ROPE: high-dimensional network modeling with robust control of edge FDR
Authors:
Jonatan Kallus,
Jose Sanchez,
Alexandra Jauhiainen,
Sven Nelander,
Rebecka Jörnsten
Abstract:
Network modeling has become increasingly popular for analyzing genomic data, to aid in the interpretation and discovery of possible mechanistic components and therapeutic targets. However, genomic-scale networks are high-dimensional models and are usually estimated from a relatively small number of samples. Therefore, their usefulness is hampered by estimation instability. In addition, the complex…
▽ More
Network modeling has become increasingly popular for analyzing genomic data, to aid in the interpretation and discovery of possible mechanistic components and therapeutic targets. However, genomic-scale networks are high-dimensional models and are usually estimated from a relatively small number of samples. Therefore, their usefulness is hampered by estimation instability. In addition, the complexity of the models is controlled by one or more penalization (tuning) parameters where small changes to these can lead to vastly different networks, thus making interpretation of models difficult. This necessitates the development of techniques to produce robust network models accompanied by estimation quality assessments.
We introduce Resampling of Penalized Estimates (ROPE): a novel statistical method for robust network modeling. The method utilizes resampling-based network estimation and integrates results from several levels of penalization through a constrained, over-dispersed beta-binomial mixture model. ROPE provides robust False Discovery Rate (FDR) control of network estimates and each edge is assigned a measure of validity, the q-value, corresponding to the FDR-level for which the edge would be included in the network model. We apply ROPE to several simulated data sets as well as genomic data from The Cancer Genome Atlas. We show that ROPE outperforms state-of-the-art methods in terms of FDR control and robust performance across data sets. We illustrate how to use ROPE to make a principled model selection for which genomic associations to study further. ROPE is available as an R package on CRAN.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
Inferring Regulatory Networks by Combining Perturbation Screens and Steady State Gene Expression Profiles
Authors:
Ali Shojaie,
Alexandra Jauhiainen,
Michael Kallitsis,
George Michailidis
Abstract:
Reconstructing transcriptional regulatory networks is an important task in functional genomics. Data obtained from experiments that perturb genes by knockouts or RNA interference contain useful information for addressing this reconstruction problem. However, such data can be limited in size and/or are expensive to acquire. On the other hand, observational data of the organism in steady state (e.g.…
▽ More
Reconstructing transcriptional regulatory networks is an important task in functional genomics. Data obtained from experiments that perturb genes by knockouts or RNA interference contain useful information for addressing this reconstruction problem. However, such data can be limited in size and/or are expensive to acquire. On the other hand, observational data of the organism in steady state (e.g. wild-type) are more readily available, but their informational content is inadequate for the task at hand. We develop a computational approach to appropriately utilize both data sources for estimating a regulatory network. The proposed approach is based on a three-step algorithm to estimate the underlying directed but cyclic network, that uses as input both perturbation screens and steady state gene expression data. In the first step, the algorithm determines causal orderings of the genes that are consistent with the perturbation data, by combining an exhaustive search method with a fast heuristic that in turn couples a Monte Carlo technique with a fast search algorithm. In the second step, for each obtained causal ordering, a regulatory network is estimated using a penalized likelihood based method, while in the third step a consensus network is constructed from the highest scored ones. Extensive computational experiments show that the algorithm performs well in reconstructing the underlying network and clearly outperforms competing approaches that rely only on a single data source. Further, it is established that the algorithm produces a consistent estimate of the regulatory network.
△ Less
Submitted 2 December, 2013;
originally announced December 2013.
