and its natural loss function. SparseMAP automatically selects only a few global structures: it is situated between MAP inference, which picks a single structure, and marginal inference, which assigns probability mass to all structures, including implausible ones. Importantly, SparseMAP can be computed using only calls to a MAP oracle, making it applicable to problems with intractable marginal inference, e.g., linear assignment. Sparsity makes gradient backpropagation efficient regardless of the structure, enabling us to augment deep neural networks with generic and sparse structured hidden layers. Experiments in dependency parsing and natural language inference reveal competitive accuracy, improved interpretability, and the ability to capture natural language ambiguities, which is attractive for pipeline systems.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2018; v1 submitted 12 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
From Softmax to Sparsemax: A Sparse Model of Attention and Multi-Label Classification
Authors:
André F. T. Martins,
Ramón Fernandez Astudillo
Abstract:
We propose sparsemax, a new activation function similar to the traditional softmax, but able to output sparse probabilities. After deriving its properties, we show how its Jacobian can be efficiently computed, enabling its use in a network trained with backpropagation. Then, we propose a new smooth and convex loss function which is the sparsemax analogue of the logistic loss. We reveal an unexpect…
▽ More
We propose sparsemax, a new activation function similar to the traditional softmax, but able to output sparse probabilities. After deriving its properties, we show how its Jacobian can be efficiently computed, enabling its use in a network trained with backpropagation. Then, we propose a new smooth and convex loss function which is the sparsemax analogue of the logistic loss. We reveal an unexpected connection between this new loss and the Huber classification loss. We obtain promising empirical results in multi-label classification problems and in attention-based neural networks for natural language inference. For the latter, we achieve a similar performance as the traditional softmax, but with a selective, more compact, attention focus.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2016; v1 submitted 5 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Online Multiple Kernel Learning for Structured Prediction
Authors:
Andre F. T. Martins,
Mario A. T. Figueiredo,
Pedro M. Q. Aguiar,
Noah A. Smith,
Eric P. Xing
Abstract:
Despite the recent progress towards efficient multiple kernel learning (MKL), the structured output case remains an open research front. Current approaches involve repeatedly solving a batch learning problem, which makes them inadequate for large scale scenarios. We propose a new family of online proximal algorithms for MKL (as well as for group-lasso and variants thereof), which overcomes that dr…
▽ More
Despite the recent progress towards efficient multiple kernel learning (MKL), the structured output case remains an open research front. Current approaches involve repeatedly solving a batch learning problem, which makes them inadequate for large scale scenarios. We propose a new family of online proximal algorithms for MKL (as well as for group-lasso and variants thereof), which overcomes that drawback. We show regret, convergence, and generalization bounds for the proposed method. Experiments on handwriting recognition and dependency parsing testify for the successfulness of the approach.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2010;
originally announced October 2010.