Collective Reasoning Among LLMs: A Framework for Answer Validation Without Ground Truth
Authors:
Seyed Pouyan Mousavi Davoudi,
Amin Gholami Davodi,
Alireza Amiri-Margavi,
Mahdi Jafari
Abstract:
We introduce a new approach in which several advanced large language models-specifically GPT-4-0125-preview, Meta-LLAMA-3-70B-Instruct, Claude-3-Opus, and Gemini-1.5-Flash-collaborate to both produce and answer intricate, doctoral-level probability problems without relying on any single "correct" reference. Rather than depending on an established ground truth, our investigation focuses on how agre…
▽ More
We introduce a new approach in which several advanced large language models-specifically GPT-4-0125-preview, Meta-LLAMA-3-70B-Instruct, Claude-3-Opus, and Gemini-1.5-Flash-collaborate to both produce and answer intricate, doctoral-level probability problems without relying on any single "correct" reference. Rather than depending on an established ground truth, our investigation focuses on how agreement among diverse models can signal the reliability of their outputs and, by extension, reflect the overall quality of the generated questions. To measure this inter-model alignment, we apply a suite of statistical evaluations, including chi-square tests, Fleiss' Kappa coefficients, and confidence interval calculations, thereby capturing both precision in answers and clarity in question phrasing. Our analysis reveals that Claude and Gemini tend to frame questions more coherently and unambiguously, which is evidenced by their tighter confidence intervals and greater concordance with responding agents. In contrast, LLAMA exhibits wider confidence bands and a lower level of agreement, indicating more variability and reduced consistency in its question formulations. These observations support the notion that a multi-model collaborative strategy not only improves answer dependability but also offers an effective, data-driven mechanism for evaluating and refining question quality when no definitive solution exists. Ultimately, this work delivers actionable insights into enhancing AI-guided reasoning processes through coordinated interactions among heterogeneous language models.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2025; v1 submitted 28 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
ForestDSH: A Universal Hash Design for Discrete Probability Distributions
Authors:
Arash Gholami Davoodi,
Sean Chang,
Hyun Gon Yoo,
Anubhav Baweja,
Mihir Mongia,
Hosein Mohimani
Abstract:
In this paper, we consider the problem of classification of $M$ high dimensional queries $y^1,\cdots,y^M\in B^S$ to $N$ high dimensional classes $x^1,\cdots,x^N\in A^S$ where $A$ and $B$ are discrete alphabets and the probabilistic model that relates data to the classes $P(x,y)$ is known. This problem has applications in various fields including the database search problem in mass spectrometry. Th…
▽ More
In this paper, we consider the problem of classification of $M$ high dimensional queries $y^1,\cdots,y^M\in B^S$ to $N$ high dimensional classes $x^1,\cdots,x^N\in A^S$ where $A$ and $B$ are discrete alphabets and the probabilistic model that relates data to the classes $P(x,y)$ is known. This problem has applications in various fields including the database search problem in mass spectrometry. The problem is analogous to the nearest neighbor search problem, where the goal is to find the data point in a database that is the most similar to a query point. The state of the art method for solving an approximate version of the nearest neighbor search problem in high dimensions is locality sensitive hashing (LSH). LSH is based on designing hash functions that map near points to the same buckets with a probability higher than random (far) points. To solve our high dimensional classification problem, we introduce distribution sensitive hashes that map jointly generated pairs $(x,y)\sim P$ to the same bucket with probability higher than random pairs $x\sim P^A$ and $y\sim P^B$, where $P^A$ and $P^B$ are the marginal probability distributions of $P$. We design distribution sensitive hashes using a forest of decision trees and we show that the complexity of search grows with $O(N^{λ^*(P)})$ where $λ^*(P)$ is expressed in an analytical form. We further show that the proposed hashes perform faster than state of the art approximate nearest neighbor search methods for a range of probability distributions, in both theory and simulations. Finally, we apply our method to the spectral library search problem in mass spectrometry, and show that it is an order of magnitude faster than the state of the art methods.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2020; v1 submitted 11 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.