-
Bose-Marletto-Vedral experiment without observable spacetime superpositions
Authors:
Nicetu Tibau Vidal,
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral,
Giulio Chiribella
Abstract:
Reconciling quantum mechanics and general relativity remains one of the most profound challenges in modern physics. The BMV (Bose-Marletto-Vedral) experiment can assess the quantum nature of gravity by testing whether gravitational interactions can generate entanglement between quantum systems. In this work, we show that entanglement can be generated by gravity without requiring spacetime superpos…
▽ More
Reconciling quantum mechanics and general relativity remains one of the most profound challenges in modern physics. The BMV (Bose-Marletto-Vedral) experiment can assess the quantum nature of gravity by testing whether gravitational interactions can generate entanglement between quantum systems. In this work, we show that entanglement can be generated by gravity without requiring spacetime superpositions or quantum spacetime degrees of freedom by using mediators that do not satisfy the usual property of local tomography when coupling to quantum matter. Specifically, we showcase how entanglement can be generated using three distinct toy models that display non-locally tomographic couplings between quantum matter and a locally classical gravitational mediator. These models include (i) fermionic systems with the parity superselection rule, (ii) non-Abelian anyonic systems, and (iii) a novel bit anti-bit model. Our results demonstrate a crucial point: a gravitational mediator which does not exhibit superpositions of its classical basis but still qualifies as non-classical via non-locally tomographic coupling mechanisms can generate entanglement through local interactions. This work also underscores the importance of relaxing local tomography in exploring the quantum-gravitational interface. It provides a novel perspective on the role of spacetime degrees of freedom in entanglement generation through local interactions.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2025; v1 submitted 26 June, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
Temporal Entanglement and Witnesses of Non-Classicality
Authors:
Giuseppe Di Pietra,
Gaurav Bhole,
James Eaton,
Andrew J. Baldwin,
Jonathan A. Jones,
Vlatko Vedral,
Chiara Marletto
Abstract:
The universality of quantum theory has been questioned ever since it was proposed. Key to this long-unsolved question is to test whether a given physical system has non-classical features. Here we connect recently proposed witnesses of non-classicality, based on information-theoretic ideas, with the theory of temporal entanglement. We provide a protocol to witness the non-classicality of a system…
▽ More
The universality of quantum theory has been questioned ever since it was proposed. Key to this long-unsolved question is to test whether a given physical system has non-classical features. Here we connect recently proposed witnesses of non-classicality, based on information-theoretic ideas, with the theory of temporal entanglement. We provide a protocol to witness the non-classicality of a system by probing it with a qubit: we show that, assuming a general conservation law, violating temporal Bell inequalities on the qubit probe implies the non-classicality of the system under investigation. We also perform proof-of-principle experimental emulations of the proposed witness of non-classicality, using a three qubit Nuclear Magnetic Resonance quantum computer. Our result is robust, as it relies on minimal assumptions, and remarkably it can be applied in a broad range of contexts, from quantum biology to quantum gravity.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
Constructor theory of time
Authors:
David Deutsch,
Chiara Marletto
Abstract:
Constructor theory asserts that the laws of physics are expressible as specifications of which transformations of physical systems can or cannot be brought about with unbounded accuracy by devices capable of operating in a cycle ('constructors'). Hence, in particular, such specifications cannot refer to time. Thus, laws expressed in constructor-theoretic form automatically avoid the anomalous prop…
▽ More
Constructor theory asserts that the laws of physics are expressible as specifications of which transformations of physical systems can or cannot be brought about with unbounded accuracy by devices capable of operating in a cycle ('constructors'). Hence, in particular, such specifications cannot refer to time. Thus, laws expressed in constructor-theoretic form automatically avoid the anomalous properties of time in traditional formulations of fundamental theories. But that raises the problem of how they can nevertheless give meaning to duration and dynamics, and thereby be compatible with traditionally formulated laws. Here we show how.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2025; v1 submitted 13 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
Interference in complex canonical variables is not quantum
Authors:
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral
Abstract:
We formally represent the quantum interference of a single qubit embodied by a photon in the Mach-Zehnder interferometer using the classical Hamiltonian framework but with complex canonical variables. Although all operations on a single qubit can be formally expressed using the complex classical Hamiltonian dynamics, we show that the resulting system is still not a proper qubit. The reason is that…
▽ More
We formally represent the quantum interference of a single qubit embodied by a photon in the Mach-Zehnder interferometer using the classical Hamiltonian framework but with complex canonical variables. Although all operations on a single qubit can be formally expressed using the complex classical Hamiltonian dynamics, we show that the resulting system is still not a proper qubit. The reason is that it is not capable of getting entangled to another bona fide qubit and hence it does not have the information-processing capacity of a fully-fledged quantum system. This simple example powerfully illustrates the failure of all hybrid quantum-classical models in accounting for the full range of behaviour of even a single quantum bit.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
Reply to comment on: Observation of the quantum equivalence principle for matter-waves
Authors:
Or Dobkowski,
Barak Trok,
Peter Skakunenko,
Yonathan Japha,
David Groswasser,
Maxim Efremov,
Chiara Marletto,
Ivette Fuentes,
Roger Penrose,
Vlatko Vedral,
Wolfgang P. Schleich,
Ron Folman
Abstract:
We show that in contrast to a recent claim, the Quantum Galileo Interferometer is sensitive to a uniform gravitational field in the presence and even in the absence of the levitation condition.
We show that in contrast to a recent claim, the Quantum Galileo Interferometer is sensitive to a uniform gravitational field in the presence and even in the absence of the levitation condition.
△ Less
Submitted 30 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
Collapse-based models for gravity do not violate the Entanglement-Based Witness of non-classicality
Authors:
Tianfeng Feng,
Vlatko Vedral,
Chiara Marletto
Abstract:
It is known that an entanglement-based witness of non-classicality can be applied to testing quantum effects in gravity. Specifically, if a system can create entanglement between two quantum probes by local means only, then it must be non-classical. Recently, claims have been made that collapse-based models of classical gravity, i.e. Diósi-Penrose model, can predict gravitationally induced entangl…
▽ More
It is known that an entanglement-based witness of non-classicality can be applied to testing quantum effects in gravity. Specifically, if a system can create entanglement between two quantum probes by local means only, then it must be non-classical. Recently, claims have been made that collapse-based models of classical gravity, i.e. Diósi-Penrose model, can predict gravitationally induced entanglement between quantum objects, resulting in gravitationally induced entanglement is insufficient to conclude that gravity is fundamentally quantum, contrary to the witness statement. Here we vindicate the witness. We analyze the underlying physics of collapse-based models for gravity and show that these models have nonlocal features, violating the principle of locality.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Observation of the quantum equivalence principle for matter-waves
Authors:
Or Dobkowski,
Barak Trok,
Peter Skakunenko,
Yonathan Japha,
David Groswasser,
Maxim Efremov,
Chiara Marletto,
Ivette Fuentes,
Roger Penrose,
Vlatko Vedral,
Wolfgang P. Schleich,
Ron Folman
Abstract:
Einstein's general theory of relativity is based on the principle of equivalence - in essence, dating back to Galileo - which asserts that, locally, the effect of a gravitational field is equivalent to that of an accelerating reference frame, so that the local gravitational field is eliminated in a freely-falling frame. Einstein's theory enables this principle to extend to a global description of…
▽ More
Einstein's general theory of relativity is based on the principle of equivalence - in essence, dating back to Galileo - which asserts that, locally, the effect of a gravitational field is equivalent to that of an accelerating reference frame, so that the local gravitational field is eliminated in a freely-falling frame. Einstein's theory enables this principle to extend to a global description of relativistic space-time, at the expense of allowing space-time to become curved, realising a consistent frame-independent description of nature at the classical level. Einstein's theory has been confirmed to great accuracy for astrophysical bodies. However, in the quantum domain the equivalence principle has been predicted to take a unique form involving a gauge phase that is observable if the wavefunction - fundamental to quantum descriptions - allows an object to interfere with itself after being simultaneously at rest in two differently accelerating frames, one being the laboratory (Newtonian) frame and the other in the freely-falling (Einsteinian) frame. To measure this gauge phase we realise a novel cold-atom interferometer in which one wave packet stays static in the laboratory frame while the other is in free fall. We follow the relative-phase evolution of the wave packets in the two frames, confirming the equivalence principle in the quantum domain. Our observation is yet another fundamental test of the interface between quantum theory and gravity. The new interferometer also opens the door for further probing of the latter interface, as well as to searches for new physics.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2025; v1 submitted 20 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
On the Role of Locality in the Bose-Marletto-Vedral Effect
Authors:
Giuseppe Di Pietra,
Vlatko Vedral,
Chiara Marletto
Abstract:
Two of us recently proposed an entanglement-based witness of non-classicality, which can be applied to testing quantum effects in gravity in what is known as the Bose-Marletto-Vedral (BMV) effect. The witness is based on this idea: if a system can create entanglement between two quantum probes by local means only, then it must be non-classical. In this note we discuss the role of locality as an as…
▽ More
Two of us recently proposed an entanglement-based witness of non-classicality, which can be applied to testing quantum effects in gravity in what is known as the Bose-Marletto-Vedral (BMV) effect. The witness is based on this idea: if a system can create entanglement between two quantum probes by local means only, then it must be non-classical. In this note we discuss the role of locality as an assumption for the theorem supporting the witness; we also discuss other related notions of locality and comment on their mutual relations.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
The Bose-Marletto-Vedral experiment with nanodiamond interferometers: an insight on entanglement detection
Authors:
Giuseppe Di Pietra,
Fabrizio Piacentini,
Ettore Bernardi,
Ekaterina Moreva,
Carmine Napoli,
Ivo Pietro Degiovanni,
Marco Genovese,
Vlatko Vedral,
Chiara Marletto
Abstract:
Recently, it has been proposed a new method [arXiv:2405.21029] to detect quantum gravity effects, based on generating gravitational entanglement between two nano-diamonds with Nitrogen-Vacancy defects, in a magnetically trapped configuration. Here we analyse in detail the proposed experimental setup, with a particular focus on implementing the detection of the gravitationally-induced entanglement…
▽ More
Recently, it has been proposed a new method [arXiv:2405.21029] to detect quantum gravity effects, based on generating gravitational entanglement between two nano-diamonds with Nitrogen-Vacancy defects, in a magnetically trapped configuration. Here we analyse in detail the proposed experimental setup, with a particular focus on implementing the detection of the gravitationally-induced entanglement using an optical readout based on measuring the position of the nano-diamonds and its complementary basis. We also summarise some of the key theoretical and experimental ideas on which this proposed scheme is based.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Quantum-information methods for quantum gravity laboratory-based tests
Authors:
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral
Abstract:
Quantum theory and general relativity are about one century old. At present, they are considered the best available explanations of physical reality, and they have been so far corroborated by all experiments realised so far. Nonetheless, the quest to unify them is still ongoing, with several yet untested proposals for a theory of quantum gravity. Here we review the nascent field of information-the…
▽ More
Quantum theory and general relativity are about one century old. At present, they are considered the best available explanations of physical reality, and they have been so far corroborated by all experiments realised so far. Nonetheless, the quest to unify them is still ongoing, with several yet untested proposals for a theory of quantum gravity. Here we review the nascent field of information-theoretic methods applied to designing tests of quantum gravity in the laboratory. This field emerges from the fruitful extension of quantum information theory methodologies beyond the domain of applicability of quantum theory itself, to cover gravity. We shall focus mainly on the detection of gravitational entanglement between two quantum probes, comparing this method with single-probe schemes. We shall review the experimental proposal that has originated this field, as well as its variants, their applications, and discuss their potential implications for the quantum theory of gravity. We shall also highlight the role of general information-theoretic principles in illuminating the search for quantum effects in gravity.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
The role of non-classicality in mediated spatial quantum correlations
Authors:
Salvatore Raia,
Giuseppe Di Pietra,
Chiara Marletto
Abstract:
The study of non-classicality is essential to understand the quantum-to-classical transition in physical systems. Recently a witness of non-classicality has been proposed, linking the ability of a system (``the mediator") to create quantum correlations between two quantum probes with its non-classicality, intended as the existence of at least two non-commuting variables. Here we propose a new ineq…
▽ More
The study of non-classicality is essential to understand the quantum-to-classical transition in physical systems. Recently a witness of non-classicality has been proposed, linking the ability of a system (``the mediator") to create quantum correlations between two quantum probes with its non-classicality, intended as the existence of at least two non-commuting variables. Here we propose a new inequality that quantitatively links the increase in quantum correlations between the probes to the degree of non-commutativity of the mediator's observables. We test the inequality for various degrees of non-classicality of the mediator, from fully quantum to fully classical. This quantum-to-classical transition is simulated via a phase-flip channel applied to the mediator, inducing an effective reduction of the non-commutativity of its variables. Our results provide a general framework for witnessing non-classicality, quantifying the non-classicality of a system via its intrinsic properties (such as its Hilbert space dimension and observable commutators) beyond the specifics of interaction dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Universal quantum theory contains twisted logic
Authors:
Francesco Atzori,
Enrico Rebufello,
Maria Violaris,
Laura T. Knoll,
Abdulla Alhajri,
Alessio Avella,
Marco Gramegna,
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral,
Fabrizio Piacentini,
Ivo Pietro Degiovanni,
Marco Genovese
Abstract:
Quantum theory is notoriously counterintuitive, and yet remains entirely self-consistent when applied universally. Here we uncover a new manifestation of its unusual consequences. We demonstrate, theoretically and experimentally (by means of polarization-encoded single-photon qubits), that Heisenberg's uncertainty principle leads to the impossibility of stringing together logical deductions about…
▽ More
Quantum theory is notoriously counterintuitive, and yet remains entirely self-consistent when applied universally. Here we uncover a new manifestation of its unusual consequences. We demonstrate, theoretically and experimentally (by means of polarization-encoded single-photon qubits), that Heisenberg's uncertainty principle leads to the impossibility of stringing together logical deductions about outcomes of consecutive non-compatible measurements. This phenomenon resembles the geometry of a Penrose triangle, where each corner is locally consistent while the global structure is impossible. Besides this, we show how overlooking this non-trivial logical structure leads to the erroneous possibility of distinguishing non-orthogonal states with a single measurement.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Conservation Laws and the Quantization of Gravity
Authors:
Tianfeng Feng,
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral
Abstract:
Adopting general frameworks for quantum-classical dynamics, we analyze the interaction between quantum matter and a classical gravitational field. We point out that, assuming conservation of momentum or energy, and assuming that the dynamics obeys Hamiltonian formalism or a particular decomposition property set out in the paper, the classical gravitational field cannot change the momentum or energ…
▽ More
Adopting general frameworks for quantum-classical dynamics, we analyze the interaction between quantum matter and a classical gravitational field. We point out that, assuming conservation of momentum or energy, and assuming that the dynamics obeys Hamiltonian formalism or a particular decomposition property set out in the paper, the classical gravitational field cannot change the momentum or energy of the quantum system, whereas the quantum gravitational field can do so. Drawing upon the fundamental relationship between conservation laws and the quantum properties of objects, our analysis offers new perspectives for the study of quantum gravity and provides a novel interpretation of existing experimental observations, such as free fall.
△ Less
Submitted 29 July, 2024; v1 submitted 15 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Comparing coherent and incoherent models for quantum homogenization
Authors:
Anna Beever,
Maria Violaris,
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral
Abstract:
Here we investigate the role of quantum interference in the quantum homogenizer, whose convergence properties model a thermalization process. In the original quantum homogenizer protocol, a system qubit converges to the state of identical reservoir qubits through partial-swap interactions, that allow interference between reservoir qubits. We design an alternative, incoherent quantum homogenizer, w…
▽ More
Here we investigate the role of quantum interference in the quantum homogenizer, whose convergence properties model a thermalization process. In the original quantum homogenizer protocol, a system qubit converges to the state of identical reservoir qubits through partial-swap interactions, that allow interference between reservoir qubits. We design an alternative, incoherent quantum homogenizer, where each system-reservoir interaction is moderated by a control qubit using a controlled-swap interaction. We show that our incoherent homogenizer satisfies the essential conditions for homogenization, being able to transform a qubit from any state to any other state to arbitrary accuracy, with negligible impact on the reservoir qubits' states. Our results show that the convergence properties of homogenization machines that are important for modelling thermalization are not dependent on coherence between qubits in the homogenization protocol. We then derive bounds on the resources required to re-use the homogenizers for performing state transformations. This demonstrates that both homogenizers are universal for any number of homogenizations, for an increased resource cost.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2024; v1 submitted 27 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Observing ghost entanglement beyond scattering amplitudes in quantum electrodynamics
Authors:
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral
Abstract:
A fully local quantum account of the interactions experienced between charges requires us to use all the four modes of the electromagnetic vector potential, in the Lorenz gauge. However, it is frequently stated that only the two transverse modes of the vector potential are ``real" in that they contain photons that can actually be detected. The photons present in the other two modes, the scalar and…
▽ More
A fully local quantum account of the interactions experienced between charges requires us to use all the four modes of the electromagnetic vector potential, in the Lorenz gauge. However, it is frequently stated that only the two transverse modes of the vector potential are ``real" in that they contain photons that can actually be detected. The photons present in the other two modes, the scalar and the longitudinal, are considered unobservable, and are referred to as ``virtual particles" or ``ghosts". Here we argue that this view is erroneous and that even these modes can, in fact, be observed. We present an experiment which is designed to measure the entanglement generated between a charge and the scalar modes. This entanglement is a direct function of the number of photons present in the scalar field. Our conclusion therefore is that the scalar quantum variables are as ``real" as the transverse ones, where reality is defined by their ability to affect the charge. A striking consequence of this is that we cannot detect by local means a superposition of a charge bigger than that containing 137 electrons.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Temporal witnesses of non-classicality in a macroscopic biological system
Authors:
Giuseppe Di Pietra,
Vlatko Vedral,
Chiara Marletto
Abstract:
Exciton transfer along a polymer is essential for many biological processes, for instance light harvesting in photosynthetic biosystems. Here we apply a new witness of non-classicality to this phenomenon, to conclude that, if an exciton can mediate the coherent quantum evolution of a photon, then the exciton is non-classical. We then propose a general qubit model for the quantum transfer of an exc…
▽ More
Exciton transfer along a polymer is essential for many biological processes, for instance light harvesting in photosynthetic biosystems. Here we apply a new witness of non-classicality to this phenomenon, to conclude that, if an exciton can mediate the coherent quantum evolution of a photon, then the exciton is non-classical. We then propose a general qubit model for the quantum transfer of an exciton along a polymer chain, also discussing the effects of environmental decoherence. The generality of our results makes them ideal candidates to design new tests of quantum features in complex bio-molecules.
△ Less
Submitted 11 September, 2024; v1 submitted 22 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Unpredictability is perfectly possible in a deterministic universe
Authors:
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral
Abstract:
We revisit the vexed question of how unpredictability can arise in a deterministic universe, focusing on unitary quantum theory. We discuss why quantum unpredictability is irrelevant for the possibility of what some people call `free-will', and why existing `free-will' arguments are themselves irrelevant to argue for or against a physical theory.
We revisit the vexed question of how unpredictability can arise in a deterministic universe, focusing on unitary quantum theory. We discuss why quantum unpredictability is irrelevant for the possibility of what some people call `free-will', and why existing `free-will' arguments are themselves irrelevant to argue for or against a physical theory.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Interference in quantum field theory: detecting ghosts with phases
Authors:
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral
Abstract:
We discuss the implications of the principle of locality for interference in quantum field theory. As an example, we consider the interaction of two charges via a mediating quantum field and the resulting interference pattern, in the Lorenz gauge. Using the Heisenberg picture, we propose that detecting relative phases or entanglement between two charges in an interference experiment is equivalent…
▽ More
We discuss the implications of the principle of locality for interference in quantum field theory. As an example, we consider the interaction of two charges via a mediating quantum field and the resulting interference pattern, in the Lorenz gauge. Using the Heisenberg picture, we propose that detecting relative phases or entanglement between two charges in an interference experiment is equivalent to accessing empirically the gauge degrees of freedom associated with the so-called ghost (scalar) modes of the field in the Lorenz gauge. These results imply that ghost modes are measurable and hence physically relevant, contrary to what is usually thought. They also raise interesting questions about the relation between the principle of locality and the principle of gauge-invariance. Our analysis applies also to linearised quantum gravity in the harmonic gauge, and hence has implications for the recently proposed entanglement-based witnesses of non-classicality in gravity.
△ Less
Submitted 22 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
The irreversibility cost of purifying Szilard's engine: Is it possible to perform erasure using the quantum homogenizer?
Authors:
Maria Violaris,
Chiara Marletto
Abstract:
Erasure is fundamental for information processing. It is also key in connecting information theory and thermodynamics, as it is a logically irreversible task. We provide a new angle on this connection, noting that there may be an additional cost to erasure, that is not captured by standard results such as Landauer's principle. To make this point we use a model of irreversibility based on Construct…
▽ More
Erasure is fundamental for information processing. It is also key in connecting information theory and thermodynamics, as it is a logically irreversible task. We provide a new angle on this connection, noting that there may be an additional cost to erasure, that is not captured by standard results such as Landauer's principle. To make this point we use a model of irreversibility based on Constructor Theory - a recently proposed generalization of the quantum theory of computation. The model uses a machine called the "quantum homogenizer", which has the ability to approximately realise the transformation of a qubit from any state to any other state and remain approximately unchanged, through overall entirely unitary interactions. We argue that when performing erasure via quantum homogenization there is an additional cost to performing the erasure step of the Szilard's engine, because it is more difficult to reliably produce pure states in a cycle than to produce mixed states. We also discuss the implications of this result for the cost of erasure in more general terms.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Temporal witnesses of non-classicality and conservation laws
Authors:
Giuseppe Di Pietra,
Chiara Marletto
Abstract:
A general entanglement-based witness of non-classicality has recently been proposed, which can be applied to testing quantum effects in gravity. This witness is based on generating entanglement between two quantum probes via a mediator. In this paper we provide a "temporal" variant of this witness, using a single quantum probe to assess the non-classicality of the mediator. Within the formalism of…
▽ More
A general entanglement-based witness of non-classicality has recently been proposed, which can be applied to testing quantum effects in gravity. This witness is based on generating entanglement between two quantum probes via a mediator. In this paper we provide a "temporal" variant of this witness, using a single quantum probe to assess the non-classicality of the mediator. Within the formalism of quantum theory, we show that if a system $M$ is capable of inducing a coherent dynamical evolution of a quantum system $Q$, in the presence of a conservation law, then $M$ must be non-classical. This argument supports witnesses of non-classicality relying on a single quantum probe, which can be applied to a number of open issues, notably in quantum gravity or quantum biology.
△ Less
Submitted 18 May, 2024; v1 submitted 30 April, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
A local-realistic theory for fermions
Authors:
Nicetu Tibau Vidal,
Vlatko Vedral,
Chiara Marletto
Abstract:
We propose a local model for general fermionic systems, which we express in the Heisenberg picture. To this end, we shall use a recently proposed formalism, the so-called "Raymond-Robichaud" construction, which allows one to construct an explicitly local model for any dynamical theory that satisfies no-signalling, in terms of equivalence classes of transformations that can be attached to each indi…
▽ More
We propose a local model for general fermionic systems, which we express in the Heisenberg picture. To this end, we shall use a recently proposed formalism, the so-called "Raymond-Robichaud" construction, which allows one to construct an explicitly local model for any dynamical theory that satisfies no-signalling, in terms of equivalence classes of transformations that can be attached to each individual subsystem. By following the rigorous use of the parity superselection rule for fermions, we show how this construction removes the usual difficulties that fermionic systems display in regard to the definition of local states and local transformations.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Response to a comment on "Vindication of entanglement-based witnesses in hybrid quantum systems"
Authors:
Chiara Marletto,
Emanuele Marconato
Abstract:
In a recent paper, we vindicated a general entanglement-based witness of non-classicality in hybrid quantum systems. Our vindication refutes a counterexample to the witness, proposed by Hall and Reginatto. These authors recently commented further, claiming to expose "a huge number of errors and misconceptions" in it. However, their comment contains no refutation of our arguments, nor does it expos…
▽ More
In a recent paper, we vindicated a general entanglement-based witness of non-classicality in hybrid quantum systems. Our vindication refutes a counterexample to the witness, proposed by Hall and Reginatto. These authors recently commented further, claiming to expose "a huge number of errors and misconceptions" in it. However, their comment contains no refutation of our arguments, nor does it expose any error or misconception in them. But it does include a number of misconceptions about the witness of non-classicality. Here we respond to those.
△ Less
Submitted 30 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Spin, Statistics, Spacetime and Quantum Gravity
Authors:
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral
Abstract:
We explore the possibility that the connection between spin and statistics in quantum physics is of dynamical origin. We suggest that the gravitational field could provide a fully local mechanism for the phase that arises when fermionic and bosonic particles are exchanged. Our results hold even if the symmetry of space and time is Galilean, thus establishing that special relativity is not needed t…
▽ More
We explore the possibility that the connection between spin and statistics in quantum physics is of dynamical origin. We suggest that the gravitational field could provide a fully local mechanism for the phase that arises when fermionic and bosonic particles are exchanged. Our results hold even if the symmetry of space and time is Galilean, thus establishing that special relativity is not needed to explain the existence of spin (although it does motivate the introduction of creation and annihilation of particles, but this is a separate issue). We provide a model for the coupling between a particle of general spin and the gravitational field and discuss it within the context of both the equivalence principle and the Sagnac effect. This leads us to present a new experiment for testing the quantum nature of the gravitational field.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Temporal teleportation with pseudo-density operators: how dynamics emerges from temporal entanglement
Authors:
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral,
Salvatore Virzì,
Alessio Avella,
Fabrizio Piacentini,
Marco Gramegna,
Ivo Pietro Degiovanni,
Marco Genovese
Abstract:
We show that, by utilising temporal quantum correlations as expressed by pseudo-density operators (PDOs), it is possible to recover formally the standard quantum dynamical evolution as a sequence of teleportations in time. We demonstrate that any completely positive evolution can be formally reconstructed by teleportation with different temporally correlated states. This provides a different inter…
▽ More
We show that, by utilising temporal quantum correlations as expressed by pseudo-density operators (PDOs), it is possible to recover formally the standard quantum dynamical evolution as a sequence of teleportations in time. We demonstrate that any completely positive evolution can be formally reconstructed by teleportation with different temporally correlated states. This provides a different interpretation of maximally correlated PDOs, as resources to induce quantum time-evolution. Furthermore, we note that the possibility of this protocol stems from the strict formal correspondence between spatial and temporal entanglement in quantum theory. We proceed to demonstrate experimentally this correspondence, by showing a multipartite violation of generalised temporal and spatial Bell inequalities and verifying agreement with theoretical predictions to a high degree of accuracy, in high-quality photon qubits.
△ Less
Submitted 7 July, 2021; v1 submitted 23 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Vindication of entanglement-based witnesses of non-classicality in hybrid systems
Authors:
Emanuele Marconato,
Chiara Marletto
Abstract:
Recently, Vedral and one of us proposed an entanglement-based witness of non-classicality in systems that need not obey quantum theory, based on constructor-information-theoretic ideas, which offers a robust foundation for recently proposed table-top tests of non-classicality in gravity. The witness asserts that if a mediator can entangle locally two quantum systems, then it has to be non-classica…
▽ More
Recently, Vedral and one of us proposed an entanglement-based witness of non-classicality in systems that need not obey quantum theory, based on constructor-information-theoretic ideas, which offers a robust foundation for recently proposed table-top tests of non-classicality in gravity. The witness asserts that if a mediator can entangle locally two quantum systems, then it has to be non-classical. Hall and Reginatto claimed that there are classical systems that can entangle two quantum systems, thus violating our proposed witness. Here we refute that claim, explaining that the counterexample proposed by Hall and Reginatto in fact validates the witness, vindicating the witness of non-classicality in its full generality.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Decoherence effects in non-classicality tests of gravity
Authors:
Simone Rijavec,
Matteo Carlesso,
Angelo Bassi,
Vlatko Vedral,
Chiara Marletto
Abstract:
The experimental observation of a clear quantum signature of gravity is believed to be out of the grasp of current technology. However, several recent promising proposals to test the possible existence of non-classical features of gravity seem to be accessible by the state-of-art table-top experiments. Among them, some aim at measuring the gravitationally induced entanglement between two masses wh…
▽ More
The experimental observation of a clear quantum signature of gravity is believed to be out of the grasp of current technology. However, several recent promising proposals to test the possible existence of non-classical features of gravity seem to be accessible by the state-of-art table-top experiments. Among them, some aim at measuring the gravitationally induced entanglement between two masses which would be a distinct non-classical signature of gravity. We explicitly study, in two of these proposals, the effects of decoherence on the system's dynamics by monitoring the corresponding degree of entanglement. We identify the required experimental conditions necessary to perform successfully the experiments. In parallel, we account also for the possible effects of the Continuous Spontaneous Localization (CSL) model, which is the most known among the models of spontaneous wavefunction collapse. We find that any value of the parameters of the CSL model would completely hinder the generation of gravitationally induced entanglement.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2021; v1 submitted 11 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Interference in the Heisenberg Picture of Quantum Field Theory, Local Elements of Reality and Fermions
Authors:
Chiara Marletto,
Nicetu Tibau Vidal,
Vlatko Vedral
Abstract:
We describe the quantum interference of a single photon in the Mach-Zehnder interferometer using the Heisenberg picture. Our purpose is to show that the description is local just like in the case of the classical electromagnetic field, the only difference being that the electric and the magnetic fields are, in the quantum case, operators (quantum observables). We then consider a single-electron Ma…
▽ More
We describe the quantum interference of a single photon in the Mach-Zehnder interferometer using the Heisenberg picture. Our purpose is to show that the description is local just like in the case of the classical electromagnetic field, the only difference being that the electric and the magnetic fields are, in the quantum case, operators (quantum observables). We then consider a single-electron Mach-Zehnder interferometer and explain what the appropriate Heisenberg picture treatment is in this case. Interestingly, the parity superselection rule forces us to treat the electron differently to the photon. A model using only local quantum observables of different fermionic modes, such as the current operator, is nevertheless still viable to describe phase acquisition. We discuss how to extend this local analysis to coupled fermionic and bosonic fields within the same local formalism of quantum electrodynamics as formulated in the Heisenberg picture.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Emergence of Constructor-based Irreversibility in Quantum Systems: Theory and Experiment
Authors:
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral,
Laura Knoll,
Fabrizio Piacentini,
Ettore Bernardi,
Enrico Rebufello,
Alessio Avella,
Marco Gramegna,
Ivo Pietro Degiovanni,
Marco Genovese
Abstract:
The issue of irreversibility in a universe with time-reversal-symmetric laws is a central problem in physics. % , and, in particular, to statistical mechanics, information theory and quantum thermodynamics. In this letter, we discuss for the first time how irreversibility can emerge within the recently proposed constructor theory framework. Here irreversibility is expressed as the requirement that…
▽ More
The issue of irreversibility in a universe with time-reversal-symmetric laws is a central problem in physics. % , and, in particular, to statistical mechanics, information theory and quantum thermodynamics. In this letter, we discuss for the first time how irreversibility can emerge within the recently proposed constructor theory framework. Here irreversibility is expressed as the requirement that a task is possible, while its inverse is not. In particular, we demonstrate that this irreversibility is compatible with quantum theory's time reversal symmetric laws, by exploiting a specific model, based on the universal quantum homogeniser, realised experimentally with high-quality single-photon qubits.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2021; v1 submitted 30 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
The information-theoretic foundation of thermodynamic work extraction
Authors:
Chiara Marletto
Abstract:
In this paper I apply newly-proposed information-theoretic principles to thermodynamic work extraction. I show that if it is possible to extract work deterministically from a physical system prepared in any one of a set of states, then those states must be distinguishable from one another. This result is formulated independently of scale and of particular dynamical laws; it also provides a novel c…
▽ More
In this paper I apply newly-proposed information-theoretic principles to thermodynamic work extraction. I show that if it is possible to extract work deterministically from a physical system prepared in any one of a set of states, then those states must be distinguishable from one another. This result is formulated independently of scale and of particular dynamical laws; it also provides a novel connection between thermodynamics and information theory, established via the law of conservation of energy (rather than the second law of thermodynamics). Albeit compatible with these conclusions, existing thermodynamics approaches cannot provide a result of such generality, because they are scale-dependent (relying on ensembles or coarse-graining) or tied to particular dynamical laws. This paper thus provides a broader foundation for thermodynamics, with implications for the theory of von Neumann's universal constructor
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2021; v1 submitted 9 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Transforming pure and mixed states using an NMR quantum homogeniser
Authors:
Maria Violaris,
Gaurav Bhole,
Jonathan A. Jones,
Vlatko Vedral,
Chiara Marletto
Abstract:
The universal quantum homogeniser can transform a qubit from any state to any other state with arbitrary accuracy, using only unitary transformations to perform this task. Here we present an implementation of a finite quantum homogeniser using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), with a four-qubit system. We compare the homogenisation of a mixed state to a pure state, and the reverse process. After a…
▽ More
The universal quantum homogeniser can transform a qubit from any state to any other state with arbitrary accuracy, using only unitary transformations to perform this task. Here we present an implementation of a finite quantum homogeniser using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), with a four-qubit system. We compare the homogenisation of a mixed state to a pure state, and the reverse process. After accounting for the effects of decoherence in the system, we find the experimental results to be consistent with the theoretical symmetry in how the qubit states evolve in the two cases. We analyse the implications of this symmetry by interpreting the homogeniser as a physical implementation of pure state preparation and information scrambling.
△ Less
Submitted 27 January, 2021; v1 submitted 6 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
The Quantum Totalitarian Property and Exact Symmetries
Authors:
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral
Abstract:
We discuss a point, which from time to time has been doubted in the literature: all symmetries, such as those induced by the energy and momentum conservation laws, hold in quantum physics not just "on average", as is sometimes claimed, but exactly in each "branch" of the wavefunction, expressed in the basis where the conserved observable is sharp. We note that for conservation laws to hold exactly…
▽ More
We discuss a point, which from time to time has been doubted in the literature: all symmetries, such as those induced by the energy and momentum conservation laws, hold in quantum physics not just "on average", as is sometimes claimed, but exactly in each "branch" of the wavefunction, expressed in the basis where the conserved observable is sharp. We note that for conservation laws to hold exactly for quantum systems in this sense (not just on average), it is necessary to assume the so-called "totalitarian property of quantum theory", namely that any system capable of measuring a quantum observable must itself be quantised. Hence, if conservation laws are to hold exactly, the idea of a `classical measuring apparatus' (i.e., not subject to the branching structure) is untenable. We also point out that any other principle having a well-defined formulation within classical physics, such as the Equivalence principle, is also to be extended to the quantum domain in exactly the same way, i.e., branch by branch.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2020; v1 submitted 30 April, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
On the testability of the equivalence principle as a gauge principle detecting the gravitational $t^3$ phase
Authors:
C. Marletto,
V. Vedral
Abstract:
There have been various claims that the Equivalence Principle, as originally formulated by Einstein, presents several difficulties when extended to the quantum domain, even in the regime of weak gravity. Here we point out that by following the same approach as used for other classical principles, e.g. the principle of conservation of energy, one can, for weak fields, obtain a straightforward quant…
▽ More
There have been various claims that the Equivalence Principle, as originally formulated by Einstein, presents several difficulties when extended to the quantum domain, even in the regime of weak gravity. Here we point out that by following the same approach as used for other classical principles, e.g. the principle of conservation of energy, one can, for weak fields, obtain a straightforward quantum formulation of the principle. We draw attention to a recently performed test that confirms the Equivalence Principle in this form and discuss its implications.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Witnessing non-classicality beyond quantum theory
Authors:
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral
Abstract:
We propose a general argument to show that if a physical system can mediate locally the generation of entanglement between two quantum systems, then it itself must be non-classical. Remarkably, we do not assume any classical or quantum formalism to describe the mediating physical system: our result follows from general information-theoretic principles, drawn from the recently proposed constructor…
▽ More
We propose a general argument to show that if a physical system can mediate locally the generation of entanglement between two quantum systems, then it itself must be non-classical. Remarkably, we do not assume any classical or quantum formalism to describe the mediating physical system: our result follows from general information-theoretic principles, drawn from the recently proposed constructor theory of information. This argument provides the indispensable theoretical basis for recently proposed tests of non-classicality in gravity, based on witnessing gravitationally-induced entanglement in quantum probes.
△ Less
Submitted 9 August, 2020; v1 submitted 17 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Non-monogamy of spatio-temporal correlations and the black hole information loss paradox
Authors:
C. Marletto,
V. Vedral,
S. Virzì,
E. Rebufello,
A. Avella,
F. Piacentini,
M. Gramegna,
I. Degiovanni,
M. Genovese
Abstract:
Pseudo-density matrices are a generalisation of quantum states and do not obey monogamy of quantum correlations. Could this be the solution to the paradox of information loss during the evaporation of a black hole? In this paper we discuss this possibility, providing a theoretical proposal to extend quantum theory with these pseudo-states to describe the statistics arising in black-hole evaporatio…
▽ More
Pseudo-density matrices are a generalisation of quantum states and do not obey monogamy of quantum correlations. Could this be the solution to the paradox of information loss during the evaporation of a black hole? In this paper we discuss this possibility, providing a theoretical proposal to extend quantum theory with these pseudo-states to describe the statistics arising in black-hole evaporation. We also provide an experimental demonstration of this theoretical proposal, using a simulation in optical regime, that tomographically reproduces the correlations of the pseudo-density matrix describing this physical phenomenon.
△ Less
Submitted 18 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Sagnac Interferometer and the Quantum Nature of Gravity
Authors:
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral
Abstract:
We use a quantum variant of the Sagnac interferometer to argue for the quantum nature of gravity as well as to formulate a quantum version of the equivalence principle. We first present an original derivation of the phase acquired in the conventional Sagnac matter-wave interferometer, within the Hamiltonian formalism. Then we modify the interferometer in two crucial respects. The interfering matte…
▽ More
We use a quantum variant of the Sagnac interferometer to argue for the quantum nature of gravity as well as to formulate a quantum version of the equivalence principle. We first present an original derivation of the phase acquired in the conventional Sagnac matter-wave interferometer, within the Hamiltonian formalism. Then we modify the interferometer in two crucial respects. The interfering matter wave is interfered along two different distances from the centre and the interferometer is prepared in a superposition of two different angular velocities. We argue that if the radial and angular degrees of freedom of the matter wave become entangled through this experiment, then, via the equivalence principle, the gravitational field must be non-classical.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2020; v1 submitted 8 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Theoretical description and experimental simulation of quantum entanglement near open time-like curves via pseudo-density operators
Authors:
C. Marletto,
V. Vedral,
S. Virzì,
E. Rebufello,
A. Avella,
F. Piacentini,
M. Gramegna,
I. P. Degiovanni,
M. Genovese
Abstract:
Closed timelike curves are striking predictions of general relativity allowing for time-travel. They are afflicted by notorious causality issues (e.g. grandfather's paradox). Quantum models where a qubit travels back in time solve these problems, at the cost of violating quantum theory's linearity - leading e.g. to universal quantum cloning. Interestingly, linearity is violated even by open timeli…
▽ More
Closed timelike curves are striking predictions of general relativity allowing for time-travel. They are afflicted by notorious causality issues (e.g. grandfather's paradox). Quantum models where a qubit travels back in time solve these problems, at the cost of violating quantum theory's linearity - leading e.g. to universal quantum cloning. Interestingly, linearity is violated even by open timelike curves (OTCs), where the qubit does not interact with its past copy, but is initially entangled with another qubit. Non-linear dynamics is needed to avoid violating entanglement monogamy. Here we propose an alternative approach to OTCs, allowing for monogamy violations. Specifically, we describe the qubit in the OTC via a pseudo-density operator - a unified descriptor of both temporal and spatial correlations. We also simulate the monogamy violation with polarization-entangled photons, providing a pseudo-density operator quantum tomography. Remarkably, our proposal applies to any space-time correlations violating entanglement monogamy, such as those arising in black holes.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Answers to a few questions regarding the BMV experiment
Authors:
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral
Abstract:
We provide brief answers to a number of recurring questions about the BMV effect and the related experimental proposal (Bose et al., 2017; Marletto and Vedral, 2017). Some of these questions include alleged counter-examples to our result, stating that if gravity (or anything mediating the interaction) can create entanglement while complying with locality, then it must then be non-classical. Here w…
▽ More
We provide brief answers to a number of recurring questions about the BMV effect and the related experimental proposal (Bose et al., 2017; Marletto and Vedral, 2017). Some of these questions include alleged counter-examples to our result, stating that if gravity (or anything mediating the interaction) can create entanglement while complying with locality, then it must then be non-classical. Here we explain why these objections are not counter-examples and why our result still stands; we also explore a few other important subtleties often disregarded on a first read of our paper (Marletto and Vedral, 2017).
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Is the fermionic exchange phase also acquired locally?
Authors:
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral
Abstract:
We argue that the fermionic exchange phase could be detected by local means. We propose a simple experiment to test our idea. This leads us to speculate that there might be a deeper mechanism behind the notion of particle statistics in quantum physics that goes beyond the conventional argument based on the spin-statistics connections.
We argue that the fermionic exchange phase could be detected by local means. We propose a simple experiment to test our idea. This leads us to speculate that there might be a deeper mechanism behind the notion of particle statistics in quantum physics that goes beyond the conventional argument based on the spin-statistics connections.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
The Aharonov-Bohm phase is locally generated (like all other quantum phases)
Authors:
C. Marletto,
V. Vedral
Abstract:
In the Aharonov-Bohm (AB) effect, a superposed charge acquires a detectable phase by enclosing an infinite solenoid, in a region where the solenoid's electric and magnetic fields are zero. Its generation seems therefore explainable only by the local action of gauge-dependent potentials, not of gauge-independent fields. This was recently challenged by Vaidman, who explained the phase by the solenoi…
▽ More
In the Aharonov-Bohm (AB) effect, a superposed charge acquires a detectable phase by enclosing an infinite solenoid, in a region where the solenoid's electric and magnetic fields are zero. Its generation seems therefore explainable only by the local action of gauge-dependent potentials, not of gauge-independent fields. This was recently challenged by Vaidman, who explained the phase by the solenoid's current interacting with the electron's field (at the solenoid). Still, his model has a residual non-locality: it does not explain how the phase, generated at the solenoid, is detectable on the charge. In this paper we solve this non-locality explicitly, by quantising the field. We show that the AB phase is mediated locally by the entanglement between the charge and the photons, like all electromagnetic phases. We also predict a gauge-invariant value for the phase difference at each point along the charge's path. We propose a realistic experiment to measure this phase difference locally, by partial quantum state tomography on the charge, without closing the interference loop.
△ Less
Submitted 22 July, 2020; v1 submitted 8 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Witnesses of non-classicality for simulated hybrid quantum systems
Authors:
Gaurav Bhole,
Jonathan A. Jones,
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral
Abstract:
The task of testing whether quantum theory applies to all physical systems and all scales requires considering situations where a quantum probe interacts with another system that need not obey quantum theory in full. Important examples include the cases where a quantum mass probes the gravitational field, for which a unique quantum theory of gravity does not yet exist, or a quantum field, such as…
▽ More
The task of testing whether quantum theory applies to all physical systems and all scales requires considering situations where a quantum probe interacts with another system that need not obey quantum theory in full. Important examples include the cases where a quantum mass probes the gravitational field, for which a unique quantum theory of gravity does not yet exist, or a quantum field, such as light, interacts with a macroscopic system, such as a biological molecule, which may or may not obey unitary quantum theory. In this context a class of experiments has recently been proposed, where the non-classicality of a physical system that need not obey quantum theory (the gravitational field) can be tested indirectly by detecting whether or not the system is capable of entangling two quantum probes. Here we illustrate some of the subtleties of the argument, to do with the role of locality of interactions and of non-classicality, and perform proof-of-principle experiments illustrating the logic of the proposals, using a Nuclear Magnetic Resonance quantum computational platform with four qubits.
△ Less
Submitted 3 December, 2019; v1 submitted 22 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Non-commuting degrees of freedom in linear quantum gravity
Authors:
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral
Abstract:
We analyse our recently proposed experiment to witness indirectly non-commuting degrees of freedom in gravity, in the light of the analogy between the electromagnetic and the gravitational field. We thereby identify the non-commuting gravitational degrees of freedom in the linear regime of Einstein's General Relativity. They are the electric-like and the magnetic-like components of the Christoffel…
▽ More
We analyse our recently proposed experiment to witness indirectly non-commuting degrees of freedom in gravity, in the light of the analogy between the electromagnetic and the gravitational field. We thereby identify the non-commuting gravitational degrees of freedom in the linear regime of Einstein's General Relativity. They are the electric-like and the magnetic-like components of the Christoffel symbol, in the weak limit of gravity. The equivalence principle can then be used to suggest further experiments of the quantum nature of gravity, exploiting acceleration only.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Quantum-gravity effects could in principle be witnessed in neutrino-like oscillations
Authors:
C. Marletto,
V. Vedral,
D. Deutsch
Abstract:
Two of us (CM and VV) recently showed how the quantum character of a physical system, in particular the gravitational field, can in principle be witnessed without directly measuring observables of that system, solely by its ability to mediate entanglement between two other systems. Here we propose a variant of that scheme, where the entanglement is again generated via gravitational interaction, bu…
▽ More
Two of us (CM and VV) recently showed how the quantum character of a physical system, in particular the gravitational field, can in principle be witnessed without directly measuring observables of that system, solely by its ability to mediate entanglement between two other systems. Here we propose a variant of that scheme, where the entanglement is again generated via gravitational interaction, but now between two particles both at sharp locations (very close to each other) but each in a superposition of two different masses. We discuss an in-principle example using two hypothetical massive, neutral, weakly-interacting particles generated in a superposition of different masses. The key property of such particles would be that, like neutrinos, they are affected only by weak nuclear interactions and gravity.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
When can gravity path-entangle two spatially superposed masses?
Authors:
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral
Abstract:
An experimental test of quantum effects in gravity has recently been proposed, where the ability of the gravitational field to entangle two masses is used as a witness of its quantum nature. The key idea is that if gravity can generate entanglement between two masses then it must have at least some quantum features (i.e., two non-commuting observables). Here we discuss what existing models for cou…
▽ More
An experimental test of quantum effects in gravity has recently been proposed, where the ability of the gravitational field to entangle two masses is used as a witness of its quantum nature. The key idea is that if gravity can generate entanglement between two masses then it must have at least some quantum features (i.e., two non-commuting observables). Here we discuss what existing models for coupled matter and gravity predict for this experiment. Collapse-type models, and also quantum field theory in curved spacetime, as well as various induced gravities, do not predict entanglement generation; they would therefore be ruled out by observing entanglement in the experiment. Instead, local linearised quantum gravity models predict that the masses can become entangled. We analyse the mechanism by which entanglement is established in such models, modelling a gravity-assisted two-qubit gate.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Probing quantum features of photosynthetic organisms
Authors:
Tanjung Krisnanda,
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral,
Mauro Paternostro,
Tomasz Paterek
Abstract:
Recent experiments have demonstrated strong coupling between living bacteria and light. Here we propose a scheme capable of revealing non-classical features of the bacteria (quantum discord of light-bacteria correlations) without exact modelling of the organisms and their interactions with external world. The scheme puts the bacteria in a role of mediators of quantum entanglement between otherwise…
▽ More
Recent experiments have demonstrated strong coupling between living bacteria and light. Here we propose a scheme capable of revealing non-classical features of the bacteria (quantum discord of light-bacteria correlations) without exact modelling of the organisms and their interactions with external world. The scheme puts the bacteria in a role of mediators of quantum entanglement between otherwise non-interacting probing light modes. We then propose a plausible model of this experiment, using recently achieved parameters, demonstrating the feasibility of the scheme. Within this model we find that the steady state entanglement between the probes, which does not depend on the initial conditions, is accompanied by entanglement between the probes and bacteria, and provides independent evidence of the strong coupling between them.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2018; v1 submitted 17 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Gravitationally-induced entanglement between two massive particles is sufficient evidence of quantum effects in gravity
Authors:
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral
Abstract:
All existing quantum gravity proposals share the same deep problem. Their predictions are extremely hard to test in practice. Quantum effects in the gravitational field are exceptionally small, unlike those in the electromagnetic field. The fundamental reason is that the gravitational coupling constant is about 43 orders of magnitude smaller than the fine structure constant, which governs light-ma…
▽ More
All existing quantum gravity proposals share the same deep problem. Their predictions are extremely hard to test in practice. Quantum effects in the gravitational field are exceptionally small, unlike those in the electromagnetic field. The fundamental reason is that the gravitational coupling constant is about 43 orders of magnitude smaller than the fine structure constant, which governs light-matter interactions. For example, the detection of gravitons -- the hypothetical quanta of energy of the gravitational field predicted by certain quantum-gravity proposals -- is deemed to be practically impossible. In this letter we adopt a radically different, quantum-information-theoretic approach which circumvents the problem that quantum gravity is hard to test. We propose an experiment to witness quantum-like features in the gravitational field, by probing it with two masses each in a superposition of two locations. First, we prove the fact that any system (e.g. a field) capable of mediating entanglement between two quantum systems must itself be quantum. This argument is general and does not rely on any specific dynamics. Then, we propose an experiment to detect the entanglement generated between two masses via gravitational interaction. By our argument, the degree of entanglement between the masses is an indirect witness of the quantisation of the field mediating the interaction. Remarkably, this experiment does not require any quantum control over gravity itself. It is also closer to realisation than other proposals, such as detecting gravitons or detecting quantum gravitational vacuum fluctuations.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2017; v1 submitted 19 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
Witnessing quantumness of a system by observing only its classical features
Authors:
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral
Abstract:
Witnessing non-classicality in the gravitational field has been claimed to be practically impossible. This constitutes a deep problem, which has even lead some researchers to question whether gravity should be quantised, due to the weakness of quantum effects. To counteract these claims, we propose a thought experiment that witnesses non-classicality of a physical system by probing it with a qubit…
▽ More
Witnessing non-classicality in the gravitational field has been claimed to be practically impossible. This constitutes a deep problem, which has even lead some researchers to question whether gravity should be quantised, due to the weakness of quantum effects. To counteract these claims, we propose a thought experiment that witnesses non-classicality of a physical system by probing it with a qubit. Remarkably, this experiment does not require any quantum control of the system, involving only measuring a single classical observable on that system. In addition, our scheme does not even assume any specific dynamics. That non-classicality of a system can be established indirectly, by coupling it to a qubit, opens up the possibility that quantum gravitational effects could in fact be witnessed in the lab.
△ Less
Submitted 1 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
Why we need to quantise everything, including gravity
Authors:
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral
Abstract:
There is a long-standing debate about whether gravity should be quantised. A powerful line of argument in favour of quantum gravity considers models of hybrid systems consisting of coupled quantum-classical sectors. The conclusion is that such models are inconsistent: either the quantum sector's defining properties necessarily spread to the classical sector, or they are violated. These arguments h…
▽ More
There is a long-standing debate about whether gravity should be quantised. A powerful line of argument in favour of quantum gravity considers models of hybrid systems consisting of coupled quantum-classical sectors. The conclusion is that such models are inconsistent: either the quantum sector's defining properties necessarily spread to the classical sector, or they are violated. These arguments have a long history, starting with the debates about the quantum nature of the electromagnetic fields in the early days of quantum theory. Yet, they have limited scope because they rely on particular dynamical models obeying restrictive conditions, such as unitarity. In this paper we propose a radically new, more general argument, relying on less restrictive assumptions. The key feature is an information-theoretic characterisation of both sectors, including their interaction, via constraints on copying operations. These operations are necessary for the existence of observables in any physical theory, because they constitute the most general representation of measurement interactions. Remarkably, our argument is formulated without resorting to particular dynamical models, thus being applicable to any hybrid system, even those ruled by "post-quantum" theories. Its conclusion is also compatible with partially quantum systems, such as those that exhibit features like complementarity, but may lack others, such as entanglement. As an example, we consider a hybrid system of qubits and rebits. Surprisingly, despite the rebit's lack of complex amplitudes, the signature quantum protocols such as teleportation are still possible.
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Entanglement between living bacteria and quantized light witnessed by Rabi splitting
Authors:
C. Marletto,
D. M. Coles,
T. Farrow,
V. Vedral
Abstract:
We model recent experiments on living sulphur bacteria interacting with quantised light, using the Dicke model. The strong coupling achieved between the bacteria and the light indicates that during the experiment the bacteria (treated as dipoles) and the quantized light are entangled. The vacuum Rabi splitting, which was measured in the experiment for a range of different parameters, can be used a…
▽ More
We model recent experiments on living sulphur bacteria interacting with quantised light, using the Dicke model. The strong coupling achieved between the bacteria and the light indicates that during the experiment the bacteria (treated as dipoles) and the quantized light are entangled. The vacuum Rabi splitting, which was measured in the experiment for a range of different parameters, can be used as an entanglement witness.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Evolution without evolution, and without ambiguities
Authors:
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral
Abstract:
In quantum theory it is possible to explain time, and dynamics, in terms of entanglement. This is the timeless approach to time, which assumes that the universe is in a stationary state, where two non-interacting subsystems, the clock and the rest, are entangled. As a consequence, by choosing a suitable observable of the clock, the relative state of the rest of the universe evolves unitarily with…
▽ More
In quantum theory it is possible to explain time, and dynamics, in terms of entanglement. This is the timeless approach to time, which assumes that the universe is in a stationary state, where two non-interacting subsystems, the clock and the rest, are entangled. As a consequence, by choosing a suitable observable of the clock, the relative state of the rest of the universe evolves unitarily with respect to the variable labelling the clock observable's eigenstates, which is then interpreted as time. This model for an evolution without evolution (Page and Wootters, 1983), albeit elegant, has never been developed further, because it was criticised for generating severe ambiguities in the dynamics of the rest of the universe. In this paper we show that there are no such ambiguities, we also update the model, making it amenable to possible new applications.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2016; v1 submitted 15 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Constructor Theory of Probability
Authors:
Chiara Marletto
Abstract:
Unitary quantum theory, having no Born Rule, is non-probabilistic. Hence the notorious problem of reconciling it with the unpredictability and appearance of stochasticity in quantum measurements. Generalising and improving upon the so-called 'decision-theoretic approach' (Deutsch, 1999; Wallace, 2003, 2007, 2012), I shall recast that problem in the recently proposed constructor theory of informati…
▽ More
Unitary quantum theory, having no Born Rule, is non-probabilistic. Hence the notorious problem of reconciling it with the unpredictability and appearance of stochasticity in quantum measurements. Generalising and improving upon the so-called 'decision-theoretic approach' (Deutsch, 1999; Wallace, 2003, 2007, 2012), I shall recast that problem in the recently proposed constructor theory of information - where quantum theory is represented as one of a class of superinformation theories, which are local, non-probabilistic theories conforming to certain constructor-theoretic conditions. I prove that the unpredictability of measurement outcomes (to which I give an exact meaning via constructor theory), necessarily arises in superinformation theories. Then I explain how the appearance of stochasticity in (finitely many) repeated measurements can arise under superinformation theories. And I establish sufficient conditions for a superinformation theory to inform decisions (made under it) as if it were probabilistic, via a Deutsch-Wallace-type argument - thus defining a class of decision-supporting superinformation theories. This broadens the domain of applicability of that argument to cover constructor-theory compliant theories. In addition, in this version some of the argument's assumptions, previously construed as merely decision-theoretic, follow from physical properties expressed by constructor-theoretic principles.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2016; v1 submitted 12 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
