Estimation and Evaluation of the Resource-Constrained Optimal Dynamic Treatment Rule: An Application to HIV Care Retention
Authors:
Lina M. Montoya,
Elvin H. Geng,
Harriet F. Adhiambo,
Maya L. Petersen
Abstract:
The optimal strategy for deploying a treatment in a population may recommend giving all in the population that treatment. Such a strategy may not be feasible, especially in resource-limited settings. One approach for determining how to allocate a treatment in such settings is the resource-constrained optimal dynamic treatment rule (RC ODTR) SuperLearner algorithm, developed by Luedtke and van der…
▽ More
The optimal strategy for deploying a treatment in a population may recommend giving all in the population that treatment. Such a strategy may not be feasible, especially in resource-limited settings. One approach for determining how to allocate a treatment in such settings is the resource-constrained optimal dynamic treatment rule (RC ODTR) SuperLearner algorithm, developed by Luedtke and van der Laan. In this paper, we describe this algorithm, offer various novel approaches for presenting the RC ODTR and its value in terms of benefit and cost, and provide practical guidance on implementing the algorithm (including software). In particular, we apply this method to the Adaptive Strategies for Preventing and Treating Lapses of Retention in HIV care (NCT02338739) trial to determine how to best allocate conditional cash transfers (CCTs) for increasing HIV care adherence given varying constraints on the proportion of people who can receive CCTs in the population, providing one of the few applied illustrations of this method and novel substantive findings. We find that there are clinical and monetary benefits to deploying CCTs to a small percent (e.g., 10\%) of the population compared to administering the care standard for all; however, results suggest that these incremental benefits are only due to the loosening of constraints, rather than a presence of treatment effect heterogeneity strong enough to drive a more efficient and effective constrained allocation approach.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
Cost Effectiveness Analyses for Sequential Multiple Assignment Randomized Trials
Authors:
Lina M. Montoya,
Elvin H. Geng,
Harriet F. Adhiambo,
Eliud Akama,
Starley B. Shade,
Assurah Elly,
Thomas Odeny,
Maya L. Petersen
Abstract:
Sequential multiple assignment randomized trials (SMARTs) have grown in popularity in recent years, and many of their study protocols propose conducting a cost effectiveness analysis of the adaptive strategies embedded within them. The cost effectiveness of these regimes is often proposed to be assessed using incremental cost effectiveness ratios (ICERs). In this paper, we present an estimation an…
▽ More
Sequential multiple assignment randomized trials (SMARTs) have grown in popularity in recent years, and many of their study protocols propose conducting a cost effectiveness analysis of the adaptive strategies embedded within them. The cost effectiveness of these regimes is often proposed to be assessed using incremental cost effectiveness ratios (ICERs). In this paper, we present an estimation and inference procedure for such cost effectiveness measures for the embedded dynamic treatment regimes within a SMART design. In particular, we describe a targeted maximum likelihood estimator for the ICER of a SMART's embedded regimes with influence curve-based inference. We illustrate the performance of these methods using simulations. Throughout, we use as illustration a cost effectiveness analysis for the Adaptive Strategies for Preventing and Treating Lapses of Retention in HIV Care (ADAPT-R; NCT02338739) trial, presenting estimated ICERs (with inference) for embedded regimes aimed at increasing HIV care adherence. This manuscript is one of the first to present cost effectiveness analysis results from a SMART.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
