-
Inference in Gaussian state-space models with mixed effects for multiple epidemic dynamics
Authors:
Romain Narci,
Maud Delattre,
Catherine Larédo,
Elisabeta Vergu
Abstract:
The estimation from available data of parameters governing epidemics is a major challenge. In addition to usual issues (data often incomplete and noisy), epidemics of the same nature may be observed in several places or over different periods. The resulting possible inter-epidemic variability is rarely explicitly considered. Here, we propose to tackle multiple epidemics through a unique model inco…
▽ More
The estimation from available data of parameters governing epidemics is a major challenge. In addition to usual issues (data often incomplete and noisy), epidemics of the same nature may be observed in several places or over different periods. The resulting possible inter-epidemic variability is rarely explicitly considered. Here, we propose to tackle multiple epidemics through a unique model incorporating a stochastic representation for each epidemic and to jointly estimate its parameters from noisy and partial observations. By building on a previous work, a Gaussian state-space model is extended to a model with mixed effects on the parameters describing simultaneously several epidemics and their observation process. An appropriate inference method is developed, by coupling the SAEM algorithm with Kalman-type filtering. Its performances are investigated on SIR simulated data. Our method outperforms an inference method separately processing each dataset. An application to SEIR influenza outbreaks in France over several years using incidence data is also carried out, by proposing a new version of the filtering algorithm. Parameter estimations highlight a non-negligible variability between influenza seasons, both in transmission and case reporting. The main contribution of our study is to rigorously and explicitly account for the inter-epidemic variability between multiple outbreaks, both from the viewpoint of modeling and inference.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Inference for partially observed epidemic dynamics guided by Kalman filtering techniques
Authors:
Romain Narci,
Maud Delattre,
Catherine Larédo,
Elisabeta Vergu
Abstract:
Despite the recent development of methods dealing with partially observed epidemic dynamics (unobserved model coordinates, discrete and noisy outbreak data), limitations remain in practice, mainly related to the quantity of augmented data and calibration of numerous tuning parameters. In particular, as coordinates of dynamic epidemic models are coupled, the presence of unobserved coordinates leads…
▽ More
Despite the recent development of methods dealing with partially observed epidemic dynamics (unobserved model coordinates, discrete and noisy outbreak data), limitations remain in practice, mainly related to the quantity of augmented data and calibration of numerous tuning parameters. In particular, as coordinates of dynamic epidemic models are coupled, the presence of unobserved coordinates leads to a statistically difficult problem. The aim is to propose an easy-to-use and general inference method that is able to tackle these issues. First, using the properties of epidemics in large populations, a two-layer model is constructed. Via a diffusion-based approach, a Gaussian approximation of the epidemic density-dependent Markovian jump process is obtained, representing the state model. The observational model, consisting of noisy observations of certain model coordinates, is approximated by Gaussian distributions. Then, an inference method based on an approximate likelihood using Kalman filtering recursion is developed to estimate parameters of both the state and observational models. The performance of estimators of key model parameters is assessed on simulated data of SIR epidemic dynamics for different scenarios with respect to the population size and the number of observations. This performance is compared with that obtained using the well-known maximum iterated filtering method. Finally, the inference method is applied to a real data set on an influenza outbreak in a British boarding school in 1978.
△ Less
Submitted 23 July, 2021; v1 submitted 17 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Estimating Fisher Information Matrix in Latent Variable Models based on the Score Function
Authors:
Maud Delattre,
Estelle Kuhn
Abstract:
The Fisher information matrix (FIM) is a key quantity in statistics as it is required for example for evaluating asymptotic precisions of parameter estimates, for computing test statistics or asymptotic distributions in statistical testing, for evaluating post model selection inference results or optimality criteria in experimental designs. However its exact computation is often not trivial. In pa…
▽ More
The Fisher information matrix (FIM) is a key quantity in statistics as it is required for example for evaluating asymptotic precisions of parameter estimates, for computing test statistics or asymptotic distributions in statistical testing, for evaluating post model selection inference results or optimality criteria in experimental designs. However its exact computation is often not trivial. In particular in many latent variable models, it is intricated due to the presence of unobserved variables. Therefore the observed FIM is usually considered in this context to estimate the FIM. Several methods have been proposed to approximate the observed FIM when it can not be evaluated analytically. Among the most frequently used approaches are Monte-Carlo methods or iterative algorithms derived from the missing information principle. All these methods require to compute second derivatives of the complete data log-likelihood which leads to some disadvantages from a computational point of view. In this paper, we present a new approach to estimate the FIM in latent variable model. The advantage of our method is that only the first derivatives of the log-likelihood is needed, contrary to other approaches based on the observed FIM. Indeed we consider the empirical estimate of the covariance matrix of the score. We prove that this estimate of the Fisher information matrix is unbiased, consistent and asymptotically Gaussian. Moreover we highlight that none of both estimates is better than the other in terms of asymptotic covariance matrix. When the proposed estimate can not be directly analytically evaluated, we present a stochastic approximation estimation algorithm to compute it. This algorithm provides this estimate of the FIM as a by-product of the parameter estimates. We emphasize that the proposed algorithm only requires to compute the first derivatives of the complete data log-likelihood with respect to the parameters. We prove that the estimation algorithm is consistent and asymptotically Gaussian when the number of iterations goes to infinity. We evaluate the finite sample size properties of the proposed estimate and of the observed FIM through simulation studies in linear mixed effects models and mixture models. We also investigate the convergence properties of the estimation algorithm in non linear mixed effects models. We compare the performances of the proposed algorithm to those of other existing methods.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 2023; v1 submitted 13 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
An iterative algorithm for joint covariate and random effect selection in mixed effects models
Authors:
Maud Delattre,
Marie-Anne Poursat
Abstract:
We consider joint selection of fixed and random effects in general mixed-effects models. The interpretation of estimated mixed-effects models is challenging since changing the structure of one set of effects can lead to different choices of important covariates in the model. We propose a stepwise selection algorithm to perform simultaneous selection of the fixed and random effects. It is based on…
▽ More
We consider joint selection of fixed and random effects in general mixed-effects models. The interpretation of estimated mixed-effects models is challenging since changing the structure of one set of effects can lead to different choices of important covariates in the model. We propose a stepwise selection algorithm to perform simultaneous selection of the fixed and random effects. It is based on BIC-type criteria whose penalties are adapted to mixed-effects models. The proposed procedure performs model selection in both linear and nonlinear models. It should be used in the low-dimension setting where the number of covariates and the number of random effects are moderate with respect to the total number of observations. The performance of the algorithm is assessed via a simulation study, that includes also a comparative study with alternatives when available in the literature. The use of the method is illustrated in the clinical study of an antibiotic agent kinetics.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2020; v1 submitted 7 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.