-
Inverse Bayesian Optimization: Learning Human Acquisition Functions in an Exploration vs Exploitation Search Task
Authors:
Nathan Sandholtz,
Yohsuke Miyamoto,
Luke Bornn,
Maurice Smith
Abstract:
This paper introduces a probabilistic framework to estimate parameters of an acquisition function given observed human behavior that can be modeled as a collection of sample paths from a Bayesian optimization procedure. The methodology involves defining a likelihood on observed human behavior from an optimization task, where the likelihood is parameterized by a Bayesian optimization subroutine gov…
▽ More
This paper introduces a probabilistic framework to estimate parameters of an acquisition function given observed human behavior that can be modeled as a collection of sample paths from a Bayesian optimization procedure. The methodology involves defining a likelihood on observed human behavior from an optimization task, where the likelihood is parameterized by a Bayesian optimization subroutine governed by an unknown acquisition function. This structure enables us to make inference on a subject's acquisition function while allowing their behavior to deviate around the solution to the Bayesian optimization subroutine. To test our methods, we designed a sequential optimization task which forced subjects to balance exploration and exploitation in search of an invisible target location. Applying our proposed methods to the resulting data, we find that many subjects tend to exhibit exploration preferences beyond that of standard acquisition functions to capture. Guided by the model discrepancies, we augment the candidate acquisition functions to yield a superior fit to the human behavior in this task.
△ Less
Submitted 2 February, 2022; v1 submitted 16 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Estimating locomotor demands during team play from broadcast-derived tracking data
Authors:
Jacob Mortensen,
Luke Bornn
Abstract:
The introduction of optical tracking data across sports has given rise to the ability to dissect athletic performance at a level unfathomable a decade ago. One specific area that has seen substantial benefit is sports science, as high resolution coordinate data permits sports scientists to have to-the-second estimates of external load metrics, such as acceleration load and high speed running dista…
▽ More
The introduction of optical tracking data across sports has given rise to the ability to dissect athletic performance at a level unfathomable a decade ago. One specific area that has seen substantial benefit is sports science, as high resolution coordinate data permits sports scientists to have to-the-second estimates of external load metrics, such as acceleration load and high speed running distance, traditionally used to understand the physical toll a game takes on an athlete. Unfortunately, collecting this data requires installation of expensive hardware and paying costly licensing fees to data providers, restricting its availability. Algorithms have been developed that allow a traditional broadcast feed to be converted to x-y coordinate data, making tracking data easier to acquire, but coordinates are available for an athlete only when that player is within the camera frame. Obviously, this leads to inaccuracies in player load estimates, limiting the usefulness of this data for sports scientists. In this research, we develop models that predict offscreen load metrics and demonstrate the viability of broadcast-derived tracking data for understanding external load in soccer.
△ Less
Submitted 21 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Measuring Spatial Allocative Efficiency in Basketball
Authors:
Nathan Sandholtz,
Jacob Mortensen,
Luke Bornn
Abstract:
Every shot in basketball has an opportunity cost; one player's shot eliminates all potential opportunities from their teammates for that play. For this reason, player-shot efficiency should ultimately be considered relative to the lineup. This aspect of efficiency---the optimal way to allocate shots within a lineup---is the focus of our paper. Allocative efficiency should be considered in a spatia…
▽ More
Every shot in basketball has an opportunity cost; one player's shot eliminates all potential opportunities from their teammates for that play. For this reason, player-shot efficiency should ultimately be considered relative to the lineup. This aspect of efficiency---the optimal way to allocate shots within a lineup---is the focus of our paper. Allocative efficiency should be considered in a spatial context since the distribution of shot attempts within a lineup is highly dependent on court location. We propose a new metric for spatial allocative efficiency by comparing a player's field goal percentage (FG%) to their field goal attempt (FGA) rate in context of both their four teammates on the court and the spatial distribution of their shots. Leveraging publicly available data provided by the National Basketball Association (NBA), we estimate player FG% at every location in the offensive half court using a Bayesian hierarchical model. Then, by ordering a lineup's estimated FG%s and pairing these rankings with the lineup's empirical FGA rate rankings, we detect areas where the lineup exhibits inefficient shot allocation. Lastly, we analyze the impact that sub-optimal shot allocation has on a team's overall offensive potential, demonstrating that inefficient shot allocation correlates with reduced scoring.
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 2020; v1 submitted 11 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Home Sweet Home: Quantifying Home Court Advantages For NCAA Basketball Statistics
Authors:
Matthew van Bommel,
Luke Bornn,
Peter Chow-White,
Chuancong Gao
Abstract:
Box score statistics are the baseline measures of performance for National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) basketball. Between the 2011-2012 and 2015-2016 seasons, NCAA teams performed better at home compared to on the road in nearly all box score statistics across both genders and all three divisions. Using box score data from over 100,000 games spanning the three divisions for both women…
▽ More
Box score statistics are the baseline measures of performance for National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) basketball. Between the 2011-2012 and 2015-2016 seasons, NCAA teams performed better at home compared to on the road in nearly all box score statistics across both genders and all three divisions. Using box score data from over 100,000 games spanning the three divisions for both women and men, we examine the factors underlying this discrepancy. The prevalence of neutral location games in the NCAA provides an additional angle through which to examine the gaps in box score statistic performance, which we believe has been underutilized in existing literature. We also estimate a regression model to quantify the home court advantages for box score statistics after controlling for other factors such as number of possessions, and team strength. Additionally, we examine the biases of scorekeepers and referees. We present evidence that scorekeepers tend to have greater home team biases when observing men compared to women, higher divisions compared to lower divisions, and stronger teams compared to weaker teams. Finally, we present statistically significant results indicating referee decisions are impacted by attendance, with larger crowds resulting in greater bias in favor of the home team.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2021; v1 submitted 10 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Using In-Game Shot Trajectories to Better Understand Defensive Impact in the NBA
Authors:
Luke Bornn,
Daniel Daly-Grafstein
Abstract:
As 3-point shooting in the NBA continues to increase, the importance of perimeter defense has never been greater. Perimeter defenders are often evaluated by their ability to tightly contest shots, but how exactly does contesting a jump shot cause a decrease in expected shooting percentage, and can we use this insight to better assess perimeter defender ability? In this paper we analyze over 50,000…
▽ More
As 3-point shooting in the NBA continues to increase, the importance of perimeter defense has never been greater. Perimeter defenders are often evaluated by their ability to tightly contest shots, but how exactly does contesting a jump shot cause a decrease in expected shooting percentage, and can we use this insight to better assess perimeter defender ability? In this paper we analyze over 50,000 shot trajectories from the NBA to explain why, in terms of impact on shot trajectories, shooters tend to miss more when tightly contested. We present a variety of results derived from this shot trajectory data. Additionally, pairing trajectory data with features such as defender height, distance, and contest angle, we are able to evaluate not just perimeter defenders, but also shooters' resilience to defensive pressure. Utilizing shot trajectories and corresponding modeled shot-make probabilities, we are able to create perimeter defensive metrics that are more accurate and less variable than traditional metrics like opponent field goal percentage.
△ Less
Submitted 2 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Winning Is Not Everything: A contextual analysis of hockey face-offs
Authors:
Nick Czuzoj-Shulman,
David Yu,
Christopher Boucher,
Luke Bornn,
Mehrsan Javan
Abstract:
This paper takes a different approach to evaluating face-offs in ice hockey. Instead of looking at win percentages, the de facto measure of successful face-off takers for decades, focuses on the game events following the face-off and how directionality, clean wins, and player handedness play a significant role in creating value. This will demonstrate how not all face-off wins are made equal: some…
▽ More
This paper takes a different approach to evaluating face-offs in ice hockey. Instead of looking at win percentages, the de facto measure of successful face-off takers for decades, focuses on the game events following the face-off and how directionality, clean wins, and player handedness play a significant role in creating value. This will demonstrate how not all face-off wins are made equal: some players consistently create post-face-off value through clean wins and by directing the puck to high-value areas of the ice. As a result, we propose an expected events face-off model as well as a wins above expected model that take into account the value added on a face-off by targeting the puck to specific areas on the ice in various contexts, as well as the impact this has on subsequent game events.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Playing Fast Not Loose: Evaluating team-level pace of play in ice hockey using spatio-temporal possession data
Authors:
David Yu,
Christopher Boucher,
Luke Bornn,
Mehrsan Javan
Abstract:
Pace of play is an important characteristic in hockey as well as other team sports. We provide the first comprehensive study of pace within the sport of hockey, focusing on how teams and players impact pace in different regions of the ice, and the resultant effect on other aspects of the game.
First we examined how pace of play varies across the surface of the rink, across different periods, at…
▽ More
Pace of play is an important characteristic in hockey as well as other team sports. We provide the first comprehensive study of pace within the sport of hockey, focusing on how teams and players impact pace in different regions of the ice, and the resultant effect on other aspects of the game.
First we examined how pace of play varies across the surface of the rink, across different periods, at different manpower situations, between different professional leagues, and through time between seasons. Our analysis of pace by zone helps to explain some of the counter-intuitive results reported in prior studies. For instance, we show that the negative correlation between attacking speed and shots/goals is likely due to a large decline in attacking speed in the OZ.
We also studied how pace impacts the outcomes of various events. We found that pace is positively-correlated with both high-danger zone entries (e.g. odd-man rushes) and higher shot quality. However, we find that passes with failed receptions occur at higher speeds than successful receptions. These findings suggest that increased pace is beneficial, but perhaps only up to a certain extent. Higher pace can create breakdowns in defensive structure and lead to better scoring chances but can also lead to more turnovers.
Finally, we analyzed team and player-level pace in the NHL, highlighting the considerable variability in how teams and players attack and defend against pace. Taken together, our results demonstrate that measures of team-level pace derived from spatio-temporal data are informative metrics in hockey and should prove useful in other team sports.
△ Less
Submitted 5 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Markov Decision Processes with Dynamic Transition Probabilities: An Analysis of Shooting Strategies in Basketball
Authors:
Nathan Sandholtz,
Luke Bornn
Abstract:
In this paper we model basketball plays as episodes from team-specific non-stationary Markov decision processes (MDPs) with shot clock dependent transition probabilities. Bayesian hierarchical models are employed in the modeling and parametrization of the transition probabilities to borrow strength across players and through time. To enable computational feasibility, we combine lineup-specific MDP…
▽ More
In this paper we model basketball plays as episodes from team-specific non-stationary Markov decision processes (MDPs) with shot clock dependent transition probabilities. Bayesian hierarchical models are employed in the modeling and parametrization of the transition probabilities to borrow strength across players and through time. To enable computational feasibility, we combine lineup-specific MDPs into team-average MDPs using a novel transition weighting scheme. Specifically, we derive the dynamics of the team-average process such that the expected transition count for an arbitrary state-pair is equal to the weighted sum of the expected counts of the separate lineup-specific MDPs.
We then utilize these non-stationary MDPs in the creation of a basketball play simulator with uncertainty propagated via posterior samples of the model components. After calibration, we simulate seasons both on-policy and under altered policies and explore the net changes in efficiency and production under the alternate policies. Additionally, we discuss the game-theoretic ramifications of testing alternative decision policies.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2020; v1 submitted 12 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Rao-Blackwellizing Field Goal Percentage
Authors:
Daniel Daly-Grafstein,
Luke Bornn
Abstract:
Shooting skill in the NBA is typically measured by field goal percentage (FG%) - the number of makes out of the total number of shots. Even more advanced metrics like true shooting percentage are calculated by counting each player's 2-point, 3-point, and free throw makes and misses, ignoring the spatiotemporal data now available (Kubatko et al. 2007). In this paper we aim to better characterize pl…
▽ More
Shooting skill in the NBA is typically measured by field goal percentage (FG%) - the number of makes out of the total number of shots. Even more advanced metrics like true shooting percentage are calculated by counting each player's 2-point, 3-point, and free throw makes and misses, ignoring the spatiotemporal data now available (Kubatko et al. 2007). In this paper we aim to better characterize player shooting skill by introducing a new estimator based on post-shot release shot-make probabilities. Via the Rao-Blackwell theorem, we propose a shot-make probability model that conditions probability estimates on shot trajectory information, thereby reducing the variance of the new estimator relative to standard FG%. We obtain shooting information by using optical tracking data to estimate three factors for each shot: entry angle, shot depth, and left-right accuracy. Next we use these factors to model shot-make probabilities for all shots in the 2014-15 season, and use these probabilities to produce a Rao-Blackwellized FG% estimator (RB-FG%) for each player. We demonstrate that RB-FG% is better than raw FG% at predicting 3-point shooting and true-shooting percentages. Overall, we find that conditioning shot-make probabilities on spatial trajectory information stabilizes inference of FG%, creating the potential to estimate shooting statistics earlier in a season than was previously possible.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2018; v1 submitted 14 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
A Bayesian Nonparametric Approach to Geographic Regression Discontinuity Designs: Do School Districts Affect NYC House Prices?
Authors:
Maxime Rischard,
Zach Branson,
Luke Miratrix,
Luke Bornn
Abstract:
Most research on regression discontinuity designs (RDDs) has focused on univariate cases, where only those units with a "forcing" variable on one side of a threshold value receive a treatment. Geographical regression discontinuity designs (GeoRDDs) extend the RDD to multivariate settings with spatial forcing variables. We propose a framework for analysing GeoRDDs, which we implement using Gaussian…
▽ More
Most research on regression discontinuity designs (RDDs) has focused on univariate cases, where only those units with a "forcing" variable on one side of a threshold value receive a treatment. Geographical regression discontinuity designs (GeoRDDs) extend the RDD to multivariate settings with spatial forcing variables. We propose a framework for analysing GeoRDDs, which we implement using Gaussian process regression. This yields a Bayesian posterior distribution of the treatment effect at every point along the border. We address nuances of having a functional estimand defind on a border with potentially intricate topology, particularly when defining and estimating causal estimands of the local average treatment effect (LATE). The Bayesian estimate of the LATE can also be used as a test statistic in a hypothesis test with good frequentist properties, which we validate using simulations and placebo tests. We demonstrate our methodology with a dataset of property sales in New York City, to assess whether there is a discontinuity in housing prices at the border between two school district. We find a statistically significant difference in price across the border between the districts with $p$=0.002, and estimate a 20% higher price on average for a house on the more desirable side.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
A Nonparametric Bayesian Methodology for Regression Discontinuity Designs
Authors:
Zach Branson,
Maxime Rischard,
Luke Bornn,
Luke Miratrix
Abstract:
One of the most popular methodologies for estimating the average treatment effect at the threshold in a regression discontinuity design is local linear regression (LLR), which places larger weight on units closer to the threshold. We propose a Gaussian process regression methodology that acts as a Bayesian analog to LLR for regression discontinuity designs. Our methodology provides a flexible fit…
▽ More
One of the most popular methodologies for estimating the average treatment effect at the threshold in a regression discontinuity design is local linear regression (LLR), which places larger weight on units closer to the threshold. We propose a Gaussian process regression methodology that acts as a Bayesian analog to LLR for regression discontinuity designs. Our methodology provides a flexible fit for treatment and control responses by placing a general prior on the mean response functions. Furthermore, unlike LLR, our methodology can incorporate uncertainty in how units are weighted when estimating the treatment effect. We prove our method is consistent in estimating the average treatment effect at the threshold. Furthermore, we find via simulation that our method exhibits promising coverage, interval length, and mean squared error properties compared to standard LLR and state-of-the-art LLR methodologies. Finally, we explore the performance of our method on a real-world example by studying the impact of being a first-round draft pick on the performance and playing time of basketball players in the National Basketball Association.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2018; v1 submitted 16 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
Meta-Analytics: Tools for Understanding the Statistical Properties of Sports Metrics
Authors:
Alexander Franks,
Alexander D'Amour,
Daniel Cervone,
Luke Bornn
Abstract:
In sports, there is a constant effort to improve metrics which assess player ability, but there has been almost no effort to quantify and compare existing metrics. Any individual making a management, coaching, or gambling decision is quickly overwhelmed with hundreds of statistics. We address this problem by proposing a set of "meta-metrics" which can be used to identify the metrics that provide t…
▽ More
In sports, there is a constant effort to improve metrics which assess player ability, but there has been almost no effort to quantify and compare existing metrics. Any individual making a management, coaching, or gambling decision is quickly overwhelmed with hundreds of statistics. We address this problem by proposing a set of "meta-metrics" which can be used to identify the metrics that provide the most unique, reliable, and useful information for decision-makers. Specifically, we develop methods to evalute metrics based on three criteria: 1) stability: does the metric measure the same thing over time 2) discrimination: does the metric differentiate between players and 3) independence: does the metric provide new information? Our methods are easy to implement and widely applicable so they should be of interest to the broader sports community. We demonstrate our methods in analyses of both NBA and NHL metrics. Our results indicate the most reliable metrics and highlight how they should be used by sports analysts. The meta-metrics also provide useful insights about how to best construct new metrics which provide independent and reliable information about athletes.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Nonparametric hierarchical Bayesian quantiles
Authors:
Luke Bornn,
Neil Shephard,
Reza Solgi
Abstract:
Here we develop a method for performing nonparametric Bayesian inference on quantiles. Relying on geometric measure theory and employing a Hausdorff base measure, we are able to specify meaningful priors for the quantile while treating the distribution of the data otherwise nonparametrically. We further extend the method to a hierarchical model for quantiles of subpopulations, linking subgroups to…
▽ More
Here we develop a method for performing nonparametric Bayesian inference on quantiles. Relying on geometric measure theory and employing a Hausdorff base measure, we are able to specify meaningful priors for the quantile while treating the distribution of the data otherwise nonparametrically. We further extend the method to a hierarchical model for quantiles of subpopulations, linking subgroups together solely through their quantiles. Our approach is computationally straightforward, allowing for censored and noisy data. We demonstrate the proposed methodology on simulated data and an applied problem from sports statistics, where it is observed to stabilize and improve inference and prediction.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Adjusting for Scorekeeper Bias in NBA Box Scores
Authors:
Matthew van Bommel,
Luke Bornn
Abstract:
Box score statistics in the National Basketball Association are used to measure and evaluate player performance. Some of these statistics are subjective in nature and since box score statistics are recorded by scorekeepers hired by the home team for each game, there exists potential for inconsistency and bias. These inconsistencies can have far reaching consequences, particularly with the rise in…
▽ More
Box score statistics in the National Basketball Association are used to measure and evaluate player performance. Some of these statistics are subjective in nature and since box score statistics are recorded by scorekeepers hired by the home team for each game, there exists potential for inconsistency and bias. These inconsistencies can have far reaching consequences, particularly with the rise in popularity of daily fantasy sports. Using box score data, we estimate models able to quantify both the bias and the generosity of each scorekeeper for two of the most subjective statistics: assists and blocks. We then use optical player tracking data for the 2014-2015 season to improve the assist model by including other contextual spatio-temporal variables such as time of possession, player locations, and distance traveled. From this model, we present results measuring the impact of the scorekeeper and of the other contextual variables on the probability of a pass being recorded as an assist. Results for adjusting season assist totals to remove scorekeeper influence are also presented.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2016; v1 submitted 28 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Convergence Results for a Class of Time-Varying Simulated Annealing Algorithms
Authors:
Mathieu Gerber,
Luke Bornn
Abstract:
We provide a set of conditions which ensure the almost sure convergence of a class of simulated annealing algorithms on a bounded set $\mathcal{X}\subset\mathbb{R}^d$ based on a time-varying Markov kernel. The class of algorithms considered in this work encompasses the one studied in Belisle (1992) and Yang (2000) as well as its derandomized version recently proposed by Gerber and Bornn (2016). To…
▽ More
We provide a set of conditions which ensure the almost sure convergence of a class of simulated annealing algorithms on a bounded set $\mathcal{X}\subset\mathbb{R}^d$ based on a time-varying Markov kernel. The class of algorithms considered in this work encompasses the one studied in Belisle (1992) and Yang (2000) as well as its derandomized version recently proposed by Gerber and Bornn (2016). To the best of our knowledge, the results we derive are the first examples of almost sure convergence results for simulated annealing based on a time-varying kernel. In addition, the assumptions on the Markov kernel and on the cooling schedule have the advantage of being trivial to verify in practice.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2017; v1 submitted 23 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
Moment conditions and Bayesian nonparametrics
Authors:
Luke Bornn,
Neil Shephard,
Reza Solgi
Abstract:
Models phrased though moment conditions are central to much of modern inference. Here these moment conditions are embedded within a nonparametric Bayesian setup. Handling such a model is not probabilistically straightforward as the posterior has support on a manifold. We solve the relevant issues, building new probability and computational tools using Hausdorff measures to analyze them on real and…
▽ More
Models phrased though moment conditions are central to much of modern inference. Here these moment conditions are embedded within a nonparametric Bayesian setup. Handling such a model is not probabilistically straightforward as the posterior has support on a manifold. We solve the relevant issues, building new probability and computational tools using Hausdorff measures to analyze them on real and simulated data. These new methods which involve simulating on a manifold can be applied widely, including providing Bayesian analysis of quasi-likelihoods, linear and nonlinear regression, missing data and hierarchical models.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2016; v1 submitted 30 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
FastGP: An R Package for Gaussian Processes
Authors:
Giri Gopalan,
Luke Bornn
Abstract:
Despite their promise and ubiquity, Gaussian processes (GPs) can be difficult to use in practice due to the computational impediments of fitting and sampling from them. Here we discuss a short R package for efficient multivariate normal functions which uses the Rcpp and RcppEigen packages at its core. GPs have properties that allow standard functions to be sped up; as an example we include functio…
▽ More
Despite their promise and ubiquity, Gaussian processes (GPs) can be difficult to use in practice due to the computational impediments of fitting and sampling from them. Here we discuss a short R package for efficient multivariate normal functions which uses the Rcpp and RcppEigen packages at its core. GPs have properties that allow standard functions to be sped up; as an example we include functionality for Toeplitz matrices whose inverse can be computed in O(n^2) time with methods due to Trench and Durbin (Golub & Van Loan 1996), which is particularly apt when time points (or spatial locations) of a Gaussian process are evenly spaced, since the associated covariance matrix is Toeplitz in this case. Additionally, we include functionality to sample from a latent variable Gaussian process model with elliptical slice sampling (Murray, Adams, & MacKay 2010).
△ Less
Submitted 22 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
Classifying X-ray Binaries: A Probabilistic Approach
Authors:
Giri Gopalan,
Saeqa Dil Vrtilek,
Luke Bornn
Abstract:
In X-ray binary star systems consisting of a compact object that accretes material from an orbiting secondary star, there is no straightforward means to decide if the compact object is a black hole or a neutron star. To assist this classification, we develop a Bayesian statistical model that makes use of the fact that X-ray binary systems appear to cluster based on their compact object type when v…
▽ More
In X-ray binary star systems consisting of a compact object that accretes material from an orbiting secondary star, there is no straightforward means to decide if the compact object is a black hole or a neutron star. To assist this classification, we develop a Bayesian statistical model that makes use of the fact that X-ray binary systems appear to cluster based on their compact object type when viewed from a 3-dimensional coordinate system derived from X-ray spectral data. The first coordinate of this data is the ratio of counts in mid to low energy band (color 1), the second coordinate is the ratio of counts in high to low energy band (color 2), and the third coordinate is the sum of counts in all three bands. We use this model to estimate the probabilities that an X-ray binary system contains a black hole, non-pulsing neutron star, or pulsing neutron star. In particular, we utilize a latent variable model in which the latent variables follow a Gaussian process prior distribution, and hence we are able to induce the spatial correlation we believe exists between systems of the same type. The utility of this approach is evidenced by the accurate prediction of system types using Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer All Sky Monitor data, but it is not flawless. In particular, non-pulsing neutron systems containing "bursters" that are close to the boundary demarcating systems containing black holes tend to be classified as black hole systems. As a byproduct of our analyses, we provide the astronomer with public R code that can be used to predict the compact object type of X-ray binaries given training data.
△ Less
Submitted 17 August, 2018; v1 submitted 13 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
Improving Simulated Annealing through Derandomization
Authors:
Mathieu Gerber,
Luke Bornn
Abstract:
We propose and study a version of simulated annealing (SA) on continuous state spaces based on $(t,s)_R$-sequences. The parameter $R\in\bar{\mathbb{N}}$ regulates the degree of randomness of the input sequence, with the case $R=0$ corresponding to IID uniform random numbers and the limiting case $R=\infty$ to $(t,s)$-sequences. Our main result, obtained for rectangular domains, shows that the resu…
▽ More
We propose and study a version of simulated annealing (SA) on continuous state spaces based on $(t,s)_R$-sequences. The parameter $R\in\bar{\mathbb{N}}$ regulates the degree of randomness of the input sequence, with the case $R=0$ corresponding to IID uniform random numbers and the limiting case $R=\infty$ to $(t,s)$-sequences. Our main result, obtained for rectangular domains, shows that the resulting optimization method, which we refer to as QMC-SA, converges almost surely to the global optimum of the objective function $\varphi$ for any $R\in\mathbb{N}$. When $\varphi$ is univariate, we are in addition able to show that the completely deterministic version of QMC-SA is convergent. A key property of these results is that they do not require objective-dependent conditions on the cooling schedule. As a corollary of our theoretical analysis, we provide a new almost sure convergence result for SA which shares this property under minimal assumptions on $\varphi$. We further explain how our results in fact apply to a broader class of optimization methods including for example threshold accepting, for which to our knowledge no convergence results currently exist. We finally illustrate the superiority of QMC-SA over SA algorithms in a numerical study.
△ Less
Submitted 5 September, 2016; v1 submitted 12 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Fast and optimal nonparametric sequential design for astronomical observations
Authors:
Justin J. Yang,
Xufei Wang,
Pavlos Protopapas,
Luke Bornn
Abstract:
The spectral energy distribution (SED) is a relatively easy way for astronomers to distinguish between different astronomical objects such as galaxies, black holes, and stellar objects. By comparing the observations from a source at different frequencies with template models, astronomers are able to infer the type of this observed object. In this paper, we take a Bayesian model averaging perspecti…
▽ More
The spectral energy distribution (SED) is a relatively easy way for astronomers to distinguish between different astronomical objects such as galaxies, black holes, and stellar objects. By comparing the observations from a source at different frequencies with template models, astronomers are able to infer the type of this observed object. In this paper, we take a Bayesian model averaging perspective to learn astronomical objects, employing a Bayesian nonparametric approach to accommodate the deviation from convex combinations of known log-SEDs. To effectively use telescope time for observations, we then study Bayesian nonparametric sequential experimental design without conjugacy, in which we use sequential Monte Carlo as an efficient tool to maximize the volume of information stored in the posterior distribution of the parameters of interest. A new technique for performing inferences in log-Gaussian Cox processes called the Poisson log-normal approximation is also proposed. Simulations show the speed, accuracy, and usefulness of our method. While the strategy we propose in this paper is brand new in the astronomy literature, the inferential techniques developed apply to more general nonparametric sequential experimental design problems.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
-
Diversifying Sparsity Using Variational Determinantal Point Processes
Authors:
Nematollah Kayhan Batmanghelich,
Gerald Quon,
Alex Kulesza,
Manolis Kellis,
Polina Golland,
Luke Bornn
Abstract:
We propose a novel diverse feature selection method based on determinantal point processes (DPPs). Our model enables one to flexibly define diversity based on the covariance of features (similar to orthogonal matching pursuit) or alternatively based on side information. We introduce our approach in the context of Bayesian sparse regression, employing a DPP as a variational approximation to the tru…
▽ More
We propose a novel diverse feature selection method based on determinantal point processes (DPPs). Our model enables one to flexibly define diversity based on the covariance of features (similar to orthogonal matching pursuit) or alternatively based on side information. We introduce our approach in the context of Bayesian sparse regression, employing a DPP as a variational approximation to the true spike and slab posterior distribution. We subsequently show how this variational DPP approximation generalizes and extends mean-field approximation, and can be learned efficiently by exploiting the fast sampling properties of DPPs. Our motivating application comes from bioinformatics, where we aim to identify a diverse set of genes whose expression profiles predict a tumor type where the diversity is defined with respect to a gene-gene interaction network. We also explore an application in spatial statistics. In both cases, we demonstrate that the proposed method yields significantly more diverse feature sets than classic sparse methods, without compromising accuracy.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
-
A Multiresolution Stochastic Process Model for Predicting Basketball Possession Outcomes
Authors:
Daniel Cervone,
Alex D'Amour,
Luke Bornn,
Kirk Goldsberry
Abstract:
Basketball games evolve continuously in space and time as players constantly interact with their teammates, the opposing team, and the ball. However, current analyses of basketball outcomes rely on discretized summaries of the game that reduce such interactions to tallies of points, assists, and similar events. In this paper, we propose a framework for using optical player tracking data to estimat…
▽ More
Basketball games evolve continuously in space and time as players constantly interact with their teammates, the opposing team, and the ball. However, current analyses of basketball outcomes rely on discretized summaries of the game that reduce such interactions to tallies of points, assists, and similar events. In this paper, we propose a framework for using optical player tracking data to estimate, in real time, the expected number of points obtained by the end of a possession. This quantity, called \textit{expected possession value} (EPV), derives from a stochastic process model for the evolution of a basketball possession; we model this process at multiple levels of resolution, differentiating between continuous, infinitesimal movements of players, and discrete events such as shot attempts and turnovers. Transition kernels are estimated using hierarchical spatiotemporal models that share information across players while remaining computationally tractable on very large data sets. In addition to estimating EPV, these models reveal novel insights on players' decision-making tendencies as a function of their spatial strategy.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2016; v1 submitted 4 August, 2014;
originally announced August 2014.
-
Characterizing the spatial structure of defensive skill in professional basketball
Authors:
Alexander Franks,
Andrew Miller,
Luke Bornn,
Kirk Goldsberry
Abstract:
Although basketball is a dualistic sport, with all players competing on both offense and defense, almost all of the sport's conventional metrics are designed to summarize offensive play. As a result, player valuations are largely based on offensive performances and to a much lesser degree on defensive ones. Steals, blocks and defensive rebounds provide only a limited summary of defensive effective…
▽ More
Although basketball is a dualistic sport, with all players competing on both offense and defense, almost all of the sport's conventional metrics are designed to summarize offensive play. As a result, player valuations are largely based on offensive performances and to a much lesser degree on defensive ones. Steals, blocks and defensive rebounds provide only a limited summary of defensive effectiveness, yet they persist because they summarize salient events that are easy to observe. Due to the inefficacy of traditional defensive statistics, the state of the art in defensive analytics remains qualitative, based on expert intuition and analysis that can be prone to human biases and imprecision. Fortunately, emerging optical player tracking systems have the potential to enable a richer quantitative characterization of basketball performance, particularly defensive performance. Unfortunately, due to computational and methodological complexities, that potential remains unmet. This paper attempts to fill this void, combining spatial and spatio-temporal processes, matrix factorization techniques and hierarchical regression models with player tracking data to advance the state of defensive analytics in the NBA. Our approach detects, characterizes and quantifies multiple aspects of defensive play in basketball, supporting some common understandings of defensive effectiveness, challenging others and opening up many new insights into the defensive elements of basketball.
△ Less
Submitted 28 May, 2015; v1 submitted 1 May, 2014;
originally announced May 2014.
-
The Use of a Single Pseudo-Sample in Approximate Bayesian Computation
Authors:
Luke Bornn,
Natesh Pillai,
Aaron Smith,
Dawn Woodard
Abstract:
We analyze the computational efficiency of approximate Bayesian computation (ABC), which approximates a likelihood function by drawing pseudo-samples from the associated model. For the rejection sampling version of ABC, it is known that multiple pseudo-samples cannot substantially increase (and can substantially decrease) the efficiency of the algorithm as compared to employing a high-variance est…
▽ More
We analyze the computational efficiency of approximate Bayesian computation (ABC), which approximates a likelihood function by drawing pseudo-samples from the associated model. For the rejection sampling version of ABC, it is known that multiple pseudo-samples cannot substantially increase (and can substantially decrease) the efficiency of the algorithm as compared to employing a high-variance estimate based on a single pseudo-sample. We show that this conclusion also holds for a Markov chain Monte Carlo version of ABC, implying that it is unnecessary to tune the number of pseudo-samples used in ABC-MCMC. This conclusion is in contrast to particle MCMC methods, for which increasing the number of particles can provide large gains in computational efficiency.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2016; v1 submitted 24 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Factorized Point Process Intensities: A Spatial Analysis of Professional Basketball
Authors:
Andrew Miller,
Luke Bornn,
Ryan Adams,
Kirk Goldsberry
Abstract:
We develop a machine learning approach to represent and analyze the underlying spatial structure that governs shot selection among professional basketball players in the NBA. Typically, NBA players are discussed and compared in an heuristic, imprecise manner that relies on unmeasured intuitions about player behavior. This makes it difficult to draw comparisons between players and make accurate pla…
▽ More
We develop a machine learning approach to represent and analyze the underlying spatial structure that governs shot selection among professional basketball players in the NBA. Typically, NBA players are discussed and compared in an heuristic, imprecise manner that relies on unmeasured intuitions about player behavior. This makes it difficult to draw comparisons between players and make accurate player specific predictions. Modeling shot attempt data as a point process, we create a low dimensional representation of offensive player types in the NBA. Using non-negative matrix factorization (NMF), an unsupervised dimensionality reduction technique, we show that a low-rank spatial decomposition summarizes the shooting habits of NBA players. The spatial representations discovered by the algorithm correspond to intuitive descriptions of NBA player types, and can be used to model other spatial effects, such as shooting accuracy.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2014; v1 submitted 5 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
-
Sequential Monte Carlo Bandits
Authors:
Michael Cherkassky,
Luke Bornn
Abstract:
In this paper we propose a flexible and efficient framework for handling multi-armed bandits, combining sequential Monte Carlo algorithms with hierarchical Bayesian modeling techniques. The framework naturally encompasses restless bandits, contextual bandits, and other bandit variants under a single inferential model. Despite the model's generality, we propose efficient Monte Carlo algorithms to m…
▽ More
In this paper we propose a flexible and efficient framework for handling multi-armed bandits, combining sequential Monte Carlo algorithms with hierarchical Bayesian modeling techniques. The framework naturally encompasses restless bandits, contextual bandits, and other bandit variants under a single inferential model. Despite the model's generality, we propose efficient Monte Carlo algorithms to make inference scalable, based on recent developments in sequential Monte Carlo methods. Through two simulation studies, the framework is shown to outperform other empirical methods, while also naturally scaling to more complex problems for which existing approaches can not cope. Additionally, we successfully apply our framework to online video-based advertising recommendation, and show its increased efficacy as compared to current state of the art bandit algorithms.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
PAWL-Forced Simulated Tempering
Authors:
Luke Bornn
Abstract:
In this short note, we show how the parallel adaptive Wang-Landau (PAWL) algorithm of Bornn et al. (2013) can be used to automate and improve simulated tempering algorithms. While Wang-Landau and other stochastic approximation methods have frequently been applied within the simulated tempering framework, this note demonstrates through a simple example the additional improvements brought about by p…
▽ More
In this short note, we show how the parallel adaptive Wang-Landau (PAWL) algorithm of Bornn et al. (2013) can be used to automate and improve simulated tempering algorithms. While Wang-Landau and other stochastic approximation methods have frequently been applied within the simulated tempering framework, this note demonstrates through a simple example the additional improvements brought about by parallelization, adaptive proposals and automated bin splitting.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
Herded Gibbs Sampling
Authors:
Luke Bornn,
Yutian Chen,
Nando de Freitas,
Mareija Eskelin,
Jing Fang,
Max Welling
Abstract:
The Gibbs sampler is one of the most popular algorithms for inference in statistical models. In this paper, we introduce a herding variant of this algorithm, called herded Gibbs, that is entirely deterministic. We prove that herded Gibbs has an $O(1/T)$ convergence rate for models with independent variables and for fully connected probabilistic graphical models. Herded Gibbs is shown to outperform…
▽ More
The Gibbs sampler is one of the most popular algorithms for inference in statistical models. In this paper, we introduce a herding variant of this algorithm, called herded Gibbs, that is entirely deterministic. We prove that herded Gibbs has an $O(1/T)$ convergence rate for models with independent variables and for fully connected probabilistic graphical models. Herded Gibbs is shown to outperform Gibbs in the tasks of image denoising with MRFs and named entity recognition with CRFs. However, the convergence for herded Gibbs for sparsely connected probabilistic graphical models is still an open problem.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2013; v1 submitted 17 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
Forecasting with Historical Data or Process Knowledge under Misspecification: A Comparison
Authors:
Luke Bornn,
Marian Anghel,
Ingo Steinwart
Abstract:
When faced with the task of forecasting a dynamic system, practitioners often have available historical data, knowledge of the system, or a combination of both. While intuition dictates that perfect knowledge of the system should in theory yield perfect forecasting, often knowledge of the system is only partially known, known up to parameters, or known incorrectly. In contrast, forecasting using p…
▽ More
When faced with the task of forecasting a dynamic system, practitioners often have available historical data, knowledge of the system, or a combination of both. While intuition dictates that perfect knowledge of the system should in theory yield perfect forecasting, often knowledge of the system is only partially known, known up to parameters, or known incorrectly. In contrast, forecasting using previous data without any process knowledge might result in accurate prediction for simple systems, but will fail for highly nonlinear and chaotic systems. In this paper, the authors demonstrate how even in chaotic systems, forecasting with historical data is preferable to using process knowledge if this knowledge exhibits certain forms of misspecification. Through an extensive simulation study, a range of misspecification and forecasting scenarios are examined with the goal of gaining an improved understanding of the circumstances under which forecasting from historical data is to be preferred over using process knowledge.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2012;
originally announced May 2012.
-
Sparsity-Promoting Bayesian Dynamic Linear Models
Authors:
François Caron,
Luke Bornn,
Arnaud Doucet
Abstract:
Sparsity-promoting priors have become increasingly popular over recent years due to an increased number of regression and classification applications involving a large number of predictors. In time series applications where observations are collected over time, it is often unrealistic to assume that the underlying sparsity pattern is fixed. We propose here an original class of flexible Bayesian li…
▽ More
Sparsity-promoting priors have become increasingly popular over recent years due to an increased number of regression and classification applications involving a large number of predictors. In time series applications where observations are collected over time, it is often unrealistic to assume that the underlying sparsity pattern is fixed. We propose here an original class of flexible Bayesian linear models for dynamic sparsity modelling. The proposed class of models expands upon the existing Bayesian literature on sparse regression using generalized multivariate hyperbolic distributions. The properties of the models are explored through both analytic results and simulation studies. We demonstrate the model on a financial application where it is shown that it accurately represents the patterns seen in the analysis of stock and derivative data, and is able to detect major events by filtering an artificial portfolio of assets.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2012;
originally announced March 2012.
-
An Adaptive Interacting Wang-Landau Algorithm for Automatic Density Exploration
Authors:
Luke Bornn,
Pierre Jacob,
Pierre Del Moral,
Arnaud Doucet
Abstract:
While statisticians are well-accustomed to performing exploratory analysis in the modeling stage of an analysis, the notion of conducting preliminary general-purpose exploratory analysis in the Monte Carlo stage (or more generally, the model-fitting stage) of an analysis is an area which we feel deserves much further attention. Towards this aim, this paper proposes a general-purpose algorithm for…
▽ More
While statisticians are well-accustomed to performing exploratory analysis in the modeling stage of an analysis, the notion of conducting preliminary general-purpose exploratory analysis in the Monte Carlo stage (or more generally, the model-fitting stage) of an analysis is an area which we feel deserves much further attention. Towards this aim, this paper proposes a general-purpose algorithm for automatic density exploration. The proposed exploration algorithm combines and expands upon components from various adaptive Markov chain Monte Carlo methods, with the Wang-Landau algorithm at its heart. Additionally, the algorithm is run on interacting parallel chains -- a feature which both decreases computational cost as well as stabilizes the algorithm, improving its ability to explore the density. Performance is studied in several applications. Through a Bayesian variable selection example, the authors demonstrate the convergence gains obtained with interacting chains. The ability of the algorithm's adaptive proposal to induce mode-jumping is illustrated through a trimodal density and a Bayesian mixture modeling application. Lastly, through a 2D Ising model, the authors demonstrate the ability of the algorithm to overcome the high correlations encountered in spatial models.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2012; v1 submitted 17 September, 2011;
originally announced September 2011.
-
Modeling Non-Stationary Processes Through Dimension Expansion
Authors:
Luke Bornn,
Gavin Shaddick,
James V Zidek
Abstract:
In this paper, we propose a novel approach to modeling nonstationary spatial fields. The proposed method works by expanding the geographic plane over which these processes evolve into higher dimensional spaces, transforming and clarifying complex patterns in the physical plane. By combining aspects of multi-dimensional scaling, group lasso, and latent variables models, a dimensionally sparse proje…
▽ More
In this paper, we propose a novel approach to modeling nonstationary spatial fields. The proposed method works by expanding the geographic plane over which these processes evolve into higher dimensional spaces, transforming and clarifying complex patterns in the physical plane. By combining aspects of multi-dimensional scaling, group lasso, and latent variables models, a dimensionally sparse projection is found in which the originally nonstationary field exhibits stationarity. Following a comparison with existing methods in a simulated environment, dimension expansion is studied on a classic test-bed data set historically used to study nonstationary models. Following this, we explore the use of dimension expansion in modeling air pollution in the United Kingdom, a process known to be strongly influenced by rural/urban effects, amongst others, which gives rise to a nonstationary field.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2011; v1 submitted 10 November, 2010;
originally announced November 2010.
-
Discussion of "Riemann manifold Langevin and Hamiltonian Monte Carlo methods'' by M. Girolami and B. Calderhead
Authors:
Luke Bornn,
Julien Cornebise,
Gareth W. Peters
Abstract:
This technical report is the union of two contributions to the discussion of the Read Paper "Riemann manifold Langevin and Hamiltonian Monte Carlo methods" by B. Calderhead and M. Girolami, presented in front of the Royal Statistical Society on October 13th 2010 and to appear in the Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series B. The first comment establishes a parallel and possible interaction…
▽ More
This technical report is the union of two contributions to the discussion of the Read Paper "Riemann manifold Langevin and Hamiltonian Monte Carlo methods" by B. Calderhead and M. Girolami, presented in front of the Royal Statistical Society on October 13th 2010 and to appear in the Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series B. The first comment establishes a parallel and possible interactions with Adaptive Monte Carlo methods. The second comment exposes a detailed study of Riemannian Manifold Hamiltonian Monte Carlo (RMHMC) for a weakly identifiable model presenting a strong ridge in its geometry.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2010;
originally announced November 2010.
-
Bayesian clustering in decomposable graphs
Authors:
Luke Bornn,
François Caron
Abstract:
In this paper we propose a class of prior distributions on decomposable graphs, allowing for improved modeling flexibility. While existing methods solely penalize the number of edges, the proposed work empowers practitioners to control clustering, level of separation, and other features of the graph. Emphasis is placed on a particular prior distribution which derives its motivation from the class…
▽ More
In this paper we propose a class of prior distributions on decomposable graphs, allowing for improved modeling flexibility. While existing methods solely penalize the number of edges, the proposed work empowers practitioners to control clustering, level of separation, and other features of the graph. Emphasis is placed on a particular prior distribution which derives its motivation from the class of product partition models; the properties of this prior relative to existing priors is examined through theory and simulation. We then demonstrate the use of graphical models in the field of agriculture, showing how the proposed prior distribution alleviates the inflexibility of previous approaches in properly modeling the interactions between the yield of different crop varieties.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2012; v1 submitted 27 May, 2010;
originally announced May 2010.
-
Grouping Priors and the Bayesian Elastic Net
Authors:
Luke Bornn,
Raphael Gottardo,
Arnaud Doucet
Abstract:
In the literature surrounding Bayesian penalized regression, the two primary choices of prior distribution on the regression coefficients are zero-mean Gaussian and Laplace. While both have been compared numerically and theoretically, there remains little guidance on which to use in real-life situations. We propose two viable solutions to this problem in the form of prior distributions which com…
▽ More
In the literature surrounding Bayesian penalized regression, the two primary choices of prior distribution on the regression coefficients are zero-mean Gaussian and Laplace. While both have been compared numerically and theoretically, there remains little guidance on which to use in real-life situations. We propose two viable solutions to this problem in the form of prior distributions which combine and compromise between Laplace and Gaussian priors, respectively. Through cross-validation the prior which optimizes prediction performance is automatically selected. We then demonstrate the improved performance of these new prior distributions relative to Laplace and Gaussian priors in both a simulated and experimental environment.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2010;
originally announced January 2010.
