-
Adverse effects of vaccinations against the Corona-virus SARS-CoV-2: insights and hindsights from a statistical perspective
Authors:
Thomas Schmidt-Melchiors,
Jens-Peter Kreiss,
Alexander Braumann
Abstract:
Vaccinations against the virus SARS-CoV-2 have proven to be most effective against a severe corona disease. However, a significant minority of people is still critical of such a vaccination or even strictly reject it. One but surely not the only reason for this is the fear of undesired adverse effects. During the year 2021 in Germany alone approximately 150 million vaccination doses have been appl…
▽ More
Vaccinations against the virus SARS-CoV-2 have proven to be most effective against a severe corona disease. However, a significant minority of people is still critical of such a vaccination or even strictly reject it. One but surely not the only reason for this is the fear of undesired adverse effects. During the year 2021 in Germany alone approximately 150 million vaccination doses have been applied. This should be a solid basis to assess the risk of adverse effects of corona vaccinations. Based on publicly available data, especially from the German Federal Institute of Vaccines and Biomedicines (Paul-Ehrlich-Institut) and further scientific publications from Europe, Israel and the United States, this paper tries to give sound quantitative statements on the risk of (severe) adverse effects (e.g. myocarditis, thrombosis and thrombocytopenia, venous thrombosis, including cerebral venous sinus thrombosis and fatalities based thereon) of the various vaccination types, i.e. Comirnaty, Vaxzevria, Janssen and the Spikevax Covid-19 vaccine. The paper also describes some quite serious concerns about the lack of details in the publicly available data and the variations in the structure of reports from the primary source that prohibit even simple time series comparisons. However, from an overarching view all provided vaccines are pretty safe and fall mostly into the same frequency categories with respect to various clusters of undesired complications. Nevertheless there are statistically significant differences amongst the four vaccines which indicate that Vaxzevria is according to some important aspects only the second best preferable choice.
The paper aims to support a rational approach regarding the confidence in the widely available SARS-CoV-2 vaccines through a purely statistical investigation of the number of adverse effects in an unbiased manner.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Bootstrapping Whittle Estimators
Authors:
Jens-Peter Kreiss,
Efstathios Paparoditis
Abstract:
Fitting parametric models by optimizing frequency domain objective functions is an attractive approach of parameter estimation in time series analysis. Whittle estimators are a prominent example in this context. Under weak conditions and the (realistic) assumption that the true spectral density of the underlying process does not necessarily belong to the parametric class of spectral densities fitt…
▽ More
Fitting parametric models by optimizing frequency domain objective functions is an attractive approach of parameter estimation in time series analysis. Whittle estimators are a prominent example in this context. Under weak conditions and the (realistic) assumption that the true spectral density of the underlying process does not necessarily belong to the parametric class of spectral densities fitted, the distribution of Whittle estimators typically depends on difficult to estimate characteristics of the underlying process. This makes the implementation of asymptotic results for the construction of confidence intervals or for assessing the variability of estimators, difficult in practice. This paper proposes a frequency domain bootstrap method to estimate the distribution of Whittle estimators which is asymptotically valid under assumptions that not only allow for (possible) model misspecification but also for weak dependence conditions which are satisfied by a wide range of stationary stochastic processes. Adaptions of the bootstrap procedure developed to incorporate different modifications of Whittle estimators proposed in the literature, like for instance, tapered, de-biased or boundary extended Whittle estimators, are also considered. Simulations demonstrate the capabilities of the bootstrap method proposed and its good finite sample performance. A real-life data analysis also is presented.
△ Less
Submitted 23 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Estimation of the Distribution of the Individual Reproduction Number: The Case of the COVID-19 Pandemic
Authors:
Alexander Braumann,
Jonas Krampe,
Jens-Peter Kreiss,
Efstathios Paparoditis
Abstract:
We investigate the problem of estimating the distribution of the individual reproduction number governing the COVID-19 pandemic. Under the assumption that this random variable follows a Negative Binomial distribution, we focus on constructing estimators of the parameters of this distribution using reported infection data and taking into account issues like under-reporting or the time behavior of t…
▽ More
We investigate the problem of estimating the distribution of the individual reproduction number governing the COVID-19 pandemic. Under the assumption that this random variable follows a Negative Binomial distribution, we focus on constructing estimators of the parameters of this distribution using reported infection data and taking into account issues like under-reporting or the time behavior of the infection and of the reporting processes. To this end, we extract information from regionally dissaggregated data reported by German health authorities, in order to estimate not only the mean but also the variance of the distribution of the individual reproduction number. In contrast to the mean, the latter parameter also depends on the unknown under-reporting rate of the pandemic. The estimates obtained allow not only for a better understanding of the time-varying behavior of the expected value of the individual reproduction number but also of its dispersion, for the construction of bootstrap confidence intervals and for a discussion of the implications of different policy interventions. Our methodological investigations are accompanied by an empirical study of the development of the COVID-19 pandemic in Germany, which shows a strong overdispersion of the individual reproduction number.
△ Less
Submitted 19 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Bootstrap Based Inference for Sparse High-Dimensional Time Series Models
Authors:
J. Krampe,
J-P. Kreiss,
E. Paparoditis
Abstract:
Fitting sparse models to high-dimensional time series is an important area of statistical inference. In this paper we consider sparse vector autoregressive models and develop appropriate bootstrap methods to infer properties of such processes. Our bootstrap methodology generates pseudo time series using a model-based bootstrap procedure which involves an estimated, sparsified version of the underl…
▽ More
Fitting sparse models to high-dimensional time series is an important area of statistical inference. In this paper we consider sparse vector autoregressive models and develop appropriate bootstrap methods to infer properties of such processes. Our bootstrap methodology generates pseudo time series using a model-based bootstrap procedure which involves an estimated, sparsified version of the underlying vector autoregressive model. Inference is performed using so-called de-sparsified or de-biased estimators of the autoregressive model parameters. We derive the asymptotic distribution of such estimators in the time series context and establish asymptotic validity of the bootstrap procedure proposed for estimation and, appropriately modified, for testing purposes. In particular we focus on testing that large groups of autoregressive coefficients equal zero. Our theoretical results are complemented by simulations which investigate the finite sample performance of the bootstrap methodology proposed. A real-life data application is also presented.
△ Less
Submitted 24 September, 2019; v1 submitted 28 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
A Frequency Domain Bootstrap for General Stationary Processes
Authors:
Marco Meyer,
Efstathios Paparoditis,
Jens-Peter Kreiss
Abstract:
Existing frequency domain methods for bootstrapping time series have a limited range. Consider for instance the class of spectral mean statistics (also called integrated periodograms) which includes many important statistics in time series analysis, such as sample autocovariances and autocorrelations among other things. Essentially, such frequency domain bootstrap procedures cover the case of line…
▽ More
Existing frequency domain methods for bootstrapping time series have a limited range. Consider for instance the class of spectral mean statistics (also called integrated periodograms) which includes many important statistics in time series analysis, such as sample autocovariances and autocorrelations among other things. Essentially, such frequency domain bootstrap procedures cover the case of linear time series with independent innovations, and some even require the time series to be Gaussian. In this paper we propose a new, frequency domain bootstrap method which is consistent for a much wider range of stationary processes and can be applied to a large class of periodogram-based statistics. It introduces a new concept of convolved periodograms of smaller samples which uses pseudo periodograms of subsamples generated in a way that correctly imitates the weak dependence structure of the periodogram. %The new bootstrap procedure %corrects for those aspects of the distribution of spectral means that cannot be mimicked by existing procedures. We show consistency for this procedure for a general class of stationary time series, ranging clearly beyond linear processes, and for general spectral means and ratio statistics. Furthermore, and for the class of spectral means, we also show, how, using this new approach, existing bootstrap methods, which replicate appropriately only the dominant part of the distribution of interest, can be corrected. The finite sample performance of the new bootstrap procedure is illustrated via simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
