-
Quantum pions
Authors:
M. Fabbrichesi,
R. Floreanini,
E. Gabrielli,
L. Marzola
Abstract:
We show that two- and three-pion states produced in the decay of neutral kaons are contextual, entangled, and Bell nonlocal in isospin space. By reinterpreting the experimental values of the different isospin amplitudes, we can determine the amount of entanglement enjoyed by these states and the extent to which they violate the non-contextuality and Bell locality inequalities. Notably, the three-p…
▽ More
We show that two- and three-pion states produced in the decay of neutral kaons are contextual, entangled, and Bell nonlocal in isospin space. By reinterpreting the experimental values of the different isospin amplitudes, we can determine the amount of entanglement enjoyed by these states and the extent to which they violate the non-contextuality and Bell locality inequalities. Notably, the three-pion state offers a genuine multipartite test of Bell nonlocality with qutrits.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
Tests of quantum contextuality in particle physics
Authors:
M. Fabbrichesi,
R. Floreanini,
E. Gabrielli,
L. Marzola
Abstract:
Quantum contextuality refers to the impossibility of assigning a predefined, intrinsic value to a physical property of a system independently of the context in which the property is measured. It is, perhaps, the most fundamental feature of quantum mechanics. The many states with different spin that particle physics provides are the ideal setting for testing contextuality. We verify that the polari…
▽ More
Quantum contextuality refers to the impossibility of assigning a predefined, intrinsic value to a physical property of a system independently of the context in which the property is measured. It is, perhaps, the most fundamental feature of quantum mechanics. The many states with different spin that particle physics provides are the ideal setting for testing contextuality. We verify that the polarization states of single spin-1 massive particles produced at colliders are contextual. We test $W^{+}$ gauge bosons produced in top-quark decays, $J/ψ$ and $K^{*}(892)^0$ mesons in $B$-meson decays and $φ$ mesons in $χ^0_c$ and $χ^1_c$ charmonium decays by reinterpreting the data and the analyses of the ATLAS, LHCb, Belle II and BESIII experimental collaborations, respectively. The polarization states of these four particles show contextuality with a significance larger than $5σ$. We also discuss the presence of quantum contextuality in spin states of bipartite systems formed by spin-1/2 particles. We test $Λ$ and $Σ$ baryons reinterpreting two BESIII data analyses, and pairs of top quarks utilizing a recent analysis of the CMS collaboration. Quantum contextuality is present with a significance exceeding $5σ$ also in these cases. In addition, we study the feasibility of testing quantum contextuality by means of $Z$ boson production in association with the Higgs boson, $Z$ and $W$ bosons pairs created in Higgs boson decays and with pairs of $τ$ leptons. For the latter, we use Monte Carlo simulations that mimic the settings of SuperKEKB and of future lepton colliders. Experiments at high energies, though not designed for the purpose, perform surprisingly well in testing for quantum contextuality.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
Quantum Information meets High-Energy Physics: Input to the update of the European Strategy for Particle Physics
Authors:
Yoav Afik,
Federica Fabbri,
Matthew Low,
Luca Marzola,
Juan Antonio Aguilar-Saavedra,
Mohammad Mahdi Altakach,
Nedaa Alexandra Asbah,
Yang Bai,
Hannah Banks,
Alan J. Barr,
Alexander Bernal,
Thomas E. Browder,
Paweł Caban,
J. Alberto Casas,
Kun Cheng,
Frédéric Déliot,
Regina Demina,
Antonio Di Domenico,
Michał Eckstein,
Marco Fabbrichesi,
Benjamin Fuks,
Emidio Gabrielli,
Dorival Gonçalves,
Radosław Grabarczyk,
Michele Grossi
, et al. (46 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Some of the most astonishing and prominent properties of Quantum Mechanics, such as entanglement and Bell nonlocality, have only been studied extensively in dedicated low-energy laboratory setups. The feasibility of these studies in the high-energy regime explored by particle colliders was only recently shown, and has gathered the attention of the scientific community. For the range of particles a…
▽ More
Some of the most astonishing and prominent properties of Quantum Mechanics, such as entanglement and Bell nonlocality, have only been studied extensively in dedicated low-energy laboratory setups. The feasibility of these studies in the high-energy regime explored by particle colliders was only recently shown, and has gathered the attention of the scientific community. For the range of particles and fundamental interactions involved, particle colliders provide a novel environment where quantum information theory can be probed, with energies exceeding by about 12 orders of magnitude those employed in dedicated laboratory setups. Furthermore, collider detectors have inherent advantages in performing certain quantum information measurements, and allow for the reconstruction of the state of the system under consideration via quantum state tomography. Here, we elaborate on the potential, challenges, and goals of this innovative and rapidly evolving line of research, and discuss its expected impact on both quantum information theory and high-energy physics.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2025; v1 submitted 31 March, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
About testing Bell locality at colliders
Authors:
M. Fabbrichesi,
R. Floreanini,
L. Marzola
Abstract:
Quantum tomography at colliders makes it possible to measure the amount of entanglement and test the violation of the Bell inequality. We explain in detail how this is possible and why it offers the possibility of examining from a new angle the feasibility of local hidden variable models.
Quantum tomography at colliders makes it possible to measure the amount of entanglement and test the violation of the Bell inequality. We explain in detail how this is possible and why it offers the possibility of examining from a new angle the feasibility of local hidden variable models.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Quantum contextuality of spin-1 massive particles
Authors:
M. Fabbrichesi,
R. Floreanini,
E. Gabrielli,
L. Marzola
Abstract:
Contextuality is a fundamental property of quantum mechanics. Contrary to entanglement, which can only exist in composite systems, contextuality is also present for single entities. The case of a three-level system is of particular interest because--in agreement with the Bell-Kochen-Specker theorem--it is the simplest in which quantum contextuality is necessarily present. We verify that the polari…
▽ More
Contextuality is a fundamental property of quantum mechanics. Contrary to entanglement, which can only exist in composite systems, contextuality is also present for single entities. The case of a three-level system is of particular interest because--in agreement with the Bell-Kochen-Specker theorem--it is the simplest in which quantum contextuality is necessarily present. We verify that the polarizations of spin-1 massive particles produced at collider experiments indeed exhibit contextuality. To this purpose we consider $W$ gauge bosons produced in top-quark decays, $J/ψ$ and $K^{*}(892)^0$ mesons created in $B$-meson decays and $φ$ mesons resulting from $χ^0_c$ charmonium decays, making use of the data collected and analyzed by the ATLAS, LHCb and BESIII collaborations, respectively. The polarizations of all these four particles show contextuality with a significance of more than $5σ$.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
The trace distance between density matrices, a nifty tool in new-physics searches
Authors:
Marco Fabbrichesi,
Matthew Low,
Luca Marzola
Abstract:
Quantum information methods have been brought to bear on high-energy physics, including the study of entanglement and Bell nonlocality in collider experiments. Quantum information observables have also been employed to constrain possible new physics effects. We improve on this point by introducing quantum information tools routinely used to compare quantum states: the trace distance and the fideli…
▽ More
Quantum information methods have been brought to bear on high-energy physics, including the study of entanglement and Bell nonlocality in collider experiments. Quantum information observables have also been employed to constrain possible new physics effects. We improve on this point by introducing quantum information tools routinely used to compare quantum states: the trace distance and the fidelity. We find that the former outperforms other quantum information observables considered in the literature and, together with the cross section, yields the strongest bounds on possible departures from the Standard Model. The power of the proposed methodology is demonstrated with three examples of new physics searches. The first concerns the chromomagnetic dipole moment of the top quark and yields the first bound computed by means of quantum tomography and actual experimental data. The other two examples use Monte Carlo simulations and set the projected limits on the anomalous couplings of the $τ$ leptons at Belle and at a future collider, which is taken to be LEP3. For these new physics searches we also compare the sensitivity of the trace distance to those of other quantum information quantities like concurrence, magic, and the fidelity distance. In passing, we provide the first determinations of magic in colliders data by analyzing the top-quark pair production at the LHC and the charmonium decays. The significance is well above the $5σ$ level in both the cases.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
Quantum tomography with $τ$ leptons at the FCC-ee
Authors:
M. Fabbrichesi,
L. Marzola
Abstract:
The Future Circular Collider (FCC) -- in its first incarnation as a lepton collider -- will produce, according to the proposed design, more than 100 billion pairs of $τ$ leptons after working for four years at the energy of the $Z$-boson resonance. The $τ$ lepton is special because its relatively long lifetime makes it possible to reconstruct the momenta of neutrinos emitted in the single pion dec…
▽ More
The Future Circular Collider (FCC) -- in its first incarnation as a lepton collider -- will produce, according to the proposed design, more than 100 billion pairs of $τ$ leptons after working for four years at the energy of the $Z$-boson resonance. The $τ$ lepton is special because its relatively long lifetime makes it possible to reconstruct the momenta of neutrinos emitted in the single pion decay mode. The resulting large number of events is an ideal source for a full quantum tomography of the process that will test quantum entanglement and the violation of Bell inequality with unprecedented precision. In addition, the study of polarizations and spin correlations can provide a competitive determination of the Weinberg angle $ θ_W$ and constrain possible anomalous couplings in the neutral electroweak current. We utilize analytic results and Monte Carlo simulations to explore to what extent these goals might be accomplished.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2024; v1 submitted 15 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Quantum entanglement and Bell inequality violation at colliders
Authors:
Alan J. Barr,
Marco Fabbrichesi,
Roberto Floreanini,
Emidio Gabrielli,
Luca Marzola
Abstract:
The study of entanglement in particle physics has been gathering pace in the past few years. It is a new field that is providing important results about the possibility of detecting entanglement and testing Bell inequality at colliders for final states as diverse as top-quark, $τ$-lepton pairs and $Λ$-baryons, massive gauge bosons and vector mesons. In this review, after presenting definitions, to…
▽ More
The study of entanglement in particle physics has been gathering pace in the past few years. It is a new field that is providing important results about the possibility of detecting entanglement and testing Bell inequality at colliders for final states as diverse as top-quark, $τ$-lepton pairs and $Λ$-baryons, massive gauge bosons and vector mesons. In this review, after presenting definitions, tools and basic results that are necessary for understanding these developments, we summarize the main findings -- as published by the beginning of year 2024 -- including analyses of experimental data in $B$ meson decays and top-quark pair production. We include a detailed discussion of the results for both qubit and qutrits systems, that is, final states containing spin one-half and spin one particles. Entanglement has also been proposed as a new tool to constrain new particles and fields beyond the Standard Model and we introduce the reader to this promising feature as well.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2024; v1 submitted 12 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Probing entanglement and testing Bell inequality violation with $\textrm{e}^{+}\textrm{e}^{-} \rightarrow τ^{+}τ^{-}$ at Belle II
Authors:
Karl Ehatäht,
Marco Fabbrichesi,
Luca Marzola,
Christian Veelken
Abstract:
We present a feasibility study to probe quantum entanglement and Belle inequality violation in the process $\textrm{e}^{+}\textrm{e}^{-} \rightarrow τ^{+}τ^{-}$ at a center-of-mass energy of $\sqrt{s} = 10.579$ GeV. The sensitivity of the analysis is enhanced by applying a selection on the scattering angle $\vartheta$ in the $τ^{+}τ^{-}$ center-of-mass frame. We analyze events in which both $τ$ le…
▽ More
We present a feasibility study to probe quantum entanglement and Belle inequality violation in the process $\textrm{e}^{+}\textrm{e}^{-} \rightarrow τ^{+}τ^{-}$ at a center-of-mass energy of $\sqrt{s} = 10.579$ GeV. The sensitivity of the analysis is enhanced by applying a selection on the scattering angle $\vartheta$ in the $τ^{+}τ^{-}$ center-of-mass frame. We analyze events in which both $τ$ leptons decay to hadrons, using a combination of decay channels $τ^{-} \rightarrow π^{-}ν_τ$, $τ^{-} \rightarrow π^{-}π^{0}ν_τ$, and $τ^{-} \rightarrow π^{-}π^{+}π^{-}ν_τ$. The spin orientation of the $τ$ leptons in these decays is reconstructed using the polarimeter-vector method. Assuming a dataset of $200$ million $τ^{+}τ^{-}$ events and accounting for experimental resolutions, we expect the observation of quantum entanglement and Bell inequality violation by the Belle-II experiment will be possible with a significance well in excess of five standard deviations.
△ Less
Submitted 17 January, 2024; v1 submitted 29 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Bell inequality is violated in $B^0\to J/ψ\, K^{\star}(892)^0$ decays
Authors:
M. Fabbrichesi,
R. Floreanini,
E. Gabrielli,
L. Marzola
Abstract:
The violation of the Bell inequality is one of the hallmarks of quantum mechanics and can be used to rule out local deterministic alternative descriptions. We utilize the data analysis published by the LHCb collaboration on the helicity amplitudes for the decay $B^0\to J/ψ\,K^*(892)^0$ to compute the entanglement among the polarizations of the final vector mesons and the violation of the Bell ineq…
▽ More
The violation of the Bell inequality is one of the hallmarks of quantum mechanics and can be used to rule out local deterministic alternative descriptions. We utilize the data analysis published by the LHCb collaboration on the helicity amplitudes for the decay $B^0\to J/ψ\,K^*(892)^0$ to compute the entanglement among the polarizations of the final vector mesons and the violation of the Bell inequality that it entails. We find that quantum entanglement can be detected with a significance well above 5$σ$ (nominally 84$σ$) and Bell inequality is violated with a significance well above 5$σ$ (nominally 36$σ$) -- thereby firmly establishing these distinguishing feature of quantum mechanics at high energies in a collider setting and in the presence of strong and weak interactions. Entanglement is also present and the Bell inequality is violated in other decays of the $B$ mesons into vector mesons, but with lesser significance.
△ Less
Submitted 26 January, 2024; v1 submitted 8 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Bell inequalities and quantum entanglement in weak gauge bosons production at the LHC and future colliders
Authors:
M. Fabbrichesi,
R. Floreanini,
E. Gabrielli,
L. Marzola
Abstract:
Quantum entanglement of weak interaction gauge bosons produced at colliders can be explored by computing the corresponding polarization density matrix. To this end, we consider the Higgs boson decays $H\to W W^*$ and $H\to Z Z^*$, in which $W^*$ and $Z^*$ are off-shell states, and the $WW$, $WZ$ and $ZZ$ di-boson production in proton collisions. The polarization density matrix of the di-boson stat…
▽ More
Quantum entanglement of weak interaction gauge bosons produced at colliders can be explored by computing the corresponding polarization density matrix. To this end, we consider the Higgs boson decays $H\to W W^*$ and $H\to Z Z^*$, in which $W^*$ and $Z^*$ are off-shell states, and the $WW$, $WZ$ and $ZZ$ di-boson production in proton collisions. The polarization density matrix of the di-boson state is determined by the amplitude of the production process and can be experimentally reconstructed from the angular distribution of the momenta of the final states into which the gauge bosons decay. We show that a suitable instance of the Bell inequality is violated in $H\to Z Z^*$ to a degree that can be tested at the LHC with future data. The same Bell inequality is violated in the production of $WW$ and $ZZ$ boson pairs for invariant masses above 900 GeV and scattering angles close to $π/2$ in the center of mass frame. LHC data in this case are not sufficient to establish the violation of the Bell inequality. We also analyze the prospects for detecting Bell inequality violations in di-boson final states at future $e^+e^-$ and muon colliders. A further observable that provides a lower bound on the amount of polarization entanglement in the di-boson system is computed for each of the examined processes. The analytic expressions for the polarization density matrices are presented in full in an Appendix. We also provide the unitary matrices required in the optimization procedure necessary in testing the Bell inequalities.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2023; v1 submitted 1 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Testing Bell inequalities at the LHC with top-quark pairs
Authors:
M. Fabbrichesi,
R. Floreanini,
G. Panizzo
Abstract:
Entanglement between the spins of top-quark pairs produced at a collider can be used to test a (generalized) Bell inequality at energies never explored so far. We show how the measurement of a single observable can provide a test of the violation of the Bell inequality at the 98% CL with the data already collected at the Large Hadron Collider and at the 99.99% CL with the higher luminosity of the…
▽ More
Entanglement between the spins of top-quark pairs produced at a collider can be used to test a (generalized) Bell inequality at energies never explored so far. We show how the measurement of a single observable can provide a test of the violation of the Bell inequality at the 98% CL with the data already collected at the Large Hadron Collider and at the 99.99% CL with the higher luminosity of the next run.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2021; v1 submitted 23 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
