-
Comment on "Direct space-time observation of pulse tunneling in an electromagnetic band gap"
Authors:
G. Nimtz,
A. A. Stahlhofen
Abstract:
The investigation presented by Doiron, Hache, and Winful [Phys. Rev. A 76, 023823 (2007)] is not valid for the tunneling process as claimed in the paper.
The investigation presented by Doiron, Hache, and Winful [Phys. Rev. A 76, 023823 (2007)] is not valid for the tunneling process as claimed in the paper.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2008;
originally announced January 2008.
-
Comment on: Direct space-time observation of pulse tunneling in an electromagnetic band gap, S.Doiron,A.Hache,H.Winful
Authors:
G. Nimtz,
A. A. Stahlhofen
Abstract:
The title of this article is misleading. The authors have investigated a resonator but not a tunneling barrier see also Refs.\cite{Winful2} The measured superluminal group velocity and discussed is that studied on a Lorentz-Lorenz oscillator by Sommerfeld and Brillouin a hundred years ago \cite{Brillouin}. It is similar to the faster than light experiment by Wang et al. based also on anomalous d…
▽ More
The title of this article is misleading. The authors have investigated a resonator but not a tunneling barrier see also Refs.\cite{Winful2} The measured superluminal group velocity and discussed is that studied on a Lorentz-Lorenz oscillator by Sommerfeld and Brillouin a hundred years ago \cite{Brillouin}. It is similar to the faster than light experiment by Wang et al. based also on anomalous dispersion with a complex refractive index of a resonator
\cite{Wang}.
Tunneling, however, is understood and performed by electromagnetic evanescent modes or by tunneling solutions of the Schrödinger equation, which have purely imaginary wave numbers. The latter includes a purely imaginary refractive index. Signals with purely evanescent frequency components can travel at a superluminal velocity \cite{NimtzH,Nimtz1}. Inside the barrier tunneling proceeds even instantaneously, i.e.by a process described by virtual photons \cite{Stahlhofen}.
△ Less
Submitted 26 October, 2007;
originally announced October 2007.
-
Universal tunneling time for all fields
Authors:
G. Nimtz,
A. A. Stahlhofen
Abstract:
Tunneling is an important physical process. The observation that particles surmount a high mountain in spite of the fact that they don't have the necessary energy cannot be explained by classical physics. However, this so called tunneling became allowed by quantum mechanics. Experimental tunneling studies with different photonic barriers from microwave frequencies up to ultraviolet frequencies p…
▽ More
Tunneling is an important physical process. The observation that particles surmount a high mountain in spite of the fact that they don't have the necessary energy cannot be explained by classical physics. However, this so called tunneling became allowed by quantum mechanics. Experimental tunneling studies with different photonic barriers from microwave frequencies up to ultraviolet frequencies pointed towards a universal tunneling time (Haibel,Esposito). Experiments and calculations have shown that the tunneling time of opaque photonic barriers (optical mirrors, e.g.) equals approximately the reciprocal frequency of the corresponding electromagnetic wave. The tunneling process is described by virtual photons. Virtual particles like photons or electrons are not observable. However, from the theoretical point of view, they represent necessary intermediate states between observable real states. In the case of tunneling there is a virtual particle between the incident and the transmitted particle. Tunneling modes have a purely imaginary wave number. They represent solutions of the Schroedinger equation and of the classical Helmholtz equation. Recent experimental and theoretical data of electron and sound tunneling confirmed the conjecture that the tunneling process is characterized by a universal tunneling time independent of the kind of field. Tunneling proceeds at a time of the order of the reciprocal frequency of the wave.
△ Less
Submitted 6 September, 2007;
originally announced September 2007.
-
Macroscopic violation of special relativity
Authors:
G. Nimtz,
A. A. Stahlhofen
Abstract:
Feynman one of the founders of Quantum Electronic Dynamics (QED) introduced in his diagrams virtual particles as intermediate states of an interaction process. Such virtual particles are not observable, however, from the theoretical point of view they represent necessary intermediate states between observable real states. Such virtual particles were introduced for describing the interaction proc…
▽ More
Feynman one of the founders of Quantum Electronic Dynamics (QED) introduced in his diagrams virtual particles as intermediate states of an interaction process. Such virtual particles are not observable, however, from the theoretical point of view they represent necessary intermediate states between observable real states. Such virtual particles were introduced for describing the interaction process between an electron and a positron and for much more complicated interaction processes. Other candidates for virtual photons are evanescent modes known from optics. Evanescent modes have a purely imaginary wave number, they represent the mathematical analogy of the tunneling solutions of the Schrödinger equation. Evanescent modes are present in the optical processes of total reflection and in undersized wave guides for instance. The most prominent example of the occurrence of evanescent modes is frustrated total internal reflection at double prisms. In 1949 Sommerfeld \cite{Sommerfeld} pointed out that this optical phenomenon represents the analogy of quantum mechanical tunneling. The evanescent modes and tunneling violate the theory of special relativity, obviously, they represent the exception which proves the special theory of relativity. We demonstrate the quantum mechanical behavior of evanescent modes \textbf{with digital microwave} signals at a macroscopic scale of the order of a meter and show that evanescent modes are well described by virtual photons as predicted by former QED calculations.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2007;
originally announced August 2007.
