-
Temporal Entanglement and Witnesses of Non-Classicality
Authors:
Giuseppe Di Pietra,
Gaurav Bhole,
James Eaton,
Andrew J. Baldwin,
Jonathan A. Jones,
Vlatko Vedral,
Chiara Marletto
Abstract:
The universality of quantum theory has been questioned ever since it was proposed. Key to this long-unsolved question is to test whether a given physical system has non-classical features. Here we connect recently proposed witnesses of non-classicality, based on information-theoretic ideas, with the theory of temporal entanglement. We provide a protocol to witness the non-classicality of a system…
▽ More
The universality of quantum theory has been questioned ever since it was proposed. Key to this long-unsolved question is to test whether a given physical system has non-classical features. Here we connect recently proposed witnesses of non-classicality, based on information-theoretic ideas, with the theory of temporal entanglement. We provide a protocol to witness the non-classicality of a system by probing it with a qubit: we show that, assuming a general conservation law, violating temporal Bell inequalities on the qubit probe implies the non-classicality of the system under investigation. We also perform proof-of-principle experimental emulations of the proposed witness of non-classicality, using a three qubit Nuclear Magnetic Resonance quantum computer. Our result is robust, as it relies on minimal assumptions, and remarkably it can be applied in a broad range of contexts, from quantum biology to quantum gravity.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
Mechanism behind creating qubit gates expressed as interfering quantum pathway amplitudes
Authors:
Michael Kasprzak,
Gaurav Bhole,
Herschel Rabitz
Abstract:
Hamiltonian encoding was introduced as a technique for revealing the mechanism of controlled quantum systems. It does so by decomposing the evolution into pathways between the computational basis states, where each pathway has an associated complex amplitude. The magnitude of a pathway amplitude determines its significance and many pathways constructively and/or destructively interfere to produce…
▽ More
Hamiltonian encoding was introduced as a technique for revealing the mechanism of controlled quantum systems. It does so by decomposing the evolution into pathways between the computational basis states, where each pathway has an associated complex amplitude. The magnitude of a pathway amplitude determines its significance and many pathways constructively and/or destructively interfere to produce the final evolution of the system. In this paper, we apply Hamiltonian encoding to reveal the mechanism behind creating qubit gates implemented via optimal control pulses. An X gate, two CNOT gates, and a SWAP gate are examined to determine the degree of interference involved and to demonstrate that different optimal controls produce distinct mechanisms. Although the detailed mechanism for creating any gate depends on the nature of the control field, the mechanism analysis tools are generic. The presented gates and their mechanisms in this paper are thus illustrative and a researcher may apply these same tools to any gate with a suitable optimal control field.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
The Top Manifold Connectedness of Quantum Control Landscapes
Authors:
Yidian Fan,
Re-Bing Wu,
Tak-San Ho,
Gaurav V. Bhole,
Herschel Rabitz
Abstract:
The control of quantum systems has been proven to possess trap-free optimization landscapes under the satisfaction of proper assumptions. However, many details of the landscape geometry and their influence on search efficiency still need to be fully understood. This paper numerically explores the path-connectedness of globally optimal control solutions forming the top manifold of the landscape. We…
▽ More
The control of quantum systems has been proven to possess trap-free optimization landscapes under the satisfaction of proper assumptions. However, many details of the landscape geometry and their influence on search efficiency still need to be fully understood. This paper numerically explores the path-connectedness of globally optimal control solutions forming the top manifold of the landscape. We randomly sample a plurality of optimal controls in the top manifold to assess the existence of a continuous path at the top of the landscape that connects two arbitrary optimal solutions. It is shown that for different quantum control objectives including state-to-state transition probabilities, observable expectation values and unitary transformations, such a continuous path can be readily found, implying that these top manifolds are fundamentally path-connected. The significance of the latter conjecture lies in seeking locations in the top manifold where an ancillary objective can also be optimized while maintaining the full optimality of the original objective that defined the landscape.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2024; v1 submitted 23 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
On the Hardness of Measuring Magic
Authors:
Roy J. Garcia,
Gaurav Bhole,
Kaifeng Bu,
Liyuan Chen,
Haribabu Arthanari,
Arthur Jaffe
Abstract:
Quantum computers promise to solve computational problems significantly faster than classical computers. These 'speed-ups' are achieved by utilizing a resource known as magic. Measuring the amount of magic used by a device allows us to quantify its potential computational power. Without this property, quantum computers are no faster than classical computers. Whether magic can be accurately measure…
▽ More
Quantum computers promise to solve computational problems significantly faster than classical computers. These 'speed-ups' are achieved by utilizing a resource known as magic. Measuring the amount of magic used by a device allows us to quantify its potential computational power. Without this property, quantum computers are no faster than classical computers. Whether magic can be accurately measured on large-scale quantum computers has remained an open problem. To address this question, we introduce Pauli instability as a measure of magic and experimentally measure it on the IBM Eagle quantum processor. We prove that measuring large (i.e., extensive) quantities of magic is intractable. Our results suggest that one may only measure magic when a quantum computer does not provide a speed-up. We support our conclusions with both theoretical and experimental evidence. Our work illustrates the capabilities and limitations of quantum technology in measuring one of the most important resources in quantum computation.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
Efficient Hamiltonian encoding algorithms for extracting quantum control mechanism as interfering pathway amplitudes in the Dyson series
Authors:
Erez Abrams,
Michael Kasprzak,
Gaurav Bhole,
Tak-San Ho,
Herschel Rabitz
Abstract:
Hamiltonian encoding is a methodology for revealing the mechanism behind the dynamics governing controlled quantum systems. In this paper, following Mitra and Rabitz [Phys. Rev. A 67, 033407 (2003)], we define mechanism via pathways of eigenstates that describe the evolution of the system, where each pathway is associated with a complex-valued amplitude corresponding to a term in the Dyson series.…
▽ More
Hamiltonian encoding is a methodology for revealing the mechanism behind the dynamics governing controlled quantum systems. In this paper, following Mitra and Rabitz [Phys. Rev. A 67, 033407 (2003)], we define mechanism via pathways of eigenstates that describe the evolution of the system, where each pathway is associated with a complex-valued amplitude corresponding to a term in the Dyson series. The evolution of the system is determined by the constructive and destructive interference of these pathway amplitudes. Pathways with similar attributes can be grouped together into pathway classes. The amplitudes of pathway classes are computed by modulating the Hamiltonian matrix elements and decoding the subsequent evolution of the system rather than by direct computation of the individual terms in the Dyson series. The original implementation of Hamiltonian encoding was computationally intensive and became prohibitively expensive in large quantum systems. This paper presents two new encoding algorithms that calculate the amplitudes of pathway classes by using techniques from graph theory and algebraic topology to exploit patterns in the set of allowed transitions, greatly reducing the number of matrix elements that need to be modulated. These new algorithms provide an exponential decrease in both computation time and memory utilization with respect to the Hilbert space dimension of the system. To demonstrate the use of these techniques, they are applied to two illustrative state-to-state transition problems.
△ Less
Submitted 18 February, 2025; v1 submitted 8 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Robust Quantum Control: Analysis & Synthesis via Averaging
Authors:
Robert L. Kosut,
Gaurav Bhole,
Herschel Rabitz
Abstract:
An approach is presented for robustness analysis and quantum (unitary) control synthesis based on the classic method of averaging. The result is a multicriterion optimization competing the nominal (uncertainty-free) fidelity with a well known robustness measure: the size of an interaction (error) Hamiltonian, essentially the first term in the Magnus expansion of an interaction unitary. Combining t…
▽ More
An approach is presented for robustness analysis and quantum (unitary) control synthesis based on the classic method of averaging. The result is a multicriterion optimization competing the nominal (uncertainty-free) fidelity with a well known robustness measure: the size of an interaction (error) Hamiltonian, essentially the first term in the Magnus expansion of an interaction unitary. Combining this with the fact that the topology of the control landscape at high fidelity is determined by the null space of the nominal fidelity Hessian, we arrive at a new two-stage algorithm. Once the nominal fidelity is sufficiently high, we approximate both the nominal fidelity and robustness measure as quadratics in the control increments. An optimal solution is obtained by solving a convex optimization for the control increments at each iteration to keep the nominal fidelity high and reduce the robustness measure. Additionally, by separating fidelity from the robustness measure, more flexibility is available for uncertainty modeling.
△ Less
Submitted 30 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Transforming pure and mixed states using an NMR quantum homogeniser
Authors:
Maria Violaris,
Gaurav Bhole,
Jonathan A. Jones,
Vlatko Vedral,
Chiara Marletto
Abstract:
The universal quantum homogeniser can transform a qubit from any state to any other state with arbitrary accuracy, using only unitary transformations to perform this task. Here we present an implementation of a finite quantum homogeniser using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), with a four-qubit system. We compare the homogenisation of a mixed state to a pure state, and the reverse process. After a…
▽ More
The universal quantum homogeniser can transform a qubit from any state to any other state with arbitrary accuracy, using only unitary transformations to perform this task. Here we present an implementation of a finite quantum homogeniser using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), with a four-qubit system. We compare the homogenisation of a mixed state to a pure state, and the reverse process. After accounting for the effects of decoherence in the system, we find the experimental results to be consistent with the theoretical symmetry in how the qubit states evolve in the two cases. We analyse the implications of this symmetry by interpreting the homogeniser as a physical implementation of pure state preparation and information scrambling.
△ Less
Submitted 27 January, 2021; v1 submitted 6 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Efficient Hamiltonian programming in qubit arrays with nearest-neighbour couplings
Authors:
Takahiro Tsunoda,
Gaurav Bhole,
Stephen A. Jones,
Jonathan A. Jones,
Peter J. Leek
Abstract:
We consider the problem of selectively controlling couplings in a practical quantum processor with always-on interactions that are diagonal in the computational basis, using sequences of local NOT gates. This methodology is well-known in NMR implementations, but previous approaches do not scale efficiently for the general fully-connected Hamiltonian, where the complexity of finding time-optimal so…
▽ More
We consider the problem of selectively controlling couplings in a practical quantum processor with always-on interactions that are diagonal in the computational basis, using sequences of local NOT gates. This methodology is well-known in NMR implementations, but previous approaches do not scale efficiently for the general fully-connected Hamiltonian, where the complexity of finding time-optimal solutions makes them only practical up to a few tens of qubits. Given the rapid growth in the number of qubits in cutting-edge quantum processors, it is of interest to investigate the applicability of this control scheme to much larger scale systems with realistic restrictions on connectivity. Here we present an efficient scheme to find near time-optimal solutions that can be applied to engineered qubit arrays with local connectivity for any number of qubits, indicating the potential for practical quantum computing in such systems.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2020; v1 submitted 17 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
A robust entangling gate for polar molecules using magnetic and microwave fields
Authors:
Michael Hughes,
Matthew D. Frye,
Rahul Sawant,
Gaurav Bhole,
Jonathan A. Jones,
Simon L. Cornish,
M. R. Tarbutt,
Jeremy M. Hutson,
Dieter Jaksch,
Jordi Mur-Petit
Abstract:
Polar molecules are an emerging platform for quantum technologies based on their long-range electric dipole-dipole interactions, which open new possibilities for quantum information processing and the quantum simulation of strongly correlated systems. Here, we use magnetic and microwave fields to design a fast entangling gate with $>0.999$ fidelity and which is robust with respect to fluctuations…
▽ More
Polar molecules are an emerging platform for quantum technologies based on their long-range electric dipole-dipole interactions, which open new possibilities for quantum information processing and the quantum simulation of strongly correlated systems. Here, we use magnetic and microwave fields to design a fast entangling gate with $>0.999$ fidelity and which is robust with respect to fluctuations in the trapping and control fields and to small thermal excitations. These results establish the feasibility to build a scalable quantum processor with a broad range of molecular species in optical-lattice and optical-tweezers setups.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2020; v1 submitted 19 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Rescaling interactions for quantum control
Authors:
Gaurav Bhole,
Takahiro Tsunoda,
Peter J. Leek,
Jonathan A. Jones
Abstract:
A powerful control method in experimental quantum computing is the use of spin echoes, employed to select a desired term in the system's internal Hamiltonian, while refocusing others. Here we address a more general problem, describing a method to not only turn on and off particular interactions but also to rescale their strengths so that we can generate any desired effective internal Hamiltonian.…
▽ More
A powerful control method in experimental quantum computing is the use of spin echoes, employed to select a desired term in the system's internal Hamiltonian, while refocusing others. Here we address a more general problem, describing a method to not only turn on and off particular interactions but also to rescale their strengths so that we can generate any desired effective internal Hamiltonian. We propose an algorithm based on linear programming for achieving time-optimal rescaling solutions in fully coupled systems of tens of qubits, which can be modified to obtain near time-optimal solutions for rescaling systems with hundreds of qubits.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2020; v1 submitted 12 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Witnesses of non-classicality for simulated hybrid quantum systems
Authors:
Gaurav Bhole,
Jonathan A. Jones,
Chiara Marletto,
Vlatko Vedral
Abstract:
The task of testing whether quantum theory applies to all physical systems and all scales requires considering situations where a quantum probe interacts with another system that need not obey quantum theory in full. Important examples include the cases where a quantum mass probes the gravitational field, for which a unique quantum theory of gravity does not yet exist, or a quantum field, such as…
▽ More
The task of testing whether quantum theory applies to all physical systems and all scales requires considering situations where a quantum probe interacts with another system that need not obey quantum theory in full. Important examples include the cases where a quantum mass probes the gravitational field, for which a unique quantum theory of gravity does not yet exist, or a quantum field, such as light, interacts with a macroscopic system, such as a biological molecule, which may or may not obey unitary quantum theory. In this context a class of experiments has recently been proposed, where the non-classicality of a physical system that need not obey quantum theory (the gravitational field) can be tested indirectly by detecting whether or not the system is capable of entangling two quantum probes. Here we illustrate some of the subtleties of the argument, to do with the role of locality of interactions and of non-classicality, and perform proof-of-principle experiments illustrating the logic of the proposals, using a Nuclear Magnetic Resonance quantum computational platform with four qubits.
△ Less
Submitted 3 December, 2019; v1 submitted 22 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Practical Pulse Engineering: Gradient Ascent Without Matrix Exponentiation
Authors:
Gaurav Bhole,
Jonathan A. Jones
Abstract:
Since 2005 there has been a huge growth in the use of engineered control pulses to perform desired quantum operations in systems such as NMR quantum information processors. These approaches, which build on the original gradient ascent pulse engineering (GRAPE) algorithm, remain computationally intensive because of the need to calculate matrix exponentials for each time step in the control pulse. H…
▽ More
Since 2005 there has been a huge growth in the use of engineered control pulses to perform desired quantum operations in systems such as NMR quantum information processors. These approaches, which build on the original gradient ascent pulse engineering (GRAPE) algorithm, remain computationally intensive because of the need to calculate matrix exponentials for each time step in the control pulse. Here we discuss how the propagators for each time step can be approximated using the Trotter--Suzuki formula, and a further speed up achieved by avoiding unnecessary operations. The resulting procedure can give a substantial speed gain with negligible cost in propagator error, providing a more practical approach to pulse engineering.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2018; v1 submitted 20 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Rapid Exponentiation using Discrete Operators: Applications in Optimizing Quantum Controls and Simulating Quantum Dynamics
Authors:
Gaurav Bhole,
T. S. Mahesh
Abstract:
Matrix exponentiation (ME) is widely used in various fields of science and engineering. For example, the unitary dynamics of quantum systems is described by exponentiation of Hamiltonian operators. However, despite a significant attention, the numerical evaluation of ME remains computationally expensive, particularly for large dimensions. Often this process becomes a bottleneck in algorithms requi…
▽ More
Matrix exponentiation (ME) is widely used in various fields of science and engineering. For example, the unitary dynamics of quantum systems is described by exponentiation of Hamiltonian operators. However, despite a significant attention, the numerical evaluation of ME remains computationally expensive, particularly for large dimensions. Often this process becomes a bottleneck in algorithms requiring iterative evaluation of ME. Here we propose a method for approximating ME of a single operator with a bounded coefficient into a product of certain discrete operators. This approach, which we refer to as Rapid Exponentiation using Discrete Operators (REDO), is particularly efficient for iterating ME over large numbers. We describe REDO in the context of a quantum system with a constant as well as a time-dependent Hamiltonian, although in principle, it can be adapted in a more general setting. As concrete examples, we choose two applications. First, we incorporate REDO in optimal quantum control algorithms and report a speed-up of several folds over a wide range of system size. Secondly, we propose REDO for numerical simulations of quantum dynamics. In particular, we study exotic quantum freezing with noisy drive fields.
△ Less
Submitted 7 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
Strong Algorithmic Cooling in Large Star-Topology Quantum Registers
Authors:
Varad R. Pande,
Gaurav Bhole,
Deepak Khurana,
T. S. Mahesh
Abstract:
Cooling the qubit into a pure initial state is crucial for realizing fault-tolerant quantum information processing. Here we envisage a star-topology arrangement of reset and computation qubits for this purpose. The reset qubits cool or purify the computation qubit by transferring its entropy to a heat-bath with the help of a heat-bath algorithmic cooling procedure. By combining standard NMR method…
▽ More
Cooling the qubit into a pure initial state is crucial for realizing fault-tolerant quantum information processing. Here we envisage a star-topology arrangement of reset and computation qubits for this purpose. The reset qubits cool or purify the computation qubit by transferring its entropy to a heat-bath with the help of a heat-bath algorithmic cooling procedure. By combining standard NMR methods with powerful quantum control techniques, we cool central qubits of two large star topology systems, with 13 and 37 spins respectively. We obtain polarization enhancements by a factor of over 24, and an associated reduction in the spin temperature from 298 K down to 12 K. Exploiting the enhanced polarization of computation qubit, we prepare combination-coherences of orders up to 15. By benchmarking the decay of these coherences we investigate the underlying noise process. Further, we also cool a pair of computation qubits and subsequently prepare them in an effective pure-state.
△ Less
Submitted 30 July, 2017; v1 submitted 16 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Steering Quantum Dynamics via Bang-Bang Control: Implementing optimal fixed point quantum search algorithm
Authors:
Gaurav Bhole,
Anjusha V. S.,
T. S. Mahesh
Abstract:
A robust control over quantum dynamics is of paramount importance for quantum technologies. Many of the existing control techniques are based on smooth Hamiltonian modulations involving repeated calculations of basic unitaries resulting in time complexities scaling rapidly with the length of the control sequence. On the other hand, the bang-bang controls need one-time calculation of basic unitarie…
▽ More
A robust control over quantum dynamics is of paramount importance for quantum technologies. Many of the existing control techniques are based on smooth Hamiltonian modulations involving repeated calculations of basic unitaries resulting in time complexities scaling rapidly with the length of the control sequence. On the other hand, the bang-bang controls need one-time calculation of basic unitaries and hence scale much more efficiently. By employing a global optimization routine such as the genetic algorithm, it is possible to synthesize not only highly intricate unitaries, but also certain nonunitary operations. Here we demonstrate the unitary control through the first implementation of the optimal fixed-point quantum search algorithm in a three-qubit NMR system. More over, by combining the bang-bang pulses with the twirling process, we also demonstrate a nonunitary transformation of the thermal equilibrium state into an effective pure state in a five-qubit NMR system.
△ Less
Submitted 28 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Benford distributions in NMR
Authors:
Gaurav Bhole,
Abhishek Shukla,
T. S. Mahesh
Abstract:
Benford's Law is an empirical law which predicts the frequency of significant digits in databases corresponding to various phenomena, natural or artificial. Although counter intuitive at the first sight, it predicts a higher occurrence of digit 1, and decreasing occurrences to other larger digits. Here we report the Benford analysis of various NMR databases and draw several interesting inferences.…
▽ More
Benford's Law is an empirical law which predicts the frequency of significant digits in databases corresponding to various phenomena, natural or artificial. Although counter intuitive at the first sight, it predicts a higher occurrence of digit 1, and decreasing occurrences to other larger digits. Here we report the Benford analysis of various NMR databases and draw several interesting inferences. We observe that, in general, NMR signals follow Benford distribution in time-domain as well as in frequency domain. Our survey included NMR signals of various nuclear species in a wide variety of molecules in different phases, namely liquid, liquid-crystalline, and solid. We also studied the dependence of Benford distribution on NMR parameters such as signal to noise ratio, number of scans, pulse angles, and apodization. In this process we also find that, under certain circumstances, the Benford analysis can distinguish a genuine spectrum from a visually identical simulated spectrum. Further we find that chemical-shift databases and amplitudes of certain radio frequency pulses generated using optimal control techniques also satisfy Benford's law to a good extent.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
