Benford's laws tests on S&P500 daily closing values and the corresponding daily log-returns both point to huge non-conformity
Authors:
Marcel Ausloos,
Valerio Ficcadenti,
Gurjeet Dhesi,
Muhammad Shakeel
Abstract:
The so-called Benford's laws are of frequent use in order to observe anomalies and regularities in data sets, in particular, in election results and financial statements. Yet, basic financial market indices have not been much studied, if studied at all, within such a perspective. This paper presents features in the distributions of S\&P500 daily closing values and the corresponding daily log retur…
▽ More
The so-called Benford's laws are of frequent use in order to observe anomalies and regularities in data sets, in particular, in election results and financial statements. Yet, basic financial market indices have not been much studied, if studied at all, within such a perspective. This paper presents features in the distributions of S\&P500 daily closing values and the corresponding daily log returns over a long time interval, [03/01/1950 - 22/08/2014], amounting to 16265 data points. We address the frequencies of the first, second, and first two significant digits counts and explore the conformance to Benford's laws of these distributions at five different (equal size) levels of disaggregation. The log returns are studied for either positive or negative cases. The results for the S&P500 daily closing values are showing a huge lack of non-conformity, whatever the different levels of disaggregation. Some "first digits" and "first two digits" values are even missing. The causes of this non-conformity are discussed, pointing to the danger in taking Benford's laws for granted in huge databases, whence drawing "definite conclusions". The agreements with Benford's laws are much better for the log returns. Such a disparity in agreements finds an explanation in the data set itself: the inherent trend in the index. To further validate this, daily returns have been simulated calibrating the simulations with the observed data averages and tested against Benford's laws. One finds that not only the trend but also the standard deviation of the distributions are relevant parameters in concluding about conformity with Benford's laws.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
Modified Brownian Motion Approach to Modelling Returns Distribution
Authors:
Gurjeet Dhesi,
Muhammad Bilal Shakeel,
Ling Xiao
Abstract:
An innovative extension of Geometric Brownian Motion model is developed by incorporating a weighting factor and a stochastic function modelled as a mixture of power and trigonometric functions. Simulations based on this Modified Brownian Motion Model with optimal weighting factors selected by goodness of fit tests, substantially outperform the basic Geometric Brownian Motion model in terms of fitt…
▽ More
An innovative extension of Geometric Brownian Motion model is developed by incorporating a weighting factor and a stochastic function modelled as a mixture of power and trigonometric functions. Simulations based on this Modified Brownian Motion Model with optimal weighting factors selected by goodness of fit tests, substantially outperform the basic Geometric Brownian Motion model in terms of fitting the returns distribution of historic data price indices. Furthermore we attempt to provide an interpretation of the additional stochastic term in relation to irrational behaviour in financial markets and outline the importance of this novel model.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
Semiclosed Pricing Mechanism
Authors:
Dr. Gurjeet Dhesi,
Mohammad Abdul Washad Emambocus,
Muhammad Bilal Shakeel
Abstract:
This paper aims at designing the different important components of a semi-closed simulated stock market (pricing mechanism, stock allocation and news generation). The purpose is to understand the interactions of the different aspects within a 'semi-closed' system. The complexity and nature of the system led to the process of modifying the pricing mechanism which is viewed from a different angle to…
▽ More
This paper aims at designing the different important components of a semi-closed simulated stock market (pricing mechanism, stock allocation and news generation). The purpose is to understand the interactions of the different aspects within a 'semi-closed' system. The complexity and nature of the system led to the process of modifying the pricing mechanism which is viewed from a different angle to the classical Brownian Motion and the Random Walk model. However, it incorporates the essence of these two fundamental theories and then investigates the matrix of investors' behaviours in relation to news feedbacks. This paper also explores the realm of randomly generated news to the responses of participants to determine rational and irrational behaviours. This is carried out through uncompressing the time within the experiment and looking at concordant and disconcordant behaviour. The focus is on how the modified pricing equation adapts to the conditions and uniqueness surrounding a semi-closed stock market. Thus, this paper looks at how a simple market system where the main determinants of share prices are news, demand and supply along with some filtering of the external forces can affect the behaviours of investors in terms of their portfolio composition. The return distributions can then be stipulated as arising from rational or irrational trajectories and subsequently be simulated and matched via the proposed modified Brownian Motion model to empirical return distributions in specific time periods and markets.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2012; v1 submitted 1 December, 2011;
originally announced December 2011.
