-
Bridging the gap between the micro- and the macro-world of tumors
Authors:
Roberto Chignola,
Edoardo Milotti
Abstract:
At present it is still quite difficult to match the vast knowledge on the behavior of individual tumor cells with macroscopic measurements on clinical tumors. On the modeling side, we already know how to deal with many molecular pathways and cellular events, using systems of differential equations and other modeling tools, and ideally, we should be able to extend such a mathematical description up…
▽ More
At present it is still quite difficult to match the vast knowledge on the behavior of individual tumor cells with macroscopic measurements on clinical tumors. On the modeling side, we already know how to deal with many molecular pathways and cellular events, using systems of differential equations and other modeling tools, and ideally, we should be able to extend such a mathematical description up to the level of large tumor masses. An extended model should thus help us forecast the behavior of large tumors from our basic knowledge of microscopic processes. Unfortunately, the complexity of these processes makes it very difficult -- probably impossible -- to develop comprehensive analytical models. We try to bridge the gap with a simulation program which is based on basic biochemical and biophysical processes -- thereby building an effective computational model -- and in this paper we describe its structure, endeavoring to make the description sufficiently detailed and yet understandable.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2012;
originally announced January 2012.
-
Computational challenges of tumor spheroid modeling
Authors:
Roberto Chignola,
Alessio Del Fabbro,
Marcello Farina,
Edoardo Milotti
Abstract:
The speed and the versatility of today's computers open up new opportunities to simulate complex biological systems. Here we review a computational approach recently proposed by us to model large tumor cell populations and spheroids, and we put forward general considerations that apply to any fine-grained numerical model of tumors. We discuss ways to bypass computational limitations and discuss ou…
▽ More
The speed and the versatility of today's computers open up new opportunities to simulate complex biological systems. Here we review a computational approach recently proposed by us to model large tumor cell populations and spheroids, and we put forward general considerations that apply to any fine-grained numerical model of tumors. We discuss ways to bypass computational limitations and discuss our incremental approach, where each step is validated by experimental observations on a quantitative basis. We present a few results on the growth of tumor cells in closed and open environments and of tumor spheroids. This study suggests new ways to explore the initial growth phase of solid tumors and to optimize anti-tumor treatments.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2010;
originally announced December 2010.
-
Emergent Properties of Tumor Microenvironment in a Real-life Model of Multicell Tumor Spheroids
Authors:
Edoardo Milotti,
Roberto Chignola
Abstract:
Multicellular tumor spheroids are an important {\it in vitro} model of the pre-vascular phase of solid tumors, for sizes well below the diagnostic limit: therefore a biophysical model of spheroids has the ability to shed light on the internal workings and organization of tumors at a critical phase of their development. To this end, we have developed a computer program that integrates the behavior…
▽ More
Multicellular tumor spheroids are an important {\it in vitro} model of the pre-vascular phase of solid tumors, for sizes well below the diagnostic limit: therefore a biophysical model of spheroids has the ability to shed light on the internal workings and organization of tumors at a critical phase of their development. To this end, we have developed a computer program that integrates the behavior of individual cells and their interactions with other cells and the surrounding environment. It is based on a quantitative description of metabolism, growth, proliferation and death of single tumor cells, and on equations that model biochemical and mechanical cell-cell and cell-environment interactions. The program reproduces existing experimental data on spheroids, and yields unique views of their microenvironment. Simulations show complex internal flows and motions of nutrients, metabolites and cells, that are otherwise unobservable with current experimental techniques, and give novel clues on tumor development and strong hints for future therapies.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2010;
originally announced October 2010.
-
Ab initio computational modeling of tumor spheroids
Authors:
Roberto Chignola,
Alessio Del Fabbro,
Marcello Farina,
Edoardo Milotti
Abstract:
This paper is a review of the VBL project, where we develop and test a numerical simulator of tumor spheroids.
This paper is a review of the VBL project, where we develop and test a numerical simulator of tumor spheroids.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2009;
originally announced November 2009.
-
Dynamics of intracellular Ca$^{2+}$ oscillations in the presence of multisite Ca$^{2+}$-binding proteins
Authors:
Roberto Chignola,
Alessio Del Fabbro,
Edoardo Milotti
Abstract:
We study the dynamics of intracellular calcium oscillations in the presence of proteins that bind calcium on multiple sites and that are generally believed to act as passive calcium buffers in cells. We find that multisite calcium-binding proteins set a sharp threshold for calcium oscillations. Even with high concentrations of calcium-binding proteins, internal noise, which shows up spontaneousl…
▽ More
We study the dynamics of intracellular calcium oscillations in the presence of proteins that bind calcium on multiple sites and that are generally believed to act as passive calcium buffers in cells. We find that multisite calcium-binding proteins set a sharp threshold for calcium oscillations. Even with high concentrations of calcium-binding proteins, internal noise, which shows up spontaneously in cells in the process of calcium wave formation, can lead to self-oscillations. This produces oscillatory behaviors strikingly similar to those observed in real cells. In addition, for given intracellular concentrations of both calcium and calcium-binding proteins the regularity of these oscillations changes and reaches a maximum as a function noise variance, and the overall system dynamics displays stochastic coherence. We conclude that calcium-binding proteins may have an important and active role in cellular communication.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2009;
originally announced September 2009.
-
Balance between cell survival and death: a minimal quantitative model of tumor necrosis factor alpha cytotoxicity
Authors:
Roberto Chignola,
Marcello Farina,
Alessio Del Fabbro,
Edoardo Milotti
Abstract:
Tumor Necrosis Factor alpha (TNF) initiates a complex series of biochemical events in the cell upon binding to its type R1 receptor (TNF-R1). Recent experimental work has unravelled the molecular regulation of the recruitment of initial signaling complexes that lead either to cell survival or death. Survival signals are activated by direct binding of TNF to TNF-R1 at the cell membrane whereas ap…
▽ More
Tumor Necrosis Factor alpha (TNF) initiates a complex series of biochemical events in the cell upon binding to its type R1 receptor (TNF-R1). Recent experimental work has unravelled the molecular regulation of the recruitment of initial signaling complexes that lead either to cell survival or death. Survival signals are activated by direct binding of TNF to TNF-R1 at the cell membrane whereas apoptotic signals by endocytosed TNF/TNF-R1 complexes. Here we investigate these aspects by developing a quantitative mathematical model of TNF binding, internalization and intracellular signaling. Model outputs compare favorably with experimental data and allow to compute TNF-mediated cytotoxicity as observed in different cell systems. We extensively study the space of parameters to show that the model is structurally stable and robust over a broad range of parameter values. Thus, our model is suitable for implementation in multi-scale simulation programs that are presently under development to study the behavior of large tumor cell populations.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2009; v1 submitted 27 May, 2009;
originally announced May 2009.
-
A quantitative study on the growth variability of tumour cell clones in vitro
Authors:
C. Tomelleri,
E. Milotti,
C. Dalla Pellegrina,
O. Perbellini,
A. Del Fabbro,
M. T. Scupoli,
R. Chignola
Abstract:
Objectives: In this study, we quantify the growth variability of tumour cell clones from a human leukemia cell line. Materials and methods: We have used microplate spectrophotometry to measure the growth kinetics of hundreds of individual cell clones from the Molt3 cell line. The growth rate of each clonal population has been estimated by fitting experimental data with the logistic equation. Res…
▽ More
Objectives: In this study, we quantify the growth variability of tumour cell clones from a human leukemia cell line. Materials and methods: We have used microplate spectrophotometry to measure the growth kinetics of hundreds of individual cell clones from the Molt3 cell line. The growth rate of each clonal population has been estimated by fitting experimental data with the logistic equation. Results: The growth rates were observed to vary among different clones. Up to six clones with a growth rate above or below the mean growth rate of the parent population were further cloned and the growth rates of their offsprings were measured. The distribution of the growth rates of the subclones did not significantly differ from that of the parent population thus suggesting that growth variability has an epigenetic origin. To explain the observed distributions of clonal growth rates we have developed a probabilistic model assuming that the fluctuations in the number of mitochondria through successive cell cycles are the leading cause of growth variability. For fitting purposes, we have estimated experimentally by flow cytometry the maximum average number of mitochondria in Molt3 cells. The model fits nicely the observed distributions of growth rates, however, cells in which the mitochondria were rendered non functional (rho-0 cells) showed only a 30% reduction in the clonal growth variability with respect to normal cells. Conclusions: A tumor cell population is a dynamic ensemble of clones with highly variable growth rate. At least part of this variability is due to fluctuations in the number of mitochondria.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2007;
originally announced April 2007.
-
Ab initio phenomenological simulation of the growth of large tumor cell populations
Authors:
Roberto Chignola,
Alessio Del Fabbro,
Chiara Dalla Pellegrina,
Edoardo Milotti
Abstract:
In a previous paper we have introduced a phenomenological model of cell metabolism and of the cell cycle to simulate the behavior of large tumor cell populations (Chignola R and Milotti E, Phys. Biol. 2 (2005) 8-22). Here we describe a refined and extended version of the model that includes some of the complex interactions between cells and their surrounding environment. The present version take…
▽ More
In a previous paper we have introduced a phenomenological model of cell metabolism and of the cell cycle to simulate the behavior of large tumor cell populations (Chignola R and Milotti E, Phys. Biol. 2 (2005) 8-22). Here we describe a refined and extended version of the model that includes some of the complex interactions between cells and their surrounding environment. The present version takes into consideration several additional energy-consuming biochemical pathways such as protein and DNA synthesis, the tuning of extracellular pH and of the cell membrane potential. The control of the cell cycle - that was previously modeled by means of ad hoc thresholds - has been directly addressed here by considering checkpoints from proteins that act as targets for phosphorylation on multiple sites. As simulated cells grow, they can now modify the chemical composition of the surrounding environment which in turn acts as a feedback mechanism to tune cell metabolism and hence cell proliferation: in this way we obtain growth curves that match quite well those observed in vitro with human leukemia cell lines. The model is strongly constrained and returns results that can be directly compared with actual experiments, because it uses parameter values in narrow ranges estimated from experimental data, and in perspective we hope to utilize it to develop in silico studies of the growth of very large tumor cell populations (10^6 cells or more) and to support experimental research. In particular, the program is used here to make predictions on the behaviour of cells grown in a glucose-poor medium: these predictions are confirmed by experimental observation.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2007;
originally announced March 2007.
-
Dynamical hysteresis in multisite protein modification
Authors:
Edoardo Milotti,
Alessio Del Fabbro,
Chiara Dalla Pellegrina,
Roberto Chignola
Abstract:
Multisite protein modification is a ubiquitous mechanism utilized by cells to control protein functions. We have recently proposed a dynamical description of multisite protein modification which embodies all the essential features of the process (E. Milotti, A. Del Fabbro, C. Dalla Pellegrina, and R. Chignola, Physica A, in press), and we have used this model to analyze the stability and the tim…
▽ More
Multisite protein modification is a ubiquitous mechanism utilized by cells to control protein functions. We have recently proposed a dynamical description of multisite protein modification which embodies all the essential features of the process (E. Milotti, A. Del Fabbro, C. Dalla Pellegrina, and R. Chignola, Physica A, in press), and we have used this model to analyze the stability and the time-scales of this mechanism. The same model can be used to understand how the system responds to stimuli: here we show that it displays frequency-dependent dynamical hysteresis. This behavior closely parallels -- with the due differences -- what is observed in magnetic systems. By selecting model parameters that span the known biological ranges, we find that the frequency-dependent features cover the band of the observed oscillations of molecular intracellular signals, and this suggests that this mechanism may have an important role in cellular information processing.
△ Less
Submitted 12 February, 2007;
originally announced February 2007.
-
Dynamics of allosteric action in multisite protein modification
Authors:
Edoardo Milotti,
Alessio Del Fabbro,
Chiara Dalla Pellegrina,
Roberto Chignola
Abstract:
Protein functions in cells may be activated or modified by the attachment of several kinds of chemical groups. While protein phosphorylation, i.e. the attachment of a phosphoryl (PO$_3^-$) group, is the most studied form of protein modification, and is known to regulate the functions of many proteins, protein behavior can also be modified by nitrosylation, acetylation, methylation, etc. A protei…
▽ More
Protein functions in cells may be activated or modified by the attachment of several kinds of chemical groups. While protein phosphorylation, i.e. the attachment of a phosphoryl (PO$_3^-$) group, is the most studied form of protein modification, and is known to regulate the functions of many proteins, protein behavior can also be modified by nitrosylation, acetylation, methylation, etc. A protein can have multiple modification sites, and display some form of transition only when enough sites are modified. In a previous paper we have modeled the generic equilibrium properties of multisite protein modification (R.Chignola, C. Dalla Pellegrina, A. Del Fabbro, E.Milotti, Physica A {\bf 371}, 463 (2006)) and we have shown that it can account both for sharp, robust thresholds and for information transfer between processes with widely separated timescales. Here we use the same concepts to expand that analysis starting from a dynamical description of multisite modification: we give analytical results for the basic dynamics and numerical results in an example where the modification chain is cascaded with a Michaelis-Menten step. We modify the dynamics and analyze an example with realistic phosphorylation/dephosphorylation steps, and give numerical evidence of the independence of the allosteric effect from the details of the attachment-detachment processes. We conclude that multisite protein modification is dynamically equivalent to the classic allosteric effect.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2006; v1 submitted 26 September, 2006;
originally announced September 2006.
-
Thresholds, long delays and stability from generalized allosteric effect in protein networks
Authors:
Roberto Chignola,
Chiara Dalla Pellegrina,
Alessio Del Fabbro,
Edoardo Milotti
Abstract:
Post-transductional modifications tune the functions of proteins and regulate the collective dynamics of biochemical networks that determine how cells respond to environmental signals. For example, protein phosphorylation and nitrosylation are well-known to play a pivotal role in the intracellular transduction of activation and death signals. A protein can have multiple sites where chemical grou…
▽ More
Post-transductional modifications tune the functions of proteins and regulate the collective dynamics of biochemical networks that determine how cells respond to environmental signals. For example, protein phosphorylation and nitrosylation are well-known to play a pivotal role in the intracellular transduction of activation and death signals. A protein can have multiple sites where chemical groups can reversibly attach in processes such as phosphorylation or nitrosylation. A microscopic description of these processes must take into account the intrinsic probabilistic nature of the underlying reactions. We apply combinatorial considerations to standard enzyme kinetics and in this way we extend to the dynamic regime a simplified version of the traditional models on the allosteric regulation of protein functions. We link a generic modification chain to a downstream Michaelis-Menten enzymatic reaction and we demonstrate numerically that this accounts both for thresholds and long time delays in the conversion of the substrate by the enzyme. The proposed mechanism is stable and robust and the higher the number of modification sites, the greater the stability. We show that a high number of modification sites converts a fast reaction into a slow process, and the slowing down depends on the number of sites and may span many orders of magnitude; in this way multisite modification of proteins stands out as a general mechanism that allows the transfer of information from the very short time scales of enzyme reactions (milliseconds) to the long time scale of cell response (hours).
△ Less
Submitted 26 January, 2006;
originally announced January 2006.
