-
The Carbon Premium: Correlation or Causation? Evidence from S&P 500 Companies
Authors:
Namasi G. Sankar,
Suryadeepto Nag,
Siddhartha P. Chakrabarty,
Sankarshan Basu
Abstract:
In the context of whether investors are aware of carbon-related risks, it is often hypothesized that there may be a carbon premium in the value of stocks of firms, conferring an abnormal excess value to firms' shares as a form of compensation to investors for their transition risk exposure through the ownership of carbon instensive stocks. However, there is little consensus in the literature regar…
▽ More
In the context of whether investors are aware of carbon-related risks, it is often hypothesized that there may be a carbon premium in the value of stocks of firms, conferring an abnormal excess value to firms' shares as a form of compensation to investors for their transition risk exposure through the ownership of carbon instensive stocks. However, there is little consensus in the literature regarding the existence of such a premium. Moreover few studies have examined whether the correlation that is often observed is actually causal. The pertinent question is whether more polluting firms give higher returns or do firms with high returns have less incentive to decarbonize? In this study, we investigate whether firms' emissions is causally linked to the presence of a carbon premium in a panel of 141 firms listed in the S\&P500 index using fixed-effects analysis, with propensity score weighting to control for selection bias in which firms increase their emissions. We find that there is a statistically significant positive carbon premium associated with Scope 1 emissions, while there is no significant premium associated with Scope 2 emissions, implying that risks associated with direct emissions by the firm are priced, while bought emissions are not.
△ Less
Submitted 29 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Learning Financial Networks with High-frequency Trade Data
Authors:
Kara Karpman,
Sumanta Basu,
David Easley
Abstract:
Financial networks are typically estimated by applying standard time series analyses to price-based economic variables collected at low-frequency (e.g., daily or monthly stock returns or realized volatility). These networks are used for risk monitoring and for studying information flows in financial markets. High-frequency intraday trade data sets may provide additional insights into network linka…
▽ More
Financial networks are typically estimated by applying standard time series analyses to price-based economic variables collected at low-frequency (e.g., daily or monthly stock returns or realized volatility). These networks are used for risk monitoring and for studying information flows in financial markets. High-frequency intraday trade data sets may provide additional insights into network linkages by leveraging high-resolution information. However, such data sets pose significant modeling challenges due to their asynchronous nature, nonlinear dynamics, and nonstationarity. To tackle these challenges, we estimate financial networks using random forests. The edges in our network are determined by using microstructure measures of one firm to forecast the sign of the change in a market measure (either realized volatility or returns kurtosis) of another firm. We first investigate the evolution of network connectivity in the period leading up to the U.S. financial crisis of 2007-09. We find that the networks have the highest density in 2007, with high degree connectivity associated with Lehman Brothers in 2006. A second analysis into the nature of linkages among firms suggests that larger firms tend to offer better predictive power than smaller firms, a finding qualitatively consistent with prior works in the market microstructure literature.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Exploring Financial Networks Using Quantile Regression and Granger Causality
Authors:
Kara Karpman,
Samriddha Lahiry,
Diganta Mukherjee,
Sumanta Basu
Abstract:
In the post-crisis era, financial regulators and policymakers are increasingly interested in data-driven tools to measure systemic risk and to identify systemically important firms. Granger Causality (GC) based techniques to build networks among financial firms using time series of their stock returns have received significant attention in recent years. Existing GC network methods model conditiona…
▽ More
In the post-crisis era, financial regulators and policymakers are increasingly interested in data-driven tools to measure systemic risk and to identify systemically important firms. Granger Causality (GC) based techniques to build networks among financial firms using time series of their stock returns have received significant attention in recent years. Existing GC network methods model conditional means, and do not distinguish between connectivity in lower and upper tails of the return distribution - an aspect crucial for systemic risk analysis. We propose statistical methods that measure connectivity in the financial sector using system-wide tail-based analysis and is able to distinguish between connectivity in lower and upper tails of the return distribution. This is achieved using bivariate and multivariate GC analysis based on regular and Lasso penalized quantile regressions, an approach we call quantile Granger causality (QGC). By considering centrality measures of these financial networks, we can assess the build-up of systemic risk and identify risk propagation channels. We provide an asymptotic theory of QGC estimators under a quantile vector autoregressive model, and show its benefit over regular GC analysis on simulated data. We apply our method to the monthly stock returns of large U.S. firms and demonstrate that lower tail based networks can detect systemically risky periods in historical data with higher accuracy than mean-based networks. In a similar analysis of large Indian banks, we find that upper and lower tail networks convey different information and have the potential to distinguish between periods of high connectivity that are governed by positive vs negative news in the market.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2022; v1 submitted 21 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Modeling Multivariate Positive-Valued Time Series Using R-INLA
Authors:
Chiranjit Dutta,
Nalini Ravishanker,
Sumanta Basu
Abstract:
In this paper we describe fast Bayesian statistical analysis of vector positive-valued time series, with application to interesting financial data streams. We discuss a flexible level correlated model (LCM) framework for building hierarchical models for vector positive-valued time series. The LCM allows us to combine marginal gamma distributions for the positive-valued component responses, while a…
▽ More
In this paper we describe fast Bayesian statistical analysis of vector positive-valued time series, with application to interesting financial data streams. We discuss a flexible level correlated model (LCM) framework for building hierarchical models for vector positive-valued time series. The LCM allows us to combine marginal gamma distributions for the positive-valued component responses, while accounting for association among the components at a latent level. We use integrated nested Laplace approximation (INLA) for fast approximate Bayesian modeling via the R-INLA package, building custom functions to handle this setup. We use the proposed method to model interdependencies between realized volatility measures from several stock indexes.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2022; v1 submitted 10 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Single Event Transition Risk: A Measure for Long Term Carbon Exposure
Authors:
Suryadeepto Nag,
Siddhartha P. Chakrabarty,
Sankarshan Basu
Abstract:
Although there is a growing consensus that a low-carbon transition will be necessary to mitigate the accelerated climate change, the magnitude of transition-risk for investors is difficult to measure exactly. Investors are therefore constrained by the unavailability of suitable measures to quantify the magnitude of the risk and are forced to use the likes of absolute emissions data or ESG scores i…
▽ More
Although there is a growing consensus that a low-carbon transition will be necessary to mitigate the accelerated climate change, the magnitude of transition-risk for investors is difficult to measure exactly. Investors are therefore constrained by the unavailability of suitable measures to quantify the magnitude of the risk and are forced to use the likes of absolute emissions data or ESG scores in order to manage their portfolios. In this article, we define the Single Event Transition Risk (SETR) and illustrate how it can be used to approximate the magnitude of the total exposure of the price of a share to low-carbon transition. We also discuss potential applications of the single event framework and the SETR as a risk measure and discuss future direction on how this can be extended to a system with multiple transition events.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2022; v1 submitted 14 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Modeling the commodity prices of base metals in Indian commodity market using a Higher Order Markovian Approach
Authors:
Suryadeepto Nag,
Sankarshan Basu,
Siddhartha P. Chakrabarty
Abstract:
A Higher Order Markovian (HOM) model to capture the dynamics of commodity prices is proposed as an alternative to a Markovian model. In particular, the order of the former model, is taken to be the delay, in the response of the industry, to the market information. This is then empirically analyzed for the prices of Copper Mini and four other bases metals, namely Aluminum, Lead, Nickel and Zinc, in…
▽ More
A Higher Order Markovian (HOM) model to capture the dynamics of commodity prices is proposed as an alternative to a Markovian model. In particular, the order of the former model, is taken to be the delay, in the response of the industry, to the market information. This is then empirically analyzed for the prices of Copper Mini and four other bases metals, namely Aluminum, Lead, Nickel and Zinc, in the Indian commodities market. In case of Copper Mini, the usage of the HOM approach consistently offer improvement, over the Markovian approach, in terms of the errors in forecasting. Similar trends were observed for the other base metals considered, with the exception of Aluminum, which can be attributed the volatility in the Asian market during the COVID-19 outbreak.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
High-Dimensional Estimation, Basis Assets, and the Adaptive Multi-Factor Model
Authors:
Liao Zhu,
Sumanta Basu,
Robert A. Jarrow,
Martin T. Wells
Abstract:
The paper proposes a new algorithm for the high-dimensional financial data -- the Groupwise Interpretable Basis Selection (GIBS) algorithm, to estimate a new Adaptive Multi-Factor (AMF) asset pricing model, implied by the recently developed Generalized Arbitrage Pricing Theory, which relaxes the convention that the number of risk-factors is small. We first obtain an adaptive collection of basis as…
▽ More
The paper proposes a new algorithm for the high-dimensional financial data -- the Groupwise Interpretable Basis Selection (GIBS) algorithm, to estimate a new Adaptive Multi-Factor (AMF) asset pricing model, implied by the recently developed Generalized Arbitrage Pricing Theory, which relaxes the convention that the number of risk-factors is small. We first obtain an adaptive collection of basis assets and then simultaneously test which basis assets correspond to which securities, using high-dimensional methods. The AMF model, along with the GIBS algorithm, is shown to have a significantly better fitting and prediction power than the Fama-French 5-factor model.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2021; v1 submitted 23 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Forecasting non-stationary financial time series through genetic algorithm
Authors:
M. B. Porecha,
P. K. Panigrahi,
J. C. Parikh,
C. M. Kishtawal,
Sujit Basu
Abstract:
We utilize a recently developed genetic algorithm, in conjunction with discrete wavelets, for carrying out successful forecasts of the trend in financial time series, that includes the NASDAQ composite index. Discrete wavelets isolate the local, small scale variations in these non-stationary time series, after which the genetic algorithm's predictions are found to be quite accurate. The power la…
▽ More
We utilize a recently developed genetic algorithm, in conjunction with discrete wavelets, for carrying out successful forecasts of the trend in financial time series, that includes the NASDAQ composite index. Discrete wavelets isolate the local, small scale variations in these non-stationary time series, after which the genetic algorithm's predictions are found to be quite accurate. The power law behavior in Fourier domain reveals an underlying self-affine dynamical behavior, well captured by the algorithm, in the form of an analytic equation. Remarkably, the same equation captures the trend of the Bombay stock exchange composite index quite well.
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2005;
originally announced July 2005.