-
Modelling the spread of two successive SIR epidemics on a configuration model network
Authors:
Frank Ball,
Abid Ali Lashari,
David Sirl,
Pieter Trapman
Abstract:
We present a stochastic model for two successive SIR (Susceptible, Infectious, Recovered) epidemics in the same network structured population. Individuals infected during the first epidemic might have (partial) immunity for the second one. The first epidemic is analysed through a bond percolation model, while the second epidemic is approximated by a three-type branching process in which the types…
▽ More
We present a stochastic model for two successive SIR (Susceptible, Infectious, Recovered) epidemics in the same network structured population. Individuals infected during the first epidemic might have (partial) immunity for the second one. The first epidemic is analysed through a bond percolation model, while the second epidemic is approximated by a three-type branching process in which the types of individuals depend on their position in the percolation clusters used for the first epidemic. This branching process approximation enables us to calculate, in the large population limit and conditional upon a large outbreak in the first epidemic, a threshold parameter and the probability of a large outbreak for the second epidemic. A second branching process approximation enables us to calculate the fraction of the population that are infected by such a second large outbreak.
We illustrate our results through some specific cases which have appeared previously in the literature and show that our asymptotic results give good approximations for finite populations.
△ Less
Submitted 28 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Possible counter-intuitive impact of local vaccine mandates for vaccine-preventable infectious diseases
Authors:
Maddalena Donà,
Pieter Trapman
Abstract:
We model the impact of local vaccine mandates on the spread of vaccine-preventable infectious diseases, which in the absence of vaccines will mainly affect children. Examples of such diseases are measles, rubella, mumps and pertussis. To model the spread of the pathogen, we use a stochastic SIR (Susceptible, Infectious, Recovered) model with two levels of mixing in a closed population, often refer…
▽ More
We model the impact of local vaccine mandates on the spread of vaccine-preventable infectious diseases, which in the absence of vaccines will mainly affect children. Examples of such diseases are measles, rubella, mumps and pertussis. To model the spread of the pathogen, we use a stochastic SIR (Susceptible, Infectious, Recovered) model with two levels of mixing in a closed population, often referred to as the household model. In this model individuals make local contacts within a specific small subgroup of the population (e.g.\ within a household or a school class), while they also make global contacts with random people in the population at a much lower rate than the rate of local contacts.
We consider what happens if schools are given freedom to impose vaccine mandates on all of their pupils, except for the pupils that are exempt from vaccination because of medical reasons. We investigate how such a mandate affects the probability of an outbreak of a disease and the probability that a pupil that is medically exempt from vaccination, gets infected during an outbreak. We show that if the population vaccine coverage is close to the herd-immunity level then both probabilities may increase if local vaccine mandates are implemented. This is caused by unvaccinated pupils moving to schools without mandates.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
The risk for a new COVID-19 wave -- and how it depends on $R_0$, the current immunity level and current restrictions
Authors:
Tom Britton,
Pieter Trapman,
Frank Ball
Abstract:
The COVID-19 pandemic has hit different parts of the world differently: some regions are still in the rise of the first wave, other regions are now facing a decline after a first wave, and yet other regions have started to see a second wave. The current immunity level $\hat i$ in a region is closely related to the cumulative fraction infected, which primarily depends on two factors: a) the initial…
▽ More
The COVID-19 pandemic has hit different parts of the world differently: some regions are still in the rise of the first wave, other regions are now facing a decline after a first wave, and yet other regions have started to see a second wave. The current immunity level $\hat i$ in a region is closely related to the cumulative fraction infected, which primarily depends on two factors: a) the initial potential for COVID-19 in the region (often quantified by the basic reproduction number $R_0$), and b) the timing, amount and effectiveness of preventive measures put in place. By means of a mathematical model including heterogeneities owing to age, social activity and susceptibility, and allowing for time-varying preventive measures, the risk for a new epidemic wave and its doubling time, and how they depend on $R_0$, $\hat i$ and the overall effect of the current preventive measures, are investigated. Focus lies on quantifying the minimal overall effect of preventive measures $p_{Min}$ needed to prevent a future outbreak. The first result shows that the current immunity level $\hat i$ plays a more influential roll than when immunity is obtained from vaccination. Secondly, by comparing regions with different $R_0$ and $\hat i$ it is shown that regions with lower $R_0$ and low $\hat i$ may now need higher preventive measures ($p_{Min}$) compared with other regions having higher $R_0$ but also higher $\hat i$, even when such immunity levels are far from herd immunity.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Key Questions for Modelling COVID-19 Exit Strategies
Authors:
Robin N Thompson,
T Deirdre Hollingsworth,
Valerie Isham,
Daniel Arribas-Bel,
Ben Ashby,
Tom Britton,
Peter Challoner,
Lauren H K Chappell,
Hannah Clapham,
Nik J Cunniffe,
A Philip Dawid,
Christl A Donnelly,
Rosalind Eggo,
Sebastian Funk,
Nigel Gilbert,
Julia R Gog,
Paul Glendinning,
William S Hart,
Hans Heesterbeek,
Thomas House,
Matt Keeling,
Istvan Z Kiss,
Mirjam Kretzschmar,
Alun L Lloyd,
Emma S McBryde
, et al. (18 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Combinations of intense non-pharmaceutical interventions ('lockdowns') were introduced in countries worldwide to reduce SARS-CoV-2 transmission. Many governments have begun to implement lockdown exit strategies that allow restrictions to be relaxed while attempting to control the risk of a surge in cases. Mathematical modelling has played a central role in guiding interventions, but the challenge…
▽ More
Combinations of intense non-pharmaceutical interventions ('lockdowns') were introduced in countries worldwide to reduce SARS-CoV-2 transmission. Many governments have begun to implement lockdown exit strategies that allow restrictions to be relaxed while attempting to control the risk of a surge in cases. Mathematical modelling has played a central role in guiding interventions, but the challenge of designing optimal exit strategies in the face of ongoing transmission is unprecedented. Here, we report discussions from the Isaac Newton Institute 'Models for an exit strategy' workshop (11-15 May 2020). A diverse community of modellers who are providing evidence to governments worldwide were asked to identify the main questions that, if answered, will allow for more accurate predictions of the effects of different exit strategies. Based on these questions, we propose a roadmap to facilitate the development of reliable models to guide exit strategies. The roadmap requires a global collaborative effort from the scientific community and policy-makers, and is made up of three parts: i) improve estimation of key epidemiological parameters; ii) understand sources of heterogeneity in populations; iii) focus on requirements for data collection, particularly in Low-to-Middle-Income countries. This will provide important information for planning exit strategies that balance socio-economic benefits with public health.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2020; v1 submitted 21 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
The disease-induced herd immunity level for Covid-19 is substantially lower than the classical herd immunity level
Authors:
Tom Britton,
Frank Ball,
Pieter Trapman
Abstract:
Most countries are suffering severely from the ongoing covid-19 pandemic despite various levels of preventive measures. A common question is if and when a country or region will reach herd immunity $h$. The classical herd immunity level $h_C$ is defined as $h_C=1-1/R_0$, where $R_0$ is the basic reproduction number, for covid-19 estimated to lie somewhere in the range 2.2-3.5 depending on country…
▽ More
Most countries are suffering severely from the ongoing covid-19 pandemic despite various levels of preventive measures. A common question is if and when a country or region will reach herd immunity $h$. The classical herd immunity level $h_C$ is defined as $h_C=1-1/R_0$, where $R_0$ is the basic reproduction number, for covid-19 estimated to lie somewhere in the range 2.2-3.5 depending on country and region. It is shown here that the disease-induced herd immunity level $h_D$, after an outbreak has taken place in a country/region with a set of preventive measures put in place, is actually substantially smaller than $h_C$. As an illustration we show that if $R_0=2.5$ in an age-structured community with mixing rates fitted to social activity studies, and also categorizing individuals into three categories: low active, average active and high active, and where preventive measures affect all mixing rates proportionally, then the disease-induced herd immunity level is $h_D=43\%$ rather than $h_C=1-1/2.5=60\%$. Consequently, a lower fraction infected is required for herd immunity to appear. The underlying reason is that when immunity is induced by disease spreading, the proportion infected in groups with high contact rates is greater than that in groups with low contact rates. Consequently, disease-induced immunity is stronger than when immunity is uniformly distributed in the community as in the classical herd immunity level.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Who is the infector? Epidemic models with symptomatic and asymptomatic cases
Authors:
Ka Yin Leung,
Pieter Trapman,
Tom Britton
Abstract:
What role do asymptomatically infected individuals play in the transmission dynamics? There are many diseases, such as norovirus and influenza, where some infected hosts show symptoms of the disease while others are asymptomatically infected, i.e. do not show any symptoms. The current paper considers a class of epidemic models following an SEIR (Susceptible $\to$ Exposed $\to$ Infectious $\to$ Rec…
▽ More
What role do asymptomatically infected individuals play in the transmission dynamics? There are many diseases, such as norovirus and influenza, where some infected hosts show symptoms of the disease while others are asymptomatically infected, i.e. do not show any symptoms. The current paper considers a class of epidemic models following an SEIR (Susceptible $\to$ Exposed $\to$ Infectious $\to$ Recovered) structure that allows for both symptomatic and asymptomatic cases. The following question is addressed: what fraction $ρ$ of those individuals getting infected are infected by symptomatic (asymptomatic) cases? This is a more complicated question than the related question for the beginning of the epidemic: what fraction of the expected number of secondary cases of a typical newly infected individual, i.e. what fraction of the basic reproduction number $R_0$, is caused by symptomatic individuals? The latter fraction only depends on the type-specific reproduction numbers, while the former fraction $ρ$ also depends on timing and hence on the probabilistic distributions of latent and infectious periods of the two types (not only their means). Bounds on $ρ$ are derived for the situation where these distributions (and even their means) are unknown. Special attention is given to the class of Markov models and the class of continuous-time Reed-Frost models as two classes of distribution functions. We show how these two classes of models can exhibit very different behaviour.
△ Less
Submitted 26 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Characterizing the Initial Phase of Epidemic Growth on some Empirical Networks
Authors:
Kristoffer Spricer,
Pieter Trapman
Abstract:
A key parameter in models for the spread of infectious diseases is the basic reproduction number $R_0$, which is the expected number of secondary cases a typical infected primary case infects during its infectious period in a large mostly susceptible population. In order for this quantity to be meaningful, the initial expected growth of the number of infectious individuals in the large-population…
▽ More
A key parameter in models for the spread of infectious diseases is the basic reproduction number $R_0$, which is the expected number of secondary cases a typical infected primary case infects during its infectious period in a large mostly susceptible population. In order for this quantity to be meaningful, the initial expected growth of the number of infectious individuals in the large-population limit should be exponential.
We investigate to what extent this assumption is valid by performing repeated simulations of epidemics on selected empirical networks, viewing each epidemic as a random process in discrete time. The initial phase of each epidemic is analyzed by fitting the number of infected people at each time step to a generalised growth model, allowing for estimating the shape of the growth. For reference, similar investigations are done on some elementary graphs such as integer lattices in different dimensions and configuration model graphs, for which the early epidemic behaviour is known.
We find that for the empirical networks tested in this paper, exponential growth characterizes the early stages of the epidemic, except when the network is restricted by a strong low-dimensional spacial constraint, such as is the case for the two-dimensional square lattice. However, on finite integer lattices of sufficiently high dimension, the early development of epidemics shows exponential growth.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Inferring $R_0$ in emerging epidemics - the effect of common population structure is small
Authors:
Pieter Trapman,
Frank Ball,
Jean-Stéphane Dhersin,
Viet Chi Tran,
Jacco Wallinga,
Tom Britton
Abstract:
When controlling an emerging outbreak of an infectious disease it is essential to know the key epidemiological parameters, such as the basic reproduction number $R_0$ and the control effort required to prevent a large outbreak. These parameters are estimated from the observed incidence of new cases and information about the infectious contact structures of the population in which the disease sprea…
▽ More
When controlling an emerging outbreak of an infectious disease it is essential to know the key epidemiological parameters, such as the basic reproduction number $R_0$ and the control effort required to prevent a large outbreak. These parameters are estimated from the observed incidence of new cases and information about the infectious contact structures of the population in which the disease spreads. However, the relevant infectious contact structures for new, emerging infections are often unknown or hard to obtain. Here we show that for many common true underlying heterogeneous contact structures, the simplification to neglect such structures and instead assume that all contacts are made homogeneously in the whole population, results in conservative estimates for $R_0$ and the required control effort. This means that robust control policies can be planned during the early stages of an outbreak, using such conservative estimates of the required control effort.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Reproduction numbers for epidemic models with households and other social structures II: comparisons and implications for vaccination
Authors:
Frank Ball,
Lorenzo Pellis,
Pieter Trapman
Abstract:
In this paper we consider epidemic models of directly transmissible SIR (susceptible $\to$ infective $\to$ recovered) and SEIR (with an additional latent class) infections in fully-susceptible populations with a social structure, consisting either of households or of households and workplaces. We review most reproduction numbers defined in the literature for these models, including the basic repro…
▽ More
In this paper we consider epidemic models of directly transmissible SIR (susceptible $\to$ infective $\to$ recovered) and SEIR (with an additional latent class) infections in fully-susceptible populations with a social structure, consisting either of households or of households and workplaces. We review most reproduction numbers defined in the literature for these models, including the basic reproduction number $R_0$ introduced in the companion paper of this, for which we provide a simpler, more elegant derivation. Extending previous work, we provide a complete overview of the inequalities among these reproduction numbers and resolve some open questions. Special focus is put on the exponential-growth-associated reproduction number $R_r$, which is loosely defined as the estimate of $R_0$ based on the observed exponential growth of an emerging epidemic obtained when the social structure is ignored. We show that for the vast majority of the models considered in the literature $R_r \geq R_0$ when $R_0 \ge 1$ and $R_r \leq R_0$ when $R_0 \le 1$. We show that, in contrast to models without social structure, vaccination of a fraction $1-1/R_0$ of the population, chosen uniformly at random, with a perfect vaccine is usually insufficient to prevent large epidemics. In addition, we provide significantly sharper bounds than the existing ones for bracketing the critical vaccination coverage between two analytically tractable quantities, which we illustrate by means of extensive numerical examples.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2015; v1 submitted 16 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
Stochastic epidemics in growing populations
Authors:
Tom Britton,
Pieter Trapman
Abstract:
Consider a uniformly mixing population which grows as a super-critical linear birth and death process. At some time an infectious disease (of SIR or SEIR type) is introduced by one individual being infected from outside. It is shown that three different scenarios may occur: 1) an epidemic never takes off, 2) an epidemic gets going and grows but at a slower rate than the community thus still being…
▽ More
Consider a uniformly mixing population which grows as a super-critical linear birth and death process. At some time an infectious disease (of SIR or SEIR type) is introduced by one individual being infected from outside. It is shown that three different scenarios may occur: 1) an epidemic never takes off, 2) an epidemic gets going and grows but at a slower rate than the community thus still being negligible in terms of population fractions, or 3) an epidemic takes off and grows quicker than the community eventually leading to an endemic equilibrium. Depending on the parameter values, either scenario 1 is the only possibility, both scenario 1 and 2 are possible, or scenario 1 and 3 are possible.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2013;
originally announced September 2013.
-
Epidemics on random intersection graphs
Authors:
Frank G. Ball,
David J. Sirl,
Pieter Trapman
Abstract:
In this paper we consider a model for the spread of a stochastic SIR (Susceptible $\to$ Infectious $\to$ Recovered) epidemic on a network of individuals described by a random intersection graph. Individuals belong to a random number of cliques, each of random size, and infection can be transmitted between two individuals if and only if there is a clique they both belong to. Both the clique sizes a…
▽ More
In this paper we consider a model for the spread of a stochastic SIR (Susceptible $\to$ Infectious $\to$ Recovered) epidemic on a network of individuals described by a random intersection graph. Individuals belong to a random number of cliques, each of random size, and infection can be transmitted between two individuals if and only if there is a clique they both belong to. Both the clique sizes and the number of cliques an individual belongs to follow mixed Poisson distributions. An infinite-type branching process approximation (with type being given by the length of an individual's infectious period) for the early stages of an epidemic is developed and made fully rigorous by proving an associated limit theorem as the population size tends to infinity. This leads to a threshold parameter $R_*$, so that in a large population an epidemic with few initial infectives can give rise to a large outbreak if and only if $R_*>1$. A functional equation for the survival probability of the approximating infinite-type branching process is determined; if $R_*\le1$, this equation has no nonzero solution, while if $R_*>1$, it is shown to have precisely one nonzero solution. A law of large numbers for the size of such a large outbreak is proved by exploiting a single-type branching process that approximates the size of the susceptibility set of a typical individual.
△ Less
Submitted 28 April, 2014; v1 submitted 18 November, 2010;
originally announced November 2010.
-
Bounding basic characteristics of spatial epidemics with a new percolation model
Authors:
Ronald Meester,
Pieter Trapman
Abstract:
We introduce a new percolation model to describe and analyze the spread of an epidemic on a general directed and locally finite graph. We assign a two-dimensional random weight vector to each vertex of the graph in such a way that the weights of different vertices are i.i.d., but the two entries of the vector assigned to a vertex need not be independent. The probability for an edge to be open de…
▽ More
We introduce a new percolation model to describe and analyze the spread of an epidemic on a general directed and locally finite graph. We assign a two-dimensional random weight vector to each vertex of the graph in such a way that the weights of different vertices are i.i.d., but the two entries of the vector assigned to a vertex need not be independent. The probability for an edge to be open depends on the weights of its end vertices, but conditionally on the weights, the states of the edges are independent of each other. In an epidemiological setting, the vertices of a graph represent the individuals in a (social) network and the edges represent the connections in the network. The weights assigned to an individual denote its (random) infectivity and susceptibility, respectively. We show that one can bound the percolation probability and the expected size of the cluster of vertices that can be reached by an open path starting at a given vertex from above and below by the corresponding quantities for respectively independent bond and site percolation with certain densities; this generalizes a result of Kuulasmaa. Many models in the literature are special cases of our general model.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2010; v1 submitted 23 December, 2008;
originally announced December 2008.
-
A useful relationship between epidemiology and queueing theory
Authors:
Pieter Trapman,
Martin Bootsma
Abstract:
In this paper we establish a relation between the spread of infectious diseases and the dynamics of so called M/G/1 queues with processor sharing. The in epidemiology well known relation between the spread of epidemics and branching processes and the in queueing theory well known relation between M/G/1 queues and birth death processes will be combined to provide a framework in which results from…
▽ More
In this paper we establish a relation between the spread of infectious diseases and the dynamics of so called M/G/1 queues with processor sharing. The in epidemiology well known relation between the spread of epidemics and branching processes and the in queueing theory well known relation between M/G/1 queues and birth death processes will be combined to provide a framework in which results from queueing theory can be used in epidemiology and vice versa.
In particular, we consider the number of infectious individuals in a standard SIR epidemic model at the moment of the first detection of the epidemic, where infectious individuals are detected at a constant per capita rate. We use a result from the literature on queueing processes to show that this number of infectious individuals is geometrically distributed.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2008;
originally announced December 2008.
-
Threshold behaviour and final outcome of an epidemic on a random network with household structure
Authors:
Frank Ball,
David Sirl,
Pieter Trapman
Abstract:
This paper considers a stochastic SIR (susceptible$\to$infective$\to$removed) epidemic model in which individuals may make infectious contacts in two ways, both within `households' (which for ease of exposition are assumed to have equal size) and along the edges of a random graph describing additional social contacts. Heuristically-motivated branching process approximations are described, which…
▽ More
This paper considers a stochastic SIR (susceptible$\to$infective$\to$removed) epidemic model in which individuals may make infectious contacts in two ways, both within `households' (which for ease of exposition are assumed to have equal size) and along the edges of a random graph describing additional social contacts. Heuristically-motivated branching process approximations are described, which lead to a threshold parameter for the model and methods for calculating the probability of a major outbreak, given few initial infectives, and the expected proportion of the population who are ultimately infected by such a major outbreak. These approximate results are shown to be exact as the number of households tends to infinity by proving associated limit theorems. Moreover, simulation studies indicate that these asymptotic results provide good approximations for modestly sized finite populations. The extension to unequal sized households is discussed briefly.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2010; v1 submitted 22 December, 2008;
originally announced December 2008.
