A rigorous benchmarking of methods for SARS-CoV-2 lineage abundance estimation in wastewater
Authors:
Viorel Munteanu,
Victor Gordeev,
Michael Saldana,
Eva Aßmann,
Justin Maine Su,
Nicolae Drabcinski,
Oksana Zlenko,
Maryna Kit,
Felicia Iordachi,
Khooshbu Kantibhai Patel,
Abdullah Al Nahid,
Likhitha Chittampalli,
Yidian Xu,
Pavel Skums,
Shelesh Agrawal,
Martin Hölzer,
Adam Smith,
Alex Zelikovsky,
Serghei Mangul
Abstract:
In light of the continuous transmission and evolution of SARS-CoV-2 coupled with a significant decline in clinical testing, there is a pressing need for scalable, cost-effective, long-term, passive surveillance tools to effectively monitor viral variants circulating in the population. Wastewater genomic surveillance of SARS-CoV-2 has arrived as an alternative to clinical genomic surveillance, allo…
▽ More
In light of the continuous transmission and evolution of SARS-CoV-2 coupled with a significant decline in clinical testing, there is a pressing need for scalable, cost-effective, long-term, passive surveillance tools to effectively monitor viral variants circulating in the population. Wastewater genomic surveillance of SARS-CoV-2 has arrived as an alternative to clinical genomic surveillance, allowing to continuously monitor the prevalence of viral lineages in communities of various size at a fraction of the time, cost, and logistic effort and serving as an early warning system for emerging variants, critical for developed communities and especially for underserved ones. Importantly, lineage prevalence estimates obtained with this approach aren't distorted by biases related to clinical testing accessibility and participation. However, the relative performance of bioinformatics methods used to measure relative lineage abundances from wastewater sequencing data is unknown, preventing both the research community and public health authorities from making informed decisions regarding computational tool selection. Here, we perform comprehensive benchmarking of 18 bioinformatics methods for estimating the relative abundance of SARS-CoV-2 (sub)lineages in wastewater by using data from 36 in vitro mixtures of synthetic lineage and sublineage genomes. In addition, we use simulated data from 78 mixtures of lineages and sublineages co-occurring in the clinical setting with proportions mirroring their prevalence ratios observed in real data. Importantly, we investigate how the accuracy of the evaluated methods is impacted by the sequencing technology used, the associated error rate, the read length, read depth, but also by the exposure of the synthetic RNA mixtures to wastewater, with the goal of capturing the effects induced by the wastewater matrix, including RNA fragmentation and degradation.
△ Less
Submitted 21 January, 2024; v1 submitted 29 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
SARS-CoV-2 Wastewater Genomic Surveillance: Approaches, Challenges, and Opportunities
Authors:
Viorel Munteanu,
Michael A. Saldana,
David Dreifuss,
Wenhao O. Ouyang,
Jannatul Ferdous,
Fatemeh Mohebbi,
Jessica Schlueter,
Dumitru Ciorba,
Viorel Bostan,
Victor Gordeev,
Justin Maine Su,
Nadiia Kasianchuk,
Nitesh Kumar Sharma,
Sergey Knyazev,
Eva Aßmann,
Andrei Lobiuc,
Mihai Covasa,
Keith A. Crandall,
Nicholas C. Wu,
Christopher E. Mason,
Braden T Tierney,
Alexander G Lucaci,
Roel A. Ophoff,
Cynthia Gibas,
Piotr Rzymski
, et al. (7 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
During the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic, wastewater-based genomic surveillance (WWGS) emerged as an efficient viral surveillance tool that takes into account asymptomatic cases and can identify known and novel mutations and offers the opportunity to assign known virus lineages based on the detected mutations profiles. WWGS can also hint towards novel or cryptic lineages, but it is difficult to clearly iden…
▽ More
During the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic, wastewater-based genomic surveillance (WWGS) emerged as an efficient viral surveillance tool that takes into account asymptomatic cases and can identify known and novel mutations and offers the opportunity to assign known virus lineages based on the detected mutations profiles. WWGS can also hint towards novel or cryptic lineages, but it is difficult to clearly identify and define novel lineages from wastewater (WW) alone. While WWGS has significant advantages in monitoring SARS-CoV-2 viral spread, technical challenges remain, including poor sequencing coverage and quality due to viral RNA degradation. As a result, the viral RNAs in wastewater have low concentrations and are often fragmented, making sequencing difficult. WWGS analysis requires advanced computational tools that are yet to be developed and benchmarked. The existing bioinformatics tools used to analyze wastewater sequencing data are often based on previously developed methods for quantifying the expression of transcripts or viral diversity. Those methods were not developed for wastewater sequencing data specifically, and are not optimized to address unique challenges associated with wastewater. While specialized tools for analysis of wastewater sequencing data have also been developed recently, it remains to be seen how they will perform given the ongoing evolution of SARS-CoV-2 and the decline in testing and patient-based genomic surveillance. Here, we discuss opportunities and challenges associated with WWGS, including sample preparation, sequencing technology, and bioinformatics methods.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2025; v1 submitted 23 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
