-
Evaluation of tools for differential gene expression analysis by RNA-seq on a 48 biological replicate experiment
Authors:
Nicholas J. Schurch,
Pieta Schofield,
Marek Gierliński,
Christian Cole,
Alexander Sherstnev,
Vijender Singh,
Nicola Wrobel,
Karim Gharbi,
Gordon G. Simpson,
Tom Owen-Hughes,
Mark Blaxter,
Geoffrey J. Barton
Abstract:
An RNA-seq experiment with 48 biological replicates in each of 2 conditions was performed to determine the number of biological replicates ($n_r$) required, and to identify the most effective statistical analysis tools for identifying differential gene expression (DGE). When $n_r=3$, seven of the nine tools evaluated give true positive rates (TPR) of only 20 to 40 percent. For high fold-change gen…
▽ More
An RNA-seq experiment with 48 biological replicates in each of 2 conditions was performed to determine the number of biological replicates ($n_r$) required, and to identify the most effective statistical analysis tools for identifying differential gene expression (DGE). When $n_r=3$, seven of the nine tools evaluated give true positive rates (TPR) of only 20 to 40 percent. For high fold-change genes ($|log_{2}(FC)|\gt2$) the TPR is $\gt85$ percent. Two tools performed poorly; over- or under-predicting the number of differentially expressed genes. Increasing replication gives a large increase in TPR when considering all DE genes but only a small increase for high fold-change genes. Achieving a TPR $\gt85$% across all fold-changes requires $n_r\gt20$. For future RNA-seq experiments these results suggest $n_r\gt6$, rising to $n_r\gt12$ when identifying DGE irrespective of fold-change is important. For $6 \lt n_r \lt 12$, superior TPR makes edgeR the leading tool tested. For $n_r \ge12$, minimizing false positives is more important and DESeq outperforms the other tools.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2015; v1 submitted 8 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Statistical models for RNA-seq data derived from a two-condition 48-replicate experiment
Authors:
Marek Gierliński,
Christian Cole,
Pietà Schofield,
Nicholas J. Schurch,
Alexander Sherstnev,
Vijender Singh,
Nicola Wrobel,
Karim Gharbi,
Gordon Simpson,
Tom Owen-Hughes,
Mark Blaxter,
Geoffrey J. Barton
Abstract:
High-throughput RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) is now the standard method to determine differential gene expression. Identifying differentially expressed genes crucially depends on estimates of read count variability. These estimates are typically based on statistical models such as the negative binomial distribution, which is employed by the tools edgeR, DESeq and cuffdiff. Until now, the validity of t…
▽ More
High-throughput RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) is now the standard method to determine differential gene expression. Identifying differentially expressed genes crucially depends on estimates of read count variability. These estimates are typically based on statistical models such as the negative binomial distribution, which is employed by the tools edgeR, DESeq and cuffdiff. Until now, the validity of these models has usually been tested on either low-replicate RNA-seq data or simulations. A 48-replicate RNA-seq experiment in yeast was performed and data tested against theoretical models. The observed gene read counts were consistent with both log-normal and negative binomial distributions, while the mean-variance relation followed the line of constant dispersion parameter of ~0.01. The high-replicate data also allowed for strict quality control and screening of bad replicates, which can drastically affect the gene read-count distribution. RNA-seq data have been submitted to ENA archive with project ID PRJEB5348.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Improved annotation of 3-prime untranslated regions and complex loci by combination of strand-specific Direct RNA Sequencing, RNA-seq and ESTs
Authors:
Nick Schurch,
Christian Cole,
Alexander Sherstnev,
Junfang Song,
Céline Duc,
Kate G. Storey,
W. H. Irwin McLean,
Sara J. Brown,
Gordon G. Simpson,
Geoffrey J. Barton
Abstract:
The reference annotations made for a genome sequence provide the framework for all subsequent analyses of the genome. Correct annotation is particularly important when interpreting the results of RNA-seq experiments where short sequence reads are mapped against the genome and assigned to genes according to the annotation. Inconsistencies in annotations between the reference and the experimental sy…
▽ More
The reference annotations made for a genome sequence provide the framework for all subsequent analyses of the genome. Correct annotation is particularly important when interpreting the results of RNA-seq experiments where short sequence reads are mapped against the genome and assigned to genes according to the annotation. Inconsistencies in annotations between the reference and the experimental system can lead to incorrect interpretation of the effect on RNA expression of an experimental treatment or mutation in the system under study. Until recently, the genome-wide annotation of 3-prime untranslated regions received less attention than coding regions and the delineation of intron/exon boundaries. In this paper, data produced for samples in Human, Chicken and A. thaliana by the novel single-molecule, strand-specific, Direct RNA Sequencing technology from Helicos Biosciences which locates 3-prime polyadenylation sites to within +/- 2 nt, were combined with archival EST and RNA-Seq data. Nine examples are illustrated where this combination of data allowed: (1) gene and 3-prime UTR re-annotation (including extension of one 3-prime UTR by 5.9 kb); (2) disentangling of gene expression in complex regions; (3) clearer interpretation of small RNA expression and (4) identification of novel genes. While the specific examples displayed here may become obsolete as genome sequences and their annotations are refined, the principles laid out in this paper will be of general use both to those annotating genomes and those seeking to interpret existing publically available annotations in the context of their own experimental data
△ Less
Submitted 11 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
