-
On the Minimal Theory of Consciousness Implicit in Active Inference
Authors:
Christopher J. Whyte,
Andrew W. Corcoran,
Jonathan Robinson,
Ryan Smith,
Rosalyn J. Moran,
Thomas Parr,
Karl J. Friston,
Anil K. Seth,
Jakob Hohwy
Abstract:
The multifaceted nature of experience poses a challenge to the study of consciousness. Traditional neuroscientific approaches often concentrate on isolated facets, such as perceptual awareness or the global state of consciousness and construct a theory around the relevant empirical paradigms and findings. Theories of consciousness are, therefore, often difficult to compare; indeed, there might be…
▽ More
The multifaceted nature of experience poses a challenge to the study of consciousness. Traditional neuroscientific approaches often concentrate on isolated facets, such as perceptual awareness or the global state of consciousness and construct a theory around the relevant empirical paradigms and findings. Theories of consciousness are, therefore, often difficult to compare; indeed, there might be little overlap in the phenomena such theories aim to explain. Here, we take a different approach: starting with active inference, a first principles framework for modelling behaviour as (approximate) Bayesian inference, and building up to a minimal theory of consciousness, which emerges from the shared features of computational models derived under active inference. We review a body of work applying active inference models to the study of consciousness and argue that there is implicit in all these models a small set of theoretical commitments that point to a minimal (and testable) theory of consciousness.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Fine-tuning neural excitation/inhibition for tailored ketamine use in treatment-resistant depression
Authors:
Erik D. Fagerholm,
Robert Leech,
Steven Williams,
Carlos A. Zarate Jr.,
Rosalyn J. Moran,
Jessica R. Gilbert
Abstract:
The glutamatergic modulator ketamine has been shown to rapidly reduce depressive symptoms in patients with treatment-resistant major depressive disorder (TRD). Although its mechanisms of action are not fully understood, changes in cortical excitation/inhibition (E/I) following ketamine administration are well documented in animal models and could represent a potential biomarker of treatment respon…
▽ More
The glutamatergic modulator ketamine has been shown to rapidly reduce depressive symptoms in patients with treatment-resistant major depressive disorder (TRD). Although its mechanisms of action are not fully understood, changes in cortical excitation/inhibition (E/I) following ketamine administration are well documented in animal models and could represent a potential biomarker of treatment response. Here, we analyse neuromagnetic virtual electrode timeseries collected from the primary somatosensory cortex in 18 unmedicated patients with TRD and in an equal number of age-matched healthy controls during a somatosensory 'airpuff' stimulation task. These two groups were scanned as part of a clinical trial of ketamine efficacy under three conditions: a) baseline; b) 6-9 hours following subanesthetic ketamine infusion; and c) 6-9 hours following placebo-saline infusion. We obtained estimates of E/I interaction strengths by using Dynamic Causal Modelling (DCM) on the timeseries, thereby allowing us to pinpoint, under each scanning condition, where each subject's dynamics lie within the Poincaré diagram - as defined in dynamical systems theory. We demonstrate that the Poincaré diagram offers classification capability for TRD patients, in that the further the patients' coordinates were shifted (by virtue of ketamine) toward the stable (top-left) quadrant of the Poincaré diagram, the more their depressive symptoms improved. The same relationship was not observed by virtue of a placebo effect - thereby verifying the drug-specific nature of the results. We show that the shift in neural dynamics required for symptom improvement necessitates an increase in both excitatory and inhibitory coupling. We present accompanying MATLAB code made available in a public repository, thereby allowing for future studies to assess individually-tailored treatments of TRD.
△ Less
Submitted 4 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
The principle of stationary action in neural systems
Authors:
Erik D. Fagerholm,
Karl J. Friston,
Rosalyn J. Moran,
Robert Leech
Abstract:
The principle of stationary action is a cornerstone of modern physics, providing a powerful framework for investigating dynamical systems found in classical mechanics through to quantum field theory. However, computational neuroscience, despite its heavy reliance on concepts in physics, is anomalous in this regard as its main equations of motion are not compatible with a Lagrangian formulation and…
▽ More
The principle of stationary action is a cornerstone of modern physics, providing a powerful framework for investigating dynamical systems found in classical mechanics through to quantum field theory. However, computational neuroscience, despite its heavy reliance on concepts in physics, is anomalous in this regard as its main equations of motion are not compatible with a Lagrangian formulation and hence with the principle of stationary action. Taking the Dynamic Causal Modelling neuronal state equation, Hodgkin-Huxley model, and the Leaky Integrate-and-Fire model as examples, we show that it is possible to write complex oscillatory forms of these equations in terms of a single Lagrangian. We therefore bring mathematical descriptions in computational neuroscience under the remit of the principle of stationary action and use this reformulation to express symmetries and associated conservation laws arising in neural systems.
△ Less
Submitted 6 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Effective immunity and second waves: a dynamic causal modelling study
Authors:
Karl J. Friston,
Thomas Parr,
Peter Zeidman,
Adeel Razi,
Guillaume Flandin,
Jean Daunizeau,
Oliver J. Hulme,
Alexander J. Billig,
Vladimir Litvak,
Cathy J. Price,
Rosalyn J. Moran,
Anthony Costello,
Deenan Pillay,
Christian Lambert
Abstract:
This technical report addresses a pressing issue in the trajectory of the coronavirus outbreak; namely, the rate at which effective immunity is lost following the first wave of the pandemic. This is a crucial epidemiological parameter that speaks to both the consequences of relaxing lockdown and the propensity for a second wave of infections. Using a dynamic causal model of reported cases and deat…
▽ More
This technical report addresses a pressing issue in the trajectory of the coronavirus outbreak; namely, the rate at which effective immunity is lost following the first wave of the pandemic. This is a crucial epidemiological parameter that speaks to both the consequences of relaxing lockdown and the propensity for a second wave of infections. Using a dynamic causal model of reported cases and deaths from multiple countries, we evaluated the evidence models of progressively longer periods of immunity. The results speak to an effective population immunity of about three months that, under the model, defers any second wave for approximately six months in most countries. This may have implications for the window of opportunity for tracking and tracing, as well as for developing vaccination programmes, and other therapeutic interventions.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Tracking and tracing in the UK: a dynamic causal modelling study
Authors:
Karl J. Friston,
Thomas Parr,
Peter Zeidman,
Adeel Razi,
Guillaume Flandin,
Jean Daunizeau,
Oliver J. Hulme,
Alexander J. Billig,
Vladimir Litvak,
Cathy J. Price,
Rosalyn J. Moran,
Christian Lambert
Abstract:
By equipping a previously reported dynamic causal model of COVID-19 with an isolation state, we modelled the effects of self-isolation consequent on tracking and tracing. Specifically, we included a quarantine or isolation state occupied by people who believe they might be infected but are asymptomatic, and only leave if they test negative. We recovered maximum posteriori estimates of the model pa…
▽ More
By equipping a previously reported dynamic causal model of COVID-19 with an isolation state, we modelled the effects of self-isolation consequent on tracking and tracing. Specifically, we included a quarantine or isolation state occupied by people who believe they might be infected but are asymptomatic, and only leave if they test negative. We recovered maximum posteriori estimates of the model parameters using time series of new cases, daily deaths, and tests for the UK. These parameters were used to simulate the trajectory of the outbreak in the UK over an 18-month period. Several clear-cut conclusions emerged from these simulations. For example, under plausible (graded) relaxations of social distancing, a rebound of infections within weeks is unlikely. The emergence of a later second wave depends almost exclusively on the rate at which we lose immunity, inherited from the first wave. There exists no testing strategy that can attenuate mortality rates, other than by deferring or delaying a second wave. A sufficiently powerful tracking and tracing policy--implemented at the time of writing (10th May 2020)--will defer any second wave beyond a time horizon of 18 months. Crucially, this deferment is within current testing capabilities (requiring an efficacy of tracing and tracking of about 20% of asymptomatic infected cases, with less than 50,000 tests per day). These conclusions are based upon a dynamic causal model for which we provide some construct and face validation, using a comparative analysis of the United Kingdom and Germany, supplemented with recent serological studies.
△ Less
Submitted 16 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Fighting seizures with seizures: diffusion and stability in neural systems
Authors:
Erik D. Fagerholm,
Chayanin Tangwiriyasakul,
Karl J. Friston,
Inês R. Violante,
Steven Williams,
David W. Carmichael,
Suejen Perani,
Federico E. Turkheimer,
Rosalyn J. Moran,
Robert Leech,
Mark P. Richardson
Abstract:
Seizure activity is a ubiquitous and pernicious pathophysiology that, in principle, should yield to mathematical treatments of (neuronal) ensemble dynamics - and therefore interventions on stochastic chaos. A seizure can be characterised as a deviation of neural activity from a stable dynamical regime, i.e. one in which signals fluctuate only within a limited range. In silico treatments of neural…
▽ More
Seizure activity is a ubiquitous and pernicious pathophysiology that, in principle, should yield to mathematical treatments of (neuronal) ensemble dynamics - and therefore interventions on stochastic chaos. A seizure can be characterised as a deviation of neural activity from a stable dynamical regime, i.e. one in which signals fluctuate only within a limited range. In silico treatments of neural activity are an important tool for understanding how the brain can achieve stability, as well as how pathology can lead to seizures and potential strategies for mitigating instabilities, e.g. via external stimulation. Here, we demonstrate that the (neuronal) state equation used in Dynamic Causal Modelling generalises to a Fokker-Planck formalism when propagation of neuronal activity along structural connections is considered. Using the Jacobian of this generalised state equation, we show that an initially unstable system can be rendered stable via a reduction in diffusivity (i.e., connectivity that disperses neuronal fluctuations). We show, for neural systems prone to epileptic seizures, that such a reduction can be achieved via external stimulation. Specifically, we show that this stimulation should be applied in such a way as to temporarily mirror epileptic activity in the areas adjoining an affected brain region - thus 'fighting seizures with seizures'. We offer proof of principle using simulations based on functional neuroimaging data collected from patients with idiopathic generalised epilepsy, in which we successfully suppress pathological activity in a distinct sub-network. Our hope is that this technique can form the basis for real-time monitoring and intervention devices that are capable of suppressing or even preventing seizures in a non-invasive manner.
△ Less
Submitted 2 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Second waves, social distancing, and the spread of COVID-19 across America
Authors:
Karl J. Friston,
Thomas Parr,
Peter Zeidman,
Adeel Razi,
Guillaume Flandin,
Jean Daunizeau,
Oliver J. Hulme,
Alexander J. Billig,
Vladimir Litvak,
Cathy J. Price,
Rosalyn J. Moran,
Christian Lambert
Abstract:
We recently described a dynamic causal model of a COVID-19 outbreak within a single region. Here, we combine several of these (epidemic) models to create a (pandemic) model of viral spread among regions. Our focus is on a second wave of new cases that may result from loss of immunity--and the exchange of people between regions--and how mortality rates can be ameliorated under different strategic r…
▽ More
We recently described a dynamic causal model of a COVID-19 outbreak within a single region. Here, we combine several of these (epidemic) models to create a (pandemic) model of viral spread among regions. Our focus is on a second wave of new cases that may result from loss of immunity--and the exchange of people between regions--and how mortality rates can be ameliorated under different strategic responses. In particular, we consider hard or soft social distancing strategies predicated on national (Federal) or regional (State) estimates of the prevalence of infection in the population. The modelling is demonstrated using timeseries of new cases and deaths from the United States to estimate the parameters of a factorial (compartmental) epidemiological model of each State and, crucially, coupling between States. Using Bayesian model reduction, we identify the effective connectivity between States that best explains the initial phases of the outbreak in the United States. Using the ensuing posterior parameter estimates, we then evaluate the likely outcomes of different policies in terms of mortality, working days lost due to lockdown and demands upon critical care. The provisional results of this modelling suggest that social distancing and loss of immunity are the two key factors that underwrite a return to endemic equilibrium.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Estimating required 'lockdown' cycles before immunity to SARS-CoV-2: Model-based analyses of susceptible population sizes, 'S0', in seven European countries including the UK and Ireland
Authors:
Rosalyn J. Moran,
Erik D. Fagerholm,
Maell Cullen,
Jean Daunizeau,
Mark P. Richardson,
Steven Williams,
Federico Turkheimer,
Rob Leech,
Karl J. Friston
Abstract:
We used Bayesian model inversion to estimate epidemic parameters from the reported case and death rates from seven countries using data from late January 2020 to April 5th 2020. Two distinct generative model types were employed: first a continuous time dynamical-systems implementation of a Susceptible-Exposed-Infectious-Recovered (SEIR) model and second: a partially observable Markov Decision Proc…
▽ More
We used Bayesian model inversion to estimate epidemic parameters from the reported case and death rates from seven countries using data from late January 2020 to April 5th 2020. Two distinct generative model types were employed: first a continuous time dynamical-systems implementation of a Susceptible-Exposed-Infectious-Recovered (SEIR) model and second: a partially observable Markov Decision Process (MDP) or hidden Markov model (HMM) implementation of an SEIR model. Both models parameterise the size of the initial susceptible population (S0), as well as epidemic parameters. Parameter estimation (data fitting) was performed using a standard Bayesian scheme (variational Laplace) designed to allow for latent unobservable states and uncertainty in model parameters.
Both models recapitulated the dynamics of transmissions and disease as given by case and death rates. The peaks of the current waves were predicted to be in the past for four countries (Italy, Spain, Germany and Switzerland) and to emerge in 0.5-2 weeks in Ireland and 1-3 weeks in the UK. For France one model estimated the peak within the past week and the other in the future in two weeks. Crucially, Maximum a posteriori (MAP) estimates of S0 for each country indicated effective population sizes of below 20% (of total population size), under both the continuous time and HMM models. With a Bayesian weighted average across all seven countries and both models, we estimated that 6.4% of the total population would be immune. From the two models the maximum percentage of the effective population was estimated at 19.6% of the total population for the UK, 16.7% for Ireland, 11.4% for Italy, 12.8% for Spain, 18.8% for France, 4.7% for Germany and 12.9% for Switzerland.
Our results indicate that after the current wave, a large proportion of the total population will remain without immunity.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Dynamic causal modelling of COVID-19
Authors:
Karl J. Friston,
Thomas Parr,
Peter Zeidman,
Adeel Razi,
Guillaume Flandin,
Jean Daunizeau,
Oliver J. Hulme,
Alexander J. Billig,
Vladimir Litvak,
Rosalyn J. Moran,
Cathy J. Price,
Christian Lambert
Abstract:
This technical report describes a dynamic causal model of the spread of coronavirus through a population. The model is based upon ensemble or population dynamics that generate outcomes, like new cases and deaths over time. The purpose of this model is to quantify the uncertainty that attends predictions of relevant outcomes. By assuming suitable conditional dependencies, one can model the effects…
▽ More
This technical report describes a dynamic causal model of the spread of coronavirus through a population. The model is based upon ensemble or population dynamics that generate outcomes, like new cases and deaths over time. The purpose of this model is to quantify the uncertainty that attends predictions of relevant outcomes. By assuming suitable conditional dependencies, one can model the effects of interventions (e.g., social distancing) and differences among populations (e.g., herd immunity) to predict what might happen in different circumstances. Technically, this model leverages state-of-the-art variational (Bayesian) model inversion and comparison procedures, originally developed to characterise the responses of neuronal ensembles to perturbations. Here, this modelling is applied to epidemiological populations to illustrate the kind of inferences that are supported and how the model per se can be optimised given timeseries data. Although the purpose of this paper is to describe a modelling protocol, the results illustrate some interesting perspectives on the current pandemic; for example, the nonlinear effects of herd immunity that speak to a self-organised mitigation process.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Seizure intervention via diffusion mechanisms
Authors:
Erik D. Fagerholm,
Rosalyn J. Moran,
Robert Leech
Abstract:
We begin by demonstrating that the neuronal state equation from Dynamic Causal Modelling takes on the form of the discretized Fokker-Planck equation upon the inclusion of local activity gradients within a network. Using the Jacobian of this modified neuronal state equation, we show that an initially unstable system can be rendered stable via a decrease in diffusivity. Therefore, if a node within t…
▽ More
We begin by demonstrating that the neuronal state equation from Dynamic Causal Modelling takes on the form of the discretized Fokker-Planck equation upon the inclusion of local activity gradients within a network. Using the Jacobian of this modified neuronal state equation, we show that an initially unstable system can be rendered stable via a decrease in diffusivity. Therefore, if a node within the system is known to be unstable due to a tendency toward epileptic seizures for example, then our results indicate that intervention techniques should take the counter-intuitive approach of mirroring activity in the nodes immediately surrounding a pathological region - effectively fighting seizures with seizures. Finally, using a two-region system as an example, we show that one can also tune diffusivity in such a way as to allow for the suppression of oscillatory activity during epileptic seizures.
△ Less
Submitted 26 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Estimating quantities conserved by virtue of scale invariance in timeseries
Authors:
Erik D. Fagerholm,
W. M. C. Foulkes,
Yasir Gallero-Salas,
Fritjof Helmchen,
Karl J. Friston,
Rosalyn J. Moran,
Robert Leech
Abstract:
In contrast to the symmetries of translation in space, rotation in space, and translation in time, the known laws of physics are not universally invariant under transformation of scale. However, the action can be invariant under change of scale in the special case of a scale free dynamical system that can be described in terms of a Lagrangian, that itself scales inversely with time. Crucially, thi…
▽ More
In contrast to the symmetries of translation in space, rotation in space, and translation in time, the known laws of physics are not universally invariant under transformation of scale. However, the action can be invariant under change of scale in the special case of a scale free dynamical system that can be described in terms of a Lagrangian, that itself scales inversely with time. Crucially, this means symmetries under change of scale can exist in dynamical systems under certain constraints. Our contribution lies in the derivation of a generalised scale invariant Lagrangian - in the form of a power series expansion - that satisfies these constraints. This generalised Lagrangian furnishes a normal form for dynamic causal models (i.e., state space models based upon differential equations) that can be used to distinguish scale invariance (scale symmetry) from scale freeness in empirical data. We establish face validity with an analysis of simulated data and then show how scale invariance can be identified - and how the associated conserved quantities can be estimated - in neuronal timeseries.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Dynamic causal modelling of phase-amplitude interactions
Authors:
Erik D. Fagerholm,
Rosalyn J. Moran,
Ines R. Violante,
Robert Leech,
Karl J. Friston
Abstract:
Models of coupled oscillators are used to describe a wide variety of phenomena in neuroimaging. These models typically rest on the premise that oscillator dynamics do not evolve beyond their respective limit cycles, and hence that interactions can be described purely in terms of phase differences. Whilst mathematically convenient, the restrictive nature of phase-only models can limit their explana…
▽ More
Models of coupled oscillators are used to describe a wide variety of phenomena in neuroimaging. These models typically rest on the premise that oscillator dynamics do not evolve beyond their respective limit cycles, and hence that interactions can be described purely in terms of phase differences. Whilst mathematically convenient, the restrictive nature of phase-only models can limit their explanatory power. We therefore propose a generalisation of dynamic causal modelling that incorporates both phase and amplitude. This allows for the separate quantifications of phase and amplitude contributions to the connectivity between neural regions. We establish, using model-generated data and simulations of coupled pendula, that phase-only models perform well only under weak coupling conditions. We also show that, despite their higher complexity, phase-amplitude models can describe strongly coupled systems more effectively than their phase-only counterparts. We relate our findings to four metrics commonly used in neuroimaging: the Kuramoto order parameter, cross-correlation, phase-lag index, and spectral entropy. We find that, with the exception of spectral entropy, the phase-amplitude model is able to capture all metrics more effectively than the phase-only model. We then demonstrate, using local field potential recordings in rodents and functional magnetic resonance imaging in macaque monkeys, that amplitudes in oscillator models play an important role in describing neural dynamics in anaesthetised brain states.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Network constraints in scale free dynamical systems
Authors:
Erik D. Fagerholm,
W. M. C. Foulkes,
Yasir Gallero-Salas,
Fritjof Helmchen,
Karl J. Friston,
Robert Leech,
Rosalyn J. Moran
Abstract:
Scale free dynamics are observed in a variety of physical and biological systems. These include neural activity in which evidence for scale freeness has been reported using a range of imaging modalities. Here, we derive the ways in which connections within a network must transform - relative to system size - in order to maintain scale freeness and test these theoretical transformations via simulat…
▽ More
Scale free dynamics are observed in a variety of physical and biological systems. These include neural activity in which evidence for scale freeness has been reported using a range of imaging modalities. Here, we derive the ways in which connections within a network must transform - relative to system size - in order to maintain scale freeness and test these theoretical transformations via simulations. First, we explore the known invariance of planetary motion for orbits varying in size. Using parametric empirical Bayesian modelling and a generic dynamical systems model, we show that we recover Kepler's third law from orbital timeseries, using our proposed transformations; thereby providing construct validation. We then demonstrate that the dynamical critical exponent is inversely proportional to the time rescaling exponent, in the context of coarse graining operations. Using murine calcium imaging data, we then show that the dynamical critical exponent can be estimated in an empirical biological setting. Specifically, we compare dynamical critical exponents - associated with spontaneous and task states in two regions of imaged cortex - that are classified as task-relevant and task-irrelevant. We find, consistently across animals, that the task-irrelevant region exhibits higher dynamical critical exponents during spontaneous activity than during task performance. Conversely, the task-relevant region is associated with higher dynamical critical exponents in task vs. spontaneous states. These data support the idea that higher dynamical critical exponents, within relevant cortical structures, underwrite neuronal processing due to the implicit increase in cross-scale information transmission.
△ Less
Submitted 19 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Breaking the bonds of weak coupling: the dynamic causal modelling of oscillator amplitudes
Authors:
Erik D. Fagerholm,
Rosalyn J. Moran,
Inês R. Violante,
Robert Leech,
Karl J. Friston
Abstract:
Models of coupled oscillators are useful in describing a wide variety of phenomena in physics, biology and economics. These models typically rest on the premise that the oscillators are weakly coupled, meaning that amplitudes can be assumed to be constant and dynamics can therefore be described purely in terms of phase differences. Whilst mathematically convenient, the restrictive nature of the we…
▽ More
Models of coupled oscillators are useful in describing a wide variety of phenomena in physics, biology and economics. These models typically rest on the premise that the oscillators are weakly coupled, meaning that amplitudes can be assumed to be constant and dynamics can therefore be described purely in terms of phase differences. Whilst mathematically convenient, the restrictive nature of the weak coupling assumption can limit the explanatory power of these phase-coupled oscillator models. We therefore propose an extension to the weakly-coupled oscillator model that incorporates both amplitude and phase as dependent variables. We use the bilinear neuronal state equations of dynamic causal modelling as a foundation in deriving coupled differential equations that describe the activity of both weakly and strongly coupled oscillators. We show that weakly-coupled oscillator models are inadequate in describing the processes underlying the temporally variable signals observed in a variety of systems. We demonstrate that phase-coupled models perform well on simulations of weakly coupled systems but fail when connectivity is no longer weak. On the other hand, using Bayesian model selection, we show that our phase-amplitude coupling model can describe non-weakly coupled systems more effectively despite the added complexity associated with using amplitude as an extra dependent variable. We demonstrate the advantage of our phase-amplitude model in the context of model-generated data, as well as of a simulation of inter-connected pendula, neural local field potential recordings in rodents under anaesthesia and international economic gross domestic product data.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
