Showing 1–6 of 6 results for author: Zaoui, F

Evaluation of Performance Measures for Qualifying Flood Models with Satellite Observations

Authors: Jean-Paul Travert, Sébastien Boyaval, Cédric Goeury, Vito Bacchi, Fabrice Zaoui

Abstract: This work discusses how to choose performance measures to compare numerical simulations of a flood event with one satellite image, e.g., in a model calibration or validation procedure. A series of criterion are proposed to evaluate the sensitivity of performance measures with respect to the flood extent, satellite characteristics (position, orientation), and measurements/processing errors (satelli… ▽ More This work discusses how to choose performance measures to compare numerical simulations of a flood event with one satellite image, e.g., in a model calibration or validation procedure. A series of criterion are proposed to evaluate the sensitivity of performance measures with respect to the flood extent, satellite characteristics (position, orientation), and measurements/processing errors (satellite raw values or extraction of the flood maps). Their relevance is discussed numerically in the case of one flooding event (on the Garonne River in France in February 2021), using a distribution of water depths simulated from a shallow-water model parameterized by an uncertain friction field. After identifying the performance measures respecting the most criteria, a correlation analysis is carried out to identify how various performance measures are similar. Then, a methodology is proposed to rank performance measures and select the most robust to observation errors. The methodology is shown useful at identifying four performance measures out of 28 in the study case. Note that the various top-ranked performance measures do not lead to the same calibration result as regards the friction field of the shallow-water model. The methodology can be applied to the comparison of any flood model with any flood event. △ Less

Submitted 1 August, 2024; originally announced August 2024.

Surrogate-based variational data assimilation for tidal modelling

Authors: Rem-Sophia Mouradi, Cédric Goeury, Olivier Thual, Fabrice Zaoui, Pablo Tassi

Abstract: Data assimilation (DA) is widely used to combine physical knowledge and observations. It is nowadays commonly used in geosciences to perform parametric calibration. In a context of climate change, old calibrations can not necessarily be used for new scenarios. This raises the question of DA computational cost, as costly physics-based numerical models need to be reanalyzed. Reduction and metamodell… ▽ More Data assimilation (DA) is widely used to combine physical knowledge and observations. It is nowadays commonly used in geosciences to perform parametric calibration. In a context of climate change, old calibrations can not necessarily be used for new scenarios. This raises the question of DA computational cost, as costly physics-based numerical models need to be reanalyzed. Reduction and metamodelling represent therefore interesting perspectives, for example proposed in recent contributions as hybridization between ensemble and variational methods, to combine their advantages (efficiency, non-linear framework). They are however often based on Monte Carlo (MC) type sampling, which often requires considerable increase of the ensemble size for better efficiency, therefore representing a computational burden in ensemble-based methods as well. To address these issues, two methods to replace the complex model by a surrogate are proposed and confronted : (i) PODEn3DVAR directly inspired from PODEn4DVAR, relies on an ensemble-based joint parameter-state Proper Orthogonal Decomposition (POD), which provides a linear metamodel ; (ii) POD-PCE-3DVAR, where the model states are POD reduced then learned using Polynomial Chaos Expansion (PCE), resulting in a non-linear metamodel. Both metamodels allow to write an approximate cost function whose minimum can be analytically computed, or deduced by a gradient descent at negligible cost. Furthermore, adapted metamodelling error covariance matrix is given for POD-PCE-3DVAR, allowing to substantially improve the metamodel-based DA analysis. Proposed methods are confronted on a twin experiment, and compared to classical 3DVAR on a measurement-based problem. Results are promising, in particular superior with POD-PCE-3DVAR, showing good convergence to classical 3DVAR and robustness to noise. △ Less

Submitted 8 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Interoperability and computational framework for simulating open channel hydraulics: application to sensitivity analysis and calibration of Gironde Estuary model

Authors: Cedric Goeury, Yoann Audouin, Fabrice Zaoui

Abstract: Water resource management is of crucial societal and economic importance, requiring a strong capacity for anticipating environmental change. Progress in physical process knowledge, numerical methods and computational power, allows us to address hydro-environmental problems of growing complexity. Modeling of river and marine flows is no exception. With the increase in IT resources, environmental mo… ▽ More Water resource management is of crucial societal and economic importance, requiring a strong capacity for anticipating environmental change. Progress in physical process knowledge, numerical methods and computational power, allows us to address hydro-environmental problems of growing complexity. Modeling of river and marine flows is no exception. With the increase in IT resources, environmental modeling is evolving to meet the challenges of complex real-world problems. This paper presents a new distributed Application Programming Interface (API) of the open source TELEMAC-MASCARET system to run hydro-environmental simulations with the help of the interoperability concept. Use of the API encourages and facilitates the combination of worldwide reference environmental libraries with the hydro-informatic system. Consequently, the objective of the paper is to promote the interoperability concept for studies dealing with such issues as uncertainty propagation, global sensitivity analysis, optimization, multi-physics or multi-dimensional coupling. To illustrate the capability of the API, an operational problem for improving the navigation capacity of the Gironde Estuary is presented. The API potential is demonstrated in a re-calibration context. The API is used for a multivariate sensitivity analysis to quickly reveal the most influential parameters which can then be optimally calibrated with the help of a data assimilation technique. △ Less

Submitted 2 July, 2021; v1 submitted 12 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Journal ref: Environmental Modelling and Software 2021

Physically interpretable machine learning algorithm on multidimensional non-linear fields

Authors: Rem-Sophia Mouradi, Cédric Goeury, Olivier Thual, Fabrice Zaoui, Pablo Tassi

Abstract: In an ever-increasing interest for Machine Learning (ML) and a favorable data development context, we here propose an original methodology for data-based prediction of two-dimensional physical fields. Polynomial Chaos Expansion (PCE), widely used in the Uncertainty Quantification community (UQ), has long been employed as a robust representation for probabilistic input-to-output mapping. It has bee… ▽ More In an ever-increasing interest for Machine Learning (ML) and a favorable data development context, we here propose an original methodology for data-based prediction of two-dimensional physical fields. Polynomial Chaos Expansion (PCE), widely used in the Uncertainty Quantification community (UQ), has long been employed as a robust representation for probabilistic input-to-output mapping. It has been recently tested in a pure ML context, and shown to be as powerful as classical ML techniques for point-wise prediction. Some advantages are inherent to the method, such as its explicitness and adaptability to small training sets, in addition to the associated probabilistic framework. Simultaneously, Dimensionality Reduction (DR) techniques are increasingly used for pattern recognition and data compression and have gained interest due to improved data quality. In this study, the interest of Proper Orthogonal Decomposition (POD) for the construction of a statistical predictive model is demonstrated. Both POD and PCE have amply proved their worth in their respective frameworks. The goal of the present paper was to combine them for a field-measurement-based forecasting. The described steps are also useful to analyze the data. Some challenging issues encountered when using multidimensional field measurements are addressed, for example when dealing with few data. The POD-PCE coupling methodology is presented, with particular focus on input data characteristics and training-set choice. A simple methodology for evaluating the importance of each physical parameter is proposed for the PCE model and extended to the POD-PCE coupling. △ Less

Submitted 10 December, 2020; v1 submitted 28 May, 2020; originally announced May 2020.

Reconstruction of Hydraulic Data by Machine Learning

Authors: Corentin J. Lapeyre, Nicolas Cazard, Pamphile T. Roy, Sophie Ricci, Fabrice Zaoui

Abstract: Numerical simulation models associated with hydraulic engineering take a wide array of data into account to produce predictions: rainfall contribution to the drainage basin (characterized by soil nature, infiltration capacity and moisture), current water height in the river, topography, nature and geometry of the river bed, etc. This data is tainted with uncertainties related to an imperfect knowl… ▽ More Numerical simulation models associated with hydraulic engineering take a wide array of data into account to produce predictions: rainfall contribution to the drainage basin (characterized by soil nature, infiltration capacity and moisture), current water height in the river, topography, nature and geometry of the river bed, etc. This data is tainted with uncertainties related to an imperfect knowledge of the field, measurement errors on the physical parameters calibrating the equations of physics, an approximation of the latter, etc. These uncertainties can lead the model to overestimate or underestimate the flow and height of the river. Moreover, complex assimilation models often require numerous evaluations of physical solvers to evaluate these uncertainties, limiting their use for some real-time operational applications. In this study, we explore the possibility of building a predictor for river height at an observation point based on drainage basin time series data. An array of data-driven techniques is assessed for this task, including statistical models, machine learning techniques and deep neural network approaches. These are assessed on several metrics, offering an overview of the possibilities related to hydraulic time-series. An important finding is that for the same hydraulic quantity, the best predictors vary depending on whether the data is produced using a physical model or real observations. △ Less

Submitted 4 March, 2019; originally announced March 2019.

Comments: Submitted to SimHydro 2019

A GPU-enabled finite volume solver for large shallow water simulations

Authors: Fabrice Zaoui

Abstract: This paper presents the implementation of a HLLC finite volume solver using GPU technology for the solution of shallow water problems in two dimensions. It compares both CPU and GPU approaches for implementing all the solver's steps. The technology of graphics and central processors is highlighted with a particular emphasis on the CUDA architecture of NVIDIA. The simple and well-documented Applica… ▽ More This paper presents the implementation of a HLLC finite volume solver using GPU technology for the solution of shallow water problems in two dimensions. It compares both CPU and GPU approaches for implementing all the solver's steps. The technology of graphics and central processors is highlighted with a particular emphasis on the CUDA architecture of NVIDIA. The simple and well-documented Application Programming Interface (CUDA API) facilitates the use of the display card workstation as an additional computer unit to the central processor. Four professional solutions of the NVIDIA Quadro line are tested. Comparison tests between CPU and GPU are carried out on unstructured grids of small sizes (up to 10,000 elements), medium and large sizes (up to 10,000,000 elements). For all test cases, the accuracy of results is of the same order of magnitude for both approaches. Furthermore, the obtained speed gains with the GPU strongly depend on the model of the graphics card, the size of the problem and the simulation time. △ Less

Submitted 28 June, 2018; originally announced July 2018.