Showing 1–50 of 54 results for author: Ghirardi, G

What really matters in Hilbert-space stochastic processes

Authors: Giancarlo Ghirardi, Oreste Nicrosini, Alberto Rimini

Abstract: The relationship between discontinuous and continuous stochastic processes in Hilbert space is investigated. It is shown that for any continuos process there is a parent discontinuous process, that becomes the continuous one in the proper infinite frequency limit. From the point of view of solving the quantum measurement problem, what really matters is the choice of the set of operators whose valu… ▽ More The relationship between discontinuous and continuous stochastic processes in Hilbert space is investigated. It is shown that for any continuos process there is a parent discontinuous process, that becomes the continuous one in the proper infinite frequency limit. From the point of view of solving the quantum measurement problem, what really matters is the choice of the set of operators whose value distributions are made sharp. In particular, the key role of position sharping is emphasized. △ Less

Submitted 15 February, 2017; originally announced February 2017.

Comments: 8 pages. To be published in Shan Gao (ed.), "Collapse of the Wave Function", Cambridge University Press

Is a description deeper than the quantum one possible?

Authors: Giancarlo Ghirardi, Raffaele Romano

Abstract: Recently, it has been argued that quantum mechanics is a complete theory, and that different quantum states do necessarily correspond to different elements of reality, under the assumptions that quantum mechanics is correct and that measurement settings can be freely chosen. In this work, we prove that this result is a consequence of an unnecessarily strong mathematical expression of the free choi… ▽ More Recently, it has been argued that quantum mechanics is a complete theory, and that different quantum states do necessarily correspond to different elements of reality, under the assumptions that quantum mechanics is correct and that measurement settings can be freely chosen. In this work, we prove that this result is a consequence of an unnecessarily strong mathematical expression of the free choice assumption, which embodies more conditions than explicitly stated. The issues of the completeness of quantum mechanics, and of the interpretation of the state vector, are by no means resolved. Taking this perspective, we describe how the recently introduced class of crypto-nonlocal hidden variables theories can be used to characterize the maximal possible departure from quantum mechanics, when the system consists of a pair of qubits. △ Less

Submitted 16 January, 2015; originally announced January 2015.

Comments: 8 pages, QTAP Vaxjo 2013

Journal ref: Phys. Scr. T163 (2014) 014028

Quantum Mechanics and Perceptive Processes: a reply to Elio Conte

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi

Abstract: Recently, Elio Conte has commented a paper by the present author devoted to analyze the possibility of checking experimentally whether the perceptual process can lead to the collapse of the wavefunction. Here we answer to the comments by Conte and we show that he has missed to grasp the crucial elements of our proposal. Morever, we discuss some ideas put forward by Conte concerning the occurrence… ▽ More Recently, Elio Conte has commented a paper by the present author devoted to analyze the possibility of checking experimentally whether the perceptual process can lead to the collapse of the wavefunction. Here we answer to the comments by Conte and we show that he has missed to grasp the crucial elements of our proposal. Morever, we discuss some ideas put forward by Conte concerning the occurrence of quantum superpositions of different states of consciousness and we show that they are rather vague and not cogent. △ Less

Submitted 8 November, 2014; originally announced November 2014.

Comments: 7 pages, 1 figure, to appear on International Journal of Theoretical Physics

John Stuart Bell: recollections of a great scientist and a great man

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi

Abstract: This contribution to the book in honour of J.S. Bell will probably differ from the remaining ones, in particular since only a part of it will be devoted to specific technical arguments. In fact I have considered appropriate to share with the community of physicists interested in the foundational problems of our best theory the repeated interactions I had with him in the last four years of his life… ▽ More This contribution to the book in honour of J.S. Bell will probably differ from the remaining ones, in particular since only a part of it will be devoted to specific technical arguments. In fact I have considered appropriate to share with the community of physicists interested in the foundational problems of our best theory the repeated interactions I had with him in the last four years of his life, the deep discussions in which we have been involved in particular in connection with the elaboration of collapse theories and their interpretation, the contributions he gave to the development of this approach, both at a formal level, as well as championing it on repeated occasions. In brief, I intend to play here the role of one of those lucky persons who became acquainted with him personally, who has exchanged important views with him, who has learned a lot from his deep insight and conceptual lucidity, and, last but not least, one whose scientific work has been appreciated by him. Moreover, due to the fact that this book intends to celebrate the 50th anniversary of the derivation of the fundamental inequality which bears his name, I will also devote a small part of the text to recall his clear cut views about the locality issue, views that I believe have not been grasped correctly by a remarkable part of the scientific community. I will analyze this problem in quite general terms at the end of the paper. △ Less

Submitted 4 November, 2014; originally announced November 2014.

Comments: 22 pages, 11 figures

Comments on a recent proposal of superluminal communication

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi

Abstract: We analyze critically a recent proposal of faster than light communication. We analyze critically a recent proposal of faster than light communication. △ Less

Submitted 4 November, 2014; originally announced November 2014.

Comments: 6 pages, 1 figure

Collapse Models and Perceptual Processes

Authors: G. C. Ghirardi, R. Romano

Abstract: Theories including a collapse mechanism have been presented various years ago. They are based on a modification of standard quantum mechanics in which nonlinear and stochastic terms are added to the evolution equation. Their principal merits derive from the fact that they are mathematically precise schemes accounting, on the basis of a unique universal dynamical principle, both for the quantum beh… ▽ More Theories including a collapse mechanism have been presented various years ago. They are based on a modification of standard quantum mechanics in which nonlinear and stochastic terms are added to the evolution equation. Their principal merits derive from the fact that they are mathematically precise schemes accounting, on the basis of a unique universal dynamical principle, both for the quantum behavior of microscopic systems as well as for the reduction associated to measurement processes and for the classical behavior of macroscopic objects. Since such theories qualify themselves not as new interpretations but as modifications of the standard theory they can be, in principle, tested against quantum mechanics. Recently, various investigations identifying possible crucial test have been discussed. In spite of the extreme difficulty to perform such tests it seems that recent technological developments allow at least to put precise limits on the parameters characterizing the modifications of the evolution equation. Here we will simply mention some of the recent investigations in this direction, while we will mainly concentrate our attention to the way in which collapse theories account for definite perceptual process. The differences between the case of reductions induced by perceptions and those related to measurement procedures by means of standard macroscopic devices will be discussed. On this basis, we suggest a precise experimental test of collapse theories involving conscious observers. We make plausible, by discussing in detail a toy model, that the modified dynamics can give rise to quite small but systematic errors in the visual perceptual process. △ Less

Submitted 15 January, 2014; originally announced January 2014.

Comments: 17 pages, 5 figures, to appear on the Conference Series of Journal of Physics A

On Kalamidas' proposal of faster than light quantum communication

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi, Raffaele Romano

Abstract: In a recent paper, Kalamidas has advanced a new proposal of faster than light communication which has not yet been proved invalid. In this paper, by strictly sticking to the standard quantum formalism we prove that, as all previous proposals, it does not work. In a recent paper, Kalamidas has advanced a new proposal of faster than light communication which has not yet been proved invalid. In this paper, by strictly sticking to the standard quantum formalism we prove that, as all previous proposals, it does not work. △ Less

Submitted 5 June, 2013; originally announced June 2013.

Comments: 8 pages, 1 figure

On a quite recent proposal of faster than light quantum communication

Authors: G. C Ghirardi, R. Romano

Abstract: In a recent paper, Kalamidas has advanced a new proposal of faster than light communication which has not yet been proved invalid. In this paper we show that, as all previous proposals, it does not work. The mistake arises from an inappropriate use of some approximations. In a recent paper, Kalamidas has advanced a new proposal of faster than light communication which has not yet been proved invalid. In this paper we show that, as all previous proposals, it does not work. The mistake arises from an inappropriate use of some approximations. △ Less

Submitted 5 June, 2013; v1 submitted 24 May, 2013; originally announced May 2013.

Comments: 4 pages, 1 figure. This paper has been withdrawn because we have worked out a more general and complete proof of the same argument

Entanglement, Nonlocality, Superluminal Signaling and Cloning

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi

Abstract: The paper is a Chapter of a book. In it an exhaustive review of the proposals to send faster than light signals resorting to quantum nonlocality and the reduction process is presented, together with a critical analysis and rebuttal of all proposals. The most interesting part of the Chapter is the one in which the problem of quantum cloning is discussed. Actually, a proposal of superluminal signali… ▽ More The paper is a Chapter of a book. In it an exhaustive review of the proposals to send faster than light signals resorting to quantum nonlocality and the reduction process is presented, together with a critical analysis and rebuttal of all proposals. The most interesting part of the Chapter is the one in which the problem of quantum cloning is discussed. Actually, a proposal of superluminal signaling based on an hypothetical cloning machine has been presented by N. Herbert. The proposal does not work just because of the assumption that one can clone nonorthogonal states. The fact that such a machine is incompatible with quantum theory (i.e., the so-called No-Cloning Theorem) has been proved, for the first time, by the author of the present chapter in his referee's report to Herbert's paper. In the final part of the paper some recent (different but similarly not correct) proposals are analyzed and the reasons for which they are basically wrong are presented. △ Less

Submitted 17 May, 2013; v1 submitted 10 May, 2013; originally announced May 2013.

Comments: 29 pages, 4 figures, Book Chapter of: Advances in Quantum Mechanics, P. Bracken, ed. INTECH, 2013 Note: after having submitted this paper to the arXives, I realized that there is a mistake in eq.(1). In the last expression at the r.h.s. the p_{i} under the sum should appear squared

On the completeness of quantum mechanics and the interpretation of the state vector

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi, Raffaele Romano

Abstract: Recently, it has been argued that quantum mechanics is complete, and that quantum states vectors are necessarily in one-to-one correspondence with the elements of reality, under the assumptions that quantum theory is correct and that measurement settings can be freely chosen. In this work, we argue that the adopted form of the free choice assumption is stronger than needed. We unveil hidden assump… ▽ More Recently, it has been argued that quantum mechanics is complete, and that quantum states vectors are necessarily in one-to-one correspondence with the elements of reality, under the assumptions that quantum theory is correct and that measurement settings can be freely chosen. In this work, we argue that the adopted form of the free choice assumption is stronger than needed. We unveil hidden assumptions underlying these results, which limit their range of validity. We support our argument by a model for the bipartite two-level system, reproducing quantum mechanics, in which the free will assumption is respected, and different quantum states can be connected to the same state of reality. △ Less

Submitted 25 February, 2013; originally announced February 2013.

Comments: 15 pages, comments are welcome

Journal ref: J. Phys.: Conf. Ser. 442, 012002 (2013)

Comment on "Is a system's wave function in one-to-one correspondence with its elements of reality?" [arXiv:1111.6597]

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi, Raffaele Romano

Abstract: Recently, it has been argued [arXiv:1111.6597, arXiv:1005.5173] that different quantum states do necessarily correspond to different elements of reality, under the assumption that quantum mechanics is correct and that measurement settings can be freely chosen. Here, we prove that additional assumptions are necessary to derive this results, which then has not general validity. Recently, it has been argued [arXiv:1111.6597, arXiv:1005.5173] that different quantum states do necessarily correspond to different elements of reality, under the assumption that quantum mechanics is correct and that measurement settings can be freely chosen. Here, we prove that additional assumptions are necessary to derive this results, which then has not general validity. △ Less

Submitted 6 February, 2013; originally announced February 2013.

Comments: 1 page, Latex

About possible extensions of quantum theory

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi, Raffaele Romano

Abstract: Recently it has been claimed that no extension of quantum theory can have improved predictive power, the statement following, according to the authors, from the assumptions of free will and of the correctness of quantum predictions concerning the correlations of measurement outcomes. Here we prove that the argument is basically awed by an inappropriate use of the assumption of free will. In partic… ▽ More Recently it has been claimed that no extension of quantum theory can have improved predictive power, the statement following, according to the authors, from the assumptions of free will and of the correctness of quantum predictions concerning the correlations of measurement outcomes. Here we prove that the argument is basically awed by an inappropriate use of the assumption of free will. In particular, among other implications, the claim, if correct, would imply that Bohmian Mechanics is incompatible with free will. This statement, appearing in the paper, derives from the unjustified identification of free will with the no-signaling constraint and of a purely formal and not physical use of such a constraint. △ Less

Submitted 21 June, 2013; v1 submitted 21 January, 2013; originally announced January 2013.

Comments: 9 pages, 1 figure; in publication on Found. of Phys

Journal ref: Foundations of Physics: Volume 43, Issue 7 (2013), Page 881-894

Onthological models predictively inequivalent to quantum theory

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi, Raffaele Romano

Abstract: Recently, it has been argued that no extension of quantum theory can have improved predictive power under a strong assumption of free choice of the experimental settings and validity of quantum mechanics. Here, under a different free choice assumption, we describe a model which violates this statement for almost all states of a bipartite two-level system, in a possibly experimentally testable way.… ▽ More Recently, it has been argued that no extension of quantum theory can have improved predictive power under a strong assumption of free choice of the experimental settings and validity of quantum mechanics. Here, under a different free choice assumption, we describe a model which violates this statement for almost all states of a bipartite two-level system, in a possibly experimentally testable way. From consistency with quantum mechanics and the nonsignaling principle, we derive a bound on the local averages for the family of deterministic ontological theories that our model belongs to. △ Less

Submitted 26 April, 2013; v1 submitted 12 January, 2013; originally announced January 2013.

Comments: 5 pages, 2 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 170404 (2013)

On a proposal of superluminal communication

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi, Raffaele Romano

Abstract: Recently, various new proposals of superluminal transmission of information have appeared in the literature. Since they make systematic resort to recent formal and practical improvements in quantum mechanics, the old theorems proving the impossibility of such a performance must be adapted to the new scenario. In this paper we consider some of the most challenging proposals of this kind and we show… ▽ More Recently, various new proposals of superluminal transmission of information have appeared in the literature. Since they make systematic resort to recent formal and practical improvements in quantum mechanics, the old theorems proving the impossibility of such a performance must be adapted to the new scenario. In this paper we consider some of the most challenging proposals of this kind and we show why they cannot work. △ Less

Submitted 7 May, 2012; originally announced May 2012.

Comments: Latex, 11 pages, 1 figures. Submitted for publication

Journal ref: J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 45, 232001 (FTC) (2012)

Classical, quantum and superquantum correlations

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi, Raffaele Romano

Abstract: A deeper understanding of the origin of quantum correlations is expected to shred light on the physical principles underlying quantum mechanics. In this work, we reconsider the possibility of devising "crypto-nonlocal theories", using a terminology firstly introduced by Leggett. We generalize and simplify the investigations on this subject which can be found in the literature. At their deeper leve… ▽ More A deeper understanding of the origin of quantum correlations is expected to shred light on the physical principles underlying quantum mechanics. In this work, we reconsider the possibility of devising "crypto-nonlocal theories", using a terminology firstly introduced by Leggett. We generalize and simplify the investigations on this subject which can be found in the literature. At their deeper level, such theories allow nonlocal correlations which can overcome the quantum limit. △ Less

Submitted 5 May, 2012; originally announced May 2012.

Comments: 21 pages, submitted to Int. J. Mod. Phys. B, special issue "Classical Vs Quantum correlations in composite systems" edited by L. Amico, S. Bose, V. Korepin and V. Vedral

Journal ref: Int. J. Mod. Phys. B 27, 1245011 (2013)

A simple note on the nonlocal structure of the PR-box

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi, Raffaele Romano

Abstract: In view of the remarkable interest raised by the introduction of the so called PR-box we analyze its nonlocal features from the point of view of Parameter and Outcome Dependence. In view of the remarkable interest raised by the introduction of the so called PR-box we analyze its nonlocal features from the point of view of Parameter and Outcome Dependence. △ Less

Submitted 30 April, 2012; originally announced April 2012.

Comments: 6 pages, submitted for publication

A general theorem on local parts of hidden variable models

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi, Raffaele Romano

Abstract: We extend to any maximally entangled state of a bipartite system whose constituents are arbitrarily (but finite) dimensional the result, recently derived for two-dimensional constituents, that hidden variable theories cannot have local parts, i.e., that their local averages cannot differ from the quantum mechanical ones. We extend to any maximally entangled state of a bipartite system whose constituents are arbitrarily (but finite) dimensional the result, recently derived for two-dimensional constituents, that hidden variable theories cannot have local parts, i.e., that their local averages cannot differ from the quantum mechanical ones. △ Less

Submitted 21 March, 2012; originally announced March 2012.

Comments: 5 pages, submitted for publication

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 86, 022107 (2012)

Quantum and Superquantum Nonlocal Correlations

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi, Raffaele Romano

Abstract: We present a simple hidden variable model for the singlet state of a pair of qubits, characterized by two kinds, hierarchically ordered, of hidden variables. We prove that, averaging over both types of variables, one reproduces all the quantum mechanical correlations of the singlet state. On the other hand, averaging only over the hidden variables of the lower level, one obtains a general formal t… ▽ More We present a simple hidden variable model for the singlet state of a pair of qubits, characterized by two kinds, hierarchically ordered, of hidden variables. We prove that, averaging over both types of variables, one reproduces all the quantum mechanical correlations of the singlet state. On the other hand, averaging only over the hidden variables of the lower level, one obtains a general formal theoretical scheme exhibiting correlations stronger than the quantum ones, but with faster-than-light communication forbidden. This result is interesting by itself since it shows that a violation of the quantum bound for nonlocal correlations can be implemented in a precise physical manner and not only mathematically, and it suggests that resorting to two levels of nonlocal hidden variables might led to a deeper understanding of the physical principles at the basis of quantum nonlocality. △ Less

Submitted 14 March, 2012; originally announced March 2012.

Comments: 5 pages, 1 figure. Submitted for publication

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 86, 022116 (2012)

A general hidden variable model for the two-qubits system

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi, Raffaele Romano

Abstract: We generalize Bell's hidden variable model describing the singlet state of a two-qubits system by extending it to arbitrary states and observables. As in the original work, we assume a uniform, state-independent probability distribution for the hidden variables which are identified with the unit vectors of a 3-dimensional real space. By slightly modifying our model, we provide also a minimal hidde… ▽ More We generalize Bell's hidden variable model describing the singlet state of a two-qubits system by extending it to arbitrary states and observables. As in the original work, we assume a uniform, state-independent probability distribution for the hidden variables which are identified with the unit vectors of a 3-dimensional real space. By slightly modifying our model, we provide also a minimal hidden variable description of the two-qubits system, relying on a single hidden variable. We discuss the main features and the implications of the model. △ Less

Submitted 14 March, 2012; originally announced March 2012.

Comments: 4 pages, submitted for publication

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 85, 042102 (2012)

Matter Density and Relativistic Models of Wave Function Collapse

Authors: Daniel Bedingham, Detlef Duerr, GianCarlo Ghirardi, Sheldon Goldstein, Roderich Tumulka, Nino Zanghi

Abstract: Mathematical models for the stochastic evolution of wave functions that combine the unitary evolution according to the Schroedinger equation and the collapse postulate of quantum theory are well understood for non-relativistic quantum mechanics. Recently, there has been progress in making these models relativistic. But even with a fully relativistic law for the wave function evolution, a problem w… ▽ More Mathematical models for the stochastic evolution of wave functions that combine the unitary evolution according to the Schroedinger equation and the collapse postulate of quantum theory are well understood for non-relativistic quantum mechanics. Recently, there has been progress in making these models relativistic. But even with a fully relativistic law for the wave function evolution, a problem with relativity remains: Different Lorentz frames may yield conflicting values for the matter density at a space-time point. We propose here a relativistic law for the matter density function. According to our proposal, the matter density function at a space-time point x is obtained from the wave function psi on the past light cone of x by setting the i-th particle position in |psi|^2 equal to x, integrating over the other particle positions, and averaging over i. We show that the predictions that follow from this proposal agree with all known experimental facts. △ Less

Submitted 12 July, 2013; v1 submitted 6 November, 2011; originally announced November 2011.

Comments: 6 pages LaTeX, 2 figures; v4: minor improvements

Journal ref: Journal of Statistical Physics 154: 623-631 (2014)

On a recent proof of nonlocality without inequalities

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi

Abstract: Recently a quite stimulating paper [1] dealing with the possibility of exploiting the nonlocal aspects of a superposition of states of a single photon appeared. We regard as greatly relevant the results which have been obtained. However we think that the presentation of the matter and the way to derive the conclusion are not fully satisfactory and do not put the necessary emphasis on some subtle b… ▽ More Recently a quite stimulating paper [1] dealing with the possibility of exploiting the nonlocal aspects of a superposition of states of a single photon appeared. We regard as greatly relevant the results which have been obtained. However we think that the presentation of the matter and the way to derive the conclusion are not fully satisfactory and do not put the necessary emphasis on some subtle basic aspects like locality and realism. In view of its interest we consider it useful to reconsider the line of reasoning of ref.[1] and to derive once more its results by following a procedure which seems to us more lucid and which makes fully clear the role of the various conceptual aspects of the treatment. We hope that our analysis will contribute to clarify and to deepen the interesting results of ref.[1]. △ Less

Submitted 27 January, 2011; originally announced January 2011.

Does quantum nonlocality irremediably conflict with Special Relativity?

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi

Abstract: We reconsider the problem of the compatibility of quantum nonlocality and the requests for a relativistically invariant theoretical scheme. We begin by discussing a recent important paper by T. Norsen [arXiv:0808.2178] on this problem and we enlarge our considerations to give a general picture of the conceptually relevant issue to which this paper is devoted. We reconsider the problem of the compatibility of quantum nonlocality and the requests for a relativistically invariant theoretical scheme. We begin by discussing a recent important paper by T. Norsen [arXiv:0808.2178] on this problem and we enlarge our considerations to give a general picture of the conceptually relevant issue to which this paper is devoted. △ Less

Submitted 1 December, 2009; originally announced December 2009.

Comments: 18 pages, 1 figure

The interpretation of quantum mechanics: where do we stand?

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi

Abstract: We reconsider some important foundational problems of quantum mechanics. After reviewing the measurement problem and discussing its unavoidability, we analyze some proposals to overcome it. This analysis leads us to reconsider the current debate on our best theory, i.e. quantum mechanics itself. We stress that, after the remarkable interest and the many efforts which have lead, in the last years… ▽ More We reconsider some important foundational problems of quantum mechanics. After reviewing the measurement problem and discussing its unavoidability, we analyze some proposals to overcome it. This analysis leads us to reconsider the current debate on our best theory, i.e. quantum mechanics itself. We stress that, after the remarkable interest and the many efforts which have lead, in the last years of the past century, to a revival of the subject, and, more important, to new interesting results, we are now witnessing a re-emergence of the vague and unprofessional positions which have characterized the debate in the second quarter of the XXth century. In particular we consider as extremely serious the fact that a completely mistaken position concerning the real meaning of Bell's theorem seems to have been taken by many scientists in the field. △ Less

Submitted 6 April, 2009; originally announced April 2009.

Comments: 16 pages

Contextuality, Nonlocality and Counterfactual Arguments

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi, Karl Wienand

Abstract: In this paper, following an elementary line of thought which somewhat differs from the usual one, we prove once more that any deterministic theory predictively equivalent to quantum mechanics unavoidably exhibits a contextual character. The purpose of adopting this perspective is that of paving the way for a critical analysis of the use of counterfactual arguments when dealing with nonlocal phys… ▽ More In this paper, following an elementary line of thought which somewhat differs from the usual one, we prove once more that any deterministic theory predictively equivalent to quantum mechanics unavoidably exhibits a contextual character. The purpose of adopting this perspective is that of paving the way for a critical analysis of the use of counterfactual arguments when dealing with nonlocal physical processes. △ Less

Submitted 6 April, 2009; originally announced April 2009.

Comments: 14 pages

Reconsidering Mermin's "In praise of measurement"

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi

Abstract: We critically analyze a recent paper by D. Mermin and we compare his statements with Bell's position on the problems he is discussing. We critically analyze a recent paper by D. Mermin and we compare his statements with Bell's position on the problems he is discussing. △ Less

Submitted 3 June, 2008; originally announced June 2008.

On a recent proposal of faster than light quantum communication

Authors: A. Bassi, G. C. Ghirardi

Abstract: In a recent paper, A.Y. Shiekh has discussed an experimental set-up which, in his opinion, should make possible faster-than-light communication using the collapse of the quantum wave function. Contrary to the many proposals which have been presented in the past, he does not resort to an entangled state of two systems but he works with a single particle in a superposition of two states - correspo… ▽ More In a recent paper, A.Y. Shiekh has discussed an experimental set-up which, in his opinion, should make possible faster-than-light communication using the collapse of the quantum wave function. Contrary to the many proposals which have been presented in the past, he does not resort to an entangled state of two systems but he works with a single particle in a superposition of two states - corresponding to its propagation in opposite directions - one of which goes through an appropriate interferometer. The possibility for an observer near the interferometer to introduce or not, at his free will, a phase shifter along one of the paths should allow to change instantaneously the probability of finding the particle in the far-away region corresponding to the other state of the superposition and, correspondingly, to change the intensity of a beam of particles reaching a distant observer. In this paper we show a flaw in the argument: once more, as it has been proved in full generality a long time ago, the process of wave packet reduction cannot be used for superluminal communication. △ Less

Submitted 20 March, 2008; v1 submitted 28 November, 2007; originally announced November 2007.

Comments: 9 pages, LaTeX. Minor changes made

Journal ref: Int. Journ. Theor. Phys. 47, 2500 (2008).

Proofs of nonlocality without inequalities revisited

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi, Luca Marinatto

Abstract: We discuss critically the so-called nonlocality without inequalities proofs for bipartite quantum states, we generalize them and we analyze their relation with the Clauser-Horne inequality. We discuss critically the so-called nonlocality without inequalities proofs for bipartite quantum states, we generalize them and we analyze their relation with the Clauser-Horne inequality. △ Less

Submitted 4 November, 2007; originally announced November 2007.

Comments: 8 pages, RevTex; to be published on PLA

The Hilbert space operator formalism within dynamical reduction models

Authors: A. Bassi, G. C. Ghirardi, D. G. M. Salvetti

Abstract: Unlike standard quantum mechanics, dynamical reduction models assign no particular a priori status to `measurement processes', `apparata', and `observables', nor self-adjoint operators and positive operator valued measures enter the postulates defining these models. In this paper, we show why and how the Hilbert-space operator formalism, which standard quantum mechanics postulates, can be derive… ▽ More Unlike standard quantum mechanics, dynamical reduction models assign no particular a priori status to `measurement processes', `apparata', and `observables', nor self-adjoint operators and positive operator valued measures enter the postulates defining these models. In this paper, we show why and how the Hilbert-space operator formalism, which standard quantum mechanics postulates, can be derived from the fundamental evolution equation of dynamical reduction models. Far from having any special ontological meaning, we show that within the dynamical reduction context the operator formalism is just a compact and convenient way to express the statistical properties of the outcomes of experiments. △ Less

Submitted 26 September, 2007; v1 submitted 19 July, 2007; originally announced July 2007.

Comments: 25 pages, RevTeX. Changes made and two figures added

Journal ref: Journ. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 40, 13755-13772 (2007)

A critical analysis of Popper's experiment

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi, Luca Marinatto, Francesco de Stefano

Abstract: An experiment which could decide against the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics has been proposed by K. Popper and, subsequently, it has been criticized by M.J. Collett and R. Loudon. Here we show that both the above mentioned arguments are not correct because they are based on a misuse of basic quantum rules. An experiment which could decide against the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics has been proposed by K. Popper and, subsequently, it has been criticized by M.J. Collett and R. Loudon. Here we show that both the above mentioned arguments are not correct because they are based on a misuse of basic quantum rules. △ Less

Submitted 26 February, 2007; originally announced February 2007.

Comments: 12 pages, 3 figures, RevTex; to be published on PRA

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 75, 042107 (2007)

Hardy's proof of nonlocality in the presence of noise

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi, Luca Marinatto

Abstract: We extend the validity of Hardy's nonlocality without inequalities proof to cover the case of special one-parameter classes of non-pure statistical operators. These mixed states are obtained by mixing the Hardy states with a completely chaotic noise or with a colored noise and they represent a realistic description of imperfect preparation processes of (pure) Hardy states in nonlocality experime… ▽ More We extend the validity of Hardy's nonlocality without inequalities proof to cover the case of special one-parameter classes of non-pure statistical operators. These mixed states are obtained by mixing the Hardy states with a completely chaotic noise or with a colored noise and they represent a realistic description of imperfect preparation processes of (pure) Hardy states in nonlocality experiments. Within such a framework we are able to exhibit a precise range of values of the parameter measuring the noise affecting the non-optimal preparation of an arbitrary Hardy state, for which it is still possible to put into evidence genuine nonlocal effects. Equivalently, our work exhibits particular classes of bipartite mixed states whose constituents do not admit any local and deterministic hidden variable model reproducing the quantum mechanical predictions. △ Less

Submitted 21 December, 2006; v1 submitted 30 October, 2006; originally announced October 2006.

Comments: 9 pages, 2 figures, RevTex, revised version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 74, 062107 (2006)

The Conway-Kochen argument and relativistic GRW models

Authors: A. Bassi, G. C. Ghirardi

Abstract: In a recent paper, Conway and Kochen proposed what is now known as the "Free Will theorem" which, among other things, should prove the impossibility of combining GRW models with special relativity, i.e., of formulating relativistically invariant models of spontaneous wavefunction collapse. Since their argument basically amounts to a non-locality proof for any theory aiming at reproducing quantum… ▽ More In a recent paper, Conway and Kochen proposed what is now known as the "Free Will theorem" which, among other things, should prove the impossibility of combining GRW models with special relativity, i.e., of formulating relativistically invariant models of spontaneous wavefunction collapse. Since their argument basically amounts to a non-locality proof for any theory aiming at reproducing quantum correlations, and since it was clear since very a long time that any relativistic collapse model must be non-local in some way, we discuss why the theorem of Conway and Kochen does not affect the program of formulating relativistic GRW models. △ Less

Submitted 22 January, 2007; v1 submitted 24 October, 2006; originally announced October 2006.

Comments: 16 pages, RevTeX

Journal ref: Found. Phys. 37, 169 (2007)

Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger argument of nonlocality without inequalities for mixed states

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi, Luca Marinatto

Abstract: We generalize the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger nonlocality without inequalities argument to cover the case of arbitrary mixed statistical operators associated to three-qubits quantum systems. More precisely, we determine the radius of a ball (in the trace distance topology) surrounding the pure GHZ state and containing arbitrary mixed statistical operators which cannot be described by any local a… ▽ More We generalize the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger nonlocality without inequalities argument to cover the case of arbitrary mixed statistical operators associated to three-qubits quantum systems. More precisely, we determine the radius of a ball (in the trace distance topology) surrounding the pure GHZ state and containing arbitrary mixed statistical operators which cannot be described by any local and realistic hidden variable model and which are, as a consequence, noncompletely separable. As a practical application, we focus on certain one-parameter classes of mixed states which are commonly considered in the experimental realization of the original GHZ argument and which result from imperfect preparations of the pure GHZ state. In these cases we determine for which values of the parameter controlling the noise a nonlocality argument can still be exhibited, despite the mixedness of the considered states. Moreover, the effect of the imperfect nature of measurement processes is discussed. △ Less

Submitted 8 August, 2006; v1 submitted 22 March, 2006; originally announced March 2006.

Comments: 8 pages, RevTex; added references, corrected typos

Journal ref: Physical Review A 74, 1 (2006)

Hardy's criterion of nonlocality for mixed states

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi, Luca Marinatto

Abstract: We generalize Hardy's proof of nonlocality to the case of bipartite mixed statistical operators, and we exhibit a necessary condition which has to be satisfied by any given mixed state $σ$ in order that a local and realistic hidden variable model exists which accounts for the quantum mechanical predictions implied by $σ$. Failure of this condition will imply both the impossibility of any local e… ▽ More We generalize Hardy's proof of nonlocality to the case of bipartite mixed statistical operators, and we exhibit a necessary condition which has to be satisfied by any given mixed state $σ$ in order that a local and realistic hidden variable model exists which accounts for the quantum mechanical predictions implied by $σ$. Failure of this condition will imply both the impossibility of any local explanation of certain joint probability distributions in terms of hidden variables and the nonseparability of the considered mixed statistical operator. Our result can be also used to determine the maximum amount of noise, arising from imperfect experimental implementations of the original Hardy's proof of nonlocality, in presence of which it is still possible to put into evidence the nonlocal features of certain mixed states. △ Less

Submitted 20 March, 2006; originally announced March 2006.

Comments: 7 pages, RevTex

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 73, 032102 (2006)

Identical particles and entanglement

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi, Luca Marinatto

Abstract: We review two general criteria for deciding whether a pure bipartite quantum state describing a system of two identical particles is entangled or not. The first one considers the possibility of attributing a complete set of objective properties to each particle belonging to the composed system, while the second is based both on the consideration of the Slater-Schmidt number of the fermionic and… ▽ More We review two general criteria for deciding whether a pure bipartite quantum state describing a system of two identical particles is entangled or not. The first one considers the possibility of attributing a complete set of objective properties to each particle belonging to the composed system, while the second is based both on the consideration of the Slater-Schmidt number of the fermionic and bosonic analog of the Schmidt decomposition and on the evaluation of the von Neumann entropy of the one-particle reduced statistical operators. △ Less

Submitted 28 September, 2005; originally announced September 2005.

Comments: 8 pages; Latex; Talk delivered at the International Conference on Quantum Optics 2004, Minsk, Belarus

Journal ref: Optics and Spectroscopy 99, 386 (2005)

Nonlocality without inequalities

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi, Luca Marinatto

Abstract: We prove that every conceivable hidden variable model reproducing the quantum mechanical predictions of almost any entangled state must necessarily violate Bell's locality condition. The proof does not involve the consideration of any Bell inequality but it rests on simple set theoretic arguments and it works for almost any noncompletely factorizable state vector associated to any number of part… ▽ More We prove that every conceivable hidden variable model reproducing the quantum mechanical predictions of almost any entangled state must necessarily violate Bell's locality condition. The proof does not involve the consideration of any Bell inequality but it rests on simple set theoretic arguments and it works for almost any noncompletely factorizable state vector associated to any number of particles whose Hilbert spaces have arbitrary dimensionality. △ Less

Submitted 28 September, 2005; originally announced September 2005.

Comments: 10 pages; Latex; Talk delivered at ICSSUR'05, Besancon, France, 2-6 May 2005; to be published on J. Opt. B (special issue)

Journal ref: J. Opt. B 7, 643 (2005).

Nonlocality without inequalities for almost all entangled states of any quantum system

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi, Luca Marinatto

Abstract: It is shown that it is possible to rule out all local and stochastic hidden variable models accounting for the quantum mechanical predictions implied by almost any entangled quantum state vector of any number of particles whose Hilbert spaces have arbitrary dimensions, without resorting to Bell-type inequalities. The present proof makes use of the mathematically precise notion of Bell locality a… ▽ More It is shown that it is possible to rule out all local and stochastic hidden variable models accounting for the quantum mechanical predictions implied by almost any entangled quantum state vector of any number of particles whose Hilbert spaces have arbitrary dimensions, without resorting to Bell-type inequalities. The present proof makes use of the mathematically precise notion of Bell locality and it involves only simple set theoretic arguments. △ Less

Submitted 25 May, 2005; originally announced May 2005.

Comments: 5 pages, RevTeX, to be published on Physical Review A

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 72, 014105 (2005)

Criteria for the entanglement of composite systems of identical particles

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi, Luca Marinatto

Abstract: We identify a general criterion for detecting entanglement of pure bipartite quantum states describing a system of two identical particles. Such a criterion is based both on the consideration of the Slater-Schmidt number of the fermionic and bosonic analog of the Schmidt decomposition and on the evaluation of the von Neumann entropy of the one-particle reduced statistical operators. We identify a general criterion for detecting entanglement of pure bipartite quantum states describing a system of two identical particles. Such a criterion is based both on the consideration of the Slater-Schmidt number of the fermionic and bosonic analog of the Schmidt decomposition and on the evaluation of the von Neumann entropy of the one-particle reduced statistical operators. △ Less

Submitted 12 October, 2004; originally announced October 2004.

Comments: 8 pages, Latex

Journal ref: Fortschr. Phys. 52, No.11-12, 1045-1051 (2004)

General criterion for the entanglement of two indistinguishable particles

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi, Luca Marinatto

Abstract: We relate the notion of entanglement for quantum systems composed of two identical constituents to the impossibility of attributing a complete set of properties to both particles. This implies definite constraints on the mathematical form of the state vector associated with the whole system. We then analyze separately the cases of fermion and boson systems, and we show how the consideration of b… ▽ More We relate the notion of entanglement for quantum systems composed of two identical constituents to the impossibility of attributing a complete set of properties to both particles. This implies definite constraints on the mathematical form of the state vector associated with the whole system. We then analyze separately the cases of fermion and boson systems, and we show how the consideration of both the Slater-Schmidt number of the fermionic and bosonic analog of the Schmidt decomposition of the global state vector and the von Neumann entropy of the one-particle reduced density operators can supply us with a consistent criterion for detecting entanglement. In particular, the consideration of the von Neumann entropy is particularly useful in deciding whether the correlations of the considered states are simply due to the indistinguishability of the particles involved or are a genuine manifestation of the entanglement. The treatment leads to a full clarification of the subtle aspects of entanglement of two identical constituents which have been a source of embarrassment and of serious misunderstandings in the recent literature. △ Less

Submitted 14 July, 2004; v1 submitted 12 January, 2004; originally announced January 2004.

Comments: 18 pages, Latex; revised version: Section 3.2 rewritten, new Theorems added, reference [1] corrected. To appear on Phys.Rev.A 70, (2004)

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A. 70, 012109 (2004)

An optimal entropic uncertainty relation in a two-dimensional Hilbert space

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi, Luca Marinatto, Raffaele Romano

Abstract: We derive an optimal entropic uncertainty relation for an arbitrary pair of observables in a two-dimensional Hilbert space. Such a result, for the simple case we are considering, definitively improves all the entropic uncertainty relations which have appeared in the literature. We derive an optimal entropic uncertainty relation for an arbitrary pair of observables in a two-dimensional Hilbert space. Such a result, for the simple case we are considering, definitively improves all the entropic uncertainty relations which have appeared in the literature. △ Less

Submitted 20 October, 2003; originally announced October 2003.

Comments: 7 pages, Latex, 2 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Lett. A 317 (2003) 32-36

Quantum vs classical computation: a proposal opening a new perspective

Authors: A. Bassi, G. C. Ghirardi

Abstract: We develop a classical model of computation (the S model) which captures some important features of quantum computation, and which allows to design fast algorithms for solving specific problems. In particular, we show that Deutsch's problem can be trated within the S model of computation in the same way as within quantum computation; also Grover's search problem of an unsorted database finds a s… ▽ More We develop a classical model of computation (the S model) which captures some important features of quantum computation, and which allows to design fast algorithms for solving specific problems. In particular, we show that Deutsch's problem can be trated within the S model of computation in the same way as within quantum computation; also Grover's search problem of an unsorted database finds a surprisingly fast solution. The correct understanding of these results put into a new perspective the relationship between quantum and classical computation. △ Less

Submitted 13 June, 2003; v1 submitted 10 April, 2003; originally announced April 2003.

Comments: 13 pages, RevTeX. Misprints corrected

Dynamical Reduction Models

Authors: Angelo Bassi, GianCarlo Ghirardi

Abstract: The report presents an exhaustive review of the recent attempt to overcome the difficulties that standard quantum mechanics meets in accounting for the measurement (or macro-objectification) problem, an attempt based on the consideration of nonlinear and stochastic modifications of the Schroedinger equation. The proposed new dynamics is characterized by the feature of not contradicting any known… ▽ More The report presents an exhaustive review of the recent attempt to overcome the difficulties that standard quantum mechanics meets in accounting for the measurement (or macro-objectification) problem, an attempt based on the consideration of nonlinear and stochastic modifications of the Schroedinger equation. The proposed new dynamics is characterized by the feature of not contradicting any known fact about microsystems and of accounting, on the basis of a unique, universal dynamical principle, for wavepacket reduction and for the classical behavior of macroscopic systems. We recall the motivations for the new approach and we briefly review the other proposals to circumvent the above mentioned difficulties which appeared in the literature. In this way we make clear the conceptual and historical context characterizing the new approach. After having reviewed the mathematical techniques (stochastic differential calculus) which are essential for the rigorous and precise formulation of the new dynamics, we discuss in great detail its implications and we stress its relevant conceptual achievements. The new proposal requires also to work out an appropriate interpretation; a procedure which leads us to a reconsideration of many important issues about the conceptual status of theories based on a genuinely Hilbert space description of natural processes. We also discuss the possibility and the problems one meets in trying to develop an analogous formalism for the relativistic case. Finally we discuss the experimental implications of the new dynamics for various physical processes which should allow, in principle, to test it against quantum mechanics. △ Less

Submitted 8 April, 2003; v1 submitted 21 February, 2003; originally announced February 2003.

Comments: 165 pages, LaTeX

Journal ref: Phys.Rept. 379 (2003) 257

A general scheme for ensemble purification

Authors: Angelo Bassi, GianCarlo Ghirardi

Abstract: We exhibit a general procedure to purify any given ensemble by identifying an appropriate interaction between the physical system S of the ensemble and the reference system K. We show that the interaction can be chosen in such a way to lead to a spatial separation of the pair S-K. As a consequence, one can use it to prepare at a distance different equivalent ensembles. The argument associates a… ▽ More We exhibit a general procedure to purify any given ensemble by identifying an appropriate interaction between the physical system S of the ensemble and the reference system K. We show that the interaction can be chosen in such a way to lead to a spatial separation of the pair S-K. As a consequence, one can use it to prepare at a distance different equivalent ensembles. The argument associates a physically precise procedure to the purely formal and fictitious process usually considered in the literature. We conclude with an illuminating example taken from quantum computational theory. △ Less

Submitted 5 November, 2002; v1 submitted 26 June, 2002; originally announced June 2002.

Comments: 7 pages, LaTeX. Revised version: typographical errors corrected

Journal ref: Phys.Lett. A309 (2003) 24

Entanglement and Properties

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi, Luca Marinatto

Abstract: Various topics concerning the entanglement of composite quantum systems are considered with particular emphasis concerning the strict relations of such a problem with the one of attributing objective properties to the constituents. In particular we will focus our attention to composite quantum systems composed of identical constituents, with the purpose of dealing with subtle issues, which have… ▽ More Various topics concerning the entanglement of composite quantum systems are considered with particular emphasis concerning the strict relations of such a problem with the one of attributing objective properties to the constituents. In particular we will focus our attention to composite quantum systems composed of identical constituents, with the purpose of dealing with subtle issues, which have never been adequately discussed in the literature, originating from the true indistinguishability of the subsystems involved. △ Less

Submitted 6 May, 2003; v1 submitted 4 June, 2002; originally announced June 2002.

Comments: 10 pages, Latex, corrected typos

Journal ref: Fortschr. Phys. 51, 379-387 (2003)

Dynamical Reduction Models with General Gaussian Noises

Authors: Angelo Bassi, GianCarlo Ghirardi

Abstract: We consider the effect of replacing in stochastic differential equations leading to the dynamical collapse of the statevector, white noise stochastic processes with non white ones. We prove that such a modification can be consistently performed without altering the most interesting features of the previous models. One of the reasons to discuss this matter derives from the desire of being allowed… ▽ More We consider the effect of replacing in stochastic differential equations leading to the dynamical collapse of the statevector, white noise stochastic processes with non white ones. We prove that such a modification can be consistently performed without altering the most interesting features of the previous models. One of the reasons to discuss this matter derives from the desire of being allowed to deal with physical stochastic fields, such as the gravitational one, which cannot give rise to white noises. From our point of view the most relevant motivation for the approach we propose here derives from the fact that in relativistic models the occurrence of white noises is the main responsible for the appearance of untractable divergences. Therefore, one can hope that resorting to non white noises one can overcome such a difficulty. We investigate stochastic equations with non white noises, we discuss their reduction properties and their physical implications. Our analysis has a precise interest not only for the above mentioned subject but also for the general study of dissipative systems and decoherence. △ Less

Submitted 27 January, 2002; originally announced January 2002.

Comments: 22 pages, Latex

Journal ref: Phys.Rev. A65 (2002) 042114

Entanglement and Properties of Composite Quantum Systems: a Conceptual and Mathematical Analysis

Authors: Giancarlo Ghirardi, Luca Marinatto, Tullio Weber

Abstract: Various topics concerning the entanglement of composite quantum systems are considered with particular emphasis concerning the strict relations of such a problem with the one of attributing objective properties to the constituents. Most of the paper deals with composite systems in pure states. After a detailed discussion and a precise formal analysis of the case of systems of distinguishable par… ▽ More Various topics concerning the entanglement of composite quantum systems are considered with particular emphasis concerning the strict relations of such a problem with the one of attributing objective properties to the constituents. Most of the paper deals with composite systems in pure states. After a detailed discussion and a precise formal analysis of the case of systems of distinguishable particles, the problems of entanglement and the one of the properties of subsystems of systems of identical particles are thourougly discussed. This part is the most interesting and new and it focuses various subtle questions which have never been adequately discussed in the literature. Some inappropriate assertions which appeared in recent papers are analyzed. The relations of the main subject of the paper with the nonlocal aspects of quantum mechanics, as well as with the possibility of deriving Bell's inequality are also considered. △ Less

Submitted 4 March, 2002; v1 submitted 4 September, 2001; originally announced September 2001.

Comments: revised version: added subsec. 9.2.5; removed Theo. 12.1; minor grammatical changes; 57 pages; Latex; to be published on Journal of Statistical Physics

Journal ref: J. Stat. Phys.; Vol. 108 (2002) 49-121

A General Argument Against the Universal Validity of the Superposition Principle

Authors: Angelo Bassi, GianCarlo Ghirardi

Abstract: We reconsider a well known problem of quantum theory, i.e. the so called measurement (or macro-objectification) problem, and we rederive the fact that it gives rise to serious problems of interpretation. The novelty of our approach derives from the fact that the relevant conclusion is obtained in a completely general way, in particular, without resorting to any of the assumptions of ideality whi… ▽ More We reconsider a well known problem of quantum theory, i.e. the so called measurement (or macro-objectification) problem, and we rederive the fact that it gives rise to serious problems of interpretation. The novelty of our approach derives from the fact that the relevant conclusion is obtained in a completely general way, in particular, without resorting to any of the assumptions of ideality which are usually done for the measurement process. The generality and unescapability of our assumptions (we take into account possible malfunctionings of the apparatus, its unavoidable entanglement with the environmment, its high but not absolute reliability, its fundamentally uncontrollable features) allow to draw the conclusion that the very possibility of performing measurements on a microsystem combined with the assumed general validity of the linear nature of quantum evolution leads to a fundamental contradiction. △ Less

Submitted 5 September, 2000; originally announced September 2000.

Comments: 17 pages, Latex, to appear in Phys. Lett. A

Journal ref: Phys.Lett. A275 (2000) 373

Local measurements of nonlocal observables and the relativistic reduction process

Authors: GianCarlo Ghirardi

Abstract: In this paper we reconsider the constraints which are imposed by relativistic requirements to any model of dynamical reduction. We review the debate on the subject and we call attention on the fundamental contributions by Aharonov and Albert. Having done this we present a new formulation, which is much simpler and more apt for our analysis, of the proposal put forward by these authors to perform… ▽ More In this paper we reconsider the constraints which are imposed by relativistic requirements to any model of dynamical reduction. We review the debate on the subject and we call attention on the fundamental contributions by Aharonov and Albert. Having done this we present a new formulation, which is much simpler and more apt for our analysis, of the proposal put forward by these authors to perform measurements of nonlocal observables by means of local interactions and detections. We take into account recently proposed relativistic models of dynamical reduction and we show that, in spite of some mathematical difficulties related to the appearence of divergences, they represent a perfectly appropriate conceptual framework which meets all necessary requirements for a relativistic account of wave packet reduction. Subtle questions like the appropriate way to deal with counterfactual reasoning in a relativistic and nonlocal context are also analyzed in detail. △ Less

Submitted 31 March, 2000; originally announced March 2000.

About the Notion of Truth in the Decoherent Histories Approach: a reply to Griffiths

Authors: Angelo Bassi, GianCarlo Ghirardi

Abstract: Griffiths claims that the ``single family rule'', a basic postulate of the decoherent histories approach, rules out our requirement that any decoherent history has a unique truth value, independently from the decoherent family to which it may belong. Here we analyze the reasons which make our requirement indispensable and we discuss the consequences of rejecting it. Griffiths claims that the ``single family rule'', a basic postulate of the decoherent histories approach, rules out our requirement that any decoherent history has a unique truth value, independently from the decoherent family to which it may belong. Here we analyze the reasons which make our requirement indispensable and we discuss the consequences of rejecting it. △ Less

Submitted 13 December, 1999; originally announced December 1999.

Comments: 4 pages, Latex, to appear in Phys. Lett. A

Journal ref: Phys.Lett. A265 (2000) 153

Decoherent Histories and Realism

Authors: Angelo Bassi, GianCarlo Ghirardi

Abstract: We reconsider the Decoherent Histories approach to Quantum Mechanics and we analyze some problems related to its interpretation which, according to us, have not been adequately clarified by its proponents. We put forward some assumptions which, in our opinion, are necessary for a realistic interpretation of the probabilities that the formalism attaches to decoherent histories. We prove that such… ▽ More We reconsider the Decoherent Histories approach to Quantum Mechanics and we analyze some problems related to its interpretation which, according to us, have not been adequately clarified by its proponents. We put forward some assumptions which, in our opinion, are necessary for a realistic interpretation of the probabilities that the formalism attaches to decoherent histories. We prove that such assumptions, unless one limits the set of the decoherent families which can be taken into account, lead to a logical contradiction. The line of reasoning we will follow is conceptually different from other arguments which have been presented and which have been rejected by the supporters of the Decoherent Histories approach. The conclusion is that the Decoherent Histories approach, to be considered as an interesting realistic alternative to the orthodox interpretation of Quantum Mechanics, requires the identification of a mathematically precise criterion to characterize an appropriate set of decoherent families which does not give rise to any problem. △ Less

Submitted 7 December, 1999; originally announced December 1999.

Comments: 34 pages, LaTeX. To appear in Journ. Stat. Phys

Journal ref: J.Statist.Phys. 98 (2000) 457-494

More about Dynamical Reduction and the Enumeration Principle

Authors: Angelo Bassi, GianCarlo Ghirardi

Abstract: In view of the arguments put forward by Clifton and Monton [1999] in a recent preprint, we reconsider the alleged conflict of dynamical reduction models with the enumeration principle. We prove that our original analysis of such a problem is correct, that the GRW model does not meet any difficulty and that the reasoning of the above authors is inappropriate since it does not take into account th… ▽ More In view of the arguments put forward by Clifton and Monton [1999] in a recent preprint, we reconsider the alleged conflict of dynamical reduction models with the enumeration principle. We prove that our original analysis of such a problem is correct, that the GRW model does not meet any difficulty and that the reasoning of the above authors is inappropriate since it does not take into account the correct interpretation of the dynamical reduction theories. △ Less

Submitted 14 July, 1999; originally announced July 1999.

Comments: 23 pages, Latex, to appear in Brit. J. Phil. Sci

Journal ref: Brit. Journ. Phil. Sci. 50, 719 (1999).