-
Modeling Suggests Combined-Drug Treatments for Disorders Impairing Synaptic Plasticity via Shared Signaling Pathways
Authors:
Paul Smolen,
Douglas A Baxter,
John H Byrne
Abstract:
Genetic disorders such as Rubinstein-Taybi syndrome (RTS) and Coffin-Lowry syndrome (CLS) cause lifelong cognitive disability, including deficits in learning and memory. Can pharmacological therapies be suggested to improve learning and memory in these disorders? To address this question, we simulated drug effects within a computational model describing induction of late long-term potentiation (L-…
▽ More
Genetic disorders such as Rubinstein-Taybi syndrome (RTS) and Coffin-Lowry syndrome (CLS) cause lifelong cognitive disability, including deficits in learning and memory. Can pharmacological therapies be suggested to improve learning and memory in these disorders? To address this question, we simulated drug effects within a computational model describing induction of late long-term potentiation (L-LTP). Biochemical pathways impaired in these and other disorders converge on a common target, histone acetylation by acetyltransferases such as CREB binding protein (CBP), which facilitates gene induction necessary for L-LTP. We focused on four drug classes: tropomyosin receptor kinase B (TrkB) agonists, cAMP phosphodiesterase inhibitors, histone deacetylase inhibitors, and ampakines. Simulations suggested each drug type alone may rescue deficits in L-LTP. A potential disadvantage, however, was the necessity of simulating strong drug effects (high doses), which could produce adverse side effects. Thus, we investigated the effects of six drug pairs among the four classes described above. These combination treatments normalized impaired L-LTP with substantially smaller drug doses. In addition three of these combinations, a TrkB agonist paired with an ampakine and a cAMP phosphodiesterase inhibitor paired with a TrkB agonist or an ampakine, exhibited strong synergism in L-LTP rescue. Therefore, we suggest these drug combinations are promising candidates for further empirical studies in animal models of genetic disorders that impair acetylation, L-LTP, and learning.
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Comparing Theories for the Maintenance of Late LTP and Long-Term Memory: Computational Analysis of the Roles of Kinase Feedback Pathways and Synaptic Reactivation
Authors:
Paul Smolen,
Douglas A. Baxter,
John H. Byrne
Abstract:
How can memories be maintained from days to a lifetime, given turnover of proteins that underlie expression of long-term synaptic potentiation (LTP)? One likely solution relies on synaptic positive feedback loops, prominently including persistent activation of CaM kinase II (CaMKII) and self-activated synthesis of protein kinase M zeta (PKM). Recent studies also suggest positive feedback based on…
▽ More
How can memories be maintained from days to a lifetime, given turnover of proteins that underlie expression of long-term synaptic potentiation (LTP)? One likely solution relies on synaptic positive feedback loops, prominently including persistent activation of CaM kinase II (CaMKII) and self-activated synthesis of protein kinase M zeta (PKM). Recent studies also suggest positive feedback based on recurrent synaptic reactivation within neuron assemblies, or engrams, is necessary to maintain memories. The relative importance of these feedback mechanisms is controversial. To explore the likelihood that each mechanism is necessary or sufficient, we simulated LTP maintenance with a simplified model incorporating persistent kinase activation, synaptic tagging, and preferential reactivation of strong synapses, and analyzed implications of recent data. We simulated three model variants, each maintaining LTP with one feedback loop: self-activated PKM synthesis (variant I); self-activated CamKII (variant II); and recurrent reactivation of strengthened synapses (variant III). Variant I requires and predicts that PKM must contribute to synaptic tagging. Variant II maintains LTP and suggests persistent CaMKII activation could maintain PKM activity, a feedforward interaction not previously considered. However we note data challenging this feedback loop. In variant III synaptic reactivation drives, and thus predicts, recurrent or persistent activity elevations of CamKII and other necessary kinases, plausibly contributing to empirically persistent elevation of PKM levels. Reactivation is thus predicted to sustain recurrent rounds of synaptic tagging and incorporation of plasticity-related proteins. We also suggest (model variant IV) that synaptic reactivation and autonomous kinase activation could synergistically maintain LTP. We propose experiments that could discriminate these maintenance mechanisms.
△ Less
Submitted 26 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
How Can Memories Last for Days, Years, or a Lifetime? Proposed Mechanisms for Maintaining Synaptic Potentiation and Memory
Authors:
Paul Smolen,
Douglas A. Baxter,
John H. Byrne
Abstract:
With memory encoding reliant on persistent changes in the properties of synapses, a key question is how can memories be maintained from days to months or a lifetime given molecular turnover? It is likely that positive feedback loops are necessary to persistently maintain the strength of synapses that participate in encoding. Such feedback may occur within signal-transduction cascades and/or the re…
▽ More
With memory encoding reliant on persistent changes in the properties of synapses, a key question is how can memories be maintained from days to months or a lifetime given molecular turnover? It is likely that positive feedback loops are necessary to persistently maintain the strength of synapses that participate in encoding. Such feedback may occur within signal-transduction cascades and/or the regulation of translation, and it may occur within specific subcellular compartments or within neuronal networks. Not surprisingly, numerous positive feedback loops have been proposed. Some posited loops operate at the level of biochemical signal transduction cascades, such as persistent activation of calcium/calmodulin kinase II or protein kinase M. Another level consists of feedback loops involving transcriptional, epigenetic and translational pathways, and autocrine actions of growth factors such as BDNF. Finally, at the neuronal network level, recurrent reactivation of cell assemblies encoding memories is likely to be essential for late maintenance of memory. These levels are not isolated, but linked by shared components of feedback loops. Here, we review characteristics of some commonly discussed feedback loops proposed to underlie the maintenance of memory and long-term synaptic plasticity, assess evidence for and against their necessity, and suggest experiments that could further delineate the dynamics of these feedback loops. We also discuss crosstalk between proposed loops, and ways in which such interaction can facilitate the rapidity and robustness of memory formation and storage.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2019; v1 submitted 13 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Paradoxical LTP maintenance with inhibition of protein synthesis and the proteasome suggests a novel protein synthesis requirement for early LTP reversal
Authors:
Paul Smolen,
Douglas A. Baxter,
John H. Byrne
Abstract:
The transition from early long-term potentiation (E-LTP) to late LTP (L-LTP) involves protein synthesis and degradation. L-LTP is blocked by inhibiting either protein synthesis or proteasome-dependent degradation prior to and during a tetanic stimulus, but paradoxically, L-LTP is not blocked when synthesis and degradation are inhibited simultaneously, suggesting counter-acting positive and negativ…
▽ More
The transition from early long-term potentiation (E-LTP) to late LTP (L-LTP) involves protein synthesis and degradation. L-LTP is blocked by inhibiting either protein synthesis or proteasome-dependent degradation prior to and during a tetanic stimulus, but paradoxically, L-LTP is not blocked when synthesis and degradation are inhibited simultaneously, suggesting counter-acting positive and negative proteins regulate L-LTP. To investigate this paradox, we modeled LTP at the Schaffer collateral synapse. Nine differential equations describe the levels of positive and negative regulator proteins (PP and NP) and transitions among five discrete synaptic states, a basal state (BAS), three E-LTP states (EP1, EP2, ED), and a L-LTP state (LP). A stimulus initiates the transition from BAS to EP1 and from EP1 to EP2, initiates the synthesis of PP and NP, and activates the ubiquitin-proteasome system (UPS). UPS mediates transitions of EP1 and EP2 to ED and the degradation of NP. The conversion of E-LTP to L-LTP is mediated by a PP-dependent transition from ED to LP. NP mediates reversal of EP2 to BAS. This model simulates empirical observations: 1) normal L-LTP, 2) block by either proteasome inhibitor or protein synthesis inhibitor alone, and 3) preservation of L-LTP when both inhibitors are applied together. Elements of this abstract model can be correlated with specific molecules and processes. Moreover, the model makes testable predictions, such as a unique synaptic state ED that precedes the transition to L-LTP, and a time window for the action of the UPS (during the transitions from EP1 and EP2 to ED). Tests of these predictions will provide insights into the processes of long-term synaptic plasticity.
△ Less
Submitted 20 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
The right time to learn: mechanisms and optimization of spaced learning
Authors:
Paul Smolen,
Yili Zhang,
John H. Byrne
Abstract:
For many types of learning, spaced training that involves repeated long inter-trial intervals (ITIs) leads to more robust memory formation than does massed training that involves short or no intervals. Several cognitive theories have been proposed to explain this superiority, but only recently has data begun to delineate the underlying cellular and molecular mechanisms of spaced training. We revie…
▽ More
For many types of learning, spaced training that involves repeated long inter-trial intervals (ITIs) leads to more robust memory formation than does massed training that involves short or no intervals. Several cognitive theories have been proposed to explain this superiority, but only recently has data begun to delineate the underlying cellular and molecular mechanisms of spaced training. We review these theories and data here. Computational models of the implicated signaling cascades have predicted that spaced training with irregular ITIs can enhance learning. This strategy of using models to predict optimal spaced training protocols, combined with pharmacotherapy, suggests novel ways to rescue impaired synaptic plasticity and learning.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
-
Simulations Suggest Pharmacological Methods for Rescuing Long-Term Potentiation
Authors:
Paul Smolen,
Douglas A. Baxter,
John H. Byrne
Abstract:
Congenital cognitive dysfunctions are frequently due to deficits in molecular pathways that underlie synaptic plasticity. For example, Rubinstein-Taybi syndrome (RTS) is due to a mutation in cbp, encoding the histone acetyltransferase CREB-binding protein (CBP). CBP is a transcriptional co-activator for CREB, and induction of CREB-dependent transcription plays a key role in long-term memory (LTM).…
▽ More
Congenital cognitive dysfunctions are frequently due to deficits in molecular pathways that underlie synaptic plasticity. For example, Rubinstein-Taybi syndrome (RTS) is due to a mutation in cbp, encoding the histone acetyltransferase CREB-binding protein (CBP). CBP is a transcriptional co-activator for CREB, and induction of CREB-dependent transcription plays a key role in long-term memory (LTM). In animal models of RTS, mutations of cbp impair LTM and late-phase long-term potentiation (LTP). To explore intervention strategies to rescue the deficits in LTP, we extended a previous model of LTP induction to describe histone acetylation and simulated LTP impairment due to cbp mutation. Plausible drug effects were simulated by parameter changes, and many increased LTP. However no parameter variation consistent with a biochemical effect of a known drug fully restored LTP. Thus we examined paired parameter variations. A pair that simulated the effects of a phosphodiesterase inhibitor (slowing cAMP degradation) concurrent with a deacetylase inhibitor (prolonging histone acetylation) restored LTP. Importantly these paired parameter changes did not alter basal synaptic weight. A pair that simulated a phosphodiesterase inhibitor and an acetyltransferase activator was similarly effective. For both pairs strong additive synergism was present. These results suggest that promoting histone acetylation while simultaneously slowing the degradation of cAMP may constitute a promising strategy for restoring deficits in LTP that may be associated with learning deficits in RTS. More generally these results illustrate the strategy of combining modeling and empirical studies may help design effective therapies for improving long-term synaptic plasticity and learning in cognitive disorders.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2014;
originally announced August 2014.
-
Interlinked Dual-Time Feedback Loops can Enhance Robustness to Stochasticity and Persistence of Memory
Authors:
Paul Smolen,
Douglas A. Baxter,
John H. Byrne
Abstract:
Multiple interlinked positive feedback loops shape the stimulus responses of various biochemical systems, such as the cell cycle or intracellular calcium release. Recent studies with simplified models have identified two advantages of coupling fast and slow feedback loops. Namely, this dual-time structure enables a fast response while enhancing resistances of responses and bistability to stimulus…
▽ More
Multiple interlinked positive feedback loops shape the stimulus responses of various biochemical systems, such as the cell cycle or intracellular calcium release. Recent studies with simplified models have identified two advantages of coupling fast and slow feedback loops. Namely, this dual-time structure enables a fast response while enhancing resistances of responses and bistability to stimulus noise. We now find that in addition: 1) the dual-time structure confers resistance to internal noise due to molecule number fluctuations, and 2) model variants with altered coupling, which better represent some specific systems, share all the above advantages. We develop a similar bistable model with a fast autoactivation loop coupled to a slow loop, which minimally represents positive feedback that may be essential for long-term synaptic potentiation (LTP). The advantages of fast response and noise resistance carry over to this model. Empirically, LTP develops resistance to reversal over ~1 h. The model suggests this resistance may result from increased amounts of synaptic kinases involved in positive feedback.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
Molecular Constraints on Synaptic Tagging and Maintenance of Long-Term Potentiation: A Predictive Model
Authors:
Paul Smolen,
Douglas A. Baxter,
John H. Byrne
Abstract:
Protein synthesis-dependent, late long-term potentiation (LTP) and depression (LTD) at glutamatergic hippocampal synapses are well characterized examples of long-term synaptic plasticity. Persistent increased activity of the enzyme protein kinase M (PKM) is thought essential for maintaining LTP. Additional spatial and temporal features that govern LTP and LTD induction are embodied in the synaptic…
▽ More
Protein synthesis-dependent, late long-term potentiation (LTP) and depression (LTD) at glutamatergic hippocampal synapses are well characterized examples of long-term synaptic plasticity. Persistent increased activity of the enzyme protein kinase M (PKM) is thought essential for maintaining LTP. Additional spatial and temporal features that govern LTP and LTD induction are embodied in the synaptic tagging and capture (STC) and cross capture hypotheses. Only synapses that have been "tagged" by an stimulus sufficient for LTP and learning can "capture" PKM. A model was developed to simulate the dynamics of key molecules required for LTP and LTD. The model concisely represents relationships between tagging, capture, LTD, and LTP maintenance. The model successfully simulated LTP maintained by persistent synaptic PKM, STC, LTD, and cross capture, and makes testable predictions concerning the dynamics of PKM. The maintenance of LTP, and consequently of at least some forms of long-term memory, is predicted to require continual positive feedback in which PKM enhances its own synthesis only at potentiated synapses. This feedback underlies bistability in the activity of PKM. Second, cross capture requires the induction of LTD to induce dendritic PKM synthesis, although this may require tagging of a nearby synapse for LTP. The model also simulates the effects of PKM inhibition, and makes additional predictions for the dynamics of CaM kinases. Experiments testing the above predictions would significantly advance the understanding of memory maintenance.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2012; v1 submitted 16 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
-
Bistable MAP Kinase Activity: A Plausible Mechanism Contributing to Maintenance of Late Long-Term Potentiation
Authors:
Paul Smolen,
Douglas A. Baxter,
John H. Byrne
Abstract:
Bistability of MAP kinase (MAPK) activity has been suggested to contribute to several cellular processes, including differentiation and long-term synaptic potentiation. A recent model (48) predicts bistability due to interactions of the kinases and phosphatases in the MAPK pathway, without feedback from MAPK to earlier reactions. Using this model and enzyme concentrations appropriate for neurons…
▽ More
Bistability of MAP kinase (MAPK) activity has been suggested to contribute to several cellular processes, including differentiation and long-term synaptic potentiation. A recent model (48) predicts bistability due to interactions of the kinases and phosphatases in the MAPK pathway, without feedback from MAPK to earlier reactions. Using this model and enzyme concentrations appropriate for neurons, we simulated bistable MAPK activity, but bistability only was present within a relatively narrow range of activity of Raf, the first pathway kinase. Stochastic fluctuations in molecule numbers eliminated bistability for small molecule numbers, such as are expected in the volume of a dendritic spine. However, positive feedback loops have been posited from MAPK up to Raf activation. One proposed loop in which MAPK directly activates Raf was incorporated into the model. We found that such feedback greatly enhanced the robustness of both stable states of MAPK activity to stochastic fluctuations and to parameter variations. Bistability was robust for molecule numbers plausible for a dendritic spine volume. The upper state of MAPK activity was resistant to inhibition of MEK activation for > 1 h, suggesting inhibitor experiments have not sufficed to rule out a role for persistent MAPK activity in LTP maintenance. These simulations suggest that persistent MAPK activity and consequent upregulation of translation may contribute to LTP maintenance and to long-term memory. Experiments using a fluorescent MAPK substrate may further test this hypothesis.
△ Less
Submitted 18 February, 2008;
originally announced February 2008.
-
A Model of the Roles of Essential Kinases in the Induction and Expression of Late Long-Term Potentiation
Authors:
Paul Smolen,
Douglas A. Baxter,
John H. Byrne
Abstract:
The induction of late long-term potentiation (L-LTP) involves complex interactions among second messenger cascades. To gain insights into these interactions, a mathematical model was developed for L-LTP induction in the CA1 region of the hippocampus. The differential equation-based model represents actions of protein kinase A (PKA), MAP kinase (MAPK), and CaM kinase II (CAMKII) in the vicinity o…
▽ More
The induction of late long-term potentiation (L-LTP) involves complex interactions among second messenger cascades. To gain insights into these interactions, a mathematical model was developed for L-LTP induction in the CA1 region of the hippocampus. The differential equation-based model represents actions of protein kinase A (PKA), MAP kinase (MAPK), and CaM kinase II (CAMKII) in the vicinity of the synapse, and activation of transcription by CaM kinase IV (CAMKIV) and MAPK. L-LTP is represented by increases in a synaptic weight. Simulations suggest that steep, supralinear stimulus-response relationships between stimuli (elevations in [Ca2+]) and kinase activation are essential for translating brief stimuli into long-lasting gene activation and synaptic weight increases. Convergence of multiple kinase activities to induce L-LTP helps to generate a threshold whereby the amount of L-LTP varies steeply with the number of tetanic electrical stimuli. The model simulates tetanic, theta-burst, pairing-induced, and chemical L-LTP, as well as L-LTP due to synaptic tagging. The model also simulates inhibition of L-LTP by inhibition of MAPK, CAMKII, PKA, or CAMKIV. The model predicts results of experiments to delineate mechanisms underlying L-LTP induction and expression. For example, the cAMP antagonist RpcAMPs, which inhibits L-LTP induction, is predicted to inhibit ERK activation. The model also appears useful to clarify similarities and differences between hippocampal L-LTP and long-term synaptic strengthening in other systems.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 2006;
originally announced January 2006.
-
Simulation of Drosophila Circadian Oscillations, Mutations, and Light Responses by a Model with VRI, PDP-1, and CLK
Authors:
Paul Smolen,
Paul E. Hardin,
Brian S. Lo,
Douglas A. Baxter,
John H. Byrne
Abstract:
A model of Drosophila circadian rhythm generation was developed to represent feedback loops based on transcriptional regulation of per, Clk (dclock), Pdp-1, and vri (vrille). The model postulates that histone acetylation kinetics make transcriptional activation a nonlinear function of [CLK]. Such a nonlinearity is essential to simulate robust circadian oscillations of transcription in our model…
▽ More
A model of Drosophila circadian rhythm generation was developed to represent feedback loops based on transcriptional regulation of per, Clk (dclock), Pdp-1, and vri (vrille). The model postulates that histone acetylation kinetics make transcriptional activation a nonlinear function of [CLK]. Such a nonlinearity is essential to simulate robust circadian oscillations of transcription in our model and in previous models. Simulations suggest two positive feedback loops involving Clk are not essential for oscillations, because oscillations of [PER] were preserved when Clk, vri, or Pdp-1 expression was fixed. Eliminating the negative feedback loop in which PER represses per expression abolished oscillations. Simulations of per or Clk null mutations and of vri, Clk, or Pdp-1 heterozygous null mutations altered model behavior in ways similar to experimental data. The model simulated a photic phase-response curve resembling experimental curves, and oscillations entrained to simulated light-dark cycles. The model makes experimental predictions, some of which could be tested in transgenic Drosophila.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2004;
originally announced January 2004.
