-
Ubiquitous Asymptotic Robustness in Biochemical Systems
Authors:
Hyukpyo Hong,
Diego Rojas La Luz,
Gheorghe Craciun
Abstract:
Living systems maintain stable internal states despite environmental fluctuations. Absolute concentration robustness (ACR) is a striking homeostatic phenomenon in which the steady-state concentration of a molecular species remains entirely invariant to changes in total molecular supply. Although experimental studies have reported approximate -- but not exact -- robustness in steady-state concentra…
▽ More
Living systems maintain stable internal states despite environmental fluctuations. Absolute concentration robustness (ACR) is a striking homeostatic phenomenon in which the steady-state concentration of a molecular species remains entirely invariant to changes in total molecular supply. Although experimental studies have reported approximate -- but not exact -- robustness in steady-state concentrations, such behavior has often been attributed to exact ACR motifs perturbed by measurement noise or minor side reactions, rather than recognized as a structural property of the network itself. In this work, we highlight a previously underappreciated phenomenon, which we term {\em asymptotic ACR} (or {\em aACR}): approximate robustness can emerge solely from the architecture of the reaction network, without requiring parameters being negligible or the presence of an exact ACR motif. We find that aACR is far more common than classical ACR, as demonstrated in systems such as the \textit{Escherichia coli} EnvZ-OmpR system and MAPK signaling cascade. Furthermore, we mathematically prove that such ubiquity stems solely from network structures. Finally, we reveal a counterintuitive feature of aACR in systems with multiple conserved quantities, revealing subtle distinctions in how robustness manifests in complex biochemical networks.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
Weakly reversible deficiency zero realizations of reaction networks
Authors:
Neal Buxton,
Gheorghe Craciun,
Abhishek Deshpande,
Casian Pantea
Abstract:
We prove that if a given reaction network $\mathcal{N}$ has a weakly reversible deficiency zero realization for all choice of rate constants, then there exists a $\textit{unique}$ weakly reversible deficiency zero network $\mathcal{N}'$ such that $\mathcal{N}$ is realizable by $\mathcal{N}'$. Additionally, we propose an algorithm to find this weakly reversible deficiency zero network…
▽ More
We prove that if a given reaction network $\mathcal{N}$ has a weakly reversible deficiency zero realization for all choice of rate constants, then there exists a $\textit{unique}$ weakly reversible deficiency zero network $\mathcal{N}'$ such that $\mathcal{N}$ is realizable by $\mathcal{N}'$. Additionally, we propose an algorithm to find this weakly reversible deficiency zero network $\mathcal{N}'$ when it exists.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
Generalized Lotka-Volterra Systems and Complex Balanced Polyexponential Systems
Authors:
Diego Rojas La Luz,
Gheorghe Craciun,
Polly Y. Yu
Abstract:
We study the global stability of generalized Lotka-Volterra systems with generalized polynomial right-hand side, without restrictions on the number of variables or the polynomial degree, including negative and non-integer degree. We introduce polyexponential dynamical systems, which are equivalent to the generalized Lotka-Volterra systems, and we use an analogy to the theory of mass-action kinetic…
▽ More
We study the global stability of generalized Lotka-Volterra systems with generalized polynomial right-hand side, without restrictions on the number of variables or the polynomial degree, including negative and non-integer degree. We introduce polyexponential dynamical systems, which are equivalent to the generalized Lotka-Volterra systems, and we use an analogy to the theory of mass-action kinetics to define and analyze complex balanced polyexponential systems, and implicitly analyze complex balanced generalized Lotka-Volterra systems. We prove that complex balanced generalized Lotka-Volterra systems have globally attracting states, up to standard conservation relations, which become linear for the associated polyexponential systems. In particular, complex balanced generalized Lotka-Volterra systems cannot give rise to periodic solutions, chaotic dynamics, or other complex dynamical behaviors. We describe a simple sufficient condition for complex balance in terms of an associated graph structure, and we use it to analyze specific examples.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
The Dimension of the Disguised Toric Locus of a Reaction Network
Authors:
Gheorghe Craciun,
Abhishek Deshpande,
Jiaxin Jin
Abstract:
Under mass-action kinetics, complex-balanced systems emerge from biochemical reaction networks and exhibit stable and predictable dynamics. For a reaction network $G$, the associated dynamical system is called $\textit{disguised toric}$ if it can yield a complex-balanced realization on a possibly different network $G_1$. This concept extends the robust properties of toric systems to those that are…
▽ More
Under mass-action kinetics, complex-balanced systems emerge from biochemical reaction networks and exhibit stable and predictable dynamics. For a reaction network $G$, the associated dynamical system is called $\textit{disguised toric}$ if it can yield a complex-balanced realization on a possibly different network $G_1$. This concept extends the robust properties of toric systems to those that are not inherently toric. In this work, we study the $\textit{disguised toric locus}$ of a reaction network - i.e., the set of positive rate constants that make the corresponding mass-action system disguised toric. Our primary focus is to compute the exact dimension of this locus. We subsequently apply our results to Thomas-type and circadian clock models.
△ Less
Submitted 3 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
Planar chemical reaction systems with algebraic and non-algebraic limit cycles
Authors:
Gheorghe Craciun,
Radek Erban
Abstract:
The Hilbert number $H(n)$ is defined as the maximum number of limit cycles of a planar autonomous system of ordinary differential equations (ODEs) with right-hand sides containing polynomials of degree at most $n \in {\mathbb N}$. The dynamics of chemical reaction systems with two chemical species can be (under mass-action kinetics) described by such planar autonomous ODEs, where $n$ is equal to t…
▽ More
The Hilbert number $H(n)$ is defined as the maximum number of limit cycles of a planar autonomous system of ordinary differential equations (ODEs) with right-hand sides containing polynomials of degree at most $n \in {\mathbb N}$. The dynamics of chemical reaction systems with two chemical species can be (under mass-action kinetics) described by such planar autonomous ODEs, where $n$ is equal to the maximum order of the chemical reactions in the system. Analogues of the Hilbert number $H(n)$ for three different classes of chemical reaction systems are investigated: (i) chemical systems with reactions up to the $n$-th order; (ii) systems with up to $n$-molecular chemical reactions; and (iii) weakly reversible chemical reaction networks. In each case (i), (ii) and (iii), the question on the number of limit cycles is considered. Lower bounds on the modified Hilbert numbers are provided for both algebraic and non-algebraic limit cycles. Furthermore, given a general algebraic curve $h(x,y)=0$ of degree $n_h \in {\mathbb N}$ and containing one or more ovals in the positive quadrant, a chemical system is constructed which has the oval(s) as its stable algebraic limit cycle(s). The ODEs describing the dynamics of the constructed chemical system contain polynomials of degree at most $n=2\,n_h+1.$ Considering $n_h \ge 4,$ the algebraic curve $h(x,y)=0$ can contain multiple closed components with the maximum number of ovals given by Harnack's curve theorem as $1+(n_h-1)(n_h-2)/2$, which is equal to 4 for $n_h=4.$ Algebraic curve $h(x,y)=0$ with $n_h=4$ and the maximum number of four ovals is used to construct a chemical system which has four stable algebraic limit cycles.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2025; v1 submitted 7 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Reaction Network Motifs for Static and Dynamic Absolute Concentration Robustness
Authors:
Badal Joshi,
Gheorghe Craciun
Abstract:
Networks with absolute concentration robustness (ACR) have the property that a translation of a coordinate hyperplane either contains all steady states (static ACR) or attracts all trajectories (dynamic ACR). The implication for the underlying biological system is robustness in the concentration of one of the species independent of the initial conditions as well as independent of the concentration…
▽ More
Networks with absolute concentration robustness (ACR) have the property that a translation of a coordinate hyperplane either contains all steady states (static ACR) or attracts all trajectories (dynamic ACR). The implication for the underlying biological system is robustness in the concentration of one of the species independent of the initial conditions as well as independent of the concentration of all other species. Identifying network conditions for dynamic ACR is a challenging problem. We lay the groundwork in this paper by studying small reaction networks, those with 2 reactions and 2 species. We give a complete classification by ACR properties of these minimal reaction networks. The dynamics is rich even within this simple setting. Insights obtained from this work will help illuminate the properties of more complex networks with dynamic ACR.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2022; v1 submitted 20 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Multistationarity in cyclic sequestration-transmutation networks
Authors:
Gheorghe Craciun,
Badal Joshi,
Casian Pantea,
Ike Tan
Abstract:
We consider a natural class of reaction networks which consist of reactions where either two species can inactivate each other (i.e., sequestration), or some species can be transformed into another (i.e., transmutation), in a way that gives rise to a feedback cycle. We completely characterize the capacity of multistationarity of these networks. This is especially interesting because such networks…
▽ More
We consider a natural class of reaction networks which consist of reactions where either two species can inactivate each other (i.e., sequestration), or some species can be transformed into another (i.e., transmutation), in a way that gives rise to a feedback cycle. We completely characterize the capacity of multistationarity of these networks. This is especially interesting because such networks provide simple examples of "atoms of multistationarity", i.e., minimal networks that can give rise to multiple positive steady states
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2022; v1 submitted 26 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Homeostasis and injectivity: a reaction network perspective
Authors:
Gheorghe Craciun,
Abhishek Deshpande
Abstract:
Homeostasis is a mechanism by which a feature can remain invariant with change in external parameters. We adopt the definition of homeostasis in the context of singularity theory. We make a connection between homeostasis and the theory of injective reaction networks. In particular, we show that a reaction network cannot exhibit homeostasis if a modified reaction network (which we call the homeosta…
▽ More
Homeostasis is a mechanism by which a feature can remain invariant with change in external parameters. We adopt the definition of homeostasis in the context of singularity theory. We make a connection between homeostasis and the theory of injective reaction networks. In particular, we show that a reaction network cannot exhibit homeostasis if a modified reaction network (which we call the homeostasis-associated reaction network) is injective. We provide examples of reaction networks which can or cannot exhibit homeostasis by analyzing the injectivity of the homeostasis-associated reaction network.
△ Less
Submitted 30 April, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Foundations of Static and Dynamic Absolute Concentration Robustness
Authors:
Badal Joshi,
Gheorghe Craciun
Abstract:
Absolute Concentration Robustness (ACR) was introduced by Shinar and Feinberg as robustness of equilibrium species concentration in a mass action dynamical system. Their aim was to devise a mathematical condition that will ensure robustness in the function of the biological system being modeled. The robustness of function rests on what we refer to as empirical robustness -- the concentration of a…
▽ More
Absolute Concentration Robustness (ACR) was introduced by Shinar and Feinberg as robustness of equilibrium species concentration in a mass action dynamical system. Their aim was to devise a mathematical condition that will ensure robustness in the function of the biological system being modeled. The robustness of function rests on what we refer to as empirical robustness -- the concentration of a species remains unvarying, when measured in the long run, across arbitrary initial conditions. Even simple examples show that the ACR notion introduced in Shinar and Feinberg (here referred to as static ACR) is neither necessary nor sufficient for empirical robustness. To make a stronger connection with empirical robustness, we define dynamic ACR, a property related to long-term, global dynamics, rather than only to equilibrium behavior. We discuss general dynamical systems with dynamic ACR properties as well as parametrized families of dynamical systems related to reaction networks. We find necessary and sufficient conditions for dynamic ACR in complex balanced reaction networks, a class of networks that is central to the theory of reaction networks.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2022; v1 submitted 28 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Autocatalytic systems and recombination: a reaction network perspective
Authors:
Gheorghe Craciun,
Abhishek Deshpande,
Badal Joshi,
Polly Y. Yu
Abstract:
Autocatalytic systems are very often incorporated in the "origin of life" models, a connection that has been analyzed in the context of the classical hypercycles introduced by Manfred Eigen. We investigate the dynamics of certain networks called bimolecular autocatalytic systems. In particular, we consider the dynamics corresponding to the relative populations in these networks, and show that they…
▽ More
Autocatalytic systems are very often incorporated in the "origin of life" models, a connection that has been analyzed in the context of the classical hypercycles introduced by Manfred Eigen. We investigate the dynamics of certain networks called bimolecular autocatalytic systems. In particular, we consider the dynamics corresponding to the relative populations in these networks, and show that they can be analyzed by studying well-chosen autonomous polynomial dynamical systems. Moreover, we find that one can use results from reaction network theory to prove persistence and permanence of several types of bimolecular autocatalytic systems called autocatalytic recombination networks.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Minimal invariant regions and minimal globally attracting regions for toric differential inclusions
Authors:
Yida Ding,
Abhishek Deshpande,
Gheorghe Craciun
Abstract:
Toric differential inclusions occur as key dynamical systems in the context of the Global Attractor Conjecture. We introduce the notions of minimal invariant regions and minimal globally attracting regions for toric differential inclusions. We describe a procedure for constructing explicitly the minimal invariant and minimal globally attracting regions for two-dimensional toric differential inclus…
▽ More
Toric differential inclusions occur as key dynamical systems in the context of the Global Attractor Conjecture. We introduce the notions of minimal invariant regions and minimal globally attracting regions for toric differential inclusions. We describe a procedure for constructing explicitly the minimal invariant and minimal globally attracting regions for two-dimensional toric differential inclusions. In particular, we obtain invariant regions and globally attracting regions for two-dimensional weakly reversible or endotactic dynamical systems (even if they have time-dependent parameters).
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Delay stability of reaction systems
Authors:
Gheorghe Craciun,
Maya Mincheva,
Casian Pantea,
Polly Y. Yu
Abstract:
Delay differential equations are used as a model when the effect of past states has to be taken into account. In this work we consider delay models of chemical reaction networks with mass action kinetics. We obtain a sufficient condition for absolute delay stability of equilibrium concentrations, i.e., local asymptotic stability independent of the delay parameters. Several interesting examples on…
▽ More
Delay differential equations are used as a model when the effect of past states has to be taken into account. In this work we consider delay models of chemical reaction networks with mass action kinetics. We obtain a sufficient condition for absolute delay stability of equilibrium concentrations, i.e., local asymptotic stability independent of the delay parameters. Several interesting examples on sequestration networks with delays are presented.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2020; v1 submitted 10 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Weakly reversible mass-action systems with infinitely many positive steady states
Authors:
Balázs Boros,
Gheorghe Craciun,
Polly Y. Yu
Abstract:
We show that weakly reversible mass-action systems can have a continuum of positive steady states, coming from the zeroes of a multivariate polynomial. Moreover, the same is true of systems whose underlying reaction network is reversible and has a single connected component. In our construction, we relate operations on the reaction network to the multivariate polynomial occurring as a common facto…
▽ More
We show that weakly reversible mass-action systems can have a continuum of positive steady states, coming from the zeroes of a multivariate polynomial. Moreover, the same is true of systems whose underlying reaction network is reversible and has a single connected component. In our construction, we relate operations on the reaction network to the multivariate polynomial occurring as a common factor in the system of differential equations.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2020; v1 submitted 21 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Endotactic Networks and Toric Differential Inclusions
Authors:
Gheorghe Craciun,
Abhishek Deshpande
Abstract:
An important dynamical property of biological interaction networks is persistence, which intuitively means that "no species goes extinct". It has been conjectured that dynamical system models of weakly reversible networks (i.e., networks for which each reaction is part of a cycle) are persistent. The property of persistence is also related to the well known global attractor conjecture. An approach…
▽ More
An important dynamical property of biological interaction networks is persistence, which intuitively means that "no species goes extinct". It has been conjectured that dynamical system models of weakly reversible networks (i.e., networks for which each reaction is part of a cycle) are persistent. The property of persistence is also related to the well known global attractor conjecture. An approach for the proof of the global attractor conjecture uses an embedding of weakly reversible dynamical systems into toric differential inclusions. We show that the larger class of endotactic dynamical systems can also be embedded into toric differential inclusions. Moreover, we show that, essentially, endotactic networks form the largest class of networks with this property.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Mathematical Analysis of Chemical Reaction Systems
Authors:
Polly Y. Yu,
Gheorghe Craciun
Abstract:
The use of mathematical methods for the analysis of chemical reaction systems has a very long history, and involves many types of models: deterministic versus stochastic, continuous versus discrete, and homogeneous versus spatially distributed. Here we focus on mathematical models based on deterministic mass-action kinetics. These models are systems of coupled nonlinear differential equations on t…
▽ More
The use of mathematical methods for the analysis of chemical reaction systems has a very long history, and involves many types of models: deterministic versus stochastic, continuous versus discrete, and homogeneous versus spatially distributed. Here we focus on mathematical models based on deterministic mass-action kinetics. These models are systems of coupled nonlinear differential equations on the positive orthant. We explain how mathematical properties of the solutions of mass-action systems are strongly related to key properties of the networks of chemical reactions that generate them, such as specific versions of reversibility and feedback interactions.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Lyapunov functions, stationary distributions, and non-equilibrium potential for chemical reaction networks
Authors:
David F. Anderson,
Gheorghe Craciun,
Manoj Gopalkrishnan,
Carsten Wiuf
Abstract:
We consider the relationship between stationary distributions for stochastic models of reaction systems and Lyapunov functions for their deterministic counterparts. Specifically, we derive the well known Lyapunov function of reaction network theory as a scaling limit of the non-equilibrium potential of the stationary distribution of stochastically modeled complex balanced systems. We extend this r…
▽ More
We consider the relationship between stationary distributions for stochastic models of reaction systems and Lyapunov functions for their deterministic counterparts. Specifically, we derive the well known Lyapunov function of reaction network theory as a scaling limit of the non-equilibrium potential of the stationary distribution of stochastically modeled complex balanced systems. We extend this result to general birth-death models and demonstrate via example that similar scaling limits can yield Lyapunov functions even for models that are not complex or detailed balanced, and may even have multiple equilibria.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2015; v1 submitted 17 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
A Dimension Reduction Method for Inferring Biochemical Networks
Authors:
Gheorghe Craciun,
Casian Pantea,
Grzegorz A. Rempala
Abstract:
We present herein an extension of an algebraic statistical method for inferring biochemical reaction networks from experimental data, proposed recently in [3]. This extension allows us to analyze reaction networks that are not necessarily full-dimensional, i.e., the dimension of their stoichiometric space is smaller than the number of species. Specifically, we propose to augment the original alg…
▽ More
We present herein an extension of an algebraic statistical method for inferring biochemical reaction networks from experimental data, proposed recently in [3]. This extension allows us to analyze reaction networks that are not necessarily full-dimensional, i.e., the dimension of their stoichiometric space is smaller than the number of species. Specifically, we propose to augment the original algebraic-statistical algorithm for network inference with a preprocessing step that identifies the subspace spanned by the correct reaction vectors, within the space spanned by the species. This dimension reduction step is based on principal component analysis of the input data and its relationship with various subspaces generated by sets of candidate reaction vectors. Simulated examples are provided to illustrate the main ideas involved in implementing this method, and to asses its performance.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2009;
originally announced February 2009.
-
Algebraic Methods for Inferring Biochemical Networks: a Maximum Likelihood Approach
Authors:
Gheorghe Craciun,
Casian Pantea,
Grzegorz A. Rempala
Abstract:
We present a novel method for identifying a biochemical reaction network based on multiple sets of estimated reaction rates in the corresponding reaction rate equations arriving from various (possibly different) experiments. The current method, unlike some of the graphical approaches proposed in the literature, uses the values of the experimental measurements only relative to the geometry of the…
▽ More
We present a novel method for identifying a biochemical reaction network based on multiple sets of estimated reaction rates in the corresponding reaction rate equations arriving from various (possibly different) experiments. The current method, unlike some of the graphical approaches proposed in the literature, uses the values of the experimental measurements only relative to the geometry of the biochemical reactions under the assumption that the underlying reaction network is the same for all the experiments.
The proposed approach utilizes algebraic statistical methods in order to parametrize the set of possible reactions so as to identify the most likely network structure, and is easily scalable to very complicated biochemical systems involving a large number of species and reactions. The method is illustrated with a numerical example of a hypothetical network arising form a "mass transfer"-type model.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2008; v1 submitted 2 October, 2008;
originally announced October 2008.
