Showing 1–50 of 54 results for author: Holme, P

The nature of epidemic criticality in temporal networks

Authors: Chao-Ran Cai, Yuan-Yuan Nie, Petter Holme

Abstract: Analytical studies of network epidemiology almost exclusively focus on the extreme situations where the time scales of network dynamics are well separated (longer or shorter) from that of epidemic propagation. In realistic scenarios, however, these time scales could be similar, which has profound implications for epidemic modeling (e.g., one can no longer reduce the dimensionality of epidemic mode… ▽ More Analytical studies of network epidemiology almost exclusively focus on the extreme situations where the time scales of network dynamics are well separated (longer or shorter) from that of epidemic propagation. In realistic scenarios, however, these time scales could be similar, which has profound implications for epidemic modeling (e.g., one can no longer reduce the dimensionality of epidemic models). We build a theory for the critical behavior of susceptible-infected-susceptible (SIS) epidemics in the vicinity of the critical threshold on the activity-driven model of temporal networks. We find that the persistence of links in the network leads to increasing recovery rates reducing the threshold. Dynamic correlations (coming from being close to infected nodes increases the likelihood of infection) drive the threshold in the opposite direction. These two counteracting effects make epidemic criticality in temporal networks a remarkably complex phenomenon. △ Less

Submitted 20 November, 2023; originally announced November 2023.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Res. 6, L022017 (2024)

Social physics

Authors: Marko Jusup, Petter Holme, Kiyoshi Kanazawa, Misako Takayasu, Ivan Romic, Zhen Wang, Suncana Gecek, Tomislav Lipic, Boris Podobnik, Lin Wang, Wei Luo, Tin Klanjscek, Jingfang Fan, Stefano Boccaletti, Matjaz Perc

Abstract: Recent decades have seen a rise in the use of physics methods to study different societal phenomena. This development has been due to physicists venturing outside of their traditional domains of interest, but also due to scientists from other disciplines taking from physics the methods that have proven so successful throughout the 19th and the 20th century. Here we dub this field 'social physics'… ▽ More Recent decades have seen a rise in the use of physics methods to study different societal phenomena. This development has been due to physicists venturing outside of their traditional domains of interest, but also due to scientists from other disciplines taking from physics the methods that have proven so successful throughout the 19th and the 20th century. Here we dub this field 'social physics' and pay our respect to intellectual mavericks who nurtured it to maturity. We do so by reviewing the current state of the art. Starting with a set of topics that are at the heart of modern human societies, we review research dedicated to urban development and traffic, the functioning of financial markets, cooperation as the basis for our evolutionary success, the structure of social networks, and the integration of intelligent machines into these networks. We then shift our attention to a set of topics that explore potential threats to society. These include criminal behaviour, large-scale migrations, epidemics, environmental challenges, and climate change. We end the coverage of each topic with promising directions for future research. Based on this, we conclude that the future for social physics is bright. Physicists studying societal phenomena are no longer a curiosity, but rather a force to be reckoned with. Notwithstanding, it remains of the utmost importance that we continue to foster constructive dialogue and mutual respect at the interfaces of different scientific disciplines. △ Less

Submitted 11 January, 2022; v1 submitted 5 October, 2021; originally announced October 2021.

Comments: 359 pages, 78 figures; published in Physics Reports

Journal ref: Phys. Rep. 948, 1-148 (2022)

Networks of climate change: Connecting causes and consequences

Authors: Petter Holme, Juan C. Rocha

Abstract: Understanding the causes and consequences of, and devising countermeasures to, global warming is a profoundly complex problem. Network representations are sometimes the only way forward, and sometimes able to reduce the complexity of the original problem. Networks are both necessary and natural elements of climate science. Furthermore, networks form a mathematical foundation for a multitude of com… ▽ More Understanding the causes and consequences of, and devising countermeasures to, global warming is a profoundly complex problem. Network representations are sometimes the only way forward, and sometimes able to reduce the complexity of the original problem. Networks are both necessary and natural elements of climate science. Furthermore, networks form a mathematical foundation for a multitude of computational and analytical techniques. We are only beginning to see the benefits of this connection between the sciences of climate change and network science. In this review, we cover the wide spectrum of network applications in the climate-change literature -- what they represent, how they are analyzed, and what insights they bring. We also discuss network data, tools, and problems yet to be explored. △ Less

Submitted 27 May, 2022; v1 submitted 20 May, 2021; originally announced May 2021.

Multistage onset of epidemics in heterogeneous networks

Authors: Chao-Ran Cai, Zhi-Xi Wu, Petter Holme

Abstract: We develop a theory for the susceptible-infected-susceptible (SIS) epidemic model on networks that incorporate both network structure and dynamic correlations. This theory can account for the multistage onset of the epidemic phase in scale-free networks. This phenomenon is characterized by multiple peaks in the susceptibility as a function of the infection rate. It can be explained by that, even u… ▽ More We develop a theory for the susceptible-infected-susceptible (SIS) epidemic model on networks that incorporate both network structure and dynamic correlations. This theory can account for the multistage onset of the epidemic phase in scale-free networks. This phenomenon is characterized by multiple peaks in the susceptibility as a function of the infection rate. It can be explained by that, even under the global epidemic threshold, a hub can sustain the epidemics for an extended period. Moreover, our approach improves theoretical calculations of prevalence close to the threshold in heterogeneous networks and also can predict the average risk of infection for neighbors of nodes with different degree and state on uncorrelated static networks. △ Less

Submitted 10 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Building surrogate temporal network data from observed backbones

Authors: Charley Presigny, Petter Holme, Alain Barrat

Abstract: In many data sets, crucial elements co-exist with non-essential ones and noise. For data represented as networks in particular, several methods have been proposed to extract a "network backbone", i.e., the set of most important links. However, the question of how the resulting compressed views of the data can effectively be used has not been tackled. Here we address this issue by putting forward a… ▽ More In many data sets, crucial elements co-exist with non-essential ones and noise. For data represented as networks in particular, several methods have been proposed to extract a "network backbone", i.e., the set of most important links. However, the question of how the resulting compressed views of the data can effectively be used has not been tackled. Here we address this issue by putting forward and exploring several systematic procedures to build surrogate data from various kinds of temporal network backbones. In particular, we explore how much information about the original data need to be retained alongside the backbone so that the surrogate data can be used in data-driven numerical simulations of spreading processes. We illustrate our results using empirical temporal networks with a broad variety of structures and properties. △ Less

Submitted 6 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 103, 052304 (2021)

Exit rights open complex pathways to cooperation

Authors: Chen Shen, Marko Jusup, Lei Shi, Zhen Wang, Matjaz Perc, Petter Holme

Abstract: We study the evolutionary dynamics of the prisoner's dilemma game in which cooperators and defectors interact with another actor type called exiters. Rather than being exploited by defectors, exiters exit the game in favour of a small payoff. We find that this simple extension of the game allows cooperation to flourish in well-mixed populations when iterations or reputation are added. In networked… ▽ More We study the evolutionary dynamics of the prisoner's dilemma game in which cooperators and defectors interact with another actor type called exiters. Rather than being exploited by defectors, exiters exit the game in favour of a small payoff. We find that this simple extension of the game allows cooperation to flourish in well-mixed populations when iterations or reputation are added. In networked populations, however, the exit option is less conducive to cooperation. Instead, it enables the coexistence of cooperators, defectors, and exiters through cyclic dominance. Other outcomes are also possible as the exit payoff increases or the network structure changes, including network-wide oscillations in actor abundances that may cause the extinction of exiters and the domination of defectors, although game parameters should favour exiting. The complex dynamics that emerges in the wake of a simple option to exit the game implies that nuances matter even if our analyses are restricted to incentives for rational behaviour. △ Less

Submitted 6 December, 2020; v1 submitted 30 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Journal ref: J. R. Soc. Interface 18, 20200777 (2021)

Flexible imitation suppresses epidemics through better vaccination

Authors: Soya Miyoshi, Marko Jusup, Petter Holme

Abstract: The decision of whether or not to vaccinate is a complex one. It involves the contribution both to a social good -- herd immunity -- and to one's own well being. It is informed by social influence, personal experience, education, and mass media. In our work, we investigate a situation in which individuals make their choice based on how social neighbourhood responded to previous epidemics. We do th… ▽ More The decision of whether or not to vaccinate is a complex one. It involves the contribution both to a social good -- herd immunity -- and to one's own well being. It is informed by social influence, personal experience, education, and mass media. In our work, we investigate a situation in which individuals make their choice based on how social neighbourhood responded to previous epidemics. We do this by proposing a minimalistic model using components from game theory, network theory and the modelling of epidemic spreading, and opinion dynamics. Individuals can use the information about the neighbourhood in two ways -- either they follow the majority or the best-performing neighbour. Furthermore, we let individuals learn which of these two decision-making strategies to follow from their experience. Our results show that the flexibility of individuals to chose how to integrate information from the neighbourhood increases the vaccine uptake and decreases the epidemic severity if the following conditions are fulfilled. First, the initial fraction of individuals who imitate the neighbourhood majority should be limited, and second, the memory of previous outbreaks should be sufficiently long. These results have implications for the acceptance of novel vaccines and raising awareness about vaccination, while also pointing to promising future research directions. △ Less

Submitted 12 October, 2020; v1 submitted 1 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Journal ref: J. Comp. Soc. Sci 4, 709-720 (2021)

Fast and principled simulations of the SIR model on temporal networks

Authors: Petter Holme

Abstract: The Susceptible-Infectious-Recovered (SIR) model is the canonical model of epidemics of infections that make people immune upon recovery. Many of the open questions in computational epidemiology concern the underlying contact structure's impact on models like the SIR model. Temporal networks constitute a theoretical framework capable of encoding structures both in the networks of who could infect… ▽ More The Susceptible-Infectious-Recovered (SIR) model is the canonical model of epidemics of infections that make people immune upon recovery. Many of the open questions in computational epidemiology concern the underlying contact structure's impact on models like the SIR model. Temporal networks constitute a theoretical framework capable of encoding structures both in the networks of who could infect whom and when these contacts happen. In this article, we discuss the detailed assumptions behind such simulations -- how to make them comparable with analytically tractable formulations of the SIR model, and at the same time, as realistic as possible. We also present a highly optimized, open-source code for this purpose and discuss all steps needed to make the program as fast as possible. △ Less

Submitted 2 October, 2020; v1 submitted 28 July, 2020; originally announced July 2020.

Small inter-event times govern epidemic spreading on temporal networks

Authors: Naoki Masuda, Petter Holme

Abstract: Just like the degrees of human and animal interaction networks, the distribution of the times between interactions is known to often be right-skewed and fat-tailed. Both these distributions affect epidemic dynamics strongly, but, as we show in this Letter, for very different reasons. Whereas the high degrees of the tail are critical for facilitating epidemics, it is the small interevent times that… ▽ More Just like the degrees of human and animal interaction networks, the distribution of the times between interactions is known to often be right-skewed and fat-tailed. Both these distributions affect epidemic dynamics strongly, but, as we show in this Letter, for very different reasons. Whereas the high degrees of the tail are critical for facilitating epidemics, it is the small interevent times that control the dynamics of epidemics. We investigate this effect both analytically and numerically for different versions of the Susceptible-Infected-Recovered model on different types of networks. △ Less

Submitted 9 April, 2020; v1 submitted 10 November, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Research 2, 023163 (2020)

Coupling the circadian rhythms of population movement and the immune system in infectious disease modeling

Authors: Zhanwei Du, Petter Holme

Abstract: The dynamics of infectious diseases propagating in populations depends both on human interaction patterns, the contagion process and the pathogenesis within hosts. The immune system follows a circadian rhythm and, consequently, the chance of getting infected varies with the time of day an individual is exposed to the pathogen. The movement and interaction of people also follow 24-hour cycles, whic… ▽ More The dynamics of infectious diseases propagating in populations depends both on human interaction patterns, the contagion process and the pathogenesis within hosts. The immune system follows a circadian rhythm and, consequently, the chance of getting infected varies with the time of day an individual is exposed to the pathogen. The movement and interaction of people also follow 24-hour cycles, which couples these two phenomena. We use a stochastic metapopulation model informed by hourly mobility data for two medium-sized Chinese cities. By this setup, we investigate how the epidemic risk depends on the difference of the clocks governing the population movement and the immune systems. In most of the scenarios we test, we observe circadian rhythms would constrain the pace and extent of disease emergence. The three measures (strength, outward transmission risk and introduction risk) are highly correlated with each other. For example of the Yushu City, outward transmission risk and introduction risk are correlated with a Pearson's correlation coefficient of 0.83, and the risks correlate to strength with coefficients of $-0.85$ and $-0.75$, respectively (all have $p<0.05$), in simulations with no circadian effect and $R_0=1.5$. The relation between the circadian rhythms of the immune system and daily routines in human mobility can affect the pace and extent of infectious disease spreading. Shifting commuting times could mitigate the emergence of outbreaks. △ Less

Submitted 12 October, 2019; originally announced October 2019.

Beyond ranking nodes: Predicting epidemic outbreak sizes by network centralities

Authors: Doina Bucur, Petter Holme

Abstract: Identifying important nodes for disease spreading is a central topic in network epidemiology. We investigate how well the position of a node, characterized by standard network measures, can predict its epidemiological importance in any graph of a given number of nodes. This is in contrast to other studies that deal with the easier prediction problem of ranking nodes by their epidemic importance in… ▽ More Identifying important nodes for disease spreading is a central topic in network epidemiology. We investigate how well the position of a node, characterized by standard network measures, can predict its epidemiological importance in any graph of a given number of nodes. This is in contrast to other studies that deal with the easier prediction problem of ranking nodes by their epidemic importance in given graphs. As a benchmark for epidemic importance, we calculate the exact expected outbreak size given a node as the source. We study exhaustively all graphs of a given size, so do not restrict ourselves to certain generative models for graphs, nor to graph data sets. Due to the large number of possible nonisomorphic graphs of a fixed size, we are limited to 10-node graphs. We find that combinations of two or more centralities are predictive ($R^2$ scores of 0.91 or higher) even for the most difficult parameter values of the epidemic simulation. Typically, these successful combinations include one normalized spectral centralities (such as PageRank or Katz centrality) and one measure that is sensitive to the number of edges in the graph. △ Less

Submitted 11 February, 2020; v1 submitted 22 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Journal ref: PLoS Comput. Biol. 16(7): e1008052 (2020)

Navigating temporal networks

Authors: Sang Hoon Lee, Petter Holme

Abstract: Navigation on graphs is the problem how an agent walking on the graph can get from a source to a target with limited information about the graph. The information and the way to exploit it can vary. In this paper, we study navigation on temporal networks -- networks where we have explicit information about the time of the interaction, not only who interacts with whom. We contrast a type of greedy n… ▽ More Navigation on graphs is the problem how an agent walking on the graph can get from a source to a target with limited information about the graph. The information and the way to exploit it can vary. In this paper, we study navigation on temporal networks -- networks where we have explicit information about the time of the interaction, not only who interacts with whom. We contrast a type of greedy navigation -- where agents follow paths that would have worked well in the past -- with two strategies that do not exploit the additional information. We test these on empirical temporal network data sets. The greedy navigation is indeed more efficient than the reference strategies, meaning that there are correlations in the real temporal networks that can be exploited. We find that the navigability for individual nodes is most strongly correlated with degree and burstiness, i.e., both topological and temporal structures affect the navigation efficiency. △ Less

Submitted 14 April, 2018; originally announced April 2018.

Objective measures for sentinel surveillance in network epidemiology

Authors: Petter Holme

Abstract: Assume one has the capability of determining whether a node in a network is infectious or not by probing them. Then problem of optimizing sentinel surveillance in networks is to identify the nodes to probe such that an emerging disease outbreak can be discovered early or reliably. Whether the emphasis should be on early or reliable detection depends on the scenario in question. We investigate thre… ▽ More Assume one has the capability of determining whether a node in a network is infectious or not by probing them. Then problem of optimizing sentinel surveillance in networks is to identify the nodes to probe such that an emerging disease outbreak can be discovered early or reliably. Whether the emphasis should be on early or reliable detection depends on the scenario in question. We investigate three objective measures from the literature quantifying the performance of nodes in sentinel surveillance -- the time to detection or extinction, the time to detection, and the frequency of detection. As a basis for the comparison, we use the susceptible-infectious-recovered model on static and temporal networks of human contacts. We show that, for some regions of parameter space, the three objective measures can rank the nodes very differently. This means sentinel surveillance is a class of problems, and solutions need to chose an objective measure for the particular scenario in question. As opposed to other problems in network epidemiology, we draw similar conclusions from the static and temporal networks. Furthermore, we do not find one type of network structure that predicts the objective measures -- that depends both on the data set and the SIR parameter values. △ Less

Submitted 23 May, 2018; v1 submitted 28 March, 2018; originally announced March 2018.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 98, 022313 (2018)

Epidemic extinction in networks: Insights from the 12,110 smallest graphs

Authors: Petter Holme, Liubov Tupikina

Abstract: We investigate the expected time to extinction in the susceptible-infectious-susceptible (SIS) model of disease spreading. Rather than using stochastic simulations, or asymptotic calculations in network models, we solve the extinction time exactly for all connected graphs with three to eight vertices. This approach enables us to discover descriptive relations that would be impossible with stochast… ▽ More We investigate the expected time to extinction in the susceptible-infectious-susceptible (SIS) model of disease spreading. Rather than using stochastic simulations, or asymptotic calculations in network models, we solve the extinction time exactly for all connected graphs with three to eight vertices. This approach enables us to discover descriptive relations that would be impossible with stochastic simulations. It also helps us discovering graphs and configurations of S and I with anomalous behaviors with respect to disease spreading. We find that for large transmission rates the extinction time is independent of the configurations, just dependent on the graph. In this limit, the number of vertices and edges determine the extinction time very accurately (deviations primarily coming from the fluctuations in degrees). We find that the rankings of configurations with respect to extinction times at low and high transmission rates are correlated at low prevalences and negatively correlated for high prevalences. The most important structural factor determining this ranking is the degrees of the infectious vertices. △ Less

Submitted 18 September, 2018; v1 submitted 24 February, 2018; originally announced February 2018.

Comments: v2 has some minor bug fixes

Three faces of node importance in network epidemiology: Exact results for small graphs

Authors: Petter Holme

Abstract: We investigate three aspects of the importance of nodes with respect to Susceptible-Infectious-Removed (SIR) disease dynamics: influence maximization (the expected outbreak size given a set of seed nodes), the effect of vaccination (how much deleting nodes would reduce the expected outbreak size) and sentinel surveillance (how early an outbreak could be detected with sensors at a set of nodes). We… ▽ More We investigate three aspects of the importance of nodes with respect to Susceptible-Infectious-Removed (SIR) disease dynamics: influence maximization (the expected outbreak size given a set of seed nodes), the effect of vaccination (how much deleting nodes would reduce the expected outbreak size) and sentinel surveillance (how early an outbreak could be detected with sensors at a set of nodes). We calculate the exact expressions of these quantities, as functions of the SIR parameters, for all connected graphs of three to seven nodes. We obtain the smallest graphs where the optimal node sets are not overlapping. We find that: node separation is more important than centrality for more than one active node, that vaccination and influence maximization are the most different aspects of importance, and that the three aspects are more similar when the infection rate is low. △ Less

Submitted 14 October, 2017; v1 submitted 21 August, 2017; originally announced August 2017.

Comments: (v3: thoroughly revised)

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 96, 062305 (2017)

Probing empirical contact networks by simulation of spreading dynamics

Authors: Petter Holme

Abstract: Disease, opinions, ideas, gossip, etc. all spread on social networks. How these networks are connected (the network structure) influences the dynamics of the spreading processes. By investigating these relationships one gains understanding both of the spreading itself and the structure and function of the contact network. In this chapter, we will summarize the recent literature using simulation of… ▽ More Disease, opinions, ideas, gossip, etc. all spread on social networks. How these networks are connected (the network structure) influences the dynamics of the spreading processes. By investigating these relationships one gains understanding both of the spreading itself and the structure and function of the contact network. In this chapter, we will summarize the recent literature using simulation of spreading processes on top of empirical contact data. We will mostly focus on disease simulations on temporal proximity networks -- networks recording who is close to whom, at what time -- but also cover other types of networks and spreading processes. We analyze 29 empirical networks to illustrate the methods. △ Less

Submitted 27 June, 2017; originally announced June 2017.

Impact of misinformation in temporal network epidemiology

Authors: Petter Holme, Luis E C Rocha

Abstract: We investigate the impact of misinformation about the contact structure on the ability to predict disease outbreaks. We base our study on 31 empirical temporal networks and tune the frequencies in errors in the node identities or timestamps of contacts. We find that for both these spreading scenarios, the maximal misprediction of both the outbreak size and time to extinction follows an stretched e… ▽ More We investigate the impact of misinformation about the contact structure on the ability to predict disease outbreaks. We base our study on 31 empirical temporal networks and tune the frequencies in errors in the node identities or timestamps of contacts. We find that for both these spreading scenarios, the maximal misprediction of both the outbreak size and time to extinction follows an stretched exponential convergence as a function of the error frequency. We furthermore determine the temporal-network structural factors influencing the parameters of this convergence. △ Less

Submitted 26 June, 2017; v1 submitted 7 April, 2017; originally announced April 2017.

Journal ref: Net Sci 7 (2019) 52-69

Ranking influential spreaders is an ill-defined problem

Authors: Jain Gu, Sungmin Lee, Jari Saramäki, Petter Holme

Abstract: Finding influential spreaders of information and disease in networks is an important theoretical problem, and one of considerable recent interest. It has been almost exclusively formulated as a node-ranking problem -- methods for identifying influential spreaders rank nodes according to how influential they are. In this work, we show that the ranking approach does not necessarily work: the set of… ▽ More Finding influential spreaders of information and disease in networks is an important theoretical problem, and one of considerable recent interest. It has been almost exclusively formulated as a node-ranking problem -- methods for identifying influential spreaders rank nodes according to how influential they are. In this work, we show that the ranking approach does not necessarily work: the set of most influential nodes depends on the number of nodes in the set. Therefore, the set of $n$ most important nodes to vaccinate does not need to have any node in common with the set of $n+1$ most important nodes. We propose a method for quantifying the extent and impact of this phenomenon, and show that it is common in both empirical and model networks. △ Less

Submitted 16 March, 2017; originally announced March 2017.

Journal ref: EPL 118 (2017) 68002

Cost-efficient vaccination protocols for network epidemiology

Authors: Petter Holme, Nelly Litvak

Abstract: We investigate methods to vaccinate contact networks -- i.e. removing nodes in such a way that disease spreading is hindered as much as possible -- with respect to their cost-efficiency. Any real implementation of such protocols would come with costs related both to the vaccination itself, and gathering of information about the network. Disregarding this, we argue, would lead to erroneous evaluati… ▽ More We investigate methods to vaccinate contact networks -- i.e. removing nodes in such a way that disease spreading is hindered as much as possible -- with respect to their cost-efficiency. Any real implementation of such protocols would come with costs related both to the vaccination itself, and gathering of information about the network. Disregarding this, we argue, would lead to erroneous evaluation of vaccination protocols. We use the susceptible-infected-recovered model -- the generic model for diseases making patients immune upon recovery -- as our disease-spreading scenario, and analyze outbreaks on both empirical and model networks. For different relative costs, different protocols dominate. For high vaccination costs and low costs of gathering information, the so-called acquaintance vaccination is the most cost efficient. For other parameter values, protocols designed for query-efficient identification of the network's largest degrees are most efficient. △ Less

Submitted 20 May, 2017; v1 submitted 21 December, 2016; originally announced December 2016.

Temporal network structures controlling disease spreading

Authors: Petter Holme

Abstract: We investigate disease spreading on eight empirical data sets of human contacts (mostly proximity networks recording who is close to whom, at what time). We compare three levels of representations of these data sets: temporal networks, static networks and a fully connected topology. We notice that the difference between the static and fully-connected networks -- with respect to time to extinction… ▽ More We investigate disease spreading on eight empirical data sets of human contacts (mostly proximity networks recording who is close to whom, at what time). We compare three levels of representations of these data sets: temporal networks, static networks and a fully connected topology. We notice that the difference between the static and fully-connected networks -- with respect to time to extinction and average outbreak size -- is smaller than between the temporal and static topologies. This suggests that, for these data sets, temporal structures influence disease spreading more than static network structures. To explain the details in the differences between the representations, we use 32 network measures. This study concur that long-time temporal structures, like the turnover of nodes and links, are the most important for the spreading dynamics. △ Less

Submitted 3 May, 2016; originally announced May 2016.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 94, 022305 (2016)

Collective decision making with a mix of majority and minority seekers

Authors: Petter Holme, Hang-Hyun Jo

Abstract: We study a model of a population making a binary decision based on information spreading within the population, which is fully connected or covering a square grid. We assume that a fraction of the population wants to make the choice of the majority, while the rest want to make the minority choice. This resembles opinion spreading with "contrarian" agents, but has the game theoretic aspect that age… ▽ More We study a model of a population making a binary decision based on information spreading within the population, which is fully connected or covering a square grid. We assume that a fraction of the population wants to make the choice of the majority, while the rest want to make the minority choice. This resembles opinion spreading with "contrarian" agents, but has the game theoretic aspect that agents try to optimize their own situation in ways that are incompatible with the common good. When this fraction is less than 1/2, the population can efficiently self-organize to a state where agents get what they want -- the majority (i.e. the majority seekers) have one opinion, the minority seekers have the other. If the fraction is larger than 1/2, there is a frustration in the population that dramatically changes the dynamics. In this region, the population converges, through some distinct phases, to a state of approximately equal-sized opinions. Just over the threshold the state of the population is furthest from the collectively optimal solution. △ Less

Submitted 11 May, 2016; v1 submitted 25 March, 2016; originally announced March 2016.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 93, 052308 (2016)

Modeling the dynamics of dissent

Authors: Eun Lee, Petter Holme, Sang Hoon Lee

Abstract: We investigate the formation of opinion against authority in an authoritarian society composed of agents with different levels of authority. We explore a "dissenting" opinion, held by lower-ranking, obedient, or less authoritative people, spreading in an environment of an "affirmative" opinion held by authoritative leaders. A real-world example would be a corrupt society where people revolt agains… ▽ More We investigate the formation of opinion against authority in an authoritarian society composed of agents with different levels of authority. We explore a "dissenting" opinion, held by lower-ranking, obedient, or less authoritative people, spreading in an environment of an "affirmative" opinion held by authoritative leaders. A real-world example would be a corrupt society where people revolt against such leaders, but it can be applied to more general situations. In our model, agents can change their opinion depending on their authority relative to their neighbors and their own confidence level. In addition, with a certain probability, agents can override the affirmative opinion to take the dissenting opinion of a neighbor. Based on analytic derivation and numerical simulations, we observe that both the network structure and heterogeneity in authority, and their correlation, significantly affect the possibility of the dissenting opinion to spread through the population. In particular, the dissenting opinion is suppressed when the authority distribution is very heterogeneous and there exists a positive correlation between the authority and the number of neighbors of people (degree). Except for such an extreme case, though, spreading of the dissenting opinion takes place when people have the tendency to override the authority to hold the dissenting opinion, but the dissenting opinion can take a long time to spread to the entire society, depending on the model parameters. We argue that the internal social structure of agents sets the scale of the time to reach consensus, based on the analysis of the underlying structural properties of opinion spreading. △ Less

Submitted 9 April, 2018; v1 submitted 7 March, 2016; originally announced March 2016.

Comments: 25 pages, 6 figures, 1 table

Journal ref: Physica A 486, 262 (2017)

Information content of contact-pattern representations and predictability of epidemic outbreaks

Authors: Petter Holme

Abstract: To understand the contact patterns of a population -- who is in contact with whom, and when the contacts happen -- is crucial for modeling outbreaks of infectious disease. Traditional theoretical epidemiology assumes that any individual can meet any with equal probability. A more modern approach, network epidemiology, assumes people are connected into a static network over which the disease spread… ▽ More To understand the contact patterns of a population -- who is in contact with whom, and when the contacts happen -- is crucial for modeling outbreaks of infectious disease. Traditional theoretical epidemiology assumes that any individual can meet any with equal probability. A more modern approach, network epidemiology, assumes people are connected into a static network over which the disease spreads. Newer yet, temporal network epidemiology, includes the time in the contact representations. In this paper, we investigate the effect of these successive inclusions of more information. Using empirical proximity data, we study both outbreak sizes from unknown sources, and from known states of ongoing outbreaks. In the first case, there are large differences going from a fully mixed simulation to a network, and from a network to a temporal network. In the second case, differences are smaller. We interpret these observations in terms of the temporal network structure of the data sets. For example, a fast overturn of nodes and links seem to make the temporal information more important. △ Less

Submitted 23 March, 2015; originally announced March 2015.

Comments: Supplementary material not included

Journal ref: Sci. Rep. 5, 14462 (2015)

Shadows of the SIS immortality transition in small networks

Authors: Petter Holme

Abstract: Much of the research on the behavior of the SIS model on networks has concerned the infinite size limit; in particular the phase transition between a state where outbreaks can reach a finite fraction of the population, and a state where only a finite number would be infected. For finite networks, there is also a dynamic transition---the immortality transition---when the per-contact transmission pr… ▽ More Much of the research on the behavior of the SIS model on networks has concerned the infinite size limit; in particular the phase transition between a state where outbreaks can reach a finite fraction of the population, and a state where only a finite number would be infected. For finite networks, there is also a dynamic transition---the immortality transition---when the per-contact transmission probability $λ$ reaches one. If $λ< 1$, the probability that an outbreak will survive by an observation time $t$ tends to zero as $t \rightarrow \infty$; if $λ= 1$, this probability is one. We show that treating $λ= 1$ as a critical point predicts the $λ$-dependence of the survival probability also for more moderate $λ$-values. The exponent, however, depends on the underlying network. This fact could, by measuring how a vertex' deletion changes the exponent, be used to evaluate the role of a vertex in the outbreak. Our work also confirms an extremely clear separation between the early die-off (from the outbreak failing to take hold in the population) and the later extinctions (corresponding to rare stochastic events of several consecutive transmission events failing to occur). △ Less

Submitted 13 May, 2015; v1 submitted 6 March, 2015; originally announced March 2015.

Comments: Bug fixes from the first version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 92, (2015) 012804

Time evolution of predictability of epidemics on networks

Authors: Petter Holme, Taro Takaguchi

Abstract: Epidemic outbreaks of new pathogens, or known pathogens in new populations, cause a great deal of fear because they are hard to predict. For theoretical models of disease spreading, on the other hand, quantities characterizing the outbreak converge to deterministic functions of time. Our goal in this paper is to shed some light on this apparent discrepancy. We measure the diversity of (and, thus,… ▽ More Epidemic outbreaks of new pathogens, or known pathogens in new populations, cause a great deal of fear because they are hard to predict. For theoretical models of disease spreading, on the other hand, quantities characterizing the outbreak converge to deterministic functions of time. Our goal in this paper is to shed some light on this apparent discrepancy. We measure the diversity of (and, thus, the predictability of) outbreak sizes and extinction times as functions of time given different scenarios of the amount of information available. Under the assumption of perfect information -- i.e., knowing the state of each individual with respect to the disease -- the predictability decreases exponentially, or faster, with time. The decay is slowest for intermediate values of the per-contact transmission probability. With a weaker assumption on the information available, assuming that we know only the fraction of currently infectious, recovered, or susceptible individuals, the predictability also decreases exponentially most of the time. There are, however, some peculiar regions in this scenario where the predictability decreases. In other words, to predict its final size with a given accuracy, we would need increasingly more information about the outbreak. △ Less

Submitted 5 May, 2015; v1 submitted 15 December, 2014; originally announced December 2014.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 91, 042811 (2015)

The basic reproduction number as a predictor for epidemic outbreaks in temporal networks

Authors: Petter Holme, Naoki Masuda

Abstract: The basic reproduction number R0 -- the number of individuals directly infected by an infectious person in an otherwise susceptible population -- is arguably the most widely used estimator of how severe an epidemic outbreak can be. This severity can be more directly measured as the fraction people infected once the outbreak is over, Ω. In traditional mathematical epidemiology and common formulatio… ▽ More The basic reproduction number R0 -- the number of individuals directly infected by an infectious person in an otherwise susceptible population -- is arguably the most widely used estimator of how severe an epidemic outbreak can be. This severity can be more directly measured as the fraction people infected once the outbreak is over, Ω. In traditional mathematical epidemiology and common formulations of static network epidemiology, there is a deterministic relationship between R0 and Ω. However, if one considers disease spreading on a temporal contact network -- where one knows when contacts happen, not only between whom -- then larger R0 does not necessarily imply larger Ω. In this paper, we numerically investigate the relationship between R0 and Ω for a set of empirical temporal networks of human contacts. Among 31 explanatory descriptors of temporal network structure, we identify those that make R0 an imperfect predictor of Ω. We find that descriptors related to both temporal and topological aspects affect the relationship between R0 and Ω, but in different ways. △ Less

Submitted 24 July, 2014; originally announced July 2014.

Journal ref: PLoS ONE 10, e0120567 (2015)

Model versions and fast algorithms for network epidemiology

Authors: Petter Holme

Abstract: Network epidemiology has become a core framework for investigating the role of human contact patterns in the spreading of infectious diseases. In network epidemiology represents the contact structure as a network of nodes (individuals) connected by links (sometimes as a temporal network where the links are not continuously active) and the disease as a compartmental model (where individuals are ass… ▽ More Network epidemiology has become a core framework for investigating the role of human contact patterns in the spreading of infectious diseases. In network epidemiology represents the contact structure as a network of nodes (individuals) connected by links (sometimes as a temporal network where the links are not continuously active) and the disease as a compartmental model (where individuals are assigned states with respect to the disease and follow certain transition rules between the states). In this paper, we discuss fast algorithms for such simulations and also compare two commonly used versions - one where there is a constant recovery rate (the number of individuals that stop being infectious per time is proportional to the number of such people), the other where the duration of the disease is constant. We find that, for most practical purposes, these versions are qualitatively the same. △ Less

Submitted 5 March, 2014; originally announced March 2014.

Comments: This write-up covers some details about simulating epidemiological models on networks. Feedback is appreciated

Journal ref: Journal of Logistical Engineering University 30, 1-7 (2014)

Extinction times of epidemic outbreaks in networks

Authors: Petter Holme

Abstract: In the Susceptible-Infectious-Recovered (SIR) model of disease spreading, the time to extinction of the epidemics happens at an intermediate value of the per-contact transmission probability. Too contagious infections burn out fast in the population. Infections that are not contagious enough die out before they spread to a large fraction of people. We characterize how the maximal extinction time i… ▽ More In the Susceptible-Infectious-Recovered (SIR) model of disease spreading, the time to extinction of the epidemics happens at an intermediate value of the per-contact transmission probability. Too contagious infections burn out fast in the population. Infections that are not contagious enough die out before they spread to a large fraction of people. We characterize how the maximal extinction time in SIR simulations on networks depend on the network structure. For example we find that the average distances in isolated components, weighted by the component size, is a good predictor of the maximal time to extinction. Furthermore, the transmission probability giving the longest outbreaks is larger than, but otherwise seemingly independent of, the epidemic threshold. △ Less

Submitted 15 October, 2013; originally announced October 2013.

Birth and death of links control disease spreading in empirical contact networks

Authors: Petter Holme, Fredrik Liljeros

Abstract: We investigate what structural aspects of a collection of twelve empirical temporal networks of human contacts are important to disease spreading. We scan the entire parameter spaces of the two canonical models of infectious disease epidemiology -- the Susceptible-Infectious-Susceptible (SIS) and Susceptible-Infectious-Removed (SIR) models. The results from these simulations are compared to refere… ▽ More We investigate what structural aspects of a collection of twelve empirical temporal networks of human contacts are important to disease spreading. We scan the entire parameter spaces of the two canonical models of infectious disease epidemiology -- the Susceptible-Infectious-Susceptible (SIS) and Susceptible-Infectious-Removed (SIR) models. The results from these simulations are compared to reference data where we eliminate structures in the interevent intervals, the time to the first contact in the data, or the time from the last contact to the end of the sampling. The picture we find is that the birth and death of links, and the total number of contacts over a link, are essential to predict outbreaks. On the other hand, the exact times of contacts between the beginning and end, or the interevent interval distribution, do not matter much. In other words, a simplified picture of these empirical data sets that suffices for epidemiological purposes is that links are born, is active with some intensity, and die. △ Less

Submitted 23 May, 2014; v1 submitted 24 July, 2013; originally announced July 2013.

Journal ref: Scientific Reports 4, 4999 (2014)

Epidemiologically optimal static networks from temporal network data

Authors: Petter Holme

Abstract: Network epidemiology's most important assumption is that the contact structure over which infectious diseases propagate can be represented as a static network. However, contacts are highly dynamic, changing at many time scales. In this paper, we investigate conceptually simple methods to construct static graphs for network epidemiology from temporal contact data. We evaluate these methods on empir… ▽ More Network epidemiology's most important assumption is that the contact structure over which infectious diseases propagate can be represented as a static network. However, contacts are highly dynamic, changing at many time scales. In this paper, we investigate conceptually simple methods to construct static graphs for network epidemiology from temporal contact data. We evaluate these methods on empirical and synthetic model data. For almost all our cases, the network representation that captures most relevant information is a so-called exponential-threshold network. In these, each contact contributes with a weight decreasing exponentially with time, and there is an edge between a pair of vertices if the weight between them exceeds a threshold. Networks of aggregated contacts over an optimally chosen time window perform almost as good as the exponential-threshold networks. On the other hand, networks of accumulated contacts over the entire sampling time, and networks of concurrent partnerships, perform worse. We discuss these observations in the context of the temporal and topological structure of the data sets. △ Less

Submitted 4 February, 2013; originally announced February 2013.

Neutral theory of chemical reaction networks

Authors: Sang Hoon Lee, Sebastian Bernhardsson, Petter Holme, Beom Jun Kim, Petter Minnhagen

Abstract: To what extent do the characteristic features of a chemical reaction network reflect its purpose and function? In general, one argues that correlations between specific features and specific functions are key to understanding a complex structure. However, specific features may sometimes be neutral and uncorrelated with any system-specific purpose, function or causal chain. Such neutral features ar… ▽ More To what extent do the characteristic features of a chemical reaction network reflect its purpose and function? In general, one argues that correlations between specific features and specific functions are key to understanding a complex structure. However, specific features may sometimes be neutral and uncorrelated with any system-specific purpose, function or causal chain. Such neutral features are caused by chance and randomness. Here we compare two classes of chemical networks: one that has been subjected to biological evolution (the chemical reaction network of metabolism in living cells) and one that has not (the atmospheric planetary chemical reaction networks). Their degree distributions are shown to share the very same neutral system-independent features. The shape of the broad distributions is to a large extent controlled by a single parameter, the network size. From this perspective, there is little difference between atmospheric and metabolic networks; they are just different sizes of the same random assembling network. In other words, the shape of the degree distribution is a neutral characteristic feature and has no functional or evolutionary implications in itself; it is not a matter of life and death. △ Less

Submitted 20 March, 2012; v1 submitted 16 December, 2011; originally announced December 2011.

Comments: 13 pages, 8 figures

Journal ref: New J. Phys. 14, 033032 (2012)

Cooperation, structure and hierarchy in multiadaptive games

Authors: Sungmin Lee, Petter Holme, Zhi-Xi Wu

Abstract: Game-theoretical models where the rules of the game and the interaction structure both coevolves with the game dynamics -- multiadaptive games -- capture very flexible situations where cooperation among selfish agents can emerge. In this work, we will discuss a multiadaptive model presented in a recent Letter [Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 028702 (2011)], and generalizations of it. The model captures a no… ▽ More Game-theoretical models where the rules of the game and the interaction structure both coevolves with the game dynamics -- multiadaptive games -- capture very flexible situations where cooperation among selfish agents can emerge. In this work, we will discuss a multiadaptive model presented in a recent Letter [Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 028702 (2011)], and generalizations of it. The model captures a non-equilibrium situation where social unrest increases the incentive to cooperate and, simultaneously, agents are partly free to influence with whom they interact. First, we investigate the details of how the feedback from the behavior of agents determines the emergence of cooperation and hierarchical contact structures. We also study the stability of the system to different types of noise, and find that different regions of parameter space show very different response. Some types of noise can destroy an all-cooperator state. If, on the other hand, hubs are stable, then so is the all-C state. Finally, we investigate the dependence of the ratio between the timescales of strategy updates and the evolution of the interaction structure. We find that a comparatively fast strategy dynamics is a prerequisite for the emergence of cooperation. △ Less

Submitted 7 December, 2011; originally announced December 2011.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E. 84, 061148 (2011)

Atmospheric reaction systems as null-models to identify structural traces of evolution in metabolism

Authors: Petter Holme, Mikael Huss, Sang Hoon Lee

Abstract: The metabolism is the motor behind the biological complexity of an organism. One problem of characterizing its large-scale structure is that it is hard to know what to compare it to. All chemical reaction systems are shaped by the same physics that gives molecules their stability and affinity to react. These fundamental factors cannot be captured by standard null-models based on randomization. The… ▽ More The metabolism is the motor behind the biological complexity of an organism. One problem of characterizing its large-scale structure is that it is hard to know what to compare it to. All chemical reaction systems are shaped by the same physics that gives molecules their stability and affinity to react. These fundamental factors cannot be captured by standard null-models based on randomization. The unique property of organismal metabolism is that it is controlled, to some extent, by an enzymatic machinery that is subject to evolution. In this paper, we explore the possibility that reaction systems of planetary atmospheres can serve as a null-model against which we can define metabolic structure and trace the influence of evolution. We find that the two types of data can be distinguished by their respective degree distributions. This is especially clear when looking at the degree distribution of the reaction network (of reaction connected to each other if they involve the same molecular species). For the Earth's atmospheric network and the human metabolic network, we look into more detail for an underlying explanation of this deviation. However, we cannot pinpoint a single cause of the difference, rather there are several concurrent factors. By examining quantities relating to the modular-functional organization of the metabolism, we confirm that metabolic networks have a more complex modular organization than the atmospheric networks, but not much more. We interpret the more variegated modular arrangement of metabolism as a trace of evolved functionality. On the other hand, it is quite remarkable how similar the structures of these two types of networks are, which emphasizes that the constraints from the chemical properties of the molecules has a larger influence in shaping the reaction system than does natural selection. △ Less

Submitted 7 May, 2011; v1 submitted 17 April, 2011; originally announced April 2011.

Journal ref: PLoS ONE 6(5), e19759 (2011)

Emergent Hierarchical Structures in Multiadaptive Games

Authors: Sungmin Lee, Petter Holme, Zhi-Xi Wu

Abstract: We investigate a game-theoretic model of a social system where both the rules of the game and the interaction structure are shaped by the behavior of the agents. We call this type of model, with several types of feedback couplings from the behavior of the agents to their environment, a multiadaptive game. Our model has a complex behavior with several regimes of different dynamic behavior accompani… ▽ More We investigate a game-theoretic model of a social system where both the rules of the game and the interaction structure are shaped by the behavior of the agents. We call this type of model, with several types of feedback couplings from the behavior of the agents to their environment, a multiadaptive game. Our model has a complex behavior with several regimes of different dynamic behavior accompanied by different network topological properties. Some of these regimes are characterized by heterogeneous, hierarchical interaction networks, where cooperation and network topology coemerge from the dynamics. △ Less

Submitted 19 January, 2011; v1 submitted 24 December, 2010; originally announced December 2010.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 028702 (2011)

Metabolic robustness and network modularity: A model study

Authors: Petter Holme

Abstract: [Background] Several studies have mentioned network modularity -- that a network can easily be decomposed into subgraphs that are densely connected within and weakly connected between each other -- as a factor affecting metabolic robustness. In this paper we measure the relation between network modularity and several aspects of robustness directly in a model system of metabolism. [Methodology/Prin… ▽ More [Background] Several studies have mentioned network modularity -- that a network can easily be decomposed into subgraphs that are densely connected within and weakly connected between each other -- as a factor affecting metabolic robustness. In this paper we measure the relation between network modularity and several aspects of robustness directly in a model system of metabolism. [Methodology/Principal Findings] By using a model for generating chemical reaction systems where one can tune the network modularity, we find that robustness increases with modularity for changes in the concentrations of metabolites, whereas it decreases with changes in the expression of enzymes. The same modularity scaling is true for the speed of relaxation after the perturbations. [Conclusions/Significance] Modularity is not a general principle for making metabolism either more or less robust; this question needs to be addressed specifically for different types of perturbations of the system. △ Less

Submitted 20 December, 2010; originally announced December 2010.

Journal ref: PLoS ONE 6, e16605 (2011)

Exploiting temporal network structures of human interaction to effectively immunize populations

Authors: Sungmin Lee, Luis E. C. Rocha, Fredrik Liljeros, Petter Holme

Abstract: If we can lower the number of people needed to vaccinate for a community to be immune against contagious diseases, we can save resources and life. A key to reach such a lower threshold of immunization is to find and vaccinate people who, through their behavior, are more likely to become infected and effective to spread the disease than the average. Fortunately, the very behavior that makes these p… ▽ More If we can lower the number of people needed to vaccinate for a community to be immune against contagious diseases, we can save resources and life. A key to reach such a lower threshold of immunization is to find and vaccinate people who, through their behavior, are more likely to become infected and effective to spread the disease than the average. Fortunately, the very behavior that makes these people important to vaccinate can help us finding them. People you have met recently are more likely to be socially active and thus central in the contact pattern, and important to vaccinate. We propose two immunization schemes exploiting temporal contact patterns. Both of these rely only on obtainable, local information and could implemented in practice. We show that these schemes outperform benchmark protocols in four real data sets under various epidemic scenarios. The data sets are dynamic, which enables us to make more realistic evaluations than other studies - we use information only about the past to perform the vaccination and the future to simulate disease outbreaks. We also use models to elucidate the mechanisms behind how the temporal structures make our immunization protocols efficient. △ Less

Submitted 17 November, 2010; originally announced November 2010.

Journal ref: PLoS ONE 7(5): e36439 (2012)

Emergence of collective memories

Authors: Sungmin Lee, Verónica C Ramenzoni, Petter Holme

Abstract: We understand the dynamics of the world around us as by associating pairs of events, where one event has some influence on the other. These pairs of events can be aggregated into a web of memories representing our understanding of an episode of history. The events and the associations between them need not be directly experienced-they can also be acquired by communication. In this paper we take a… ▽ More We understand the dynamics of the world around us as by associating pairs of events, where one event has some influence on the other. These pairs of events can be aggregated into a web of memories representing our understanding of an episode of history. The events and the associations between them need not be directly experienced-they can also be acquired by communication. In this paper we take a network approach to study the dynamics of memories of history. First we investigate the network structure of a data set consisting of reported events by several individuals and how associations connect them. We focus our measurement on degree distributions, degree correlations, cycles (which represent inconsistencies as they would break the time ordering) and community structure. We proceed to model effects of communication using an agent-based model. We investigate the conditions for the memory webs of different individuals to converge to collective memories, how groups where the individuals have similar memories (but different from other groups) can form. Our work outlines how the cognitive representation of memories and social structure can co-evolve as a contagious process. We generate some testable hypotheses including that the number of groups is limited as a function of the total population size. △ Less

Submitted 14 August, 2010; originally announced August 2010.

Journal ref: PLoS ONE 5(9): e12522 (2010)

Simulated epidemics in an empirical spatiotemporal network of 50,185 sexual contacts

Authors: Luis Enrique Correa Rocha, Fredrik Liljeros, Petter Holme

Abstract: We study implications of the dynamical and spatial contact structure between Brazilian escorts and sex-buyers for the spreading of sexually transmitted infections (STI). Despite a highly skewed degree distribution diseases spreading in this contact structure have rather well-defined epidemic thresholds. Temporal effects create a broad distribution of outbreak sizes even if the transmission probabi… ▽ More We study implications of the dynamical and spatial contact structure between Brazilian escorts and sex-buyers for the spreading of sexually transmitted infections (STI). Despite a highly skewed degree distribution diseases spreading in this contact structure have rather well-defined epidemic thresholds. Temporal effects create a broad distribution of outbreak sizes even if the transmission probability is taken to the hypothetical value of 100%. Temporal correlations speed up outbreaks, especially in the early phase, compared to randomized contact structures. The time-ordering and the network topology, on the other hand, slow down the epidemics. Studying compartmental models we show that the contact structure can probably not support the spread of HIV, not even if individuals were sexually active during the acute infection. We investigate hypothetical means of containing an outbreak and find that travel restrictions are about as efficient as removal of the vertices of highest degree. In general, the type of commercial sex we study seems not like a major factor in STI epidemics. △ Less

Submitted 14 June, 2010; originally announced June 2010.

Comments: 19 pages including 7 figures

Three faces of metabolites: Pathways, localizations and network positions

Authors: Jing Zhao, Petter Holme

Abstract: To understand the system-wide organization of metabolism, different lines of study have devised different categorizations of metabolites. The relationship and difference between categories can provide new insights for a more detailed description of the organization of metabolism. In this study, we investigate the relative organization of three categorizations of metabolites -- pathways, subcellu… ▽ More To understand the system-wide organization of metabolism, different lines of study have devised different categorizations of metabolites. The relationship and difference between categories can provide new insights for a more detailed description of the organization of metabolism. In this study, we investigate the relative organization of three categorizations of metabolites -- pathways, subcellular localizations and network clusters, by block-model techniques borrowed from social-network studies and further characterize the categories from topological point of view. The picture of the metabolism we obtain is that of peripheral modules, characterized both by being dense network clusters and localized to organelles, connected by a central, highly connected core. Pathways typically run through several network clusters and localizations, connecting them laterally. The strong overlap between organelles and network clusters suggest that these are natural "modules" -- relatively independent sub-systems. The different categorizations divide the core metabolism differently suggesting that this, if possible, should be not be treated as a module on par with the organelles. Although overlapping more than chance, none of the pathways correspond very closely to a network cluster or localization. This, we believe, highlights the benefits of different orthogonal classifications and future experimental categorizations based on simple principles. △ Less

Submitted 22 July, 2009; originally announced July 2009.

Model validation of simple-graph representations of metabolism

Authors: Petter Holme

Abstract: The large-scale properties of chemical reaction systems, such as the metabolism, can be studied with graph-based methods. To do this, one needs to reduce the information -- lists of chemical reactions -- available in databases. Even for the simplest type of graph representation, this reduction can be done in several ways. We investigate different simple network representations by testing how wel… ▽ More The large-scale properties of chemical reaction systems, such as the metabolism, can be studied with graph-based methods. To do this, one needs to reduce the information -- lists of chemical reactions -- available in databases. Even for the simplest type of graph representation, this reduction can be done in several ways. We investigate different simple network representations by testing how well they encode information about one biologically important network structure -- network modularity (the propensity for edges to be cluster into dense groups that are sparsely connected between each other). To reach this goal, we design a model of reaction-systems where network modularity can be controlled and measure how well the reduction to simple graphs capture the modular structure of the model reaction system. We find that the network types that best capture the modular structure of the reaction system are substrate-product networks (where substrates are linked to products of a reaction) and substance networks (with edges between all substances participating in a reaction). Furthermore, we argue that the proposed model for reaction systems with tunable clustering is a general framework for studies of how reaction-systems are affected by modularity. To this end, we investigate statistical properties of the model and find, among other things, that it recreate correlations between degree and mass of the molecules. △ Less

Submitted 16 December, 2008; originally announced December 2008.

Comments: to appear in J. Roy. Soc. Inteface

Journal ref: J. R. Soc. Interface 6, 1027-1034 (2009)

Substance graphs are optimal simple-graph representations of metabolism

Authors: Petter Holme, Mikael Huss

Abstract: One approach to studying the system-wide organization of biochemistry is to use statistical graph theory. Even in such a heavily simplified method, which disregards most of the dynamic aspects of biochemistry, one is faced with fundamental questions, such as how the chemical reaction systems should be reduced to a graph retaining as much functional information as possible from the original react… ▽ More One approach to studying the system-wide organization of biochemistry is to use statistical graph theory. Even in such a heavily simplified method, which disregards most of the dynamic aspects of biochemistry, one is faced with fundamental questions, such as how the chemical reaction systems should be reduced to a graph retaining as much functional information as possible from the original reaction system. In such graph representations, should the edges go between substrates and products, or substrates and substrates, or both? Should vertices represent substances or reactions? Different definitions encode different information about the reaction system. In this paper we evaluate four different graph representations of metabolism, applied to data from different organisms and databases. The graph representations are evaluated by comparing the overlap between clusters (network modules) and annotated functions, and also by comparing the set of identified currency metabolites with those that other authors have identified using qualitative biological arguments. We find that a "substance network," where all metabolites participating in a reaction are connected, is relatively better than others, evaluated both with respect to the functional overlap between modules and functions and to the number and identity of identified currency metabolites. △ Less

Submitted 3 December, 2008; v1 submitted 17 June, 2008; originally announced June 2008.

Journal ref: Chinese Sci. Bull. 55, 3161-3168 (2010)

The diplomat's dilemma: Maximal power for minimal effort in social networks

Authors: Petter Holme, Gourab Ghoshal

Abstract: Closeness is a global measure of centrality in networks, and a proxy for how influential actors are in social networks. In most network models, and many empirical networks, closeness is strongly correlated with degree. However, in social networks there is a cost of maintaining social ties. This leads to a situation (that can occur in the professional social networks of executives, lobbyists, dip… ▽ More Closeness is a global measure of centrality in networks, and a proxy for how influential actors are in social networks. In most network models, and many empirical networks, closeness is strongly correlated with degree. However, in social networks there is a cost of maintaining social ties. This leads to a situation (that can occur in the professional social networks of executives, lobbyists, diplomats and so on) where agents have the conflicting objectives of aiming for centrality while simultaneously keeping the degree low. We investigate this situation in an adaptive network-evolution model where agents optimize their positions in the network following individual strategies, and using only local information. The strategies are also optimized, based on the success of the agent and its neighbors. We measure and describe the time evolution of the network and the agents' strategies. △ Less

Submitted 26 May, 2008; originally announced May 2008.

Comments: Submitted to Adaptive Networks: Theory, Models and Applications, to be published from Springer

Journal ref: Adaptive networks: Theory, models and applications, Thilo Gross and Hiroki Sayama, eds., (Springer, Berlin, 2009), pp. 269-288.

Comment on "Regularizing capacity of metabolic networks"

Authors: Petter Holme, Mikael Huss

Abstract: In a recent paper, Marr, Muller-Linow and Hutt [Phys. Rev. E 75, 041917 (2007)] investigate an artificial dynamic system on metabolic networks. They find a less complex time evolution of this dynamic system in real networks, compared to networks of reference models. The authors argue that this suggests that metabolic network structure is a major factor behind the stability of biochemical steady… ▽ More In a recent paper, Marr, Muller-Linow and Hutt [Phys. Rev. E 75, 041917 (2007)] investigate an artificial dynamic system on metabolic networks. They find a less complex time evolution of this dynamic system in real networks, compared to networks of reference models. The authors argue that this suggests that metabolic network structure is a major factor behind the stability of biochemical steady states. We reanalyze the same kind of data using a dynamic system modeling actual reaction kinetics. The conclusions about stability, from our analysis, are inconsistent with those of Marr et al. We argue that this issue calls for a more detailed type of modeling. △ Less

Submitted 6 February, 2008; v1 submitted 28 May, 2007; originally announced May 2007.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 77, 023901 (2008)

Exploring the assortativity-clustering space of a network's degree sequence

Authors: Petter Holme, Jing Zhao

Abstract: Nowadays there is a multitude of measures designed to capture different aspects of network structure. To be able to say if the structure of certain network is expected or not, one needs a reference model (null model). One frequently used null model is the ensemble of graphs with the same set of degrees as the original network. In this paper we argue that this ensemble can be more than just a nul… ▽ More Nowadays there is a multitude of measures designed to capture different aspects of network structure. To be able to say if the structure of certain network is expected or not, one needs a reference model (null model). One frequently used null model is the ensemble of graphs with the same set of degrees as the original network. In this paper we argue that this ensemble can be more than just a null model -- it also carries information about the original network and factors that affect its evolution. By mapping out this ensemble in the space of some low-level network structure -- in our case those measured by the assortativity and clustering coefficients -- one can for example study how close to the valid region of the parameter space the observed networks are. Such analysis suggests which quantities are actively optimized during the evolution of the network. We use four very different biological networks to exemplify our method. Among other things, we find that high clustering might be a force in the evolution of protein interaction networks. We also find that all four networks are conspicuously robust to both random errors and targeted attacks. △ Less

Submitted 6 November, 2006; originally announced November 2006.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 75, 046111 (2007)

Local symmetries in complex networks

Authors: Petter Holme

Abstract: Symmetry -- invariance to certain operators -- is a fundamental concept in many branches of physics. We propose ways to measure symmetric properties of vertices, and their surroundings, in networks. To be stable to the randomness inherent in many complex networks, we consider measures that are continuous rather than dichotomous. The main operator we suggest is permutations of the paths of a cert… ▽ More Symmetry -- invariance to certain operators -- is a fundamental concept in many branches of physics. We propose ways to measure symmetric properties of vertices, and their surroundings, in networks. To be stable to the randomness inherent in many complex networks, we consider measures that are continuous rather than dichotomous. The main operator we suggest is permutations of the paths of a certain length leading out from a vertex. If these paths are more similar (in some sense) than expected, the vertex is a local center of symmetry in networks. We discuss different precise definitions based on this idea and give examples how different symmetry coefficients can be applied to protein interaction networks. △ Less

Submitted 6 September, 2006; v1 submitted 30 August, 2006; originally announced August 2006.

Comments: Presented at (and submitted to the proceedings of) Dynamics Days Asia Pacific 4

Journal ref: Journal of the Korean Physical Society 50, 300-303 (2007)

Dynamic scaling regimes of collective decision making

Authors: Andreas Gronlund, Petter Holme, Petter Minnhagen

Abstract: We investigate a social system of agents faced with a binary choice. We assume there is a correct, or beneficial, outcome of this choice. Furthermore, we assume agents are influenced by others in making their decision, and that the agents can obtain information that may guide them towards making a correct decision. The dynamic model we propose is of nonequilibrium type, converging to a final dec… ▽ More We investigate a social system of agents faced with a binary choice. We assume there is a correct, or beneficial, outcome of this choice. Furthermore, we assume agents are influenced by others in making their decision, and that the agents can obtain information that may guide them towards making a correct decision. The dynamic model we propose is of nonequilibrium type, converging to a final decision. We run it on random graphs and scale-free networks. On random graphs, we find two distinct regions in terms of the "finalizing time" -- the time until all agents have finalized their decisions. On scale-free networks on the other hand, there does not seem to be any such distinct scaling regions. △ Less

Submitted 24 August, 2007; v1 submitted 25 May, 2006; originally announced May 2006.

Journal ref: Europhys. Lett. 81, (2008) 28003

Currency and commodity metabolites: Their identification and relation to the modularity of metabolic networks

Authors: Mikael Huss, Petter Holme

Abstract: The large-scale shape and function of metabolic networks are intriguing topics of systems biology. Such networks are on one hand commonly regarded as modular (i.e. built by a number of relatively independent subsystems), but on the other hand they are robust in a way not expected of a purely modular system. To address this question we carefully discuss the partition of metabolic networks into su… ▽ More The large-scale shape and function of metabolic networks are intriguing topics of systems biology. Such networks are on one hand commonly regarded as modular (i.e. built by a number of relatively independent subsystems), but on the other hand they are robust in a way not expected of a purely modular system. To address this question we carefully discuss the partition of metabolic networks into subnetworks. The practice of preprocessing such networks by removing the most abundant substrates, "currency metabolites," is formalized into a network-based algorithm. We study partitions for metabolic networks of many organisms and find cores of currency metabolites and modular peripheries of what we call "commodity metabolites." The networks are found to be more modular than random networks but far from perfectly divisible into modules. We argue that cross-modular edges are the key for the robustness of metabolism. △ Less

Submitted 31 March, 2006; originally announced March 2006.

Journal ref: IET Systems Biology 1, 280-285 (2007)

Nonequilibrium phase transition in the coevolution of networks and opinions

Authors: Petter Holme, M. E. J. Newman

Abstract: Models of the convergence of opinion in social systems have been the subject of a considerable amount of recent attention in the physics literature. These models divide into two classes, those in which individuals form their beliefs based on the opinions of their neighbors in a social network of personal acquaintances, and those in which, conversely, network connections form between individuals… ▽ More Models of the convergence of opinion in social systems have been the subject of a considerable amount of recent attention in the physics literature. These models divide into two classes, those in which individuals form their beliefs based on the opinions of their neighbors in a social network of personal acquaintances, and those in which, conversely, network connections form between individuals of similar beliefs. While both of these processes can give rise to realistic levels of agreement between acquaintances, practical experience suggests that opinion formation in the real world is not a result of one process or the other, but a combination of the two. Here we present a simple model of this combination, with a single parameter controlling the balance of the two processes. We find that the model undergoes a continuous phase transition as this parameter is varied, from a regime in which opinions are arbitrarily diverse to one in which most individuals hold the same opinion. We characterize the static and dynamical properties of this transition. △ Less

Submitted 9 March, 2006; v1 submitted 3 March, 2006; originally announced March 2006.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 74, 056108 (2006)

Dynamics of networking agents competing for high centrality and low degree

Authors: Petter Holme, Gourab Ghoshal

Abstract: We model a system of networking agents that seek to optimize their centrality in the network while keeping their cost, the number of connections they are participating in, low. Unlike other game-theory based models for network evolution, the success of the agents is related only to their position in the network. The agents use strategies based on local information to improve their chance of succ… ▽ More We model a system of networking agents that seek to optimize their centrality in the network while keeping their cost, the number of connections they are participating in, low. Unlike other game-theory based models for network evolution, the success of the agents is related only to their position in the network. The agents use strategies based on local information to improve their chance of success. Both the evolution of strategies and network structure are investigated. We find a dramatic time evolution with cascades of strategy change accompanied by a change in network structure. On average the network self-organizes to a state close to the transition between a fragmented state and a state with a giant component. Furthermore, with increasing system size both the average degree and the level of fragmentation decreases. We also observe that the network keeps on actively evolving, although it does not have to, thus suggesting a Red Queen-like situation where agents have to keep on networking and responding to the moves of the others in order to stay successful. △ Less

Submitted 8 December, 2005; v1 submitted 6 December, 2005; originally announced December 2005.

Comments: v2: Fig. 3 fixed

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 098701 (2006)

The contact network of patients in a regional healthcare system

Authors: Fredrik Liljeros, Petter Holme, Johan Giesecke

Abstract: Yet in spite of advances in hospital treatment, hospitals continue to be a breeding ground for several airborne diseases and for diseases that are transmitted through close contacts like SARS, methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA), norovirus infections and tuberculosis (TB). Here we extract contact networks for up to 295,108 inpatients for durations up to two years from a database u… ▽ More Yet in spite of advances in hospital treatment, hospitals continue to be a breeding ground for several airborne diseases and for diseases that are transmitted through close contacts like SARS, methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA), norovirus infections and tuberculosis (TB). Here we extract contact networks for up to 295,108 inpatients for durations up to two years from a database used for administrating a local public healthcare system serving a population of 1.9 million individuals. Structural and dynamical properties of the network of importance for the transmission of contagious diseases are then analyzed by methods from network epidemiology. The contact networks are found to be very much determined by an extreme (age independent) variation in duration of hospital stays and the hospital structure. We find that that the structure of contacts between in-patients exhibit structural properties, such as a high level of transitivity, assortativity and variation in number of contacts, that are likely to be of importance for the transmission of less contagious diseases. If these properties are considered when designing prevention programs the risk for and the effect of epidemic outbreaks may be decreased. △ Less

Submitted 10 May, 2005; originally announced May 2005.

Journal ref: Mathematical Population Studies 14, (2007) 269-284