-
Experimentally testable whole brain manifolds that recapitulate behavior
Authors:
Gerald M Pao,
Cameron Smith,
Joseph Park,
Keichi Takahashi,
Wassapon Watanakeesuntorn,
Hiroaki Natsukawa,
Sreekanth H Chalasani,
Tom Lorimer,
Ryousei Takano,
Nuttida Rungratsameetaweemana,
George Sugihara
Abstract:
We propose an algorithm grounded in dynamical systems theory that generalizes manifold learning from a global state representation, to a network of local interacting manifolds termed a Generative Manifold Network (GMN). Manifolds are discovered using the convergent cross mapping (CCM) causal inference algorithm which are then compressed into a reduced redundancy network. The representation is a ne…
▽ More
We propose an algorithm grounded in dynamical systems theory that generalizes manifold learning from a global state representation, to a network of local interacting manifolds termed a Generative Manifold Network (GMN). Manifolds are discovered using the convergent cross mapping (CCM) causal inference algorithm which are then compressed into a reduced redundancy network. The representation is a network of manifolds embedded from observational data where each orthogonal axis of a local manifold is an embedding of a individually identifiable neuron or brain area that has exact correspondence in the real world. As such these can be experimentally manipulated to test hypotheses derived from theory and data analysis. Here we demonstrate that this representation preserves the essential features of the brain of flies,larval zebrafish and humans. In addition to accurate near-term prediction, the GMN model can be used to synthesize realistic time series of whole brain neuronal activity and locomotion viewed over the long term. Thus, as a final validation of how well GMN captures essential dynamic information, we show that the artificially generated time series can be used as a training set to predict out-of-sample observed fly locomotion, as well as brain activity in out of sample withheld data not used in model building. Remarkably, the artificially generated time series show realistic novel behaviors that do not exist in the training data, but that do exist in the out-of-sample observational data. This suggests that GMN captures inherently emergent properties of the network. We suggest our approach may be a generic recipe for mapping time series observations of any complex nonlinear network into a model that is able to generate naturalistic system behaviors that identifies variables that have real world correspondence and can be experimentally manipulated.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Massively Parallel Causal Inference of Whole Brain Dynamics at Single Neuron Resolution
Authors:
Wassapon Watanakeesuntorn,
Keichi Takahashi,
Kohei Ichikawa,
Joseph Park,
George Sugihara,
Ryousei Takano,
Jason Haga,
Gerald M. Pao
Abstract:
Empirical Dynamic Modeling (EDM) is a nonlinear time series causal inference framework. The latest implementation of EDM, cppEDM, has only been used for small datasets due to computational cost. With the growth of data collection capabilities, there is a great need to identify causal relationships in large datasets. We present mpEDM, a parallel distributed implementation of EDM optimized for moder…
▽ More
Empirical Dynamic Modeling (EDM) is a nonlinear time series causal inference framework. The latest implementation of EDM, cppEDM, has only been used for small datasets due to computational cost. With the growth of data collection capabilities, there is a great need to identify causal relationships in large datasets. We present mpEDM, a parallel distributed implementation of EDM optimized for modern GPU-centric supercomputers. We improve the original algorithm to reduce redundant computation and optimize the implementation to fully utilize hardware resources such as GPUs and SIMD units. As a use case, we run mpEDM on AI Bridging Cloud Infrastructure (ABCI) using datasets of an entire animal brain sampled at single neuron resolution to identify dynamical causation patterns across the brain. mpEDM is 1,530 X faster than cppEDM and a dataset containing 101,729 neuron was analyzed in 199 seconds on 512 nodes. This is the largest EDM causal inference achieved to date.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Global evidence for non-random dynamics in fish recruitment
Authors:
Charles T. Perretti,
Stephan B. Munch,
Michael J. Fogarty,
George Sugihara
Abstract:
Understanding what controls apparently random fluctuations in fish recruitment is a major challenge in fisheries science. Our current inability to anticipate recruitment failures has led to costly management actions and in some cases complete fishery collapse. Time series observations of fish recruitment reflect an interplay of underlying population processes, environmental forcing, measurement er…
▽ More
Understanding what controls apparently random fluctuations in fish recruitment is a major challenge in fisheries science. Our current inability to anticipate recruitment failures has led to costly management actions and in some cases complete fishery collapse. Time series observations of fish recruitment reflect an interplay of underlying population processes, environmental forcing, measurement error, and process error. Given that the error component is often very strong, an important unresolved question is whether any non-random signal can be uncovered in the annual fluctuations of recruitment time series. Here, we address this fundamental question in an analysis of 569 fish populations from a global database of recruitment. Using a nonparametric time series analysis method, we find overwhelming evidence for non-random dynamics operating in the recruitment process. Unlike previous explorations of this topic, our approach does not require the specification of a stock-recruitment model, and it can be used on recruitment estimates derived from a wide-range of abundance estimation methods. The evidence for non-randomness is robust across a wide range of fish families and abundance estimation methods. We also find that the statistical support for non-randomness increases consistently with the number of observations of a fish stock. This result provides the encouraging news that with continued observations, and the appropriate covariates, we should ultimately be able to uncover the mechanistic drivers of fish recruitment.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Reply to Hartig et al. [arXiv:1305.3544]: The "true model" myth
Authors:
Charles T. Perretti,
Stephan B. Munch,
George Sugihara
Abstract:
We have shown that commonly used model-fitting methods fail when the underlying ecological system is chaotic. Importantly, Hartig & Dormann [arXiv:1305.3544] suggest an alternative method that is able to overcome this problem for the logistic model when the "true model" is known. This is encouraging, however the more relevant test is of the method when the "true model" is unknown, as it always is…
▽ More
We have shown that commonly used model-fitting methods fail when the underlying ecological system is chaotic. Importantly, Hartig & Dormann [arXiv:1305.3544] suggest an alternative method that is able to overcome this problem for the logistic model when the "true model" is known. This is encouraging, however the more relevant test is of the method when the "true model" is unknown, as it always is for real ecosystems. By making a small modification to the "true model," we find that the suggested method provides inaccurate forecasts and severely biased estimates of the ecological dynamics. In contrast, a model-free approach is able to provide accurate forecasts and a useful foundation for ecological understanding without the burdensome assumption of a "true model."
△ Less
Submitted 22 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
