Showing 1–48 of 48 results for author: Gill, R

Further comments on "Is the moon there if nobody looks? Bell inequalities and physical reality"

Authors: Richard D. Gill

Abstract: Kupczynski (2023) claims that Gill and Lambare (2022a, 2022b) misrepresent several of his published papers. This paper shows that the latest version of his "contextuality by default" model of a Bell experiment places no constraints whatsoever on the statistics of observed results in Bell type experiments. It thereby effectively allows arbitrary non-locality, ie direct causal effects of local measu… ▽ More Kupczynski (2023) claims that Gill and Lambare (2022a, 2022b) misrepresent several of his published papers. This paper shows that the latest version of his "contextuality by default" model of a Bell experiment places no constraints whatsoever on the statistics of observed results in Bell type experiments. It thereby effectively allows arbitrary non-locality, ie direct causal effects of local measurement settings on distant measurement outcomes. △ Less

Submitted 4 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Comments: 6 pages

Bell's theorem is an exercise in the statistical theory of causality

Authors: Richard D. Gill

Abstract: In this short note, I derive the Bell-CHSH inequalities as an elementary result in the present-day theory of statistical causality based on graphical models or Bayes' nets, defined in terms of DAGs (Directed Acyclic Graphs) representing direct statistical causal influences between a number of observed and unobserved random variables. I show how spatio-temporal constraints in loophole-free Bell exp… ▽ More In this short note, I derive the Bell-CHSH inequalities as an elementary result in the present-day theory of statistical causality based on graphical models or Bayes' nets, defined in terms of DAGs (Directed Acyclic Graphs) representing direct statistical causal influences between a number of observed and unobserved random variables. I show how spatio-temporal constraints in loophole-free Bell experiments, and natural classical statistical causality considerations, lead to Bell's notion of local hidden variables, and thence to the CHSH inequalities. The word "local" applies to the way that the chosen settings influence the observed outcomes. The case of contextual setting-dependent hidden variables (thought of as being located in the measurement devices and dependent on the measurement settings) is automatically covered, despite recent claims that Bell's conclusions can be circumvented in this way. △ Less

Submitted 20 March, 2023; v1 submitted 10 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: 5 pages; version 2: corrected some annoying (because confusing) math typos. arXiv admin note: substantial text overlap with arXiv:2208.09930

Commentary: Is the moon there if nobody looks -- Bell inequalities and physical reality

Authors: Richard D. Gill, Justo P. Lambare

Abstract: Marian Kupczynski(MK)is the author of a controversial paper published (2020) in the journal Frontiers in Physics. The work is built around a mathematical claim by MK which is actually false, and MK's logical reasoning around his claim is also incorrect. The same claim was made by him in several other recent papers published in other journals. A proof that the claimed result is false is the main co… ▽ More Marian Kupczynski(MK)is the author of a controversial paper published (2020) in the journal Frontiers in Physics. The work is built around a mathematical claim by MK which is actually false, and MK's logical reasoning around his claim is also incorrect. The same claim was made by him in several other recent papers published in other journals. A proof that the claimed result is false is the main content of our present "Comment". It is purely a mathematical counter-example to a mathematical claim in a number of MK's papers. △ Less

Submitted 16 January, 2023; v1 submitted 4 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: 4 pages. arXiv admin note: substantial text overlap with arXiv:2208.09930. The overlap is with a much longer preprint containing much extra material, and which the authors are submitting to another journal

Journal ref: Front. Phys., 09 December 2022, Sec. Statistical and Computational Physics

Comment on: Bell tests explained by classical optics without quantum entanglement

Authors: Richard D. Gill

Abstract: In a paper published in the journal Physics Essays in 2021, the author D.L. Mamas writes "A polarized photon interacts with a polarizer through the component of the photon's electric field which is aligned with the polarizer. This component varies as the cosine of the angle through which the polarizer is rotated, explaining the cosine observed in Bell test data. Quantum mechanics is unnecessary an… ▽ More In a paper published in the journal Physics Essays in 2021, the author D.L. Mamas writes "A polarized photon interacts with a polarizer through the component of the photon's electric field which is aligned with the polarizer. This component varies as the cosine of the angle through which the polarizer is rotated, explaining the cosine observed in Bell test data. Quantum mechanics is unnecessary and plays no role". Mamas is right that according to this physical model, one will observe a negative cosine. However, the amplitude of the cosine curve is 50%, not 100%, and it consequently does not violate any Bell-CHSH inequality. Mamas' physical model is a classic local hidden variables model. The result is illustrated with a Monte Carlo simulation. △ Less

Submitted 1 May, 2023; v1 submitted 2 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: Version 5. Accepted by Physics Essays. 5pp

Journal ref: Physics Essays, Volume 36, Number 1, March 2023, pp. 87-89(3)

Optimal statistical analyses of Bell experiments

Authors: Richard D. Gill

Abstract: We show how both smaller and more reliable p-values can be computed in Bell-type experiments by using statistical deviations from no-signalling equalities to reduce statistical noise in the estimation of Bell's S or Eberhard's J. Further improvement is obtained by using Wilks' likelihood ratio test based on the four tetranomially distributed vectors of counts of the four different outcome combinat… ▽ More We show how both smaller and more reliable p-values can be computed in Bell-type experiments by using statistical deviations from no-signalling equalities to reduce statistical noise in the estimation of Bell's S or Eberhard's J. Further improvement is obtained by using Wilks' likelihood ratio test based on the four tetranomially distributed vectors of counts of the four different outcome combinations, one 4-vector for each of the four setting combinations. The methodology is illustrated by application to the loophole-free Bell experiments of 2015 and 2016 performed in Delft and Munich, at NIST, and in Vienna respectively; and also to the earlier Innsbruck experiment of Weihs et al. (1998) and the recent Munich experiment of Zhang et al. (2022), which investigates use of a loophole-free Bell experiment as part of a protocol for Device Independent Quantum Key Distribution, DIQKD. △ Less

Submitted 1 May, 2023; v1 submitted 1 September, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Comments: 16 pages. Version 4: added a section with a potted history of Bell experiments in order to give a useful bibliography and a starting point for those wanting to learn more about the physics context

Kupczynski's Contextual Locally Causal Probabilistic Models are constrained by Bell's theorem

Authors: Richard D. Gill, Justo Pastor Lambare

Abstract: In a sequence of papers, Marian Kupczynski has argued that Bell's theorem can be circumvented if one takes correct account of contextual setting-dependent parameters describing measuring instruments. We show that this is not true. Despite first appearances, Kupczynksi's concept of a contextual locally causal probabilistic model is mathematically a special case of a Bell local hidden variables mode… ▽ More In a sequence of papers, Marian Kupczynski has argued that Bell's theorem can be circumvented if one takes correct account of contextual setting-dependent parameters describing measuring instruments. We show that this is not true. Despite first appearances, Kupczynksi's concept of a contextual locally causal probabilistic model is mathematically a special case of a Bell local hidden variables model. Thus, even if one takes account of contextuality in the way he suggests, the Bell-CHSH inequality can still be derived. Violation thereof by quantum mechanics cannot be easily explained away: quantum mechanics and local realism (including Kupczynski's claimed enlargement of the concept) are not compatible with one another. Further inspection shows that Kupczynski is actually falling back on the detection loophole. Since 2015, numerous loophole-free experiments have been performed, in which the Bell-CHSH inequality is violated, so despite any other possible imperfections of such experiments, Kupczynski's escape route for local realism is not available △ Less

Submitted 2 June, 2023; v1 submitted 21 August, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

Comments: Version 8. 15 pages. Final version for "Quantum reports"

Quantum Computation, Data Science, and Bell games

Authors: Richard D. Gill

Abstract: I draw attention to statistical, probabilistic, computer science aspects of the highly related topics of the Bell game and of a possible future Quantum Internet. I draw attention to statistical, probabilistic, computer science aspects of the highly related topics of the Bell game and of a possible future Quantum Internet. △ Less

Submitted 27 May, 2022; v1 submitted 11 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Comments: Invited discussion of paper to appear very soon in Harvard Data Science Review by Yazhen Wang. Revision 1 - some typos corrected

Journal ref: Harvard Data Science Review 2022, 4(1). https://hdsr.mitpress.mit.edu/pub/4ioy3d9j/release/3

Comment on "Quantum correlations are weaved by the spinors of the Euclidean primitives"

Authors: Richard D. Gill

Abstract: I point out fatal mathematical errors in the paper "Quantum correlations are weaved by the spinors of the Euclidean primitives" by Joy Christian, published (2019) in the journal Royal Society Open Science. I point out fatal mathematical errors in the paper "Quantum correlations are weaved by the spinors of the Euclidean primitives" by Joy Christian, published (2019) in the journal Royal Society Open Science. △ Less

Submitted 27 May, 2022; v1 submitted 6 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Comments: Written by invitation of the editors of "Royal Society Open Science". Hopefully now nearly final version

Journal ref: R. Soc. open sci. (2022) 9, 201909

Comment on "Bell's Theorem Versus Local Realism in a Quaternionic Model of Physical Space"

Authors: Richard D. Gill

Abstract: I point out critical errors in the paper "Bell's Theorem Versus Local Realism in a Quaternionic Model of Physical Space" by J. Christian, published in IEEE Access. Christian's paper in fact contains several conflicting models. None of them form counterexamples to Bell's theorem. Most of Christian's paper is devoted to a model based on the detection loophole due to Pearle (1970). I point out critical errors in the paper "Bell's Theorem Versus Local Realism in a Quaternionic Model of Physical Space" by J. Christian, published in IEEE Access. Christian's paper in fact contains several conflicting models. None of them form counterexamples to Bell's theorem. Most of Christian's paper is devoted to a model based on the detection loophole due to Pearle (1970). △ Less

Submitted 27 May, 2022; v1 submitted 27 February, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Comments: 6 pages. This is version 4 - the paper is yet again revised in response to a third round of refereeing by an unusually large number of referees many of whom disagree with one another

Journal ref: IEEE Access, vol. 9, pp. 154933-154937, 2021, https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/9622238

Gull's theorem revisited

Authors: Richard D. Gill

Abstract: Steve Gull, in unpublished work available on his Cambridge University homepage, has outlined a proof of Bell's theorem using Fourier theory. Gull's philosophy is that Bell's theorem (or perhaps a key lemma in its proof) can be seen as a no-go theorem for a project in distributed computing with classical, not quantum, computers. We present his argument, correcting misprints and filling gaps. In his… ▽ More Steve Gull, in unpublished work available on his Cambridge University homepage, has outlined a proof of Bell's theorem using Fourier theory. Gull's philosophy is that Bell's theorem (or perhaps a key lemma in its proof) can be seen as a no-go theorem for a project in distributed computing with classical, not quantum, computers. We present his argument, correcting misprints and filling gaps. In his argument, there were two completely separated computers in the network. We need three in order to fill all the gaps in his proof: a third computer supplies a stream of random numbers to the two computers representing the two measurement stations in Bell's work. One could also imagine that computer replaced by a cloned, virtual computer, generating the same pseudo-random numbers within each of Alice and Bob's computers. Either way, we need an assumption of the presence of shared i.i.d. randomness in the form of a synchronised sequence of realisations of i.i.d. hidden variables underlying the otherwise deterministic physics of the sequence of trials. Gull's proof then just needs a third step: rewriting an expectation as the expectation of a conditional expectation given the hidden variables. △ Less

Submitted 27 May, 2022; v1 submitted 1 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Comments: Version 8: minor corrections. arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:2001.11338

Journal ref: Entropy 2022, 24(5), 679. https://www.mdpi.com/1099-4300/24/5/679

Comment on "Dr. Bertlmann's Socks in a Quaternionic World of Ambidextral Reality"

Authors: Richard D. Gill

Abstract: I point out critical errors in the paper "Dr. Bertlmann's Socks in a Quaternionic World of Ambidextral Reality" by Joy~Christian, published in IEEE Access. Christian's model does not generate the singlet correlations but in fact simply reproduces the Bertlmann effect. John Bell's friend and colleague Reinhold Bertlmann of CERN, in his younger days, always wore one pink and one blue sock, at random… ▽ More I point out critical errors in the paper "Dr. Bertlmann's Socks in a Quaternionic World of Ambidextral Reality" by Joy~Christian, published in IEEE Access. Christian's model does not generate the singlet correlations but in fact simply reproduces the Bertlmann effect. John Bell's friend and colleague Reinhold Bertlmann of CERN, in his younger days, always wore one pink and one blue sock, at random. The moment you saw his left foot, you knew what colour sock would be on his right foot. Action at a distance? As John Bell liked to explain, quantum entanglement cannot be explained away in such an easy way. Yet Christian's model assigns the two particles of the EPR-B experiment an equal and opposite spin at the source, the choice being determined by a fair coin toss. However they are measured, these spins are recovered. Christian's computer simulation works by not actually simulating his model at all but by almost directly tracing the negative cosine built into his computer algebra package. Bell's theorem has not been disproved. Debate as to what it means for the foundations of physics as well as for quantum information engineering (quantum communication, computation) is more lively today than ever before. Christian's paper, alas, does not contribute to the debate, but distracts from it. A possible role for Geometric Algebra is still wide open and deserves further investigation, informed by a proper understanding of the mathematical content of Bell's theorem. △ Less

Submitted 27 May, 2022; v1 submitted 30 January, 2020; originally announced January 2020.

Comments: 8 pages. Version 8. Final, accepted version

MSC Class: 81P45

Journal ref: IEEE Access, vol. 9, pp. 44592-44598, 2021. https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/9380450

Event based simulation of an EPR-B experiment by local hidden variables: epr-simple and epr-clocked

Authors: Richard D. Gill

Abstract: In this note, I analyze the data generated by M. Fodje's (2013, 2014) simulation programs "epr-simple" and "epr-clocked". They were written in Python and published on Github. Inspection of the program descriptions showed that they made use of the detection-loophole and the coincidence-loophole respectively. I evaluate them with appropriate modified Bell-CHSH type inequalities: the Larsson detectio… ▽ More In this note, I analyze the data generated by M. Fodje's (2013, 2014) simulation programs "epr-simple" and "epr-clocked". They were written in Python and published on Github. Inspection of the program descriptions showed that they made use of the detection-loophole and the coincidence-loophole respectively. I evaluate them with appropriate modified Bell-CHSH type inequalities: the Larsson detection-loophole adjusted CHSH, and the Larsson-Gill coincidence-loophole adjusted CHSH (NB: its correctness is conjecture, we do not have proof). The experimental efficiencies turn out to be approximately eta = 81% (close to optimal) and gamma = 55% (far from optimal). The observed values of CHSH are, as they should be, within the appropriately adjusted bounds. Fodjes' detection-loophole model turns out to be very, very close to Pearle's famous 1970 model, so the efficiency is close to optimal. The model has the same defect as Pearle's: the joint detection rates exhibit signalling. His coincidence-loophole model is actually a clever modification of his detection-loophole model. Because of this, however, it cannot lead to optimal efficiency. △ Less

Submitted 10 April, 2021; v1 submitted 1 July, 2015; originally announced July 2015.

Comments: This is version 11 of this preprint. Earlier versions incorrectly stated that documentation of Michel Fodje's simulation was inexistent. This version also contains better explanation of my terminology. It is also posted on Researchers.one, article 2020-01-1. Another version on preprints.org, preprints202001.0045, is being updated

MSC Class: 81P45

No probability loophole in the CHSH

Authors: Richard D. Gill

Abstract: Geurdes (2014, Results in Physics) outlines a probabilistic construction of a counterexample to Bell's theorem. He gives a procedure to repeatedly sample from a specially constructed "pool" of local hidden variable models (depending on a table of numerically calculated parameters) and select from the results one LHV model, determining a random value S of the usual CHSH combination of four (theoret… ▽ More Geurdes (2014, Results in Physics) outlines a probabilistic construction of a counterexample to Bell's theorem. He gives a procedure to repeatedly sample from a specially constructed "pool" of local hidden variable models (depending on a table of numerically calculated parameters) and select from the results one LHV model, determining a random value S of the usual CHSH combination of four (theoretical) correlation values. He claims Prob(|S| > 2) > 0. We expose a fatal flaw in the analysis: the procedure generates a non-local hidden variable model. To disprove this claim, Geurdes should program his procedure and generate random LHV's till he finds one violating the CHSH inequality. △ Less

Submitted 27 May, 2022; v1 submitted 31 May, 2015; originally announced June 2015.

Comments: version 3: major revision, new analysis, identification of main error

Journal ref: Results in Physics, Volume 5, 2015, Pages 156-157. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2211379715000315

Pearle's Hidden-Variable Model Revisited

Authors: Richard D. Gill

Abstract: Pearle (1970) gave an example of a local hidden variables model which exactly reproduced the singlet correlations of quantum theory, through the device of data-rejection: particles can fail to be detected in a way which depends on the hidden variables carried by the particles and on the measurement settings. If the experimenter computes correlations between measurement outcomes of particle pairs f… ▽ More Pearle (1970) gave an example of a local hidden variables model which exactly reproduced the singlet correlations of quantum theory, through the device of data-rejection: particles can fail to be detected in a way which depends on the hidden variables carried by the particles and on the measurement settings. If the experimenter computes correlations between measurement outcomes of particle pairs for which both particles are detected, he is actually looking at a subsample of particle pairs, determined by interaction involving both measurement settings and the hidden variables carried in the particles. We correct a mistake in Pearle's formulas (a normalization error) and more importantly show that the model is more simple than first appears. We illustrate with visualisations of the model and with a small simulation experiment, with code in the statistical programming language R included in the paper. Open problems are discussed. △ Less

Submitted 30 January, 2020; v1 submitted 17 May, 2015; originally announced May 2015.

Comments: 19pp. This is now arXiv version 4 = final revision for journal

MSC Class: 81P45

Journal ref: Entropy 2020, 22(1), 1; https://doi.org/10.3390/e22010001

Macroscopic Unobservability of Spinorial Sign Changes

Authors: Richard D. Gill

Abstract: In Section 5 of Christian (2014), published in IJTP, an experiment is described which is purported to have the capacity for exhibiting quantum correlations in a completely classical environment. Unfortunately the experiment has an interesting self-destructive property: it is certain not to deliver the required result, hence it is pretty certain that no experimenter will ever bother to perform it. In Section 5 of Christian (2014), published in IJTP, an experiment is described which is purported to have the capacity for exhibiting quantum correlations in a completely classical environment. Unfortunately the experiment has an interesting self-destructive property: it is certain not to deliver the required result, hence it is pretty certain that no experimenter will ever bother to perform it. △ Less

Submitted 1 May, 2023; v1 submitted 8 December, 2014; originally announced December 2014.

Comments: Revised according to request of referee of IJTP: added comments on senselessness of bivectorial correlation in context of Bell's theorem

Journal ref: International Journal of Theoretical Physics volume 55, pages 255-257 (2016)

The triangle wave versus the cosine: How classical systems can optimally approximate EPR-B correlations

Authors: Richard D. Gill

Abstract: The famous singlet correlations of a composite quantum system consisting of two spatially separated components exhibit notable features of two kinds. The first kind consists of striking certainty relations: perfect correlation and perfect anti-correlation in certain settings. The second kind consists of a number of symmetries, in particular, invariance under rotation, as well as invariance under e… ▽ More The famous singlet correlations of a composite quantum system consisting of two spatially separated components exhibit notable features of two kinds. The first kind consists of striking certainty relations: perfect correlation and perfect anti-correlation in certain settings. The second kind consists of a number of symmetries, in particular, invariance under rotation, as well as invariance under exchange of components, parity, or chirality. In this note, I investigate the class of correlation functions that can be generated by classical composite physical systems when we restrict attention to systems which reproduce the certainty relations exactly, and for which the rotational invariance of the correlation function is the manifestation of rotational invariance of the underlying classical physics. I call such correlation functions classical EPR-B correlations. It turns out that the other three (binary) symmetries can then be obtained "for free": they are exhibited by the correlation function, and can be imposed on the underlying physics by adding an underlying randomisation level. We end up with a simple probabilistic description of all possible classical EPR-B correlations in terms of a "spinning coloured disk" model, and a research programme: describe these functions in a concise analytic way. We survey open problems, and we show that the widespread idea that "quantum correlations are more extreme than classical physics allows" is at best highly inaccurate, through giving a concrete example of a classical correlation which satisfies all the symmetries and all the certainty relations and which exceeds the quantum correlations over a whole range of settings △ Less

Submitted 6 December, 2022; v1 submitted 22 December, 2013; originally announced December 2013.

Comments: This version, arXiv:1312.6403v.6, as accepted by "Entropy" 27 February 2020

MSC Class: 81P45

Journal ref: Entropy 2020, 22(3), 287

Quantum local asymptotic normality based on a new quantum likelihood ratio

Authors: Koichi Yamagata, Akio Fujiwara, Richard D. Gill

Abstract: We develop a theory of local asymptotic normality in the quantum domain based on a novel quantum analogue of the log-likelihood ratio. This formulation is applicable to any quantum statistical model satisfying a mild smoothness condition. As an application, we prove the asymptotic achievability of the Holevo bound for the local shift parameter. We develop a theory of local asymptotic normality in the quantum domain based on a novel quantum analogue of the log-likelihood ratio. This formulation is applicable to any quantum statistical model satisfying a mild smoothness condition. As an application, we prove the asymptotic achievability of the Holevo bound for the local shift parameter. △ Less

Submitted 8 November, 2013; v1 submitted 13 October, 2012; originally announced October 2012.

Comments: Published in at http://dx.doi.org/10.1214/13-AOS1147 the Annals of Statistics (http://www.imstat.org/aos/) by the Institute of Mathematical Statistics (http://www.imstat.org)

Report number: IMS-AOS-AOS1147

Journal ref: Annals of Statistics 2013, Vol. 41, No. 4, 2197-2217

Statistics, Causality and Bell's Theorem

Authors: Richard D. Gill

Abstract: Bell's [Physics 1 (1964) 195-200] theorem is popularly supposed to establish the nonlocality of quantum physics. Violation of Bell's inequality in experiments such as that of Aspect, Dalibard and Roger [Phys. Rev. Lett. 49 (1982) 1804-1807] provides empirical proof of nonlocality in the real world. This paper reviews recent work on Bell's theorem, linking it to issues in causality as understood by… ▽ More Bell's [Physics 1 (1964) 195-200] theorem is popularly supposed to establish the nonlocality of quantum physics. Violation of Bell's inequality in experiments such as that of Aspect, Dalibard and Roger [Phys. Rev. Lett. 49 (1982) 1804-1807] provides empirical proof of nonlocality in the real world. This paper reviews recent work on Bell's theorem, linking it to issues in causality as understood by statisticians. The paper starts with a proof of a strong, finite sample, version of Bell's inequality and thereby also of Bell's theorem, which states that quantum theory is incompatible with the conjunction of three formerly uncontroversial physical principles, here referred to as locality, realism and freedom. Locality is the principle that the direction of causality matches the direction of time, and that causal influences need time to propagate spatially. Realism and freedom are directly connected to statistical thinking on causality: they relate to counterfactual reasoning, and to randomisation, respectively. Experimental loopholes in state-of-the-art Bell type experiments are related to statistical issues of post-selection in observational studies, and the missing at random assumption. They can be avoided by properly matching the statistical analysis to the actual experimental design, instead of by making untestable assumptions of independence between observed and unobserved variables. Methodological and statistical issues in the design of quantum Randi challenges (QRC) are discussed. The paper argues that Bell's theorem (and its experimental confirmation) should lead us to relinquish not locality, but realism. △ Less

Submitted 30 January, 2015; v1 submitted 21 July, 2012; originally announced July 2012.

Comments: Published in at http://dx.doi.org/10.1214/14-STS490 the Statistical Science (http://www.imstat.org/sts/) by the Institute of Mathematical Statistics (http://www.imstat.org)

Report number: IMS-STS-STS490

Journal ref: Statistical Science 2014, Vol. 29, No. 4, 512-528

A proof of Bell's inequality in quantum mechanics using causal interactions

Authors: James M. Robins, Tyler J. VanderWeele, Richard D. Gill

Abstract: We give a simple proof of Bell's inequality in quantum mechanics which, in conjunction with experiments, demonstrates that the local hidden variables assumption is false. The proof sheds light on relationships between the notion of causal interaction and interference between particles. We give a simple proof of Bell's inequality in quantum mechanics which, in conjunction with experiments, demonstrates that the local hidden variables assumption is false. The proof sheds light on relationships between the notion of causal interaction and interference between particles. △ Less

Submitted 20 July, 2012; originally announced July 2012.

Comments: http://biostats.bepress.com/cobra/art83

Report number: COBRA Preprint Series, Working Paper 83

Journal ref: Scandinavian Journal of Statistics Volume 42, Issue 2, pages 329-335, June 2015

Tomography and state reconstruction with superconducting single-photon detectors

Authors: Jelmer J. Renema, Giulia Frucci, Michiel J. A. de Dood, Richard Gill, Andrea Fiore, Martin P. van Exter

Abstract: We perform quantum state reconstruction of coherent and thermal states with a detector which has an enhanced multiphoton response. The detector is based on superconducting nanowires, where the bias current sets the dependence of the click probability on the photon number; this bias current is used as tuning parameter in the state reconstruction. The nonlinear response makes our nanowire-based dete… ▽ More We perform quantum state reconstruction of coherent and thermal states with a detector which has an enhanced multiphoton response. The detector is based on superconducting nanowires, where the bias current sets the dependence of the click probability on the photon number; this bias current is used as tuning parameter in the state reconstruction. The nonlinear response makes our nanowire-based detector superior to the linear detectors that are conventionally used for quantum state reconstruction. △ Less

Submitted 6 September, 2012; v1 submitted 22 June, 2012; originally announced June 2012.

Comments: revision of intro compared to V1

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 86, 062113 (2012) [6 pages]

Does Geometric Algebra provide a loophole to Bell's Theorem? (with corrections)

Authors: Richard D. Gill

Abstract: In 2007, and in a series of later papers, Joy Christian claimed to refute Bell's theorem, presenting an alleged local realistic model of the singlet correlations using techniques from Geometric Algebra (GA). Several authors published papers refuting his claims, and Christian's ideas did not gain acceptance. However, he recently succeeded in publishing yet more ambitious and complex versions of his… ▽ More In 2007, and in a series of later papers, Joy Christian claimed to refute Bell's theorem, presenting an alleged local realistic model of the singlet correlations using techniques from Geometric Algebra (GA). Several authors published papers refuting his claims, and Christian's ideas did not gain acceptance. However, he recently succeeded in publishing yet more ambitious and complex versions of his theory in fairly mainstream journals. How could this be? The mathematics and logic of Bell's theorem is simple and transparent and has been intensely studied and debated for over 50 years. Christian claims to have a mathematical counterexample to a purely mathematical theorem. Each new version of Christian's model used new devices to circumvent Bell's theorem or depended on a new way to misunderstand Bell's work. These devices and misinterpretations are in common use by other Bell critics, so it useful to identify and name them. I hope that this paper can serve as a useful resource to those who need to evaluate new "disproofs of Bell's theorem". Christian's fundamental idea is simple and quite original: he gives a probabilistic interpretation of the fundamental GA equation a.b = (ab + ba)/2. After that, ambiguous notation and technical complexity allow sign errors to be hidden from sight, and new mathematical errors can be introduced. △ Less

Submitted 30 March, 2021; v1 submitted 7 March, 2012; originally announced March 2012.

Comments: 11th version: minor but necessary correction to math requested by myself and some corrections to tone of text requested by editor of Entropy after evaluation of a complaint made by a third person

MSC Class: 81P45

Journal ref: Entropy 2020, 22(1), 61 (21 pp.)

On Asymptotic Quantum Statistical Inference

Authors: Richard D. Gill, Madalin Guta

Abstract: We study asymptotically optimal statistical inference concerning the unknown state of $N$ identical quantum systems, using two complementary approaches: a "poor man's approach" based on the van Trees inequality, and a rather more sophisticated approach using the recently developed quantum form of LeCam's theory of Local Asymptotic Normality. We study asymptotically optimal statistical inference concerning the unknown state of $N$ identical quantum systems, using two complementary approaches: a "poor man's approach" based on the van Trees inequality, and a rather more sophisticated approach using the recently developed quantum form of LeCam's theory of Local Asymptotic Normality. △ Less

Submitted 1 May, 2023; v1 submitted 9 December, 2011; originally announced December 2011.

Comments: 34 pages. to appear in `From Probability to Statistics and Back: High-Dimensional Models and Processes'. A Festschrift in Honor of Jon Wellner. Edited by Banerjee, M., Bunea, F., Huang, J., Maathuis, M. and Koltchinskii, V. extension of a previous paper arXiv:math/0512443

Journal ref: IMS Collections (9) 105-127, 2013 (From Probability to Statistics and Back: High-Dimensional Models and Processes A Festschrift in Honor of Jon A. Wellner Banerjee, M., Bunea, F., Huang, J., Koltchinskii, V., and Maathuis, M. H., Editors)

A tight Tsirelson inequality for infinitely many outcomes

Authors: S. Zohren, P. Reska, R. D. Gill, W. Westra

Abstract: We present a novel tight bound on the quantum violations of the CGLMP inequality in the case of infinitely many outcomes. Like in the case of Tsirelson's inequality the proof of our new inequality does not require any assumptions on the dimension of the Hilbert space or kinds of operators involved. However, it is seen that the maximal violation is obtained by the conjectured best measurements and… ▽ More We present a novel tight bound on the quantum violations of the CGLMP inequality in the case of infinitely many outcomes. Like in the case of Tsirelson's inequality the proof of our new inequality does not require any assumptions on the dimension of the Hilbert space or kinds of operators involved. However, it is seen that the maximal violation is obtained by the conjectured best measurements and a pure, but not maximally entangled, state. We give an approximate state which, in the limit where the number of outcomes tends to infinity, goes to the optimal state for this setting. This state might be potentially relevant for experimental verifications of Bell inequalities through multi-dimenisonal entangled photon pairs. △ Less

Submitted 3 May, 2010; v1 submitted 2 March, 2010; originally announced March 2010.

Comments: 5 pages, 2 figures; improved presentation, change in title, as published.

Journal ref: Europhysics Letters 90 (2010) 10002

Schrödinger's cat meets Occam's razor

Authors: Richard D. Gill

Abstract: We discuss V.P. Belavkin's (2007) approach to the Schrödinger cat problem and show its close relation to ideas based on superselection and interaction with the environment developed by N.P. Landsman (1995). The purpose of the paper is to explain these ideas in the most simple possible context, namely: discrete time and separable Hilbert spaces, in order to make them accessible to those coming from… ▽ More We discuss V.P. Belavkin's (2007) approach to the Schrödinger cat problem and show its close relation to ideas based on superselection and interaction with the environment developed by N.P. Landsman (1995). The purpose of the paper is to explain these ideas in the most simple possible context, namely: discrete time and separable Hilbert spaces, in order to make them accessible to those coming from the philosophy of science and not too happy with idiosyncratic notation and terminology and sophisticated mathematical tools. Conventional elementary mathematical descriptions of quantum mechanics take "measurement" to be a primitive concept. Paradoxes arise when we choose to consider smaller or larger systems as measurement devices in their own right, by making different and apparently arbitrary choices of location of the "Heisenberg cut". Various quantum interpretations have different resolutions of the paradox. In Belavkin's approach, the classical world around us does really exist, and it evolves stochastically and dynamically in time according to probability laws following from successive applications of the Born law. It is a collapse theory, and necessarily it is non-local. The quantum/classical distinction is determined by the arrow of time. The underlying unitary evolution of the wave-function of the universe enables the designation of a collection of beables which grows as time evolves, and which therefore can be assigned random, classical trajectories. In a slogan: the past is particles, the future is a wave. We, living in the now, are located on the cutting edge between past and future. △ Less

Submitted 6 December, 2022; v1 submitted 17 May, 2009; originally announced May 2009.

Comments: Published version: 11 pages, has now appeared in "Entropy"

Journal ref: Entropy 2022, 24(11), 1586

Maximal violation of the CGLMP inequality for infinite dimensional states

Authors: S. Zohren, R. D. Gill

Abstract: We present a much simplified version of the CGLMP inequality for the 2 x 2 x d Bell scenario. Numerical maximization of the violation of this inequality over all states and measurements suggests that the optimal state is far from maximally entangled, while the best measurements are the same as conjectured best measurements for the maximally entangled state. For very large values of d the inequal… ▽ More We present a much simplified version of the CGLMP inequality for the 2 x 2 x d Bell scenario. Numerical maximization of the violation of this inequality over all states and measurements suggests that the optimal state is far from maximally entangled, while the best measurements are the same as conjectured best measurements for the maximally entangled state. For very large values of d the inequality seems to reach its minimal value given by the probability constraints. This gives numerical evidence for a tight quantum Bell inequality (or generalized Csirelson inequality) for the 2 x 2 x inf scenario. △ Less

Submitted 27 March, 2008; v1 submitted 3 December, 2006; originally announced December 2006.

Comments: Introduction shortened, small changes, including new results for dimension of Hilbert space bigger than number of outcomes; 4 pages, 2 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 120406 (2008)

Better Bell inequalities (passion at a distance)

Authors: Richard D. Gill

Abstract: I explain so-called quantum nonlocality experiments and discuss how to optimize them. Statistical tools from missing data maximum likelihood are crucial. New results are given on CGLMP, CH and ladder inequalities. Open problems are also discussed. I explain so-called quantum nonlocality experiments and discuss how to optimize them. Statistical tools from missing data maximum likelihood are crucial. New results are given on CGLMP, CH and ladder inequalities. Open problems are also discussed. △ Less

Submitted 6 September, 2007; v1 submitted 3 October, 2006; originally announced October 2006.

Comments: Published at http://dx.doi.org/10.1214/074921707000000328 in the IMS Lecture Notes Monograph Series (http://www.imstat.org/publications/lecnotes.htm) by the Institute of Mathematical Statistics (http://www.imstat.org)

Report number: IMS-LNMS55-LNMS5508 MSC Class: 60G42; 62M07 (Primary) 81P68 (Secondary)

Journal ref: IMS Lecture Notes Monograph Series 2007, Vol. 55, 135-148

Separable Measurement Estimation of Density Matrices and its Fidelity Gap with Collective Protocols

Authors: E. Bagan, M. A. Ballester, R. D. Gill, R. Munoz-Tapia, O. Romero-Isart

Abstract: We show that there exists a gap between the performance of separable and collective measurements in qubit mixed-state estimation that persists in the large sample limit. We characterize such gap in terms of the corresponding bounds on the mean fidelity. We present an adaptive protocol that attains the separable-measurement bound. This (optimal separable) protocol uses von Neumann measurements an… ▽ More We show that there exists a gap between the performance of separable and collective measurements in qubit mixed-state estimation that persists in the large sample limit. We characterize such gap in terms of the corresponding bounds on the mean fidelity. We present an adaptive protocol that attains the separable-measurement bound. This (optimal separable) protocol uses von Neumann measurements and can be easily implemented with current technology. △ Less

Submitted 25 September, 2006; v1 submitted 21 December, 2005; originally announced December 2005.

Comments: version published in PRL

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 130501 (2006)

Conciliation of Bayes and Pointwise Quantum State Estimation: Asymptotic information bounds in quantum statistics

Authors: Richard D. Gill

Abstract: We derive an asymptotic lower bound on the Bayes risk when N identical quantum systems whose state depends on a vector of unknown parameters are jointly measured in an arbitrary way and the parameters of interest estimated on the basis of the resulting data. The bound is an integrated version of a quantum Cramér-Rao bound due to Holevo (1982), and it thereby links the fixed N exact Bayesian optima… ▽ More We derive an asymptotic lower bound on the Bayes risk when N identical quantum systems whose state depends on a vector of unknown parameters are jointly measured in an arbitrary way and the parameters of interest estimated on the basis of the resulting data. The bound is an integrated version of a quantum Cramér-Rao bound due to Holevo (1982), and it thereby links the fixed N exact Bayesian optimality usually pursued in the physics literature with the pointwise asymptotic optimality favoured in classical mathematical statistics. By heuristic arguments the bound can be expected to be sharp. This does turn out to be the case in various important examples, where it can be used to prove asymptotic optimality of interesting and useful measurement-and-estimation schemes. On the way we obtain a new family of "dual Holevo bounds" of independent interest. △ Less

Submitted 1 May, 2023; v1 submitted 19 December, 2005; originally announced December 2005.

Comments: Entitled "Asymptotic information bounds in quantum statistics", accepted for publication subject to expansion by inclusion of introductory material by Annals of Statistics, 2003. I missed dead-line (Lucia de B. case). This version appeared in conference proceedings given below. Finally revised and extended, co-author Madalin Guta, arXiv:1112.2078, published 2013 in another conference proceedings

MSC Class: 62F12; 62P35

Journal ref: Pages:239-261 in: Quantum Stochastics and Information - Statistics, Filtering and Control, Edited By: V P Belavkin and M Guţă. World Scientific Press, 2008

Optimal full estimation of qubit mixed states

Authors: E. Bagan, M. A. Ballester, R. D. Gill, A. Monras, R. Munoz-Tapia

Abstract: We obtain the optimal scheme for estimating unknown qubit mixed states when an arbitrary number N of identically prepared copies is available. We discuss the case of states in the whole Bloch sphere as well as the restricted situation where these states are known to lie on the equatorial plane. For the former case we obtain that the optimal measurement does not depend on the prior probability di… ▽ More We obtain the optimal scheme for estimating unknown qubit mixed states when an arbitrary number N of identically prepared copies is available. We discuss the case of states in the whole Bloch sphere as well as the restricted situation where these states are known to lie on the equatorial plane. For the former case we obtain that the optimal measurement does not depend on the prior probability distribution provided it is isotropic. Although the equatorial-plane case does not have this property for arbitrary N, we give a prior-independent scheme which becomes optimal in the asymptotic limit of large N. We compute the maximum mean fidelity in this asymptotic regime for the two cases. We show that within the pointwise estimation approach these limits can be obtained in a rather easy and rapid way. This derivation is based on heuristic arguments that are made rigorous by using van Trees inequalities. The interrelation between the estimation of the purity and the direction of the state is also discussed. In the general case we show that they correspond to independent estimations whereas for the equatorial-plane states this is only true asymptotically. △ Less

Submitted 20 October, 2005; originally announced October 2005.

Comments: 19 pages, no figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 73, 032301 (2006)

Optimal Bell tests do not require maximally entangled states

Authors: Antonio Acin, Richard Gill, Nicolas Gisin

Abstract: Any Bell test consists of a sequence of measurements on a quantum state in space-like separated regions. Thus, a state is better than others for a Bell test when, for the optimal measurements and the same number of trials, the probability of existence of a local model for the observed outcomes is smaller. The maximization over states and measurements defines the optimal nonlocality proof. Numeri… ▽ More Any Bell test consists of a sequence of measurements on a quantum state in space-like separated regions. Thus, a state is better than others for a Bell test when, for the optimal measurements and the same number of trials, the probability of existence of a local model for the observed outcomes is smaller. The maximization over states and measurements defines the optimal nonlocality proof. Numerical results show that the required optimal state does not have to be maximally entangled. △ Less

Submitted 27 June, 2005; originally announced June 2005.

Comments: 1 figure, REVTEX4

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 210402 (2005)

An invitation to quantum tomography (II)

Authors: L. M. Artiles, R. D. Gill, M. I. Guta

Abstract: The quantum state of a light beam can be represented as an infinite dimensional density matrix or equivalently as a density on the plane called the Wigner function. We describe quantum tomography as an inverse statistical problem in which the state is the unknown parameter and the data is given by results of measurements performed on identical quantum systems. We present consistency results for… ▽ More The quantum state of a light beam can be represented as an infinite dimensional density matrix or equivalently as a density on the plane called the Wigner function. We describe quantum tomography as an inverse statistical problem in which the state is the unknown parameter and the data is given by results of measurements performed on identical quantum systems. We present consistency results for Pattern Function Projection Estimators as well as for Sieve Maximum Likelihood Estimators for both the density matrix of the quantum state and its Wigner function. Finally we illustrate via simulated data the performance of the estimators. An EM algorithm is proposed for practical implementation. There remain many open problems, e.g. rates of convergence, adaptation, studying other estimators, etc., and a main purpose of the paper is to bring these to the attention of the statistical community. △ Less

Submitted 1 June, 2004; v1 submitted 31 May, 2004; originally announced May 2004.

Comments: An earlier version of this paper with more mathematical background but less applied statistical content can be found on arXiv as quant-ph/0303020. An electronic version of the paper with high resolution figures (postscript instead of bitmaps) is available from the authors. v2: added cross-validation results, references

Report number: Eurandom report 2004-024 MSC Class: 62G07; 62P35

Journal ref: Journal of the Royal Statistical Society (B) 67, 109-134 (2005)

Teleportation into Quantum Statistics

Authors: Richard D. Gill

Abstract: The paper is a tutorial introduction to quantum information theory, developing the basic model and emphasizing the role of statistics and probability. The paper is a tutorial introduction to quantum information theory, developing the basic model and emphasizing the role of statistics and probability. △ Less

Submitted 22 June, 2022; v1 submitted 29 May, 2004; originally announced May 2004.

Comments: Been waiting 3 years for math.ST

MSC Class: 62F12; 62P35

Journal ref: Journal of the Korean Statistical Society 30 (2001), 291-325; https://www.koreascience.or.kr/article/JAKO200111920784848.pub?&lang=en

Asymptotics in Quantum Statistics

Authors: Richard D. Gill

Abstract: Observations or measurements taken of a quantum system (a small number of fundamental particles) are inherently random. If the state of the system depends on unknown parameters, then the distribution of the outcome depends on these parameters too, and statistical inference problems result. Often one has a choice of what measurement to take, corresponding to different experimental set-ups or sett… ▽ More Observations or measurements taken of a quantum system (a small number of fundamental particles) are inherently random. If the state of the system depends on unknown parameters, then the distribution of the outcome depends on these parameters too, and statistical inference problems result. Often one has a choice of what measurement to take, corresponding to different experimental set-ups or settings of measurement apparatus. This leads to a design problem--which measurement is best for a given statistical problem. This paper gives an introduction to this field in the most simple of settings, that of estimating the state of a spin-half particle given n independent copies of the particle. We show how in some cases asymptotically optimal measurements can be constructed. Other cases present interesting open problems, connected to the fact that for some models, quantum Fisher information is in some sense non-additive. In physical terms, we have non-locality without entanglement. △ Less

Submitted 29 May, 2004; originally announced May 2004.

Comments: This is already a few years old but has been waiting all that time for math.ST

MSC Class: 62F12; 62P35

Journal ref: State of the Art in Probability and Statistics, IMS Lecture Notes - Monograph Series 36 (2001), 255-285, eds A.W. van der Vaart, M. de Gunst, C.A.J. Klaassen

Bell's inequality and the coincidence-time loophole

Authors: Jan-Åke Larsson, Richard Gill

Abstract: This paper analyzes effects of time-dependence in the Bell inequality. A generalized inequality is derived for the case when coincidence and non-coincidence [and hence whether or not a pair contributes to the actual data] is controlled by timing that depends on the detector settings. Needless to say, this inequality is violated by quantum mechanics and could be violated by experimental data prov… ▽ More This paper analyzes effects of time-dependence in the Bell inequality. A generalized inequality is derived for the case when coincidence and non-coincidence [and hence whether or not a pair contributes to the actual data] is controlled by timing that depends on the detector settings. Needless to say, this inequality is violated by quantum mechanics and could be violated by experimental data provided that the loss of measurement pairs through failure of coincidence is small enough, but the quantitative bound is more restrictive in this case than in the previously analyzed "efficiency loophole." △ Less

Submitted 21 June, 2004; v1 submitted 3 December, 2003; originally announced December 2003.

Comments: revtex4, 3 figures, v2: epl document class, reformatted w slight changes

Journal ref: Europhysics Letters, vol 67, pp. 707-713 (2004)

The chaotic chameleon

Authors: Richard D. Gill

Abstract: Various local hidden variables models for the singlet correlations exploit the detection loophole, or other loopholes connected with post-selection on coincident arrival times. I consider the connection with a probabilistic simulation technique called rejection-sampling, and pose some natural questions concerning what can be achieved and what cannot be achieved with local (or distributed) reject… ▽ More Various local hidden variables models for the singlet correlations exploit the detection loophole, or other loopholes connected with post-selection on coincident arrival times. I consider the connection with a probabilistic simulation technique called rejection-sampling, and pose some natural questions concerning what can be achieved and what cannot be achieved with local (or distributed) rejection sampling. In particular a new and more serious loophole, which we call the coincidence loophole, is introduced. △ Less

Submitted 29 May, 2004; v1 submitted 29 July, 2003; originally announced July 2003.

Comments: v.2: 7pp; conjecture 1 disproved by Gisin & Gisin (1999) but which leads to new open problems and conjectures. v.3: minor correction and addition. To appear in proceedings of "Quantum Probability and Infinite Dimensional Analysis", Greifswald, 2003; World Scientific. v.4: major revision in view of solution of another conjecture by Larsson & Gill (2003)

Journal ref: pp. 269--276 in: M. Sch"urmann and U. Franz (eds.), Quantum Probability and Infinite Dimensional Analysis: from Foundations to Applications. QP--PQ: Quantum Probability and White Noise Analysis, Volume 18 (2005). World Scientific.

On Quantum Statistical Inference, II

Authors: O. E. Barndorff-Nielsen, R. D. Gill, P. E. Jupp

Abstract: Interest in problems of statistical inference connected to measurements of quantum systems has recently increased substantially, in step with dramatic new developments in experimental techniques for studying small quantum systems. Furthermore, theoretical developments in the theory of quantum measurements have brought the basic mathematical framework for the probability calculations much closer… ▽ More Interest in problems of statistical inference connected to measurements of quantum systems has recently increased substantially, in step with dramatic new developments in experimental techniques for studying small quantum systems. Furthermore, theoretical developments in the theory of quantum measurements have brought the basic mathematical framework for the probability calculations much closer to that of classical probability theory. The present paper reviews this field and proposes and interrelates a number of new concepts for an extension of classical statistical inference to the quantum context. △ Less

Submitted 13 December, 2003; v1 submitted 26 July, 2003; originally announced July 2003.

Comments: This is the final version of quant-ph/0307189: half the length, some different material. Has appeared in JRSS B 65 (2003), with discussion

Journal ref: J. Roy. Statist. Soc. B 65 (2003), 775-816

On Quantum Statistical Inference, I

Authors: O. E. Barndorff-Nielsen, R. D. Gill, P. E. Jupp

Abstract: Recent developments in the mathematical foundations of quantum mechanics have brought the theory closer to that of classical probability and statistics. On the other hand, the unique character of quantum physics sets many of the questions addressed apart from those met classically in stochastics. Furthermore, concurrent advances in experimental techniques and in the theory of quantum computation… ▽ More Recent developments in the mathematical foundations of quantum mechanics have brought the theory closer to that of classical probability and statistics. On the other hand, the unique character of quantum physics sets many of the questions addressed apart from those met classically in stochastics. Furthermore, concurrent advances in experimental techniques and in the theory of quantum computation have led to a strong interest in questions of quantum information, in particular in the sense of the amount of information about unknown parameters in given observational data or accessible through various possible types of measurements. This scenery is outlined (with an audience of statisticians and probabilists in mind). △ Less

Submitted 26 July, 2003; v1 submitted 25 July, 2003; originally announced July 2003.

Comments: A shorter version containing some different material will appear (2003), with discussion, in J. Roy. Statist. Soc. B, and is archived as quant-ph/0307191

Report number: Tech. rep. 2001-19, MaPhySto, Dept. Math. Sci., Univ. Aarhus

On an Argument of David Deutsch

Authors: Richard D. Gill

Abstract: We analyse an argument of Deutsch, which purports to show that the deterministic part of classical quantum theory together with deterministic axioms of classical decision theory, together imply that a rational decision maker behaves as if the probabilistic part of quantum theory (Born's law) is true. We uncover two missing assumptions in the argument, and show that the argument also works for an… ▽ More We analyse an argument of Deutsch, which purports to show that the deterministic part of classical quantum theory together with deterministic axioms of classical decision theory, together imply that a rational decision maker behaves as if the probabilistic part of quantum theory (Born's law) is true. We uncover two missing assumptions in the argument, and show that the argument also works for an instrumentalist who is prepared to accept that the outcome of a quantum measurement is random in the frequentist sense: Born's law is a consequence of functional and unitary invariance principles belonging to the deterministic part of quantum mechanics. Unfortunately, it turns out that after the necessary corrections we have done no more than give an easier proof of Gleason's theorem under stronger assumptions. However, for some special cases the proof method gives positive results while using different assumptions to Gleason. This leads to the conjecture that the proof could be improved to give the same conclusion as Gleason under unitary invariance together with a much weaker functional invariance condition. △ Less

Submitted 29 May, 2004; v1 submitted 25 July, 2003; originally announced July 2003.

Comments: Revision 28-7-03: added reference Final revision 28-05-04. To appear in proceedings of "Quantum Probability and Infinite Dimensional Analysis", Greifswald, 2003; World Scientific

Journal ref: pp. 277--292 in: M. Sch"urmann and U. Franz (eds.), Quantum Probability and Infinite Dimensional Analysis: from Foundations to Applications. QP--PQ: Quantum Probability and White Noise Analysis, Volume 18 (2005). World Scientific.

The statistical strength of nonlocality proofs

Authors: Wim van Dam, Peter Grunwald, Richard Gill

Abstract: There exist numerous proofs of Bell's theorem, stating that quantum mechanics is incompatible with local realistic theories of nature. Here we define the strength of such nonlocality proofs in terms of the amount of evidence against local realism provided by the corresponding experiments. This measure tells us how many trials of the experiment we should perform in order to observe a substantial… ▽ More There exist numerous proofs of Bell's theorem, stating that quantum mechanics is incompatible with local realistic theories of nature. Here we define the strength of such nonlocality proofs in terms of the amount of evidence against local realism provided by the corresponding experiments. This measure tells us how many trials of the experiment we should perform in order to observe a substantial violation of local realism. Statistical considerations show that the amount of evidence should be measured by the Kullback-Leibler or relative entropy divergence between the probability distributions over the measurement outcomes that the respective theories predict. The statistical strength of a nonlocality proof is thus determined by the experimental implementation of it that maximizes the Kullback-Leibler divergence from experimental (quantum mechanical) truth to the set of all possible local theories. An implementation includes a specification with which probabilities the different measurement settings are sampled, and hence the maximization is done over all such setting distributions. We analyze two versions of Bell's nonlocality proof (his original proof and an optimized version by Peres), and proofs by Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt, Hardy, Mermin, and Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger. We find that the GHZ proof is at least four and a half times stronger than all other proofs, while of the two-party proofs, the one of CHSH is the strongest. △ Less

Submitted 1 June, 2004; v1 submitted 17 July, 2003; originally announced July 2003.

Comments: 36 pages, no figures, v2: major changes in presentation, no changes in results, conjectures added

Journal ref: IEEE-Transactions on Information Theory 51 (2005), 2812-2835

A geometric proof of the Kochen-Specker no-go theorem

Authors: Richard D. Gill, Michael S. Keane

Abstract: We give a short geometric proof of the Kochen-Specker no-go theorem for non-contextual hidden variables models. Note added to this version: I understand from Jan-Aake Larsson that the construction we give here actually contains the original Kochen-Specker construction as well as many others (Bell, Conway and Kochen, Schuette, perhaps also Peres). We give a short geometric proof of the Kochen-Specker no-go theorem for non-contextual hidden variables models. Note added to this version: I understand from Jan-Aake Larsson that the construction we give here actually contains the original Kochen-Specker construction as well as many others (Bell, Conway and Kochen, Schuette, perhaps also Peres). △ Less

Submitted 2 April, 2003; originally announced April 2003.

Comments: This paper appeared some years ago, before the author was aware of quant-ph. It is relevant to recent developments concerning Kochen-Specker theorems

Journal ref: J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 29 (1996), L289--L291

An invitation to quantum tomography

Authors: Richard Gill, Madalin Guta

Abstract: We describe quantum tomography as an inverse statistical problem and show how entropy methods can be used to study the behaviour of sieved maximum likelihood estimators. There remain many open problems, and a main purpose of the paper is to bring these to the attention of the statistical community. We describe quantum tomography as an inverse statistical problem and show how entropy methods can be used to study the behaviour of sieved maximum likelihood estimators. There remain many open problems, and a main purpose of the paper is to bring these to the attention of the statistical community. △ Less

Submitted 31 May, 2004; v1 submitted 4 March, 2003; originally announced March 2003.

Comments: 19 pages, submitted to J. Royal Stat. Soc. B. Note added 31/05/04: a revised version with further statistical results but less mathematical details, and with co-author Luis Artiles, has been posted on arXiv as math.ST/0405595

Report number: Eurandom report 2003-005

Time, Finite Statistics, and Bell's Fifth Position

Authors: Richard D. Gill

Abstract: I discuss three issues connected to Bell's theorem and Bell-CHSH-type experiments: time and the memory loophole, finite statistics (how wide are the error bars Under Local Realism), and the question of whether a loophole-free experiment is feasible, a surprising omission on Bell's list of four positions to hold in the light of his results. Levy's (1935) theory of martingales, and Fisher's (1935) t… ▽ More I discuss three issues connected to Bell's theorem and Bell-CHSH-type experiments: time and the memory loophole, finite statistics (how wide are the error bars Under Local Realism), and the question of whether a loophole-free experiment is feasible, a surprising omission on Bell's list of four positions to hold in the light of his results. Levy's (1935) theory of martingales, and Fisher's (1935) theory of randomization in experimental design, take care of time and of finite statistics. I exploit a (classical) computer network metaphor for local realism to argue that Bell's conclusions are independent of how one likes to interpret probability, and give a critique of some recent anti-Bellist literature. △ Less

Submitted 14 January, 2015; v1 submitted 14 January, 2003; originally announced January 2003.

Comments: 28 pages; proceedings of Vaxjo conference (2002) on foundations of QM and probability. Version 2: corrected a LaTeX error (\mathbb 1 did not work)

Journal ref: pp. 179-206 in: Proc. of "Foundations of Probability and Physics - 2", Ser. Math. Modelling in Phys., Engin., and Cogn. Sc., vol. 5/2002, Växjö Univ. Press, 2003

No time loophole in Bell's theorem; the Hess-Philipp model is non-local

Authors: R. D. Gill, G. Weihs, A. Zeilinger, M. Zukowski

Abstract: Hess and Philipp have recently claimed that proofs of Bell's theorem have overlooked the possibility of time dependence in local hidden variables, hence the theorem has not been proven true. Moreover they present what is claimed to be a local realistic model of the EPR correlations. If this is true then Bell's theorem is not just unproven, but false. We refute both claims. Firstly we explain why… ▽ More Hess and Philipp have recently claimed that proofs of Bell's theorem have overlooked the possibility of time dependence in local hidden variables, hence the theorem has not been proven true. Moreover they present what is claimed to be a local realistic model of the EPR correlations. If this is true then Bell's theorem is not just unproven, but false. We refute both claims. Firstly we explain why time is not an issue in Bell's theorem, and secondly show that their hidden variables model violates Einstein separability. Hess and Philipp have overlooked the freedom of the experimenter to choose settings of a measurement apparatus at will: any setting could be in force during the same time period. △ Less

Submitted 29 August, 2002; originally announced August 2002.

Comments: 5 pages, submitted to P.N.A.S; some overlap with our earlier quant-ph/0204169

Journal ref: PNAS 2002, 99: 14632-14635

Comment on "Exclusion of time in the theorem of Bell" by K. Hess and W. Philipp

Authors: R. D. Gill, G. Weihs, A. Zeilinger, M. Zukowski

Abstract: A recent Letter by Hess and Philipp claims that Bell's theorem neglects the possibility of time-like dependence in local hidden variables, hence is not conclusive. Moreover the authors claim that they have constructed, in an earlier paper, a local realistic model of the EPR correlations. However, they themselves have neglected the experimenter's freedom to choose settings, while on the other han… ▽ More A recent Letter by Hess and Philipp claims that Bell's theorem neglects the possibility of time-like dependence in local hidden variables, hence is not conclusive. Moreover the authors claim that they have constructed, in an earlier paper, a local realistic model of the EPR correlations. However, they themselves have neglected the experimenter's freedom to choose settings, while on the other hand, Bell's theorem can be formulated to cope with time-like dependence. This in itself proves that their toy model cannot satisfy local realism, but we also indicate where their proof of its local realistic nature fails. △ Less

Submitted 30 April, 2002; originally announced April 2002.

Comments: Latex needs epl.cls

Journal ref: Europhys. Lett. (2003) 61, 282-283

The Quantum Monty Hall Problem

Authors: G. M. D'Ariano, R. D. Gill, M. Keyl, B. Kuemmerer, H. Maassen, R. F. Werner

Abstract: We consider a quantum version of a well-known statistical decision problem, whose solution is, at first sight, counter-intuitive to many. In the quantum version a continuum of possible choices (rather than a finite set) has to be considered. It can be phrased as a two person game between a player P and a quiz master Q. Then P always has a strategy at least as good as in the classical case, while… ▽ More We consider a quantum version of a well-known statistical decision problem, whose solution is, at first sight, counter-intuitive to many. In the quantum version a continuum of possible choices (rather than a finite set) has to be considered. It can be phrased as a two person game between a player P and a quiz master Q. Then P always has a strategy at least as good as in the classical case, while Q's best strategy results in a game having the same value as the classical game. We investigate the consequences of Q storing his information in classical or quantum ways. It turns out that Q's optimal strategy is to use a completely entangled quantum notepad, on which to encode his prior information. △ Less

Submitted 21 February, 2002; originally announced February 2002.

Comments: 8 Pages, RevTeX 4. Associated information (including a Java simulation) can be found at http://www.imaph.tu-bs.de/qi/monty

Journal ref: Quant. Inf. Comput. 2, no. 5, 355-366 (2002)

Accardi contra Bell (cum mundi): The Impossible Coupling

Authors: Richard D. Gill

Abstract: An experimentally observed violation of Bell's inequality is supposed to show the failure of local realism to deal with quantum reality. However, finite statistics and the time sequential nature of real experiments still allow a loophole for local realism, known as the memory loophole. We show that the randomized design of the Aspect experiment closes this loophole. Our main tool is van de Geer'… ▽ More An experimentally observed violation of Bell's inequality is supposed to show the failure of local realism to deal with quantum reality. However, finite statistics and the time sequential nature of real experiments still allow a loophole for local realism, known as the memory loophole. We show that the randomized design of the Aspect experiment closes this loophole. Our main tool is van de Geer's (2000) supermartingale version of the classical Bernstein (1924) inequality guaranteeing, at the root n scale, a not-heavier-than-Gaussian tail of the distribution of a sum of bounded supermartingale differences. The results are used to specify a protocol for a public bet between the author and L. Accardi, who in recent papers (Accardi and Regoli, 2000a,b, 2001; Accardi, Imafuku and Regoli, 2002) has claimed to have produced a suite of computer programmes, to be run on a network of computers, which will simulate a violation of Bell's inequalites. At a sample size of thirty thousand, both error probabilities are guaranteed smaller than one in a million, provided we adhere to the sequential randomized design. The results also show that Hess and Philipp's (2001a,b) recent claims are mistaken that Bell's theorem fails because of time phenomena supposedly neglected by Bell. △ Less

Submitted 18 September, 2002; v1 submitted 24 October, 2001; originally announced October 2001.

Comments: To appear (2002) in: Mathematical Statistics and Applications: Festschrift for Constance van Eeden, Moore, M., Leger, C. and Froda, S. (eds), IMS Lecture Notes-Monograph series, Institute of Mathematical Statistics, Hayward, Ca

Report number: EURANDOM Report 2001-032

Journal ref: pp. 133-154 in: Mathematical Statistics and Applications: Festschrift for Constance van Eeden. Eds: M. Moore, S. Froda and C. Léger. IMS Lecture Notes -- Monograph Series, Volume 42 (2003). Institute of Mathematical Statistics. Beachwood, Ohio

State estimation for large ensembles

Authors: R. D. Gill, S. Massar

Abstract: We consider the problem of estimating the state of a large but finite number $N$ of identical quantum systems. In the limit of large $N$ the problem simplifies. In particular the only relevant measure of the quality of the estimation is the mean quadratic error matrix. Here we present a bound on the mean quadratic error which is a new quantum version of the Cramér-Rao inequality. This new bound… ▽ More We consider the problem of estimating the state of a large but finite number $N$ of identical quantum systems. In the limit of large $N$ the problem simplifies. In particular the only relevant measure of the quality of the estimation is the mean quadratic error matrix. Here we present a bound on the mean quadratic error which is a new quantum version of the Cramér-Rao inequality. This new bound expresses in a succinct way how in the quantum case one can trade information about one parameter for information about another parameter. The bound holds for arbitrary measurements on pure states, but only for separable measurements on mixed states--a striking example of non-locality without entanglement for mixed but not for pure states. Cramér-Rao bounds are generally derived under the assumption that the estimator is unbiased. We also prove that under additional regularity conditions our bound also holds for biased estimators. Finally we prove that when the unknown states belong to a 2 dimensional Hilbert space our quantum Cramér-Rao bound can always be attained and we provide an explicit measurement strategy that attains our bound. This therefore provides a complete solution to the problem of estimating as efficiently as possible the unknown state of a large ensemble of qubits in the same pure state. For qubits in the same mixed state, this also provides an optimal estimation strategy if one only considers separable measurements. △ Less

Submitted 26 October, 1999; v1 submitted 18 February, 1999; originally announced February 1999.

Comments: 23 pages, latex

Report number: ULB-TH/99-04

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.A61:042312,2002

Fisher information in quantum statistics

Authors: O. E. Barndorff-Nielsen, R. D. Gill

Abstract: Braunstein and Caves (1994) proposed to use Helstrom's {\em quantum information} number to define, meaningfully, a metric on the set of all possible states of a given quantum system. They showed that the quantum information is nothing else than the maximal Fisher information in a measurement of the quantum system, maximized over all possible measurements. Combining this fact with classical stati… ▽ More Braunstein and Caves (1994) proposed to use Helstrom's {\em quantum information} number to define, meaningfully, a metric on the set of all possible states of a given quantum system. They showed that the quantum information is nothing else than the maximal Fisher information in a measurement of the quantum system, maximized over all possible measurements. Combining this fact with classical statistical results, they argued that the quantum information determines the asymptotically optimal rate at which neighbouring states on some smooth curve can be distinguished, based on arbitrary measurements on $n$ identical copies of the given quantum system. We show that the measurement which maximizes the Fisher information typically depends on the true, unknown, state of the quantum system. We close the resulting loophole in the argument by showing that one can still achieve the same, optimal, rate of distinguishability, by a two stage adaptive measurement procedure. When we consider states lying not on a smooth curve, but on a manifold of higher dimension, the situation becomes much more complex. We show that the notion of ``distinguishability of close-by states'' depends strongly on the measurement resources one allows oneself, and on a further specification of the task at hand. The quantum information matrix no longer seems to play a central role. △ Less

Submitted 23 February, 2000; v1 submitted 5 August, 1998; originally announced August 1998.

Comments: This version replaces the previous versions of February 1999 (titled 'An Example of Non-Attainability of Expected Quantum Information') and that of November 1999. Proofs and results are much improved. To appear in J. Phys. A

Journal ref: J.Phys. A30 (2000) 4481-4490