Neural mechanisms of predictive processing: a collaborative community experiment through the OpenScope program
Authors:
Ido Aizenbud,
Nicholas Audette,
Ryszard Auksztulewicz,
Krzysztof Basiński,
André M. Bastos,
Michael Berry,
Andres Canales-Johnson,
Hannah Choi,
Claudia Clopath,
Uri Cohen,
Rui Ponte Costa,
Roberto De Filippo,
Roman Doronin,
Steven P. Errington,
Jeffrey P. Gavornik,
Colleen J. Gillon,
Arno Granier,
Jordan P. Hamm,
Loreen Hertäg,
Henry Kennedy,
Sandeep Kumar,
Alexander Ladd,
Hugo Ladret,
Jérôme A. Lecoq,
Alexander Maier
, et al. (25 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
This review synthesizes advances in predictive processing within the sensory cortex. Predictive processing theorizes that the brain continuously predicts sensory inputs, refining neuronal responses by highlighting prediction errors. We identify key computational primitives, such as stimulus adaptation, dendritic computation, excitatory/inhibitory balance and hierarchical processing, as central to…
▽ More
This review synthesizes advances in predictive processing within the sensory cortex. Predictive processing theorizes that the brain continuously predicts sensory inputs, refining neuronal responses by highlighting prediction errors. We identify key computational primitives, such as stimulus adaptation, dendritic computation, excitatory/inhibitory balance and hierarchical processing, as central to this framework. Our review highlights convergences, such as top-down inputs and inhibitory interneurons shaping mismatch signals, and divergences, including species-specific hierarchies and modality-dependent layer roles. To address these conflicts, we propose experiments in mice and primates using in-vivo two-photon imaging and electrophysiological recordings to test whether temporal, motor, and omission mismatch stimuli engage shared or distinct mechanisms. The resulting dataset, collected and shared via the OpenScope program, will enable model validation and community analysis, fostering iterative refinement and refutability to decode the neural circuits of predictive processing.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
Information-theoretic analyses of neural data to minimize the effect of researchers' assumptions in predictive coding studies
Authors:
Patricia Wollstadt,
Daniel L. Rathbun,
W. Martin Usrey and,
André Moraes Bastos,
Michael Lindner,
Viola Priesemann,
Michael Wibral
Abstract:
Studies investigating neural information processing often implicitly ask both, which processing strategy out of several alternatives is used and how this strategy is implemented in neural dynamics. A prime example are studies on predictive coding. These often ask if confirmed predictions about inputs or predictions errors between internal predictions and inputs are passed on in a hierarchical neur…
▽ More
Studies investigating neural information processing often implicitly ask both, which processing strategy out of several alternatives is used and how this strategy is implemented in neural dynamics. A prime example are studies on predictive coding. These often ask if confirmed predictions about inputs or predictions errors between internal predictions and inputs are passed on in a hierarchical neural system--while at the same time looking for the neural correlates of coding for errors and predictions. If we do not know exactly what a neural system predicts at any given moment, this results in a circular analysis--as has been criticized correctly. To circumvent such circular analysis, we propose to express information processing strategies (such as predictive coding) by local information-theoretic quantities, such that they can be estimated directly from neural data. We demonstrate our approach by investigating two opposing accounts of predictive coding-like processing strategies, where we quantify the building blocks of predictive coding, namely predictability of inputs and transfer of information, by local active information storage and local transfer entropy. We define testable hypotheses on the relationship of both quantities to identify which of the assumed strategies was used. We demonstrate our approach on spiking data from the retinogeniculate synapse of the cat. Applying our local information dynamics framework, we are able to show that the synapse codes for predictable rather than surprising input. To support our findings, we apply measures from partial information decomposition, which allow to differentiate if the transferred information is primarily bottom-up sensory input or information transferred conditionally on the current state of the synapse. Supporting our local information-theoretic results, we find that the synapse preferentially transfers bottom-up information.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 2023; v1 submitted 21 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
