-
Feasibility of accelerating homogeneous catalyst discovery with fault-tolerant quantum computers
Authors:
Nicole Bellonzi,
Alexander Kunitsa,
Joshua T. Cantin,
Jorge A. Campos-Gonzalez-Angulo,
Maxwell D. Radin,
Yanbing Zhou,
Peter D. Johnson,
Luis A. Martínez-Martínez,
Mohammad Reza Jangrouei,
Aritra Sankar Brahmachari,
Linjun Wang,
Smik Patel,
Monika Kodrycka,
Ignacio Loaiza,
Robert A. Lang,
Alán Aspuru-Guzik,
Artur F. Izmaylov,
Jhonathan Romero Fontalvo,
Yudong Cao
Abstract:
The industrial manufacturing of chemicals consumes a significant amount of energy and raw materials. In principle, the development of new catalysts could greatly improve the efficiency of chemical production. However, the discovery of viable catalysts can be exceedingly challenging because it is difficult to know the efficacy of a candidate without experimentally synthesizing and characterizing it…
▽ More
The industrial manufacturing of chemicals consumes a significant amount of energy and raw materials. In principle, the development of new catalysts could greatly improve the efficiency of chemical production. However, the discovery of viable catalysts can be exceedingly challenging because it is difficult to know the efficacy of a candidate without experimentally synthesizing and characterizing it. This study explores the feasibility of using fault-tolerant quantum computers to accelerate the discovery of homogeneous catalysts for nitrogen fixation, an industrially important chemical process. It introduces a set of ground-state energy estimation problems representative of calculations needed for the discovery of homogeneous catalysts and analyzes them on three dimensions: economic utility, classical hardness, and quantum resource requirements. For the highest utility problem considered, two steps of a catalytic cycle for the generation of cyanate anion from dinitrogen, the economic utility of running these computations is estimated to be $200,000, and the required runtime for double-factorized phase estimation on a fault-tolerant superconducting device is estimated under conservative assumptions to be 139,000 QPU-hours. The computational cost of an equivalent DMRG calculation is estimated to be about 400,000 CPU-hours. These results suggest that, with continued development, it will be feasible for fault-tolerant quantum computers to accelerate the discovery of homogeneous catalysts.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Reducing the cost of energy estimation in the variational quantum eigensolver algorithm with robust amplitude estimation
Authors:
Peter D. Johnson,
Alexander A. Kunitsa,
Jérôme F. Gonthier,
Maxwell D. Radin,
Corneliu Buda,
Eric J. Doskocil,
Clena M. Abuan,
Jhonathan Romero
Abstract:
Quantum chemistry and materials is one of the most promising applications of quantum computing. Yet much work is still to be done in matching industry-relevant problems in these areas with quantum algorithms that can solve them. Most previous efforts have carried out resource estimations for quantum algorithms run on large-scale fault-tolerant architectures, which include the quantum phase estimat…
▽ More
Quantum chemistry and materials is one of the most promising applications of quantum computing. Yet much work is still to be done in matching industry-relevant problems in these areas with quantum algorithms that can solve them. Most previous efforts have carried out resource estimations for quantum algorithms run on large-scale fault-tolerant architectures, which include the quantum phase estimation algorithm. In contrast, few have assessed the performance of near-term quantum algorithms, which include the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) algorithm. Recently, a large-scale benchmark study [Gonthier et al. 2020] found evidence that the performance of the variational quantum eigensolver for a set of industry-relevant molecules may be too inefficient to be of practical use. This motivates the need for developing and assessing methods that improve the efficiency of VQE. In this work, we predict the runtime of the energy estimation subroutine of VQE when using robust amplitude estimation (RAE) to estimate Pauli expectation values. Under conservative assumptions, our resource estimation predicts that RAE can reduce the runtime over the standard estimation method in VQE by one to two orders of magnitude. Despite this improvement, we find that the runtimes are still too large to be practical. These findings motivate two complementary efforts towards quantum advantage: 1) the investigation of more efficient near-term methods for ground state energy estimation and 2) the development of problem instances that are of industrial value and classically challenging, but better suited to quantum computation.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Classically-Boosted Variational Quantum Eigensolver
Authors:
Maxwell D. Radin,
Peter Johnson
Abstract:
The ability of near-term quantum computers to represent classically-intractable quantum states has brought much interest in using such devices for estimating the ground and excited state energies of fermionic Hamiltonians. The usefulness of such near-term techniques, generally based on the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE), however, is limited by device noise and the need to perform many circu…
▽ More
The ability of near-term quantum computers to represent classically-intractable quantum states has brought much interest in using such devices for estimating the ground and excited state energies of fermionic Hamiltonians. The usefulness of such near-term techniques, generally based on the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE), however, is limited by device noise and the need to perform many circuit repetitions. This paper addresses these challenges by generalizing VQE to consider wavefunctions in a subspace spanned by classically tractable states and states that can be prepared on a quantum computer. The manuscript shows how the ground and excited state energies can be estimated using such "classical-boosting" and how this approach can be combined with VQE Hamiltonian decomposition techniques. Unlike existing VQE approaches, the sensitivity to sampling error and device noise approaches zero in the limit where the classically tractable states are able to describe an eigenstate. A detailed analysis of the measurement requirements in the simplest case, where a single computational basis state is used to boost conventional VQE, shows that the ground-state energy estimation of several closed-shell homonuclear diatomic molecules can be accelerated by a factor of approximately 10-1000. The analysis also shows that the measurement reduction of such single basis state boosting, relative to conventional VQE, can be estimated using only the overlap between the ground state and the computational basis state used for boosting.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Measurements as a roadblock to near-term practical quantum advantage in chemistry: resource analysis
Authors:
Jérôme F. Gonthier,
Maxwell D. Radin,
Corneliu Buda,
Eric J. Doskocil,
Clena M. Abuan,
Jhonathan Romero
Abstract:
Recent advances in quantum computing devices have brought attention to hybrid quantum-classical algorithms like the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) as a potential route to practical quantum advantage in chemistry. However, it is not yet clear whether such algorithms, even in the absence of device error, could actually achieve quantum advantage for systems of practical interest. We have perfo…
▽ More
Recent advances in quantum computing devices have brought attention to hybrid quantum-classical algorithms like the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) as a potential route to practical quantum advantage in chemistry. However, it is not yet clear whether such algorithms, even in the absence of device error, could actually achieve quantum advantage for systems of practical interest. We have performed an exhaustive analysis to estimate the number of qubits and number of measurements required to compute the combustion energies of small organic molecules and related systems to within chemical accuracy of experimental values using VQE. We consider several key modern improvements to VQE, including low-rank factorizations of the Hamiltonian. Our results indicate that although these techniques are useful, they will not be sufficient to achieve practical quantum computational advantage for our molecular set, or for similar molecules. This suggests that novel approaches to operator estimation leveraging quantum coherence, such as Enhanced Likelihood Functions [arxiv:2006.09350, arxiv:2006.09349], may be required.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2022; v1 submitted 7 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
OpenFermion: The Electronic Structure Package for Quantum Computers
Authors:
Jarrod R. McClean,
Kevin J. Sung,
Ian D. Kivlichan,
Yudong Cao,
Chengyu Dai,
E. Schuyler Fried,
Craig Gidney,
Brendan Gimby,
Pranav Gokhale,
Thomas Häner,
Tarini Hardikar,
Vojtěch Havlíček,
Oscar Higgott,
Cupjin Huang,
Josh Izaac,
Zhang Jiang,
Xinle Liu,
Sam McArdle,
Matthew Neeley,
Thomas O'Brien,
Bryan O'Gorman,
Isil Ozfidan,
Maxwell D. Radin,
Jhonathan Romero,
Nicholas Rubin
, et al. (10 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Quantum simulation of chemistry and materials is predicted to be an important application for both near-term and fault-tolerant quantum devices. However, at present, developing and studying algorithms for these problems can be difficult due to the prohibitive amount of domain knowledge required in both the area of chemistry and quantum algorithms. To help bridge this gap and open the field to more…
▽ More
Quantum simulation of chemistry and materials is predicted to be an important application for both near-term and fault-tolerant quantum devices. However, at present, developing and studying algorithms for these problems can be difficult due to the prohibitive amount of domain knowledge required in both the area of chemistry and quantum algorithms. To help bridge this gap and open the field to more researchers, we have developed the OpenFermion software package (www.openfermion.org). OpenFermion is an open-source software library written largely in Python under an Apache 2.0 license, aimed at enabling the simulation of fermionic models and quantum chemistry problems on quantum hardware. Beginning with an interface to common electronic structure packages, it simplifies the translation between a molecular specification and a quantum circuit for solving or studying the electronic structure problem on a quantum computer, minimizing the amount of domain expertise required to enter the field. The package is designed to be extensible and robust, maintaining high software standards in documentation and testing. This release paper outlines the key motivations behind design choices in OpenFermion and discusses some basic OpenFermion functionality which we believe will aid the community in the development of better quantum algorithms and tools for this exciting area of research.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2019; v1 submitted 20 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
