Showing 1–2 of 2 results for author: Barmomanesh, S
-
Toward Improving Predictive Risk Modelling for New Zealand's Child Welfare System Using Clustering Methods
Authors:
Sahar Barmomanesh,
Victor Miranda-Soberanis
Abstract:
The combination of clinical judgement and predictive risk models crucially assist social workers to segregate children at risk of maltreatment and decide when authorities should intervene. Predictive risk modelling to address this matter has been initiated by several governmental welfare authorities worldwide involving administrative data and machine learning algorithms. While previous studies hav…
▽ More
The combination of clinical judgement and predictive risk models crucially assist social workers to segregate children at risk of maltreatment and decide when authorities should intervene. Predictive risk modelling to address this matter has been initiated by several governmental welfare authorities worldwide involving administrative data and machine learning algorithms. While previous studies have investigated risk factors relating to child maltreatment, several gaps remain as to understanding how such risk factors interact and whether predictive risk models perform differently for children with different features. By integrating Principal Component Analysis and K-Means clustering, this paper presents initial findings of our work on the identification of such features as well as their potential effect on current risk modelling frameworks. This approach allows examining existent, unidentified yet, clusters of New Zealand (NZ) children reported with care and protection concerns, as well as to analyse their inner structure, and evaluate the performance of prediction models trained cluster wise. We aim to discover the extent of clustering degree required as an early step in the development of predictive risk models for child maltreatment and so enhance the accuracy of such models intended for use by child protection authorities. The results from testing LASSO logistic regression models trained on identified clusters revealed no significant difference in their performance. The models, however, performed slightly better for two clusters including younger children. our results suggest that separate models might need to be developed for children of certain age to gain additional control over the error rates and to improve model accuracy. While results are promising, more evidence is needed to draw definitive conclusions, and further investigation is necessary.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Potential Biased Outcomes on Child Welfare and Racial Minorities in New Zealand using Predictive Models: An Initial Review on Mitigation Approaches
Authors:
Sahar Barmomanesh,
Victor Miranda-Soberanis
Abstract:
Increasingly, the combination of clinical judgment and predictive risk modelling have been assisting social workers to segregate children at risk of maltreatment and recommend potential interventions of authorities. A critical concern among governments and research communities worldwide is that misinterpretations due to poor modelling techniques will often result in biased outcomes for people with…
▽ More
Increasingly, the combination of clinical judgment and predictive risk modelling have been assisting social workers to segregate children at risk of maltreatment and recommend potential interventions of authorities. A critical concern among governments and research communities worldwide is that misinterpretations due to poor modelling techniques will often result in biased outcomes for people with certain characteristics (e.g., race, socioeconomic status). In the New Zealand care and protection system, the over-representation of Māori might be incidentally intensified by predictive risk models leading to possible cycles of bias towards Māori, ending disadvantaged or discriminated against, in decision-making policies. Ensuring these models can identify the risk as accurately as possible and do not unintentionally add to an over-representation of Māori becomes a crucial matter. In this article we address this concern with the application of predictive risk modelling in the New Zealand care and protection system. We study potential factors that might impact the accuracy and fairness of such statistical models along with possible approaches for improvement.
△ Less
Submitted 31 July, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
