-
Virtual Lung Screening Trial (VLST): An In Silico Study Inspired by the National Lung Screening Trial for Lung Cancer Detection
Authors:
Fakrul Islam Tushar,
Liesbeth Vancoillie,
Cindy McCabe,
Amareswararao Kavuri,
Lavsen Dahal,
Brian Harrawood,
Milo Fryling,
Mojtaba Zarei,
Saman Sotoudeh-Paima,
Fong Chi Ho,
Dhrubajyoti Ghosh,
Michael R. Harowicz,
Tina D. Tailor,
Sheng Luo,
W. Paul Segars,
Ehsan Abadi,
Kyle J. Lafata,
Joseph Y. Lo,
Ehsan Samei
Abstract:
Clinical imaging trials play a crucial role in advancing medical innovation but are often costly, inefficient, and ethically constrained. Virtual Imaging Trials (VITs) present a solution by simulating clinical trial components in a controlled, risk-free environment. The Virtual Lung Screening Trial (VLST), an in silico study inspired by the National Lung Screening Trial (NLST), illustrates the pot…
▽ More
Clinical imaging trials play a crucial role in advancing medical innovation but are often costly, inefficient, and ethically constrained. Virtual Imaging Trials (VITs) present a solution by simulating clinical trial components in a controlled, risk-free environment. The Virtual Lung Screening Trial (VLST), an in silico study inspired by the National Lung Screening Trial (NLST), illustrates the potential of VITs to expedite clinical trials, minimize risks to participants, and promote optimal use of imaging technologies in healthcare. This study aimed to show that a virtual imaging trial platform could investigate some key elements of a major clinical trial, specifically the NLST, which compared Computed tomography (CT) and chest radiography (CXR) for lung cancer screening. With simulated cancerous lung nodules, a virtual patient cohort of 294 subjects was created using XCAT human models. Each virtual patient underwent both CT and CXR imaging, with deep learning models, the AI CT-Reader and AI CXR-Reader, acting as virtual readers to perform recall patients with suspicion of lung cancer. The primary outcome was the difference in diagnostic performance between CT and CXR, measured by the Area Under the Curve (AUC). The AI CT-Reader showed superior diagnostic accuracy, achieving an AUC of 0.92 (95% CI: 0.90-0.95) compared to the AI CXR-Reader's AUC of 0.72 (95% CI: 0.67-0.77). Furthermore, at the same 94% CT sensitivity reported by the NLST, the VLST specificity of 73% was similar to the NLST specificity of 73.4%. This CT performance highlights the potential of VITs to replicate certain aspects of clinical trials effectively, paving the way toward a safe and efficient method for advancing imaging-based diagnostics.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2025; v1 submitted 17 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
A personalized Uncertainty Quantification framework for patient survival models: estimating individual uncertainty of patients with metastatic brain tumors in the absence of ground truth
Authors:
Yuqi Wang,
Aarzu Gupta,
David Carpenter,
Trey Mullikin,
Zachary J. Reitman,
Scott Floyd,
John Kirkpatrick,
Joseph K. Salama,
Paul W. Sperduto,
Jian-Guo Liu,
Mustafa R. Bashir,
Kyle J. Lafata
Abstract:
TodevelopanovelUncertaintyQuantification (UQ) framework to estimate the uncertainty of patient survival models in the absence of ground truth, we developed and evaluated our approach based on a dataset of 1383 patients treated with stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) for brain metastases between January 2015 and December 2020. Our motivating hypothesis is that a time-to-event prediction of a test pati…
▽ More
TodevelopanovelUncertaintyQuantification (UQ) framework to estimate the uncertainty of patient survival models in the absence of ground truth, we developed and evaluated our approach based on a dataset of 1383 patients treated with stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) for brain metastases between January 2015 and December 2020. Our motivating hypothesis is that a time-to-event prediction of a test patient on inference is more certain given a higher feature-space-similarity to patients in the training set. Therefore, the uncertainty for a particular patient-of-interest is represented by the concordance index between a patient similarity rank and a prediction similarity rank. Model uncertainty was defined as the increased percentage of the max uncertainty-constrained-AUC compared to the model AUC. We evaluated our method on multiple clinically-relevant endpoints, including time to intracranial progression (ICP), progression-free survival (PFS) after SRS, overall survival (OS), and time to ICP and/or death (ICPD), on a variety of both statistical and non-statistical models, including CoxPH, conditional survival forest (CSF), and neural multi-task linear regression (NMTLR). Our results show that all models had the lowest uncertainty on ICP (2.21%) and the highest uncertainty (17.28%) on ICPD. OS models demonstrated high variation in uncertainty performance, where NMTLR had the lowest uncertainty(1.96%)and CSF had the highest uncertainty (14.29%). In conclusion, our method can estimate the uncertainty of individual patient survival modeling results. As expected, our data empirically demonstrate that as model uncertainty measured via our technique increases, the similarity between a feature-space and its predicted outcome decreases.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Quantifying U-Net Uncertainty in Multi-Parametric MRI-based Glioma Segmentation by Spherical Image Projection
Authors:
Zhenyu Yang,
Kyle Lafata,
Eugene Vaios,
Zongsheng Hu,
Trey Mullikin,
Fang-Fang Yin,
Chunhao Wang
Abstract:
The projection of planar MRI data onto a spherical surface is equivalent to a nonlinear image transformation that retains global anatomical information. By incorporating this image transformation process in our proposed spherical projection-based U-Net (SPU-Net) segmentation model design, multiple independent segmentation predictions can be obtained from a single MRI. The final segmentation is the…
▽ More
The projection of planar MRI data onto a spherical surface is equivalent to a nonlinear image transformation that retains global anatomical information. By incorporating this image transformation process in our proposed spherical projection-based U-Net (SPU-Net) segmentation model design, multiple independent segmentation predictions can be obtained from a single MRI. The final segmentation is the average of all available results, and the variation can be visualized as a pixel-wise uncertainty map. An uncertainty score was introduced to evaluate and compare the performance of uncertainty measurements. The proposed SPU-Net model was implemented on the basis of 369 glioma patients with MP-MRI scans (T1, T1-Ce, T2, and FLAIR). Three SPU-Net models were trained to segment enhancing tumor (ET), tumor core (TC), and whole tumor (WT), respectively. The SPU-Net model was compared with (1) the classic U-Net model with test-time augmentation (TTA) and (2) linear scaling-based U-Net (LSU-Net) segmentation models in terms of both segmentation accuracy (Dice coefficient, sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy) and segmentation uncertainty (uncertainty map and uncertainty score). The developed SPU-Net model successfully achieved low uncertainty for correct segmentation predictions (e.g., tumor interior or healthy tissue interior) and high uncertainty for incorrect results (e.g., tumor boundaries). This model could allow the identification of missed tumor targets or segmentation errors in U-Net. Quantitatively, the SPU-Net model achieved the highest uncertainty scores for three segmentation targets (ET/TC/WT): 0.826/0.848/0.936, compared to 0.784/0.643/0.872 using the U-Net with TTA and 0.743/0.702/0.876 with the LSU-Net (scaling factor = 2). The SPU-Net also achieved statistically significantly higher Dice coefficients, underscoring the improved segmentation accuracy.
△ Less
Submitted 12 August, 2023; v1 submitted 12 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
A Neural Ordinary Differential Equation Model for Visualizing Deep Neural Network Behaviors in Multi-Parametric MRI based Glioma Segmentation
Authors:
Zhenyu Yang,
Zongsheng Hu,
Hangjie Ji,
Kyle Lafata,
Scott Floyd,
Fang-Fang Yin,
Chunhao Wang
Abstract:
Purpose: To develop a neural ordinary differential equation (ODE) model for visualizing deep neural network (DNN) behavior during multi-parametric MRI (mp-MRI) based glioma segmentation as a method to enhance deep learning explainability. Methods: By hypothesizing that deep feature extraction can be modeled as a spatiotemporally continuous process, we designed a novel deep learning model, neural O…
▽ More
Purpose: To develop a neural ordinary differential equation (ODE) model for visualizing deep neural network (DNN) behavior during multi-parametric MRI (mp-MRI) based glioma segmentation as a method to enhance deep learning explainability. Methods: By hypothesizing that deep feature extraction can be modeled as a spatiotemporally continuous process, we designed a novel deep learning model, neural ODE, in which deep feature extraction was governed by an ODE without explicit expression. The dynamics of 1) MR images after interactions with DNN and 2) segmentation formation can be visualized after solving ODE. An accumulative contribution curve (ACC) was designed to quantitatively evaluate the utilization of each MRI by DNN towards the final segmentation results. The proposed neural ODE model was demonstrated using 369 glioma patients with a 4-modality mp-MRI protocol: T1, contrast-enhanced T1 (T1-Ce), T2, and FLAIR. Three neural ODE models were trained to segment enhancing tumor (ET), tumor core (TC), and whole tumor (WT). The key MR modalities with significant utilization by DNN were identified based on ACC analysis. Segmentation results by DNN using only the key MR modalities were compared to the ones using all 4 MR modalities. Results: All neural ODE models successfully illustrated image dynamics as expected. ACC analysis identified T1-Ce as the only key modality in ET and TC segmentations, while both FLAIR and T2 were key modalities in WT segmentation. Compared to the U-Net results using all 4 MR modalities, Dice coefficient of ET (0.784->0.775), TC (0.760->0.758), and WT (0.841->0.837) using the key modalities only had minimal differences without significance. Conclusion: The neural ODE model offers a new tool for optimizing the deep learning model inputs with enhanced explainability. The presented methodology can be generalized to other medical image-related deep learning applications.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2022; v1 submitted 1 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
