-
Asymmetry in Distributions of Accumulated Gains and Losses in Stock Returns
Authors:
Hamed Farahani,
R. A. Serota
Abstract:
We study decades-long historic distributions of accumulated S\&P500 returns, from daily returns to those over several weeks. The time series of the returns emphasize major upheavals in the markets -- Black Monday, Tech Bubble, Financial Crisis and Covid Pandemic -- which are reflected in the tail ends of the distributions. De-trending the overall gain, we concentrate on comparing distributions of…
▽ More
We study decades-long historic distributions of accumulated S\&P500 returns, from daily returns to those over several weeks. The time series of the returns emphasize major upheavals in the markets -- Black Monday, Tech Bubble, Financial Crisis and Covid Pandemic -- which are reflected in the tail ends of the distributions. De-trending the overall gain, we concentrate on comparing distributions of gains and losses. Specifically, we compare the tails of the distributions, which are believed to exhibit power-law behavior and possibly contain outliers. Towards this end we find confidence intervals of the linear fits of the tails of the complementary cumulative distribution functions on a log-log scale, as well as conduct a statistical U-test in order to detect outliers. We also study probability density functions of the full distributions of the returns with the emphasis on their asymmetry. The key empirical observations are that the mean of de-trended distributions increases near-linearly with the number of days of accumulation while the overall skew is negative -- consistent with the heavier tails of losses -- and depends little on the number of days of accumulation. At the same time the variance of the distributions exhibits near-perfect linear dependence on the number of days of accumulation, that is it remains constant if scaled to the latter. Finally, we discuss the theoretical framework for understanding accumulated returns. Our main conclusion is that the current state of theory, which predicts symmetric or near-symmetric distributions of returns cannot explain the aggregate of empirical results.
△ Less
Submitted 31 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Are there Dragon Kings in the Stock Market?
Authors:
Jiong Liu,
M. Dashti Moghaddam,
R. A. Serota
Abstract:
We undertake a systematic study of historic market volatility spanning roughly five preceding decades. We focus specifically on the time series of realized volatility (RV) of the S&P500 index and its distribution function. As expected, the largest values of RV coincide with the largest economic upheavals of the period: Savings and Loan Crisis, Tech Bubble, Financial Crisis and Covid Pandemic. We a…
▽ More
We undertake a systematic study of historic market volatility spanning roughly five preceding decades. We focus specifically on the time series of realized volatility (RV) of the S&P500 index and its distribution function. As expected, the largest values of RV coincide with the largest economic upheavals of the period: Savings and Loan Crisis, Tech Bubble, Financial Crisis and Covid Pandemic. We address the question of whether these values belong to one of the three categories: Black Swans (BS), that is they lie on scale-free, power-law tails of the distribution; Dragon Kings (DK), defined as statistically significant upward deviations from BS; or Negative Dragons Kings (nDK), defined as statistically significant downward deviations from BS. In analyzing the tails of the distribution with RV > 40, we observe the appearance of "potential" DK which eventually terminate in an abrupt plunge to nDK. This phenomenon becomes more pronounced with the increase of the number of days over which the average RV is calculated -- here from daily, n=1, to "monthly," n=21. We fit the entire distribution with a modified Generalized Beta (mGB) distribution function, which terminates at a finite value of the variable but exhibits a long power-law stretch prior to that, as well as Generalized Beta Prime (GB2) distribution function, which has a power-law tail. We also fit the tails directly with a straight line on a log-log scale. In order to ascertain BS, DK or nDK behavior, all fits include their confidence intervals and p-values are evaluated for the data points to check if they can come from the respective distributions.
△ Less
Submitted 7 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Rethinking Generalized Beta Family of Distributions
Authors:
Jiong Liu,
R. A. Serota
Abstract:
We approach the Generalized Beta (GB) family of distributions using a mean-reverting stochastic differential equation (SDE) for a power of the variable, whose steady-state (stationary) probability density function (PDF) is a modified GB (mGB) distribution. The SDE approach allows for a lucid explanation of Generalized Beta Prime (GB2) and Generalized Beta (GB1) limits of GB distribution and, furth…
▽ More
We approach the Generalized Beta (GB) family of distributions using a mean-reverting stochastic differential equation (SDE) for a power of the variable, whose steady-state (stationary) probability density function (PDF) is a modified GB (mGB) distribution. The SDE approach allows for a lucid explanation of Generalized Beta Prime (GB2) and Generalized Beta (GB1) limits of GB distribution and, further down, of Generalized Inverse Gamma (GIGa) and Generalized Gamma (GGa) limits, as well as describe the transition between the latter two. We provide an alternative form to the "traditional" GB PDF to underscore that a great deal of usefulness of GB distribution lies in its allowing a long-range power-law behavior to be ultimately terminated at a finite value. We derive the cumulative distribution function (CDF) of the "traditional" GB, which belongs to the family generated by the regularized beta function and is crucial for analysis of the tails of the distribution. We analyze fifty years of historical data on realized market volatility, specifically for S\&P500, as a case study of the use of GB/mGB distributions and show that its behavior is consistent with that of negative Dragon Kings.
△ Less
Submitted 5 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Distributions of Historic Market Data -- Relaxation and Correlations
Authors:
M. Dashti Moghaddam,
Zhiyuan Liu,
R. A. Serota
Abstract:
We investigate relaxation and correlations in a class of mean-reverting models for stochastic variances. We derive closed-form expressions for the correlation functions and leverage for a general form of the stochastic term. We also discuss correlation functions and leverage for three specific models -- multiplicative, Heston (Cox-Ingersoll-Ross) and combined multiplicative-Heston -- whose steady-…
▽ More
We investigate relaxation and correlations in a class of mean-reverting models for stochastic variances. We derive closed-form expressions for the correlation functions and leverage for a general form of the stochastic term. We also discuss correlation functions and leverage for three specific models -- multiplicative, Heston (Cox-Ingersoll-Ross) and combined multiplicative-Heston -- whose steady-state probability density functions are Gamma, Inverse Gamma and Beta Prime respectively, the latter two exhibiting "fat" tails. For the Heston model, we apply the eigenvalue analysis of the Fokker-Planck equation to derive the correlation function -- in agreement with the general analysis -- and to identify a series of time scales, which are observable in relaxation of cumulants on approach to the steady state. We test our findings on a very large set of historic financial markets data.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2020; v1 submitted 11 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Generalized Beta Prime Distribution: Stochastic Model of Economic Exchange and Properties of Inequality Indices
Authors:
M. Dashti Moghaddam,
Jeffrey Mills,
R. A. Serota
Abstract:
We argue that a stochastic model of economic exchange, whose steady-state distribution is a Generalized Beta Prime (also known as GB2), and some unique properties of the latter, are the reason for GB2's success in describing wealth/income distributions. We use housing sale prices as a proxy to wealth/income distribution to numerically illustrate this point. We also explore parametric limits of the…
▽ More
We argue that a stochastic model of economic exchange, whose steady-state distribution is a Generalized Beta Prime (also known as GB2), and some unique properties of the latter, are the reason for GB2's success in describing wealth/income distributions. We use housing sale prices as a proxy to wealth/income distribution to numerically illustrate this point. We also explore parametric limits of the distribution to do so analytically. We discuss parametric properties of the inequality indices -- Gini, Hoover, Theil T and Theil L -- vis-a-vis those of GB2 and introduce a new inequality index, which serves a similar purpose. We argue that Hoover and Theil L are more appropriate measures for distributions with power-law dependencies, especially fat tails, such as GB2.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Implied and Realized Volatility: A Study of Distributions and the Distribution of Difference
Authors:
M. Dashti Moghaddam,
Jiong Liu,
R. A. Serota
Abstract:
We study distributions of realized variance (squared realized volatility) and squared implied volatility, as represented by VIX and VXO indices. We find that Generalized Beta distribution provide the best fits. These fits are much more accurate for realized variance than for squared VIX and VXO -- possibly another indicator that the latter have deficiencies in predicting the former. We also show t…
▽ More
We study distributions of realized variance (squared realized volatility) and squared implied volatility, as represented by VIX and VXO indices. We find that Generalized Beta distribution provide the best fits. These fits are much more accurate for realized variance than for squared VIX and VXO -- possibly another indicator that the latter have deficiencies in predicting the former. We also show that there are noticeable differences between the distributions of the 1970-2017 realized variance and its 1990-2017 portion, for which VIX and VXO became available. This may be indicative of a feedback effect that implied volatility has on realized volatility. We also discuss the distribution of the difference between squared implied volatility and realized variance and show that, at the basic level, it is consistent with Pearson's correlations obtained from linear regression.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Implied and Realized Volatility: A Study of the Ratio Distribution
Authors:
M. Dashti Moghaddam,
R. A. Serota
Abstract:
We analyze correlations between squared volatility indices, VIX and VXO, and realized variances -- the known one, for the current month, and the predicted one, for the following month. We show that the ratio of the two is best fitted by a Beta Prime distribution, whose shape parameters depend strongly on which of the two months is used.
We analyze correlations between squared volatility indices, VIX and VXO, and realized variances -- the known one, for the current month, and the predicted one, for the following month. We show that the ratio of the two is best fitted by a Beta Prime distribution, whose shape parameters depend strongly on which of the two months is used.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Combined Mutiplicative-Heston Model for Stochastic Volatility
Authors:
M. Dashti Moghaddam,
R. A. Serota
Abstract:
We consider a model of stochastic volatility which combines features of the multiplicative model for large volatilities and of the Heston model for small volatilities. The steady-state distribution in this model is a Beta Prime and is characterized by the power-law behavior at both large and small volatilities. We discuss the reasoning behind using this model as well as consequences for our recent…
▽ More
We consider a model of stochastic volatility which combines features of the multiplicative model for large volatilities and of the Heston model for small volatilities. The steady-state distribution in this model is a Beta Prime and is characterized by the power-law behavior at both large and small volatilities. We discuss the reasoning behind using this model as well as consequences for our recent analyses of distributions of stock returns and realized volatility.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Distributions of Historic Market Data -- Implied and Realized Volatility
Authors:
M. Dashti Moghaddam,
Zhiyuan Liu,
R. A. Serota
Abstract:
We undertake a systematic comparison between implied volatility, as represented by VIX (new methodology) and VXO (old methodology), and realized volatility. We compare visually and statistically distributions of realized and implied variance (volatility squared) and study the distribution of their ratio. We find that the ratio is best fitted by heavy-tailed -- lognormal and fat-tailed (power-law)…
▽ More
We undertake a systematic comparison between implied volatility, as represented by VIX (new methodology) and VXO (old methodology), and realized volatility. We compare visually and statistically distributions of realized and implied variance (volatility squared) and study the distribution of their ratio. We find that the ratio is best fitted by heavy-tailed -- lognormal and fat-tailed (power-law) -- distributions, depending on whether preceding or concurrent month of realized variance is used. We do not find substantial difference in accuracy between VIX and VXO. Additionally, we study the variance of theoretical realized variance for Heston and multiplicative models of stochastic volatility and compare those with realized variance obtained from historic market data.
△ Less
Submitted 14 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Distributions of Historic Market Data - Stock Returns
Authors:
Zhiyuan Liu,
M. Dashti Moghaddam,
R. A. Serota
Abstract:
We show that the moments of the distribution of historic stock returns are in excellent agreement with the Heston model and not with the multiplicative model, which predicts power-law tails of volatility and stock returns. We also show that the mean realized variance of returns is a linear function of the number of days over which the returns are calculated. The slope is determined by the mean val…
▽ More
We show that the moments of the distribution of historic stock returns are in excellent agreement with the Heston model and not with the multiplicative model, which predicts power-law tails of volatility and stock returns. We also show that the mean realized variance of returns is a linear function of the number of days over which the returns are calculated. The slope is determined by the mean value of the variance (squared volatility) in the mean-reverting stochastic volatility models, such as Heston and multiplicative, independent of stochasticity. The distribution function of stock returns, which rescales with the increase of the number of days of return, is obtained from the steady-state variance distribution function using the product distribution with the normal distribution.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2017; v1 submitted 29 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
On absence of steady state in the Bouchaud-Mézard network model
Authors:
Zhiyuan Liu,
R. A. Serota
Abstract:
In the limit of infinite number of nodes (agents), the Itô-reduced Bouchaud-Mézard network model of economic exchange has a time-independent mean and a steady-state inverse gamma distribution. We show that for a finite number of nodes the mean is actually distributed as a time-dependent lognormal and inverse gamma is quasi-stationary, with the time-dependent scale parameter.
In the limit of infinite number of nodes (agents), the Itô-reduced Bouchaud-Mézard network model of economic exchange has a time-independent mean and a steady-state inverse gamma distribution. We show that for a finite number of nodes the mean is actually distributed as a time-dependent lognormal and inverse gamma is quasi-stationary, with the time-dependent scale parameter.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
A Model for Stock Returns and Volatility
Authors:
Tao Ma,
R. A. Serota
Abstract:
We prove that Student's t-distribution provides one of the better fits to returns of S&P component stocks and the generalized inverse gamma distribution best fits VIX and VXO volatility data. We further argue that a more accurate measure of the volatility may be possible based on the fact that stock returns can be understood as the product distribution of the volatility and normal distributions. W…
▽ More
We prove that Student's t-distribution provides one of the better fits to returns of S&P component stocks and the generalized inverse gamma distribution best fits VIX and VXO volatility data. We further argue that a more accurate measure of the volatility may be possible based on the fact that stock returns can be understood as the product distribution of the volatility and normal distributions. We find Brown noise in VIX and VXO time series and explain the mean and the variance of the relaxation times on approach to the steady-state distribution.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
Distribution Of Wealth In A Network Model Of The Economy
Authors:
Tao Ma,
John G. Holden,
R. A. Serota
Abstract:
We show, analytically and numerically, that wealth distribution in the Bouchaud-Mézard network model of the economy is described by a three-parameter generalized inverse gamma distribution. In the mean-field limit of a network with any two agents linked, it reduces to the inverse gamma distribution.
We show, analytically and numerically, that wealth distribution in the Bouchaud-Mézard network model of the economy is described by a three-parameter generalized inverse gamma distribution. In the mean-field limit of a network with any two agents linked, it reduces to the inverse gamma distribution.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
