-
The analysis of paired comparison data in the presence of cyclicality and intransitivity
Authors:
Rahul Singh,
Ori Davidov
Abstract:
A principled approach to cyclicality and intransitivity in cardinal paired comparison data is developed within the framework of graphical linear models. Fundamental to our developments is a detailed understanding and study of the parameter space which accommodates cyclicality and intransitivity. In particular, the relationships between the reduced, completely transitive model, the full, not necess…
▽ More
A principled approach to cyclicality and intransitivity in cardinal paired comparison data is developed within the framework of graphical linear models. Fundamental to our developments is a detailed understanding and study of the parameter space which accommodates cyclicality and intransitivity. In particular, the relationships between the reduced, completely transitive model, the full, not necessarily transitive model, and all manner of intermediate models are explored for both complete and incomplete paired comparison graphs. It is shown that identifying cyclicality and intransitivity reduces to a model selection problem and a new method for model selection employing geometrical insights, unique to the problem at hand, is proposed. The large sample properties of the estimators as well as guarantees on the selected model are provided. It is thus shown that in large samples all cyclicalities and intransitivities can be identified. The method is exemplified using simulations and the analysis of an illustrative example.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Least squares for cardinal paired comparisons data
Authors:
Rahul Singh,
George Iliopoulos,
Ori Davidov
Abstract:
Least square estimators for graphical models for cardinal paired comparison data with and without covariates are rigorously analyzed. Novel, graph--based, necessary and sufficient conditions that guarantee strong consistency, asymptotic normality and the exponential convergence of the estimated ranks are emphasized. A complete theory for models with covariates is laid out. In particular, condition…
▽ More
Least square estimators for graphical models for cardinal paired comparison data with and without covariates are rigorously analyzed. Novel, graph--based, necessary and sufficient conditions that guarantee strong consistency, asymptotic normality and the exponential convergence of the estimated ranks are emphasized. A complete theory for models with covariates is laid out. In particular, conditions under which covariates can be safely omitted from the model are provided. The methodology is employed in the analysis of both finite and infinite sets of ranked items where the case of large sparse comparison graphs is addressed. The proposed methods are explored by simulation and applied to the ranking of teams in the National Basketball Association (NBA).
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2025; v1 submitted 13 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
On the use of historical estimates
Authors:
Ori Davidov,
Tamas Rudas
Abstract:
The use of historical estimates in current studies is common in a wide variety of application areas. Nevertheless, despite their routine use the uncertainty associated with historical estimates is rarely properly accounted for in the analysis. In this communication we review common practices and then provide a mathematical formulation and a principled methodology for addressing the problem of draw…
▽ More
The use of historical estimates in current studies is common in a wide variety of application areas. Nevertheless, despite their routine use the uncertainty associated with historical estimates is rarely properly accounted for in the analysis. In this communication we review common practices and then provide a mathematical formulation and a principled methodology for addressing the problem of drawing inferences in the presence of historical data. Three distinct variants are investigated in detail; the corresponding limiting distributions are found and compared. The design of future studies, given historical data, is also explored and relations with a variety of other well--studied statistical problems discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Analysis of High Dimensional Compositional Data Containing Structural Zeros with Applications to Microbiome Data
Authors:
Abhishek Kaul,
Ori Davidov,
Shyamal D. Peddada
Abstract:
This paper is motivated by the recent interest in the analysis of high dimen- sional microbiome data. A key feature of this data is the presence of `structural zeros' which are microbes missing from an observation vector due to an underlying biological process and not due to error in measurement. Typical notions of missingness are insufficient to model these structural zeros. We define a general f…
▽ More
This paper is motivated by the recent interest in the analysis of high dimen- sional microbiome data. A key feature of this data is the presence of `structural zeros' which are microbes missing from an observation vector due to an underlying biological process and not due to error in measurement. Typical notions of missingness are insufficient to model these structural zeros. We define a general framework which allows for structural zeros in the model and propose methods of estimating sparse high dimensional covariance and precision matrices under this setup. We establish error bounds in the spectral and frobenius norms for the proposed esti- mators and empirically support them with a simulation study. We also apply the proposed methodology to the global human gut microbiome data of Yatsunenko (2012).
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
