-
Simulating Relational Event Histories: Why and How
Authors:
Rumana Lakdawala,
Joris Mulder,
Roger Leenders
Abstract:
Many important social phenomena are characterized by repeated interactions among individuals over time such as email exchanges in an organization or face-to-face interactions in a classroom. To understand the underlying mechanisms of social interaction dynamics, statistical simulation techniques of longitudinal network data on a fine temporal granularity are crucially important. This paper makes t…
▽ More
Many important social phenomena are characterized by repeated interactions among individuals over time such as email exchanges in an organization or face-to-face interactions in a classroom. To understand the underlying mechanisms of social interaction dynamics, statistical simulation techniques of longitudinal network data on a fine temporal granularity are crucially important. This paper makes two contributions to the field. First, we present statistical frameworks to simulate relational event networks under dyadic and actor-oriented relational event models which are implemented in a new R package 'remulate'. Second, we explain how the simulation framework can be used to address challenging problems in temporal social network analysis, such as model fit assessment, theory building, network intervention planning, making predictions, understanding the impact of network structures, to name a few. This is shown in three extensive case studies. In the first study, it is elaborated why simulation-based techniques are crucial for relational event model assessment which is illustrated for a network of criminal gangs. In the second study, it is shown how simulation techniques are important when building and extending theories about social phenomena which is illustrated via optimal distinctiveness theory. In the third study, we demonstrate how simulation techniques contribute to a better understanding of the longevity and the potential effect sizes of network interventions. Through these case studies and software, researchers will be able to better understand social interaction dynamics using relational event data from real-life networks.
△ Less
Submitted 8 January, 2025; v1 submitted 28 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
A Bayesian actor-oriented multilevel relational event model with hypothesis testing procedures
Authors:
Fabio Vieira,
Roger Leenders,
Daniel McFarland,
Joris Mulder
Abstract:
Relational event network data are becoming increasingly available. Consequently, statistical models for such data have also surfaced. These models mainly focus on the analysis of single networks, while in many applications, multiple independent event sequences are observed, which are likely to display similar social interaction dynamics. Furthermore, statistical methods for testing hypotheses abou…
▽ More
Relational event network data are becoming increasingly available. Consequently, statistical models for such data have also surfaced. These models mainly focus on the analysis of single networks, while in many applications, multiple independent event sequences are observed, which are likely to display similar social interaction dynamics. Furthermore, statistical methods for testing hypotheses about social interaction behavior are underdeveloped. Therefore, the contribution of the current paper is twofold. First, we present a multilevel extension of the dynamic actor-oriented model, which allows researchers to model sender and receiver processes separately. The multilevel formulation enables principled probabilistic borrowing of information across networks to accurately estimate drivers of social dynamics. Second, a flexible methodology is proposed to test hypotheses about common and heterogeneous social interaction drivers across relational event sequences. Social interaction data between children and teachers in classrooms are used to showcase the methodology.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2023; v1 submitted 22 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Separating the Wheat from the Chaff: Bayesian Regularization in Dynamic Social Networks
Authors:
Diana Karimova,
Joris Mulder,
Roger Th. A. J. Leenders
Abstract:
In recent years there has been an increasing interest in the use of relational event models for dynamic social network analysis. The basis of these models is the concept of an "event", defined as a triplet of time, sender, and receiver of some social interaction. The key question that relational event models aim to answer is what drives social interactions among actors. Researchers often consider…
▽ More
In recent years there has been an increasing interest in the use of relational event models for dynamic social network analysis. The basis of these models is the concept of an "event", defined as a triplet of time, sender, and receiver of some social interaction. The key question that relational event models aim to answer is what drives social interactions among actors. Researchers often consider a very large number of predictors in their studies (including exogenous variables, endogenous network effects, and various interaction effects). The problem is however that employing an excessive number of effects may lead to model overfitting and inflated Type-I error rates. Consequently, the fitted model can easily become overly complex and the implied social interaction behavior becomes difficult to interpret. A potential solution to this problem is to apply Bayesian regularization using shrinkage priors. In this paper, we propose Bayesian regularization methods for relational event models using four different priors: a flat prior model with no shrinkage effect, a ridge estimator with a normal prior, a Bayesian lasso with a Laplace prior, and a horseshoe estimator with a numerically constructed prior that has an asymptote at zero. We develop and use these models for both an actor-oriented relational event model and a dyad-oriented relational event model. We show how to apply Bayesian regularization methods for these models and provide insights about which method works best and guidelines how to apply them in practice. Our results show that shrinkage priors can reduce Type-I errors while keeping reasonably high predictive performance and yielding parsimonious models to explain social network behavior.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
A Bayesian semi-parametric approach for modeling memory decay in dynamic social networks
Authors:
Giuseppe Arena,
Joris Mulder,
Roger Th. A. J. Leenders
Abstract:
In relational event networks, the tendency for actors to interact with each other depends greatly on the past interactions between the actors in a social network. Both the quantity of past interactions and the time that elapsed since the past interactions occurred affect the actors' decision-making to interact with other actors in the network. Recently occurred events generally have a stronger inf…
▽ More
In relational event networks, the tendency for actors to interact with each other depends greatly on the past interactions between the actors in a social network. Both the quantity of past interactions and the time that elapsed since the past interactions occurred affect the actors' decision-making to interact with other actors in the network. Recently occurred events generally have a stronger influence on current interaction behavior than past events that occurred a long time ago--a phenomenon known as "memory decay". Previous studies either predefined a short-run and long-run memory or fixed a parametric exponential memory using a predefined half-life period. In real-life relational event networks however it is generally unknown how the memory of actors about the past events fades as time goes by. For this reason it is not recommendable to fix this in an ad hoc manner, but instead we should learn the shape of memory decay from the observed data. In this paper, a novel semi-parametric approach based on Bayesian Model Averaging is proposed for learning the shape of the memory decay without requiring any parametric assumptions. The method is applied to relational event history data among socio-political actors in India.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Hamiltonian ABC
Authors:
Edward Meeds,
Robert Leenders,
Max Welling
Abstract:
Approximate Bayesian computation (ABC) is a powerful and elegant framework for performing inference in simulation-based models. However, due to the difficulty in scaling likelihood estimates, ABC remains useful for relatively low-dimensional problems. We introduce Hamiltonian ABC (HABC), a set of likelihood-free algorithms that apply recent advances in scaling Bayesian learning using Hamiltonian M…
▽ More
Approximate Bayesian computation (ABC) is a powerful and elegant framework for performing inference in simulation-based models. However, due to the difficulty in scaling likelihood estimates, ABC remains useful for relatively low-dimensional problems. We introduce Hamiltonian ABC (HABC), a set of likelihood-free algorithms that apply recent advances in scaling Bayesian learning using Hamiltonian Monte Carlo (HMC) and stochastic gradients. We find that a small number forward simulations can effectively approximate the ABC gradient, allowing Hamiltonian dynamics to efficiently traverse parameter spaces. We also describe a new simple yet general approach of incorporating random seeds into the state of the Markov chain, further reducing the random walk behavior of HABC. We demonstrate HABC on several typical ABC problems, and show that HABC samples comparably to regular Bayesian inference using true gradients on a high-dimensional problem from machine learning.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
