-
Causal KL: Evaluating Causal Discovery
Authors:
Rodney T. O'Donnell,
Kevin B. Korb,
Lloyd Allison
Abstract:
The two most commonly used criteria for assessing causal model discovery with artificial data are edit-distance and Kullback-Leibler divergence, measured from the true model to the learned model. Both of these metrics maximally reward the true model. However, we argue that they are both insufficiently discriminating in judging the relative merits of false models. Edit distance, for example, fails…
▽ More
The two most commonly used criteria for assessing causal model discovery with artificial data are edit-distance and Kullback-Leibler divergence, measured from the true model to the learned model. Both of these metrics maximally reward the true model. However, we argue that they are both insufficiently discriminating in judging the relative merits of false models. Edit distance, for example, fails to distinguish between strong and weak probabilistic dependencies. KL divergence, on the other hand, rewards equally all statistically equivalent models, regardless of their different causal claims. We propose an augmented KL divergence, which we call Causal KL (CKL), which takes into account causal relationships which distinguish between observationally equivalent models. Results are presented for three variants of CKL, showing that Causal KL works well in practice.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Markov Blanket Discovery using Minimum Message Length
Authors:
Yang Li,
Kevin B Korb,
Lloyd Allison
Abstract:
Causal discovery automates the learning of causal Bayesian networks from data and has been of active interest from their beginning. With the sourcing of large data sets off the internet, interest in scaling up to very large data sets has grown. One approach to this is to parallelize search using Markov Blanket (MB) discovery as a first step, followed by a process of combining MBs in a global causa…
▽ More
Causal discovery automates the learning of causal Bayesian networks from data and has been of active interest from their beginning. With the sourcing of large data sets off the internet, interest in scaling up to very large data sets has grown. One approach to this is to parallelize search using Markov Blanket (MB) discovery as a first step, followed by a process of combining MBs in a global causal model. We develop and explore three new methods of MB discovery using Minimum Message Length (MML) and compare them empirically to the best existing methods, whether developed specifically as MB discovery or as feature selection. Our best MML method is consistently competitive and has some advantageous features.
△ Less
Submitted 16 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Latent Variable Discovery Using Dependency Patterns
Authors:
Xuhui Zhang,
Kevin B. Korb,
Ann E. Nicholson,
Steven Mascaro
Abstract:
The causal discovery of Bayesian networks is an active and important research area, and it is based upon searching the space of causal models for those which can best explain a pattern of probabilistic dependencies shown in the data. However, some of those dependencies are generated by causal structures involving variables which have not been measured, i.e., latent variables. Some such patterns of…
▽ More
The causal discovery of Bayesian networks is an active and important research area, and it is based upon searching the space of causal models for those which can best explain a pattern of probabilistic dependencies shown in the data. However, some of those dependencies are generated by causal structures involving variables which have not been measured, i.e., latent variables. Some such patterns of dependency "reveal" themselves, in that no model based solely upon the observed variables can explain them as well as a model using a latent variable. That is what latent variable discovery is based upon. Here we did a search for finding them systematically, so that they may be applied in latent variable discovery in a more rigorous fashion.
△ Less
Submitted 22 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
Learning Bayesian Networks with Restricted Causal Interactions
Authors:
Julian R. Neil,
Chris S. Wallace,
Kevin B. Korb
Abstract:
A major problem for the learning of Bayesian networks (BNs) is the exponential number of parameters needed for conditional probability tables. Recent research reduces this complexity by modeling local structure in the probability tables. We examine the use of log-linear local models. While log-linear models in this context are not new (Whittaker, 1990; Buntine, 1991; Neal, 1992; Heckerman and M…
▽ More
A major problem for the learning of Bayesian networks (BNs) is the exponential number of parameters needed for conditional probability tables. Recent research reduces this complexity by modeling local structure in the probability tables. We examine the use of log-linear local models. While log-linear models in this context are not new (Whittaker, 1990; Buntine, 1991; Neal, 1992; Heckerman and Meek, 1997), for structure learning they are generally subsumed under a naive Bayes model. We describe an alternative interpretation, and use a Minimum Message Length (MML) (Wallace, 1987) metric for structure learning of networks exhibiting causal independence, which we term first-order networks (FONs). We also investigate local model selection on a node-by-node basis.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
