-
Extrapolation of Relative Treatment Effects using Change-point Survival Models
Authors:
Philip Cooney,
Arthur White
Abstract:
Introduction: Modelling of relative treatment effects is an important aspect to consider when extrapolating the long-term survival outcomes of treatments. Flexible parametric models offer the ability to accurately model the observed data, however, the extrapolated relative treatment effects and subsequent survival function may lack face validity. Methods: We investigate the ability of change-point…
▽ More
Introduction: Modelling of relative treatment effects is an important aspect to consider when extrapolating the long-term survival outcomes of treatments. Flexible parametric models offer the ability to accurately model the observed data, however, the extrapolated relative treatment effects and subsequent survival function may lack face validity. Methods: We investigate the ability of change-point survival models to estimate changes in the relative treatment effects, specifically treatment delay, loss of treatment effects and converging hazards. These models are implemented using standard Bayesian statistical software and propagate the uncertainty associate with all model parameters including the change-point location. A simulation study was conducted to assess the predictive performance of these models compared with other parametric survival models. Change-point survival models were applied to three datasets, two of which were used in previous health technology assessments. Results: Change-point survival models typically provided improved extrapolated survival predictions, particularly when the changes in relative treatment effects are large. When applied to the real world examples they provided good fit to the observed data while and in some situations produced more clinically plausible extrapolations than those generated by flexible spline models. Change-point models also provided support to a previously implemented modelling approach which was justified by visual inspection only and not goodness of fit to the observed data. Conclusions: We believe change-point survival models offer the ability to flexibly model observed data while also modelling and investigating clinically plausible scenarios with respect to the relative treatment effects.
△ Less
Submitted 31 December, 2023;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Incorporating Expert Opinion on Observable Quantities into Statistical Models -- A General Framework
Authors:
Philip Cooney,
Arthur White
Abstract:
This article describes an approach to incorporate expert opinion on observable quantities through the use of a loss function which updates a prior belief as opposed to specifying parameters on the priors. Eliciting information on observable quantities allows experts to provide meaningful information on a quantity familiar to them, in contrast to elicitation on model parameters, which may be subjec…
▽ More
This article describes an approach to incorporate expert opinion on observable quantities through the use of a loss function which updates a prior belief as opposed to specifying parameters on the priors. Eliciting information on observable quantities allows experts to provide meaningful information on a quantity familiar to them, in contrast to elicitation on model parameters, which may be subject to interactions with other parameters or non-linear transformations before obtaining an observable quantity. The approach to incorporating expert opinion described in this paper is distinctive in that we do not specify a prior to match an expert's opinion on observed quantity, rather we obtain a posterior by updating the model parameters through a loss function. This loss function contains the observable quantity, expressed a function of the parameters, and is related to the expert's opinion which is typically operationalized as a statistical distribution. Parameters which generate observable quantities which are further from the expert's opinion incur a higher loss, allowing for the model parameters to be estimated based on their fidelity to both the data and expert opinion, with the relative strength determined by the number of observations and precision of the elicited belief. Including expert opinion in this fashion allows for a flexible specification of the opinion and in many situations is straightforward to implement with commonly used probabilistic programming software. We highlight this using three worked examples of varying model complexity including survival models, a multivariate normal distribution and a regression problem.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Change-point Detection for Piecewise Exponential Models
Authors:
Philip Cooney,
Arthur White
Abstract:
In decision modelling with time to event data, parametric models are often used to extrapolate the survivor function. One such model is the piecewise exponential model whereby the hazard function is partitioned into segments, with the hazard constant within the segment and independent between segments and the boundaries of these segments are known as change-points. We present an approach for deter…
▽ More
In decision modelling with time to event data, parametric models are often used to extrapolate the survivor function. One such model is the piecewise exponential model whereby the hazard function is partitioned into segments, with the hazard constant within the segment and independent between segments and the boundaries of these segments are known as change-points. We present an approach for determining the location and number of change-points in piecewise exponential models. Inference is performed in a Bayesian framework using Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) where the model parameters can be integrated out of the model and the number of change-points can be sampled as part of the MCMC scheme. We can estimate both the uncertainty in the change-point locations and hazards for a given change-point model and obtain a probabilistic interpretation for the number of change-points. We evaluate model performance to determine changepoint numbers and locations in a simulation study and show the utility of the method using two data sets for time to event data. In a dataset of Glioblastoma patients we use the piecewise exponential model to describe the general trends in the hazard function. In a data set of heart transplant patients, we show the piecewise exponential model produces the best statistical fit and extrapolation amongst other standard parametric models. Piecewise exponential models may be useful for survival extrapolation if a long-term constant hazard trend is clinically plausible. A key advantage of this method is that the number and change-point locations are automatically estimated rather than specified by the analyst.
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Utilizing Expert Opinion to inform Extrapolation of Survival Models
Authors:
Philip Cooney,
Arthur White
Abstract:
In decision modelling with time to event data, there are a variety of parametric models which could be used to extrapolate the survivor function. Each of these implies a different hazard function and in situations where there is moderate censoring, they can result in quite different extrapolations. Expert opinion on the long-term survival or other quantities could reduce model uncertainty. We pres…
▽ More
In decision modelling with time to event data, there are a variety of parametric models which could be used to extrapolate the survivor function. Each of these implies a different hazard function and in situations where there is moderate censoring, they can result in quite different extrapolations. Expert opinion on the long-term survival or other quantities could reduce model uncertainty. We present a general and easily implementable approach for including a variety of types of expert opinions. Expert opinion is incorporated by penalizing the likelihood function. Inference is performed in a Bayesian framework, however, this approach can also be implemented using frequentist methods. The issue of aggregating pooling expert opinions is also considered and included in the analysis. We validate the method against a previously published approach and include a worked example of this method. This work highlights that expert opinions can be implemented in a straightforward manner using this approach, however, more work is required on the correct elicitation of these quantities.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
