-
Insider trading with penalties, entropy and quadratic BSDEs
Authors:
Umut Çetin
Abstract:
Kyle model in continuous time where the insider may be subject to legal penalties is considered. In equilibrium the insider internalises this legal risk by trading less aggressively. The equilibrium is characterised via the solution of a backward stochastic differential equation (BSDE) whose terminal condition is determined as the fixed point of a non-linear operator in equilibrium. The insider's…
▽ More
Kyle model in continuous time where the insider may be subject to legal penalties is considered. In equilibrium the insider internalises this legal risk by trading less aggressively. The equilibrium is characterised via the solution of a backward stochastic differential equation (BSDE) whose terminal condition is determined as the fixed point of a non-linear operator in equilibrium. The insider's expected penalties in equilibrium is non-monotone in the fee structure and is given by the relative entropy of the law of a particular h-transformation of Brownian motion.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Is Kyle's equilibrium model stable?
Authors:
Umut Cetin,
Kasper Larsen
Abstract:
In the dynamic discrete-time trading setting of Kyle (1985), we prove that Kyle's equilibrium model is stable when there are one or two trading times. For three or more trading times, we prove that Kyle's equilibrium is not stable. These theoretical results are proven to hold irrespectively of all Kyle's input parameters.
In the dynamic discrete-time trading setting of Kyle (1985), we prove that Kyle's equilibrium model is stable when there are one or two trading times. For three or more trading times, we prove that Kyle's equilibrium is not stable. These theoretical results are proven to hold irrespectively of all Kyle's input parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2023; v1 submitted 18 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Order routing and market quality: Who benefits from internalisation?
Authors:
Umut Çetin,
Alaina Danilova
Abstract:
We analyse two models of liquidity provision to determine the retail traders' preference for marketable order routing. Order internalization is captured by a model of market makers competing for the retail order flow in a Bertrand fashion. On the other hand, the price-taking competitive liquidity providers characterize the open exchange model. We show that, when liquidity providers are risk averse…
▽ More
We analyse two models of liquidity provision to determine the retail traders' preference for marketable order routing. Order internalization is captured by a model of market makers competing for the retail order flow in a Bertrand fashion. On the other hand, the price-taking competitive liquidity providers characterize the open exchange model. We show that, when liquidity providers are risk averse, routing of the marketable orders to the wholesalers is preferred by all retail traders: informed, uninformed and noisy. The unwillingness of liquidity providers to bear risk causes the strategic trader (informed or not) to absorb large shocks in their inventories. This results in mean reverting inventories, price reversal, and lower market depth. The equilibria in both models coincide with Kyle (1985) when liquidity providers are risk neutral. We also identify a universal parameter that allows comparison of market liquidity, profit and value of information across different markets.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Uniqueness in Cauchy problems for diffusive real-valued strict local martingales
Authors:
Umut Cetin,
Kasper Larsen
Abstract:
For a real-valued one dimensional diffusive strict local martingale,, we provide a set of smooth functions in which the Cauchy problem has a unique classical solution under a local Hölder condition. Under the weaker Engelbert-Schmidt conditions, we provide a set in which the Cauchy problem has a unique weak solution. We exemplify our results using quadratic normal volatility models and the two dim…
▽ More
For a real-valued one dimensional diffusive strict local martingale,, we provide a set of smooth functions in which the Cauchy problem has a unique classical solution under a local Hölder condition. Under the weaker Engelbert-Schmidt conditions, we provide a set in which the Cauchy problem has a unique weak solution. We exemplify our results using quadratic normal volatility models and the two dimensional Bessel process.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2022; v1 submitted 29 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Informed trading, limit order book and implementation shortfall: equilibrium and asymptotics
Authors:
Umut Çetin,
Henri Waelbroeck
Abstract:
We propose a static equilibrium model for limit order book where profit-maximizing investors receive an information signal regarding the liquidation value of the asset and execute via a competitive dealer with random initial inventory, who trades against a competitive limit order book populated by liquidity suppliers. We show that an equilibrium exists for bounded signal distributions, obtain clos…
▽ More
We propose a static equilibrium model for limit order book where profit-maximizing investors receive an information signal regarding the liquidation value of the asset and execute via a competitive dealer with random initial inventory, who trades against a competitive limit order book populated by liquidity suppliers. We show that an equilibrium exists for bounded signal distributions, obtain closed form solutions for Bernoulli-type signals and propose a straightforward iterative algorithm to compute the equilibrium order book for the general case. We obtain the exact analytic asymptotics for the market impact of large trades and show that the functional form depends on the tail distribution of the private signal of the insiders. In particular, the impact follows a power law if the signal has fat tails while the law is logarithmic in case of lighter tails. Moreover, the tail distribution of the trade volume in equilibrium obeys a power law in our model. We find that the liquidity suppliers charge a minimum bid-ask spread that is independent of the amount of `noise' trading but increasing in the degree of informational advantage of insiders in equilibrium. The model also predicts that the order book flattens as the amount of noise trading increases converging to a model with proportional transactions costs.. Competition among the insiders leads to aggressive trading causing the aggregate profit to vanish in the limiting case $N\to\infty$. The numerical results also show that the spread increases with the number of insiders keeping the other parameters fixed. Finally, an equilibrium may not exist if the liquidation value is unbounded. We conjecture that existence of equilibrium requires a sufficient amount of competition among insiders if the signal distribution exhibit fat tails.
△ Less
Submitted 9 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
On pricing rules and optimal strategies in general Kyle-Back models
Authors:
Umut Çetin,
Albina Danilova
Abstract:
The folk result in Kyle-Back models states that the value function of the insider remains unchanged when her admissible strategies are restricted to absolutely continuous ones. In this paper we show that, for a large class of pricing rules used in current literature, the value function of the insider can be finite when her strategies are restricted to be absolutely continuous and infinite when thi…
▽ More
The folk result in Kyle-Back models states that the value function of the insider remains unchanged when her admissible strategies are restricted to absolutely continuous ones. In this paper we show that, for a large class of pricing rules used in current literature, the value function of the insider can be finite when her strategies are restricted to be absolutely continuous and infinite when this restriction is not imposed. This implies that the folk result doesn't hold for those pricing rules and that they are not consistent with equilibrium. We derive the necessary conditions for a pricing rule to be consistent with equilibrium and prove that, when a pricing rule satisfies these necessary conditions, the insider's optimal strategy is absolutely continuous, thus obtaining the classical result in a more general setting.
This, furthermore, allows us to justify the standard assumption of absolute continuity of insider's strategies since one can construct a pricing rule satisfying the necessary conditions derived in the paper that yield the same price process as the pricing rules employed in the modern literature when insider's strategies are absolutely continuous.
△ Less
Submitted 20 August, 2021; v1 submitted 18 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Mathematics of Market Microstructure under Asymmetric Information
Authors:
Umut Çetın
Abstract:
These are the lecture notes for the summer course given for 2018 Mathematical Finance Summer School at Shandong Unversity. It contains a brief introduction to the Kyle model and the related topics in filtering, enlargement of filtrations and Markov bridges.
These are the lecture notes for the summer course given for 2018 Mathematical Finance Summer School at Shandong Unversity. It contains a brief introduction to the Kyle model and the related topics in filtering, enlargement of filtrations and Markov bridges.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Financial equilibrium with asymmetric information and random horizon
Authors:
Umut Çetin
Abstract:
We study in detail and explicitly solve the version of Kyle's model introduced in a specific case in \cite{BB}, where the trading horizon is given by an exponentially distributed random time. The first part of the paper is devoted to the analysis of time-homogeneous equilibria using tools from the theory of one-dimensional diffusions. It turns out that such an equilibrium is only possible if the f…
▽ More
We study in detail and explicitly solve the version of Kyle's model introduced in a specific case in \cite{BB}, where the trading horizon is given by an exponentially distributed random time. The first part of the paper is devoted to the analysis of time-homogeneous equilibria using tools from the theory of one-dimensional diffusions. It turns out that such an equilibrium is only possible if the final payoff is Bernoulli distributed as in \cite{BB}. We show in the second part that the signal of the market makers use in the general case is a time-changed version of the one that they would have used had the final payoff had a Bernoulli distribution. In both cases we characterise explicitly the equilibrium price process and the optimal strategy of the informed trader. Contrary to the original Kyle model it is found that the reciprocal of market's depth, i.e. Kyle's lambda, is a uniformly integrable supermartingale. While Kyle's lambda is a potential, i.e. converges to $0$, for the Bernoulli distributed final payoff, its limit in general is different than $0$.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2017; v1 submitted 29 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
Markovian Nash equilibrium in financial markets with asymmetric information and related forward-backward systems
Authors:
Umut Çetin,
Albina Danilova
Abstract:
This paper develops a new methodology for studying continuous-time Nash equilibrium in a financial market with asymmetrically informed agents. This approach allows us to lift the restriction of risk neutrality imposed on market makers by the current literature. It turns out that, when the market makers are risk averse, the optimal strategies of the agents are solutions of a forward-backward system…
▽ More
This paper develops a new methodology for studying continuous-time Nash equilibrium in a financial market with asymmetrically informed agents. This approach allows us to lift the restriction of risk neutrality imposed on market makers by the current literature. It turns out that, when the market makers are risk averse, the optimal strategies of the agents are solutions of a forward-backward system of partial and stochastic differential equations. In particular, the price set by the market makers solves a nonstandard "quadratic" backward stochastic differential equation. The main result of the paper is the existence of a Markovian solution to this forward-backward system on an arbitrary time interval, which is obtained via a fixed-point argument on the space of absolutely continuous distribution functions. Moreover, the equilibrium obtained in this paper is able to explain several stylized facts which are not captured by the current asymmetric information models.
△ Less
Submitted 2 September, 2016; v1 submitted 9 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Point process bridges and weak convergence of insider trading models
Authors:
Umut Çetin,
Hao Xing
Abstract:
We construct explicitly a bridge process whose distribution, in its own filtration, is the same as the difference of two independent Poisson processes with the same intensity and its time 1 value satisfies a specific constraint. This construction allows us to show the existence of Glosten-Milgrom equilibrium and its associated optimal trading strategy for the insider. In the equilibrium the inside…
▽ More
We construct explicitly a bridge process whose distribution, in its own filtration, is the same as the difference of two independent Poisson processes with the same intensity and its time 1 value satisfies a specific constraint. This construction allows us to show the existence of Glosten-Milgrom equilibrium and its associated optimal trading strategy for the insider. In the equilibrium the insider employs a mixed strategy to randomly submit two types of orders: one type trades in the same direction as noise trades while the other cancels some of the noise trades by submitting opposite orders when noise trades arrive. The construction also allows us to prove that Glosten-Milgrom equilibria converge weakly to Kyle-Back equilibrium, without the additional assumptions imposed in \textit{K. Back and S. Baruch, Econometrica, 72 (2004), pp. 433-465}, when the common intensity of the Poisson processes tends to infinity.
△ Less
Submitted 28 January, 2013; v1 submitted 19 May, 2012;
originally announced May 2012.
-
On absolutely continuous compensators and nonlinear filtering equations in default risk models
Authors:
Umut Çetin
Abstract:
We discuss the pricing of defaultable assets in an incomplete information model where the default time is given by a first hitting time of an unobservable process. We show that in a fairly general Markov setting, the indicator function of the default has an absolutely continuous compensator. Given this compensator we then discuss the optional projection of a class of semimartingales onto the filtr…
▽ More
We discuss the pricing of defaultable assets in an incomplete information model where the default time is given by a first hitting time of an unobservable process. We show that in a fairly general Markov setting, the indicator function of the default has an absolutely continuous compensator. Given this compensator we then discuss the optional projection of a class of semimartingales onto the filtration generated by the observation process and the default indicator process. Available formulas for the pricing of defaultable assets are analyzed in this setting and some alternative formulas are suggested.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2012;
originally announced May 2012.
-
Dynamic Markov bridges motivated by models of insider trading
Authors:
Luciano Campi,
Umut Çetin,
Albina Danilova
Abstract:
Given a Markovian Brownian martingale $Z$, we build a process $X$ which is a martingale in its own filtration and satisfies $X_1 = Z_1$. We call $X$ a dynamic bridge, because its terminal value $Z_1$ is not known in advance. We compute explicitly its semimartingale decomposition under both its own filtration $\cF^X$ and the filtration $\cF^{X,Z}$ jointly generated by $X$ and $Z$. Our construction…
▽ More
Given a Markovian Brownian martingale $Z$, we build a process $X$ which is a martingale in its own filtration and satisfies $X_1 = Z_1$. We call $X$ a dynamic bridge, because its terminal value $Z_1$ is not known in advance. We compute explicitly its semimartingale decomposition under both its own filtration $\cF^X$ and the filtration $\cF^{X,Z}$ jointly generated by $X$ and $Z$. Our construction is heavily based on parabolic PDE's and filtering techniques. As an application, we explicitly solve an equilibrium model with insider trading, that can be viewed as a non-Gaussian generalization of Back and Pedersen's \cite{BP}, where insider's additional information evolves over time.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
-
Modeling Credit Risk with Partial Information
Authors:
Umut Cetin,
Robert Jarrow,
Philip Protter,
Yildiray Yildirim
Abstract:
This paper provides an alternative approach to Duffie and Lando [Econometrica 69 (2001) 633-664] for obtaining a reduced form credit risk model from a structural model. Duffie and Lando obtain a reduced form model by constructing an economy where the market sees the manager's information set plus noise.
The noise makes default a surprise to the market. In contrast, we obtain a reduced form mod…
▽ More
This paper provides an alternative approach to Duffie and Lando [Econometrica 69 (2001) 633-664] for obtaining a reduced form credit risk model from a structural model. Duffie and Lando obtain a reduced form model by constructing an economy where the market sees the manager's information set plus noise.
The noise makes default a surprise to the market. In contrast, we obtain a reduced form model by constructing an economy where the market sees a reduction of the manager's information set. The reduced information makes default a surprise to the market. We provide an explicit formula for the default intensity based on an Azema martingale, and we use excursion theory of Brownian motions to price risky debt.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2004;
originally announced July 2004.
