Showing 1–50 of 128 results for author: Bassett, D S

Towards principles of brain network organization and function

Authors: Suman Kulkarni, Dani S. Bassett

Abstract: The brain is immensely complex, with diverse components and dynamic interactions building upon one another to orchestrate a wide range of functions and behaviors. Understanding patterns of these complex interactions and how they are coordinated to support collective neural activity and function is critical for parsing human and animal behavior, treating mental illness, and developing artificial in… ▽ More The brain is immensely complex, with diverse components and dynamic interactions building upon one another to orchestrate a wide range of functions and behaviors. Understanding patterns of these complex interactions and how they are coordinated to support collective neural activity and function is critical for parsing human and animal behavior, treating mental illness, and developing artificial intelligence. Rapid experimental advances in imaging, recording, and perturbing neural systems across various species now provide opportunities and challenges to distill underlying principles of brain organization and function. Here, we take stock of recent progresses and review methods used in the statistical analysis of brain networks, drawing from fields of statistical physics, network theory and information theory. Our discussion is organized by scale, starting with models of individual neurons and extending to large-scale networks mapped across brain regions. We then examine the organizing principles and constraints that shape the biological structure and function of neural circuits. Finally, we describe current opportunities aimed at improving models in light of recent developments and at bridging across scales to contribute to a better understanding of brain networks. △ Less

Submitted 5 August, 2024; originally announced August 2024.

Comments: Submitted to Annual Review of Biophysics. Comments welcome. When citing this paper, please use the following: Kulkarni S, Bassett DS. 2025. Towards Principles of Brain Network Organization and Function. Annu. Rev. Biophys. 54: Submitted. DOI: 10.1146/annurev-biophys-030722-110624

Human Learning of Hierarchical Graphs

Authors: Xiaohuan Xia, Andrei A. Klishin, Jennifer Stiso, Christopher W. Lynn, Ari E. Kahn, Lorenzo Caciagli, Dani S. Bassett

Abstract: Humans are constantly exposed to sequences of events in the environment. Those sequences frequently evince statistical regularities, such as the probabilities with which one event transitions to another. Collectively, inter-event transition probabilities can be modeled as a graph or network. Many real-world networks are organized hierarchically and understanding how humans learn these networks is… ▽ More Humans are constantly exposed to sequences of events in the environment. Those sequences frequently evince statistical regularities, such as the probabilities with which one event transitions to another. Collectively, inter-event transition probabilities can be modeled as a graph or network. Many real-world networks are organized hierarchically and understanding how humans learn these networks is an ongoing aim of current investigations. While much is known about how humans learn basic transition graph topology, whether and to what degree humans can learn hierarchical structures in such graphs remains unknown. We investigate how humans learn hierarchical graphs of the Sierpiński family using computer simulations and behavioral laboratory experiments. We probe the mental estimates of transition probabilities via the surprisal effect: a phenomenon in which humans react more slowly to less expected transitions, such as those between communities or modules in the network. Using mean-field predictions and numerical simulations, we show that surprisal effects are stronger for finer-level than coarser-level hierarchical transitions. Surprisal effects at coarser levels of the hierarchy are difficult to detect for limited learning times or in small samples. Using a serial response experiment with human participants (n=$100$), we replicate our predictions by detecting a surprisal effect at the finer-level of the hierarchy but not at the coarser-level of the hierarchy. To further explain our findings, we evaluate the presence of a trade-off in learning, whereby humans who learned the finer-level of the hierarchy better tended to learn the coarser-level worse, and vice versa. Our study elucidates the processes by which humans learn hierarchical sequential events. Our work charts a road map for future investigation of the neural underpinnings and behavioral manifestations of graph learning. △ Less

Submitted 5 September, 2023; originally announced September 2023.

Comments: 22 pages, 10 figures, 1 table

Information content of note transitions in the music of J. S. Bach

Authors: Suman Kulkarni, Sophia U. David, Christopher W. Lynn, Dani S. Bassett

Abstract: Music has a complex structure that expresses emotion and conveys information. Humans process that information through imperfect cognitive instruments that produce a gestalt, smeared version of reality. How can we quantify the information contained in a piece of music? Further, what is the information inferred by a human, and how does that relate to (and differ from) the true structure of a piece?… ▽ More Music has a complex structure that expresses emotion and conveys information. Humans process that information through imperfect cognitive instruments that produce a gestalt, smeared version of reality. How can we quantify the information contained in a piece of music? Further, what is the information inferred by a human, and how does that relate to (and differ from) the true structure of a piece? To tackle these questions quantitatively, we present a framework to study the information conveyed in a musical piece by constructing and analyzing networks formed by notes (nodes) and their transitions (edges). Using this framework, we analyze music composed by J. S. Bach through the lens of network science and information theory. Regarded as one of the greatest composers in the Western music tradition, Bach's work is highly mathematically structured and spans a wide range of compositional forms, such as fugues and choral pieces. Conceptualizing each composition as a network of note transitions, we quantify the information contained in each piece and find that different kinds of compositions can be grouped together according to their information content and network structure. Moreover, we find that the music networks communicate large amounts of information while maintaining small deviations of the inferred network from the true network, suggesting that they are structured for efficient communication of information. We probe the network structures that enable this rapid and efficient communication of information--namely, high heterogeneity and strong clustering. Taken together, our findings shed new light on the information and network properties of Bach's compositions. More generally, our framework serves as a stepping stone for exploring musical complexities, creativity and the structure of information in a range of complex systems. △ Less

Submitted 4 September, 2023; v1 submitted 2 January, 2023; originally announced January 2023.

Comments: 22 pages, 13 figure; discussion in section IV and VII expanded, references added, results unchanged

Compression supports low-dimensional representations of behavior across neural circuits

Authors: Dale Zhou, Jason Z. Kim, Adam R. Pines, Valerie J. Sydnor, David R. Roalf, John A. Detre, Ruben C. Gur, Raquel E. Gur, Theodore D. Satterthwaite, Dani S. Bassett

Abstract: Dimensionality reduction, a form of compression, can simplify representations of information to increase efficiency and reveal general patterns. Yet, this simplification also forfeits information, thereby reducing representational capacity. Hence, the brain may benefit from generating both compressed and uncompressed activity, and may do so in a heterogeneous manner across diverse neural circuits… ▽ More Dimensionality reduction, a form of compression, can simplify representations of information to increase efficiency and reveal general patterns. Yet, this simplification also forfeits information, thereby reducing representational capacity. Hence, the brain may benefit from generating both compressed and uncompressed activity, and may do so in a heterogeneous manner across diverse neural circuits that represent low-level (sensory) or high-level (cognitive) stimuli. However, precisely how compression and representational capacity differ across the cortex remains unknown. Here we predict different levels of compression across regional circuits by using random walks on networks to model activity flow and to formulate rate-distortion functions, which are the basis of lossy compression. Using a large sample of youth ($n=1,040$), we test predictions in two ways: by measuring the dimensionality of spontaneous activity from sensorimotor to association cortex, and by assessing the representational capacity for 24 behaviors in neural circuits and 20 cognitive variables in recurrent neural networks. Our network theory of compression predicts the dimensionality of activity ($t=12.13, p<0.001$) and the representational capacity of biological ($r=0.53, p=0.016$) and artificial ($r=0.61, p<0.001$) networks. The model suggests how a basic form of compression is an emergent property of activity flow between distributed circuits that communicate with the rest of the network. △ Less

Submitted 29 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:2001.05078

Controlling collective dynamical states of mesoscale brain networks with local perturbations

Authors: Lia Papadopoulos, Demian Battaglia, Dani S. Bassett

Abstract: Oscillatory synchrony is hypothesized to support the flow of information between brain regions, with different phase-locked configurations enabling activation of different effective interactions. Along these lines, past work has proposed multistable phase-locking as a means for hardwired brain networks to flexibly support multiple functional patterns, without having to reconfigure their anatomical… ▽ More Oscillatory synchrony is hypothesized to support the flow of information between brain regions, with different phase-locked configurations enabling activation of different effective interactions. Along these lines, past work has proposed multistable phase-locking as a means for hardwired brain networks to flexibly support multiple functional patterns, without having to reconfigure their anatomical connections. Given the potential link between interareal communication and phase-locked states, it is thus important to understand how those states might be controlled to achieve rapid alteration of functional connectivity in interareal circuits. Here, we study functional state control in small networks of coupled neural masses that display collective multistability under determinstic conditions, and that display more biologically-realistic irregular oscillations and transient phase-locking when conditions are stochastic. In particular, we investigate the global responses of these mesoscale circuits to external signals that target only a single subunit. Focusing mainly on the more realistic scenario wherein network dynamics are stochastic, we identify conditions under which local inputs (i) can trigger fast transitions to topologically distinct functional connectivity motifs that are temporarily stable ("state switching"), (ii) can smoothly adjust the spatial pattern of phase-relations for a particular set of lead-lag relationships ("state morphing"), and (iii) fail to regulate global phase-locking states. In total, our results add to a growing literature highlighting that the modulation of multistable, interareal coherence patterns could provide a basis for flexible brain network operation. △ Less

Submitted 25 August, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

A structurally informed model for modulating functional connectivity

Authors: Andrew C. Murphy, Romain Duprat, Theodore D. Satterthwaite, Desmond J. Oathes, Dani S. Bassett

Abstract: Functional connectivity (FC) between brain regions tracks symptom severity in many neuropsychiatric disorders. Transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) directly alters regional activity and indirectly alters FC. Predicting how FC will change following TMS is difficult, but would allow novel therapies that target FC to improve symptoms. We address this challenge by proposing a predictive model that… ▽ More Functional connectivity (FC) between brain regions tracks symptom severity in many neuropsychiatric disorders. Transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) directly alters regional activity and indirectly alters FC. Predicting how FC will change following TMS is difficult, but would allow novel therapies that target FC to improve symptoms. We address this challenge by proposing a predictive model that explains how TMS-induced activation can change the strength of FC. Here, we focus on the FC of the frontoparietal (FPS) and default mode (DMS) systems given the importance of their FC in executive function and affective disorders. We fit this model to neuroimaging data in 29 individuals who received TMS to the frontal cortex and evaluated the FC between the FPS and DMS. For each individual, we measured the TMS-induced change in FC between the FPS and DMS (the FC network), and the structural coupling between the stimulated area and the FPS and DMS (the structural context network (SCN)). We find that TMS-induced FC changes are best predicted when the model accounts for white matter fibers from the stimulated area to the two systems. We find that the correlation between these two networks (structure-function coupling) - and therefore the predictability of the TMS-induced modulation - was highest when the SCN contained a dense core of intraconnected regions, indicating that the stimulated area had ample access to an anatomical module. Further, we found that when the core of the SCN overlapped with the FPS and DMS, we observed the greatest change in the strength of their FC. Broadly, our findings explain how the structural connectivity of a stimulated region modulates TMS-induced changes in the brain's functional network. Efforts to account for such structural connections could improve predictions of TMS response, further informing the development of TMS protocols for clinical translation. △ Less

Submitted 24 August, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

Synchronization of coupled Kuramoto oscillators competing for resources

Authors: Keith A. Kroma-Wiley, Peter J. Mucha, Dani S. Bassett

Abstract: Populations of oscillators are present throughout nature. Very often synchronization is observed in such populations if they are allowed to interact. A paradigmatic model for the study of such phenomena has been the Kuramoto model. However, considering real oscillations are rarely isochronous as a function of energy, it is natural to extend the model by allowing the natural frequencies to vary as… ▽ More Populations of oscillators are present throughout nature. Very often synchronization is observed in such populations if they are allowed to interact. A paradigmatic model for the study of such phenomena has been the Kuramoto model. However, considering real oscillations are rarely isochronous as a function of energy, it is natural to extend the model by allowing the natural frequencies to vary as a function of some dynamical resource supply. Beyond just accounting for a dynamical supply of resources, however, competition over a \emph{shared} resource supply is important in a variety of biological systems. In neuronal systems, for example, resource competition enables the study of neural activity via fMRI. It is reasonable to expect that this dynamical resource allocation should have consequences for the synchronization behavior of the brain. This paper presents a modified Kuramoto dynamics which includes additional dynamical terms that provide a relatively simple model of resource competition among populations of Kuramoto oscillators. We design a mutlilayer system which highlights the impact of the competition dynamics, and we show that in this designed system, correlations can arise between the synchronization states of two populations of oscillators which share no phase-coupling edges. These correlations are interesting in light of the often observed variance between functional and structural connectivity measures in real systems. The model presented here then suggests that some of the observed discrepancy may be explained by the way in which the brain dynamically allocates resources to different regions according to demand. If true, models such as this one provide a theoretical framework for analyzing the differences between structural and functional measures, and possibly implicate dynamical resource allocation as an integral part of the neural computation process. △ Less

Submitted 6 June, 2022; originally announced June 2022.

Comments: 12 pages, 2 figures

Modeling observed gender imbalances in academic citation practices

Authors: Jennifer Stiso, Kendra Oudyk, Maxwell M. Bertolero, Dale Zhou, Erin G. Teich, David M. Lydon-Staley, Perry Zurn, Dani S. Bassett

Abstract: In multiple academic disciplines, having a perceived gender of `woman' is associated with a lower than expected rate of citations. In some fields, that disparity is driven primarily by the citations of men and is increasing over time despite increasing diversification of the profession. It is likely that complex social interactions and individual ideologies shape these disparities. Computational m… ▽ More In multiple academic disciplines, having a perceived gender of `woman' is associated with a lower than expected rate of citations. In some fields, that disparity is driven primarily by the citations of men and is increasing over time despite increasing diversification of the profession. It is likely that complex social interactions and individual ideologies shape these disparities. Computational models of select factors that reproduce empirical observations can help us understand some of the minimal driving forces behind these complex phenomena and therefore aid in their mitigation. Here, we present a simple agent-based model of citation practices within academia, in which academics generate citations based on three factors: their estimate of the collaborative network of the field, how they sample that estimate, and how open they are to learning about their field from other academics. We show that increasing homophily -- or the tendency of people to interact with others more like themselves -- in these three domains is sufficient to reproduce observed biases in citation practices. We find that homophily in sampling an estimate of the field influences total citation rates, and openness to learning from new and unfamiliar authors influences the change in those citations over time. We next model a real-world intervention -- the citation diversity statement -- which has the potential to influence both of these parameters. We determine a parameterization of our model that matches the citation practices of academics who use the citation diversity statement. This parameterization paired with an openness to learning from many new authors can result in citation practices that are equitable and stable over time. Ultimately, our work underscores the importance of homophily in shaping citation practices and provides evidence that specific actions may mitigate biased citation practices in academia. △ Less

Submitted 26 April, 2022; originally announced April 2022.

Curiosity as filling, compressing, and reconfiguring knowledge networks

Authors: Shubhankar P. Patankar, Dale Zhou, Christopher W. Lynn, Jason Z. Kim, Mathieu Ouellet, Harang Ju, Perry Zurn, David M. Lydon-Staley, Dani S. Bassett

Abstract: Due to the significant role that curiosity plays in our lives, several theoretical constructs, such as the information gap theory and compression progress theory, have sought to explain how we engage in its practice. According to the former, curiosity is the drive to acquire information that is missing from our understanding of the world. According to the latter, curiosity is the drive to construc… ▽ More Due to the significant role that curiosity plays in our lives, several theoretical constructs, such as the information gap theory and compression progress theory, have sought to explain how we engage in its practice. According to the former, curiosity is the drive to acquire information that is missing from our understanding of the world. According to the latter, curiosity is the drive to construct an increasingly parsimonious mental model of the world. To complement the densification processes inherent to these theories, we propose the conformational change theory, wherein we posit that curiosity results in mental models with marked conceptual flexibility. We formalize curiosity as the process of building a growing knowledge network to quantitatively investigate information gap theory, compression progress theory, and the conformational change theory of curiosity. In knowledge networks, gaps can be identified as topological cavities, compression progress can be quantified using network compressibility, and flexibility can be measured as the number of conformational degrees of freedom. We leverage data acquired from the online encyclopedia Wikipedia to determine the degree to which each theory explains the growth of knowledge networks built by individuals and by collectives. Our findings lend support to a pluralistic view of curiosity, wherein intrinsically motivated information acquisition fills knowledge gaps and simultaneously leads to increasingly compressible and flexible knowledge networks. Across individuals and collectives, we determine the contexts in which each theoretical account may be explanatory, thereby clarifying their complementary and distinct explanations of curiosity. Our findings offer a novel network theoretical perspective on intrinsically motivated information acquisition that may harmonize with or compel an expansion of the traditional taxonomy of curiosity. △ Less

Submitted 3 April, 2022; originally announced April 2022.

Comments: 30 pages, 5 figures in main text, and 14 pages, 5 figures in supplement

The information content of brain states is explained by structural constraints on state energetics

Authors: Leon Weninger, Pragya Srivastava, Dale Zhou, Jason Z. Kim, Eli J. Cornblath, Maxwell A. Bertolero, Ute Habel, Dorit Merhof, Dani S. Bassett

Abstract: Signal propagation along the structural connectome of the brain induces changes in the patterns of activity. These activity patterns define global brain states and contain information in accordance with their expected probability of occurrence. The structural connectome, in conjunction with the dynamics, determines the set of possible brain states and constrains the transition between accessible s… ▽ More Signal propagation along the structural connectome of the brain induces changes in the patterns of activity. These activity patterns define global brain states and contain information in accordance with their expected probability of occurrence. The structural connectome, in conjunction with the dynamics, determines the set of possible brain states and constrains the transition between accessible states. Yet, precisely how these structural constraints on state-transitions relate to their information content remains unexplored. To address this gap in knowledge, we defined the information content as a function of the activation distribution, where statistically rare values of activation correspond to high information content. With this numerical definition in hand, we studied the spatiotemporal distribution of information content in fMRI data from the Human Connectome Project during different tasks, and report four key findings. First, information content strongly depends on the cognitive task. Second, while information content shows similarities to other measures of brain activity, it is distinct from both Neurosynth maps and task contrast maps generated by a general linear model applied to the fMRI data. Third, the brain's structural wiring constrains the cost to control its state, where the cost to transition into high information content states is larger than that to transition into low information content states. Finally, all state transitions - especially those to high information content states - are less costly than expected from random network null models, thereby indicating the brain's marked efficiency. Taken together, our findings establish an explanatory link between the information contained in a brain state and the energetic cost of attaining that state, thereby laying important groundwork for our understanding of large-scale cognitive computations. △ Less

Submitted 15 March, 2023; v1 submitted 26 October, 2021; originally announced October 2021.

Comments: 16 pages, 4 figures + supplement (5 pages, 5 figures)

MSC Class: 93-08 (primary); 92-08; 94-05 (secondary) ACM Class: G.3; H.1.1; J.3

Structural underpinnings of control in multiplex networks

Authors: Pragya Srivastava, Peter J. Mucha, Emily Falk, Fabio Pasqualetti, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: To design control strategies that predictably manipulate a system's behavior, it is first necessary to understand how the system's structure relates to its response. Many complex systems can be represented as multilayer networks whose response and control can be studied in the framework of network control theory. It remains unknown how a system's layered architecture dictates its control propertie… ▽ More To design control strategies that predictably manipulate a system's behavior, it is first necessary to understand how the system's structure relates to its response. Many complex systems can be represented as multilayer networks whose response and control can be studied in the framework of network control theory. It remains unknown how a system's layered architecture dictates its control properties, particularly when control signals can only access the system through a single input layer. Here, we use the framework of linear control theory to probe the control properties of a duplex network with directed interlayer links. We determine the manner in which the structural properties of layers and relative interlayer arrangement together dictate the system's response. For this purpose, we calculate the exact expression of optimal control energy in terms of layer spectra and the relative alignment between the eigenmodes of the input layer and the deeper target layer. For a range of numerically constructed duplex networks, we then calculate the control properties of the two layers as a function of target-layer densities and layer topology. The alignment of layer eigenmodes emerges as an important parameter that sets the cost and routing of the optimal energy for control. We understand these results in a simplified limit of a single-mode approximation, and we build metrics to characterize the routing of optimal control energy through the eigenmodes of each layer. Our analytical and numerical results together provide insights into the relationships between structure and control in duplex networks. More generally, they serve as a platform for future work designing optimal \emph{interlayer} control strategies. △ Less

Submitted 15 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Comments: 14 pages, 5 figures, 19 pages supplementary material, 10 supplementary figures

Variability in higher order structure of noise added to weighted networks

Authors: Ann S. Blevins, Jason Z. Kim, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: From spiking activity in neuronal networks to force chains in granular materials, the behavior of many real-world systems depends on a network of both strong and weak interactions. These interactions give rise to complex and higher-order system behaviors, and are encoded using data as the network's edges. However, distinguishing between true weak edges and low-weight edges caused by noise remains… ▽ More From spiking activity in neuronal networks to force chains in granular materials, the behavior of many real-world systems depends on a network of both strong and weak interactions. These interactions give rise to complex and higher-order system behaviors, and are encoded using data as the network's edges. However, distinguishing between true weak edges and low-weight edges caused by noise remains a challenge. We address this problem by examining the higher-order structure of noisy, weak edges added to model networks. We find that the structure of low-weight, noisy edges varies according to the topology of the model network to which it is added. By investigating this variation more closely, we see that at least three qualitative classes of noise structure emerge. Furthermore, we observe that the structure of noisy edges contains enough model-specific information to classify the model networks with moderate accuracy. Finally, we offer network generation rules that can drive different types of structure in added noisy edges. Our results demonstrate that noise does not present as a monolithic nuisance, but rather as a nuanced, topology-dependent, and even useful entity in characterizing higher-order network interactions. Hence, we provide an alternate approach to noise management by embracing its role in such interactions. △ Less

Submitted 11 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Comments: 15 pages, 6 figures (main text)

MSC Class: 55U99

The growing topology of the C. elegans connectome

Authors: Alec Helm, Ann S. Blevins, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: Probing the developing neural circuitry in Caenorhabditis elegans has enhanced our understanding of nervous systems. The C. elegans connectome, like those of other species, is characterized by a rich club of densely connected neurons embedded within a small-world architecture. This organization of neuronal connections, captured by quantitative network statistics, provides insight into the system's… ▽ More Probing the developing neural circuitry in Caenorhabditis elegans has enhanced our understanding of nervous systems. The C. elegans connectome, like those of other species, is characterized by a rich club of densely connected neurons embedded within a small-world architecture. This organization of neuronal connections, captured by quantitative network statistics, provides insight into the system's capacity to perform integrative computations. Yet these network measures are limited in their ability to detect weakly connected motifs, such as topological cavities, that may support the systems capacity to perform segregated computations. We address this limitation by using persistent homology to track the evolution of topological cavities in the growing C. elegans connectome throughout neural development, and assess the degree to which the growing connectomes topology is resistant to biological noise. We show that the developing connectome topology is both relatively robust to changes in neuron birth times and not captured by similar growth models. Additionally, we quantify the consequence of a neurons specific birth time and ask if this metric tracks other biological properties of neurons. Our results suggest that the connectomes growing topology is a robust feature of the developing connectome that is distinct from other network properties, and that the growing topology is particularly sensitive to the exact birth times of a small set of predominantly motor neurons. By utilizing novel measurements that track biological features, we anticipate that our study will be helpful in the construction of more accurate models of neuronal development in C. elegans △ Less

Submitted 24 August, 2021; v1 submitted 31 December, 2020; originally announced January 2021.

Is the brain macroscopically linear? A system identification of resting state dynamics

Authors: Erfan Nozari, Maxwell A. Bertolero, Jennifer Stiso, Lorenzo Caciagli, Eli J. Cornblath, Xiaosong He, Arun S. Mahadevan, George J. Pappas, Dani Smith Bassett

Abstract: A central challenge in the computational modeling of neural dynamics is the trade-off between accuracy and simplicity. At the level of individual neurons, nonlinear dynamics are both experimentally established and essential for neuronal functioning. An implicit assumption has thus formed that an accurate computational model of whole-brain dynamics must also be highly nonlinear, whereas linear mode… ▽ More A central challenge in the computational modeling of neural dynamics is the trade-off between accuracy and simplicity. At the level of individual neurons, nonlinear dynamics are both experimentally established and essential for neuronal functioning. An implicit assumption has thus formed that an accurate computational model of whole-brain dynamics must also be highly nonlinear, whereas linear models may provide a first-order approximation. Here, we provide a rigorous and data-driven investigation of this hypothesis at the level of whole-brain blood-oxygen-level-dependent (BOLD) and macroscopic field potential dynamics by leveraging the theory of system identification. Using functional MRI (fMRI) and intracranial EEG (iEEG), we model the resting state activity of 700 subjects in the Human Connectome Project (HCP) and 122 subjects from the Restoring Active Memory (RAM) project using state-of-the-art linear and nonlinear model families. We assess relative model fit using predictive power, computational complexity, and the extent of residual dynamics unexplained by the model. Contrary to our expectations, linear auto-regressive models achieve the best measures across all three metrics, eliminating the trade-off between accuracy and simplicity. To understand and explain this linearity, we highlight four properties of macroscopic neurodynamics which can counteract or mask microscopic nonlinear dynamics: averaging over space, averaging over time, observation noise, and limited data samples. Whereas the latter two are technological limitations and can improve in the future, the former two are inherent to aggregated macroscopic brain activity. Our results, together with the unparalleled interpretability of linear models, can greatly facilitate our understanding of macroscopic neural dynamics and the principled design of model-based interventions for the treatment of neuropsychiatric disorders. △ Less

Submitted 11 August, 2021; v1 submitted 22 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Improving J-divergence of brain connectivity states by graph Laplacian denoising

Authors: Tiziana Cattai, Gaetano Scarano, Marie-Constance Corsi, Danielle S. Bassett, Fabrizio De Vico Fallani, Stefania Colonnese

Abstract: Functional connectivity (FC) can be represented as a network, and is frequently used to better understand the neural underpinnings of complex tasks such as motor imagery (MI) detection in brain-computer interfaces (BCIs). However, errors in the estimation of connectivity can affect the detection performances. In this work, we address the problem of denoising common connectivity estimates to improv… ▽ More Functional connectivity (FC) can be represented as a network, and is frequently used to better understand the neural underpinnings of complex tasks such as motor imagery (MI) detection in brain-computer interfaces (BCIs). However, errors in the estimation of connectivity can affect the detection performances. In this work, we address the problem of denoising common connectivity estimates to improve the detectability of different connectivity states. Specifically, we propose a denoising algorithm that acts on the network graph Laplacian, which leverages recent graph signal processing results. Further, we derive a novel formulation of the Jensen divergence for the denoised Laplacian under different states. Numerical simulations on synthetic data show that the denoising method improves the Jensen divergence of connectivity patterns corresponding to different task conditions. Furthermore, we apply the Laplacian denoising technique to brain networks estimated from real EEG data recorded during MI-BCI experiments. Using our novel formulation of the J-divergence, we are able to quantify the distance between the FC networks in the motor imagery and resting states, as well as to understand the contribution of each Laplacian variable to the total J-divergence between two states. Experimental results on real MI-BCI EEG data demonstrate that the Laplacian denoising improves the separation of motor imagery and resting mental states, and shortens the time interval required for connectivity estimation. We conclude that the approach shows promise for the robust detection of connectivity states while being appealing for implementation in real-time BCI applications. △ Less

Submitted 22 December, 2020; v1 submitted 21 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Comments: This work has been submitted to the IEEE for possible publication

Journal ref: IEEE transactions on Signal and Information Processing over Networks 7 (2021): 493-508

Phase-Amplitude Coupling in Neuronal Oscillator Networks

Authors: Yuzhen Qin, Tommaso Menara, Danielle S. Bassett, Fabio Pasqualetti

Abstract: Phase-amplitude coupling (PAC) describes the phenomenon where the power of a high-frequency oscillation evolves with the phase of a low-frequency one. We propose a model that explains the emergence of PAC in two commonly-accepted architectures in the brain, namely, a high-frequency neural oscillation driven by an external low-frequency input and two interacting local oscillations with distinct, lo… ▽ More Phase-amplitude coupling (PAC) describes the phenomenon where the power of a high-frequency oscillation evolves with the phase of a low-frequency one. We propose a model that explains the emergence of PAC in two commonly-accepted architectures in the brain, namely, a high-frequency neural oscillation driven by an external low-frequency input and two interacting local oscillations with distinct, locally-generated frequencies. We further propose an interconnection structure for brain regions and demonstrate that low-frequency phase synchrony can integrate high-frequency activities regulated by local PAC and control the direction of information flow across distant regions. △ Less

Submitted 8 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Comments: 6 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Research 3, 023218 (2021)

BCI learning induces core-periphery reorganization in M/EEG multiplex brain networks

Authors: Marie-Constance Corsi, Mario Chavez, Denis Schwartz, Nathalie George, Laurent Hugueville, Ari E. Kahn, Sophie Dupont, Danielle S. Bassett, Fabrizio De Vico Fallani

Abstract: Brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) constitute a promising tool for communication and control. However, mastering non-invasive closed-loop systems remains a learned skill that is difficult to develop for a non-negligible proportion of users. The involved learning process induces neural changes associated with a brain network reorganization that remains poorly understood. To address this inter-subject… ▽ More Brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) constitute a promising tool for communication and control. However, mastering non-invasive closed-loop systems remains a learned skill that is difficult to develop for a non-negligible proportion of users. The involved learning process induces neural changes associated with a brain network reorganization that remains poorly understood. To address this inter-subject variability, we adopted a multilayer approach to integrate brain network properties from electroencephalographic (EEG) and magnetoencephalographic (MEG) data resulting from a four-session BCI training program followed by a group of healthy subjects. Our method gives access to the contribution of each layer to multilayer network that tends to be equal with time. We show that regardless the chosen modality, a progressive increase in the integration of somatosensory areas in the alpha band was paralleled by a decrease of the integration of visual processing and working memory areas in the beta band. Notably, only brain network properties in multilayer network correlated with future BCI scores in the alpha2 band: positively in somatosensory and decision-making related areas and negatively in associative areas. Our findings cast new light on neural processes underlying BCI training. Integrating multimodal brain network properties provides new information that correlates with behavioral performance and could be considered as a potential marker of BCI learning. △ Less

Submitted 17 March, 2021; v1 submitted 26 October, 2020; originally announced October 2020.

Comments: This is the version of the article before editing, as submitted by an author to the Journal of Neural Engineering. IOP Publishing Ltd is not responsible for any errors or omissions in this version of the manuscript or any version derived from it. The Version of Record is available online athttp://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1741-2552/abef39

Network controllability in transmodal cortex predicts psychosis spectrum symptoms

Authors: Linden Parkes, Tyler M. Moore, Monica E. Calkins, Matthew Cieslak, David R. Roalf, Daniel H. Wolf, Ruben C. Gur, Raquel E. Gur, Theodore D. Satterthwaite, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: The psychosis spectrum is associated with structural dysconnectivity concentrated in transmodal association cortex. However, understanding of this pathophysiology has been limited by an exclusive focus on the direct connections to a region. Using Network Control Theory, we measured variation in both direct and indirect structural connections to a region to gain new insights into the pathophysiolog… ▽ More The psychosis spectrum is associated with structural dysconnectivity concentrated in transmodal association cortex. However, understanding of this pathophysiology has been limited by an exclusive focus on the direct connections to a region. Using Network Control Theory, we measured variation in both direct and indirect structural connections to a region to gain new insights into the pathophysiology of the psychosis spectrum. We used psychosis symptom data and structural connectivity in 1,068 youths aged 8 to 22 years from the Philadelphia Neurodevelopmental Cohort. Applying a Network Control Theory metric called average controllability, we estimated each brain region's capacity to leverage its direct and indirect structural connections to control linear brain dynamics. Next, using non-linear regression, we determined the accuracy with which average controllability could predict negative and positive psychosis spectrum symptoms in out-of-sample testing. We also compared prediction performance for average controllability versus strength, which indexes only direct connections to a region. Finally, we assessed how the prediction performance for psychosis spectrum symptoms varied over the functional hierarchy spanning unimodal to transmodal cortex. Average controllability outperformed strength at predicting positive psychosis spectrum symptoms, demonstrating that indexing indirect structural connections to a region improved prediction performance. Critically, improved prediction was concentrated in association cortex for average controllability, whereas prediction performance for strength was uniform across the cortex, suggesting that indexing indirect connections is crucial in association cortex. Examining inter-individual variation in direct and indirect structural connections to association cortex is crucial for accurate prediction of positive psychosis spectrum symptoms. △ Less

Submitted 1 October, 2020; originally announced October 2020.

How We Learn About our Networked World

Authors: Sophia U. David, Sophie E. Loman, Christopher W. Lynn, Ann S. Blevins, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: When presented with information of any type, from music to language to mathematics, the human mind subconsciously arranges it into a network. A network puts pieces of information like musical notes, syllables or mathematical concepts into context by linking them together. These networks help our minds organize information and anticipate what is coming. Here we present two questions about network b… ▽ More When presented with information of any type, from music to language to mathematics, the human mind subconsciously arranges it into a network. A network puts pieces of information like musical notes, syllables or mathematical concepts into context by linking them together. These networks help our minds organize information and anticipate what is coming. Here we present two questions about network building. 1) Can humans more easily learn some types of networks than others? 2) Do humans find some links between ideas more surprising than others? The answer to both questions is "Yes," and we explain why. The findings provide much-needed insight into the ways that humans learn about the networked world around them. Moreover, the study paves the way for future efforts seeking to optimize how information is presented to accelerate human learning. △ Less

Submitted 8 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Comments: 11 pages, 3 figures

Habit learning supported by efficiently controlled network dynamics in naive macaque monkeys

Authors: Karol P. Szymula, Fabio Pasqualetti, Ann M. Graybiel, Theresa M. Desrochers, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: Primates display a marked ability to learn habits in uncertain and dynamic environments. The associated perceptions and actions of such habits engage distributed neural circuits. Yet, precisely how such circuits support the computations necessary for habit learning remain far from understood. Here we construct a formal theory of network energetics to account for how changes in brain state produce… ▽ More Primates display a marked ability to learn habits in uncertain and dynamic environments. The associated perceptions and actions of such habits engage distributed neural circuits. Yet, precisely how such circuits support the computations necessary for habit learning remain far from understood. Here we construct a formal theory of network energetics to account for how changes in brain state produce changes in sequential behavior. We exercise the theory in the context of multi-unit recordings spanning the caudate nucleus, prefrontal cortex, and frontal eyefields of female macaque monkeys engaged in 60-180 sessions of a free scan task that induces motor habits. The theory relies on the determination of effective connectivity between recording channels, and on the stipulation that a brain state is taken to be the trial-specific firing rate across those channels. The theory then predicts how much energy will be required to transition from one state into another, given the constraint that activity can spread solely through effective connections. Consistent with the theory's predictions, we observed smaller energy requirements for transitions between more similar and more complex trial saccade patterns, and for sessions characterized by less entropic selection of saccade patterns. Using a virtual lesioning approach, we demonstrate the resilience of the observed relationships between minimum control energy and behavior to significant disruptions in the inferred effective connectivity. Our theoretically principled approach to the study of habit learning paves the way for future efforts examining how behavior arises from changing patterns of activity in distributed neural circuitry. △ Less

Submitted 25 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: Main Text: 17 pages and 6 figures; Supplement Text: 9 pages and 8 figures

Towards precise resting-state fMRI biomarkers in psychiatry: synthesizing developments in transdiagnostic research, dimensional models of psychopathology, and normative neurodevelopment

Authors: Linden Parkes, Theodore D. Satterthwaite, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: Searching for biomarkers has been a chief pursuit of the field of psychiatry. Toward this end, studies have catalogued candidate resting-state biomarkers in nearly all forms of mental disorder. However, it is becoming increasingly clear that these biomarkers lack specificity, limiting their capacity to yield clinical impact. We discuss three avenues of research that are overcoming this limitation:… ▽ More Searching for biomarkers has been a chief pursuit of the field of psychiatry. Toward this end, studies have catalogued candidate resting-state biomarkers in nearly all forms of mental disorder. However, it is becoming increasingly clear that these biomarkers lack specificity, limiting their capacity to yield clinical impact. We discuss three avenues of research that are overcoming this limitation: (i) the adoption of transdiagnostic research designs, which involve studying and explicitly comparing multiple disorders from distinct diagnostic axes of psychiatry; (ii) dimensional models of psychopathology that map the full spectrum of symptomatology and that cut across traditional disorder boundaries; and (iii) modeling individuals' unique functional connectomes throughout development. We provide a framework for tying these subfields together that draws on tools from machine learning and network science. △ Less

Submitted 8 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: Keywords: Psychiatry; biomarker; transdiagnostic; dimensional psychopathology; normative modeling; fingerprint; network science

The growth and form of knowledge networks by kinesthetic curiosity

Authors: Dale Zhou, David M. Lydon-Staley, Perry Zurn, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: Throughout life, we might seek a calling, companions, skills, entertainment, truth, self-knowledge, beauty, and edification. The practice of curiosity can be viewed as an extended and open-ended search for valuable information with hidden identity and location in a complex space of interconnected information. Despite its importance, curiosity has been challenging to computationally model because t… ▽ More Throughout life, we might seek a calling, companions, skills, entertainment, truth, self-knowledge, beauty, and edification. The practice of curiosity can be viewed as an extended and open-ended search for valuable information with hidden identity and location in a complex space of interconnected information. Despite its importance, curiosity has been challenging to computationally model because the practice of curiosity often flourishes without specific goals, external reward, or immediate feedback. Here, we show how network science, statistical physics, and philosophy can be integrated into an approach that coheres with and expands the psychological taxonomies of specific-diversive and perceptual-epistemic curiosity. Using this interdisciplinary approach, we distill functional modes of curious information seeking as searching movements in information space. The kinesthetic model of curiosity offers a vibrant counterpart to the deliberative predictions of model-based reinforcement learning. In doing so, this model unearths new computational opportunities for identifying what makes curiosity curious. △ Less

Submitted 4 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

The why, how, and when of representations for complex systems

Authors: Leo Torres, Ann S. Blevins, Danielle S. Bassett, Tina Eliassi-Rad

Abstract: Complex systems thinking is applied to a wide variety of domains, from neuroscience to computer science and economics. The wide variety of implementations has resulted in two key challenges: the progenation of many domain-specific strategies that are seldom revisited or questioned, and the siloing of ideas within a domain due to inconsistency of complex systems language. In this work we offer basi… ▽ More Complex systems thinking is applied to a wide variety of domains, from neuroscience to computer science and economics. The wide variety of implementations has resulted in two key challenges: the progenation of many domain-specific strategies that are seldom revisited or questioned, and the siloing of ideas within a domain due to inconsistency of complex systems language. In this work we offer basic, domain-agnostic language in order to advance towards a more cohesive vocabulary. We use this language to evaluate each step of the complex systems analysis pipeline, beginning with the system and data collected, then moving through different mathematical formalisms for encoding the observed data (i.e. graphs, simplicial complexes, and hypergraphs), and relevant computational methods for each formalism. At each step we consider different types of \emph{dependencies}; these are properties of the system that describe how the existence of one relation among the parts of a system may influence the existence of another relation. We discuss how dependencies may arise and how they may alter interpretation of results or the entirety of the analysis pipeline. We close with two real-world examples using coauthorship data and email communications data that illustrate how the system under study, the dependencies therein, the research question, and choice of mathematical representation influence the results. We hope this work can serve as an opportunity of reflection for experienced complexity scientists, as well as an introductory resource for new researchers. △ Less

Submitted 4 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: 50 pages, 18 figures

MSC Class: 68R10

Broken detailed balance and entropy production in the human brain

Authors: Christopher W. Lynn, Eli J. Cornblath, Lia Papadopoulos, Maxwell A. Bertolero, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: Living systems break detailed balance at small scales, consuming energy and producing entropy in the environment in order to perform molecular and cellular functions. However, it remains unclear how broken detailed balance manifests at macroscopic scales, and how such dynamics support higher-order biological functions. Here we present a framework to quantify broken detailed balance by measuring en… ▽ More Living systems break detailed balance at small scales, consuming energy and producing entropy in the environment in order to perform molecular and cellular functions. However, it remains unclear how broken detailed balance manifests at macroscopic scales, and how such dynamics support higher-order biological functions. Here we present a framework to quantify broken detailed balance by measuring entropy production in macroscopic systems. We apply our method to the human brain, an organ whose immense metabolic consumption drives a diverse range of cognitive functions. Using whole-brain imaging data, we demonstrate that the brain nearly obeys detailed balance when at rest, but strongly breaks detailed balance when performing physically and cognitively demanding tasks. Using a dynamic Ising model, we show that these large-scale violations of detailed balance can emerge from fine-scale asymmetries in the interactions between elements, a known feature of neural systems. Together, these results suggest that violations of detailed balance are vital for cognition, and provide a general tool for quantifying entropy production in macroscopic systems. △ Less

Submitted 16 March, 2021; v1 submitted 5 May, 2020; originally announced May 2020.

Comments: 19 pages, 15 figures

Time-evolving controllability of effective connectivity networks during seizure progression

Authors: Brittany H. Scheid, Arian Ashourvan, Jennifer Stiso, Kathryn A. Davis, Fadi Mikhail, Fabio Pasqualetti, Brian Litt, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: Over one third of the estimated 3 million people with epilepsy in the US are medication resistant. Responsive neurostimulation from chronically implanted electrodes provides a promising treatment option and alternative to resective surgery. However, determining personalized optimal stimulation parameters, including when and where to intervene to guarantee a positive patient outcome, is a major ope… ▽ More Over one third of the estimated 3 million people with epilepsy in the US are medication resistant. Responsive neurostimulation from chronically implanted electrodes provides a promising treatment option and alternative to resective surgery. However, determining personalized optimal stimulation parameters, including when and where to intervene to guarantee a positive patient outcome, is a major open challenge. Network neuroscience and control theory offer useful tools that may guide improvements in parameter selection for control of anomalous neural activity. Here we use a novel method to characterize dynamic controllability across consecutive effective connectivity (EC) networks based on regularized partial correlations between implanted electrodes during the onset, propagation, and termination phases of thirty-four seizures. We estimate regularized partial correlation adjacency matrices from one-second time windows of intracranial electrocorticography recordings using the Graphical Least Absolute Shrinkage and Selection Operator (GLASSO). Average and modal controllability metrics calculated from each resulting EC network track the time-varying controllability of the brain on an evolving landscape of conditionally dependent network interactions. We show that average controllability increases throughout a seizure and is negatively correlated with modal controllability throughout. Furthermore, our results support the hypothesis that the energy required to drive the brain to a seizure-free state from an ictal state is smallest during seizure onset; yet, we find that applying control energy at electrodes in the seizure onset zone may not always be energetically favorable. Our work suggests that a low-complexity model of time-evolving controllability may offer new insights for developing and improving control strategies targeting seizure suppression. △ Less

Submitted 6 April, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

Comments: Main text is 7 pages and contains 4 figures, supplement is 17 pages and contains 9 figures and one table

Journal ref: PNAS 2021 Vol. 118 No. 5

Mediated Remote Synchronization of Kuramoto-Sakaguchi Oscillators: the Number of Mediators Matters

Authors: Yuzhen Qin, Ming Cao, Brian D. O. Anderson, Danielle S. Bassett, Fabio Pasqualetti

Abstract: Cortical regions without direct neuronal connections have been observed to exhibit synchronized dynamics. A recent empirical study has further revealed that such regions that share more common neighbors are more likely to behave coherently. To analytically investigate the underlying mechanisms, we consider that a set of n oscillators, which have no direct connections, are linked through m intermed… ▽ More Cortical regions without direct neuronal connections have been observed to exhibit synchronized dynamics. A recent empirical study has further revealed that such regions that share more common neighbors are more likely to behave coherently. To analytically investigate the underlying mechanisms, we consider that a set of n oscillators, which have no direct connections, are linked through m intermediate oscillators (called mediators), forming a complete bipartite network structure. Modeling the oscillators by the Kuramoto-Sakaguchi model, we rigorously prove that mediated remote synchronization, i.e., synchronization between those n oscillators that are not directly connected, becomes more robust as the number of mediators increases. Simulations are also carried out to show that our theoretical findings can be applied to other general and complex networks. △ Less

Submitted 9 July, 2020; v1 submitted 16 March, 2020; originally announced March 2020.

Deep Neural Networks Carve the Brain at its Joints

Authors: Maxwell A. Bertolero, Dustin Moraczewski, Adam Thomas, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: How an individual's unique brain connectivity determines that individual's cognition, behavior, and risk for pathology is a fundamental question in basic and clinical neuroscience. In seeking answers, many have turned to machine learning, with some noting the particular promise of deep neural networks in modelling complex non-linear functions. However, it is not clear that complex functions actual… ▽ More How an individual's unique brain connectivity determines that individual's cognition, behavior, and risk for pathology is a fundamental question in basic and clinical neuroscience. In seeking answers, many have turned to machine learning, with some noting the particular promise of deep neural networks in modelling complex non-linear functions. However, it is not clear that complex functions actually exist between brain connectivity and behavior, and thus if deep neural networks necessarily outperform simpler linear models, or if their results would be interpretable. Here we show that, across 52 subject measures of cognition and behavior, deep neural networks fit to each brain region's connectivity outperform linear regression, particularly for the brain's connector hubs--regions with diverse brain connectivity--whereas the two approaches perform similarly when fit to brain systems. Critically, averaging deep neural network predictions across brain regions results in the most accurate predictions, demonstrating the ability of deep neural networks to easily model the various functions that exists between regional brain connectivity and behavior, carving the brain at its joints. Finally, we shine light into the black box of deep neural networks using multislice network models. We determined that the relationship between connector hubs and behavior is best captured by modular deep neural networks. Our results demonstrate that both simple and complex relationships exist between brain connectivity and behavior, and that deep neural networks can fit both. Moreover, deep neural networks are particularly powerful when they are first fit to the various functions of a system independently and then combined. Finally, deep neural networks are interpretable when their architectures are structurally characterized using multislice network models. △ Less

Submitted 9 September, 2020; v1 submitted 20 February, 2020; originally announced February 2020.

Models of communication and control for brain networks: distinctions, convergence, and future outlook

Authors: Pragya Srivastava, Erfan Nozari, Jason Z. Kim, Harang Ju, Dale Zhou, Cassiano Becker, Fabio Pasqualetti, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: Recent advances in computational models of signal propagation and routing in the human brain have underscored the critical role of white matter structure. A complementary approach has utilized the framework of network control theory to better understand how white matter constrains the manner in which a region or set of regions can direct or control the activity of other regions. Despite the potent… ▽ More Recent advances in computational models of signal propagation and routing in the human brain have underscored the critical role of white matter structure. A complementary approach has utilized the framework of network control theory to better understand how white matter constrains the manner in which a region or set of regions can direct or control the activity of other regions. Despite the potential for both of these approaches to enhance our understanding of the role of network structure in brain function, little work has sought to understand the relations between them. Here, we seek to explicitly bridge computational models of communication and principles of network control in a conceptual review of the current literature. By drawing comparisons between communication and control models in terms of the level of abstraction, the dynamical complexity, the dependence on network attributes, and the interplay of multiple spatiotemporal scales, we highlight the convergence of and distinctions between the two frameworks. Based on the understanding of the intertwined nature of communication and control in human brain networks, this work provides an integrative perspective for the field and outlines exciting directions for future work. △ Less

Submitted 17 February, 2020; originally announced February 2020.

Comments: 23 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Network Neuroscience, 2020

Path-dependent connectivity, not modularity, consistently predicts controllability of structural brain networks

Authors: Shubhankar P. Patankar, Jason Z. Kim, Fabio Pasqualetti, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: The human brain displays rich communication dynamics that are thought to be particularly well-reflected in its marked community structure. Yet, the precise relationship between community structure in structural brain networks and the communication dynamics that can emerge therefrom is not well-understood. In addition to offering insight into the structure-function relationship of networked systems… ▽ More The human brain displays rich communication dynamics that are thought to be particularly well-reflected in its marked community structure. Yet, the precise relationship between community structure in structural brain networks and the communication dynamics that can emerge therefrom is not well-understood. In addition to offering insight into the structure-function relationship of networked systems, such an understanding is a critical step towards the ability to manipulate the brain's large-scale dynamical activity in a targeted manner. We investigate the role of community structure in the controllability of structural brain networks. At the region level, we find that certain network measures of community structure are sometimes statistically correlated with measures of linear controllability. However, we then demonstrate that this relationship depends on the distribution of network edge weights. We highlight the complexity of the relationship between community structure and controllability by performing numerical simulations using canonical graph models with varying mesoscale architectures and edge weight distributions. Finally, we demonstrate that weighted subgraph centrality, a measure rooted in the graph spectrum, and which captures higher-order graph architecture, is a stronger and more consistent predictor of controllability. Our study contributes to an understanding of how the brain's diverse mesoscale structure supports transient communication dynamics. △ Less

Submitted 18 December, 2020; v1 submitted 16 February, 2020; originally announced February 2020.

Comments: 32 pages, 7 figures in main text, and 22 pages, 11 figures in supplement

Relations between large scale brain connectivity and effects of regional stimulation depend on collective dynamical state

Authors: Lia Papadopoulos, Christopher W. Lynn, Demian Battaglia, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: At the macroscale, the brain operates as a network of interconnected neuronal populations, which display rhythmic dynamics that support interareal communication. Understanding how stimulation of a particular brain area impacts such concerted activity is important for gaining basic insights into brain function and for developing neuromodulation as a therapeutic tool. However, it remains difficult t… ▽ More At the macroscale, the brain operates as a network of interconnected neuronal populations, which display rhythmic dynamics that support interareal communication. Understanding how stimulation of a particular brain area impacts such concerted activity is important for gaining basic insights into brain function and for developing neuromodulation as a therapeutic tool. However, it remains difficult to predict the downstream effects of focal stimulation. Specifically, little is known about how the collective oscillatory regime of network activity may affect the outcomes of regional perturbations on cooperative dynamics. Here, we combine connectome data and biophysical modeling to begin filling these gaps. By tuning parameters that control the collective dynamics of the network, we identify distinct states of simulated brain activity, and investigate how the distributed effects of stimulation manifest in different states. When baseline oscillations are weak, the stimulated area exhibits enhanced power and frequency, and due to network interactions, nearby regions develop phase locked activity in the excited frequency band. Importantly, we find that focal stimulation also causes more distributed modifications to network coherence at regions' baseline oscillation frequencies, and that these effects are better predicted by functional rather than structural connectivity. In contrast, when the network operates in a regime of stronger endogenous oscillations, stimulation causes only slight shifts in power and frequency, and network averaged changes in coherence are more homogenous across the choice of the stimulated area. In sum, this work builds upon and extends previous computational studies investigating the impacts of stimulation, and highlights that both the stimulation site, and, crucially, the regime of brain network dynamics, can influence the network wide responses to local perturbations. △ Less

Submitted 12 February, 2020; v1 submitted 31 January, 2020; originally announced February 2020.

Comments: Main Text: 32 pages, 10 figures; Supplement: 14 pages, 10 figures

Journal ref: PLoS Computational Biology, 16-9 (2020)

Efficient Coding in the Economics of Human Brain Connectomics

Authors: Dale Zhou, Christopher W. Lynn, Zaixu Cui, Rastko Ciric, Graham L. Baum, Tyler M. Moore, David R. Roalf, John A. Detre, Ruben C. Gur, Raquel E. Gur, Theodore D. Satterthwaite, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: In systems neuroscience, most models posit that brain regions communicate information under constraints of efficiency. Yet, evidence for efficient communication in structural brain networks characterized by hierarchical organization and highly connected hubs remains sparse. The principle of efficient coding proposes that the brain transmits maximal information in a metabolically economical or comp… ▽ More In systems neuroscience, most models posit that brain regions communicate information under constraints of efficiency. Yet, evidence for efficient communication in structural brain networks characterized by hierarchical organization and highly connected hubs remains sparse. The principle of efficient coding proposes that the brain transmits maximal information in a metabolically economical or compressed form to improve future behavior. To determine how structural connectivity supports efficient coding, we develop a theory specifying minimum rates of message transmission between brain regions to achieve an expected fidelity, and we test five predictions from the theory based on random walk communication dynamics. In doing so, we introduce the metric of compression efficiency, which quantifies the trade-off between lossy compression and transmission fidelity in structural networks. In a large sample of youth (n = 1,042; age 8-23 years), we analyze structural networks derived from diffusion weighted imaging and metabolic expenditure operationalized using cerebral blood flow. We show that structural networks strike compression efficiency trade-offs consistent with theoretical predictions. We find that compression efficiency prioritizes fidelity with development, heightens when metabolic resources and myelination guide communication, explains advantages of hierarchical organization, links higher input fidelity to disproportionate areal expansion, and shows that hubs integrate information by lossy compression. Lastly, compression efficiency is predictive of behavior--beyond a conventional metric--for cognitive domains including executive function, memory, complex reasoning, and social cognition. Our findings elucidate how macroscale connectivity supports efficient coding, and serve to foreground communication processes that utilize random walk dynamics constrained by network connectivity. △ Less

Submitted 2 November, 2021; v1 submitted 14 January, 2020; originally announced January 2020.

Phase/amplitude synchronization of brain signals during motor imagery BCI tasks

Authors: Tiziana Cattai, Stefania Colonnese, Marie-Constance Corsi, Danielle S. Bassett, Gaetano Scarano, Fabrizio De Vico Fallani

Abstract: The extraction of brain functioning features is a crucial step in the definition of brain-computer interfaces (BCIs). In the last decade, functional connectivity (FC) estimators have been increasingly explored based on their ability to capture synchronization between multivariate brain signals. However, the underlying neurophysiological mechanisms and the extent to which they can improve performan… ▽ More The extraction of brain functioning features is a crucial step in the definition of brain-computer interfaces (BCIs). In the last decade, functional connectivity (FC) estimators have been increasingly explored based on their ability to capture synchronization between multivariate brain signals. However, the underlying neurophysiological mechanisms and the extent to which they can improve performance in BCI-related tasks, is still poorly understood. To address this gap in knowledge, we considered a group of 20 healthy subjects during an EEG-based hand motor imagery (MI) task. We studied two well-established FC estimators, i.e. spectral- and imaginary-coherence, and investigated how they were modulated by the MI task. We characterized the resulting FC networks by extracting the strength of connectivity of each EEG sensor and compared the discriminant power with respect to standard power spectrum features. At the group level, results showed that while spectral-coherence based network features were increasing the controlateral motor area, those based on imaginary-coherence were decreasing. We demonstrated that this opposite, but complementary, behavior was respectively determined by the increase in amplitude and phase synchronization between the brain signals. At the individual level, we proved that including these network connectivity features in the classification of MI mental states led to an overall improvement in accuracy. Taken together, our results provide fresh insights into the oscillatory mechanisms subserving brain network changes during MI and offer new perspectives to improve BCI performance. △ Less

Submitted 5 December, 2019; originally announced December 2019.

On the nature of explanations offered by network science: A perspective from and for practicing neuroscientists

Authors: Maxwell A. Bertolero, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: Network neuroscience represents the brain as a collection of regions and inter-regional connections. Given its ability to formalize systems-level models, network neuroscience has generated unique explanations of neural function and behavior. The mechanistic status of these explanations and how they can contribute to and fit within the field of neuroscience as a whole has received careful treatment… ▽ More Network neuroscience represents the brain as a collection of regions and inter-regional connections. Given its ability to formalize systems-level models, network neuroscience has generated unique explanations of neural function and behavior. The mechanistic status of these explanations and how they can contribute to and fit within the field of neuroscience as a whole has received careful treatment from philosophers. However, these philosophical contributions have not yet reached many neuroscientists. Here we complement formal philosophical efforts by providing an applied perspective from and for neuroscientists. We discuss the mechanistic status of the explanations offered by network neuroscience and how they contribute to, enhance, and interdigitate with other types of explanations in neuroscience. In doing so, we rely on philosophical work concerning the role of causality, scale, and mechanisms in scientific explanations. In particular, we make the distinction between an explanation and the evidence supporting that explanation, and we argue for a scale-free nature of mechanistic explanations. In the course of these discussions, we hope to provide a useful applied framework in which network neuroscience explanations can be exercised across scales and combined with other fields of neuroscience to gain deeper insights into the brain and behavior. △ Less

Submitted 12 November, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

Comments: This article is part a forthcoming Topics in Cognitive Science Special Issue: "Levels of Explanation in Cognitive Science: From Molecules to Culture," Matteo Colombo and Markus Knauff (Topic Editors)

How humans learn and represent networks

Authors: Christopher W. Lynn, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: Humans communicate, receive, and store information using sequences of items -- from words in a sentence or notes in music to abstract concepts in lectures and books. The networks formed by these items (nodes) and the sequential transitions between them (edges) encode important structural features of human communication and knowledge. But how do humans learn the networks of probabilistic transition… ▽ More Humans communicate, receive, and store information using sequences of items -- from words in a sentence or notes in music to abstract concepts in lectures and books. The networks formed by these items (nodes) and the sequential transitions between them (edges) encode important structural features of human communication and knowledge. But how do humans learn the networks of probabilistic transitions that underlie sequences of items? Moreover, what do people's internal maps of these networks look like? Here, we introduce graph learning, a growing and interdisciplinary field focused on studying how humans learn and represent networks in the world around them. We begin by describing established results from statistical learning showing that humans are adept at detecting differences in the transition probabilities between items in a sequence. We next present recent experiments that directly control for differences in transition probabilities, demonstrating that human behavior also depends critically on the abstract network structure of transitions. Finally, we present computational models that researchers have proposed to explain the effects of network structure on human behavior and cognition. Throughout, we highlight a number of exciting open questions in the study of graph learning that will require creative insights from cognitive scientists and network scientists alike. △ Less

Submitted 25 March, 2020; v1 submitted 16 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Comments: 9 pages, 6 figures

Architecture and evolution of semantic networks in mathematics texts

Authors: Nicolas H. Christianson, Ann Sizemore Blevins, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: Knowledge is a network of interconnected concepts. Yet, precisely how the topological structure of knowledge constrains its acquisition remains unknown, hampering the development of learning enhancement strategies. Here we study the topological structure of semantic networks reflecting mathematical concepts and their relations in college-level linear algebra texts. We hypothesize that these networ… ▽ More Knowledge is a network of interconnected concepts. Yet, precisely how the topological structure of knowledge constrains its acquisition remains unknown, hampering the development of learning enhancement strategies. Here we study the topological structure of semantic networks reflecting mathematical concepts and their relations in college-level linear algebra texts. We hypothesize that these networks will exhibit structural order, reflecting the logical sequence of topics that ensures accessibility. We find that the networks exhibit strong core-periphery architecture, where a dense core of concepts presented early is complemented with a sparse periphery presented evenly throughout the exposition; the latter is composed of many small modules each reflecting more narrow domains. Using tools from applied topology, we find that the expositional evolution of the semantic networks produces and subsequently fills knowledge gaps, and that the density of these gaps tracks negatively with community ratings of each textbook. Broadly, our study lays the groundwork for future efforts developing optimal design principles for textbook exposition and teaching in a classroom setting. △ Less

Submitted 24 September, 2019; v1 submitted 13 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Comments: 22 pages, 5 figures

A practical guide to methodological considerations in the controllability of structural brain networks

Authors: Teresa M. Karrer, Jason Z. Kim, Jennifer Stiso, Ari E. Kahn, Fabio Pasqualetti, Ute Habel, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: Predicting how the brain can be driven to specific states by means of internal or external control requires a fundamental understanding of the relationship between neural connectivity and activity. Network control theory is a powerful tool from the physical and engineering sciences that can provide insights regarding that relationship; it formalizes the study of how the dynamics of a complex syste… ▽ More Predicting how the brain can be driven to specific states by means of internal or external control requires a fundamental understanding of the relationship between neural connectivity and activity. Network control theory is a powerful tool from the physical and engineering sciences that can provide insights regarding that relationship; it formalizes the study of how the dynamics of a complex system can arise from its underlying structure of interconnected units. Given the recent use of network control theory in neuroscience, it is now timely to offer a practical guide to methodological considerations in the controllability of structural brain networks. Here we provide a systematic overview of the framework, examine the impact of modeling choices on frequently studied control metrics, and suggest potentially useful theoretical extensions. We ground our discussions, numerical demonstrations, and theoretical advances in a dataset of high-resolution diffusion imaging with 730 diffusion directions acquired over approximately 1 hour of scanning from ten healthy young adults. Following a didactic introduction of the theory, we probe how a selection of modeling choices affects four common statistics: average controllability, modal controllability, minimum control energy, and optimal control energy. Next, we extend the current state of the art in two ways: first, by developing an alternative measure of structural connectivity that accounts for radial propagation of activity through abutting tissue, and second, by defining a complementary metric quantifying the complexity of the energy landscape of a system. We close with specific modeling recommendations and a discussion of methodological constraints. △ Less

Submitted 9 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Learning in brain-computer interface control evidenced by joint decomposition of brain and behavior

Authors: Jennifer Stiso, Marie-Constance Corsi, Jean M. Vettel, Javier O. Garcia, Fabio Pasqualetti, Fabrizio De Vico Fallani, Timothy H. Lucas, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: Motor imagery-based brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) use an individuals ability to volitionally modulate localized brain activity as a therapy for motor dysfunction or to probe causal relations between brain activity and behavior. However, many individuals cannot learn to successfully modulate their brain activity, greatly limiting the efficacy of BCI for therapy and for basic scientific inquiry.… ▽ More Motor imagery-based brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) use an individuals ability to volitionally modulate localized brain activity as a therapy for motor dysfunction or to probe causal relations between brain activity and behavior. However, many individuals cannot learn to successfully modulate their brain activity, greatly limiting the efficacy of BCI for therapy and for basic scientific inquiry. Previous research suggests that coherent activity across diverse cognitive systems is a hallmark of individuals who can successfully learn to control the BCI. However, little is known about how these distributed networks interact through time to support learning. Here, we address this gap in knowledge by constructing and applying a multimodal network approach to decipher brain-behavior relations in motor imagery-based brain-computer interface learning using MEG. Specifically, we employ a minimally constrained matrix decomposition method (non-negative matrix factorization) to simultaneously identify regularized, covarying subgraphs of functional connectivity, to assess their similarity to task performance, and to detect their time-varying expression. Individuals also displayed marked variation in the spatial properties of subgraphs such as the connectivity between the frontal lobe and the rest of the brain, and in the temporal properties of subgraphs such as the stage of learning at which they reached maximum expression. From these observations, we posit a conceptual model in which certain subgraphs support learning by modulating brain activity in regions important for sustaining attention. To test this model, we use tools that stipulate regional dynamics on a networked system (network control theory), and find that good learners display a single subgraph whose temporal expression tracked performance and whose architecture supports easy modulation of brain regions important for attention. △ Less

Submitted 2 August, 2019; v1 submitted 31 July, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Brain state stability during working memory is explained by network control theory, modulated by dopamine D1/D2 receptor function, and diminished in schizophrenia

Authors: Urs Braun, Anais Harneit, Giulio Pergola, Tommaso Menara, Axel Schaefer, Richard F. Betzel, Zhenxiang Zang, Janina I. Schweiger, Kristina Schwarz, Junfang Chen, Giuseppe Blasi, Alessandro Bertolino, Daniel Durstewitz, Fabio Pasqualetti, Emanuel Schwarz, Andreas Meyer-Lindenberg, Danielle S. Bassett, Heike Tost

Abstract: Dynamical brain state transitions are critical for flexible working memory but the network mechanisms are incompletely understood. Here, we show that working memory entails brainwide switching between activity states. The stability of states relates to dopamine D1 receptor gene expression while state transitions are influenced by D2 receptor expression and pharmacological modulation. Schizophrenia… ▽ More Dynamical brain state transitions are critical for flexible working memory but the network mechanisms are incompletely understood. Here, we show that working memory entails brainwide switching between activity states. The stability of states relates to dopamine D1 receptor gene expression while state transitions are influenced by D2 receptor expression and pharmacological modulation. Schizophrenia patients show altered network control properties, including a more diverse energy landscape and decreased stability of working memory representations. △ Less

Submitted 21 June, 2019; originally announced June 2019.

Human information processing in complex networks

Authors: Christopher W. Lynn, Lia Papadopoulos, Ari E. Kahn, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: Humans communicate using systems of interconnected stimuli or concepts -- from language and music to literature and science -- yet it remains unclear how, if at all, the structure of these networks supports the communication of information. Although information theory provides tools to quantify the information produced by a system, traditional metrics do not account for the inefficient ways that h… ▽ More Humans communicate using systems of interconnected stimuli or concepts -- from language and music to literature and science -- yet it remains unclear how, if at all, the structure of these networks supports the communication of information. Although information theory provides tools to quantify the information produced by a system, traditional metrics do not account for the inefficient ways that humans process this information. Here we develop an analytical framework to study the information generated by a system as perceived by a human observer. We demonstrate experimentally that this perceived information depends critically on a system's network topology. Applying our framework to several real networks, we find that they communicate a large amount of information (having high entropy) and do so efficiently (maintaining low divergence from human expectations). Moreover, we show that such efficient communication arises in networks that are simultaneously heterogeneous, with high-degree hubs, and clustered, with tightly-connected modules -- the two defining features of hierarchical organization. Together, these results suggest that many communication networks are constrained by the pressures of information transmission, and that these pressures select for specific structural features. △ Less

Submitted 25 March, 2020; v1 submitted 3 June, 2019; originally announced June 2019.

Comments: 87 pages, 26 figures, 13 tables

The human brain's network architecture is genetically encoded by modular pleiotropy

Authors: Maxwell A. Bertolero, Ann Sizemore Blevins, Graham L. Baum, Ruben C. Gur, Raquel E. Gur, David R. Roalf, Theodore D. Satterthwaite, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: For much of biology, the manner in which genotype maps to phenotype remains a fundamental mystery. The few maps that are known tend to show modular pleiotropy: sets of phenotypes are determined by distinct sets of genes. One key map that has evaded discovery is that of the human brain's network architecture. Here, we determine the form of this map for gene coexpression and single nucleotide polymo… ▽ More For much of biology, the manner in which genotype maps to phenotype remains a fundamental mystery. The few maps that are known tend to show modular pleiotropy: sets of phenotypes are determined by distinct sets of genes. One key map that has evaded discovery is that of the human brain's network architecture. Here, we determine the form of this map for gene coexpression and single nucleotide polymorphisms. We discover that mostly non-overlapping sets of genes encode the connectivity of brain network modules (or so-called communities), suggesting that brain network communities demarcate genetic transitions. We find that these clean boundaries break down at connector hubs, whose integrative connectivity is encoded by pleiotropic genes from mostly non-overlapping sets. Broadly, this study opens fundamentally new directions in the study of genetic encoding of brain development, evolution, and disease. △ Less

Submitted 3 November, 2019; v1 submitted 18 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

On the reorderability of node-filtered order complexes

Authors: Ann Sizemore Blevins, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: Growing graphs describe a multitude of developing processes from maturing brains to expanding vocabularies to burgeoning public transit systems. Each of these growing processes likely adheres to proliferation rules that establish an effective order of node and connection emergence. When followed, such proliferation rules allow the system to properly develop along a predetermined trajectory. But ru… ▽ More Growing graphs describe a multitude of developing processes from maturing brains to expanding vocabularies to burgeoning public transit systems. Each of these growing processes likely adheres to proliferation rules that establish an effective order of node and connection emergence. When followed, such proliferation rules allow the system to properly develop along a predetermined trajectory. But rules are rarely followed. Here we ask what topological changes in the growing graph trajectories might occur after the specific but basic perturbation of permuting the node emergence order. Specifically we harness applied topological methods to determine which of six growing graph models exhibit topology that is robust to randomizing node order, termed global reorderability, and robust to temporally-local node swaps, termed local reorderability. We find that the six graph models fall upon a spectrum of both local and global reorderability, and furthermore we provide theoretical connections between robustness to node pair ordering and robustness to arbitrary node orderings. Finally we discuss real-world applications of reorderability analyses and suggest possibilities for designing reorderable networks. △ Less

Submitted 24 July, 2019; v1 submitted 6 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

Comments: 41 pages, 16 figures

MSC Class: 55U10

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 101, 052311 (2020)

Functional brain network architecture supporting the learning of social networks in humans

Authors: Steven H. Tompson, Ari E. Kahn, Emily B. Falk, Jean M. Vettel, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: Most humans have the good fortune to live their lives embedded in richly structured social groups. Yet, it remains unclear how humans acquire knowledge about these social structures to successfully navigate social relationships. Here we address this knowledge gap with an interdisciplinary neuroimaging study drawing on recent advances in network science and statistical learning. Specifically, we co… ▽ More Most humans have the good fortune to live their lives embedded in richly structured social groups. Yet, it remains unclear how humans acquire knowledge about these social structures to successfully navigate social relationships. Here we address this knowledge gap with an interdisciplinary neuroimaging study drawing on recent advances in network science and statistical learning. Specifically, we collected BOLD MRI data while participants learned the community structure of both social and non-social networks, in order to examine whether the learning of these two types of networks was differentially associated with functional brain network topology. From the behavioral data in both tasks, we found that learners were sensitive to the community structure of the networks, as evidenced by a slower reaction time on trials transitioning between clusters than on trials transitioning within a cluster. From the neuroimaging data collected during the social network learning task, we observed that the functional connectivity of the hippocampus and temporoparietal junction was significantly greater when transitioning between clusters than when transitioning within a cluster. Furthermore, temporoparietal regions of the default mode were more strongly connected to hippocampus, somatomotor, and visual regions during the social task than during the non-social task. Collectively, our results identify neurophysiological underpinnings of social versus non-social network learning, extending our knowledge about the impact of social context on learning processes. More broadly, this work offers an empirical approach to study the learning of social network structures, which could be fruitfully extended to other participant populations, various graph architectures, and a diversity of social contexts in future studies. △ Less

Submitted 20 April, 2019; originally announced April 2019.

Unifying Modular and Core-Periphery Structure in Functional Brain Networks over Development

Authors: Shi Gu, Cedric Huchuan Xia, Rastko Ciric, Tyler M. Moore, Ruben C. Gur, Raquel E. Gur, Theodore D. Satterthwaite, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: At rest, human brain functional networks display striking modular architecture in which coherent clusters of brain regions are activated. The modular account of brain function is pervasive, reliable, and reproducible. Yet, a complementary perspective posits a core-periphery or rich-club account of brain function, where hubs are densely interconnected with one another, allowing for integrative proc… ▽ More At rest, human brain functional networks display striking modular architecture in which coherent clusters of brain regions are activated. The modular account of brain function is pervasive, reliable, and reproducible. Yet, a complementary perspective posits a core-periphery or rich-club account of brain function, where hubs are densely interconnected with one another, allowing for integrative processing. Unifying these two perspectives has remained difficult due to the fact that the methodological tools to identify modules are entirely distinct from the methodological tools to identify core-periphery structure. Here we leverage a recently-developed model-based approach -- the weighted stochastic block model -- that simultaneously uncovers modular and core-periphery structure, and we apply it to fMRI data acquired at rest in 872 youth of the Philadelphia Neurodevelopmental Cohort. We demonstrate that functional brain networks display rich meso-scale organization beyond that sought by modularity maximization techniques. Moreover, we show that this meso-scale organization changes appreciably over the course of neurodevelopment, and that individual differences in this organization predict individual differences in cognition more accurately than module organization alone. Broadly, our study provides a unified assessment of modular and core-periphery structure in functional brain networks, providing novel insights into their development and implications for behavior. △ Less

Submitted 4 April, 2019; v1 submitted 30 March, 2019; originally announced April 2019.

Linear Dynamics & Control of Brain Networks

Authors: Jason Z. Kim, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: The brain is an intricately structured organ responsible for the rich emergent dynamics that support the complex cognitive functions we enjoy as humans. With around $10^{11}$ neurons and $10^{15}$ synapses, understanding how the human brain works has proven to be a daunting endeavor, requiring concerted collaboration across traditional disciplinary boundaries. In some cases, that collaboration has… ▽ More The brain is an intricately structured organ responsible for the rich emergent dynamics that support the complex cognitive functions we enjoy as humans. With around $10^{11}$ neurons and $10^{15}$ synapses, understanding how the human brain works has proven to be a daunting endeavor, requiring concerted collaboration across traditional disciplinary boundaries. In some cases, that collaboration has occurred between experimentalists and technicians, who offer new physical tools to measure and manipulate neural function. In other contexts, that collaboration has occurred between experimentalists and theorists, who offer new conceptual tools to explain existing data and inform new directions for empirical research. In this chapter, we offer an example of the latter. Specifically, we focus on the simple but powerful framework of linear systems theory as a useful tool both for capturing biophysically relevant parameters of neural activity and connectivity, and for analytical and numerical study. We begin with a brief overview of state-space representations and linearization of neural models for non-linear dynamical systems. We then derive core concepts in the theory of linear systems such as the impulse and controlled responses to external stimuli, achieving desired state transitions, controllability, and minimum energy control. Afterwards, we discuss recent advances in the application of linear systems theory to structural and functional brain data across multiple spatial and temporal scales, along with methodological considerations and limitations. We close with a brief discussion of open frontiers and our vision for the future. △ Less

Submitted 8 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Comments: 30 pages, 3 figures, 10 problems

The control of brain network dynamics across diverse scales of space and time

Authors: Evelyn Tang, Harang Ju, Graham L. Baum, David R. Roalf, Theodore D. Satterthwaite, Fabio Pasqualetti, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: The human brain is composed of distinct regions that are each associated with particular functions and distinct propensities for the control of neural dynamics. However, the relation between these functions and control profiles is poorly understood, as is the variation in this relation across diverse scales of space and time. Here we probe the relation between control and dynamics in brain network… ▽ More The human brain is composed of distinct regions that are each associated with particular functions and distinct propensities for the control of neural dynamics. However, the relation between these functions and control profiles is poorly understood, as is the variation in this relation across diverse scales of space and time. Here we probe the relation between control and dynamics in brain networks constructed from diffusion tensor imaging data in a large community based sample of young adults. Specifically, we probe the control properties of each brain region and investigate their relationship with dynamics across various spatial scales using the Laplacian eigenspectrum. In addition, through analysis of regional modal controllability and partitioning of modes, we determine whether the associated dynamics are fast or slow, as well as whether they are alternating or monotone. We find that brain regions that facilitate the control of energetically easy transitions are associated with activity on short length scales and slow time scales. Conversely, brain regions that facilitate control of difficult transitions are associated with activity on long length scales and fast time scales. Built on linear dynamical models, our results offer parsimonious explanations for the activity propagation and network control profiles supported by regions of differing neuroanatomical structure. △ Less

Submitted 1 June, 2020; v1 submitted 21 January, 2019; originally announced January 2019.

Comments: 12 pages, 7 figures. arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:1607.01010

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 101, 062301 (2020)

Multiscale and multimodal network dynamics underpinning working memory

Authors: Andrew C. Murphy, Maxwell A. Bertolero, Lia Papadopoulos, David M. Lydon-Staley, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: Working memory (WM) allows information to be stored and manipulated over short time scales. Performance on WM tasks is thought to be supported by the frontoparietal system (FPS), the default mode system (DMS), and interactions between them. Yet little is known about how these systems and their interactions relate to individual differences in WM performance. We address this gap in knowledge using f… ▽ More Working memory (WM) allows information to be stored and manipulated over short time scales. Performance on WM tasks is thought to be supported by the frontoparietal system (FPS), the default mode system (DMS), and interactions between them. Yet little is known about how these systems and their interactions relate to individual differences in WM performance. We address this gap in knowledge using functional MRI data acquired during the performance of a 2-back WM task, as well as diffusion tensor imaging data collected in the same individuals. We show that the strength of functional interactions between the FPS and DMS during task engagement is inversely correlated with WM performance, and that this strength is modulated by the activation of FPS regions but not DMS regions. Next, we use a clustering algorithm to identify two distinct subnetworks of the FPS, and find that these subnetworks display distinguishable patterns of gene expression. Activity in one subnetwork is positively associated with the strength of FPS-DMS functional interactions, while activity in the second subnetwork is negatively associated. Further, the pattern of structural linkages of these subnetworks explains their differential capacity to influence the strength of FPS-DMS functional interactions. To determine whether these observations could provide a mechanistic account of large-scale neural underpinnings of WM, we build a computational model of the system composed of coupled oscillators. Modulating the amplitude of the subnetworks in the model causes the expected change in the strength of FPS-DMS functional interactions, thereby offering support for a mechanism in which subnetwork activity tunes functional interactions. Broadly, our study presents a holistic account of how regional activity, functional interactions, and structural linkages together support individual differences in WM in humans. △ Less

Submitted 19 January, 2019; originally announced January 2019.

Network structure of cascading neural systems predicts stimulus propagation and recovery

Authors: Harang Ju, Jason Z. Kim, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: Many neural systems display cascading behavior characterized by uninterrupted sequences of neuronal firing. This gap precludes an understanding of how variations in network structure manifest in neural dynamics and either support or impinge upon information processing. Here, we develop a theoretical understanding of how network structure supports information processing through network dynamics, an… ▽ More Many neural systems display cascading behavior characterized by uninterrupted sequences of neuronal firing. This gap precludes an understanding of how variations in network structure manifest in neural dynamics and either support or impinge upon information processing. Here, we develop a theoretical understanding of how network structure supports information processing through network dynamics, and we validate our theory with empirical data. Using a generalized spiking model and mathematical tools from linear systems theory, network control theory, and information theory, we show how network structure can be designed to temporally extend the propagation and recovery of certain stimulus patterns. Moreover, we observe cycles as structural and dynamic motifs that are prevalent in such networks. Broadly, our results demonstrate how cascading neural networks could contribute to cognitive faculties that require lasting activation of neuronal patterns, such as working memory or attention. △ Less

Submitted 10 November, 2019; v1 submitted 21 December, 2018; originally announced December 2018.

Stability of spontaneous, correlated activity in mouse auditory cortex

Authors: Richard F. Betzel, Katherine C. Wood, Christopher Angeloni, Maria Neimark Geffen, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: Neural systems can be modeled as networks of functionally connected neural elements. The resulting network can be analyzed using mathematical tools from network science and graph theory to quantify the system's topological organization and to better understand its function. While the network-based approach is common in the analysis of large-scale neural systems probed by non-invasive neuroimaging,… ▽ More Neural systems can be modeled as networks of functionally connected neural elements. The resulting network can be analyzed using mathematical tools from network science and graph theory to quantify the system's topological organization and to better understand its function. While the network-based approach is common in the analysis of large-scale neural systems probed by non-invasive neuroimaging, few studies have used network science to study the organization of networks reconstructed at the cellular level, and thus many very basic and fundamental questions remain unanswered. Here, we used two-photon calcium imaging to record spontaneous activity from the same set of cells in mouse auditory cortex over the course of several weeks. We reconstruct functional networks in which cells are linked to one another by edges weighted according to the correlation of their fluorescence traces. We show that the networks exhibit modular structure across multiple topological scales and that these multi-scale modules unfold as part of a hierarchy. We also show that, on average, network architecture becomes increasingly dissimilar over time, with similarity decaying monotonically with the distance (in time) between sessions. Finally, we show that a small fraction of cells maintain strongly-correlated activity over multiple days, forming a stable temporal core surrounded by a fluctuating and variable periphery. Our work provides a careful methodological blueprint for future studies of spontaneous activity measured by two-photon calcium imaging using cutting-edge computational methods and machine learning algorithms informed by explicit graphical models from network science. The methods are easily extended to additional datasets, opening the possibility of studying cellular level network organization of neural systems and how that organization is modulated by stimuli or altered in models of disease. △ Less

Submitted 10 December, 2018; originally announced December 2018.

Comments: 15 pages, 3 figures

Learning differentially reorganizes brain activity and connectivity

Authors: Maxwell A Bertolero, Azeez Adebimpe, Ankit N. Khambhati, Marcelo G. Mattar, Daniel Romer, Sharon L. Thompson-Schill, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: Human learning is a complex process in which future behavior is altered via the reorganization of brain activity and connectivity. It remains unknown whether activity and connectivity differentially reorganize during learning, and, if so, how that differential reorganization tracks stages of learning across distinct brain areas. Here, we address this gap in knowledge by measuring brain activity an… ▽ More Human learning is a complex process in which future behavior is altered via the reorganization of brain activity and connectivity. It remains unknown whether activity and connectivity differentially reorganize during learning, and, if so, how that differential reorganization tracks stages of learning across distinct brain areas. Here, we address this gap in knowledge by measuring brain activity and functional connectivity in a longitudinal fMRI experiment in which healthy adult human participants learn the values of novel objects over the course of four days. An increasing similarity in activity or functional connectivity across subjects during learning reflects reorganization toward a common functional architecture. We assessed the presence of reorganization in activity and connectivity both during value learning and during the resting-state, allowing us to differentiate common elicited processes from intrinsic processes. We found a complex and dynamic reorganization of brain connectivity and activity--as a function of time, space, and performance--that occurs while subjects learn. Spatially localized brain activity reorganizes across the brain to a common functional architecture early in learning, and this reorganization tracks early learning performance. In contrast, spatially distributed connectivity reorganizes across the brain to a common functional architecture as training progresses, and this reorganization tracks later learning performance. Particularly good performance is associated with a sticky connectivity, that persists into the resting state. Broadly, our work uncovers distinct principles of reorganization in activity and connectivity at different phases of value learning, which inform the ongoing study of learning processes more generally. △ Less

Submitted 10 September, 2020; v1 submitted 20 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

The physics of brain network structure, function, and control

Authors: Christopher W. Lynn, Danielle S. Bassett

Abstract: The brain is a complex organ characterized by heterogeneous patterns of structural connections supporting unparalleled feats of cognition and a wide range of behaviors. New noninvasive imaging techniques now allow these patterns to be carefully and comprehensively mapped in individual humans and animals. Yet, it remains a fundamental challenge to understand how the brain's structural wiring suppor… ▽ More The brain is a complex organ characterized by heterogeneous patterns of structural connections supporting unparalleled feats of cognition and a wide range of behaviors. New noninvasive imaging techniques now allow these patterns to be carefully and comprehensively mapped in individual humans and animals. Yet, it remains a fundamental challenge to understand how the brain's structural wiring supports cognitive processes, with major implications for the personalized treatment of mental health disorders. Here, we review recent efforts to meet this challenge that draw on intuitions, models, and theories from physics, spanning the domains of statistical mechanics, information theory, and dynamical systems and control. We begin by considering the organizing principles of brain network architecture instantiated in structural wiring under constraints of symmetry, spatial embedding, and energy minimization. We next consider models of brain network function that stipulate how neural activity propagates along these structural connections, producing the long-range interactions and collective dynamics that support a rich repertoire of system functions. Finally, we consider perturbative experiments and models for brain network control, which leverage the physics of signal transmission along structural wires to infer intrinsic control processes that support goal-directed behavior and to inform stimulation-based therapies for neurological disease and psychiatric disorders. Throughout, we highlight several open questions in the physics of brain network structure, function, and control that will require creative efforts from physicists willing to brave the complexities of living matter. △ Less

Submitted 7 January, 2019; v1 submitted 17 September, 2018; originally announced September 2018.

Journal ref: Nat Rev Phys 1, 318-332 (2019)